DOCSLIB.ORG

Business Case

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Business Case Millennium Line Broadway Extension (MLBE) Project Business Case March 2018 Millennium Line Broadway Extension March 2018 Business Case Page I TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .............................................................................................................................. 4 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................. 4 Current Transit Cannot Meet Demand Along the Broadway Corridor .................................................. 4 Strategic Analysis of Potential Project Alternatives .............................................................................. 5 Proposed Scope of Millennium Line Broadway Extension.................................................................... 6 Benefits of the MLBE for the Province and Region ............................................................................... 6 Procurement Assessment ..................................................................................................................... 7 Project Schedule and Costs .................................................................................................................. 7 Project Funding ..................................................................................................................................... 9 1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................. 10 1.1 Purpose ..................................................................................................................................... 10 PART A – RATIONALE FOR THE PROJECT ........................................................................................... 12 2 STRATEGIC CONTEXT ..................................................................................................................... 13 2.1 Province of British Columbia ..................................................................................................... 13 2.2 Metro Vancouver Region .......................................................................................................... 15 2.3 TransLink .................................................................................................................................. 17 2.4 Broadway Corridor .................................................................................................................... 19 3 EXISTING CHALLENGES .................................................................................................................. 21 3.1 Limiting Economic Development Potential ............................................................................... 21 3.2 Capacity, Reliability And Travel Times Of Existing Transit Services ........................................ 22 3.3 Existing Gaps and Bottlenecks in Rapid Transit Network ........................................................ 23 3.4 Assist in Achieving Mode Share and Environmental Targets ................................................... 25 4 PROJECT OBJECTIVES AND OUTCOMES ..................................................................................... 26 PART B – DELIVERY OF THE PROJECT ................................................................................................ 27 5 ASSESSMENT OF POTENTIAL PROJECT ALTERNATIVES ......................................................... 28 5.1 Identification and Evaluation of Potential options ..................................................................... 28 5.2 Decision to Phase Rapid Transit Development On Broadway Corridor ................................... 29 5.3 Identification and Evaluation of Potential Project Alternatives ................................................. 31 5.4 Updated Multiple Account Evaluation Summary ...................................................................... 31 5.5 Recommendation ...................................................................................................................... 36 Millennium Line Broadway Extension March 2018 Business Case Page II 6 PHYSICAL ASSET SCOPE ............................................................................................................... 37 6.1 Project Alignment ...................................................................................................................... 38 6.2 Station Scope ............................................................................................................................ 40 6.3 Operation and Maintenance Scope .......................................................................................... 43 6.4 Bus Operating Cost Savings ..................................................................................................... 44 7 PROJECT ASSESSMENT.................................................................................................................. 45 7.1 Capital and Operating Cost Estimate ....................................................................................... 45 7.2 Benefit Cost Analysis ................................................................................................................ 46 7.3 Project Impact ........................................................................................................................... 50 7.4 Sensitivity Analysis ................................................................................................................... 53 7.5 Achievement of Project Objectives ........................................................................................... 53 8 PROJECT STATUS ............................................................................................................................ 54 8.1 Engagement Program ............................................................................................................... 54 8.2 Technical Planning .................................................................................................................... 54 8.3 Environment .............................................................................................................................. 55 PART C – PROCUREMENT OPTIONS ANALYSIS .................................................................................. 56 9 APPROACH ........................................................................................................................................ 56 9.1 Procurement Options Identification ........................................................................................... 56 9.2 Procurement Options Analysis ................................................................................................. 56 10 PROCUREMENT OPTIONS ANALYSIS – DB VERSUS DBF .......................................................... 58 10.1 Multiple Criterion Analysis ........................................................................................................ 58 10.2 Risk Analysis ............................................................................................................................. 59 10.3 Financial Modelling ................................................................................................................... 61 10.4 Value for Money Calculation ..................................................................................................... 66 10.5 Market Sounding ....................................................................................................................... 67 11 RECOMMENDED PROCUREMENT OPTION ................................................................................... 68 PART D – PROCUREMENT PLAN AND FUNDING IMPACT .................................................................. 69 12 PROCUREMENT PLAN ..................................................................................................................... 69 12.1 Recommended Procurement Process ...................................................................................... 69 12.2 Procurement Schedule ............................................................................................................. 69 12.3 Project Governance .................................................................................................................. 70 12.4 Project Delivery ......................................................................................................................... 71 12.5 Communications and Consultation ........................................................................................... 73 12.6 Performance Measurement ...................................................................................................... 73 Millennium Line Broadway Extension March 2018 Business Case Page III 13 FUNDING ............................................................................................................................................ 76 13.1 Project Costs ............................................................................................................................. 76 13.2 Sources of Funding ................................................................................................................... 78 13.3 Project Funding Requirement Summary ................................................................................... 80 PART E – RECOMMENDATION ...............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Customer Service Performance September 2020 West Coast Express
    Customer Service Performance September 2020 West Coast Express © Synovate Table Of Contents Highlights and Recommendations 3 Project Objectives 8 Methodology 9 Detailed Findings 12 WCE Performance 13 Trends in Transit Usage Among WCE Riders 22 Trends in WCE Usage 29 Customer Profiles 36 APPENDICES Appendix A – Survey Instrument 2 Highlights and Recommendations The revised West Coast Express Customer Service Performance Survey was launched in March 2003. The survey was redesigned to focus solely on the aspects of service that are most positively correlated with system performance ratings from customers. In addition, the redesigned survey implements the Transportation Research Board’s Impact Score Method to identify and prioritize those service attributes that are most negatively impacting the largest number of customers. This will assist in the prioritization of service improvements. 3 Highlights and Recommendations • Many of the significant shifts in top ratings for WCE service aspects may be attributable to riders’ changing perceptions and expectations as a result of the ongoing COVID-19 virus. As of March 11th, the World Health Organization declared COVID-19 a global pandemic, and by March 16th the BC provincial government recommended stay- at-home directives and physical distancing precautions, which has greatly impacted the daily lives of transit riders. While restrictions have eased in recent months as the provincial government has moved BC into Phase 3 of its Restart Plan (which allows for safe travel and re-opening of businesses such as restaurants/bars), concern around the COVID-19 virus is highly relevant for the general public. As a result, the proportion of Captive WCE Riders has increased directionally (36%, up from 29% last period), which may have an impact on the results throughout the report.
    [Show full text]
  • 2017 05 11 Translink Increases Seabus Frequency
    MEDIA RELEASE TransLink increases SeaBus frequency 15-minute sailings will now run until 9 p.m. May 11, 2017 NEW WESTMINSTER, BC — Starting May 19, customers will benefit from another SeaBus service increase as part of TransLink’s continued roll out of Phase One of the 10-Year Mayors’ Vision for Metro Vancouver Transportation. This service increase means 15-minute sailings will start earlier on weekends and run until 9 p.m. every day, making it even easier to travel to or from the North Shore. SeaBus service increases include: 15-minute sailings starting at 6 a.m. on weekdays, 7 a.m. on Saturdays and 8 a.m. on Sundays and most holidays. 15-minute service will also extend later into the evening. This will allow customers to enjoy peak-hour service for departures until 9:02 p.m. from Lonsdale Quay and 9:16 from Waterfront Station every day. As part of Phase One of the 10-Year Vision, TransLink increased SeaBus service in January by doubling service on Sundays and holidays from 10 a.m. to 7 p.m. With the May 19 increase, SeaBus joins the Frequent Transit Network (FTN), a network of corridors where transit service runs at least every 15 minutes in both directions through the day and into the evening, every day of the week. People traveling along Frequent Transit Network corridors can expect convenient, reliable, easy-to-use services that are frequent enough that they do not need to refer to a schedule. Other TransLink services that are part of the FTN include the Expo, Millennium and Canada lines, and B-Line bus service.
    [Show full text]
  • Skytrain Upgrade Project
    BACKGROUNDER SKYTRAIN UPGRADE PROJECT Upgrades to the existing SkyTrain network are necessary to meet current and future demand, and are a pre-condition for new rapid transit projects WHAT IS THE SKYTRAIN UPGRADE PROJECT? The 2014 Vision for Metro Vancouver Transit and Transportation included analysis and recommendations on the type of investments needed to keep the existing SkyTrain system modern and up to the task of meeting growing demand over the next 30 years. The upgrade project includes: 100 new Mark III SkyTrain cars (28 already funded in Phase One Plan; 72 cars remaining); New storage and maintenance facilities for the new cars Control and power system upgrades to ensure new cars can be operated Station upgrades to improve passenger amenities and access WHY IS THIS UPGRADE PROJECT NEEDED NOW? Current and future ridership will strain the existing system The Expo Line officially launched in 1986 and the Millennium Line opened in 2002. Since then the population and level of employment in the region has grown, and the current capacity of the system is insufficient to meet the demands during period periods. This is resulting in passengers being passed up and crowding on platforms at the busiest stations during peak periods. The recent opening of the Evergreen Extension has resulted in higher ridership and crowding on the system more quickly than anticipated. This is expected to worsen with more people coming to the region, more development near stations, and planned bus expansion in the 10-Year Vision connecting to the SkyTrain system. Previous improvements and investments in the Phase One Plan only meets today’s needs TransLink procured 28 Mark III SkyTrain cars to meet the ridership demand from the Evergreen Extension, and the Phase One Plan of the 10-Year Vision includes 28 additional Mark III cars.
    [Show full text]
  • SUNWOOD SQUARE Coquitlam, BC
    SUNWOOD SQUARE Coquitlam, BC BentallGreenOak (Canada) Limited Partnership, Brokerage bentallgreenoak.com SUNWOOD SQUARE Coquitlam, BC LOCATION: 3025 Lougheed Highway, Coquitlam, BC MAJOR INTERSECTION: Lougheed Highway & Westwood Street TYPE: Open Community Centre (grocery anchored) RENOVATION: 2009 TOTAL GLA: 198,965 square feet MAJOR TENANTS: Shoppers Drug Mart 20,767 square feet Jysk 17,053 square feet ANCILLARY: 76,643 square feet (36 stores) DEMOGRAPHICS (2022 PROJECTIONS): MARKET SUMMARY: 1 km 3 km 5 km Sunwood Square is the dominant open community centre in the Coquitlam Town Centre trade area. Bisected Total Population 13,046 103,499 190,884 by two civic thoroughfares in addition to its proximity to the Lougheed Highway and Westwood Street arteries, Total Households 5,547 40,079 68,744 Sunwood Square offers superior access and parking availability in this affluent, established, yet still growing, Average trade area. Sunwood Square was extensively renovated in 2009. Household Income $83,443 $107,494 $124,993 Translink’s completion of the Millennium Line Evergreen Extension, which opened at the end of 2016, brought an increase in demand on the residential front. The Evergreen Extension connects Coquitlam City Centre through Port Moody to Lougheed Town Centre and onwards to Vancouver. In addition a significant number of residential condominium towers have been built within the vicinity with several others currently in the planning stages or under construction. Sunwood Square is well positioned at the heart of the growth within Coquitlam Town Centre. SUNWOOD SQUARE Coquitlam, BC UNIT TENANT SQ FT UNIT TENANT SQ FT 100 76,900 460 Sunwood Veterinary 220 Bloomin’ Buds Florist 613 Clinic 1,146 230 Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • Northwest Transit Exchange 2017
    Northwest UBC Transit Robson Square 800 Robson St. Exchange Vancouver, BC 2017 V6Z 3B7 Come join us for the 2017 Northwest Transit Exchange! The Northwest Transit Exchange is an annual event for transportation network and service planners throughout the West Coast of the US and Canada to come and share their expertise and learn about key and exciting initiatives from other agencies in our region. This year’s event will be hosted by TransLink, Metro Vancouver’s regional transportation agency. The Northwest Transit Exchange will take place over two full-days: Dates: Thursday, October 12th – Friday, October 13th 2017 Registration cost: Free! Travel, Meals, and Accommodations: Individual responsibility, coffee and refreshments provided Location: UBC – Robson Square 800 Robson Street Vancouver, BC V6Z 3B7 Below you’ll see some of the topics we’ll be discussing at this year’s Exchange. We have some speakers already lined up, but we’re also looking for people/agencies to share their expertise in some of the open sessions without presenters. Additionally, if there’s a topic you’re interested in presenting on that already has a speaker listed, please don’t hesitate to contact us anyhow! We’re open to having multiple presenters at each session. Also, if you have a topic/session that you would like to present please contact us and we will be happy to discuss further. The sessions are usually conversational, with a short presentation and then a larger group discussion. It’s a great opportunity to share what your agency is up to for further regional transportation success stories.
    [Show full text]
  • Companies Compete for Right to Sell Cannabis on UEL, Steps From
    Published by the University Neighbourhoods Association Volume 12, Issue 6 JUNE 21, 2021 Companies Compete for Right to Residents Sell Cannabis on UEL, Steps from UBC Rally but Achieve Little at UNA Board Meeting Anti-cannabis petition was launched online; impassioned speeches were made A delegation of residents did little but evoke sympathy for their cause at a UNA Board meeting on June 15. The delegates attended the meeting to pro- test the possibility of a cannabis company being granted the right to set up shop in the University Endowment Lands, steps from UBC. The provincial government—which man- ages the UEL—is taking steps to properly Another change of land use application on the University Endowment Lands, at the former Bubble Waffle Cafe location. handle the applications of two companies seeking licenses, and this includes mea- suring the pulse of the community, part of Neighbours are asked for the following: You won’t find screens or associates glued which are those living or working in Uni- comments; second company is • Taking the time to understand the culti- to iPads. Instead, you’ll receive personal- versity Marketplace. ized service and thoughtful information brought into the fray vation methodology and processing tech- niques of our core suppliers to ensure our regarding cannabis, in a retail environment The issue has garnered wide-spread inter- quality standards are met and that products that will leave you feeling calm and con- est, in large part because of the proximity John Tompkins are appropriately priced. fident. of the companies to UBC—where over Editor • Doing our part to ‘Break through the can- • The BC Government has deemed canna- 60,000 people are studying, pandemic nabis Stigma’ by staying informed of the bis retail an essential service.
    [Show full text]
  • For Transit Information, Including Real-Time Next Bus, Please Call 604.953.3333 Or Visit Translink.Ca
    Metro Vancouver Transit Map Effective Until Dec. 19, 2016 259 to Lions Bay Ferries to Vancouver Island, C12 to Brunswick Beach Bowen Island and Sunshine Coast Downtown Vancouver Transit Services £ m C Grouse Mountain Skyride minute walk SkyTrain Horseshoe Bay COAL HARBOUR C West End Coal Harbour C WEST Community Community High frequency rail service. Canada Line Centre Centre Waterfront END Early morning to late Vancouver Convention evening. £ Centre C Canada Expo Line Burrard Tourism Place Vancouver Millennium Line C Capilano Salmon Millennium Line Hatchery C Evergreen Extension Caulfeild ROBSON C SFU Harbour Evelyne Capilano Buses Vancouver Centre Suspension GASTOWN Saller City Centre BCIT Centre Bridge Vancouver £ Lynn Canyon Frequent bus service, with SFU Ecology Centre Art Gallery B-Line Woodward's limited stops. UBC Robson Sq £ VFS £ C Regular Bus Service Library Municipal St Paul's Vancouver Carnegie Service at least once an hour Law Edgemont Hall Community Centre CHINATOWN Lynn Hospital Courts during the daytime (or College Village Westview Valley Queen
    [Show full text]
  • No. 5, Eglinton Crosstown LRT, Page 18 Credit: Metrolinx
    2020 No. 5, Eglinton Crosstown LRT, Page 18 Credit: Metrolinx Top100 Projects 2020 One Man Changes the Face of 2020’s Top 10 Top100 Projects — 2020 f not for one individual, this year’s Top100 may have looked An annual report inserted in familiar. ReNew Canada’s I When this year’s research process began, there was little change within this year’s Top 10, as many of the nation’s January/February 2020 issue megaprojects were still in progress. Significant progress has been made on all of the projects we saw grace the Top 10 in our report last year, but completion dates extend beyond the end of the MANAGING Andrew Macklin 2019 calendar year. EDITOR [email protected] Enter Matt Clark, Metrolinx’s Chief Capital Officer, who took GROUP over the position from Peter Zuk. You see, when Zuk was in charge Todd Latham PUBLISHER of publicly expressing capital budgets, particularly in the context of the GO Expansion project, he had done so by breaking down PUBLISHER Nick Krukowski the $13.5 billion spend by corridor. That breakdown led to the full expansion represented by as many as nine projects in the content ART DIRECTOR AND Donna Endacott SENIORDESIGN of the Top100. Clark does it differently. In the quarterly reports made public ASSOCIATE following Metrolinx board meetings, the capital projects for the Simran Chattha EDITOR GO Expansion are broken down into three allotments (on corridor, off corridor, and early works). The result? Six less GO Expansion CONTENT AND MARKETING Todd Westcott projects in the Top100, but two new projects in our Top 10 MANAGER including a new number one.
    [Show full text]
  • Phase Two of the 10-Year Vision 2018 – 2027 INVESTMENT PLAN
    Phase Two of the 10-Year Vision 2018 – 2027 INVESTMENT PLAN APPROVED JUNE 28, 2018 tenyearvision.translink.ca TRANSLINK MAYORS’ COUNCIL BOARD OF DIRECTORS ON REGIONAL TRANSPORTATION Lorraine Cunningham, Chair Derek Corrigan, Chair Lois Jackson Mayor, City of Burnaby Mayor, City of Delta Larry Beasley Richard Walton, Vice-chair Greg Moore Jim Chu Mayor, District of North Vancouver Mayor, City of Port Coquitlam Sarah Clark Wayne Baldwin John McEwen Derek Corrigan Mayor, City of White Rock Mayor, Village of Anmore Mayor, City of Burnaby John Becker Darrell Mussatto Murray Dinwoodie Mayor, City of Pitt Meadows Mayor, City of North Vancouver Anne Giardini Malcom Brodie Nicole Read Mayor, City of Richmond Mayor, District of Maple Ridge Tony Gugliotta Karl Buhr Gregor Robertson Karen Horcher Mayor, Village of Lions Bay Mayor, City of Vancouver Marcella Szel Mike Clay Ted Schaffer Mayor, City of Port Moody Mayor, City of Langley Richard Walton Mayor, District of Jonathan Coté Murray Skeels North Vancouver Mayor, City of New Westminster Mayor, Bowen Island Municipality Ralph Drew Michael Smith Mayor, Village of Belcarra Mayor, District of West Vancouver Jack Froese Richard Stewart Mayor, Township of Langley Mayor, City of Coquitlam Maria Harris Bryce Williams Director, Electoral Area ‘A’ Chief, Tsawwassen First Nation Linda Hepner Mayor, City of Surrey For the purpose of the South Coast British Columbia Transportation Authority Act, this document constitutes the investment plan prepared in 2017 and 2018 for the 2018-27 period. This document will serve as TransLink’s strategic and financial plan beginning July 1, 2018, until a replacement investment plan is approved.
    [Show full text]
  • Schedule 04 – Appendix K Stations Emergency Egress Analysis
    BROADWAY SUBWAY PROJECT Commercial in Confidence PROJECT AGREEMENT EXECUTION COPY SCHEDULE 4 APPENDIX K – STATIONS EMERGENCY EGRESS ANALYSIS RIDERSHIP DATA 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................... 2 2. Design Year .......................................................................................................................................................... 2 3. Ridership and Train Operations Data .................................................................................................................... 2 BROADWAY SUBWAY PROJECT Commercial in Confidence PROJECT AGREEMENT EXECUTION COPY SCHEDULE 4 APPENDIX K – STATIONS EMERGENCY EGRESS ANALYSIS RIDERSHIP DATA 1. Introduction (a) This Appendix K [Stations Emergency Egress Analysis Ridership Data] sets out the data to be used by Project Co to conduct emergency egress calculations for determination of the required size of egress routes in the Stations. 2. Design Year (a) Project Co shall design all Stations for a design year of 2045 as per the data set out in this Appendix K [Stations Emergency Egress Analysis Ridership Data]. (b) This Appendix K [Stations Emergency Egress Analysis Ridership Data] was developed through the TransLink Regional Transportation (RTM) EMME 2045 forecast model. Projections corresponding with Arbutus Station as the terminus station versus extension of the line to UBC were evaluated, with the extension to UBC producing
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 Transit Service Guidelines
    2018 TRANSIT SERVICE GUIDELINES DRAFT: June 6, 2018 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION 2 3 REFERENCE INFORMATION 48 1.1 What are the Transit Service Guidelines? 3 3.1 Vehicle Capacity Reference Table 49 1.2 Using the Transit Service Guidelines 5 3.2 Service Productivity Reference Tables 50 1.3 Understanding Service Types 7 2 TRANSIT SERVICE GUIDELINES 10 APPENDIX 54 2.1 Overview 11 A Glossary 55 2.2 Layout and Organization 12 B References 59 DI Demand-oriented Service 14 C Acknowledgements 60 D.1 Transit-supportive Land Use and Demand 16 U Useful Service 20 U.1 Passenger Load 21 U.2 Stop Spacing 24 U.3 Service Frequency 26 U.4 Span of Service 28 U.5 Punctuality and Regularity 30 U.6 Route Design 34 PE Productive and Efficient Service 38 PE.1 Boardings per Revenue Hour 40 PE.2 Capacity Utilization 42 PE.3 Passenger Turnover 44 PE.4 Cost per Boarded Passenger 46 2 TransLink Transit Service Guidelines 1 Introduction 1. Introduction 1.1 What are the Transit Service Guidelines? 1.2 Using the Transit Service Guidelines 1.3 Understanding Service Types TransLink is the transportation authority for the Vancouver metropolitan area. It has responsibility for planning, managing, and delivering an integrated regional transit network—including rapid transit, commuter rail, and bus services—to provide access and mobility for people across the region. In consultation with stakeholders and customers, TransLink determines where demand is greatest, what types of service are most appropriate, and how resources are prioritized. The Transit Service Guidelines provide a framework for achieving these objectives and delivering a transit network useful to the greatest number of people.
    [Show full text]
  • Planning for RAV: Achieving Public Objectives in the Context of a PPP Project
    Planning for RAV: Achieving Public Objectives in the Context of a PPP Project Lon LaClaire, Transportation Engineer Anita Molaro, Development Planner CITY OF VANCOUVER CITY OF VANCOUVER Presentation Outline Vancouver and the Region The RAV Line Vancouver Stations Waterfront Station Robson Station Broadway Station Marine Drive Portal CITY OF VANCOUVER City of Vancouver Population of Vancouver:CITY OF VANCOUVER 550, 000 Constrained Region Population of Greater Vancouver Regional CITYDistrict: OF VANCOUVER 2.4 million Context: Greater Vancouver CITY OF VANCOUVER Dense Metropolitan Core CITY OF VANCOUVER Vancouver Transit Strategy Transit systems layers: local, city-wide, and regional CITY OF VANCOUVER Vancouver transit strategy The RAV Line CITY OF VANCOUVER Context - Regional RAV is one of three rapid transit lines that are cornerstones of Regional Land use and transportation plans – LRSP, Transport 2021. CITY OF VANCOUVER Regional Transit Network SeaBus Skytrain West Coast Express commuter rail RAV CITY OF VANCOUVER Context – Vancouver City of Vancouver land use and transportation plans support the regional plans: CityPlan Central Area Plan Transportation Plan Downtown Transportation Plan CITY OF VANCOUVER Rail Transit Is Needed Buses alone will not attract sufficient ridership to achieve the City’s transportation targets and land use goals Buses alone can not carry the number of transit trips needed to achieve the targets Rail is more compatible with the City’s livability goals CITY OF VANCOUVER 19991999 TransitTransit
    [Show full text]