Hot Rocks from Cold Places: a Field, Geochemical and Geochronological Study from the High Arctic Large Igneous P Rovince (HALIP) at Axel Heiberg Island, Nunavut
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! !"#$%"&'($)*"+$,"-.$/-0&1(2$3$451-.6$71"&81+5&0-$09.$ 71"&8*"9"-":5&0-$;#<.=$)*"+$#81$!5:8$3*&$>0*:1$ ?:91"<($/*"@59&1$A!3>?/B$0#$3C1-$!15D1*:$?(-09.6$ E<90@<#$ $ $ by Cole Girard Kingsbury A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Earth Sciences Ottawa – Carleton Geoscience Centre and Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2016 Cole Girard Kingsbury ! ! !"#$%&'$() ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) The geology of the Arctic is greatly influenced by a period of widespread Cretaceous magmatic activity, the High Arctic Large Igneous Province (HALIP). Two major tholeiitic magmatic pulses characterize HALIP: an initial 120 -130 Ma pulse that affected Arctic Canada and formally adjacent regions of Svalbard (Norway) and Franz Josef Land (Russia). In Canada, this pulse fed lava flows of the Isachsen Formation. A second 90-100 Ma pulse that apparently only affected the Canadian side of the Arctic, fed flood basalts of the Strand Fiord Formation. The goal of this thesis is to improve understanding of Arctic magmatism of the enigmatic HALIP through field, remote sensing, geochemical and geochronology investigations of mafic intrusive rocks collected in the South Fiord area of Axel Heiberg Island, Nunavut, and comparison with mafic lavas of the Isachsen and Strand Fiord Formations collected from other localities on the Island. Ground-based and remote sensing observations of the South Fiord area reveal a complex network of mafic sills and mainly SSE-trending dykes. Two new U-Pb baddeleyite ages of 95.18 ± 0.35 Ma and 95.56 ± 0.24 Ma from South Fiord intrusions along with geochemical similarity confirm these intrusions (including the SSE-trending dykes) are feeders for the Strand Fiord Formation lavas. The ages constrain a 3 Ma transition between the two pulses of older tholeiitic and the younger stage of alkaline magmatism that begins with the 92 Ma Wootton Igneous Complex. Based on trace element and Sm-Nd isotopic data, this 95 Ma pulse of South Fiord intrusives and Strand Fiord Formation lavas are derived from a homogenous upper mantle source that was crustally contaminated by sedimentary rocks of the Sverdrup Basin. In contrast, lavas of the older c. 120-130 Ma Isachsen Formation are derived from a heterogeneous mantle source and experienced significantly less crustal contamination. The mantle heterogeneity of lavas in the Isachsen Formation is probably defined in part by mantle melting that incorporated sediments from paleosubduction fronts ancestral to the Aleutian subduction zone. Furthermore, major element concentrations may also suggest contamination by evaporite diapirs from the Carboniferous Otto Fiord Formation. ! ""! ! !'*+,-./01/2/+$#() ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) “It takes a village to raise a Child” ~African Proverb “It takes a community to intellectually raise a PhD student” ~Paraphrased from above A Doctor of Philosophy degree is a massive undertaking that takes a community of dedicated individuals guiding aspiring students such as myself through the hoops and milestones even though only one name – mine – appears on the cover of this thesis. Firstly, I would like to thank Drs. Richard Ernst and Brian Cousens for playing a big game of chance 4 years ago in accepting me as their PhD student, being very supportive while also maintaining high expectations. I thank them greatly for helping me through this monumental project from start to end, sharing a wealth of knowledge in the fields of igneous geochemistry and large igneous provinces (LIPs) as well as unwittingly being “honorary Professors of Cole Management” in the last weeks of this degree journey. I would also like to thank Dr. Marie-Claude Williamson of the Geological Survey of Canada (GSC) for serving on my advisory committee and taking me on a field season on Axel Heiberg Island in part to help me with the field component of my project, setting me straight when required, as well as providing additional samples from her PhD thesis in order to supplement my thesis samples. In addition, I thank Dr. Steve Bergman of Shell –a generous and enthusiastic project sponsor – for his help in reviewing thesis chapters as well as lending his expertise on Arctic geology pertaining to HALIP. I also want to thank Rick McNeil and Steve Day (GSC team members who also were field members in 2013) for their company on Axel Heiberg Island during the 2013 field campaign and Gerry for skillful helicopter piloting and the company he provided during the extra days on the Island due to “Lowey” the low-pressure system. In addition I thank Jeff Harris for assistance in the remote sensing aspect of my work presented herein. Processing samples both for geochemical, isotopic and U-Pb age analysis took up the better part of my time in the middle years of this project, what I call the “dart- throwing” phase. I want to thank Tim Mount for assistance in teaching me how to use the ! """! ! rock saw, “blender,” and “Alvin” along with making my thin sections and the discussions about sample preparation process. Furthermore, I thank Etienne Menard and Matt Hanewitch for help in sample processing. Thanks to Dr. Shuangquan Zhang for help in guiding me through the process of turning rock powder into excellent Sm-Nd isotopic data including sample dissolution, ion exchange chromatography and mass-spectrometer loading and measurements. I also acknowledge Peter Jones in the microprobe lab here at Carleton University for helping me search for baddelyites in diabasic and gabbroic samples, Dr. Ulf, Soderlund at Lund University (Sweden) for separating these and Dr. Sandra Kamo (Jack Satterly geochronology lab, University of Toronto) for obtaining high quality U-Pb ages based on baddeleyites along with assistance in data interpretation. Finally I pay loads of thanks to Sonia Tanguay for being my Paul Menton Centre disability coordinator along with all the meetings we have had together in the last 4 years which helped me process emotions and thoughts and taught me that the sky is still up in the sky. In addition, I thank all of my fellow graduate students past and present in the LIPs and geochemistry research community for their camaraderie, help and support including Chris Rogers, Niko Kastek, Sarah Davey, Susan Kingdon, Dr. Ann Timmermans, Kim Klausen and Matthew Trenkler. Last but not least, I want to thank my friends and family back home in Oregon including my parental units Steve and Diane as well as friends at “16 ! Hour Fitness” and from KindTree Productions – Autism Rocks for their friendships and support from afar: this thesis is dedicated to them all and to all students presently writing their own thesis knowing that the journey to a complete thesis is a struggle – I salute you. This thesis was supported financially through an NSERC CRD Grant (CRDPJ 419503-11) to Dr. Richard Ernst, the Polar Continental Shelf Program (PCSP), the Geological Survey of Canada Environmental Geoscience project, a Geological Society of America Research Grant as well as a departmental scholarship. I count myself very lucky to be surrounded with very supportive people who can see beyond my Quirkiness. ! "#! ! 3%/4&'/()) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS: Field and sample collections: I (Cole Kingsbury) conducted fieldwork in the South Fiord region of Axel Heiberg Island, northern Canada, that involved documenting structural information about igneous intrusions and their relations with sedimentary rocks as well as making decisions about sample selection under the watchful eyes of Dr. Marie-Claude Williamson and Steven Day (both Geological Survey of Canada). I decided upon the general field area (South Fiord) in consultation with Dr. Marie-Claude Williamson but the specific field traversing area was determined on the spot largely by where snow was sufficiently melted to permit field traverses based on helicopter reconnaissance. The samples I collected from South Fiord were supplemented by archived samples collected by Dr. Marie-Claude Williamson in the Geodetic Hills and Camp Five Creek localities of Axel Heiberg Island initially for her PhD thesis. These archived samples were bequeathed to me at Dr. Williamson’s decision for this thesis as a means for chemical comparisons. Geochemical processing: Once samples from South Fiord along with Dr. Williamson’s archived samples arrived, I processed the South Fiord samples to thin section pucks and powder for major- and trace-element along with isotopic geochemistry. Assistants were hired to process Dr. Williamson’s samples. Tim Mount (Carleton University) made standard and single- polished thin sections on my specifications. On return of major- and trace element data from ALS Laboratories in North Vancouver, BC, I chose samples for Sm-Nd isotopic analysis. I weighed and dissolved spiked powders with the spike provided by Dr. Shuangquan Zhang (Carleton University). I then took each through ion exchange chromatography, and prepared and ran each through the TIMS (Thermal Ionization Mass Spectrometer) instrument at Carleton University under guidance from Dr. Shuangquan Zhang and Dr. Brian Cousens. ! #! ! Geochronology processing: I selected the samples reported herein for U-Pb dating based on locating baddeleyites via electron microprobe with assistance from Peter Jones (Carleton University). I then secured the three samples chosen in separate labeled bags and then handed each to Dr. Richard Ernst (Carleton University) for shipment to Dr. Ulf Söderlund (Lund University, Sweden) for baddeleyite separation. Dr. Söderlund then shipped baddeleyite separates from the two samples that yielded baddeleyites to Dr. Sandra Kamo (University of Toronto) for Isotope Dilution Thermal Ionization Mass Sprectrometer (ID-TIMS) U-Pb dating. Thesis and manuscript construction: Unless otherwise indicated, I drafted all figures herein presented. In addition I took the lead in the interpretation of data and their broader significance but benefited greatly from substantive discussions and reviews from Drs. Richard Ernst and Brian Cousens (Carleton University), Dr. Marie-Claude Williamson (Geological Survey of Canada) and Dr.