Mineral Assemblages in Granitoid Rocks: Melt : Biotite Reaction in The
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
American Mi ner al o gist, Volume72, pages 863-878, 1987 Evolutionof magmaticAFM mineral assemblagesin granitoid rocks: The hornblende* melt : biotite reaction in the Libertv Hill pluton, South Carolina J. Ar,nxaNDER SPEER* OrogenicStudies Laboratory, Department of GeologicalSciences, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and StateUniversity, Blacksburg,Virginia 24061, U.S.A. AssrRAcr The Liberty Hill pluton comprisesa central, coarse-grainededenite + biotite granitoid faciesgrading to a biotite, pargasite + biotite, or muscovite * biotite granitoid marginal facies.The replacementof amphibole by biotite, mineral compositions, and "liquid" vari- ation diagrams for the Liberty Hill help determine the AFM mineral-crystallization re- actions in the Liberty Hill pluton. These reactions evolved from liquid : amphibole to liquid : biotite with an intervening liquid + amphibole : biotite reaction resulting from either (l) movement along the amphibole-biotite liquidus boundary from the even, liq- uid: amphibole * biotite, to the odd, liquid + amphibole : biotite, crystallization reaction with decreasingtemperatures or (2) movement of the liquid composition from the amphibole field into the biotite field. The liquid + amphibole : biotite reaction involved additional phases;the full reaction may have taken the form liquid I + amphi- bole*ilmenite:biotite+qtrarlz+anorthite+K-feldspar+titanite+magnetite+ liquid 2, where the liquid is the interstitial melt. The extended crystallization history to lower temperaturesand higher water activities at the margins of the pluton allowed the reaction to exhaust the amphibole before the liquid; the subsequentliquid : biotite crys- tallization reaction produced the biotite granitoid facies. Locally, muscovite crystallized accordingto the reaction liquid : muscovite + biotite, producing the muscovite + biotite facies. The pluton is intruded by a finer-grained biotite granitoid believed to be derived from interstitial melt of the coarser-grainedgranitoids. This derivation explains why bio- tite is the only AFM mineral in the finer-grained granitoids and why biotites from all Liberty Hill granitoids are generally similar in composition. The averageKo value l(XBJe/XB;)/(W;/Xf"b')lis 1.04 for coexisting Hbl and Bt. This K" is higher than the 0.69-0.93 normally observed in igneousrocks, but equal to values for specificinstances of biotite replacing amphibole in the Peruvian Coastal batholith. Com- bined with the results obtained from the contact aureole, the central granitoids preserve conditions of 725"C,P,oor E 4.5 kbar, Po",oE 0.5 P,"o,,andfo, - 10-15,slightly more oxidizing than the NNO solid buffer. Marginal granitoids yield conditions of 647"C, Po,,or P,.^,, andfo, I 10-16,suggesting a more prolonged reaction history. INrnonucrroN ciesoverlap thoseofthe centralgranitoids, arguing against Many of the late Paleozoic granitoid plutons of the significant differentiation (Speeret al., unpub. ms.). The southernAppalachians are composite bodies with coarse- marginal facies do show minor wall rock-magma inter- grained amphibole + biotite and biotite varietal facies action that affectedsome trace-elementand oxygen-iso- (Speeret al., 1980). From field relations, thesefacies ap- tope compositions(Wenner and Speer,1986). An alter- pear closelyrelated, and multiple intrusion or differentia- native explanation for the mineralogical relation between tion comesto mind as an explanation for the relationship. the central and marginal facies is suggestedby the wide- In the Liberty Hill pluton, the coarse-grainedcentral am- spreadtexture of biotite replacing amphibole. phibole + biotite granitoids grade imperceptibly into Understanding the mineral assemblagesand composi- marginal biotite granitoids, seeminglyruling out multiple tions in igneousrocks requires linking them to the evolv- intrusions. The compositions of the marginal biotite fa- ing conditions and compositions of the interstitial melt during crystallization. This is a well-developed area of gabbroic * Present address:Department of Marine, Earth and Atmo- investigation for rocks, but much less so for spheric Sciences,Box 8208, North Carolina State University, granitoid rocks. Recently, Abbott and Clarke (1979) and Raleigh,North Carolina27695-8208, U.S.A. Abbott (1981, 1985) have given the sequenceofAFM 0003404x/87/09 I 0-0863$02.00 863 864 SPEER:EVOLUTION OF MAGMATIC AFM ASSEMBLAGES IN GRANITOID ROCKS crystallization reactionsin granitoids in more detail than given in Tables 1 to 3. Mineral formulas and componentswere Bowen's(1928) reaction series. These have beenused in calculatedusing the computer program suPERrncer-ofRucklidge program stoichiometric interpreting the crystallization reactions in strongly per- (1971). The also calculatedan assumed amount of water and added it to the oxide weight percentages aluminous granitoids, such as the cordierite-bearing for the hydrous minerals. Mineral abbreviations in the text, ta- pluton, South Carolina (Speer,198 1b). Their CloudsCreek bles, and figuresare those recommendedby The American Min- use is extended here to the metaluminous Liberty Hill eralogist(ketz, 1983). pluton, South Carolina, in order to understand the evo- lution of amphibole + biotite, biotite, and muscovite + Amphibole biotite granitoids. Amphibole occursas euhedralto subhedralprismatic crystals up to 0.5 cm long. They are pleochroic dark yellow green to Gnolocrc sETTTNG moderate blue green and are locally twinned on (100). Micro- The Liberty Hill pluton is roughly elliptical, covering probe analyses(App. 1, selectedanalyses in Table l) show that 360 km'zin Kershaw, l,ancaster, and Fairfield Counties, the amphiboles in the central granitoids are ferro-edenitesand north-central South Carolina. The Liberty Hill pluton ferro-edenitic hornblendes(Fig.2a), hereafterreferred to as fer- comprises severaltexturally and mineralogically distinct ro-edenites.These ferro-edeniteshave a narrow compositional Fe/(Fe + Mg) near 0.6 and a Si content in the facies(Fig. 1). The predominant faciesis a coarse-grained range with an half-unit-cell formula of 6.56 to 6.85 atoms per 24 anions. The ferro-edenite + biotite granitoid occupying the center of F and Cl contents rangebetween 0.08 and 0.22 molo/oF/(OH + pluton. pargasite the Coarse-grainedbiotite, ferroan + F + Cl) and between0.005 and 0.03 mo10/oCV(OH + F + CD, biotite, and muscovite * biotite granitoids occur along respectively.Amphiboles in granitoids of the northeast corner the northern and easternborders ofthe pluton and have of the pluton have thin, discontinuousaluminous rims of ferroan gradational contactswith the central ferro-edenite * bio- pargasite(Fig. 2B). Thesealuminous rims are lessthan 0.01 mm tite granitoids. This reversezoning of the mineral facies thick and are only locally visible, where there is a color difer- is believed to result from accumulation of magma with a ence. According to graphical representationsof Doolan et al. greater percentageof evolved, interstitial melt near the (1978)and Thompson(1981), the substitutionin the aluminous margin as a result of the pluton's emplacementas well as rims is primarily a tschermakite [AlrMg 'Si-'] + edenite to form pargasite. a minor amount of contamination from the wall rocks [NaAlSi-,] substitution Many amphiboles are intergrown with biotite, but generally (Wenner and Speer, 1986). There are severalyounger fa- the order of crystallization is uncertain. Where textures are un- pluton cies in the Liberty Hill that intrude the coarse- ambiguous,the amphiboles are partially (Fig. 3a) or completely grained granitoids as dikes or plugs up to I km2 in area. (Fig. 3b) replaced by biotite. In what is interpreted as a later The most prominent are fine- to medium-grained biotite reaction texture, amphiboles can be replacedby chlorite + epi- granitoids in the west-centralpart ofthe pluton (Fig. 1), dote + plagioclase.Scattered throughout the pluton are amphi- which are believed to have differentiated from the coarse- boles with clinopyroxene inclusions (Fig. 3c). The amphibole grained facies. adjacent to these pyroxenes is pale green actinolite that is dis- The contact aureole of the pluton was described by continuously zoned to ferro-edenite at the rim, comparable in pluton (Fig. Speer(198 I a). The pelitic assemblagein the country rock, composition to amphiboles elsewherein the 2b). muscovite + chlorite + albite * epidote + quartz + Biotite magnetite + ilmenite, changesin responseto prograde Greenish-blackbiotite is a ubiquitous mafic phasein the Lib- pluton. metamorphism on approachingthe The following erty Hill pluton, forming up to 5 modal percent of the rock. isograds are encountered:porphyroblastic magnetite in, Biotite occursinterstitially to feldsparsand quartz, replacingam- epidote + albite out, biotite + cordierite in, chlorite out, phibole, and as inclusions in leucocratic minerals. Individual K-feldspar in, and muscovite or magnetite out. Several flakesare up to 5 mm across.Biotite is pleochroic grayish orange additional metamorphic minerals appearin the xenoliths: to greenishblack in thin section. garnet, orthopyroxene, andalusite, sillimanite, and fi- Microprobe analyses(App. l, selectedanalyses in Table 2) brolite. It was concluded that the pluton was emplaced show that biotite compositions from the granitoids fall approx- phlogopite at a depth correspondingto 4.5-kbar pressure.The mag- imately midway between and annite with an inter- The range of molar Fel(Fe + Mg) is small ma was relatively dry, and the xenoliths yield estimated mediate Al