INDEX - VOLUME 6 (1961) THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC JOURNAL

No.1, January Edi tor'sPage _ -+ The Coins of Canada. R. C. YVilley

Chapter VII. Coins of New Brunswick _ -/ Addenda to "A Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics". R. C. W illey _ 18 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham _ 22 C.N.A. Libra ry List, January 1961 _ 26 New :Members, etc. _ 37 C.N.A. Chapter Reports _ 43 The Question Box. R. C. W illey _ 47 Regulations on Coin Purchases. Royal Canadian _ 56

No.2, February Editor's Page _ 60 Trade Tokens of Alberta. Donald M. Stewart _ 63 Check List of Alberta Trade Tokens. Donald M. Stewart _ 64 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham _ 73 What Should I Collect. Jerome H. Remick _ 74 Obituary - Frederick Ernest Taylor. J. R. B. Yarnold _ 80 New Members, etc. _ 80 C.N.A. Chapter Reports _ 83

No.3, March Editor's Page 108 C.N.A. Draft Constitution 109 A Listing of Dates for Australia's Regal Coinages.· Jerome H. Remick 120 The Regal Coinage of New Zealand, 1933 - 1960. Jerome H. Remick 125 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 127 Hamilton Convention Highlights. B. R. Brace and T. Anderson 129 New Memhers, etc. 130 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 133 The Question Box. R. C. Willey 149

No.4, April Edi tor's Page 168 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Willey Chapter VIII. Coins of Lower Canada 169 Hamilton Convention Highlights. B. R. Brace 186 Ancient Roman Denarii of the Emperors Trajan and Hadrian. A. E. H. Petrie 18S New :\1embers, etc. 191 CoN.A. Chapter Reports 193 The Question Box. R. C. Wille}' 197

No.5, May Editor's Page __ 22-+ The Coins of Canada. R. C. \Ville}' Chapter VIn (continued) Coins of Lower Canada 226 Obituary - James Bovaird Brown. R. A. Whetter 23, Vancouver's New Canadian Medallion 236 In the C.N.Ao Library. A. Do Graham 238 Book Review. Harold Don Allen 239 Hamilton Convention Highlights. B. R. Brace 241 Medals of the United Nations. Ro W. Irwin 242 ~lonev First Anniversarv. of the National Bank of Detroit's . Museum __ 243 New Members, etc. 244 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 246

The Question Box. R. C 0 Willey 252

No.6, June Editor's Page __ 268 The Coins of Canada. Ro C. W'illey Chapter VIn (continued) Coins of Lower Canada 270 Military Medals, A Specialized Field of Numismatics. \V. D. Murray __ __ 280 In the C.N.A. Library. A. Do Graham 286 Hamilton Conventio~ Highlights. Bo R. Brace 288 Important New Displays on Monetary History at the Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. 288

New M embers, etc 0 291 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 293 Judging Displays ______296 The Question Box. R. C. W illey 297 CorI1ections in the January, March, and April 1961 Canadian Numismatic Joumals ------______30,

Nos. 7 and 8, July - August Editor's Page 316 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Willey

Chapter VIII (continued) Coins of Lower Canada 00_ 318 C.N.A. E'lection Nominations 334 :'\otice to Advertisers concerning the combined July-August Cmw- diem Numismatic Journal 33-+ Information Received as to Oualifications of Candidates still to be chosen for the 1961-1963 C.N.A. Executive 33) Do You Know \Vorld :Monetary Units? Jerome H. Remicl~ 336 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 338 Canadian Coinage Production in 1959 and 1960. Royal Canadian lvlint - 340 Book Review. Harold Don Allen 341 Hamilton Convention Highlights. B. R. Brace 343 New :NIembers, etc. 343 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 345 A Find of Halifax Ferry Tokens. Walter Holmes 348 The Question Box. R. C. W ille)' 349

No.9, September Editor's P,age. A. E. H. Petrie: Annual Statement 364 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Willey Chapter IX. Coins of Upper Canada 367 The Numismatic Society of J\1ontreal and Gerald E. Hart. Ken- neth Bunnett 376 Saanich Bus To1ens. Larry Gingras 378 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 380 Book Review. Harold Don Allen 382 Some Varieties and Variants of Breton 715. C. Faulkner 383 Corrections in the June, and July-August 1961 Canadian Numis- matic Journals 387 New Members, etc. 387 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 389

No. 10, October Editor's Page 412 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Willey Chapter X. Coins of the Province of Canada 414 Numismatics and History, Parts I and II. Philip Grierson 421 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 429 Do You Know Subsidiary Coins? Jerome H. Remick 430 Obsolete Modern Coins, and Their Source Countries. Jerome H. Remick ______432 New Members, etc. 434 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 435 Warning (concerning misl'aid early Canadian currency, recovered soon 'afterwards) 437 Canadian Charter :Nlembers of the American Nllli1ismatic Asso- ciation. Jacl~ \V. Ogilvie and A. E. H. Petrie 452 No. 11 t November Editor's Page .- +;6 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Yf/illey Chapter XI. Coins for the Northwest and British Columbia +,8 Chapter XII. The Dominion of Canada (Victoria and Edwa rd V II) __ -+6 2 Numismatics and History, Parts III and IV. Philip Grierson 468 Three Recent British Coinage Series (Fiji, Jamaica, Rhodesia and N yasaland). Jerome H. Remick 474 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 478 N ew ~'I emhers, etc. 481 C.N.A. Chapter Reports __ 483

No. 12, December Editor's Page ___ 504 The Coins of Canada. R. C. Willey Chapter XII. The Dominion of Canada (George V to con- clusion) _ :; 06 Book Review. Harold Don Allen 514 Some Reflections Upon Being Fifty Years a Coin Collector. R. W. McLachlan, Septemher 1911 516 In the C.N.A. Library. A. D. Graham 519 New :NIemhers, etc. :; 20 C.N.A. Chapter Reports 521 uke Canadian AlumiJmatic journal IN D EX TO VOLUME 7-1962 Prepared by R. C. Willey, Assistant Editor I January Editor's Page . 4 Some Reflections upon being Fifty Years a Coin Collector R. W. McLachlan . . 6 Communion Tokens of Scotland and Canada. David I. McRitchie 11 Report on the Fifth Numismatic Convention in Israel . 14 In the C.N.A. Library...... 16 Canadian Numismatic Association Library List . 19 New Members, etc. . . 35 Chapter Reports . . 38 Coins and Coin Weights . 43 Regulations on Coin Purchases. The Royal Canadian Mint . 59

II February Editor's Page . .. . . 64 Sub-Editorial. Larry Gingras . . 65 Royal Mints of the Spanish Indies. L. W ..vlcCabe . 66 A Third Supplement of British Columbia Trade Tokens. L. C. Hill . 77 In the C.N.A. Library . 88 Highland and Belfry Trade Tokens. S. S. Carroll . 90 North Vancouver City Ferries and their Tokens. Larry Gingras . 91 Some Trade Tokens and Medallic Souvenirs of the Canadian West. L. C. Hill . 93 Book Reviews . 102 New Members, etc. . 103 Chapter Reports . 105

'" March Editor's Page . 128 March Report on the 1962 C.N.A. Convention . 129 Biographical Sketches of Gerald E. Hart and Louis Joseph Casault Adapted from Breton . 131 A Catalogue of the Library of Parliament Numismatic Collections, Ottawa 134 The Royal Canadian Mounted Police Medal for Long Service and Good Conduct. R. W. Irwin . 140 The Canadian Volunteer Service Medal. R. W. Irwi11 .. 143 Some Reflections upon being Fifty Years a Coin Collector. R. W. McLachlan . 144 The Coins of Canada: Addenda and Corrigenda. R. C. Willey . 150 Addenda to "A Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics". R. C. Willey. 153 In the C.N.A. Library ..... '" ." "...... 156 New Members, etc. 158 Chapter Reports 162 IV April Editor's Page . 188 April Report on the 1962 Convention . 189 A Catalogue of the Library of Parliament Numismatic Collections, Ottawa 190 The Story of the Farthing-Part I. R. C. Willey . 199 Revisions to Recent Issues of the Journal...... 206 In the C.N.A. Library . 207 Canada's Dot Coinage of 1937. G.RL. Potter . 208 Spanish Perforated . Cmdr. G. E. Gray .. 213 The City of Victoria Centennial Medal .. 214 Public Notice of Measures to Facilitate the Removal of Old Copper from Circulation (1870). The Minister of Finance . 216 New Members, etc. . . 218 Chapter Reports .. . 221 V May Editor's Page .. 244 May Report on the 1962 Convention .. 246 A Catalogue of the Library of Parliament Numismatic Collections, Ottawa 247 Pinchbeck's Louisbourg Medals of 1758. R. W. McLachlan . 255 The Story of the Farthing-Part II. R. C. Willey .. 258 In the C.N.A. Library . 262 Book Review . 264 Indian Arrowheads as a Medium of Exchange. F. Jarrett 265 Numbers of Dies Used in Operative Department of the Royal Canadian Mint . 267 Current Trends in Gold. The Bank of Nova Scotia .. . 267 Competition for the Design of the 1964 Canada Silver . 270 The First Canadial?- Agricultural Medal .. 271 Nova Scotia's Official Coinage: A Primary Document. Halifax Coin Club News Letter .. 273 Obituaries-John Frederick Jones & Henry S. Smieding... .. 274 Coinage of the New Canadian Mint 1909 . 275 New Members, etc. .. 275 Chapter Reports .. 277 Canadian Wildlife Service Reward Medallion .. 296 VI June Editor's Page .. 300 A.N.A.-C.N.A. Convention Medal .. 301 Temporary Change of Director for the Maritimes . 302 A Message to 1962 Convention Patrons . 302 A Catalogue of the Library of Parliament Numismatic Collections, Ottawa 303 Canadian Military Medals Awarded for Service in the War of 1812 ...... 310 Medals of the War of 1812-1814 with Bars for Fort Detroit, Chateauguay, and Chrystler's Farm. R. W. McLachlan 311 The Barrier of Familiarity. M. W. Thistle 317 Obituary-Abel Theodore Johannes Isberg 319 In the C.N.A. Library.. .. 320 Book Review 321 Value Factors in Coin Collecting. Wayne L. Jacobs 322 1891 Canada Cent Varieties Reconsidered. R. C. Ryder 326 Canadian Coinage Production in 1960 and 1961 327 New Members, etc. , 327 Chapter Reports . .. 329 VII July A Message from the President 352 An Important Unpublished Variety of Canada's 1954 Coinage. R Margolis 354 From the Library . 356 Book Review .. 357 The Phantom Token. Wayne L. Jacobs 358 A Canadian Numismatist's Views on Collecting United States Coins. R. A. Holloway 360 Trade Notes .. 361 The Question Box 362 Report on the Province of Quebec Numismatic Association 364 The General Secretary Reports 365 Club News 368 New Provincial Association Formed 372 Directory of Members 381 VIII August A Message from the President 428 Coin of the Realm-Part r. L. W. McCabe 431 Canada's First $25 Bill. Allan Klenman 433 First Annual Convention of the Province of Quebec Numismatic Association 434 Official 1962 Convention program 436 Sherbrooke Chamber of Commerce to Issue Medal 440 From the Library 441 The General Secretary Reports 442 Club News 444 Coinage Metals-Part I-Victoria Numismatic Society...... 459 IX September Editor's Page 464 A Message from the President 466 Convention Award Winners 467 Convention Medals Available 467 Coin of the Realm-Part II L. W. McCabe 469 Trade Tokens in Alberta. D. M. Stewart 473 Mint Information . 476 The Question Box 477 The General Secretary Reports 479 From the Library 481 Club News .. 482 Who's Who in the C.N.A. - Walter Holmes 483

X October Editor's Page . 500 Coin of the Realm - Part III L. W. McCabe . 503 Trade Tokens in Alberta - Part I D. M. Stewart . 507 Club News . 509 The General Secretary Reports .. 511 From the Library . 513 Convention Pictures . . 514 Convention Notes . . . 518 The Question Box . 519

XI November Editor's Page . 540 Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada-Part I ~ &wm~ . 542 Coinage Metals - Part II Victoria Numismatic Society 548 Whither Our Silver Coins? Stanley Twardy...... 549 Trade Tokens in Alberta - Part II D. M. Stewart . 551 The London Numismatic Society's 1962 Annual Meeting 554 From the Library . 555 The Question Box . 556 The General Secretary Reports . 558 Club News . . 560

XII December Editor's Page . 580 The Token of John Shaw f.-I. Prenoveau ~...... 582 Le Jeton de John Shaw. I.-J, Prenoveau . 583 On Insuring your Coin Collection Hub Strain . 586 Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada - Part II F. Bowman . 588 Potpourri . 594 From the Library . 596 Book Reviews . 599 The Question Box...... 600 The General Secretary Reports . 601 Club News 603 THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC JOURNAL

INDEX TO VOLUME 8, 1963

OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF

THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC ASSOCIATION

Enclosure with Vol. 9, No.2 February, 1964 Uhe Canadian vNumiJmalic journal

IN D EX

TO VOLUME 8 - 1963

Prepared by R. C. Willey, Assistant Editor

Anchor Money . 463 Art in Coins .. 283 Aurora Centennial Token 194 Award of Merit of the O.N.A . 284 Bank Notes . 4, 56 Bank of Montreal Museum . 329 Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics (Addenda) 95 Bowman, Fred - Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada 17, 58, 100, 154, 198, 245, 292, 333, 381, 420, 469, 513 British Columbia- Hon. John Robson Token . 327 Nelson Street Railway Tokens . 465 British Commonwealth of Nations, Commemorative Coins of the . 413 Bunnett, Kenneth - On Collecting Varieties 419 Calico, F. Xavier Philip, Prince of Spain and King of England and Ireland 417 Canadian Coins, weight, , and size of . 425 Canadian National Exhibition Medals . 377 Canadian Numismatic Association Constitution and By-Laws '.' opposite p. 340 Letters Patent of Incorporation opposite p. 298 Canadian Numismatic Research Society...... 457 Canadian Society of Medallic Arts . . 195, 331, 512 Clark, James W. Commemorative Coins of the British Commonwealth of Nations 413 Coinage Metals . 332 Coin Clubs . 287 Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada 17,58,100,154,198,245,292,333,381,420,469, 513 Convention Story 1963 . 368 Decimal Currency in Great Britain . 239 Dethridge, Kaye and Nancy North American Trading and Transportation Co. Tokens . 510 Dickie, Gordon The Magdalen Islands Token . . 235 Ferguson Collection, items on display 236, 244 Foreign Coins, collecting of . . 416 Forman, Jerome F. The Numismatist and Gold in the World Today...... 289 Forster, F. G. Ribbons and Medals 147 Gibbs, Jeremiah Biography . 7 Numismatics . . 9, 55, 98, 151

11 Gingras, Larry Nelson Street Railwav Tokens 465 Gold, and Numismatists - 289 Great Britain Report on decimal currency . 239 Coins portraying Philip of Spain .... 417 Commemorative Coins 413 Greene, Ronald A. Notes on the Hon. John Robson Token 327 Harper, T. G. Numismatics Means More 150, 163 Hider, Roy Some Thoughts on Operating a Successful Coin Club 287 Hill, Leslie C. On the Importance of Proper Research and Recording . 53 Newfoundland Paper Currency .. 237 Northwest Company Numismatica '" . 509 Irwin, R. W. Anchor Money 463 Jacobs, Wayne L. Nova Scotia's Regal Tokens 458 Korning, S. Aesthetic Appreciation of Fine Art in Coins . 283 MacDonald, A. M. National School of Halifax Medal . 466 Magdalen Islands Token 235 Maria Theresa 197 McRitchie, D. J. Coin Quiz 187, 384, 471 Medals Medals and Ribbons 147 National School of Halifax Medal .. 466 Northwest Company . 509 New Canadian Silver Dollar for 1964 . 97 Newfoundland Paper Money . 237 Variety of 1890 ten-cent piece . 508 North American Trading and Transportation Tokens .. 510 Northwest Company Numismatica . . 509 Nova S'cotia Medal of the National School of Halifax .. 466 Regal Tokens 458 Numismatics Survey by Jeremiah Gibbs 9, 55, 98, 151 Numismatics Means More 150, 163 Palestine, Ancient coins of .. 505 Prenoveau, J. J. The Token of J. H. Roy (English and French text) .. 143 Questions and Answers Coin Quiz ...... 187, 384, 471 Question Box ...... 22, 61, 86, 157, 241

111 Remick, Jerome H. Why not Collect the Coins of a Foreign Country? 416 Research and Recording 53 Ribbons and Medals ... 147 Robson, Hon. John, Token of 327 Roy, J. H., Token of . 142 Royal Bank of Canada to Display Items from Ferguson Collection 236, 244 Royal Canadian Mint Report 189 Sandham, Alfred. Reprint of this 1869 work on Canadian coins and tokens 107 Tokens, Canadian Colonial Magdalen Islands Token . 197 Northwest Company Token .. 509 Nova Scotia, Regal Tokens of . 458 Roy, J. H., Token of .. 143 Tokens, later Canadian and American Aurora Centennial Token . 194 Nelson Street Railway Tokens . 465 North American Trading and Transportation Co. Tokens 510 Robson, Hon. John, Token of . 327 Varieties . 419 Wilkinson, Dr. John S. receives O.N.A. Award of Merit 284 Willey, R. C. Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics (Addenda) ...... 95 Coins of Palestine in New Testament Times ...... 505 Question Box . 21, 61, 86, 157, 241

INSERTS:

Constitution & By-laws - August Letters Patent Incorporating the Association - July Library List - February Index for 1962 - February Election Ballots - July

A key to the page numbers given in this index follows: 1- 48-January 227-320-July 49- 8S-February 321-360-August 89-136-March 361-408-September 137-180-April 409-452-october 181-228-May 453-500-November 229-276-June 501-540-Decernber

IV THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC JOURNAL

!J.nJex TO VOLUME 9, 1964

OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF

THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC ASSOCIATION

Enclosure with Vol. 10, No.2 February, 1965 KEY to the page numbers given in this index 1- 44 January 273-320 July 45- 84 February 321-360 August 85-128 March 361-404 September 129-176 April 405-452 October 177-224 May 453-500 November 225-272 June 501-544 December •

INDEX Alberta Golden Jubilee Medals, The - by Donald M. Stewart 97 Ashe, David Clippers; Pale Ghosts of Yesteryear 281, 329, 373 Auction, Selling by - by J. E. Charlton 240 Baffin Land, King of - by D. M. Stewart 182 Book Reviews Canadian Cent Varieties - by James R. Croghan 121 Catalog of Modern World Coins, A- by R. S. Yeoman 516 Coin Preservation Handbook - by Charles Frank 516 Coins in China's History - by Arthur Cole Bradden 60 Coins of British Oceania - by Robert L. Clarke ..... 147 Coins - Questions and Answers - by Krause Publications Staff 516 Commercial Coins - 1787-1804 by R. C. Bell 22 Communion Tokens: The Australian, New Zealand and Miscellaneous Series - by R. M. Greig, H. Robinson and W. W. Woodside 516 From Real to Rand - by J. T. Becklake 308 Guide Book of United States Coins, A, 1965 Edition - by R. S. Yeoman 377 Guide to the Grading of United States Coins, A- by Martin R. Brown and John W. Dunn 241 Major Coin Varieties (Part I) - by Hans Zoel 309 Open Account - by Keith Sinclair and W. F. MandIe 517 Profit March of Your Coin Investment - 1935-1971, The - by George W. Haylings 309 Silver Dollars of North and South America, The - by Wayte Raymond 198 Standard Catalogue of Canadian Coins, Tokens and Paper Money, 1965 edition-by James E. Charlton 377 Bowman, Fred The Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada 15,54,98, 143, 195,243,292,336,379,425,470 and 518 Bradfield, Elston G. The Kennedy Half Dollar 183 British Commonwealth of Nations Series, Information Available on the-by Jerome H. Renwick . . 5 13 Brunswick Checks, The 1. M. - by Elwood Garns 368

Canada General Service Medal, The - by Edward Denby 509 Canada Medal, The - by Ross W. Irwin ...... 367 Canadian Bank of Commerce, The "Dawson" and "Yukon" Overprinted Notes of the - by Scott Simpson 353 Canadian Coin Counterfeits - bv Pat. Melligan 288 Canadian Large Cents - by Neil Shafer 91 Canadian Numismatics, Past, Present and Future by Major Sheldon S. Carroll 231 Carroll, Major Sheldon S. Canadian Numismatics, Past, Present and Future 231 Redeemable Chartered Bank Notes ...... 369 Casual Look at Telephone Tokens, A- by D. M. Stewart 332 Centenary of Newfoundland Decimal Patterns, The - by Leslie C. Hill 512 Changing Money? - by Richard F. Jansen 461 Charlton. J. E Selling by Auction 240 -2- Chartered Bank Notes, Redeemable - by Sheldon S. Carroll 369 Checks, The J. M. Brunswick - by Elwood Garns 368 Clark, James W. The "Specimen" 1935 Great Britain Crown: A Fourth Type 508 Clarke, William N. The Coinage of Hanoverian England 5 Clippers: Pale Ghosts of Yesteryear bv David Ash 281, 329, 373 Coinage of Hanoverian England, The - by William N. Clarke 5 Coin Quiz - by D. 1. McRitchie 141, 291, 421 Coins, Edge Inscriptions on - by Alex. M. Sweeton 239 Collectors? Where are the - by T. G. Harper 511 Communion Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada - by Fred Bowman 15, 54, 98, 143, 195, 243, 292, 336. 379, 425. 470 518 Conspirator's Victory Coin, A- by G. J. Dickie 50 Convention, The 1964 - at Halifax, Nova Scotia Report - by A. M. MacDonald 415 Business...... 417 Counterfeits, Canadian Coin - by Pat Melligan 288 Countermarked Spanish Dollar, The - by G. J. Dickie 422 Countermarks, The Mysterious GR 5 ORD - by R. C. Willey 238 Denby, Edward When a Baby Won a General Service Medal 51 Military Medals - Why and How to Collect Them 419 The Canada General Service Medal 509 Dickie, G. J. A Conspirator's Victorly Coin 50 Gold Nobles and the Battle of Sluys 371 Irish Gunmoney 289 Dickie, G. J. The Countermarked Spanish Dollar 422 Dollar, The Countermarked Spanish - by G. J. Dickie 422 Dufferin Medal, The - by Dr. Stuart Kenning 287

Edge Inscriptions on Coins - by Alex M. Sweeton 239 1858 Five Cent Piece, The - by Leslie C. Hill 237

Face of Audacity, The - by Robert Werlich 9 Facts!, Let's State the - by T. G. Harper 137 Five Cent Piece, The 1858 - by Leslie C. Hill 237

Garns, Elwood The J. M. Brunswick Checks 368 General Service Medal, When a Baby Won a - by Edward Denby 51 Gold Nobles and the Battle of Sluys-by G. J. Dickie. 371 Grading of Canadian Coins, A Thumbnail Guide to the-by Sol Taylor II Gray, John, (of Vancouver) An Open Letter to Roll Accumators 468 "K. G." (George Kruger Gray) 507 Great Britain Crown: A Fourth Type, The "Specimen" 1935 - by James W. Clark 508 Greene, Ronald A. The Token Collector's Dilemma, The Plastic Token 12 The Holmes Gold Medal 458 Guay, Allen E. Official Commemorative Medals of Canada 135, 187, 236 Gunmoney, Irish - by G. J. Dickie 289

Halle, Cleo The Speculators - Bless Them ...... 186 Hanoverian England, The Coinage of - by William N. Clarke 5 Harper, T. G. Let's State the Facts! 137 Where are the Collectors? 511 3- Hill. Leslie C. An Early Medal of the Hudson's Bay Co. 96 The Centenary of Newfoundland Decimal Patterns 512 The 1858 Five Cent Piece 237 Type Set Collecting 14 Hobby Not Based on One Coin or One Year - by Clifford Mischler 364 Holmes Gold Medal, The - by Ronald A. Greene 458 Hudson's Bay Co., An Early Medal of the - by Leslie Hill 96 Inflation Not New 192 Information Available on the British Commonwealth of Nations Series - by Jerome H. Renwick 513 Irish Gunmoney - by G. J. Dickie 289 Irwin, Ross W. Military Honours and Decorations 94 Price and Value . 49 The Canada Medal . 367 The Twenty Cent Pieces 285 Jacobs, Wayne L. The "Plumper" Pieces of Eight 8 Jansen, Richard F. Changing Money? 461 Johnson, James Numismatist Defined ...... 370 July Fourth Oration, A- by Dr. O. L. Puckett 464 Kennedy Half Dollar, The - by Elston G. Bradfield 183 Kenning, Dr. Stuart The Dufferin Medal 287 "K. G." (George Kruger Gray) . 507 King of Baffin Land - by D. M. Stewart 182 Let's State the Facts! - by T. G. Harper 137 Manville, Ray The Two Varieties of the United States 1960 Cents 139 McRitchie, D. J. Coin Quiz . . 141, 291, 421 Medal, The Canada - by Ross W. Irwin 367 Medal, The Canada General Service - by Edward Denby 509 Medal, The Dufferin - by Dr. Stuart Kenning 287 Medal, The Holmes Gold - by Ronald A. Greene . 458 Medal, The Westdock Commemorative - by D. M. Stewart 309 Medal of the Hudson's Bay Co., An Early - by Leslie Hill 96 Medals, The Alberta Golden Jubilee - by Donald M. Stewart 97 Medals of Canada, Official Commemorative - by Allen Guay 135, 187, 236 Medals - Why and How to Collect Them, Military - by Edward Denby 419 MelIigan, Pat The Straight Goods ..... 465 Canadian Coin Counterfeits . . 288 Military Honours and Decorations - by Ross W. Irwin . 94 Military Medals - Why and How to Collect Them - by Edward Denby 419 Mint, The Royal Canadian - by Norval A. Parker 326 Mischler, Clifford Hobby Not Based on One Coin or One Year . 364 Mysterious GR 5 ORD Countermarks, The - by R. C. Willey 238 Newfoundland Decimal Patterns, The Centenary of - by Leslie C. Hill 512 1916 "c" Sovereign, The . 411 Nobles and the Battle of Sluys, Gold - by G. J. Dickie 371 Notes, Redeemable Chartered Bank - by Major Sheldon S. Carroll .... 369 Notes of the Canadian Bank of Commerce, The "Dawson" and "Yukon" Overprinted - by Scott Simpson .. 353 Numismatics, Past, Present and Future, Canadian - by Major Sheldon S. Carroll . . . 231 Numismatist, The Professional - by Lloyd T. Smith 324 Numismatist Defined - by James G. Johnson 370 -4- Obverse-Reverse Question Aired 245 Official Commemorative Medals of Canada - by Allen Guay 135, 187, 236 Open Letter to Roll Accumulators, An - by John Gray (Vcr.) 468 Parker, Norval A. The Royal Canadian Mint 326 Patterns, The Centenary of Newfoundland Decimal - by Leslie C. Hill 512 "Plumper" Pieces of Eight, The - by Wayne L. Jacobs 8 Price and Value - by Ross W. Irwin 49 Price of Progress, The - by Murray G. Weston 95 Professional Numismatist, The - by Lloyd T. Smith 324 Puckett, Dr. O. L. A July Fourth Oration 464 Renwick, Jerome H. Information Available on the British Commonwealth of Nations Series 513 Royal Canadian Mint, The - by Norval A. Parker 326 Selling by Auction - by J. E. Charlton 240 Shafer, Neil Canadian Large Cents 91 Simpson, Scott The "Dawson" and "Yukon" Overprinted Notes of the Canadian Bank of Commerce 353 Smith, Lloyd T. The Professional Numismatist 324 Sovereign, The 1916 "C" 411 Speculators - Bless Them, The - by Cleo Halle 186 Stewart, Donald M. The Alberta Golden Jubilee Medals 97 The Westlock Commemorative Medal 309 King of Baffin Land .... 182 A Casual Look at Telephone Tokens 332 Straight Goods, The - by Pat Melligan 465 Sweeton, Alex M. Edge Inscriptions on Coins 239 Taler, The 242 Taylor, Sol A Thumbnail Guide to the Grading of Canadian Coins 11 Telephone Tokens, A Casual Look at - by D. M. Stuart 332 Thumbnail Guide to the Grading of Canadian Coins, A-by Sol Taylor 11 Token Collector's Dilemma, The Plastic Token - by Ronald A. Greene 12 Tokens, A Casual Look at Telephone - by D. M. Stuart ..... 332 Tokens of the Presbyterian Church in Canada, Communion - by Fred Bowman 15, 54, 98, 143, 195, 243, 292, 336, 379, 425, 470 518 Twenty Cent Pieces, The - by Ross W. Irwin 285 Two Varieties of the United States 1960 Cents, The - by Ray Manville 139 Type Set Collecting - by Leslie Hill 14 United States 1960 Cents, The Two Varieties of the - by Ray Manville 139 Werlich, Robert The Face of Audacity .. . . . 9 Westlock Commemorative Medal, The - by D. M. Stewart 309 Weston, Murray G. The Price of Progress ...... 95 When a Baby Won a General Service Medal - by Edward Denby 51 Where are the Collectors? - by T. G. Harper 511 Willey, R. C. The Mysterious GR 5 ORD Countermarks 238 INSERTS Library List - February Index for 1963 - February -5- THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC JOURNAL

JnJex TO VOLUME 10, 1965

OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF

THE CANADIAN NUMISMATIC ASSOCIATION

Enclosure with Vol. 11, No.2 February, 1966 KEY

to the page numbers given in this index

1- 40 January 269-312 July 41- 84 February 313-352 August 85-128 March 353-392 September 129-176 April 393-436 October 177-220 May 437-476 November 221-268 June 477-520 December

INDEX

A Little Knowledge is a Profitable Thing-R. S. Yeoman 232 A View of the City . 233 Addenda To The Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics-R. C. Willey 93 Atlantic Provinces Numismatic Association Formed 283 Australian -Canberra 368

Beardshaw, Alan Grape-Shot; Five Francs Per Shot 96 The Big Sneeze of Vigo Bay 329 Boy Scout Coin Collectors Badge Test, Could You Pass The? 326 Bowman, Fred The Tokens of A. D. Porcheron 51 The Lesslie Two Penny Token 445 British Columbia Numismatic Association Formed 442

BOOK REVIEWS A Catalogue of the Coins of Brazil 468 A Guide to the Grading of Canadian Coins-Cecil S. Paul and Gerald B. Parker 238 A Guide Book of English Coins-Kenneth E. Bressett 288 American Colonial History Illustrated by Medals-W. C. Wyllys Betts 104 Canadian Monetary, Banking and Fiscal Development-R. Craig Mcivor 410 Drowned Galleons off Florida Yield Spanish Gold-Kip Wagner 468 Foreign Coins Struck at United States Mints-Charles G. Altz and E. H. Barton 510 Illustrated Guide to Chinese Cash Pieces of the Manchu Mints A.D. 1662-1796-A. E. Petrie 18 North American Currency-Grover C. Criswell, Jr. 238 Priced Catalogue of U.S. Colonial and Continental Currency-Ted N. Weissbuch and Richard T. Hoober .. 467 Prisoner of War Monies and Medals-Arlie Slabaugh 468 Simplified Grading Guide For the Coins of Canada and Newfoundland, The-Hans Zoel 410 Sovereigns of the British Empire-Capt. J. J. Cullimore Allen OBE 468 The Coins of South Africa-Dr. Alex Kaplan . 288 The Guide Book of Canadian Coins, Paper Currency and Tokens 1659-1965, Modem British Coins 1797-1965 Australian and New Zealand-H. C. Taylor and Somer James 238 Trade Tokens of Saskatchewan And Their History-C. C. Tannahill 149 United States Trade Dollar-John M. Willem 511 - 2- Caesarea and Medal 447 Calling All Artists-Design for 1967 Coins 100 Canada General Service Medal, The-R. W. Irwin 320 Canadian Coin Week-Robert Montpetit 50, 96, 133, 241 Canadian Coins of the French Regime-Major Sheldon S. Carroll 399. 441 Canadian Memorial Cross-R. W. Irwin 187 Canadian Numismatic Research Society, The Transactions-R. C. Willey 60 Caron, Normand D. Coin Care 408 Pieforts of France and Her Colonies 485 Carroll, Major Sheldon S. Canadian Coins of the French Regime 399, 441 Numismatics in the Maritimes 189 Centennial Coinage . 484 Centennial of the City of Victoria, The 1962-Ronald A Greene 191 Cigar Store Tokens-D. M. Stewart 284 Clark, James W. New Crowns for 1965 285 Coin Care-Normand D. Caron 408 Coin Grading at Home and Overseas: Points to Watch-Paul Siggers 446 Convention News 182, 226, 319 Convention, C.N.A-Montreal, 1965 Pictures 362, 365, 367 Reports-Advertising, General Secretary 363 Editor . 364 Election Committee 369 Funds-General . 411 Life Membership 412 Library 412 Medal 364 Notes .. 365 Countermarked (Counterstamped) Canadian Coins and Tokens-Kenneth L. Hallenbeck, Jr. . .. 183 Countermarked Canadian Coins and Tokens, Additional Notes On-To A Wedge . 325 Countermark, The "J.O.P."-Larry Gingras 359 Craig, H. A. The Laura Secord Medal . 361 Crowns for 1965, New-James W. Clark 285

Daniel, Forrest W. Twenty-Five Cents of 1870 282 DenbY,Edward Military General Service Medal (1793-1814) 453 Desaulniers, Don To List or Not To List. 188 Dickie, G. J. A Modern Morality Tale 367

Egyptian Medal (1882-1889)-R. W. Irwin 403 English, William Variety or Variant 443

Ferguson, J. Douglas Numismatics Across Canada 357, 405 - 3- Garns, Elwood St. George Token Varieties 97 Gibbs, J. Sir Isaac Brock and the Brock Half-Pennies 13 Gingras, Larry The "J.O.P." Countermark 359 Gold In The Junk Pile - Walter Hazzard 482 Grande Prairie Commemorative Token of 1964, The-Donald M. Stewart 330 Grape-Shot; Five Francs Per Shot - Alan Beardshaw 96 Greene, Ronald A. The 1962 Centennial of the City of Victoria 191

Haffner, Sylvia Let's Stop Collecting Status Symbols 185 Or Would You Rather Be A Judge? 323 Hallenbeck, Kenneth L. Jr., Countermarked (Counterstamped) Canadian Coins and Tokens 183 Hazzard, Walter Gold In The Junk Pile? 482 History of Canada In Money-William H. Kernohan 450, 451. 452 History Of Currency Used In Ontario-Reverend arlo Miller 228 Horwood Tokens of Newfoundland, The-Stuart Kenning, M.D. 231 House of Commons Debates 91, 140, 239. 286

Information Please - Patrick Melligan 281 Irwin, R. W. Canada General Service Medal, The 320 Canadian Memorial Cross 187 Egyptian Medal (1882-1889) 403

J.O.P. Countermark, The-Larry Gingras 359

Kenning, M.D., Stuart The Horwood Tokens of Newfoundland 231 Kernohan, William H. History of Canada In Money 450, 451, 452 Kromas, John A. Kruger-Gray, George Edward 137 Kruger-Gray, George Edward-John A. Kromas 137

Laura Secord Medal, The-H. A. Craig 361 Lesslie Two Penny Token, The-Fred Bowman 445 Let's Stop Collecting Status Symbols-Sylvia Haffner 185 Levy, Robert A.-Elected President of the PNG of C 322 Life Membership Cards, New - (CN.A.) 449 London Numismatic Society 14th Annual Banquet ... 448

Mao, KO. The First Military Note Isued by the Nationalist Revolutionary Army of China 143 Mather, Winifred Royal Marriage Commemorative Medals 7 Melligan, Patrick Information Please 281 Mildmay and Formosa Tokens, The-K A. Palmer 279 Military General Service Medals (1793-1814)-Edward Denby 453 Military Note Issued by the Nationalist Revolutionary Army of China, The First-K O. Mao . 143 -4- Miller, Reverend Orlo History of Currency Used in Ontario 228 Mint-Royal Australian-Canberra 368 Mint-Royal Canadian-Extracts from 1964 Report 276 Modern Morality Tale, A-G. 1. Dickie 367 Mongol Vignette, A-William O. West 46 Montpetit, Robert Canadian Coin Week 50, 96, 133, 241 MEDALS Caesarea 447 Churchill 366 C.N.A. Convention, 1965 364 Commemorated Victories That Weren't 488 Egyptian (1882-1889) 403 Military General Service (1793-1814) 453 New Waterloo Society Medal 192 Royal Marriage Commemorative 7 The Laura Secord 361

McCabe, Larry The Problems of Token Coinage 10, 55, 101, 146

New Crowns for 1965-James W. Clark 285 Nickel and Coinage-Dr. H. S. Ward 327 Nomination News 98, 145, 193, 235 Nova Scotia Oddities-John W. Stephens . 123 Numismatics Across Canada-J. Douglas Ferguson 357, 405 Numismatics in the Maritimes-Major Shedon S. Carroll 189

Ontario Man Gets $1000 Nickel Prize 273 Ontario Numismatic Association Convention 234 Or Would You Rather Be A Judge?-Sylvia Haffner 323

Palmer, K. A. The Tokens of Mildmay and Formosa 279 Paper Money-Dr. O. 1,. Puckett . 190 Pieforts of France and Her Colonies-Normand D. Caron 485 Pittman, John J. . 489 Potter, G. R. 1,. Variations in Re-Engraved Dates of Canada's Large Cent of 1859 483 President's Message-E. Echenberg . 5 President's Message-A. Mitchell MacDonald ...... 356, 440, 481 Problems of Token Coinage, The-Larry McCabe . 10, 55, 101, 146 Puckett, Dr. O. 1,. Paper Money 190 Putting Numismatics Back Into Coins-Sol Taylor 57

Royal Marriage Commemorative Medals-Winifred Mather 7

Sargent, Tom Some Medals Commemorated Victories that Weren't 488 Seaby Re-Issues Churchill Medallion 319 Siggers, Paul Coin Grading at Home and Overseas: Points to Watch 446 Sir Isaac Brock and the Brock Half Pennies-J. Gibbs ., 13 Silver The Modern Metal 58 - 5- Stearns, Richard Are the 1902 'Fishscales' Type Coins ? 99 Stephens, John W. Nova Scotia Oddities 123 Stewart, D. M. Cigar Store Tokens 284 Grande Prairie Commemorative Token of 1964 330 Sweeton, Alex M. United States Civil War Coins and Currency 491

Taylor, Sol Putting Numismatics Back Into Coins 57 The Day The Mint Ran Out Of Money - Scott Young 47 The Party's Over-R. S. Yeoman . 396 Token Grande Prairie Commemorative of 1964-D. M. Stewart 330 Token Varieties, S1. George-Elwood Garns 97 TOKENS Cigar Store-D. M. Stewart 284 Countermarked-Kenneth L. Hallenbeck, Jr. 183 Countermarked Additional Notes-T. A. Wedge 325 Horwood of Newfoundland-Stuart Kenning, M.D. 231 Mildmay and Formosa, The-K A. Palmer 279 Porcheron, A.D., The-Fred Bowman 51 To List Or Not To List-Don Desaulniers 188 Trenka, Stephen-Gets $1000 Nickel Prize .... 273 Twenty-Five Cents of 1870-Forrest W. Daniel 282

United States Civil War Coins and Currency-Alex M. Sweeton 491

Values of Foreign Coins .. 490 Variations in Re-Engraved Dates of Canada's Large Cent of 1859- G. R. L. Potter . 483 Variety or Variant-William English . 443 Vigo Bay, The Big Sneeze Of-Alan Beardshaw 329

Ward, Dr. H. S. Nickel and Coinage 327 Waterloo Society Medal 192 Wedge, T. A. Additional Notes on Countermarked Canadian Coins and Tokens 325 West, William O. A Mongol Vignette 46 Willey, R. C. The Transactions of Canadian Numismatic Research Society 60 Addenda to the Bibliography of Canadian Numismatics 93

Yeoman, R. S. A Little Knowledge IS a Profitable Thing 232 The Party's Over . 396 Young, Scott The Day the Mint Ran Out of Money 47

INSERTS Index for 1964--February -6-