Presentation to Martin Blume and Paul Ginsparg

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Presentation to Martin Blume and Paul Ginsparg CSE Award for Meritorious Achievement u Presentation to Martin Blume and Paul Ginsparg Annette Flanagin at Cornell University. Past President, CSE He received an AB from Journal of the American Medical Harvard and a PhD in phys- Association (JAMA) ics from Cornell. He has Chicago, Illinois held academic and research positions at Harvard, Los The Council of Science Editors gives its Alamos National Laboratory, highest award, the Award for Meritorious and Cornell. Ginsparg has Achievement, to two corecipients, Martin specialized in quantum field Blume and Paul Ginsparg. These recipients theory, string theory, and share multiple interests, generally, in the digital knowledge networks. scientific discipline of physics and in pro- He has received numerous moting excellence in the communication honors and awards and most PHOTO CREDIT: JOHN WACHTER/CPS MEDIA of scientific information, which is CSE’s recently was named Fellow of Martin Blume, Paul Ginsparg, and primary mission. They are honored for their the American Physical Society Annette Flanagin unique contributions, vision, leadership, (2000) and a MacArthur he held positions at the Atomic Energy integrity, and passion. Whether you view Foundation Fellow (2002). He has served Research Establishment in England, their contributions as radical transforma- on many committees and advisory boards, Brookhaven National Laboratory, and the tions or guided evolution, Paul Ginsparg’s including most recently the US National State University of New York at Stony and Martin Blume’s contributions have Academy of Sciences (NAS)/National Brook. Blume’s research has focused on forced editors and publishers to reevaluate Research Council (NRC) Committee on atomic and condensed-matter physics and old and current procedures, policies, and Issues in the Transborder Flow of Scientific the interface between condensed matter modes of disseminating information and Data, the NAS/NRC Committee on the and nuclear physics. He has served on have encouraged us to consider new oppor- Future of Universities, the Open Archives several editorial boards of journals and tunities. By challenging norms and views Initiative, PubMed Central’s National on many panels of the NAS/NRC, the on a wide array of issues—including intel- Advisory Committee, and the American Department of Energy, and the National lectual-property and copyright concerns, Physical Society’s Taskforce on Electronic Science Foundation. He helped to develop access to information, and traditional pub- Information Systems and Publications the American Physical Society Guidelines lishing models—and by recognizing that we Oversight Committee. He often writes for Professional Conduct, including supple- cannot assume an unchanging existence of and speaks on the future of scholarly com- mentary guidelines on responsibilities scientific journals and the roles and respon- munication, for example, on “Alternative of coauthors and collaborators, research sibilities of editors and publishers, Blume Models for Scholarly Publishing” and “The results, and references in publications. He is and Ginsparg have led us to question our Impact of Barrier-free Access and New a Fellow of the American Academy of Arts values and beliefs, have led us to find ways Technologies on Biomedical Publishing”. In and Sciences, the American Association for to cope with and keep pace with rapid 1991, Ginsparg developed the Los Alamos the Advancement of Science, the British advances in technology, and, it is hoped, Electronic Preprint Archive, now called Institute of Physics, and the American are leading us to ensure the viability of sci- arXiv, an open e-print service with more Physical Society. Since 1996, Blume has ence journals, in whatever form they may than a million articles in physics and tens been editor-in-chief of the American take, and the work of science editors and of thousands of articles in mathematics, Physical Society, with responsibility for all publishers. Ginsparg and Blume are both nonlinear science, computer science, and the Physical Review journals, Physical Review futurists and realists, freeing us from inertia, quantitative biology. Letters, and Reviews of Modern Physics. He forcing us to move forward. As such, they Martin Blume is editor-in-chief of the frequently writes and speaks about the personify Newton’s third law of motion, American Physical Society, now on leave challenge of electronic publishing, includ- that for every action (Ginsparg) there is an from Brookhaven National Laboratory. ing concerns about intellectual property, equal and opposite reaction (Blume). He received a BA from Princeton and archiving, peer review, the dual role of paper Paul Ginsparg is professor of physics a PhD in physics from Harvard. After a and electronic media, and economic ques- and computing and information science Fulbright Fellowship at Tokyo University, tions of cost minimization and recovery. Science Editor • September – October 2005 • Vol 28 • No 5 • 147.
Recommended publications
  • Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research Communication Studies, Department of Spring 4-12-2011 Secular Salvation: Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement Brent Yergensen University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/commstuddiss Part of the Speech and Rhetorical Studies Commons Yergensen, Brent, "Secular Salvation: Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement" (2011). Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research. 6. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/commstuddiss/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Communication Studies, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. SECULAR SALVATION: SACRED RHETORICAL INVENTION IN THE STRING THEORY MOVEMENT by Brent Yergensen A DISSERTATION Presented to the Faculty of The Graduate College at the University of Nebraska In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Major: Communication Studies Under the Supervision of Dr. Ronald Lee Lincoln, Nebraska April, 2011 ii SECULAR SALVATION: SACRED RHETORICAL INVENTION IN THE STRING THEORY MOVEMENT Brent Yergensen, Ph.D. University of Nebraska, 2011 Advisor: Ronald Lee String theory is argued by its proponents to be the Theory of Everything. It achieves this status in physics because it provides unification for contradictory laws of physics, namely quantum mechanics and general relativity. While based on advanced theoretical mathematics, its public discourse is growing in prevalence and its rhetorical power is leading to a scientific revolution, even among the public.
    [Show full text]
  • The Diffusion of New Media Scholarship: Power, Innovation, and Resistance in Academe
    University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 5-2002 The Diffusion of New Media Scholarship: Power, Innovation, and Resistance in Academe Judith R. Edminster University of South Florida Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the American Studies Commons Scholar Commons Citation Edminster, Judith R., "The Diffusion of New Media Scholarship: Power, Innovation, and Resistance in Academe" (2002). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/1520 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Contents Title Page Abstract Overview Methodology THE DIFFUSION OF NEW MEDIA SCHOLARSHIP: POWER, The Origin and INNOVATION, AND RESISTANCE IN ACADEME Development of the Dissertation Genre ● Current Value by ● Traditional Print ● Genre Theory Current ETD Initiatives JUDITH R. EDMINSTER ● International Initiative ● UMI Role A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment ● US Innovators of the requirements for the degree of ● Best Practices Doctor of Philosophy ● Graduate Department of English Education College of Arts and Sciences ● Challenges to University of South Florida Diffusion ● Training Issues ● Recommendations May 2002 The Diffusion of ETDs ● Relative Advantages Major Professor: Joseph M. Moxley, Ph.D. ● Compatibility Committee Members: James A. Inman, Ph.D. with Academic Debra Jacobs, Ph.D. Norms Rosann Webb Collins, Ph.D. ● Communication Barry Maid, Ph.D. ● Complexity, Trialability, Observability The University of South Florida ETD Pilot Project Sound Files and Sample ETDs References THE DIFFUSION OF NEW MEDIA SCHOLARSHIP: POWER, INNOVATION, AND RESISTANCE IN ACADEME by JUDITH R.
    [Show full text]
  • High Energy Physics Quantum Information Science Awards Abstracts
    High Energy Physics Quantum Information Science Awards Abstracts Towards Directional Detection of WIMP Dark Matter using Spectroscopy of Quantum Defects in Diamond Ronald Walsworth, David Phillips, and Alexander Sushkov Challenges and Opportunities in Noise‐Aware Implementations of Quantum Field Theories on Near‐Term Quantum Computing Hardware Raphael Pooser, Patrick Dreher, and Lex Kemper Quantum Sensors for Wide Band Axion Dark Matter Detection Peter S Barry, Andrew Sonnenschein, Clarence Chang, Jiansong Gao, Steve Kuhlmann, Noah Kurinsky, and Joel Ullom The Dark Matter Radio‐: A Quantum‐Enhanced Dark Matter Search Kent Irwin and Peter Graham Quantum Sensors for Light-field Dark Matter Searches Kent Irwin, Peter Graham, Alexander Sushkov, Dmitry Budke, and Derek Kimball The Geometry and Flow of Quantum Information: From Quantum Gravity to Quantum Technology Raphael Bousso1, Ehud Altman1, Ning Bao1, Patrick Hayden, Christopher Monroe, Yasunori Nomura1, Xiao‐Liang Qi, Monika Schleier‐Smith, Brian Swingle3, Norman Yao1, and Michael Zaletel Algebraic Approach Towards Quantum Information in Quantum Field Theory and Holography Daniel Harlow, Aram Harrow and Hong Liu Interplay of Quantum Information, Thermodynamics, and Gravity in the Early Universe Nishant Agarwal, Adolfo del Campo, Archana Kamal, and Sarah Shandera Quantum Computing for Neutrino‐nucleus Dynamics Joseph Carlson, Rajan Gupta, Andy C.N. Li, Gabriel Perdue, and Alessandro Roggero Quantum‐Enhanced Metrology with Trapped Ions for Fundamental Physics Salman Habib, Kaifeng Cui1,
    [Show full text]
  • KITP Ranks First in Research Impact
    Vol. 4, No. 1 • Spring / Summer 2008 KITP Ranks First INSIDE… In Research Impact Special for Science, p. 2 New Permanent Member, p. 2 OW CAN THE PERFORMANCE as “traditionally…one of the highest ranked Brain Design Workshop, p. 3 of the Kavli Institute for Theoretical scientific groups and so serves as a gold HPhysics be measured and assessed? standard.” Presumably that standard also Star Formation, pp. 4-5 Anne Kinney in an article published in applies to the facility with the highest the Nov. 13, 2007, issue of the Proceedings impact-index. Coordinating Housing, p. 7 of the National Academy of Sciences presents Assessing the quality of KITP Rice Endows a new way of assessing “National Scientific programming performance has proved Upcoming, p. 8 Facilities and Their Science Impact on challenging for the institute’s directors Fund to Make Nonbiomedical Research.” Her approach because much of the measurable effect in enables comparison of the impact of research terms of quality research is manifested in fostered in conjunction with a given facility. publications by visiting scientists whose KITP More The KITP with a score of 6.56 registers the primary institutional affiliation is elsewhere. Tom Abel highest impact-index reported. This way in which KITP differs from The KITP is not only the highest other institutions with which it is being Family Friendly comparatively evaluated is underscored in ranked National Science Foundation (NSF) paper because being cited in papers by other an explanatory footnote to the PNAS article: facility, but the highest ranked of all research scientists demonstrates the impact of the FOR TWO DECADES physicists visiting “KITP is a theoretical physics institute that facilities, including (in order from second to cited work on the research of others.
    [Show full text]
  • Aspen Physics Turns 50 Michael S
    COMMENT DESCRIPTION Three lines of text DESCRIPTION Three lines of text DESCRIPTION Three lines of DESCRIPTION Three lines of go in heere go in heere until go in heere go in heere until text go in heere go in heere text go in heere go in its time for p.xxx its time for p.xxx until its time for p.xxx heere until its time CS I S HY P PEN CENTER FOR PEN CENTER FOR AS S. MAXWELL/ Summer workshops at the Aspen Center for Physics give researchers respite from their academic duties. Aspen physics turns 50 Michael S. Turner reflects on how mountain serenity has bred big breakthroughs at the Aspen Center for Physics in Colorado. heoretical physicists are an odd lot: theoretical physicists, including 53 Nobel Victorian buildings and wonderful skiing. She bad communicators (Niels Bohr laureates, from 65 countries. The centre can persuaded her husband, a devotee of German and Werner Heisenberg); brilliant lay claim to the string theory revolution, the writer Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, to visit Tshowmen (Richard Feynman and George birth of the arXiv preprint archive and to set- in 1945. Seeing it as the ideal place to bring Gamow); the ‘strangest man’ (Paul Dirac), ting the agenda in condensed matter physics. together the three elements of life — eco- lots of Hungarians (Leó Szilárd, Edward Its history is tied to the revival of a silver min- nomic, cultural and physical — he invested Teller and Eugene Wigner); bad hair (Albert ing town and the American entrepreneurial millions of dollars in rebuilding it. In 1946, he Einstein); and too few women.
    [Show full text]
  • Memories of a Theoretical Physicist
    Memories of a Theoretical Physicist Joseph Polchinski Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106-4030 USA Foreword: While I was dealing with a brain injury and finding it difficult to work, two friends (Derek Westen, a friend of the KITP, and Steve Shenker, with whom I was recently collaborating), suggested that a new direction might be good. Steve in particular regarded me as a good writer and suggested that I try that. I quickly took to Steve's suggestion. Having only two bodies of knowledge, myself and physics, I decided to write an autobiography about my development as a theoretical physicist. This is not written for any particular audience, but just to give myself a goal. It will probably have too much physics for a nontechnical reader, and too little for a physicist, but perhaps there with be different things for each. Parts may be tedious. But it is somewhat unique, I think, a blow-by-blow history of where I started and where I got to. Probably the target audience is theoretical physicists, especially young ones, who may enjoy comparing my struggles with their own.1 Some dis- claimers: This is based on my own memories, jogged by the arXiv and IN- SPIRE. There will surely be errors and omissions. And note the title: this is about my memories, which will be different for other people. Also, it would not be possible for me to mention all the authors whose work might intersect mine, so this should not be treated as a reference work.
    [Show full text]
  • Aspen Physics Turns 50 Michael S
    COMMENT AWARDS Passion and punch-ups ECOLOGY A paean to decay EXHIBITION London show OBITUARY Akira Tonomura, in a chronicle of two contested charts the life that death celebrates Alan Turing’s imaging pioneer, Nobel prizes p.318 provides p.320 life and legacy p.321 remembered p.324 S. MAXWELL/ASPEN CENTER FOR PHYSICS S. MAXWELL/ASPEN CENTER FOR Summer workshops at the Aspen Center for Physics give researchers respite from their academic duties. Aspen physics turns 50 Michael S. Turner reflects on how mountain serenity has bred big breakthroughs at the Aspen Center for Physics in Colorado. heoretical physicists are an odd lot: 10,000 theoretical physicists, including 53 Victorian buildings and wonderful skiing. She bad communicators (Niels Bohr Nobel laureates, from 65 countries. The centre persuaded her husband, a devotee of German and Werner Heisenberg); brilliant can lay claim to the string-theory revolution, writer Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, to visit Tshowmen (Richard Feynman and George the birth of the arXiv preprint archive and in 1945. Seeing it as the ideal place to bring Gamow); the ‘strangest man’ (Paul Dirac); to setting the agenda for condensed-matter together the three aspects of life — economic, lots of Hungarians (Leó Szilárd, Edward physics. Its history is tied to the revival of a sil- cultural and physical — he invested millions Teller and Eugene Wigner); bad hair (Albert ver-mining town and the American entrepre- of dollars in rebuilding it. In 1946, he formed Einstein); and too few women. They don’t neurial spirit, and features a fascinating cast of the Aspen Skiing Corporation, which remains need fancy equipment — a pencil and paper characters, from philosopher Mortimer Adler the financial engine of the valley.
    [Show full text]
  • Physicists Thriving with Paperless Publishing
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by E-LIS High Energy Physics Libraries Webzine Issue 6 / March 2002 Physicists Thriving with Paperless Publishing Heath B. O'Connell (*) 14/01/2002(1) Abstract The Stanford Linear Accelerator Center (SLAC) and Deutsches Elektronen Synchrotron (DESY) libraries have been comprehensively cataloguing the High Energy Particle Physics (HEP) literature online since 1974. The core database, SPIRES -HEP, now indexes over 400,000 research articles, with almost 50% linked to fulltext electronic versions (this site now has over 15 000 search hits per day). This database motivated the creation of the first site in the United States for the World -Wide Web at SLAC. With this database and the invention of the Los Alamos E-print archives in 1991, the HEP community pioneered the trend to ``paperless publishing" and the trend to paperless access; in other words, the `` virtual library." We examine the impact this has had both on the way scientists research and on paper -based publishing. The standard of work archived at Los Alamos is very high. 70% of papers are eventually published in journals and another 20% are in conference proceedings. As a service to authors, the SPIRES -HEP collaboration has been ensuring that as much information as possible is included with each bibliographic entry for a paper. Such meta -data can include tables of the experimental data that research ers can easily use to perform their own analyses as well as detailed descriptions of the experiment, citation tracking, and links to full -text documents.
    [Show full text]
  • Kenneth G. Wilson: Renormalized After-Dinner Anecdotes
    Kenneth G. Wilson: Renormalized After-Dinner Anecdotes Paul Ginsparg Abstract This is the transcript of the after-dinner talk I gave at the close of the 16 Nov 2013 symposium \Celebrating the Science of Kenneth Geddes Wilson" [1] at Cornell University (see Fig. 1 for the poster). The video of my talk is on-line [2], and this transcript is more or less verbatim,1 with the slides used included as figures. I've also annotated it with a few clarifying footnotes, and provided references to the source materials where available. Keywords Kenneth G. Wilson · Renormalization · After-Dinner Talk 1 Introduction I've been invited to give the after-dinner talk to complete today's celebration of Ken Wilson's career. It is of course a great honor to commemorate one's thesis advisor on such an occasion | and a unique opportunity. Earlier today, Ken's wife, Alison (sitting over here), asked me to be irreverent tonight. (\Don't blame it on me," she calls out. \Not hard for you to do," says someone else.) Actually I replied, \You've got the wrong person, I only do serious." Since the afternoon events ran a bit late, there wasn't quite as much time as I'd hoped to absorb the events of the day and think about what to say tonight. But by the standards of this afternoon, I hope you're all prepared to be here until midnight ::: As Ken's student, I had only a brief window of interaction with him. Many of his colleagues here knew him from 1963 to 1988 at Cornell, or, like David Mermin, knew him since they were undergrads together starting in 1952.
    [Show full text]
  • The Arxiv: 14 Years of Open Access Scientific Communication
    The arXiv: 14 years of open access scientific communication Simeon Warner [email protected] http://www.cs.cornell.edu/people/simeon Symposium on Free Culture and the Digital Library, Emory University, Atlanta, 14th October 2005 Acknowledgements arXiv is the work of many people! Particular thanks to Paul Ginsparg, Thorsten Schwander, Mark Doyle and also to others in the past and present arXiv team. arXiv has received support from: • DOE HEP initially, • the NSF since 1995 (awards 9413208, 0132355, 0404553), • and recently the Cornell University Library. In the beginning... Started by Paul Ginsparg in 1991 at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) as a way for high-energy theoretical physicists to share preprints fairly and efficiently (then xxx.lanl.gov). Initial user-base of 160 email addresses assembled from existing pre-print distribution lists for hep-th. ...and now • 340,000 articles in physics, mathematics, computer science, and quantitative biology. • ∼4,000 submissions, 1.6 million downloads per month. • alerting service, search facilities, 17 mirrors... Timeline Aug 1991 hep-th archive with email interface started. 1992 ftp interface. hep-ph and hep-lat added locally; alg-geom, astro-ph and cond-mat added remotely. 1994 Web interface added, remote archives merged back. Jun 1995 Automatic PostScript generation from TEX source. 1996 PDF generation and web upload facility added. Sep 1997 ATMP is first journal overlay on an e-print archive. Jan 2001 OAI compliant. Sep 2001 Administrative oversight transferred to Cornell. Jul 2003 Email submission discontinued, new user registration. Sep 2003 q-bio archive launched. Dec 2003 Holiday schedule announced for the first time.
    [Show full text]
  • Cornell High Energy Theory
    Cornell Cornell High Energy Theory Group University Department of Physics, Institute for High Energy Phenomenology Cornell Laboratory for Accelerator-based Sciences and Education Faculty and Postdocs Research topics (plotted by energy scale) Grad Culture and Alumni Csaba Csáki (Professor; PhD MIT 1997, Adviser: Lisa Randall) Collider & Cosmological Flavor Physics • Heavy quark flavor physics Home of arXiv.org, the e-print archive Beyond the Standard Model. Recent work includes Randall-Sundrum Phenomenology • Discrete flavor groups • Neutrino mass and mixing The Cornell Library is currently the home of Training to become an independent researcher. Our group models, buried Higgs, EWSB and SUSY breaking through monopole • BSM collider signatures • Composite leptogenesis • Flavor signatures of new physics arXiv.org and is a leader in information science. focuses on developing its students to be prepared for an academic condensation. Current students: David Curtin (2011), Flip Tanedo. including SUSY, extra career in high energy physics. dimensions, little Higgs models Yuval Grossman (Professor; PhD Weizmann 1997, Adviser: Yosef Nir) flavor & qcd • LHC model discrimination String Theory & Cosmology • Community. Students play an active role in the theory group, participating in Flavor physics beyond the Standard Model. Recent work includes lepton • Dark matter (in)direct detection and helping to organize group events. flavor symmetries, leptogenesis, CP violation, composite neutrinos, and dark matter 10% GeV • Stringy models of inflation and
    [Show full text]
  • Against the Tide
    AGAINST THE TIDE A Critical Review by Scientists of How Physics and Astronomy Get Done Martín López Corredoira & Carlos Castro Perelman (Eds.) Against the Tide Against the Tide. A Critical Review by Scientists of How Physics and Astronomy Get Done Copyright © 2008 Martín López Corredoira Free distribution of the electronic copy of this book is allowed. Paperback copy of the Universal Publ. version (with an extra chapter) at www.universal-publishers.com 2 López Corredoira & Castro Perelman (Eds.) CONTENTS FOREWORD, BY M. LÓPEZ CORREDOIRA AND C. CASTRO PERELMAN ....................................................5 CHALLENGING DOMINANT PHYSICS PARADIGMS, BY J. M. CAMPANARIO AND B. MARTIN.............9 UNDERSTANDING CHALLENGES .................................................................................................................................... 11 INVESTIGATING DISSENT IN PHYSICS ............................................................................................................................. 15 HOW TO MOUNT A CHALLENGE ..................................................................................................................................... 17 FUNDING ....................................................................................................................................................................... 17 PUBLISHING .................................................................................................................................................................. 18 SURVIVING ATTACK
    [Show full text]