DOCSLIB.ORG

"One of the Great Polar Navigators": Captain T.C. Pullen's Personal

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Documents on Canadian Arctic Sovereignty and Security “One of the Great Polar Navigators” Captain T.C. Pullen’s Personal Records of Arctic Voyages Part 1: Government Roles Edited by P. Whitney Lackenbauer & Elizabeth Elliot-Meisel Documents on Canadian Arctic Sovereignty and Security (DCASS) ISSN 2368-4569 Series Editors: P. Whitney Lackenbauer Adam Lajeunesse Managing Editor: Ryan Dean “One of the Great Polar Navigators”: Captain T.C. Pullen’s Personal Records of Arctic Voyages, Volume 1: Official Roles P. Whitney Lackenbauer and Elizabeth Elliot-Meisel DCASS Number 12, 2018 Cover: Department of National Defence, Directorate of History and Heritage, BIOG P: Pullen, Thomas Charles, file 2004/55, folder 1. Cover design: Whitney Lackenbauer Centre for Military, Security and Centre on Foreign Policy and Federalism Strategic Studies St. Jerome’s University University of Calgary 290 Westmount Road N. 2500 University Dr. N.W. Waterloo, ON N2L 3G3 Calgary, AB T2N 1N4 Tel: 519.884.8110 ext. 28233 Tel: 403.220.4030 www.sju.ca/cfpf www.cmss.ucalgary.ca Arctic Institute of North America University of Calgary 2500 University Drive NW, ES-1040 Calgary, AB T2N 1N4 Tel: 403-220-7515 http://arctic.ucalgary.ca/ Copyright © the authors/editors, 2018 Permission policies are outlined on our website http://cmss.ucalgary.ca/research/arctic-document-series “One of the Great Polar Navigators”: Captain T.C. Pullen’s Personal Records of Arctic Voyages Volume 1: Official Roles P. Whitney Lackenbauer, Ph.D. and Elizabeth Elliot-Meisel, Ph.D. Table of Contents Table of Contents Introduction ............................................................................................................. i Acronyms ............................................................................................................... xlv Part 1: H.M.C.S. Labrador ...................................................................................... 1 Pullen’s Personal Record of HMCS Labrador, 1956-57 ........................................... 3 1956 Diary ................................................................................................. 5 1957 Arctic Voyage .................................................................................. 64 Proceedings for June 1957 .......................................................... 65 Diary, 25 June-30 July 1957 ....................................................... 68 Proceedings for July 1957 ........................................................... 74 Diary, 1 August – 30 August 1957 .............................................. 84 Proceedings for August 1957 ..................................................... 100 Diary, 1 September – 11 October 1957 .................................... 111 Part 2: Manhattan Voyage.................................................................................... 122 Draft Memorandum for the Cabinet, “Canadian Sovereignty in the Arctic,” 20 March 1969 ....................................................................................... 123 Memorandum: Letter of Instruction to Pullen from Admiral A.H.G. Storrs, 11 July 1969 ........................................................................................... 159 Memorandum from Captain T.C. Pullen, 25 July 1969 ......................... 162 1969 Northwest Passage Voyage of S.S. Manhattan: Personal Journal. .... 163 Pullen, Northern Associates Registered Report to the Canadian Hydrographic Service, “The Northwest Passage Voyage of the S.S. Manhattan, 1969. ................................................................................... 287 Report on the Arctic Tanker Test (S.S. Manhattan) August-November, 1969, compiled by Pullen, 13 January 1970 ........................................... 317 Appendix A: Captain T.C. Pullen - Record of Service .......................................... 349 Appendix B: Captain T.C. Pullen, curriculum vitae (1999) .................................. 354 Captain T.C. Pullen’s Personal Records of Arctic Voyages, vol. 1 Appendix C: List of Northwest Passage Voyages, 1906-89 ................................... 362 Appendix D: Sea Ice Glossary .............................................................................. 371 Further Reading ................................................................................................... 377 About the Editors ................................................................................................. 380 Introduction Introduction: “Pullen of the Arctic” [Captain T.C. Pullen, RCN] had become, and to the last remained, one of the great polar navigators. - Graham Rowley (1992)1 Captain Thomas Charles Pullen (1918-1990), RCN, OC, CD, D.Sc., FHSC, a fifth generation naval officer, commanded numerous ships during his career with the Royal Canadian Navy (RCN) from 1936-65. He became a noted authority on and explorer of the Arctic after he took command of the naval icebreaker HMCS Labrador in 1956. Retiring after thirty years of active naval service, Pullen served as an advisor and consultant to government and industry on arctic marine operations for another twenty-four years. An officer of the Order of Canada and the recipient of the Massey Gold Medal of the Royal Canadian Geographical Society for his contributions to Arctic knowledge, “Pullen of the Arctic” (as he became widely known) earned the reputation as North America’s foremost expert on Arctic navigation and icebreaking over the course of his life.2 A note on Pullen’s biographical file at the Department of National Defence observes that he was a “compulsive diary writer dating back to 1931.”3 Consequently, his personal writings provide unparalleled, first-hand insights into seminal moments in the naval and maritime history of Canada’s Arctic during the latter half of the twentieth century. Drawing upon this rich resource, this volume publishes key documents on Arctic operations that Pullen wrote in various official capacities over his career. The first part documents his role as the commanding officer of the Labrador, as senior officer of the United States Navy, US Coast Guard, and Canadian ships deployed to the Eastern Arctic during the construction phase of the Distant Early Warning (DEW) Line in 1956 and 1957, as well as his role as US Navy Task Group Commander for Operation Bellot in 1957. The second part reproduces his observations as the Government of Canada’s official 1 Graham Rowley, “Captain T.C. Pullen, RCN: Polar Navigator,” The Northern Mariner 2/2 (April 1992), 47. 2 W.O. Kupsch, “Thomas C. Pullen,” The Musk-ox 38 (1991), 69; David Maclellan, “Pullen of the Arctic,” Canadian Geographic 104/2 (1984), 26. 3 “Captain T.C. Pullen: Naval Service,” notes on DHH 2004/55, file 1. i Captain T.C. Pullen’s Personal Records of Arctic Voyages, vol. 1 representative onboard the icebreaking tanker Manhattan during its two transits of the Northwest Passage. His diaries and reports cut through the hyperbole that surrounded this controversial voyage, addressing both legitimate concerns and unwarranted criticisms, and pointed the way forward for Canadian Arctic policy. By bringing more of his ideas into public circulation, we hope to stimulate informed discussion and debate on the history of maritime operations in the Canadian Arctic, and to ensure that “Pullen of the Arctic” gets the credit that he so richly deserves for his contributions to polar navigation, knowledge, and practice. Background Thomas Charles Pullen was born in Oakville, Ontario, on 27 May 1918, into a proud nautical family with a record of naval service dating back to the eighteenth century. His great-great-grandfather, Nicholas Pullen, and sixteen of his shipmates aboard a small vessel trading in the West Indies were press- ganged into the Royal Navy in 1780. Subsequently, sixteen of Nicholas’ descendants became naval officers, including four flag officers, two captains and two commanders. The Arctic brought the family particular fame, beginning with Tom Pullen's great-uncles Commander (later Vice-Admiral) W.J.S. Pullen, who commanded the depot ship North Star on the 1852-54 Belcher expedition to find Franklin, with his younger brother T.C. Pullen (later Captain) as his second-in-command.4 Thanks to their exploits, when Tom Pullen sailed in the Arctic a century later, “there were four Pullen place- names to remind him of his great-uncles.”5 After attending Lakefield College School, a private boarding school in the picturesque Kawartha Lakes region of Ontario, from 1929-35, Tom Pullen spent one year at Oakville High School where the principal prepared him for the Royal Navy officer cadet entrance examination.6 He entered the RCN as a cadet in 1936, sailed in RMS Ansonia to the United Kingdom in 4 Maclellan, “Pullen of the Arctic,” 27. 5 Captain Tom Pullen obit, Daily Telegraph [London]. 6 James Goodwin, Our Gallant Doctor: Enigma and Tragedy – Surgeon Lieutenant George Hendry and HMCS Ottawa, 1942 (St Catharines: Dundurn, 2007), 96. ii Introduction August, and took his early training on ships of the Royal Navy.7 First he was sent to the British training cruiser HMS Frobisher where he developed his skills in the North Sea, Norwegian Sea, Atlantic Ocean, and West Indies. The next two years he spent in the First Cruiser Squadron of the British Mediterranean fleet onboard HMS Shropshire and Sussex, as well as three- months of destroyer training with HMS Hotspur and Hostile of the Second Destroyer Flotilla. His first appointment came onboard Shropshire at the rank of Midshipman. He went on to serve on the Nyon
Recommended publications
  • Transits of the Northwest Passage to End of the 2019 Navigation Season Atlantic Ocean ↔ Arctic Ocean ↔ Pacific Ocean

    Transits of the Northwest Passage to End of the 2019 Navigation Season Atlantic Ocean ↔ Arctic Ocean ↔ Pacific Ocean

    TRANSITS OF THE NORTHWEST PASSAGE TO END OF THE 2019 NAVIGATION SEASON ATLANTIC OCEAN ↔ ARCTIC OCEAN ↔ PACIFIC OCEAN R. K. Headland and colleagues 12 December 2019 Scott Polar Research Institute, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge, United Kingdom, CB2 1ER. <[email protected]> The earliest traverse of the Northwest Passage was completed in 1853 but used sledges over the sea ice of the central part of Parry Channel. Subsequently the following 314 complete maritime transits of the Northwest Passage have been made to the end of the 2019 navigation season, before winter began and the passage froze. These transits proceed to or from the Atlantic Ocean (Labrador Sea) in or out of the eastern approaches to the Canadian Arctic archipelago (Lancaster Sound or Foxe Basin) then the western approaches (McClure Strait or Amundsen Gulf), across the Beaufort Sea and Chukchi Sea of the Arctic Ocean, through the Bering Strait, from or to the Bering Sea of the Pacific Ocean. The Arctic Circle is crossed near the beginning and the end of all transits except those to or from the central or northern coast of west Greenland. The routes and directions are indicated. Details of submarine transits are not included because only two have been reported (1960 USS Sea Dragon, Capt. George Peabody Steele, westbound on route 1 and 1962 USS Skate, Capt. Joseph Lawrence Skoog, eastbound on route 1). Seven routes have been used for transits of the Northwest Passage with some minor variations (for example through Pond Inlet and Navy Board Inlet) and two composite courses in summers when ice was minimal (transits 149 and 167).
  • Canadian Arctic Through-Flow 2012 Cruise to Nares Strait

    Canadian Arctic Through-Flow 2012 Cruise to Nares Strait

    Canadian Arctic Through-flow 2012 Cruise to Nares Strait CCGS Henry Larsen August 2-17, 2012 Institute of Ocean Sciences Cruise 2012-20 Humfrey Melling – Chief Scientist Fisheries & Oceans Canada Collaborating Institutions: Institute of Ocean Sciences, University of Delaware, Oxford University, Danish Technical University, Scottish Association for Marine Science 1 Cover photo, courtesy of Jason Box: View looking south across the Petermann ice shelf towards Joe Island, Kennedy Channel and Ellesmere Island at the horizon. Note the small ice-shelf fragments in the foreground and cracks within the protruding lobe of the ice . The photograph taken in 2009, before the large ice islands calved from the shelf in August 2010 and again in July 2012. 2 Report on the Scientific Cruise of CCGS Henry Larsen, August 2012 Canadian Arctic Through-flow CCGS Henry Larsen in Nares Strait August 2-17, 2012 Overview The Canadian Arctic Through-flow (CAT) study embodies ten years’ effort within Canada and the international community to measure flows of seawater and ice through the Canadian Archipelago, between the Arctic and the Atlantic Oceans. CATs is the outgrowth of a pilot effort, the Arctic Canada Watch, established in 1997. Moorings enabling year-round measurements were first placed in western Lancaster Sound and Cardigan Strait in 1998. These carried instruments to measure current, temperature and salinity and utilized innovations to address the unique challenges of observing: 1) current direction near the geomagnetic pole; 2) salinity within the hazardous 30-m zone beneath drifting ice pack. These early installations have been maintained and augmented since 1998. In 2003, a large array of instruments was installed across the third principal path for Canadian Arctic through-flow, Nares Strait.
  • Five Hundred Meetings of the Arctic Circle by C.R

    Five Hundred Meetings of the Arctic Circle by C.R

    ARCTIC VOL. 67, NO. 2 (JUNE 2014) InfoNorth Five Hundred Meetings of the Arctic Circle by C.R. Burn HE ARCTIC CIRCLE, AN OPEN CLUB FOUNDED to bring during the talks and the meetings should therefore be together friends interested in all aspects of the moved! The Circle seems to be happy in its present accom- TNorth, celebrated its 500th meeting on 8 April 2014. modation at the location of the first meeting, where admit- The Circle, conceived on 30 October 1947, was the brain- tance restrictions have relaxed with the passage of time. In child of Graham and Diana Rowley and Tom and Jackie the first 10 years, only four of the speakers were women, Manning, who recognized the need in Ottawa for an infor- but in the last decade more than 20 women have held the mal but regular gathering of people interested in the Arc- floor. There were 79 meetings in 1947 – 58, of which 16 tic. At the time, these people were almost all working for covered government operations, 12 the natural sciences, departments and agencies of the federal government, but in 9 issues of development, and 13 human society. In the last an institution notorious for its silos, many were unaware of decade, although only 69 meetings have been held, the cor- each other’s work, interests, plans, and ideas. The Canadian responding numbers were 11, 29, 3, and 20, respectively. As Arctic had played but a small part in the Second World War, Northerners have assumed control of development within but it became a focus of much greater strategic concern dur- the territories, Ottawa’s role has diminished, and the range ing the Cold War, leading at first to military exercises and of interests active here in the South has shifted.
  • Paleocene Alkaline Volcanism in the Nares Strait Region Related to Strike-Slip Tectonics

    Paleocene Alkaline Volcanism in the Nares Strait Region Related to Strike-Slip Tectonics

    Paleocene Alkaline Volcanism in the Nares Strait Region Related to Strike-slip Tectonics Solveig Estrada & Detlef Damaske Federal Institute for Geosciences and Natural Resources (BGR), Hannover, Germany ([email protected]) The tectonic development of the North Atlantic, the Labrador Sea/Baffin Bay and the Eurasian Basin of Arctic Ocean led to relative movements between the Greenland Plate and the North American Plate. There has been a debate for many years, whether the Nares Strait between northwest Greenland and Ellesmere Island marks an ancient plate boundary in terms of a left-lateral transform fault (Wegener Fault) or whether there was no movement between Greenland and Ellesmere Island at all. New data were acquired during joint German-Canadian geological field work on northeast Ellesmere Island 1998-2000 (Mayr 2008), followed in 2001 by a geoscience cruise in Nares Strait (Tessensohn et al. 2006). Indications for sinistral strike-slip movements followed by compressive tectonics were found at the western margin of northern Nares Strait (Saalmann et al. 2005). Paleogene basins on Judge Daly Promontory, northeast Ellesmere Island, are bounded by a complex pattern of strike-slip and thrust faults. The clastic sediments in the basins are rich in volcanogenic material. Volcanic pebbles within the Cape Back basin near Nares Strait are derived from lava flows and ignimbrites of a continental rift-related, strongly differentiated, highly incompatible element enriched, alkaline volcanic suite (Estrada et al. 2009). 40Ar/39Ar amphibole and alkali feldspar ages indicate that volcanism was active around 61–58 Ma and was probably contemporaneous with sedimentation within the Paleogene pull-apart basins on Judge Daly Promontory formed by sinistral strike-slip tectonics parallel to the present-day Nares Strait.
  • 'A Little Light on What's Going On!'

    'A Little Light on What's Going On!'

    Volume VII, No. 69 ~ Winter 2014-2015 Starshell ‘A little light on what’s going on!’ CANADA IS A MARITIME NATION A maritime nation must take steps to protect and further its interests, both in home waters and with friends in distant waters. Canada therefore needs a robust and multipurpose Royal Canadian Navy. National Magazine of The Naval Association of Canada Magazine nationale de L’Association Navale du Canada www.navalassoc.ca On our cover… To date, the Royal Canadian Navy’s only purpose-built, ice-capable Arctic Patrol Vessel, HMCS Labrador, commissioned into the Royal Canadian Navy July 8th, 1954, ‘poses’ in her frozen natural element, date unknown. She was a state-of-the- Starshell art diesel electric icebreaker similar in design to the US Coast Guard’s Wind-class ISSN-1191-1166 icebreakers, however, was modified to include a suite of scientific instruments so it could serve as an exploration vessel rather than a warship like the American Coast National magazine of The Naval Association of Canada Guard vessels. She was the first ship to circumnavigate North America when, in Magazine nationale de L’Association Navale du Canada 1954, she transited the Northwest Passage and returned to Halifax through the Panama Canal. When DND decided to reduce spending by cancelling the Arctic patrols, Labrador was transferred to the Department of Transport becoming the www.navalassoc.ca CGSS Labrador until being paid off and sold for scrap in 1987. Royal Canadian Navy photo/University of Calgary PATRON • HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh HONORARY PRESIDENT • H. R. (Harry) Steele In this edition… PRESIDENT • Jim Carruthers, [email protected] NAC Conference – Canada’s Third Ocean 3 PAST PRESIDENT • Ken Summers, [email protected] The Editor’s Desk 4 TREASURER • King Wan, [email protected] The Bridge 4 The Front Desk 6 NAVAL AFFAIRS • Daniel Sing, [email protected] NAC Regalia Sales 6 HISTORY & HERITAGE • Dr.
  • Dear Secretary Salazar: I Strongly

    Dear Secretary Salazar: I Strongly

    Dear Secretary Salazar: I strongly oppose the Bush administration's illegal and illogical regulations under Section 4(d) and Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act, which reduce protections to polar bears and create an exemption for greenhouse gas emissions. I request that you revoke these regulations immediately, within the 60-day window provided by Congress for their removal. The Endangered Species Act has a proven track record of success at reducing all threats to species, and it makes absolutely no sense, scientifically or legally, to exempt greenhouse gas emissions -- the number-one threat to the polar bear -- from this successful system. I urge you to take this critically important step in restoring scientific integrity at the Department of Interior by rescinding both of Bush's illegal regulations reducing protections to polar bears. Sarah Bergman, Tucson, AZ James Shannon, Fairfield Bay, AR Keri Dixon, Tucson, AZ Ben Blanding, Lynnwood, WA Bill Haskins, Sacramento, CA Sher Surratt, Middleburg Hts, OH Kassie Siegel, Joshua Tree, CA Sigrid Schraube, Schoeneck Susan Arnot, San Francisco, CA Stephanie Mitchell, Los Angeles, CA Sarah Taylor, NY, NY Simona Bixler, Apo Ae, AE Stephan Flint, Moscow, ID Steve Fardys, Los Angeles, CA Shelbi Kepler, Temecula, CA Kim Crawford, NJ Mary Trujillo, Alhambra, CA Diane Jarosy, Letchworth Garden City,Herts Shari Carpenter, Fallbrook, CA Sheila Kilpatrick, Virginia Beach, VA Kierã¡N Suckling, Tucson, AZ Steve Atkins, Bath Sharon Fleisher, Huntington Station, NY Hans Morgenstern, Miami, FL Shawn Alma,
  • Canadian Official Historians and the Writing of the World Wars Tim Cook

    Canadian Official Historians and the Writing of the World Wars Tim Cook

    Canadian Official Historians and the Writing of the World Wars Tim Cook BA Hons (Trent), War Studies (RMC) This thesis is submitted in fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Humanities and Social Sciences UNSW@ADFA 2005 Acknowledgements Sir Winston Churchill described the act of writing a book as to surviving a long and debilitating illness. As with all illnesses, the afflicted are forced to rely heavily on many to see them through their suffering. Thanks must go to my joint supervisors, Dr. Jeffrey Grey and Dr. Steve Harris. Dr. Grey agreed to supervise the thesis having only met me briefly at a conference. With the unenviable task of working with a student more than 10,000 kilometres away, he was harassed by far too many lengthy emails emanating from Canada. He allowed me to carve out the thesis topic and research with little constraints, but eventually reined me in and helped tighten and cut down the thesis to an acceptable length. Closer to home, Dr. Harris has offered significant support over several years, leading back to my first book, to which he provided careful editorial and historical advice. He has supported a host of other historians over the last two decades, and is the finest public historian working in Canada. His expertise at balancing the trials of writing official history and managing ongoing crises at the Directorate of History and Heritage are a model for other historians in public institutions, and he took this dissertation on as one more burden. I am a far better historian for having known him.
  • 'A Little Light on What's Going On!'

    'A Little Light on What's Going On!'

    Starshell ‘A little light on what’s going on!’ Volume XII, No. 54 Spring 2011 National Magazine of the Naval Officers Association of Canada Magazine nationale de l’association des officiers de la marine du Canada In this issue The editor’s cabin 2 Our cover and the Editor’s Cabin There is insufficient space here to adequately describe the 3 Where Land Ends, Life Begins trials that befell my miniscule publishing ‘empire’ following SPRING 2011 4 Commentary: ‘You heard it hear first’ the last issue of Starshell. The old Mac G4 that housed all my 6 Naval Syllogisms for Canada page layout software (including an ancient version of Adobe 8 Shipboard Tactical Data Systems Pagemaker) as well as all my newsletter templates (I publish four 10 View from the Bridge other periodicals besides this one), graphics, fonts, etc., suffered 10 The Front Desk a hard drive crash and the aforementioned was forever lost! Sensing such a calamity STARSHELL 11 Mail Call could well be in the offing, I had purchased a new Apple iMac computer last year, 12 The Briefing Room but had been putting off the substantial investment in new publishing software. The 13 Schober’s Quiz #53 hard drive crash effectively put me out of business; a trip to the local Apple com- 13 NOAC Regalia puter dealer was no longer an option. So—as evidenced by a much lighter wallet—I 15 The Edwards’ Files: ‘Captain’s Beer’ am now armed with the latest versions of Adobe In Design, Photoshop, Illustrator 16 Broadsides: ‘Honking Big Ships’ and Acrobat Pro.
  • Hal Davies Remembered for Energy, Vision, Strong Leadership

    Hal Davies Remembered for Energy, Vision, Strong Leadership

    GOLF TOURNAMENT AGM & Action Stations INSERTS INSIDE CANADA’S NAVAL MEMORIAL HMCS SACKVILLE MARCH/APRIL 2011 Hal Davies remembered for Energy, Vision, Strong Leadership By Len Canfield The late Captain (N) Hal Davies, who served as Chair of the Canadian Naval Memorial Trust 1997-2000, is remembered by fellow Trustees for his energy, vision and strong leadership in advancing the Trust and ensuring the long-term operation of HMCS SACKVILLE. His unexpected passing oc- curred in February in the Bahamas. Trustees recall that Hal not only brought his experience as commanding officer of ships and training establishments but also his civilian business management skills to the day to day operations of the Trust and SACKVILLE. Under Hal as Chair, the CNMT Board brought forward or advanced a num- Hal Davies is shown with other members of the CNMT ber initiatives and projects, including enhancing the visibility and relevance of Board during ‘Up Spirits’ in December 1997. Front, from left: Sherry Richardson, Hal, Ray Soucie, Dick SACKVILLE; expanding membership in the Trust especially among serving Aldhelm-White. At rear, from left: Mel Baird, Charles members; strengthening the Trust’s financial position including building up Westropp, Brian Leask, Ted Smith, Len Canfield, Mar- the endowment fund, and increasing collaboration between the Trust and the vin Moore, and Don Cameron. Navy, Maritime Museum of the Atlantic and other significant stakeholders. One of the initiatives advanced by Hal was formalizing the CNMT Executive Director position and Ray Soucie assuming the position. Ray recalls Hal’s organizational abilities and contributions in a number of areas, including website design, development of a long-term communications plan, transla- tion and installation of sound stations in the ship, supporting Mel Baird’s Life Membership initiative and Canada Post’s HMCS SHAWINIGAN and HMCS SACKVILLE stamp unveiling ceremonies in 1998.
  • THE LIBERATION of OSLO and COPENHAGEN: a MIDSHIPMAN's MEMOIR C.B. Koester

    THE LIBERATION of OSLO and COPENHAGEN: a MIDSHIPMAN's MEMOIR C.B. Koester

    THE LIBERATION OF OSLO AND COPENHAGEN: A MIDSHIPMAN'S MEMOIR C.B. Koester Introduction I joined HMS Devonshire, a County-class cruiser in the Home Fleet, on 16 September 1944. For the next nine months we operated out of Scapa Flow, the naval base in the Orkneys north of Scotland which had been home to Jellicoe's Grand Fleet during World War I and harboured the main units of the Home Fleet throughout the second conflict. It was a bleak, uninviting collection of seventy-three islands—at low water—twenty-nine of them inhabited, mainly by fishermen and shepherds. Winters were generally miserable and the opportunities for recreation ashore limited. There was boat-pulling and sailing, weather permitting; an occasional game of field hockey on the naval sports ground; and perhaps a Saturday afternoon concert in the fleet canteen or a "tea dance" at the Wrennery. Otherwise, we entertained ourselves aboard: singsongs in the Gunroom; a Sunday night film in the Wardroom; deck hockey in the Dog Watches; and endless games of "liar's dice." Our operations at sea were more harrowing, but only marginally more exciting, consisting mainly of attacks on German shore installations on the Norwegian coast. We rarely saw the coastline, however, for the strikes were carried out by aircraft flying from the escort carriers in the task force. At the same time, we had to be prepared for whatever counterattack the Germans might mount, and until Tirpitz was finally disabled on 12 November 1944, such a riposte might have been severe. That and the ever-present threat of submarines notwithstanding, for most of us these operations involved a large measure of boredom and discomfort.
  • TABLE of CONTENTS Page Certificate of Examination I

    TABLE of CONTENTS Page Certificate of Examination I

    The End of the Big Ship Navy: The Trudeau Government, the Defence Policy Review and the Decommissioning of the HMCS Bonaventure by Hugh Avi Gordon B.A.H., Queen’s University at Kingston, 2001. A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS in the Department of History We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard ______________________________________________________________ Dr. D.K. Zimmerman, Supervisor (Department of History) ______________________________________________________________ Dr. P.E. Roy, Departmental Member (Department of History) ______________________________________________________________ Dr. E.W. Sager, Departmental Member (Department of History) ______________________________________________________________ Dr. J.A. Boutilier, External Examiner (Department of National Defence) © Hugh Avi Gordon, 2003 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This thesis may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. ii Supervisor: Dr. David Zimmerman ABSTRACT As part of a major defence review meant to streamline and re-prioritize the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF), in 1969, the Trudeau government decommissioned Canada’s last aircraft carrier, HMCS Bonaventure. The carrier represented a major part of Maritime Command’s NATO oriented anti- submarine warfare (ASW) effort. There were three main reasons for the government’s decision. First, the carrier’s yearly cost of $20 million was too much for the government to afford. Second, several defence experts challenged the ability of the Bonaventure to fulfill its ASW role. Third, members of the government and sections of the public believed that an aircraft carrier was a luxury that Canada did not require for its defence. There was a perception that the carrier was the wrong ship used for the wrong role.
  • Volume 4, 1951

    Volume 4, 1951

    Annual General Meeting of the Arctic Circle l Amendment to the Constitution 2 Royal Canadian Army Service Corps in northern trials and operations. By Major J.M. Berry .3 Geographical and archaeological investigations on Southampton Island, 1950. By J.B. Bird 10 Eskimo Handicrafts 12 The French Antarctic Expedition 12 Eastern Arctic Mailing List 13 Membership of The Arctic Circ1e 16 Back numbers of the Circu1ar 17 Editorial Note 17 Twenty-sixth Meeting of the Arctic Circle 18 Voyage round Cornwallis Island. By Trevor Harwood 18 The discovery of Prince Charles Island 29 The Arctic and the Specialist Navigation Course. By FIL G.J. Sweanor .30 Protection of wildlife in northeast Greenland 32 Hudsonts Bay Company Archives .3.3 ArcticMail 3.3 Membership of The Arctic Circle .35 Back numbers of the Circular 36 Editorial Note .36 Twenty-seventh Meeting of the Arctic Circle 37 Botanical Surveys in Central and Northern Manitoba. By H.J. Scoggan 37 Tuberculosis Survey: James and Hudson bays, 1950 45 Arctic Dog Disease 47 Reports of Arctic Dog Disease 48 The Varying Lemming captive in Ottawa. By T.H. Manning 50 Exercise Mukluk 50 Plant life in the Arctic 50 Membership of The Arctic Circle 51 Back numbers of the Circular 51 Editorial Note 51 APRIL-MAY 1951 Twenty-eighth Meeting of the Arctic Circle 52 Twenty-ninth Meeting of the Arctic Circle 52 Caribou in Greenland. By A.E. Porsild 52 Gravity survey of the Barnes Ice Cap. By C.A. Littlewood 58 Spring supply operations for the northern weather stations 61 Antarctic party's accident 61 Microfilm records of M'Clintock expeditions 62 Exercise Firestep 63 Hudson Bay Route Association 63 "Alaska's Health" 63 Membership of The Arctic Circle 63 Back numbers of the Circular 64 Editorial Note 64 Hydrographic survey operations of the ".Algerine" in 1950.