An Investigation of English Spelling Problems of Arabic-Speaking Students
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Portland State University PDXScholar Dissertations and Theses Dissertations and Theses 1991 An investigation of English spelling problems of Arabic-speaking students Deborah Georgette Keim Portland State University Follow this and additional works at: https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/open_access_etds Part of the Applied Linguistics Commons, and the Bilingual, Multilingual, and Multicultural Education Commons Let us know how access to this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Keim, Deborah Georgette, "An investigation of English spelling problems of Arabic-speaking students" (1991). Dissertations and Theses. Paper 4172. https://doi.org/10.15760/etd.6056 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of PDXScholar. Please contact us if we can make this document more accessible: [email protected]. AN ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS OF Deborah Georgette Keim for the Master of Arts in Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages presented June 19, 1991. Title: An Investigation of English Spelling Problems of Arabic speaking Students. APPROVED BY THE MEMBERS OF THE THE.5IS COMMITTEE: Jeanette DeCarrico, Chair Marjorie Terdal Kimberley BroJn Ray Mariels In this two-part study, English spelling errors of Arabic speaking students are investigated. Specifically, an empirical study is done to document and investigate exactly what kinds of English 2 spelling errors Arabic-speaking students actually make. Then these data are analyzed. and spelling error patterns are discovered. Next. a study is done to determine if the presence of spelling errors in written work has a significant negative effect on readers' evaluations of this writing. This study was designed to test three hypotheses in order to answer the following three research questions: 1. What kinds of spelling errors do Arabic-speaking students actually make? 2. Are there some patterns to the English spelling errors of Arabic-speaking students? 3. Do spelling errors in a written English text have a significant negative influence on readers' evaluation of it? Is there a significant relationship between spelling errors in a text and readers' evaluation of the text? The hypotheses generated from these questions are the following: 1. Arabic-speaking students make a variety of spelling errors in English. These errors are discussed in Part One, which is a descriptive study of spelling errors. The actual collection of spelling errors is included as Appendix A. 2. There are patterns to the English spelling problems of Arabic-speaking students. This hypothesis is supported based on the analysis of spelling error data in Part One. which is a descriptive study. Spelling error patterns are discussed in detail. 3 3. (A) Spelling errors in a written English text have a significant negative influence on readers' evaluation of it. (B) There is a significant difference between the mean scores a reader assigns to a text with spelling errors compared with the same text with no spelling errors. The scores will be significantly lower for a text that includes various spelling errors. compared with the same text with no spelling errors. These two hypotheses are supported by the results of Part Two of this study. The results suggest that a high density of spelling errors in a text (21 to 26\ spelling error density) has a negative influence on readers· evaluation of it. However. a low density of spelling errors in a text (7 to 13 i spelling error density) does not show a negative influence. There is a relationship between the density of spelling errors in a text and the scores that evaluators assign to the text. In this study, the scores were significantly lower for texts that included a high density of spelling errors compared with the same texts with no spelling errors. The scores were not significantly lower for texts with a low error density compared with the same texts with no spelling errors. The information presented in this thesis offers valuable insights that can increase teachers' awareness of the spelling problems of Arabic-speaking students and encourage understanding of why they have these difficulties. Furthermore. this thesis provides empirical evidence that shows the negative influence that a high density of spelling errors can have on readers· evaluation of a written text. In 4 addition, this thesis offers suggestions for helping students improve their spelling ability. It is hoped that spelling practice will be incorporated into TESOL (Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages) curricula, according to students' needs. AN INVESTIGATION OF ENGLISH SPELLING PROBLEMS OF ARABIC-SPEAKING STUDENTS by DEBORAH GEORGETTE KEIM A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in TEACHING ENGLISH TO SPEAKERS OF OTHER LANGUAGES Portland State University 1991 TO THE OFFICE OF GRADUATE STUDIES: The members of the Committee approve the thesis of Deborah Georgette Keim presented June 19, 1991. anett Marjorie Terdal Ray Mariels APPROVED: mes R. NattingerVChair, Department of Applied Linguistics -y f c and DEDICATION I would like to dedicate my thesis to my family: my mother, Frances Trebelhorn; my grandmother, Georgia Rossos; and my brother, Michael Keim. I appreciate your love and support, and I dedicate this thesis to you. With Love, Deb ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to acknowledge the members of my committee who offered their help and support with my thesis. I wish to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation to Jan DeCarrico, who acted as both my academic advisor and thesis advisor. I appreciate the guidance and support that she has given me. I want to thank Marge Terdal for her ongoing help and suggestions for my research and thesis. Also, I am grateful to Kim Brown for her support and assistance with my thesis. I wish to thank Ray Mariels for offering his ongoing support and for participating as a member of my committee. I appreciate everyone who helped me with this research project. TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS . iii LIST OF TABLES .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. vi CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 1 Research Questions and Hypotheses . 1 Background ................................ 3 Clarification of Terms ........................ 4 Summary of Literature ...................... 4 Summary .................................. 8 II REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE ...................... 10 English Spelling ............................ 10 Spelling Problems of ESL Students ............ 15 Evaluation of ESL Students' Written Work ..... 17 Spelling Problems of Arabic-Speaking Learners of English ......................... 22 Summary ................................. 29 I I I METHODS AND PROCEDURES. 31 Summary of Research ....................... 31 Research Methodology ...................... 32 Subjects ................................... 34 Instruments and Materials . 36 v Scoring ...........· .......................... 37 Statistical Procedure ......................... 41 IV RESULTS ......................................... 42 Analysis of the Spelling Error Data ............. 42 Analysis of the Raters' Scores for the Six Texts ............................. 48 Spelling Error Density . 49 V SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION ........................ 52 Discussion of Hypotheses .................... 53 Discussion of Results . 5 5 The Importance of this Research Project ........ 57 Teaching Suggestions ......................... 58 In Conclusion . 61 Directions for Further Study ................... 62 REFERENCES .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 64 APPENDICES A SPELLING ERROR DATA............................ 67 B SCORING SHEET, SCORING GUIDE, AND TWO VERSIONS OF THE PACKET OF SIX TEXTS ....................... 75 C THE SIX TEXTS WITH SPELLING ERRORS HIGHLIGHTED.................................... 94 D RATERS' SCORES .................................. 101 E ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY OF RESOURCES FOR TEACHING SPELLING .............................. 104 LIST OF TABLES TABLE PAGE I Organization of Reading Packets . 40 II Major Spelling Error Patterns . 43 III Mann-Whitney U Test Results Comparing Texts with Spelling Errors and Texts Without Spelling Errors ... 48 IV Spelling Error Density of the Texts ................ 50 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION In this two-part study, English spelling errors of Arabic speaking students are investigated. Specifically, an empirical study is done to document and investigate exactly what kinds of English spelling errors Arabic-speaking students actually make. Then these data are analyzed, and spelling error patterns are discovered. Next, a study is done to deter mine if the presence of spelling errors in written work has a significant negative effect on readers' evaluations of this writing. RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND HYPOTHESES The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the spelling problems of Arabic-speaking students. The three questions this research seeks to address are: 1. What kinds of spelling errors do Arabic-speaking students actually make? 2. Are there some patterns to the English spelling errors of Arabic-speaking students? 2 3. Do spelling errors in a written English text have a significant negative influence on readers' evaluation of it? Is there a significant relationship between spelling errors in a text and readers· evaluation or the text? The hypotheses generated from these questions are the following: l. Arabic-speaking students make