Mizoram Legislative Assembly Speaker Zahawm Tak Thutlukna
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MIZORAM LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY SPEAKER ZAHAWM TAK THUTLUKNA The Members of Mizoram Legislative Assembly (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules 1987 Rule 6 r/w Constitution of India Article 191(2)-na leh Tenth Schedule Para 2(2) hnuaia Petitioner-te’n Respondent bantir tura Petition an thehluh chungchang. 1. Er. H. Lalzirliana, MLA 2. Pu Lalrinsanga Ralte, MLA 3. Pu C. Lalmuanpuia, MLA 4. Pu Zothantluanga, MLA 5. Dr. F. Lalnunmawia, MLA 6. Pu L. Thangmawia, MLA 7. Dr. ZR. Thiamsanga, MLA 8. Pu Ramthanmawia, MLA 9. Dr. Vanlaltanpuia, MLA 10. Pu H. Biakzaua, MLA 11. Pu Lawmawma Tochhawng, MLA 12. Dr. K. Pachhunga, MLA - Petitioners Vrs Pu Lalduhoma, MLA - Respondent 1. Achunga Petitioner 12 te hi 8th Mizoram Legislative Assembly-ah Assembly bial hrang hrang atanga rorel lai MNF Party MLA te an ni a. Petitioner No. 1 hi Mamit Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 2 hi Serlui Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 3 hi Aizawl North III Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 4 Aizawl West I Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 5 hi Aizawl South III Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 6 hi Lengteng Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 7 hi Champhai North Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitoner No. 8 hi East Tuipui Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitoner No. 9 hi Lunglei North Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitoner No. 10 hi Lawngtlai East Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 11 hi Lunglei East Assembly Bial MLA a ni a, Petitioner No. 12 hi Lunglei South Assembly Bial MLA a ni bawk a ni a, chutihrualin, Respondent hi Serchhip Assembly Bial MLA a ni thung a. Petitioner-te hian Constitution of ... 2/- -2- India Tenth Schedule Para 2(2) in a sawi angin Defection avanga Respondent hi Mizoram State Legislative Assembly Member a nihna atanga bantir turin the Members of Mizoram Legislative Assembly (Disqualification on Ground of Defection) Rules 1987 Rule 6 (a hnu zelah a tawi zawngin Rules of 1987 tiin sawi a ni) hnuaiah Petition an thehlut a. Petitioner hmasa 10 te hian ni 22/9/2020 khan Petition thehlutin a hnuhnung 2 ten ni 24/9/2020 khan an thehlut ve thung a ni. Petition 12 a hrang theuhin thehluh a ni naa, Petitioner-te hming tih chauh loh chu a chhung thute a thuhmun vek. Chuvangin, heng Petition-te hi a hrang theuha ziah luh ni loin, hmun khatah a zavaiin ziah luh a ni. 2. Petition-te dawn a nih hian ka bih chhuak a, Rules of 1987, Rule 6-in a phutte an zawm em tihte ngaihtuah a ni a, Rule 6 zawm chungchangah a lungawithlaka ngaih a nih hnuin Petition copy te hi a tanchhan lehkhate (Annexures) telin Respondent hnenah ni 24/9/2020 khan pek a niin ni 14 chhunga a Chhana (Comment) thehluh phalsak a ni bawk a ni. Respondent hian a Chhanna hi ni 8/10/2020 khan a rawn thehlut a. Respondent-in a Chhanna chu Petitioner-te pek leh vek an niin Order Memo No. LA.161/LEGN/2020/435 dt. 20/10/2020 hmangin an chhanlet lehna thehluh leh phalsak an ni bawk. Petitioner 12 te hian ni 24/10/2020 ah an chhanlet lehna (Replication) chu thehlutin chung an chhanlet lehna chu Respondent hnenah pek leh a ni a. Petitioner-te leh Respondent chu Order Memo No. LA.161/LEGN/2020/758 dt. 26/10/2020 hmangin ni 3/11/2020 dar 11:00 AM ah Committee Room, Assembly Secretariat, Main Building-ah tawngka ngeia an thu leh hlate ngaihthlak a nih tur thu hriattir an ni bawk a ni. 3. A hun ruat ni 3/11/2020 hian, Petitioner zawng zawngte, Petitioner No. 8 & 9 tih loh chu, ruahmansa angin an rawn kim thei a. Kan sawi Petitioner pahnih te hi Covid-19 hri leng mek avanga an inkhung hran avangin ni 3/11/2020 ah hian an rawn tel ve thei lo a ni. LEHKHA ENFELNA LEH FINFIAHNA & TAWNGKA NGEIA AN THUSAWI NGAIHTHLAKNA 4. Petitioner leh Respondent-te hian anmahni tanhmun sawhnghehna turin lehkha eng emawzat an thehlut tel a, chung an lehkha thehluh chipchiar chu a hnuaia mite hi an ni. (a) Petitioner-te lehkha thehluhte - i. Pu Lalduhoma S/o Vaisanga (L) R/o H/No. 157, Chawlhhmun – II, … 3/- -3- ii. Aizawl, Mizoram Affidavit dt. 7/11/2018, 26 –Serchhip (ST) biala a hming pekluhna nena a thehluh. ECI website (eci.gov.in) atanga lak. iii. Lehkha F No. 56/39/2019/PPS-I/606 dt. 8/7/2019, Secretary, Election Commission of India, Nirvachan Sadan, Ashoka Road, New Delhi in President, Mizoram People’s Movement, Treasury Square, Aizawl a rawn thawn, Representation of the People Act, 1951 Section 29A hnuaiah ni 3/7/2019 atangin Zoram People’s Movement chu Political Party ah ziah luh a ni tih a hriattirna, Office of the Chief Electoral Officer, Mizoram atanga lak. iv. Pu Lalduhoma’n ZNP chu thiah tawh niin a awm tawh lo a ZPM ah an inlet tawh a ni tih inziahna Vanglaini Mizo Daily dt. 20/8/2019 lak chhuah, vantlang mipuia sem darh. v. LPS leh ZONET Local News Channel Video Clip ni 9/9/2020 a tihchhuah youtube.com atanga lak. ZPM Thalai Hqrs. Press Release Pu Lalduhoma’n ZPM Party aiawha official-a member thar lawmluhna thu a sawi ni 9/9/2020 an tihchhuah, Dr. C. Lalrammawia, Gen Secy. Publicity Deptt. ZPM Party Thalai Gen. Hqrs. in a tihchhuah leh a hming a ziah hnan, Social Media atanga lak. vi. Vanglaini Mizo Daily dt. 10/9/2020 Pu Lalduhoma’n a hma niin ZPM Party Office-ah mi thar a lawmluh leh a thusawi chungchang chhuahna lak chhuah, vantlang mipuia sem chhuah. vii. ZPM official function, Darlawnah Pu Lalduhoma a telna ZPM Party aiawha mithar lawmluhna thu a sawi tarlanna Vanglaini Mizo Daily dt. 11/9/2020 lak chhuah, vantlang mipuia sem chhuah. viii. Supreme Court thu remna lak chhuah phek 1,2 & 19 - Docid#IndiaLawLib/260866 atanga print chhuah - (2007) AIR(SCW)158 : (2007) AIR(SC) 590 : (2007) 1 Law Herald 295 : (2006) 13 SCALE 335 : (2006) 11 SCC 1 : (2006) Supp10 SCR 521 ah te a awm bawk. ix. Office of the Mizoram Peoples’ Conference Party, General Headquarters, Aizawl : Mizoram MEMO NO. PC-7/2020-2020/PR-71 … 4/- -4- hmanga tihchhuah Press Release dt. 2/10/2020 a hming ziaktu hnen atanga lak. x. Zoram Nationalist Party, General Headquarters, Aizawl : Mizoram tihchhuah “Press Release No. 4 of 25/9/2020” a hming ziaktu hnen atanga lak. xi. “Zoram People’s Movement (ZPM) Party Registration Dilna” dan anga Pu Lalpianfela Chawngthu, Tuikhuahtlang, Aizawl in RTI, Act, 2005 hnuaia State Public Information Officer, Mizoram Legislative Assembly Secretaria kal tlanga ni 23/10/2020 a a lak chhuah. (b) Documents submitted by Respondent- i. Zoram People’s Movement (Allied Front) Thuthlung. ii. Indian Express in ZPM din thu a chhuahna. iii. Janambhumi ZPM din thu a chhuahna. iv. ZPM (Tangrual Pawl) Chief Ministerial Candidate Puanna Programme. v. ZPM Press Release No.2 dt.3/10/2017. vi. The Telegraph chanchin thar chhuah. vii. Ni 8/5/2018 a ZPM Assembly leh ZPM CM Candidate puanna thlalak. viii. VUC Chairman hmaa ZPM MLA Candidate-te Rinawmna Thutiam. ix. Ni 24/10/2018 a ZPM Candidate-te thlalak. x. Ni 24/10/2018 a ZPM Candidate pangate thlalak. xi. Mizoram Post Chanchin thar chhuah. xii. General Election 2018 hmaa flag, chawlhtirner leh chhinchhiahna thuhmun lantirna ZPM Campaign programme thlalak. xiii. ‘The Hindu’ in Inthlanna result a chhuah. xiv. Ni 12/12/2018 a ZPM MLA pasarihte lawmpuina inkhawm thlalak. xv. Form No. 1 hmanga ZPM Legislature Party-te hming thehluh. xvi. 8th Mizoram Legislative Assembly Bulletin Part – II dt. 16/1/2019 in House chhunga Recognised Party/Party Affiliation a tarlanna. xvii. ECI in ni 11/3/2019 a RP Act, 1951 Section 29A hnuaia ZPM Political Party atana inziahluh dilna chungchanga lehkha (document) thehlut ... 5/- -5- tura a tihna lehkha Dr. Kenneth Chawngliana c/o Zoram People’s Movement hnena a thawn. xviii. ECI, New Delhi atanga President, Zoram People’s Movement hnena Zoram people’s Movement chu Political Party-ah RP Act, 1951 Section 29A hnuaiah ziah luh a nih thu hriattirna lehkha ni 8/7/2019 a rawn thawn. 5. Personal Hearing ni atana hun leh ni ruatah hian, Petitioner-te leh Respondent te lehkha thehluh zawng zawngte chu lehlam lehlamin enfiaha pawm a ni a. Heng lehkhate hi dik leh behchhan tlaka pawmin tu lam mahin hnial kalhna an neih loh avangin behchhan atan pawm an ni a. Tichuan, Petitioner-te lehkha thehluhte chu Exhibit P – 1 atanga Exhibit P – 12 thlengin chhinchhiah an ni a, Respondent lehkha thehluh te pawh chu Exhibit R – 1 atanga Exhibit R – 22 tia chhinchhiah bawk a ni. 6. A chunga tarlan anga lehkha thehluhte endika pawm a nih hnuah, Petitioner-te chu tawngka ngeiin an sawi duhte sawi turin koh an ni a, koh an nih angin, Pu L. Thangmawia, Petitioner No. 6 chuan Petitioner 12 te aiawhin an thu rawn thlente a sawifiah a. Chumi hnuah chuan, Respondent chu tanhmunte sawifiah turin kohl eh a ni a. Hemi hnu hian, Petitioner-te chu Respondent thusawi chungchang sawifiah tur leh chhanletna hun pek ve leh an ni a. An thusawi zawng zawngte hi Electronic Voice Recorder hmangin chhinchhiah vek a ni a. Heng an thusawi chhinchhiahte hi print chhuah leh vek niin case record-ah dah a ni. PETITIONER-TE TANFUNG 7.