DOCSLIB.ORG

Legislative Assembly

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Legislative Assembly New South Wales Legislative Assembly PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (HANSARD) Fifty-Seventh Parliament First Session Wednesday, 18 November 2020 Authorised by the Parliament of New South Wales TABLE OF CONTENTS Announcements ...................................................................................................................................... 4853 Thought Leadership Breakfast ............................................................................................................ 4853 Bills ......................................................................................................................................................... 4853 Drug Supply Prohibition Order Pilot Scheme Bill 2020 .................................................................... 4853 First Reading ................................................................................................................................... 4853 Mandatory Disease Testing Bill 2020 ................................................................................................ 4853 Second Reading Debate .................................................................................................................. 4853 Consideration in Detail ................................................................................................................... 4874 Committees ............................................................................................................................................. 4878 Legislation Review Committee .......................................................................................................... 4878 Report: Legislation Review Digest No. 23/57 ................................................................................ 4878 Report: Legislation Review Digest No. 24/57 ............................................................................... 4878 Committee on the Health Care Complaints Commission ................................................................... 4880 Report: Review of the Health Care Complaints Commission's 2017-18 and 2018-19 Annual Reports .................................................................................................................................................................... 4880 Legislation Review Committee .......................................................................................................... 4882 Membership .................................................................................................................................... 4882 Joint Standing Committee on Road Safety ......................................................................................... 4882 Membership .................................................................................................................................... 4882 Announcements ...................................................................................................................................... 4882 Australasian Parliamentary Administration Conference .................................................................... 4882 Members ................................................................................................................................................. 4882 Representation of Ministers Absent During Questions ...................................................................... 4882 Question Time ........................................................................................................................................ 4882 Asset Recycling .................................................................................................................................. 4882 State Budget and Health ..................................................................................................................... 4883 Land Tax ............................................................................................................................................. 4884 State Budget and Agriculture .............................................................................................................. 4885 Land Tax ............................................................................................................................................. 4887 State Budget ........................................................................................................................................ 4888 Camellia Land Purchase ..................................................................................................................... 4889 State Budget and COVID-19 .............................................................................................................. 4890 Independent Commission Against Corruption ................................................................................... 4892 State Budget and Social Housing ....................................................................................................... 4892 Committees ............................................................................................................................................. 4893 Legislative Assembly Committee on Law and Safety ........................................................................ 4893 Reports ............................................................................................................................................ 4893 Legislative Assembly Committee on Investment, Industry and Regional Development ................... 4893 Inquiry ............................................................................................................................................. 4893 Business of the House ............................................................................................................................. 4893 TABLE OF CONTENTS—continuing Suspension of Standing and Sessional Orders: Petition Debate ......................................................... 4893 Suspension of Standing and Sessional Orders: Christmas Felicitations ............................................. 4893 Petitions .................................................................................................................................................. 4894 Petitions Received .............................................................................................................................. 4894 Bills ......................................................................................................................................................... 4894 Mandatory Disease Testing Bill 2020 ................................................................................................ 4894 Consideration in Detail ................................................................................................................... 4894 Public Interest Debate ............................................................................................................................. 4905 Government Performance ................................................................................................................... 4905 Motions ................................................................................................................................................... 4912 Independent Commission Against Corruption ................................................................................... 4912 Reference ........................................................................................................................................ 4912 Bills ......................................................................................................................................................... 4912 Mandatory Disease Testing Bill 2020 ................................................................................................ 4912 Consideration in Detail ................................................................................................................... 4912 Business of the House ............................................................................................................................. 4917 Suspension of Standing and Sessional Orders: Referral to the Independent Commission Against Corruption ...................................................................................................................................................... 4917 Motions ................................................................................................................................................... 4917 Independent Commission Against Corruption ................................................................................... 4917 Reference ........................................................................................................................................ 4917 Bills ......................................................................................................................................................... 4923 Mandatory Disease Testing Bill 2020 ................................................................................................ 4923 Consideration in Detail ................................................................................................................... 4923 Business of the House ............................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Moving Towards the Entrenchment of Parliamentary Committees (Neil
    49TH PRESIDING OFFICERS AND CLERKS CONFERENCE WELLINGTON 8 – 13 JULY 2018 ** Paper to be presented by Neil Laurie Clerk of the Parliament, Queensland Moving towards the entrenchment of parliamentary committees Moving towards the entrenchment of parliamentary committees 2018 celebrates the 30th anniversary of the re-introduction of parliamentary committees in the Queensland Parliament. Committees went into abeyance in the Queensland Parliament from 1922 when the Legislative Council was abolished and it became unicameral until 1988 with the introduction of a Public Works Committee. The Committee system was overhauled in 2011 into a comprehensive, modern system. Further reforms in the 55th Parliament have moved Queensland closer to entrenching committees as an integral part of the parliamentary process; especially as regards the consideration of legislation. Some history re the Queensland committee system From its commencement in 1860 the Queensland Parliament had a very active committee system. Bills were regularly considered by committees and other issues, such as state development projects, were the subject of extensive inquiry.1 From the commencement of the 20th century, coinciding with the rise of political parties, committees went into decline. Only a handful of select committees (excluding domestic committees) were established after 1904 (apart from a brief period of increased committee use from 1912 to 1914, during the 19th Parliament). There were no select committees established after 1915. In 1922 the Legislative Council was abolished. This was also the effect death-knell for committees. Apart from domestic committees (the Library Committee, Refreshment Room Committee, Privileges Committee and Papers Committee etc.) there was not a single select committee established between 1915 and 1974.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of the Queensland Parliament, 1957–1989
    14 . The demise of the Coalition and the Nationals governing alone, 1981–1983 In 1980, backroom plans had been already entertained for a stand-alone National Party government supplemented by a few Liberal ‘ministerialists’— opportunists who would cross over and side with whatever the next ministry turned out to be in order to remain part of the next government. Historically, ‘ministerialists’ were typically senior parliamentarians who, forgoing party loyalties, decided to collaborate as individuals in the formulation of a new government. After the 1980 election, however, any such musing was put on hold as the two conservative parties lapsed back into coalition. This time, the Nationals clearly imposed their dominance, taking the prime portfolios and consigning the ‘leftovers’ to the Liberals. Labor began to refer to the junior partners as ‘Dr Edwards and his shattered Liberal team’—the losers who were ‘now completely the captive of the National Party’ (QPD 1981:vol. 283, p. 7). Despite his vitriolic attacks against the Premier and the National-led government, Llew Edwards retained his position as Deputy Premier and Treasurer—positions he would keep until he was deposed by Terry White on the eve of the Coalition collapse in August 1983, although there was an unsuccessful attempt by dissident Liberals to remove Edwards in November 1981. When the Premier learned about the dissident Liberal plan to topple Edwards, with Angus Innes taking the lead, he declared Innes an ‘anti-coalitionist’ and someone with whom he would not work. Instead, Bjelke-Petersen began hatching plans to form a minority government with whomsoever among the Liberals who would give him support; and then to govern alone until mid-1982.
    [Show full text]
  • Knox Family Stories
    Stories about my Knox Ancestors Bruce Fairlie December 20, 2015 1 2 1 Introduction While researching the details of my mother’s lineage, I became in- terested in the the fascinating stories associated with a number of her ancestors. I have chosen several of them to look at in rather greater detail, and their stories are presented in here. 3 2 Knoxes in London William Knox was one of my great-great-great-grandfathers. He was born about 1782 or 1793, perhaps in Scotland, perhaps in a foundling hospital in London. In any case, he was in London in 1820 when he married Dorothy (Dorothea) Fleming. Dorothy was born in Scotland, in about 1795. They wasted no time in starting a family, their first child, William, being born in August 1820 and a second, Margaret Janet, in February 1822. At about the same time, the congregation of the struggling Cale- donian Chapel at Cross Street, Hatton Garden in London were in need of a new minister. A Mr Laurie, one of the Elders of the Chapel, while on business in Glasgow ’talent spotted’ Edward Irving, who was at that time an assistant to the pre-eminent Dr Thomas Chalmers at the Tron Church. He asked Edward to undertake a four-week trial as minister at the Chapel in London. The trial was a success, and Irving was offered the job. Indeed, so keen were the Elders to have him that the obligatory need for the pastor to preach in Gaelic was removed, the Elders getting a Bill passed to annul this requirement.
    [Show full text]
  • Goodies Rule – OK?
    This preview contains the first part ofChapter 14, covering the year 1976 and part of Appendix A which covers the first few episodes in Series Six of The Goodies THE GOODIES SUPER CHAPS THREE 1976 / SERIES 6 PREVIEW Kaleidoscope Publishing The Goodies: Super Chaps Three will be published on 8 November 2010 CONTENTS Introduction ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................7 ‘Well – so much for Winchester and Cambridge’ (1940-63) ...............................................................................................9 ‘But they’re not art lovers! They’re Americans!’ (1964-65) .............................................................................................23 ‘It’s a great act! I do all the stuff!’ (1965-66) ...................................................................................................................................31 ‘Give these boys a series’ (1967) .....................................................................................................................................................................49 ‘Our programme’s gonna be on in a minute’ (1968-69)THE .......................................................................................................65 ‘We shall all be stars!’ (1969-70) .....................................................................................................................................................................87
    [Show full text]
  • Family Doctor Week July 21-27 Highlighting GP-Led Health Care, P3
    Family Doctor Week July 21-27 highlighting GP-led health care, p3 4 Q&A with the President 7 Bupa and Terry White 8 Family doctor profiles 18 Suicide prevention adviser 19 Bartone and Dutton Congo cholera campaign INSIDE 37 ISSUE 31.13 JULY 15 2019 AUSTRALIAN MEDICINE - 31.13 JULY 15 2019 1 In this issue Managing Editor: John Flannery National News 3, 7-18 Editor: Chris Johnson Graphic Design: Streamline Creative, Canberra Health on the Hill 19-21 Contributors: Nicholas Elmitt Advertising enquiries Research 32-35 Streamline Creative Tel: (02) 6260 5100 World News 36-39 Australian Medicine is the na tion al news publication of the Australian Medical Association Limited. (ACN 008426793) Columns 42 Macquarie St, Barton ACT 2600 Telephone: (02) 6270 5400 Facsimile: (02) 6270 5499 4 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE Web: www.ama.com.au 6 VICE PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE Email: ausmed@ama.com.au 23 GENERAL PRACTICE Australian Medicine welcomes diversity of opinion on national health issues. For this reason, published articles reflect the views 24 PUBLIC HEALTH OPINION of the authors and do not represent the official policy of the AMA unless stated. Contributions may be edited for clarity and length. 25 RURAL HEALTH Acceptance of advertising material is at the absolute discretion of 26 AMSA the Editor and does not imply endorsement by the magazine or the AMA. 27 DOCTORS IN TRAINING All material in Australian Medicine remains the copyright of the AMA or the author and may not be reproduced without 28 FINANCE AND ECONOMIICS permission. The material in Australian Medicine is for general 29 INDIGENOUS TASKFORCE information and guidance only and is not intended as advice.
    [Show full text]
  • Coalition.Pdf
    Kezia Griffin, ‘Maintaining a Relationship: The Queensland Coalition’ Centre for the Government of Queensland Summer Scholar Journal , 1, 2010-11 The official merger of the Queensland National and Liberal parties occurred in 2008 and saw the creation of the Liberal National Party (LNP). Since the amalgamation many have doubted the long term success and practicality of maintaining such a close partnership, and given inter and intra party conflict which has been a feature of coalition politics in the past, these critics are not without credibility. The fundamental argument against the amalgamation of the Liberal and National parties is that they are essentially two separate entities with different constituents and policy agendas. Though united by opposition to the Labor movement, the Liberals predominantly represent ‘business interests and conservative urban voters’ while the National Party has always aimed to be a ‘voice for rural interests’1. With this in mind it is difficult to envision how a cooperative coalition and now united party can be maintained while their greatest shared value is their opposition to Labor. History itself provides few answers to this question with the Liberal and National parties in Queensland butting heads over countless issues in regard to their varying social agendas. Amongst other issues, matters of economic management and trade hold major stumbling blocks for the cooperation of the two anti-Labor parties. This was evident in the debate in federal parliament in 1997 in which the Howard government, in true
    [Show full text]
  • Somerset Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment
    Richardson, Joanna and Allen, Dan and Bloxsom, John and Brown, J and Cemlyn, S and Greenfields, M and Lishman, R (2011) Somerset Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment. Project Report. De Montfort Univer- sity Leicester. Downloaded from: https://e-space.mmu.ac.uk/623499/ Version: Published Version Publisher: De Montfort University Leicester Please cite the published version https://e-space.mmu.ac.uk Somerset Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment Final edit: 14th January 2011 Jo Richardson, Dan Allen, John Bloxsom, Tim Brown, Sarah Cemlyn, Margaret Greenfields and Ros Lishman Final Draft submitted: 27th October, 2010 1 Somerset Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment Acknowledgements The project team would like to thank everyone involved in the research project. We are particularly grateful for the advice and information from Sally Woodbury and Maggie Smith-Bendell of the Romany Gypsy Advisory Group South West, Tony Thompson and Emma Nuttall of Friends, Families and Travellers, Rachel Inman, Julez Jones, Sioux How and everyone at the Robert Barton Trust. The project team would like to acknowledge the work of all the community interviewers who undertook the survey; this study would not have been possible without their hard work and local knowledge and expertise. Thank you also to Lucy Workman at the Traveller Education Service and Debbie Harvey at the Children‟s Society. Finally, thank you to Andy Foyne at South Somerset District Council, and all of the key contacts at the district and county councils for information and advice, and to Patsy Wallace for clear project timetables and guidance. 2 Somerset Gypsy and Traveller Accommodation Assessment Contents Executive summary Pg 4 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Canine Listener • Page 1 Canine Listener Robin Dickson, Pres./CEO Fed
    Winter 2011 • Canine Listener • Page 1 Canine Listener Robin Dickson, Pres./CEO Fed. Tax ID #93-0681311 Winter 2011 • NO. 115 Special Girl - Special Birthday Party Katie I. from New Jersey is a very special 10-year-old young lady. Every year for her “kid” birthday party, she asks for donations for a charity instead of birthday gifts. She has do- nated food and supplies to her local humane society and a local wildlife rescue organiza- tion. Last year she chose DFD for her charity! Her family was thrilled when she asked for dog toys and treats on her party in- vitations. After the party, they boxed up the goodies and mailed them to us for the dogs in training. We excitedly opened the box of toys and treats, and the dogs were thrilled with them! It is especially heartwarming to see someone this young who is so generous and anxious to help. Katie is obviously a dog lover, and we are very grateful for her special help. Her dona- tions help the dogs succeed in training and go on to fulfill their mission in life. Thank you McLoughlin Bulldogs! Thank you to the McLoughlin Bulldogs, Team 81, from McLoughlin Middle School in Medford, Oregon. They sent us a box of toys and treats for our dogs, along with a holiday card that included some of the following special notes from the kids: “Thank you for what you do. It really means a lot.” ~ Brittney P. “Hope you guys like the toys we got. Happy holidays.” ~ Zarissa M. “Thank you dogs for helping deaf people, without you it would be hard for them.” ~ Gage Our dogs in training asked us to pass along a message to the stu- dents and their teacher, Ms.
    [Show full text]
  • 5309T1510.Pdf
    How different would unlikely choice. He was not a good public speaker short. The coalition was re-elected in 1969 only Queensland have been if Jack and, even as a youngish backbencher, he was a because voters did not want a dull and limited Pizzey, who had a university degree problem for the party whips. His first cabinet Labor Party led by a dull and limited Jack Houston, and the experience of life gained portfolio was Works. It was ideal, because bridges, about whom the most exciting thing to be said was by serving as a World War II roads, schools, police stations - all the great items of that he judged dog shows. Queenslanders had not artillery officer, had not died in state government spending - could be dispensed to warmed, either, to Bjelke-Petersen, a curious man August 1968? For with his electorates. And Bjelke-Petersen never forgot the with a convoluted speaking style, a difficult name death, Johannes Bjellce- backbenchers concerned owed him a favour. and the reputation of being - not to put too fine a Petersen became premier. In 1968, those favours were called in. point on it - a wowser and a Bible basher. Bjelke-Petersen seemed an Bjelke-Petersen's premiership was nearly very Late in October 1970, Bjelke-Petersen was in 1920 copper fields; threaten >> 1922 state-wide industrial government for three Disquiet over Labor viability of industry. Death of George Silas turmoil (to 1929). Depression years; policies including bids > Australian Workers Curtis, left, > Qld conservatives Country National to abolish upper house; Union gains 44-hour Rockhampton's martyr merge as Country and Party leader Arthur Labor returned with week in Qld; to separation Progressive National Moore is premier.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of the Queensland Parliament, 1957–1989
    15 . The implosion of Joh Bjelke- Petersen, 1983–1987 The 1983 election ended the ‘constitutional crisis’ by providing the Nationals with exactly half the seats in the Parliament (41) and the opportunity to supplement their ministry with Liberal ministerialists who would agree to join the new government. The Premier had a number of options to secure his majority. Many of the surviving former Liberal ministers were not generally regarded as ‘anti-coalitionists’ in the previous government. The six potential ministerialists who might have been persuaded to change allegiances were: Norm Lee, Bill Lickiss, Brian Austin, Don Lane, Colin Miller and even Bill Knox. According to the Courier-Mail (15 July 1983), when two Coalition backbenchers, Bill Kaus and Bob Moore, had quit the Liberals and joined the Nationals in July, two Liberal ministers, Norm Lee and Bill Lickiss, already had indicated they would consider jumping ship. It was almost as if a race to defect was on. The two other Liberals to survive the 1983 poll, Terry White and Angus Innes, would not have been acceptable to the Premier and his senior ministers. In total, six of the eight Liberals had been ministers (although Miller had served for just 13 days after White was sacked and before the resignations of all the Liberals were accepted). Knox had been a minister since 1965 and Lee and Lickiss had been ministers since early 1975. They had some pedigree. Austin and Lane (and White) each had one parliamentary term as minister. Two Liberals, however, took the issue into their own hands. The day after the election, Austin and Lane had discussed the prospects of defecting and swapping parties, with Austin saying ‘I’m sick of this…I reckon we ought to give ’em the arse.
    [Show full text]
  • Australasian Parliamentary Review Autumn 2011, Vol. 27, No. 1
    Australasian Parliamentary Review Autumn 2011, Vol. 27, No. 1 FROM YOUR EDITOR Jennifer Aldred 1 ARTICLES 3 # A comparative analysis of rights scrutiny of bills in New Zealand, Australia and the United Kingdom: Is New Zealand lagging behind its peers? Catherine Rodgers 4 # Anti-corruption agencies: Impact on the privileges and immunities of parliament Carly Sheen 18 # Not quite as expected: Victorian Labor and the Legislative Council 2010 Paul Rodan 34 AUSTRALASIAN STUDY OF PARLIAMENT GROUP CONFERENCE 2011: THE EXECUTIVE VERSUS THE PARLIAMENT: WHO WINS? Parliament and the challenge of executive growth 44 Is the traditional role of parliament still valid in our society? Sonia Hornery 45 # Executive growth and the takeover of Australian parliaments Scott Prasser 48 Balancing the need for the executive’s right to govern against the necessity for parliamentary scrutiny 62 A new era of parliamentary reform Judy Spence 63 # Resisting executive control in Queensland’s unicameral legislature — recent developments and the changing role of the speaker in Queensland Kate Jones and Scott Prasser 67 Holding oppositions to account: the slow surrender of parliamentary democracy Jay Tilley 85 Diminishing the efficacy of disallowance motions: quasi-legislation in state jurisdictions Scott Hickie 91 # These papers have been double blind reviewed to academic standards The effects of non-government controlled upper houses on restraining the executive 108 # The impact of multi-party government on parliament-executive relations — examples from Britain and
    [Show full text]
  • Political Chronicle QUEENSLAND
    Political Chronicle QUEENSLAND Queensland politics over the last six months of 1983 were dominated by a series of tumultuous events. The state's twenty-six year old coalition government disintegrated, and was replaced for the nine-week period leading up to the state election by a National party minority government. At that election the Nationals secured 41 out of the possible 82 seats, though with the defection to them, a matter of days after the election, of two former Liberal ministers (who, incidentally, were returned as Liberal members on election day), the National party was able to form a government in its own right. For its part, the Liberal party in Queensland was almost destroyed as a political force in this state as a result of this series of events. An interesting feature of the events which took place in August was that, while the coalition break-up was sparked by incidents in the state Parliament, the Parliament itself was not involved in any of the events (e.g. the formation of a minority government) which were to follow. In this respect, the actions of the state governor, acting on the premier's advice, were to prove of considerable political significance. The Coalition Crisis The coalition crisis was set in motion on 4 August by the action of Terry White, at the time a Liberal minister in the state's coalition government, in supporting in the Legislative Assembly a Liberal backbench motion for the suspension of standing orders. White's support of this motion, which in its intent was aimed at bringing forward debate about the possible establishment of a parliamentary public accounts committee in Queensland, was interpreted by his own party leader (Dr Edwards) and by the premier (Mr Bjelke-Petersen) as a breach of ministerial responsibility.
    [Show full text]