Table of Contents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TABLE OF 8 VOLUME 8: CONSULTATION .......................................... 1 8.1 The Master Plan’s Consultation Program ................................ 1 CONTENTS 8.1.1 Public and Agency Consultation ............................................................................................. 1 8.1.2 Consultation with Key Stakeholders ................................................................................... 2 8.1.3 First Nations Consultation ........................................................................................................... 2 APPENDICES APPENDIX 8-A CONSULTATION MATERIALS CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY WATER AND WASTEWATER MASTER PLAN WSP Project No. 121-23026-00 CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY Page i 8 VOLUME 8: CONSULTATION 8.1 THE MASTER PLAN’S CONSULTATION PROGRAM Consultation effort is an important aspect of the Municipal Class EA process for Master Planning. To meet the Class EA Phase 1 and 2 consultation requirements for the City of Greater Sudbury Water and Wastewater Master Plan, two informative sessions were completed to consult stakeholders, the public, government agencies, and other interested parties. Consultation ensured that necessary information regarding the study was made available to the required parties, to be reviewed and commented on, prior to any decision making. Appendix 8-A contains relevant documents from these consultation sessions (notices and presentations). The following sections detail the consultation efforts made throughout the CGS Water and Wastewater Master Planning process. 8.1.1 PUBLIC AND AGENCY CONSULTATION The Master Plan was carried out in conjunction with Approach 1 from the MEA Class EA process, whereby the study is conducted at a broad level of assessment and in which site-specific Class EA’s for all recommended Schedule B and Schedule C projects are to be completed in the future, closer to the time of the projects’ implementation. Additional studies and consultation efforts will be required prior to the implementation of all Schedule A+, B and C projects. Four key public consultation activities were undertaken throughout the course of the CGS Master Plan; 1 Notice of Project Commencement 2 Public Consultation Session (PCS) #1 3 PCS #2 4 Notice of Study Completion Any input received from interested parties throughout the the project’s undertaking, as well as the responses to the input is included in Appendix 8-A. PROJECT NOTICES Project Notices were issued in order to notify stakeholders, the public, and other agencies of the project status and to describe the general undertaking. Details relating to publically available information, as well as reference to the Municipal Class EA process and planned PCSs were included in the notices. WSP contacted each member of the Stakeholder Contact List (See Stakeholder Contact List subsection) by mail, and the City of Greater Sudbury addressed the public by including both notices in the public newspaper twice. PCS Notices were distributed two weeks prior to the session dates. PUBLIC CONSULTATION SESSIONS The two PCSs were developed and delivered in different communities within the CGS. The first PCS, held June 2nd and 3rd of 2014, was provided in the Valley as well as in Sudbury. The presentation outlined the problem statement, the Master Planning process, existing conditions, general alternative solutions, evaluation approach, and the project’s next steps. Interested stakeholders were encouraged to provide feedback though questionnaires available at the PCS as well as online; however, it was noted that there was little public participation at this consultation session. A mailing list was made available as well, to allow interested parties to sign up to be informed of project updates. The second PCS occurred in June of 2017, and took place in where at the South End Public Library. This session was held to convey information regarding the existing water and wastewater systems, a summary of the identified existing and future infrastructure deficiencies, a description of the alternative servicing solutions developed to address the infrastructure gaps, and a presentation of the recommendations regarding the preferred solutions for each of the water and wastewater systems in the CGS. Feedback forms were made available at the session. CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY WATER AND WASTEWATER MASTER PLAN WSP Project No. 121-23026-00 CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY Page 1 STAKEHOLDER CONTACT LIST A stakeholder contact list was developed throughout the Master Planning process to ensure all appropriate stakeholders were being consulted at key times during the project. The list comprises all stakeholders and their available contact information including company, address, phone number, and email address. Updates were made to reflect interested parties based on the PCS participation. Contacts include agencies such as the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, Environment Canada, the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation, and the Ministry of the Environment. The complete stakeholder contact list is included in Appendix 8-A. 8.1.2 CONSULTATION WITH KEY STAKEHOLDERS Over the course of the Master Plan the City has undertaken several meetings with Vale to discuss the Water and Wastewater Servicing currently provided by Vale. The feedback from these discussions has been used as input into the evaluation of servicing alternatives and the determination of the final preferred servicing solutions. 8.1.3 FIRST NATIONS CONSULTATION To ensure all appropriate Métis and Aboriginal groups were being engaged throughout the Master Plan, federal and provincial websites including Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC) and Aboriginal and Treaty Rights Information System (ATRIS), respectively, were consulted to develop a list of all Indigenous communities affected by the Master Plan. A report was then submitted to the Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation regarding the Study, in order to confirm that all necessary groups were included in the notifications list. Notices of PCSs were sent to all communities included on the list. WSP CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY WATER AND WASTEWATER MASTER PLAN Project No. 121-23026-00 Page 2 CITY OF GREATER SUDBURY APPENDIX 8-A CONSULTATION MATERIALS City of Greater Sudbury Water & Wastewater Master Plan Project Mailing List Updated: December 2016 FEDERAL AGENCIES Title First Name Last Name Title Company Name Address Line 1 Address Line 2 City Province Postal Code Country Phone Fax Email Address Ms. Julie Fontaine Fisheries & Oceans Canada – OCLA Northern District 1500 Paris Street, Unit 1 Sudbury ON P3E 3B8 CA Mr. Robert Dobos Manager Environment Canada – Ontario Region 867 Lakeshore Boulevard Burlington ON L7R 4A6 CA 905-336-4953 905-336-8901 [email protected] Mr. Barry Goodwinn Industry Canada 151 Yonge Street Toronto ON M5C 2W7 CA Mr. Jason Innis Environmental Analyst and Assessment Officer Fednor Regional Operations - Industry Canada 19 Lisgar Street, Suite 307 Sudbury ON P3E 3L4 CA 705-507-6952 705-671-0717 Mr. Paul Schafer Senior Advisor Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency Place Bell Canada 160 Elgin Street, 22nd Floor Ottawa ON K1A 0H3 CA 613-948-1975 Environmental Assessment Coordinator Transport Canada, Ontario Region 4900 Yonge St, 4th Floor Toronto ON M2N 6A5 CA FIRST NATIONS AGENCIES / ABORIGINAL COMMUNITIES Ms. Heather Levecque Ministry of Indigenous Relations and Reconciliation 160 Bloor Street East, 9th Floor Toronto ON M7A 2E6 CA Mr. Franklin Paibomsai Whitefish River First Nation P.O. Box A 46 Bay of Islands Road Birch Island ON P0P 1A0 CA 705-285-4335 705-285-4532 [email protected] Mr. Angus Toulouse Chief Executive Officer Northshore Tribal Council P.O. Box 28 473 Highway 17 W Cutler ON P0P 1B0 CA 705-844-2340 705-844-2563 [email protected] Chief Ted Roque Chief Wahnapitae First Nation P.O. Box 1119 259 Taighwenini Trail Road Capreol ON P0M 1H0 CA 705-858-0610 705-858-5570 [email protected] Sudbury Métis Council 260 Alder Street, Upstairs Sudbury ON P3C 5P4 CA 705-671-9855 Métis Nation of Ontario Head Office 500 Old St. Patrick Street, Unit 3 Ottawa ON K1N 9G4 CA 613-798-1488 613-722-4225 [email protected] Chief Edward (Steven) Miller Atikameksheng Anishnawbek 25 Reserve Road Naughton ON P0M 2M0 CA 705-692-3651 705-692-5010 [email protected] LOCAL AGENCIES Mr. Curtis Thompson City of Greater Sudbury, Infrastructure Services 200 Brady Street Sudbury ON P3A 5P3 CA Mr. Perry Sarvas Simon Lake Community Stewardship Group P.O. Box 511 Naughton ON P0M 2M0 CA Ms. Lyse-Anne Papineau Conseil Scolaire Catholique Du Nouvel Ontario 201, rue Jogues Sudbury ON P3C 5L7 CA Mr. Jody Cameron Sudbury Catholic District School Board 217 Niemi Road Lively ON P3Y 1G3 CA Mr. Gord Santalo Rainbow District School Board 69 Young Street Sudbury ON P3E 3G5 CA Ms. Linda Heron Vermilion River Stewardship 379 Ronka Rd. Worthington ON P0M 3H0 CA Ms. Judy Sewell Drinking Water Source Protection Coordinator Conservation Sudbury / Nickel District Conservation Authority 199 Larch Street Suite 401, 4th Floor Sudbury ON P3E 5P9 CA (705) 674-5249 (705) 674-7939 [email protected] Ms. Lesley Flowers Greater Sudbury Watershed Alliance 403 Flowers Road Whitefish ON P0M 3E0 CA 705-866-2312 [email protected] Ms. Jennifer Babin-Fenske Coordinator of Earthcare Sudbury Initiatives City of Greater Sudbury 200 Brady Street Tom Davies Square Sudbury ON P3A 5P3 CA 705-647-4455 x 4398 jennifer.babin‐[email protected] Ms. Paddy Buchanan City of Greater Sudbury