The Medieval Manichee. a Study of the Christian Dualist Heresy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Medieval Manichee. a Study of the Christian Dualist Heresy THE MEDIEVAL MANICHEE THE MEDIEVAL MANICHEE A Study of the Christian Dualist Heresy by STEVEN RVNCIMAN .CAMBRIDGE " UNIVERSITY PRESS PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK http://www.cup.cam.ac.uk 40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011-4211, USA http://www.cup.org IO Stamford Road, Oakleigh, Melbourne 3166, Australia Ruiz de Alarcon 13, 28014 Madrid, Spain © Cambridge University Press 1947 This book is in copyright. Subject co statutory exception and co the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any pare may cake place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 1947 Reprinted 1955 Reissued 1982 Reprinted 1984, 1988, 1991, 1996, 1999 Library of Congress catalogue card number: 82-4123 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Runciman, Steven The medieval Manichee. I. Dualism (Religion) I. Tide 273 BL.218 ISBN o 521 06166 o hardback ISBN o 521 28926 2 paperback Transferredto digital printing 2003 Foreword N the following pages I have attempted to trace the history of the Dualist Tradition in Christianity from its Gnostic beginnings I to its final florescence in the later Middle Ages. Theologically speaking, the title which I have given to the book is unjustifiable; for Christian Dualism and Manichaeism were . two distinct and separate religions. But to the ordinary·Medieval churchman, in the East as in the West, all Dualists were Manichaean; and I have used a name that they would · have fowid intelligible and natural. And indeed in many ways this popular misnomer was reasonable, for the Christian Dualists, though they would never have acknowledged Mani's system, were fundamentallynearer to it than ever they were to Medieval or Modem Christianity. I hope therefore that the inaccuracy willbe forgiven me, and that no one will open this book hoping to findin it an exhaustive account of those true Manichaeans who lingered on into the Middle Ages in: the far-off recesses of Turkestan. The recent circumstances of the world and certain personal handicaps have prevented me fromhaving access to certain material that I should have liked to consult and fromhandling more fully one or two points on which I have touched. I must ask for indulgence for such omissions. I do not, however, believe that they affect the main argument. A certain unevenness of treatment in the various chapters has been forcedupon me by the nature of the evidence. If, for example, I have dealt scantily with the theology of the Bosnian Patarenes and amply with their political history, it is because we know practically nothing of the former, whereas the latter provides the key to the long existence of the church. On the other hand, it would have been possible, fromthe plentiful records at our disposal, to give a far fuller accowit of the French Cathars. But much of the material there is redwidant. I have therefore, to keep some propor­ tion in the book, selected from it what I considered to be essential and relevant to the story. V Vl Foreword At the end of the volume I give a bibliography of the books that I have consulted. There are hardlyany booksthat treatthe historyof the Tradition as a whole. But I am indebted to many works on various aspects of it. For my chapter on the Paulicians, I have made great use of F. C. Conybeare's Key of Truth. I disagree withalmost all of his conclus1ons, but every student of the Armenian Church must be immeasurably grateful to his memory for the work that he did on the sources for its history. For the Bogomils, I owe much to the studies of the Bulgarian historian, Ivanov, on Bogomil literature. For the Cathars, the volumes of M. Guiraud are invaluable. I much regret that I had written the text of my chapter before the second volume of his History of the Inquisition was published. I should like to mentionalso the personal help and encouragement that I have had from Professor Henri Gregoire. I have also had the advantage of many helpfulcriticisms and suggestions from Prince D. Obolensky. My thanksare alsodue to the Syndicsof the CambridgeUniversity Press for their unfailing kindness. S.R. Athens 1946 Since this book was first published several important works on medieval Dualism have appeared. I give a list of them on page 199, as a supplement to the Bibliography, and recommend them to the reader who wishes to followup later research on some of the points covered here. S.R. 28 December 1954 Preface to 1982 reissue In the last few decades there has been a vast increase in the number of scholars interested in medieval European heresy. Since this work first appeared in 1947 numerous books and articles have appeared on the same theme, and several of the original sources have been re-edited. I have added to my bibliography a list of the works that seem to me to be of major importance. This book attempts to show that there was a conscious Dualist tradition based on Gnostic foundations which spread across Europe fromWestern Asia to findits fullestexpression amongst the Cathars of Southern France and of Italy. I think that the argument is still valid, though some of the details have been questioned. As regards the Paulicians, an important work by Dr Garsoian, based on a vast knowledge of Armenian sources, argues that the Paulicians were not in fact Dualists. I do not think that she makes her point fully but that her researches show that amongst the heterodox Armenians who were apt to be lumped together as Paulicians there were sects whose doctrines were not as expressly Dualist as those of the Paulicians living along the Byzantine frontier, whose heresy the Greek sources prove without doubt. For the Bogomils Professor Obolensky's work, published in 1948, remains, I think, the best account. Several useful works have appeared since then, notably Professor Angelov's on the Bogomils in Bulgaria, dealing more with the social than the theological aspect of the movement. The Bosnian Church remains a subject of contro­ versy. There are scholars who regard it, not as a Dualist church but, rather, a schismatic church which developed its own characteristics, which were not necessarily heretical. I believe that it may have modified its doctrines in its later years, after the Cathar movement in the West, with which it was undoubtedly in touch, had been suppressed. There is a full discussion of the problem in F. Sanjek's Les Chretiens bosniaques et le mouvement cathare. He believes the Church to have been Dualist. VII f vm Prefaf to 1982 reissue The number of works produced in recent years on the Cathar heresy in Western Europe is vast, ranging from books that deal with medieval heresy in general to such detailed studies as Le Roy Ladurie's account of life in a heretic village from 1294 to 1324, based on the local records. Western scholars tend to stress the existence of a Dualist tradition in the West throughout the Dark Ages and to regard the Balkan influence on the heretical movement, which no one now denies, as coming in rather late in the story. Certainly a Western Dualist tradition persisted from early times; but I believe that it was continually reinforced from the East, through Italy, where connections with the East were always maintained. The later connections of the Cathars with the Bogomils are admirably demon­ strated in the notes of Edina Bozoky' s new edition of the Secret Book of the Cathars, which also emphasizes the connection of Bogomil­ Cathar literature with the literature of the earlier Gnostics. It shows, perhaps, rash arrogance for an author to reissue a book published some thirty-five years ago. I am grateful to Cambridge University Press for taking this risk and for its habitual helpful courtesy. S.R. January 1982 Contents CHAPTER I PAGE I Introduction Heresy-Persecution-Propaganda CHAPTER II PAGE 5 The Gnostic Background The Problem of Evil-Valentine and Early Gnosticism-Marcion-The fantastic Gnostics-Bardaisan-Mani and the Manichaeans-The Mon­ tanists-Paul of Samosata and Adoptionism-The Messalians CHAPTER III PAGE 26 The Paulicians I. Armenian Christianity-Messalians and Borborites---Other sects. II. John of Otzun and the first Paulicians-Paulician history from Greek sources-Criticism of its dates-The Persecution of the Paulicians­ Paulician colonies in Europe-Later Paulician history. III. The name Paulician-Paulician doctrines-The Thonraki,not the same as the Paulicians -The Key of Truth. IV. The origins of Paulicianism CHAPTER IV PAGE 63 The Bogomils I. Bulgarian Christianity-Paulicians in the Balkans-Social conditions. II. Pope Bogomil-Bogomil expansion-The Schism in Bogomilstvo­ Persecution in Constantinople. III. Bogornil doctrine-Cosmas's descrip­ tion-The descriptionof Euthymius Zigabenus-Other accounts-Bogomil literature-Pope Jeremiah-Bogomil folklore. IV. The origins of Bogo­ milstvo-Paulicians and Messalians CHAPTER V PAGE 94 The Patarenes I. The later Bogomils-In Constantinople-In Bulgaria-Persecution. II. Bogomils or Babuni in Serbia. III. Bogomils or Patarenes in Dioclea and Bosnia-Bosnian history, Patarene history-Patarenes' decline with Turkish conquest CHAPTER VI PAGE 116 The Cathars I. Heresy in Western Europe-Dualism in France-Gnostic tendencies­ Churches in England and Germany-In Italy-In Provence. II. Heretics in the Languedoc-Part played by Nobility-State of Catholic Church­ Catholic. missions-St Dominic-Peter of Castelnau's murder and the IX X Contents Albigensian Crusad�The Inquisition-The extinction of the Cathars. III. Cathar doctrines-Dualism and Monarchianism-Divergent doctrines­ Cathar ceremonies-The Convenenza-The Consolamentum-The Perfect -Cathar fasts-Other ceremonies-Church organization-Was there a Black Pope? IV.
Recommended publications
  • Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of Philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA PORPHYRIANA an OUTLINE of the DEVELOPMENT of LOGIC in BOSNIA AN
    UDK 16 (497.6) Nijaz Ibrulj Faculty of philosophy University of Sarajevo BOSNIA PORPHYRIANA AN OUTLINE OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF LOGIC IN BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA Abstract The text is a drought outlining the development of logic in Bosnia and Herzegovina through several periods of history: period of Ottoman occupation and administration of the Empire, period of Austro-Hungarian occupation and administration of the Monarchy, period of Communist regime and administration of the Socialist Republic and period from the aftermath of the aggression against the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina to this day (the Dayton Bosnia and Herzegovina) and administration of the International Community. For each of the aforementioned periods, the text treats the organization of education, the educational paradigm of the model, status of logic as a subject in the educational system of a period, as well as the central figures dealing with the issue of logic (as researchers, lecturers, authors) and the key works written in each of the periods, outlining their main ideas. The work of a Neoplatonic philosopher Porphyry, “Introduction” (Greek: Eijsagwgh;v Latin: Isagoge; Arabic: Īsāġūğī) , can be seen, in all periods of education in Bosnia and Herze - govina, as the main text, the principal textbook, as a motivation for logical thinking. That gave me the right to introduce the syntagm Bosnia Porphyriana. SURVEY 109 1. Introduction Man taman ṭaqa tazandaqa. He who practices logic becomes a heretic. 1 It would be impossible to elaborate the development of logic in Bosnia
    [Show full text]
  • PRIKAZ/REVIEW Salih Jalimam, KULIN. VELIKI BAN BOSNE
    Adnan HADŽIABDIĆ Sarajevo E-mail: [email protected] Stručni rad/Professional article UDK/UDC:94:929(497.6)“1180/1204“ Jalimam S. (049.3) Salih Jalimam, KULIN. VELIKI BAN BOSNE, Udruženje za zaštitu intelektualnih i kulturnih vrijednosti „Zenica“, Zenica 2019, 249 str. Kao plod dugogodišnjeg rada i istraživanja prof. dr. Saliha Jalimama1, objavljena je knjiga Kulin, veliki ban Bosne. Čitav svoj život Jaliman je posvetio izučavanju historije Bosne i Hercegovine i kao plod svog dugogodišnjeg rada napisao je ovo kapitalno djelo kao sintezu svih dosadašnjih poznatih činjenica o vladavini Kulina, velikog bana Bosne, kako ga autor oslovljava u radu. VIEWS 3 POGLEDI 3 - HISTORICAL HISTORIJSKI Ovim autorskim radom Jalimam je planirao da zaokruži svoj naučno-istraživački rad, ali su ga ozbiljni zdravstveni problemi i smrt, 26. aprila 2019. godine spriječili da dočeka izlazak iz štampe ovog vrijednog naučnog rada. Knjiga Kulin, veliki ban Bosne nastala je prema raspoloživim historijskim izvorima, materijalnim spomenicima kulture i ostacima usmene predaje. Dokumenti, koji su malobrojni, ali i slabo i nedovoljno korišteni pomogli 1 Prof. dr. Salih Jalimam (1951-2019) poznati bosanskohercegovački historičar čije je polje naučnog rada bio srednji vijek. Radio je na više Univerziteta (Tuzli, Zenici, Mostaru). Objavio je preko 150 naučnih radova o Bosni i Hercegovini i preko stotinu prikaza, recenzija, osvrta i dr. Učesnik je mnogih međunarodnih naučnih skupova, simpozija i konferencija. 357 Adnan HADŽIABDIĆ su da se stvori pregled prilika u srednjovjekovnoj državi Bosni. Historijskom metodom interpetiraju se i identifikuju vrijeme vlasti i vladarske moći Kulina, ali se i istovremeno prate i historijski tokovi u susjednim državama i kompariraju sa događajima u bosanskoj državi.
    [Show full text]
  • THE POSAVINA BORDER REGION of CROATIA and BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA: DEVELOPMENT up to 1918 (With Special Reference to Changes in Ethnic Composition)
    THE POSAVINA BORDER REGION OF CROATIA AND BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA: DEVELOPMENT UP TO 1918 (with special reference to changes in ethnic composition) Ivan CRKVEN^I] Zagreb UDK: 94(497.5-3 Posavina)''15/19'':323.1 Izvorni znanstveni rad Primljeno: 9. 9. 2003. After dealing with the natural features and social importance of the Posavina region in the past, presented is the importance of this region as a unique Croatian ethnic territory during the Mid- dle Ages. With the appearance of the Ottomans and especially at the beginning of the 16th century, great ethnic changes oc- cured, primarily due to the expulsion of Croats and arrival of new ethnic groups, mostly Orthodox Vlachs and later Muslims and ethnic Serbs. With the withdrawal of the Ottomans from the Pannonian basin to the areas south of the Sava River and the Danube, the Sava becomes the dividing line creating in its border areas two socially and politically different environments: the Slavonian Military Frontier on the Slavonian side and the Otto- man military-frontier system of kapitanates on the Bosnian side. Both systems had a special influence on the change of ethnic composition in this region. With the withdrawal of the Ottomans further towards the southeast of Europe and the Austrian occu- pation of Bosnia and Herzegovina the Sava River remains the border along which, especially on the Bosnian side, further changes of ethnic structure occured. Ivan Crkven~i}, Ilo~ka 34, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia. E-mail: [email protected] INTRODUCTION The research subject in this work is the border region Posavi- na between the Republic of Croatia and the Republic Bosnia- 293 -Herzegovina.
    [Show full text]
  • Jelena Mrgić-Radojčić Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade RETHINKING the TERRITORIAL DEVELOPMENT of the MEDIEVAL BOSNIAN STATE* In
    ИСТОРИЈСКИ ЧАСОПИС, књ. LI (2004) стр. 43-64 HISTORICAL REVIEW, Vol. LI (2004) pр. 43-64 УДК : 94(497.15) ”04/14” : 929 Jelena Mrgić-Radojčić Faculty of Philosophy Belgrade RETHINKING THE TERRITORIAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE MEDIEVAL BOSNIAN STATE* In many ways, the medieval Bosnian state developed at the cross- roads – between West and East, the Hungarian Kingdom, a predomi- nantly Western European state, and the Serbian Kingdom, under the strong influence of the Byzantine Empire. One may, without any further elaboration, say that Bosnia formed the periphery of both the Byzantine Empire, and Western Europe (first the Frankish and then the Hungarian state). Bosnia was far away from the most important communication line of the Balkans: the valleys of the rivers Morava and Vardar, Via militaris and also those of the rivers Ibar and Sitnica. The axis of the Bosnian state was the valley of the river Bosna, but not of the Drina ill suited for 1 communication with it steep banks and many canyons. * The author wishes to thank Prof. J. Koder, University of Vienna, Prof. S. Ćirković, Prof. M. Blagojević, and Prof. S. Mišić of Belgrade University for their usuful com- ments and corrections of the following text. 1J. Ferluga, Vizantiska uprava u Dalmaciji, (Byzantine Administration in Dalmatia), Beograd 1957; J. Koder, Der Lebensraum der Byzantiner. Historisch-geographischer Abriß ihres Mittelalterlichen Staates im östlichen Mittelmeerraum, Byzantische Geschichtsschreiber 1, Graz-Wien-Köln 1984, 20012, 13-21, passim; S. Ćirković, Bosna i Vizantija (Bosnia and Byzantium), Osam Stotina godina povelje bana Kulina, Sarajevo 1989, 23-35. Even though Bosnia was situated on the »cross-roads«, it is unacceptable to depict it as being “more of a no-man's-land than a meeting ground between the two worlds“, as J.V.A.
    [Show full text]
  • Manichaean Networks
    The Manichaean Church in Kellis Nag Hammadi and Manichaean Studies Editors Jason D. BeDuhn Dylan M. Burns Johannes van Oort Editorial Board A. D. Deconick – W.-P. Funk – I. Gardner S. N. C. Lieu – H. Lundhaug – A. Marjanen – L. Painchaud N. A. Pedersen – T. Rasimus – S. G. Richter M. Scopello – J. D. Turner† – F. Wursy Volume 100 The titles published in this series are listed at brill.com/nhms The Manichaean Church in Kellis By Håkon Fiane Teigen LEIDEN | BOSTON This is an open access title distributed under the terms of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license, which permits any non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided no alterations are made and the original author(s) and source are credited. Further information and the complete license text can be found at https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ The terms of the CC license apply only to the original material. The use of material from other sources (indicated by a reference) such as diagrams, illustrations, photos and text samples may require further permission from the respective copyright holder. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Teigen, Håkon Fiane, author. Title: The Manichaean church in Kellis / by Håkon Fiane Teigen. Description: Leiden ; Boston : Brill, [2021] | Series: Nag Hammadi and Manichaean studies, 0929–2470 ; volume 100 | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2021008227 (print) | LCCN 2021008228 (ebook) | ISBN 9789004459762 (hardback) | ISBN 9789004459779 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Manichaeism. | Manichaeans—Egypt—Kellis (Extinct city) | Kellis (Extinct city)—Civilization. Classification: LCC BT1410 .T45 2021 (print) | LCC BT1410 (ebook) | DDC 299/.932—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021008227 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021008228 Typeface for the Latin, Greek, and Cyrillic scripts: “Brill”.
    [Show full text]
  • Flood Disaster Situation Report 25Th May 2014
    United Nations / Ujedinjene nacije / Уједињене нације Office of the Resident Coordinator / Ured rezidentnog koordinatora / Уред резидентног координатора Bosnia and Herzegovina / Bosna i Hercegovina / Босна и Херцеговина Bosnia and Herzegovina – Flood Disaster Situation Report 25th May 2014 HIGHLIGHTS/KEY PRIORITIES: o Most water levels went down and water levels of Sava river basin are decreasing slowly, at a pace of less than 1cm / hour. o Mainly rural areas around Samac, Brcko, Orasje and Bijeljina are still covered with water; response activities ongoing and no life saving activities o Doboj, Olovo, Zavidovici, Zenica, Maglaj are intensively working on disinfection, sanitation, and cleaning o Around a 3,000 landslides have been reported. More than 1,000 landslides have been reported in Tuzla Canton alone. o Total number of reported casualties still cannot be confirmed (23 and in some reports up to 33) o Estimated 40,000 people have been displaced (ref. coordinators at Entity and District levels – shared through MoS Coordination Centre and the Red Cross). Estimated number of people in collective centers is between 2,600 and 3,000 o Elektroprivreda BiH reported that the electrical power grid is still severely affected in some areas (areas of Zenica-Doboj Canton, Doboj, Samac) and is being restored. o BH MAC reports that Doboj, Maglaj, Olovo, Una-Sana Canton and Posavina regions at the basin of Bosna, Krivaja and Usora rivers have so far been identified as mine and UXOs suspected areas: . Ammo depot in Orasje affected and presents a threat. BH MAC and UNDP are updating maps on mine locations. o Border crossing in Bosanski Samac, Brcko and Raca are still closed for traffic.
    [Show full text]
  • Greg Goswell, “Early Readers of the Gospels: the KEPHALAIA and TITLOI of Codex Alexandrinus”
    [JGRChJ 6 (2009) 134-74] EARLY READERS OF THE GOSPELS: THE KEPHALAIA AND TITLOI OF CODEX ALEXANDRINUS Greg Goswell Presbyterian Theological College, Melbourne, Australia For the New Testament, the oldest system of capitulation (division into chapters) known to us is that preserved in Codex Vaticanus (B 03) of the fourth century.1 I will use the notation V1, V2 etc. to refer to chapters of Vaticanus. Even a cursory examination of Vaticanus is enough to reveal that the divisions represent an evaluation of what are the sense units of the biblical passages. Each successive chapter in the Gospels is numbered using Greek letters written in red ink to the left of the columns. Capitulation is further indicated by a space of (usually) two letters at the close of the preceding chapter, a short horizontal line (paragraphos) above the first letter of the first whole line of the new chapter marking the close of the preceding paragraph, and sometimes by a letter protruding into the left margin (ekthesis).2 The system of 1. H.K. McArthur, ‘The Earliest Divisions of the Gospels’, in Studia Evangelica, III. 2 (ed. F.L. Cross; Texte und Untersuchungen, 88; Berlin: Akademie Verlag, 1964), pp. 266-72. After rejecting three other possible explanations, McAr- thur suggests that the divisions were used for citation purposes, especially in aca- demic circles. For alternate systems of chapter division in Greek versions of the Old Testament, see Robert Devreesse, Introduction à l’étude des manuscrits grecs (Paris: Klincksieck, 1954), pp. 139-41. The major divisions in Vaticanus are called chapters, while those in Alexandrinus, which are the basis of the standard divisions used in Nestle-Aland (Novum Testamentum Graece [27th Edition] = NTG27) are called kephalaia.
    [Show full text]
  • BOSNA. PODATCI O ZEMLJOPISU I POVIESTI BOSNE I HERCEGOVINE Sa Slikama U Tekstu
    Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. USPOMENI I. FR. JUKIĆA PRVOGA BUDIOCA NARODNE SVIESTI u B O S N I. Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. Vjekoslav Klaić BOSNA ©MH 2010. PREDGOVOR IVad mi je odbor „Matice Hrvatske" u srpnju ove godine povjerio, da napišem zemljopis i poviest Bosne za hrvatsko obćinstvo, najvećom se voljom prihvatili posla, i to tim radje, što je već punih sedam godina upravo Bosna bila najmilijim predmetom mojih privatnih studija. Naumili napisati djelo, gdje bi najveći trud uložio u samu poviest te liepe hrvatske zemlje, i to na temelju mnogobrojnih novijih izvora, što jih izdadoše Miklošić, Pucić, Šafafik, Theiner, Rački, Ljubić, Makušev i neki magjarski historici. Nadao sam se, da ću u ovom djelu koješta dopuniti, što bijaše nepoznato starijim piscem o Bosni, kanoti Schimeku, Engelu i Jukiću, a možda štogod i izpraviti, što su jedno­ strano shvatili neki noviji povjestnici, a napose Rus MajkoAL Ciela knjiga imala je iznositi 15 štampanih tabaka. Pišuć medjutim knjigu započeli geografijom, a ta se preko moje volje tako raztegnu, da mi napokon neostade ni vremena ni prostora za samu historiju. U toj me ne­ volji pomogne odbor „Matice Hrvatske" odredivši, da se za ovu godinu kano prvi svezak izdade samo zemljopis Bosne; a poviest Bosne da napišem nešto obsežnije za buduću godinu, te će se ovaj dio mojega rukopisa izdati kano drugi svezak djela o Bosni. Pri sastavljanju zemljopisa Bosne uzeli si za temelj slično djelce neumornoga franjevca I. Fr. Jukića, koje je doduše već pred četvrt stoljeća svj tlo ugledalo, ali ipak i danas još mnogo vriedi.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Impacts of Emigration
    On behalf of the European Commission DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion Social Impact of Emigration and Rural-Urban Migration in Central and Eastern Europe Final Country Report Bosnia and Herzegovina April 2012 Authors: Zehra Kačapor-Džihić Nermin Oruč Neither the European Commission nor any person acting on behalf of the Commission may be held responsible for the use that may be made of the information contained in this publication. Social Impact of Emigration and Rural-Urban Migration in Central and Eastern Europe VT/2010/001 Table of Contents Acronyms ............................................................................................................................. 4 1. Socio-Economic and Political Overview ..................................................................... 5 2. Main emigration and internal migration trends and patterns ....................................... 6 2.1. Main emigration trends ............................................................................................ 6 2.1.1. Conflict-induced emigration in the period 1992-1995 ........................................... 7 2.1.2. Post-war return migration ..................................................................................... 7 2.1.3. Voluntary migration of the 21st Century ................................................................ 7 2.1.4. Data on the stock of migrants and main destinations ........................................... 8 2.2. Main internal migration trends................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Studies and Sources in Islamic Art and Architecture
    STUDIES AND SOURCES IN ISLAMIC ART AND ARCHITECTURE SUPPLEMENTS TO MUQARNAS Sponsored by the Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts. VOLUME IX PREFACING THE IMAGE THE WRITING OF ART HISTORY IN SIXTEENTH-CENTURY IRAN BY DAVID J. ROXBURGH BRILL LEIDEN • BOSTON • KÖLN 2001 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Roxburgh, David J. Prefacing the image : the writing of art history in sixteenth-century Iran / David J. Roxburgh. p. cm. — (Studies and sources in Islamic art and architecture. Supplements to Muqarnas, ISSN 0921 0326 ; v. 9) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 9004113762 (alk. papier) 1. Art, Safavid—Historiography—Sources. 2. Art, Islamic—Iran– –Historiography—Sources. 3. Art criticism—Iran—History—Sources. I. Title. II. Series. N7283 .R69 2000 701’.18’095509024—dc21 00-062126 CIP Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Roxburgh, David J.: Prefacing the image : the writing of art history in sixteenth century Iran / by David J. Roxburgh. – Leiden; Boston; Köln : Brill, 2000 (Studies and sources in Islamic art and architectue; Vol 9) ISBN 90-04-11376-2 ISSN 0921-0326 ISBN 90 04 11376 2 © Copyright 2001 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Brill provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910 Danvers MA 01923, USA.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Heritage Modding'
    ‘Heritage Modding’ Historische identiteitspolitiek in mods van het spel Crusader Kings II 1 Student: Bob Djim Sjeng Hermkens, 4057805 Begeleider: Dr. Remco Ensel Moment van afstuderen: 15 juni 2018 Master Geschiedenis en Actualiteit Faculteit der Letteren, Radboud Universiteit te Nijmegen 1 Afbeelding: Mennano, ‘Kingdom of Bosnia Crusader Kings II mod | Released 2015’ (versie 4 juni 2015), ModDB <https://www.moddb.com/mods/kingdom-of-bosnia/images/overview#imagebox> [geraadpleegd op 13-06-2018]. Inhoudsopgave Hoofdstuk 1. Inleiding en Status Quaestionis………………………………………………………………………………………2 1.1. Games: definitie, medium en benaderingswijzen……………………………………………………….3 1.1.1. Narratologische school…………………………………………………………………………………….4 1.1.2. Ludologische school…………………………………………………………………………………………5 1.1.3. Ludology meets narratology…………………………………………………………………………….7 1.2. Mods………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….9 1.2.1. Mods en fora: active audiences………………………………………………………………………12 Hoofdstuk 2. Selectie en analysemodel…………………………………………………………………………………………….14 2.1. Modselectie en selectieproces………………………………………………………………………………..14 2.2. Analysemodel………………………………………………………………………………………………………….15 Hoofdstuk 3. Netwerken en hegemoniale herinneringscultuur…………………………………………………………17 3.1. Categorisatie……………………………………………………………………………………………………………18 3.2. Avatars: hiërarchie en bewegingsvrijheid………………………………………………………………..20 3.2.1. Habitus en sociaal kapitaal: hiërarchie op het forum?...................................... 21 3.2.2. Networked individualism: bewegingsvrijheid
    [Show full text]
  • Mani's Book of Mysteries: Prolegomena to a New Look
    ARAM, 22 (2010) 321-334. doi: 10.2143/ARAM.22.0.2131043 MANI’S BOOK OF MYSTERIES: PROLEGOMENA TO A NEW LOOK AT MANI, THE ‘BAPTISTS’ AND THE MANDAEANS Prof. IAIN GARDNER (University of Sydney) Abstract Before the reading of the Cologne Mani Codex (from 1969 on) scholars such as E.S. Drower commonly assumed that Mani was brought up in a Mandaean community. However, the CMC appeared to identify the ‘baptists’ of Mani’s youth as Elchasaites, and the trajectory of research changed leaving the question of Mani’s relationship with the Mandaeans in limbo. This paper does not attempt to solve this problem, but recent reports of an otherwise unknown Mandaean scroll known as the Diwan d-Razia suggest a new avenue of approach: To study Mani’s own lost Book of Mysteries as a site for debate between the apostle and other religious communities of the time. A close analy- sis of all available evidence is made, including a tentative reconstruction of the lost work in outline, based on the chapter headings preserved by al-Nadim in his Fihrist. Whilst various important points of contact with Mandaean teachings are noted, the overall conclusion is that Mani’s Book of Mysteries would have focussed firstly on testimonies about Jesus, and thereafter on a telling of the crucial moments in cosmic and redemptive history. The work evidences dialogue with Bardaisan and his followers, and may well have accessed Sethian traditions. The problematic question of Mani’s relation to nascent Mandaeism is highlighted, but it is shown that this work is unlikely to have had much in common with a priestly scroll such as we imagine the Diwan d-Razia to be, despite any superficially similar esoteric purpose.
    [Show full text]