1
Environmental Impacts of
HGV Tolling Schemes
Werner Rothengatter
Universität Karlsruhe (TH)
2
Environmental Impacts of
HGV Tolling Schemes
Directive 2006(38 Impacts of German TollCollect Scheme Plans to Extend Directive 2006/38 Implementation Problems and Caveats More Comprehensive Internalisation
Schemes
Conclusions
3
1 Directive 2006/38
Full Infrastructure Cost Recovery Differentiation According to
- Time of Day/Congestion (100%) - Euro Emission Category (100%)
Implementation in Austria and Germany Use of Revenues for Road (ASFINAG) or Road/Rail/IWW (VIFG)
4
2 Impacts of German TollCollect Scheme
Introduced: 2005 GPS/km-based Charging System (Electronic
+ Manual)
Motorways + Some Federal Primaries Charges Based on Full Life Cycle Costs Differentiation According to Euro
Categories (100% since 2009)
5
Payment System
Traffic Control Center
Value added services
Road Operator
"Toll Collect"
GPS
Pyment
Information
Payment/ VAS
Positioning
GSM/
- Call Center
- Internet
POS
SMS
Forwarder
On Board Unit
Value added services
Manual Payment
Automatic Payment
6
Micro-Simulation of Toll Impacts
Impacts on Distance, Empty Running and Consignments
Simulation der Auswirkungen einer Maut
Leerfahrtendistanz
Empty Running Distance
TGoetsaalmDtdisisttaannzce
Without
Ohne Maut Mit Maut
With Maut
OhneWMaiutthout
Mit Maut
With Maut
Simulationsperioden
Simulation Periods
Simulationsperioden
Simulation Periods
Anzahl Transportf lle pro Woche
Consignments per Week
R ckkoppelungen auf
Feedback with
Routenwahl Losgr §en/Frequenzen
• Route/Mode Choice
Transporteffizienz
• Production Process
Ohne Maut
Without
MWit Miatuht Maut
• Transport Intensity
Sowohl speditionsseitig als auch produktionsseitig.
Simulationsperioden
Simulation Periods
Quelle: IWW
Growth of Rail Freight Induced by Road
Growth of Rail Freight Traffic Comared with the Reference
7
Tolls
Scenario 2010
- Szenario I
- Szenario IIa
- Szenario IIb
45% 40% 35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10%
5% 0%
FG RT
BG RT
- FG
- BG
- FG
- BG
- FG
RT
BG RT
- FG
- BG
- FG
- BG
- SG
RV
- MG
- SG
- MG
- SG
- MG
- DLT DLT BLT BLT
- DLT DLT BLT BLT
- RV BFV BFV GFV GFV
SG = Goods with logistic Requirements, MG = Bulk Cargo, RV = Regional Transport, BFV = Domestic Transport, GFV = International Transport
Scen. I: Motorways, only and present rail productivity Scen. II: All Roads and present rail productivity Scen. II: All Roads and improved rail productivity
8
Modelled development of HGV fleet composition
Development of the HDV Fleet Structure in Germany in the Reference Case 1995 - 2010 x
60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10%
0%
- 1995
- 1997
- 1999
- 2001
- 2003
Euro-3
- 2005
- 2007
- 2009
- Euro-0 (Pre-Euro)
- Euro-1
- Euro-2
- Euro-4
- Euro-5
9
Estimated vkm HGV in Germany by Euro Emission Categories
Entwicklung der Verteilung der mautpflichtigen Fahrleistungen
Figures 2005-11/07: BAG
in Deutschland nach Schadstoffklassen 01-2005 bis 12-2010 (in %)
Figures 11/07-2010: Estimations of Prog Trans AG
(Quellen: 2005 - 10/2007: BAG; ab 11/2007: Schätzungen der ProgTrans AG)
100
90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10
0
S1 S2 S3 S4 S5
`
EEV /S6
10
3 Plans to Extend Directive 2006/38
Integration of External Costs Handbook of CE et al. Proposal of the Commission Present Status
11
Proposal of the Commission
Restrict to Three Externalities:
Congestion, Noise, Air Pollution
Take Medium Values of Handbook as
Cap Values
Leave Introduction and Final Design to Member Countries
Reconsider the Scheme in 2013
12
Handbook: Marginal External Costs of HGV
Ūct/vkm 50.0
125.0
75.0
70.0
45.0 40.0 35.0
35.0
30.0 25.0 20.0 15.0 10.0
5.0
12.8
- 10.5
- 10.6
8.5
7.0
3.1
- 2.7
- 2.7
- 2.6
- 2.2
2.0
- 1.1
- 0.0
- 0.0
- 0.0
- 1.2
1.1
0.0
- Noise
- Congestion
- Accidents
Unit cost value
- Air pollution
- ClimatechangeŹ
- Up- anddownstream
processes
Nature& Soil & landscape water
- min
- max
13
4 Implementation Problems and Caveats
Implementation Problems
- Calculation of costs for the routes and different times of day and vehicle categories
- Transaction costs
Caveats
- Dominance of congestion - Restriction to trucks inefficient - Undesired diversion effects - Impacts on land use
14
From Brindisi to Chiasso through Italy
15
1055 km in total
16
Trip scheduling
CORRIDOR : BRINDISI (IT) - CHIASSO (IT) 1055 KM
Start at 7.00 am
Segments
Bari (Italy) Molfetta
Area
interurban interurban
- Start
- Arrival km
- Period
HighPeak HighPeak
Medium Peak
Off Peak
Medium Peak
HighPeak HighPeak HighPeak
Medium Peak
Off Peak
1 Brindisi 2 Bari 3 Molfetta
7.00 AM 8.22 AM 8.22 AM 9.00 AM 9.00 AM 10.00 AM
72
Canosa di Puglia interurban
- 730
- 4 Canosa di Puglia
5 Faenza
Faenza San Lazzaro Bologna interurban 10.00 AM 5.00 PM interurban interurban suburban interurban interurban interurban interurban
5.00 PM 6.00 PM 6.00 PM 6.22 PM 6.22 PM 6.45 PM 6.45 PM 8.01 PM 8.01 PM 9.00 PM 9.00 PM 9.55 AM 9.55 AM 10.30 PM
6 San Lazzaro 7 Bologna area 8 Bologna 9 A1 KM 55
10 A1 KM 115 11 Milano
15
A1 KM 55 A1 KM 115 Milano
190
- Chiasso
- 48
- Off Peak
Total Corridor
1.055
- 17
- 18
Environmental Effectiveness
Di f f er en t ial Charge
- E5/E4
- E5/E3
- E5/E2
c t s/ k m; >32 t Handbook Prog t rans /IW W
1.7 2.6
4.8 6.5
6.8
12.3
Brea k - e v en E3 - > E5 Handbook
80,000 km
Brea k - e v en E3 Š > E 5 Progt r/ I W W
60,000 km
Brea k - e v en E4 - > E5 Prog t r / I WW
50,000 km
19
5 More Comprehensive Internalisation Schemes
Complete Schemes: All Externalities,
Mix of Instruments
Goal Driven instead of Being Based on
Abstract Paradigms
Whole Network instead of Motorways, only
Incentive Compatible
20
Mix of Instruments
Taxation (incl. Insurance) Km Charges with Env. Diff. Emission Trading Regulation Investment in Alternative
Modes
21
Scen. UL+RailProd: Tonkm by Distance and Mode
Non-bulk Cargo
- 22
- 23
Little Trust of EC in Own Strategy?
White Paper: Revitalisation of Raiways TEN-T: Clear Prioritisation of Railways,
IWW and Motorways of the Sea
Mid-term Review: Co-modality, No
Prosperous Future of Railways and IWW
Logistic Action Plan: Strengthening Pot- ential of Railways/IWW
Giga-trucks: Vague Position
24
Freight Transport Development According to Mid-term Review
Zur Anzeige wird der QuickTime™
Dekompressor „“ benötigt.
25
Zur Anzeige wird der QuickTime™
Dekompressor „“ benötigt.
26
Modal Split of Rail Freight in Germany
Zur Anzeige wird der QuickTime™
Dekompressor „“ benötigt.
27
Gigaliners on EU Roads?
Folie 28
28
6 Conclusions
Tolling a Powerful Instrument in a Bundle of
Policies
Environmental Differentiation Gives Strong
Incentives to Use Better Technology
Goal Orientation Instead of Abstract Para- digms of Economic Welfare Theory
High Potential of Comprehensive Strategies
for Technological Improvement and Modal Change
Reducing Transport Intensity as a Challenge
Economic Crisis Fostering Structural Change:
Setting Market Conditions and Incentives Right
29
A Tsunami Followed the Financial Crisis. It might Induce a Creative Disruption.