Replacing Freezing Global Gas lost fi ngers in place Turbine News
THE MAGAZINE OF ASME
SPLIT DECISIONS
E iciencies improve when the engineer and project manager see eye to eye.
VOL.133/NO.8 AUGUST 2011 | WWW.MEMAGAZINE.ORG Great engineering requires ingenuity . So does great insurance.
Life Happens! 5IBUTXIZ"4.&TFUVQUIFQFBDFPGNJOE The ASME Group Disability QSPUFDUJPOPGGFSFEUISPVHIUIF"4.&(SPVQ%JTBCJMJUZ Income Insurance Plan *ODPNF*OTVSBODF1MBOwUPIFMQHJWFZPVBTPMJETBGFUZ Plan features include: OFUBHBJOTUBQPTTJCMFGJOBODJBMIBSETIJQSFTVMUJOHGSPNB EJTBCMJOHJOKVSZPSJMMOFTT r High-value monthly bene ts up to $7,500.00 r#FOFàUTBSFOUUJFEUPBKPCPSFNQMPZFS "TBO"4.&NFNCFS ZPVIBWFUIJTWBMVBCMFPQQPSUVOJUZ HJWJOHZPVNPSFáFYJCJMJUZXJUIQPUFOUJBM UPIFMQQSPUFDUZPVSGJOBODJBMGVUVSFXJUIUIJTQMBOEFTJHOFE DBSFFSDIBOHFT TQFDJGJDBMMZGPSFOHJOFFSJOHQSPGFTTJPOBMT HJWJOHyou the r#FOFàUTDBOCFQBJEQFSDFOUUBY GSFFXIFOZPVQBZQSFNJVNTZPVSTFMG GMFYJCJMJUZUPUBJMPSMFWFMTPGDPWFSBHFUPNFFUZPVSPXO DJSDVNTUBODFT*OBEEJUJPO ZPVBMTPIBWFUIFBEWBOUBHF PGHSPVQSBUFTUPIFMQLFFQDPTUTBTBGGPSEBCMFBTQPTTJCMF
Is your insurance ready to help protect your income?
For information on features, costs, eligibility, renewability, limitations, exclusions and terms of coverage, call 1-800-289-ASME (2763) or visit www.asmeinsurance.com/disability
This program is administered by Marsh U.S. Consumer, a service of Seabury & Smith, Inc., d/b/a in CA Seabury & Smith Insurance Program Management. CA Ins. Lic. #0633005. AR Ins. Lic. #245544. Coverage may vary or may not be available in all states. The Group Disability Insurance plan is underwritten by New York Life Insurance Company, 51 Madison Ave., New York, NY 10010 52339 (8/11) on Policy Form G12501-2 ©2011 Seabury & Smith, Inc. me.hotims.com/34756-01 or circle 01
!""#$ % &%' ! "%( ) *+%# % , % %-- ' %
' ) , % %% ) ) '%%' % ( + :/;7 , ) - %7 %!%! $ (
$
"% ' ,! 1 %'!37
. " '/ - , + *00123 " ;& 4 056 780193 ' 7 "*7:''! ', % - 4 , "* %.+ 0 % % " - ! % 7 ' ( )*(-!)468
,# ) ) ) +( $
" ' ' ( )*(-).. ( )*(- !546 ' ( )*(-!9468 (# ! / 01 23 ) 7) -) ) ) ( + ) ! ! ! ' ( )*( " ! $ %+, ' + ( ! ' ( )*(-!4/ ' ( )*(-(46.8 ( )*(-!)566/
# $%&&" !%
02
!"# #$%$# &' #()*&&$&&+! $# me.hotims.com/34756-02 or circle 02 ,+$!+-&$!,$#%'. #/ features Focus on Engineering Management 30 SERVING TWO MASTERS It takes judgment and thought to balance the ethical engineer and ON THE COVER capable project manager. 08 VOLUME11 133/NO.8 By Brian Porter 35 PATENT TROLLS Even those who make and sell nothing are devising new ways to make money from U.S. patent laws. By Kirk Teska 39 EVERYDAY FINGERS Prosthetic limbs have been around a long time; but until Dan Didrick came along, working artificial fingers didn’t exist. By Jean Thilmany
Focus on Plant Engineering 42 ALTERNATIVE MEASURES When instruments can’t reach the pump, there’s another way to go with the flow. By Ray Beebe 44 A FREEZE IN TIME 6 Editorial An ASME post-construction standard leads 8 a refinery maintenance team through an Letters unfamiliar but efficient repair. 12 News & Notes By Jaan Taagepera and Nathan Tyson 16 Washington Window 48 A PUMP WAR STORY: 18 Global Window BACK TO BASICS By Gary Wamsley 20 Computing 23 Software Exchange 72 INPUT OUTPUT 24 Awards Show Off Robot Advances Tech Focus By Alan S. Brown Fluid Handling & Fluid Power 61 ME Bookshelf
departments ME-Vol51-3-Aug2011_ME-Vol51-3-Aug2011 6/28/11 10:49 PM Page 49 62 New Products
Special supplement 64 !"#$%!& $'( )*+(*,*- Resource File %!&$'( )**./! 0)* %!&$'(*.&!,*., "#$ 2*!3 !"#$ !)*,.)*.!* , '())* ,1+*! 0* )*+(*,* %!&$'( - ! IGTI’S GLOBAL GAS !" ## $ '( " # $%## %& #$!% &'(!($ & )& * )+ #, - ## 67 . - 0 ! & !)*+ ,!)'" Positions Open )) ( 0 0 1 / ))+ , 0 # & 0 . . 3 ' !# !- # 0 " # $%## % ! . 2 0 $# % & 4 "'(!$)!)"... & 4 0 0& TURBINE NEWS 0 0 5 5 # 60 +!""$) " # %& $%## % & 4 *(* $ !&!/!,!&!)' 0 69 '$. 0)1 )1$)!! $# $ '$.&& 0 & Ad Index ,!%*" 7 ###& - 0 0 # ,0 0 0& &,$)1,$,$$'2 0 0 0 +$-+'+& ,0 # )-)'$)!*" & 49+60 $)! )1$)! # % 0 89* 0 0 0 $!" # & ! , 0 ! " : 0 0 , ; , " " # $ 0 +&$)'$)" < ! , 0 $ %& ' 70 )*"'$"$)! 0 # 0 %! & % % $-+' )1$)! ( " ) & ' ( 0 0 # = ASME News !-()12%*" $ #& )! ! & B@B * +, - +. 0 0> ! * & ( *(* ?@@+@AA✲ !%!-()$- $ * & ' C && &&$''!! ++$-!" ",
DIDRICK MEDICAL INC.
2 MECHANICAL ENGINEERING | August 2011
ß ß ß ß ß ß
-RE ,1$BBPHLQGG &65 7RP&O\QH &OLHQW 1REOH 2SHUDWRU/7 'HVF6WUDWDV\V 3UHY2S /LYH [ 0DF FDSV 7ULP [ 3UHY0DF %OHHG[ 'DWH B30 3URRI NOW I THINK IN 3D. ANDMYDESIGNSJUSTKEEPGETTINGBETTER.
With our Dimension ® 3D Printer, I know my model will represent my idea exactly. And that makes it easier to improve my design with each iteration. Our Dimension is right here in the office, and that helps us get our products to market faster. The Dimension models we create are made in ABS, so they’re tough and durable. Leases start at only $275 a month, or you can buy a printer for under $15,000, so they’re also really affordable. Overall, Dimension gives me an amazing sense of freedom—and creativity.
Find out more at dimensionprinting.com/me4
Prices applicable in the United States. Additional options, shipping, applicable taxes and/or duties not included. ©2011 Stratasys, Inc.
me.hotims.com/34756-03 or circle 03
ß ß ß ß ß ß
-RE ,1$BBPHLQGG &65 7RP&O\QH &OLHQW 1REOH 2SHUDWRU/7 'HVF6WUDWDV\V 3UHY2S /LYH [ 0DF FDSV 7ULP [ 3UHY0DF %OHHG[ 'DWH B30 3URRI from the M.E.
90 years ago vault this month , August 1921 what our community is saying online
The Infl uence Exerted by the Automobile Re: The FDA is opening a dialogue on nanotechnology by publishing proposed on the Machine-Tool Industry guidelines on how the agency will identify nanomaterials in FDA-regulated products. By Henry J. Hinde president and general manager of the Toledo Machine and Tool Co. If this initiative were to be correlated with the joint efforts of existing worldwide The art of producing sheet-metal stampings from a fl at standardization entities, we soon would sheet while cold has made marked progress in recent years, have appropriate regulations in this “ and many articles are now made of sheet metal which were challenging area. formerly produced by casting or forging, or in a lathe, milling machine, drill press, or at the bench. Re: President Barack Obama is making a push to train 10,000 new American Forming and stamping operations especially have in many engineers a year. classes of work become very complex, and the art of draw- ing sheet metals, stimulated by the enormous demand of the Major engineering companies will automobile industry in particular, calling for most intricate continue to outsource . Having a bunch of new engineers won't help any unless there shapes, has reached a state of perfection hardly imagined is some sort of domestic policy to keep possible a few years ago. The results achieved by the ingenuity engineering services domestic. of the present-day press and die designers, and to no small degree also by the metallurgist, who comes into consideration Does he mean that he will retrain the through his improvements of the physical qualities of the thousands of engineers that are out of metals used, are indeed revelations in economy of production, work or in temporary jobs while they look strength of stamped articles, and the absolute interchange- for jobs in their fi eld? Or does he mean that ability and beauty of appearance of the fi nished products. ... he will fi nd work for the 2008, 2009, and 2010 graduates that are looking? At the same time the economical production of motor cars was made possible solely on account of the ability of the press Our modern culture does not promote and die manufacturers to successfully control the fl ow of the (or even value) the work ethic that is cold sheet metal into certain forms and shapes. required to earn a degree in mechanical engineering. The obsession with entertainment, computer games, and Editor’s note: The author was one of several who delivered” papers materialism has deceived many young on the subject at the Spring Meeting, held under the auspices of the people into thinking that adult life will ASME Machine Shop Practice Division. A selection of the papers was be easy —a simple extrapolation of the published in the August issue. carefree indulgences of youth. Much of what made our country great (and I believe will continue) is our entrepreneurial ethic and the environment to incubate and create new opportunities . THIS MONTH IN ASME.ORG I would propose that encouraging students What’s your engineering degree worth, and how much to harness the DIY spirit that, I believe, are your peers earning? Find out in the 2011 Engineering is having a recent renaissance will lead to capable engineers who can create new Income and Salary Survey conducted by ASME and ASCE. technology, new businesses, and ultimately jobs and demand for engineers —and new Hydrodynamic models of large bodies of fresh water may engineering fi elds! be helpful to the public in understanding ecosystems and how pollution affects them. From ASME LinkedIn groups
ON.FB.ME/MEMAGAZINE | MEMAGAZINEBLOG.ORG | MEMAGAZINE.ORG | ASME.ORG
Mechanical Engineering (ISSN 0025-6501) is published monthly by The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Three Park Avenue, New York, NY 10016-5990. Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and additional mailing offi ces. POST- MASTER: Send address changes to Mechanical Engineering, c/o The American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 22 Law Drive, Box 2300, Fairfi eld, NJ 07007-2300. Return Canadian undeliverable addresses to P.O. BOX 1051, Fort Erie, On, L2A 6C7. PRICES: To members, annually $32 for initial membership subscription, single copy $7; subscription price to nonmembers available upon request. COPYRIGHT © 2011 by The American Society of Mechanical Engineers. Canadian Goods & Services Tax Registration #126148048. Printed in U.S.A. Authorization to photocopy material for internal or personal use under circumstances not falling within the fair use provisions of the Copyright Act is granted by ASME to libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Transactional Reporting Service, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Request for special permission or bulk copying should be addressed to Reprints/Permissions Department.
4 MECHANICAL ENGINEERING | August 2011 Reduce Your Plant’s Energy Consumption Call in the Baldor IBE Team
In today’s business climate, virtually every manufacturing plant is searching for ways to reduce energy consumption and lower operating costs. With the new change in federal minimum energy efficiency requirements (Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007), now is the time to survey and replace inefficient motors. By identifying older, inefficient motors and PT components and replacing them with BaldorReliance® Super-E® Premium Efficient motors and Dodge® gearing and bearing products, you can potentially Each IBE report includes: You can expect immediate and long realize huge energy savings. term benefits from your IBE survey: Your potential energy savings Energy savings
$ 2500 A detailed list of your current products in service Improved uptime through better 2000 system and process reliability
Continuous 1500 Use Your expected payback/timing Simplified purchasing and 1000 Repair/replace comparisons inventory management 80 Hrs Per Wk 500
40 Hrs Inventory/spares analysis Product availability DOLLAR SAVINGS PER YEAR Per Wk 0 $.06 $.07 $.08 $.09 $.10 $.11 $.12 $.13 $.14 $.15 POWER COST PER KWH Local rebate and incentive If you’re struggling with rising energy program details costs and consumption, schedule an IBE survey today. Plus, an Installed Base Evaluation (IBE) provides the end user It’s an easy call with a big the framework for a motor payback. management system and overall system performance, as (864) 281-2100 well as Operational Equipment [email protected] Effectiveness (OEE) initiatives.
©2011 Baldor Electric Company baldor.com me.hotims.com/34756-04 or circle 04 BUILDING COLLABORATION Editor-in-Chief John G. Falcioni
Executive Editor CONGRATULATIONS! YOU’RE and part voodoo. Harry Hutchinson HIRED. Now you’re in charge of a A recent Harvard Business Review Associate Editors large engineering team. It’s the job article stresses that getting every- Alan S. Brown, Jean Thilmany, you always wanted. one on your team to share a purpose Jeffrey Winters You hold an engineering degree does not come simply from a corpo- Electronic Publishing Editor from a good school, and you have 15 rate statement, or even from a single Benedict Bahner years of excellent appraisals under charismatic leader. It comes from a Art & Production Designer editorial your belt. You’re a good engineer, combination of often intangible ele- Teresa M. Carboni and you’ve had plenty of experience ments that create a long-lasting and Director, Advertising Sales on how not to manage from all those e/ ective work culture. and Publishing Development boneheaded bosses you’ve had along One way to do that is to collabo- Nicholas J. Ferrari the way. The ones you swore had no rate at all levels of the enterprise. Marketing and Promotion Manager clue how to manage people. You can’t expect people on your Anthony Asiaghi The H.R. manager who gave you team to get along if you don’t engage Classifi ed and Mailing List Manager the good news about the 18 percent in similar behavior yourself. (212) 591-7534 raise that comes with the job tells The HBR article recounts the story you the fi rst thing you’ve got to do is of Microsoft’s ill-fated tablet com- Circulation Coordinator Marni A. Rice focus on getting the technical team puter that could have preempted and the project management folks Apple’s iPad by more than a decade Managing Director, Publishing & Unit Support to see eye-to-eye. Upper manage- —if it hadn’t been for internal com- Philip V. DiVietro ment, she says, is afraid of another peting divisions at Microsoft that “Deepwater Horizon thing”—a new conspired to kill the project. Micro- Online catchphrase in today’s engineering soft had not learned to collaborate www.memagazine.org (212) 591-7783; fax (212) 591-7841 reality for a failed system. with itself. E-mail: [email protected] “Good luck, don’t mess up,” she Certainly inciting collaborative says as you leave her o, ce. behaviors among workers is saddled The American Society of Mechanical Engineers with many complex dimensions President Victoria A. Rockwell Managing people, under the best President-Nominee Marc W. Goldsmith of circumstances, is hard enough, that include personal convictions, Past President Robert T. Simmons Governors Richard C. Benson, Betty L. Bowersox, but navigating between those cultural values, and the particular Julio Guerrero, Said Jahanmir, Robert N. Pangborn, concerned with safety and those on enterprise’s operating norms. But Thomas D. Pestorius, Edmund J. Seiders, J. Robert the other side of the fl oor who push when it comes to complex systems, Sims Jr., Charla K. Wise for e, ciency is even harder. Over “Demands to sacrifi ce performance Executive Director the past 50 years, engineers have are out of the question,” Porter says. Thomas G. Loughlin realized they must balance budgets “Learn from the past; use it today, Deputy Executive Director and meet business demands, says for a successful future.” Michael K. Weis Brian Porter, who we commissioned Now that you’ve been on the job a Secretary and Treasurer to write this month’s cover story, few months you realize that managing Wilbur J. Marner “Serving Two Masters.” The require- teams isn’t as easy you thought. You Assistant Secretary ments to meet technical needs such also realize the importance of collabo- Warren R. Leonard as specifi cations, public safety, and ration in the process. Not to put more Senior Vice Presidents Centers Clark McCarrell reliability, and the business require- pressure on you, but the stakes are Standards & Certifi cation Kenneth R. Balkey ments such as budget and schedule high. Failure is not an option. Institutes Dilip R. Ballal Knowledge & Community Thomas G. Libertiny “are frequently confl icting in na- Strategic Management Stacey Swisher Harnetty ture, even when they theoretically ME Editorial Advisory Board serve one another,” Porter says. John G. Falcioni, Editor-in-Chief Robert E. Nickell, Chairman; Harry Armen; Getting workers to collaborate falcionij)asme.org Leroy S. Fletcher; Richard J. Goldstein; Thomas G. Libertiny e/ ectively is part science, part art, twitter.com/johnfalcioni
For reprints, contact Edward Kane, (866) 879-9144, ext.131 [email protected]
Opinions expressed in Mechanical Engineering magazine do not necessarily refl ect the views of ASME.
6 MECHANICAL ENGINEERING | August 2011 COMSOL CONFERENCE BOSTON 2011 OCTOBER 13-15 13-15 Join us for the COMSOL Conference 2011 The premier event for multiphysics simulation GOLD SPONSORS Discover new multiphysics modeling strategies