UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURE CROSS-SECTION

Issue No. 150. April I, 1965.

IT Best Award-Winning Architecture: Victoria Architecture LOOKING FOR THE BEST Medal. 1965: Channel "O" Studios, Burwood; Hassell & McConnell, arch+s. : House, Glenard Drive, Heidelberg; Charles Duncan, arch+. 1964: New Zealand Insurance Building, 493 Bourke Street; Bates Smart & McCutcheon, archts. : House at Davey's Bay, Frankston; Guilford Bell & Neil Clerehan, archts. : House at Rye; McGlashan & Everist, archts. R.V.I.A. Street Architecture Medal (awarded 1929- 1954). 1929: Francis House, Collins Street, Melbourne, Blackett & Forster, archts. 1930: The Emily McPherson College of Domestic Economy, Russell Street, Melbourne. E. Evan Smith, archi. 1931: Lyric House, Collins Street, Melbourne, A. & K. Hen- derson, archts. 1932: A.M.P. Building, 425 Collins Street, Melbourne. Bates, Smart & McCutcheon, archts. 1933: Port Authority Building, Market Street, Melbourne. A special issue of Cross-Section produced to coincide with Sydney Smith, Ogg & Serpell, archts. the Fourteenth Annual Architectural Convention, in Mel- 1934: Buckley & Nunn's Building, 294-296 Bourke Street, bourne, March 22-April 2, 1965, and intended as a stimulant Melbourne. Bates, Smart & McCutcheon, archts. to make +hose who look at Melbourne open their eyes a 1935: Shell Corner, 163 William Street, Melbourne. A. & little wider, peer a little more keenly and seek a little more K. Henderson & Partners, archts. earnestly than is possible when lulled into the semi- 1936: Bank of New South Wales, 368 Collins Street, Mel- consciousness of the standard guided four. Melbourne is bourne. Godfrey & Spowers, archts. not an obviously dramatic city, and it is easy to find ugli- 1937: The Royal Australasian College of Surgeons, Spring ness, but in the following list of the "best" of this and Street, Melbourne. Leighton Irwin & Roy K. Steven- that, even some of the uglies are noticed to have a character son, archts. that it would be life-denying to lose. 1938: The Second Church of Christ, Scientist, Cookson As Jane Jacobs wrote in The Death and Life of Great Street, Camberwell. Bates, Smart & McCutcheon American Cities" "Quantities of the 'unaverage', which are archts. bound to be relatively small, are indispensable to vital 1939: The Heidelberg Town Hall and Municipal Offices cities", and quoting Paul Tillich, she also observed "By its Upper Heidelberg Road, Ivanhoe. Peck & Kemfer nature, the metropolis provides what otherwise could be and A. C. Leith & Associates, archts. given only by travelling; namely, the strange. Since the 1940: The Sanitarium Health Food Company Building, Main strange leads to questions and undermines familiar tradition, Street, Warburton. Edward Fielder Billson, it serves to elevate reason to ultimate significance . archi. 1941: King George V Jubilee Maternal and Infant Welfare Photographs in this issue were taken by Ian Perry, Sue Ingle- Pathological Building, Women's Hospital, Carlton. ton, Peter Burleigh, Ken Laskin of Alan Friedman Studios, Stephenson & Turner, archts. and Maurice Shaw. This special issue by courtesy of Cross- 1942: Western Branch of the National Bank of Australasia Section's regular advertisers, Dunlop. Ltd., Corner of Collins and William Streets, Mel- bourne. P. H. Meldrum and A. A. Noad, archts. 1954: Five apartments at No. 24 Hill Street, Toorak. Grounds, Romberg & Boyd, archts. if Best of H. Desbrowe Annear (1866-1933): "Inglesby", 97 Caroline Street, South Yarra, 1919. Three houses on The Eyrie, Eaglemont. IT Best of Walter Burley Griffin (1876-1937): Newman Col- lege, University of Melbourne, 1916. Capitol Theatre (what's left of it), 113 Swanston Street, 1924. Leonard House, 46 Elizabeth Street, 1925. Langi Flats, Corner of Toorak Road and Lansell Road. House, 16 Glyndebourne Avenue, Toorak, 1923. (j Best Second Phase Modern — The Streamline Era: Relova Redressing Laundry, 129 Hoddle Street, Richmond. Sani- tarium Health Food Factory (Warburton); 1936, Edward F. Billson, archt. McPherson's Hardware Store, 546 Collins Street, 1935, Reid & Pearson with Stuart Calder, archts. Looking carefully for European influences, the early Dutch school, especially Dudok, seems likely, and even Mendelsohn in his earliest period. Traces of this delight in horizontal swathes of brickwork, windows and balconies can also be seen in Stephenson and Turner's Bethesda Hospital, Erin Street, Richmond, 1936, and in the same architect's Royal Melbourne Hospital (1939-43), (which displays a gusto and self-confidence that seem missing from the latest additions); an attitude to design that culminated in the vast white dry- docked liner in Queens Road; Stanhill Flats 1949 (Frederick Romberg, archt). (( Best Terrace Houses: along Rathdown Street, Carlton, op- posite the Exhibition, and along Albert Street, East Mel- Best Avenue: Royal Parade. bourne, between Eades Street and Clarendon Street. Best City Park: Fitzroy Gardens. ¶ Best Pop Art Fence: outside Monte Carlo Reception f( Best Urban Residential Planning: St. Vincent Place & St. Rooms, Gardenvale Road, Gardenvale. Vincent Gardens, South Melbourne. ¶ Best Tram Ride: From Grattan Street, to Brunswick Road, Carlton, along Royal Parade.

Best Place to Wait (Rustic): Royal Botanic Gardens.

¶ Best Vertical Feature: Coop's Shot Tower, Knox Place, cff Little La Trobe Street, 1870.

I Best Place to Wait (if not expecting anyone): Post Office Steps, Elizabeth and Bourke Streets. Best Place to Wait (if expecting someone): Flinders Street Station, Swanston Street. Ì Best Place to Wait (if expecting): Royal Women's Hos- pital, Cardigan Street, Carlton. (( Best Area for Queen Anne type houses: East Malvern, between Tooronga Road, Wattletree Road, Bourke Road and Best Supporting Feature: Doorway, Physiology Depart- Dandenong Road. ment (at one time the Architectural School dwelt here), if Best Preserved: Como, Como Avenue, South `terra, 1865. University of Melbourne.

( Best Vista: from the Shrine Forecourt looking North. ¶ Best Stretch of City Street: Collins Street, especially from Swanston to Spring. (( Best Boulevard: Alexandra Avenue. (j Best Traffic Jam (a.m.): St. Kilda Junction. jj Best Traffic Jam (p.m.): South Eastern Freeway at Grange Road Bridge.

Q Best Anonymous Industrial Architecture: Stone Crushing Plant, Thomastown.

If Best (and only) Overhead Pedestrian Link: Myers walk- way, Post Office Place; Tompkins Shaw & Evans, archts., 1962.

Best Pop Architecture: Luna Park (Just for Fun

If Best Arcade: The Block, between Collins, Little Collins jj Best "Other" Architecture: Rear of Fairy Caves, Luna and Elizabeth Streets. Park.

Ì Best Urban "Gothick": Rialto Building, 495 Collins Street. Best Boom-Time Mansion: "Labasa", Manor Grove, If Best Basalt: Carlton and United Breweries, Bouverie Street, W. Pi++, arch+., 1890. Caulfield. Carlton.

11 Best Grand Manner Theatre: Princess, Spring Street.

Q Best Joss House: Palmerston Street, South Melbourne, if Best Fairy-Tale Post Office, Flemington. 1866. II Best Jazz Age: Wardrop's 52 Elizabeth Street. Best Window Dressing: at Georges, Collins Street. I Best Proportioned Building: No. 8 La Trobe Street. Best Panorama of the City: from Top of the Town Res- taurant, National Mutual Centre. Godfrey Spowers Hughes Mewton & Lobb and Leith and Bartlett, archts. ¶ Best Tensile Structure: Sidney Myer Music Bowl. Yuncken Freeman, archts.

IT Best Odd Clock: Above Spencer Street Station. Best Penthouse: N-E corner of Bradford Cotton Mills, Tren- nery Crescent, Abbotsford.

IT Best Street Light: Beside the Law Courts, off Lonsdale IT Best Art Nouveau: Selbourne Chambers, corner of Welling- Street. ton Parade and Simpson Streets, East Melbourne.

¶ Best All-Night Pavement Cafe: The Pieteria, Flinders Street West. if Best Atmosphere for-drinking-wine-in: Jimmy Watson's, 333 Lygon Street, Carlton. Robin Boyd, archt. Best City Square: McArthur Place, Carlton. 51' Best Beach Front: Beaconsfield Parade, South Melbourne. IT Best New Buildings: Anyone looking seriously ought to be able to make his own mind up on these. But as a clue, start in Collins Street. Better still, follow the suggested tours outlined in the Convention Issue of C.S.R's. journal, "Building Ideas". If Best Radburn Type Planning: The common parkland be- tween backs of houses facing Gatehouse Street and Park Street, between Flemington Road and Morrah Streets, Park- ville. 111 This year the Architecture Students' Convention will be held in Melbourne from May 29-June 5. The purpose of the convention is to stimulate amongst the students an aware- ness of technical advances in the building industry. The congress committee has decided on the theme: "New Materials — New Architecture", and this will be supple- mented by visiting guest speakers, work sessions, open dis- cussions and an Australia-wide competition for the students, offering £300 prize money donated by the Australian Gas Association. Adjudicators of the competition will be George Molnar, John Dalton and Ray Berg. Eric Lyons, James Stir- ling, Felix Candela, Pier Luigi Nervi, Prof. Janeba, Prof. Albert Dietz and Paolo Solero have been approached to attend the convention as guest speakers. Encouraging sup- port and financial aid has already been received from lead- ing Australian manufacturers. At this stage the enthusiasm Q Best Warehouses: Flinders Lane e.g. No. 552, Seppelt and and amount of work being done would seem to have already If Best Backside: Rear elevation of Pelais Pictures, St. Kilda. Son, 1863. ensured the success of the convention. There are two ways to deal with stilletto heels

DF1468 get tough or get Dunlop Vinyl-Asbestos We'll let you decide which way is the prettiest. And the floor's nice to look at too (for years and years). Dents and scratches that disfigure most floors don't show on Dunlop Vinyl-Asbestos. That's because their asbestos content is so high. Note: Statistics show that of the smooth surface floor tiles produced in one year in the U.S.A., 87.7% contained asbestos. As well as making them tougher, this contributes to dimensional stability and positive adhesion. Dunlop beauty never wears out. The colour (in 30 attractive choices), goes right through each tile. So it lasts as long as the tile itself, which means a lifetime. Stilletto heels may never go out of fashion. But of course, beauty won't either.

Dunlop Flooring Service. 96 Flinders Street, Melbourne. 63 0371. 27-33 Wentworth Avenue, Sydney. 2 0969. Centenary Place, Brisbane. 31 0271. 424 Murray Street, Perth. 21 8141. 131-133 Pirie Street, Adelaide. 23 2611. 27 Argyle Street, Hobart. 2 6581. 18 Paterson Street, Launceston. 2 2067.

Library Digitised Collections

Title: Cross-Section [1965]

Date: 1965

Persistent Link: http://hdl.handle.net/11343/24059

File Description: Cross-Section, Apr 1965 (no. 150)