Studies on Collingwood, History and Civilization
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Studies on Collingwood, History and Civilization Jan van der Dussen Studies on Collingwood, History and Civilization Jan van der Dussen Heerlen , The Netherlands ISBN 978-3-319-20671-4 ISBN 978-3-319-20672-1 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-20672-1 Library of Congress Control Number: 2015951386 Springer Cham Heidelberg New York Dordrecht London © Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2016 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved by the Publisher, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifi cally the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfi lms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specifi c statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. Printed on acid-free paper Springer International Publishing AG Switzerland is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www. springer.com) Acknowledgements The following four essays are reproduced from their original publication. I would like to express my gratitude to the publishers for reprinting them here. ‘Introduction to Collingwood’s Philosophy of History’, with the title ‘The Case for Historical Imagination: Defending the Human Factor and Narrative’, in Nancy Partner and Sarah Foot eds., The Sage Handbook of Historical Theory (Los Angeles/ London/New Delhi/Singapore/Washington DC, 2013: Sage), 41–66 ‘Collingwood’s Philosophy of History in the Year of his An Autobiography ’, in David Boucher and Teresa Smith eds., R.G. Collingwood : An Autobiography and Other Writings. With essays on Collingwood ’ s life and work (Oxford, 2013: Oxford University Press), 305–333 ‘Collingwood on the Ideas of Process, Progress, and Civilization’, in David Boucher, James Connelly and Tariq Modood eds., Philosophy , History and Civilization. Interdisciplinary Perspectives on R.G. Collingwood (Cardiff, 1995: University of Wales Press), 246–268 (with minor revisions) ‘Collingwood’s Claim that History is a Science’, Collingwood and British Idealism Studies 13, nr. 2 (2007), 5–30 The following three essays are revised versions of articles that were originally published as follows: ‘Collingwood’s “Lost” Manuscript of The Principles of History ’, History and Theory 36 (1997), 32–62 ‘The Philosophical Context of Collingwood’s Re-enactment Theory’, International Studies in Philosophy 27, nr. 2 (1995), 81–99 ‘The Historian and his Evidence’, in W.J. van der Dussen and Lionel Rubinoff eds., Objectivity , Method and Point of View. Essays in the Philosophy of History (Leiden, 1991: E.J. Brill), 154–169 The following essays are revised versions of articles that originally appeared in Dutch, in Jan van der Dussen, Geschiedenis en Beschaving. Kritische Opstellen over Verleden , Heden en Toekomst (Hilversum, 2005: Verloren): ‘Herodotus as Pater Historiae ’, ‘Toynbee and his Critics’, ‘Time in Perspective. In Search of Orientation in History’, ‘Sense of Crisis in Historical Perspective’, ‘Responsibility for Future Generations’, and ‘The Lasting Debate on Human Rights’. v vi Acknowledgements Parts of ‘A Quest for the Real Past. Ankersmit on Historiography and (Sublime) Historical Experience’ are a revised version of ‘Frank Ankersmit over de sublieme historische ervaring’, Civis Mundi 47 (2008) 172–188. ‘The West and the Rest’ is a revised version of ‘Tekenen des Tijds’, valedictory speech at the Open University of the Netherlands (Heerlen, 2005). Contents Part I Collingwood’s Philosophy of History 1 Introduction to Collingwood’s Philosophy of History ......................... 3 1.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 3 1.2 Complexities in Interpreting Collingwood’s Philosophy of History .......................................... 4 1.3 The Concept of History and Its Philosophy ................................. 6 1.4 The Historian and His/Her Object................................................ 8 1.5 Re-enactment of the Past: Collingwood’s Exposition .................. 10 1.6 History as the History of Thought ................................................ 11 1.7 The Reception of the Re-enactment Doctrine .............................. 15 1.8 The Philosophical Dimension of the Re-enactment Doctrine ...................................................... 16 1.9 Historical Methodology ............................................................... 20 1.10 The Logic of Question and Answer ............................................. 20 1.11 Historical Method: The Importance of Evidence ......................... 22 1.12 Empirical and Pure Methodology ................................................ 23 1.13 The Relevance of Archaeology for History .................................. 25 1.14 The Interpretation of Evidence in The Principles of History ......................................................... 26 1.15 History: From Scissors-and-Paste to Critical History .................. 27 1.16 Constructive History and Imagination ......................................... 29 1.17 The Historical Narrative ............................................................... 30 1.18 Conclusion.................................................................................... 33 2 Collingwood’s ‘Lost’ Manuscript of The Principles of History ........... 37 2.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 37 2.2 The Fate of the Manuscript of The Principles of History ............ 38 2.3 The Principles of History, Chapter 1: ‘Evidence’ ........................ 43 vii viii Contents 2.4 The Principles of History, Chapter 2: ‘Action’ ............................ 46 2.4.1 History a parte subjecti and a parte objecti ................... 46 2.4.2 Actions ........................................................................... 47 2.4.3 Evidence and Language.................................................. 49 2.4.4 ‘Action and Event’, and ‘Nature has no History’ ........... 53 2.4.5 Thought and Emotions ................................................... 55 2.4.6 Biography ....................................................................... 58 2.5 The Principles of History, Chapter 3: ‘Nature and Action’ .......... 59 2.5.1 Introduction: The ‘Absence’ of the Re-enactment Doctrine......................................... 59 2.5.2 Historical Naturalism ..................................................... 62 2.5.3 ‘The Science of Human Nature’, and ‘Nature as Environment’ .......................................... 63 2.5.4 Freedom .......................................................................... 66 2.5.5 Marx and Hegel .............................................................. 67 2.6 Conclusion.................................................................................... 70 3 Collingwood’s Philosophy of History in the Year of his An Autobiography .......................................................................... 73 3.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 73 3.2 Collingwood as a Philosopher, Archaeologist, and Historian ...... 74 3.3 The Logic of Question and Answer ............................................. 76 3.4 The Haverfi eld-Mommsen Link ................................................... 77 3.5 The Nature of Collingwood’s Laboratory of Knowledge ............ 79 3.6 Collingwood’s Elaboration of His Laboratory of Knowledge as a Theory of Inquiry and Historical Understanding ....................................................... 82 3.7 The Re-enactment Doctrine ......................................................... 84 3.8 The Principles of History ............................................................. 86 3.8.1 Outline of The Principles of History .............................. 87 3.9 The Absence of the Re-enactment Doctrine in The Principles of History ......................................................... 90 3.10 The Presence of the Re-enactment Doctrine in The Principles of History ......................................................... 92 4 The Philosophical Context of Collingwood’s Re-enactment Theory ............................................................................. 97 4.1 Introduction .................................................................................. 97 4.2 Gadamer on Collingwood ............................................................ 98 4.3 Popper on Objective Mind and Collingwood ............................... 100 4.4 The Relevance of Frege’s Theories for the Re-enactment Doctrine ........................................................................................ 104 4.4.1 Frege on Sense, Reference, and Indirect Speech ............ 104 4.4.2 Frege and Collingwood on the Nature of Thought and Knowledge of It ......................................................