DOCSLIB.ORG

I. the Royal Malaysia Police

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
I. the Royal Malaysia Police HUMAN RIGHTS “No Answers, No Apology” Police Abuses and Accountability in Malaysia WATCH “No Answers, No Apology” Police Abuses and Accountability in Malaysia Copyright © 2014 Human Rights Watch All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America ISBN: 978-1-62313-1173 Cover design by Rafael Jimenez Human Rights Watch is dedicated to protecting the human rights of people around the world. We stand with victims and activists to prevent discrimination, to uphold political freedom, to protect people from inhumane conduct in wartime, and to bring offenders to justice. We investigate and expose human rights violations and hold abusers accountable. We challenge governments and those who hold power to end abusive practices and respect international human rights law. We enlist the public and the international community to support the cause of human rights for all. Human Rights Watch is an international organization with staff in more than 40 countries, and offices in Amsterdam, Beirut, Berlin, Brussels, Chicago, Geneva, Goma, Johannesburg, London, Los Angeles, Moscow, Nairobi, New York, Paris, San Francisco, Tokyo, Toronto, Tunis, Washington DC, and Zurich. For more information, please visit our website: http://www.hrw.org APRIL 2014 ISBN: 978-1-62313-1173 “No Answers, No Apology” Police Abuses and Accountability in Malaysia Glossary .......................................................................................................................... 1 Map of Malaysia .............................................................................................................. 2 Summary ......................................................................................................................... 3 Key Recommendations ................................................................................................... 14 Methodology ................................................................................................................. 16 I. The Royal Malaysia Police ........................................................................................... 17 Royal Commission on Police Reform ....................................................................................... 21 II. Human Rights Violations by Police ............................................................................. 24 Malaysian and International Legal Standards on Use of Force ................................................. 24 Excessive Use of Force: Shooting of Suspects ......................................................................... 27 Deaths in Custody .................................................................................................................. 43 Torture and Other Ill-Treatment by Police ............................................................................... 62 Excessive Use of Force during Rallies ..................................................................................... 66 III. Lack of Transparency and Meaningful Accountability ................................................ 76 Police Internal Review Mechanisms ........................................................................................ 77 Prosecutions ......................................................................................................................... 80 Civil Damages ......................................................................................................................... 85 External Review Mechanisms ................................................................................................. 86 Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission (EAIC) ................................................................... 89 Recommendations ......................................................................................................... 95 To the Government of Malaysia ............................................................................................... 95 To the Inspector General of Police ........................................................................................... 97 To the Attorney General ........................................................................................................ 101 To the Office of High Commissioner on Human Rights............................................................ 101 Acknowledgments ....................................................................................................... 102 Appendix A: ................................................................................................................. 103 Letters to Agencies of the Government of Malaysia Requesting Data ............................ 103 Appendix B: Information Received from the Royal Malaysian Police Criminal Investigation Department ................................................................................................................. 109 Appendix C: Information Received from the Attorney General’s Office on Cases Involving Police Suspects ............................................................................................................ 112 Appendix D: Letter from Royal Malaysian Police on Police Training in Human Rights Topics .......................................................................................................................... 122 Glossary AG Attorney General AGC Attorney General’s Chambers ASP Assistant Superintendent of Police CID Criminal Investigation Division CPC Criminal Procedure Code DAP Democratic Action Party DDA Dangerous Drugs (Special Measures) Act 1985 DBKL Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur, Kuala Lumpur City Hall EAIC Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission EO Emergency (Public Order and Prevention of Crime) Ordinance 1969 FRU Federal Reserve Unit IGP Inspector General of Police IGSO Inspector General Standing Order IPCMC Independent Police Complaints and Misconduct Commission ISA Internal Security Act LRT Light Rail Transit MACC Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission MMC Malaysian Medical Council MOU Memorandum of Understanding NFA No Further Action PCA Prevention of Crime Act 1959 PAS Parti Islam Se-Malaysia, Pan-Malaysia Islamic Party PDRM Polis Diraja Malaysia, Royal Malaysia Police PRS Police Reporting System RELA Ikatan Relawan Rakyat Malaysia, Malaysian People’s Volunteer Corps RM Malaysian Ringgit (RM 1 equals US$0.30) RMP Royal Malaysia Police SDR Sudden Death Report SOP Standard Operating Procedure SOSMA Security Offenses (Special Measures) Act Suhakam Suruhanjaya Hak Asasi Malaysia, Malaysian Human Rights Commission UMNO United Malay National Organization 1 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH|APRIL 2014 Map of Malaysia “NO ANSWERS, NO APOLOGY” 2 Summary I ask Allah how my son felt when he saw a gun at his forehead, knowing he was about to die. Was he crying, screaming, “Don’t kill me?” —Norhafizah, mother of Mohd Shamil Hafiz Shapiei, 15, killed by police in 2010, Kuala Lumpur, April 2012 There is stiff resistance from police when anyone questions them. When we inquire about a case, the police tell us that it’s under investigation and everything is done according to procedures, but we are not given their SOPs [standard operating procedures] or ever told what their investigation found. “Trust us,” they say, “We are taking care of it.” But people want tangible proof of what action they take which is nowhere to be seen. There are no checks and balances. —Investigator at the Malaysian Human Rights Commission (SUHAKAM), Kuala Lumpur, May 2012 Police abuse remains a serious human rights problem in Malaysia. Unjustified shootings, mistreatment and deaths in custody, and excessive use of force in dispersing public assemblies persist because of an absence of meaningful accountability for Malaysia’s police force, the Royal Malaysia Police (RMP). Investigations into police abuse are conducted primarily by the police themselves and lack transparency. Police officers responsible for abuses are almost never prosecuted. And despite recent reforms, there is still no effective independent oversight mechanism to turn to when police investigations falter. The result is heightened public mistrust of a police force that has engaged in numerous abuses and blocked demands for accountability. This report examines more than 15 cases of alleged police abuse in Malaysia since 2009, drawing on first-hand interviews, complaints by victims or their families, and news reports. In only a handful of cases has the Malaysian government conducted serious investigations and held accountable those responsible. Government statistics provided to Human Rights Watch show that the majority of prosecutions of the police are for corruption and drug- related offenses and not deaths in custody, ill-treatment, or excessive use of force. 3 HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH|APRIL 2014 The Royal Commission to Enhance the Operation and Management of the Royal Malaysia Police (the “Royal Commission”), established in 2004 by the Malaysian king (Yang di- Pertuan Agong), raised serious concerns about police abuses. The Royal Commission received over 900 complaints of abuse including deaths in custody, physical and psychological abuse of detainees, misuse of administrative detention laws, abuse of power, and systematic lack of accountability and transparency. In 2005, the Royal Commission issued its report with 125 recommendations, including that the government amend relevant laws to make them comply with international human rights standards, and take steps to eradicate corruption, enhance investigative policing, and improve police support and
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Tayangan Filem Cereka 2018
    TAYANGAN FILEM CEREKA 2018 NO TARIKH MULA JUDUL FILEM PENGARAH NAMA SYARIKAT STATUS ASTRO SHAW SDN. BHD 1. 11.01.2018 BUSKER KYE FARIZ SELESAI TAYANGAN . TEDDY CHIN & EDEN LOMO PICTURES SDN. 2. 18.01.2018 BEST STORY (MANDARIN) SELESAI TAYANGAN WAN BHD ACE MOTION 3. 25.01.2018 BUKAN CINTA MALAIKAT AZIZ M. OSMAN PRODUCTION SDN. SELESAI TAYANGAN BHD DHANANWOODD FILMS 4. 01.02.2018 MAKRIFAT CINTA KAMAL G SELESAI TAYANGAN SDN. BHD PROFESSOR DR. A. LOMO PICTURES SDN. 5. 15.02.2018 BADANG SELESAI TAYANGAN RAZAK MOHAIDEEN BHD LOMO PICTURES SDN. 6. 15.02.2018 A HOUSE OF HAPPINESS JY TENG SELESAI TAYANGAN BHD JAGUAR LIM FILMS & 7. 22.02.2018 AMAZING TITANMAN (MANDARIN) EDDIE TIGER SELESAI TAYANGAN PROD. (M) SDN. BHD GLOBAL SOLUTION 8. 22.02.2018 SURF THIS LOVE WAAN HAFIZ SELESAI TAYANGAN RESOURCES SDN. BHD YKS FILM MAKER SDN. 9. 01.03.2018 BIDONG THE BOAT PEOPLE YUSOF KELANA SELESAI TAYANGAN BHD VIPER STUDIOS SDN. 10. 08.03.2018 KL SPECIAL FORCE SYAFIQ YUSOF SELESAI TAYANGAN BHD 11. 08.03.2018 GET HARD (MANDARIN) CHAN WAI CHEONG STORIDEAS SDN. BHD SELESAI TAYANGAN KS ARMADA MEGAH 12. 15.03.2018 33KM FROM KL (TAMIL) KS UMAAGAANTHAN SELESAI TAYANGAN SDN. BHD 13. 15.03.2018 LEE CHONG WEI RISE OF THE LEGEND (MANDARIN) TENG BEE CB PICTURES SDN. BHD SELESAI TAYANGAN AIFA MOTION PICTURES 14. 22.03.2018 HANTU WANGAN AHMAD IDHAM SELESAI TAYANGAN SDN. BHD RANGKAIAN MELATI 15. 29.03.2018 ENJIN NO 9 RAJA AZMI SELESAI TAYANGAN PRODUCTION SDN. BHD GVKM ELEPHANT 16. 19.04.2018 VILLAVAN VASSAN KUMARAN SELESAI TAYANGAN PICTURES SDN.
    [Show full text]
  • Hadi Hugs Preacher Zakir, Najib Shakes His Hand Malaysiakini.Com Apr 16Th, 2016 Umno President and Prime Minister Najib Abdul
    Hadi hugs preacher Zakir, Najib shakes his hand MalaysiaKini.com Apr 16 th , 2016 Umno president and Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak as well as PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang met with controversial Muslim preacher Zakir Naik ahead of his lecture in Kuala Lumpur this afternoon. Najib met with Zakir at a breakfast meeting at the PM’s residence, while Hadi met Zakir at an undisclosed venue in Putrajaya. “It is my hope that Zakir can tell the world that Malaysia is a moderate country which is always encouraging Muslim unity,” Najib said in a Facebook posting. He also uploaded a picture of him shaking hands with the Zakir, who is dressed in a suit. PAS meanwhile uploaded a picture of Hadi embracing Zakir in what they called a “historic meeting” of their own in Putrajaya. The meeting is part of the Indian national preacher’s Malaysia tour from April 15 - 18, PAS said in a Facebook post. Zakir, whom the Agong awarded 'tokoh maal hijrah' in 2013, courted controversy when inspector-general of police (IGP) Khalid Abu Bakar ordered the cancellation of the Malacca and Kuala Lumpur lectures, citing a threat to public peace. Hindu groups had lodged police reports against the lecture, saying that Zakir had previously made slanderous comments against other religions. Khalid retracted the ban on the Kuala Lumpur event, while Home Minister Ahmad Zahid Hamidi overturned the IGP’s decision on the Malacca lecture. However, the topic of Zakir's Malacca lecture has been changed from comparisons with Hinduism, to women’s rights in Islam.
    [Show full text]
  • Penang DAP Rally for Their Embattled Leaders Malaysiakini.Com April 01, 2012 by Susan Loone & Low Chia Ming
    Penang DAP rally for their embattled leaders MalaysiaKini.com April 01, 2012 By Susan Loone & Low Chia Ming A group of 30 DAP supporters held a brief rally in support of their leaders who had been attacked and criticised recently by various quarters, at the party's Penang headquarters today. The party's Tanjong division Youth vice chief Sukumar Subramaniam acted as spokesperson for the group which held the rally for 15 minutes, in front of Wisma DAP, the new HQ on Rangoon Road , penang dap member rally 010412 kirushnanHe was accompanied by the party's state Indian Culture bureau chief AR Kirushan (left) and Penang municipal councillor Harbinder Singh. Accompanied by members from other ethnic communities, the group held a banner, newspaper cuttings to support their leaders but refrained from criticisng anyone. They shouted pro-DAP slogans including "Putrajaya, here we come!". In a statement issued at the event, Sukumar said that the group had full confidence in DAP national chief Karpal Singh, secretary general and Penang chief minister Lim Guan Eng and state chairman and Tanjong MP Chow Kon Yeow. "We fully support Karpal who has sacrificed his entire life for the party and nation and will lead the whole party into the general election to capture Putrajaya," said Sukumar. "We, DAP members will have our energy and mind focussed to win the coming GE. Other negative distractions will not disunite us," he added. "Our enemy is BN and only BN. We will fight until we win Putrajaya. The marching towards Putrajaya has started here and our DAP leaders will lead the way," he stressed.
    [Show full text]
  • A/Hrc/32/Ni/5
    联 合 国 A/HRC/32/NI/5 Distr.: General 大 会 10 June 2016 Chinese Original: English 人权理事会 第三十二届会议 议程项目 6 普遍定期审议况 马来西亚人权委员会提交的书面材料 秘书处的说明 人权理事会秘书处根据理事会第 5/1 号决议附件所载议事规则第 7 条(b)项的 规定，谨此转交下文所附马来西亚人权委员会提交的来文。** 根据该条规定， 国家人权机构的参与须遵循人权委员会议定的安排和惯例，包括 2005 年 4 月 20 日第 2005/74 号决议。 具有促进和保护人权国家机构国际协调委员会赋予的“A 类”认可地位的国家人权机构。 ** 附件不译，原文照发。 GE.16-09511 (C) 130616 130616 A/HRC/32/NI/5 Annex [English only] Contents Page I. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 3 II. Status of Implementation of the 150 Recommendations Accepted by Malaysia ............................. 4 2.1 International Obligations ....................................................................................................... 4 2.2 Civil and Political Rights ....................................................................................................... 5 2.3 Economic, Social and Cultural Rights ................................................................................... 8 2.4 Vulnerable/Marginalised Groups ............................................................................................. 11 2.5 National Mechanisms on Human Rights ............................................................................... 16 2.6 Trafficking in Persons .............................................................................................................. 17 2.7 National Unity ........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Trends in Southeast Asia
    ISSN 0219-3213 2016 no. 9 Trends in Southeast Asia THE EXTENSIVE SALAFIZATION OF MALAYSIAN ISLAM AHMAD FAUZI ABDUL HAMID TRS9/16s ISBN 978-981-4762-51-9 30 Heng Mui Keng Terrace Singapore 119614 http://bookshop.iseas.edu.sg 9 789814 762519 Trends in Southeast Asia 16-1461 01 Trends_2016-09.indd 1 29/6/16 4:52 PM The ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute (formerly Institute of Southeast Asian Studies) was established in 1968. It is an autonomous regional research centre for scholars and specialists concerned with modern Southeast Asia. The Institute’s research is structured under Regional Economic Studies (RES), Regional Social and Cultural Studies (RSCS) and Regional Strategic and Political Studies (RSPS), and through country- based programmes. It also houses the ASEAN Studies Centre (ASC), Singapore’s APEC Study Centre, as well as the Nalanda-Sriwijaya Centre (NSC) and its Archaeology Unit. 16-1461 01 Trends_2016-09.indd 2 29/6/16 4:52 PM 2016 no. 9 Trends in Southeast Asia THE EXTENSIVE SALAFIZATION OF MALAYSIAN ISLAM AHMAD FAUZI ABDUL HAMID 16-1461 01 Trends_2016-09.indd 3 29/6/16 4:52 PM Published by: ISEAS Publishing 30 Heng Mui Keng Terrace Singapore 119614 [email protected] http://bookshop.iseas.edu.sg © 2016 ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute, Singapore All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form, or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior permission. The author is wholly responsible for the views expressed in this book which do not necessarily reflect those of the publisher.
    [Show full text]
  • SSM Annual Report 2010
    CONTENTS 02. Milestones 2010 07. Minister’s Message 11. Chairman’s Foreword 15. CEO’s Review of the Year 23. SSM’s Commission Members 31. SSM’s Executive Management 41. 2010 Economic Review and SSM’s Key Statistical Analysis 49. Report on Public Service Delivery System 63. Report on Enforcement Initiatives 93. Report on Stakeholders’ Engagements, Collaborations and Law Reform 113. Financial Statements COVER RATIONALE The 2010 Annual Report cover depicts a breathtaking view of ‘the reflection’ of SSM’s headquarters through the glass panels of another building: a clear ‘reflection of SSM 2010’ as it stands tall, committed to enhancing public service delivery and facilitating business. SSM is all set to achieve new heights in meeting business needs by creating a conducive and responsive business environment for the nation. 2 COMPANIES COMMISSION OF MALAYSIA MILESTONES 2010 27–29 JANUARY 2010 PUBLIC UNIVERSITIES Outreach programme: ‘Your Business Begins at SSM’ held at UniKL. Four Public Universities and seven Private Universities participated to encourage UNIVERSTI KEBANGSAAN MALAYSIA entrepreneurship among graduates. National University of Malaysia Public Universities • International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM) • Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) • Universiti Teknologi Mara (UiTM) • University of Malaya (UM). Private Universities • Universiti Kuala Lumpur (UniKL) • Universiti Teknikal Malaysia, Melaka (UTeM) PRIVATE INSTITUTIONS • Management And Science University (MSU) • Advanced Management and Technology Centre (PTPL) College • Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia (USIM) • Universiti Tenaga Nasional (Uniten) • Kuala Lumpur Metropolitan University (KLMU). PTPLCollege Your Assurance Of Excellence 28 JANUARY 2010 Signing of the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) between SSM and UNICEF with the main objective being to collaborate on enhancing the welfare of children in Malaysia through the practice of CR among the corporate and business community.
    [Show full text]
  • Barriers to Mobility
    An Overview of Research and Factsheets #mymobilitymatters 1 BARRIERS cover TO WOMEN’S MOBILITY An Overview of Research and Factsheet s #MYMOBILITYMATTERS An Overview of Research and Factsheets #mymobilitymatters 2 CONTENTS 02 04 PREFACE AHRC RESEARCH TEAM 05 WOMEN’S MOBILITY 06 08 STATISTICS RELATED TO CRIME CASES WOMEN 10 FOCUS GROUP DISCUSSION 16 20 QUESTIONNAIRE SURVEY SHARING DISCUSSION 23 CONCLUSION www.womenmobility.com An Overview of Research and Factsheets #mymobilitymatters 3 The research entitled “Barriers to Women’s AHRC Mobility” intended to explore the struggle and barriers of women while travelling and RESEARCH basically addressing two of the UN’s Global Goals for Sustainable Development TEAM It is a network project for the research team to acquire first-hand knowledge of UNITED KINGDOM COVENTRY UNIVERSITY the problems women experience in PROF DR. ANDREE accessing transport and analyse the existing WOODCOOK solutions and their effectiveness in UNIVERISITY OF ILLINOIS Pakistan, Malaysia and the UK DR. DEANA CATHERINE MCDONAGH PAKISTAN (DESIGNPAK) KOMAL FAIZ PUNNAL FAIZ MALAYSIA UNIVERSITY MALAYA DR YONG ADILAH SHAMSUL HARUMAIN DR NIKMATUL ADHA DR GOH HONG CHING DR NOOR SUZAINI RESEARCH ASSISTANT MIRAWAHIDA LEE WEI SAN NETWORK RESEARCH SUHANA MUSTAFA AHMAD AL-RASHID An Overview of Research and Factsheets #mymobilitymatters 4 However, it is not equally accessible for every WOMEN’S individual in benefiting from the advanced transport system due to differences need. Mobility on public transportation is focused as it MOBILITY has increasingly become a societal concern nowadays. There is growing mobility literature on It has been long recognized the importance of the gender differences in mobility development of transport system, not only in enabling individuals to travel further and faster to In the study on the choice of destinations but also have a greater transportation, mobility is societal and economic impacts globally to create a defined as the movement of more sustainable living world.
    [Show full text]
  • Malaysian Box Office 2018
    MALAYSIAN BOX OFFICE 2018 RELEASE TICKET COLLECTION NO FILM TITLE DIRECTOR STATUS DATES (RM) 1. 11.01.2018 BUSKER KYE FARIZ 68,739.94 FINISHED TEDDY CHIN & EDEN 2. 18.01.2018 BEST STORY (MANDARIN) 123,077.58 FINISHED WAN 3. 25.01.2018 BUKAN CINTA MALAIKAT AZIZ M. OSMAN 127,940.79 FINISHED 4. 01.02.2018 MAKRIFAT CINTA KAMAL G 138,686.04 FINISHED PROFESSOR DR. A. 5. 15.02.2018 BADANG 93,496.54 FINISHED RAZAK MOHAIDEEN 6. 15.02.2018 A HOUSE OF HAPPINESS JY TENG 1,568,136.05 FINISHED 7. 22.02.2018 SURF THIS LOVE WAAN HAFIZ 47,724.30 FINISHED 8. 22.02.2018 AMAZING TITANMAN (MANDARIN) EDDIE TIGER 92,634.05 FINISHED 9. 01.03.2018 BIDONG THE BOAT PEOPLE YUSOF KELANA 3,536.00 FINISHED 10. 08.03.2018 LEE CHONG WEI – RISE OF THE LEGEND (MANDARIN) TENG BEE 4,753,281.14 FINISHED 11. 08.03.2018 33KM FROM KL (TAMIL) KS UMAAGAANTHAN 18,779.00 FINISHED 12. 08.03.2018 KL SPECIAL FORCE SYAFIQ YUSOF 12,216,321.00 FINISHED 13. 08.03.2018 GET HARD (MANDARIN) CHAN WAI CHEONG 89,834.52 FINISHED 14. 22.03.2018 HANTU WANGAN AHMAD IDHAM 89,420.70 FINISHED 15. 29.03.2018 ENJIN NO 9 RAJA AZMI 7,566.17 FINISHED 16. 19.04.2018 VILLAVAN VASSAN KUMARAN 72,018.85 SCREENING OVERALL TOTAL YEAR 2018 (RM) 19,511,192.67 MALAYSIAN BOX OFFICE 2017 RELEASE TICKET COLLECTION NO FILM TITLE DIRECTOR STATUS DATES (RM) NOR ZAHIRAH BINTI 1.
    [Show full text]
  • ARE WE ASHAMED of IPOH’S GLORIOUS PAST? by Jerry Francis “City That Tin Built” – About Sums up the History of Ipoh and Its Heritage
    www.ipohecho.com.my JUNE 1 DEADLINE If you want to continue receiving the Ipoh Echo every fortnight with your daily newspaper, please IPOH inform your newsvendor. echoYour Voice In The Community See box on the right. echo May 16-31, 2010 PP 14252/10/2010(025567) FREE COPY ISSUE 97 rom 1st June please inform your news vendor to deliver the >> Pg 3 >> Pg 4 FIpoh Echo every fortnight if you wish to continue receiving your community paper. We are still a free paper. To help us defray PROTECTING THE LET’S NOT REMAIN INNOCENTS our distribution costs, we’re asking you, dear reader, to pay your A BACKWATER news vendor 30¢ per issue for delivery, i.e., a cost of 60¢ per month. A small sum for you to keep up with the latest news and information of your Ipoh community. Thank you for your continuing support of the Ipoh Echo – Your Voice of the Ipoh Community. ARE WE ASHAMED OF IPOH’S GLORIOUS PAST? By Jerry Francis “City That Tin Built” – about sums up the history of Ipoh and its heritage. These four words are also an effective slogan to promote the city. Not “Bougainvillea City” or by any other slogans. On May 27 Ipoh will celebrate its 22nd anniversary as a city. But it is sad that through all those years nothing seems to have been done to reflect its glorious past as the centre of the tin mining industry which had been so significant in the economic development of the country. The tin mining industry has since collapsed; the history of the city will also slowly fade away and be forgotten.
    [Show full text]
  • Framing Interethnic Conflict in Malaysia: a Comparative Analysis of Newspaper Coverage on the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf)
    International Journal of Communication 6 (2012), 166–189 1932–8036/20120166 Framing Interethnic Conflict in Malaysia: A Comparative Analysis of Newspaper Coverage on the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) LAI FONG YANG Taylor's University Malaysia MD SIDIN AHMAD ISHAK University of Malaya, Kuala Lumpur Despite repeated warnings from the Malaysian government, the Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) rally drew thousands of Indians protesting on the streets of Kuala Lumpur on November 25, 2007. Mistreatment of Indians and lack of press coverage of their plight had been commonplace for years. By employing framing as the theoretical framework and content analysis as the research method, this study examines what perspectives newspapers have created that influence citizens’ understanding of the Hindraf movement. Three mainstream newspapers were found to focus on the conflict frame, and their representation of Hindraf articulated a hegemonic discourse that was prejudicial to the interests of the group and contrary to a spirit of democratic inquiry. The dissimilar coverage of the same issue by the alternative newspaper denoted that publication’s varied points of view, which were rooted in different political beliefs, cultural assumptions and institutional practices. Introduction Since gaining independence in 1957, the Malaysian government has viewed interethnic relations as a real challenge to the social stability of the country (Abdul Rahman, 2000; Baharuddin, 2005; Brown, 1994). As early as 1970, Mahathir Mohamad, who was then a medical doctor and later became the fourth and longest-serving prime minister of Malaysia, claimed that there was never true racial harmony in Malaysia. In his much-debated and once-banned book, The Malay Dilemma, he argued that although there was a certain amount of tolerance and accommodation, racial harmony in Malaysia was neither real nor Lai Fong Yang: [email protected] Md Sidin Ahmadd Ishak: [email protected] Date submitted: 2011–06–03 Copyright © 2012 (Lai Fong Yang & Md Sidin Ahmad Ishak).
    [Show full text]
  • The Follies of Umno and the EC Malaysiakini.Com July 4, 2011 On
    The follies of Umno and the EC Malaysiakini.com July 4, 2011 On Nov 10, 2007, around 40,000 protestors made their way towards Istana Negara in Bersih's first march for clean and fair elections. Did it make a difference? Yes. The rakyat experienced change. It galvanised them by reinforcing their belief that together they could prove a point - that Umno is not infallible. That Umno is not great. That Umno has an Achilles heel which will bring it down: Arrogance. abdullah ahmad badawi pm anti inflation pc 090608After 2007, the promises from both Abdullah Ahmad Badawi (left), the prime minister at the time, and the Election Commission (EC) have all come to nought. As a result of this, Bersih 2.0 was bound to happen. The rakyat half expected Umno and its loyal and obedient servant, the EC, to break whatever pledges they made. Five years on, have we seen any of the Bersih's demands implemented? In 2007, Abdullah said that the EC had acceded and would comply with many of the demands of Bersih. azlan“They wanted a transparent ballot box and the use of indelible ink to prevent multiple voting. The EC has agreed to that. Other than that, they can negotiate with the commission.” The EC now says that ink is only for backward countries. They forget that we are as backward as any other banana republic. What use is a transparent ballot box when it is alleged that boxes stuffed with BN-only votes are swapped with those from the actual polling station? 'The same body since independence' In the 2007 report by Malaysiakini, Abdullah thought it incredulous that the opposition kept finding fault with the EC “despite the commission being the same body since independence”.
    [Show full text]
  • View the Table of Contents for This Issue: Https
    http://englishkyoto-seas.org/ View the table of contents for this issue: https://englishkyoto-seas.org/2018/12/vol-7-no-3-of-southeast-asian-studies/ Subscriptions: http://englishkyoto-seas.org/mailing-list/ For permissions, please send an e-mail to: [email protected] SOUTHEAST ASIAN STUDIES Vol. 7, No. 3 December 2018 CONTENTS Divides and Dissent: Malaysian Politics 60 Years after Merdeka Guest Editor: KHOO Boo Teik KHOO Boo Teik Preface ....................................................................................................(269) KHOO Boo Teik Introduction: A Moment to Mull, a Call to Critique ............................(271) ABDUL RAHMAN Ethnicity and Class: Divides and Dissent Embong in Malaysian Studies .........................................................................(281) Jeff TAN Rents, Accumulation, and Conflict in Malaysia ...................................(309) FAISAL S. Hazis Domination, Contestation, and Accommodation: 54 Years of Sabah and Sarawak in Malaysia ....................................(341) AHMAD FAUZI Shifting Trends of Islamism and Islamist Practices Abdul Hamid in Malaysia, 1957–2017 .....................................................................(363) Azmi SHAROM Law and the Judiciary: Divides and Dissent in Malaysia ....................(391) MAZNAH Mohamad Getting More Women into Politics under One-Party Dominance: Collaboration, Clientelism, and Coalition Building in the Determination of Women’s Representation in Malaysia .........................................................................................(415)
    [Show full text]