Report of Justicf Ranganath Misra Commission of Inquiry
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPORT OF JUSTICF RANGANATH MISRA COMMISSION OF INQUIRY VOLUME-II u) 771 ,t jr j JUSTICF, RANGANATH MISRA COMMISSION OF I QUIRY VOLUME II ■■•••••.■.•■••1 VOLUME II ERRATA On page No. For Read Cover page " II " 211 (i) - on top. "Volum,. II" B ".Affidavit No.-Deponent" "Affidavit No. ar nams of the depc nent with adires B "Allegation" "Nature of incidnt" 8 to 12 - Column Nos. "2" and "3" u2u -do- "4" u7u -do- u5n u/01 13 "Eat 0 istrint" aftr th- main he=dinc" 17 - against Sl.No.10i "9.7.76" "9.7.56" 22 "Nerth" "North" 22-A - on top ".Appendix 8" 25 - on top "Appendix 10" 40A - on top "Appendix 16" 50 - linp 2 from below "appointment" appointment" of the last para of the letter. INDEX Appendix No. Contents rase fs Letter of Justice Sikri 2 Memo of local inspection of Dashmesh Nagar . 3 Break up of affidavits of Delhi 3 — 7 4 Conclusions of Investigating Agency in regard to 30 incidents of Delhi . S - P 5 Details of FIRS, investigation, charge sheet; and pending cases in Delhi 13 — 18 6 Details of Gurudwaras damaged in Delhi . 19 -- 21 7 Details of educational institutions damaged in Delhi . Few police station wise maps of Kanpur 9 Break up of affidavits of Kanpur 23 -- 24 10 List of pending cases in Kanpur 2> — 26 11 Conclusions of Investigating Agency with reference to Capt. Ida bitffis statement 27 12 Conclusions of Investigating Agency regarding 22 incidents in Kanpur . 28 -- 31 13 Break up of affidavits of Bokaro i2 __ 14 List of pending cases of Bokaro-Chas 34 -- 38 IS Conclusions of Investigating Agency regarding 10 incidents at Bokaro-Chas . 39 --- 40 16 Map of Bokaro and Chas Tehsils 17 Letter of Punjab Government regarding killings in that State 11 18 Letters from U.P. Government regarding steps taken by it fur rehabilitation of riot victims -- 46 • 4' 19 Letters from Bihar Government regarding steps taken by it for rehabilitation of riot victims 20 Letters from Delhi Administration regarding steps taken for rehabilitation of riot victims 50 — (1) APPENDIX "2" 13-2-1986 The Commission decided to make a local inspection of two places within Bokaro Steel City area with a view to appreciating evidence recorded by it. Accordingly, accompanied by the Secretary to the Commission as also the Investigating Agency, the Commission 'visited between 8.30 a.m. and 9.30 a.m. today, Dashmesh Nagar area where the kacha-pucca construction housing the Gurbdwara and a row of kacha houses (jhuggis) where Sikhs were residing had been totally demolished. There is hardly any trace of construction on the area left now. This place is sur- rounded by jhuggis and small pucca construction which are said to be unauthorised. The place is not conveniently approachable on account of lack of road facility and is in fact somewhat cut off from the main link. The Commission next went to the Gurudwara in Sector 2 on which an attack had been made. During the riots a lot of victims and Sikhs who were afraid of their safety had taken shelter here. A memorandum be left on record for consideration in due course. Sd/- CHAIRMAN 2 APPENDIX '1' CITIZENS' JUSTICE COMMITTEE Justice S. M. Sikri, President 134, Sunder Nagar, Mrs. Amiya Rao New Delhi-110003 Charanjit Singh Gobinda Mukhotcy Dated : 2-4-1986 Gurbachan Singh Gian Singh Vohra Hardev Singh The Honourable Mr. Justice R. N. Misra, H. S. Phoolka, Convener Misra Commission of Enquiry, Mrs. Jaya Jaitly 5, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi. Lt. Gen. J. S. Aurora Khushwant Singh K. M. Singh Dear Justice Misra, N. D. Pancholi Rajni Kothari The Citizens' Justice Committee (CJC) has filed on 31-3-1986 before the Honou- Ranjit Singh Narula rable Commission its submissions pertaining to the matter of the continued presence Soli J. Sorabjee and participation of CJC in the proceedings of the Commission. V. M. Tarkunde In view of the discussion which took place yesterday between Your Lordship and Mr. Phoolka, and out of deference to certain observations which you were pleased to make during the course of the discussion, an emergent meeting of the CJC was convened yesterday evening. After deep and careful reconsideration of the matter, CJC regretfully finds itself unable to alter its previous decision as set out in the said submissions. CJC would like to make it absolutely clear that its decision and the said submis- sions filed by it do not in any manner imply lack of personal confidence in Your Lord- ship or any mark of disrespect for the Commission. For reasons already stated in the said submissions CJC is of the view that the procedure adopted and followed by the Commission has rendered its continued presence and participation ineffective and pointless. Yours Sincerely, Sdj- (S,M, Sikri) 4 CLASSIFICATION OF AFFIDAVITS AREA/POLICE STATION WISE (DELHI) Total No. of affidavits relating to SI. Police Station/Area No. of persons killed Affidavits Total against No. Killing Arson No. of Looting Arson Misc. Named Un-named riot affidavits & victims Looting 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 1. SUBZI MANDI : Malka .Ganj, Arya Pura, 8 1 4 1 4 7 Gulabi Bagh 12 11 29 2. SARA! ROHILA : Rohtak Road . 4 1 - 2 1 8 10 24 32 3.. ASHOK VIHAR : Nimri Colony . I I — 6 1 1 38 47 4. SADAR BAZAR : Ahata Kidara . 6 — 27 33 5. KINGSWAY CAMP : Model Town, Sunder 5 2 1 2 3 13 Nagar, Gujrawalan Town, 2 30 43 G.T. Road 6. COURT ROAD : Civil Lines . 1 7. LAWRANCE ROAD : Tri Nagar, Shakurpur, 2 1 J. J. Colony 16 8. ADARSH NAGAR : Badli . 9. BARA HINDU RAO : Azad Market, Pul Ban- 1 1 3 3 gash, DCM Road 7 10. ROSHANARA : Jawahar Nagar, Kamla Nagar, Shastri Nagar 80 00 11. WAZIRPUR : Wazirpur . 13 12. CHANDNI CFIOWK Chandni Chowk 98 98 13. MANGOLPUR I : Rohini Complex 23 4 1 45 15 81 14. SULTANPURI . 29 — — 2 2 53 55 66 99 15. JAHANGIRPURI . 10 — 2 — 1 12 14 37 16. PUNJABI BAGH : Paschim Vihar 4 3 — 4 3 8 8 " 17. RAJORI GARDEN : Tagore Garden, Mansaro- — 1 — 1 1 — war Garden 12 18. TILAK NAGAR : Chand Nagar, Ram Nagar, 3 2 1 7 Subash Nagar, Ashok 18 Nagar, Fateh Nagar, Chaunkhandi APPENDIX "3" CLASSIFICATION OF AFFIDAVITS RECEIVED IN DELI-II 2905 I. Total Affidavits Received 639 2. Affidavits in support of the victims 308 3. Affidavits connected with deaths 49 4. Affidavits connected with arson . 52 5. Affidavits connected with looting 121 6. Affidavits connected with arson & looting 98 7. Affidavits in which miscellaneous facts have been stated • . 10 8. Affidavits not entertained as out of jurisdiction, time barred etc. 1 9. Affidavits withdrawn 2266 10. Affidavits against the victims 128 11. Affidavits (Evidence Recorded) . 3 6 CLASSIFICATION OF AFFIDAVITS AREA/POLICE STATION WISE (DELHI) Total No. of affidavits relating to No. of persons killed Affidavits Total SI. Police Station/Area against No. of No. Killing Arson Looting Arson Misc. Named Un- riot affidavits & named victims Looting 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 37. SHAHDARA : Azad Nagar, Dadri Gaon, 29 1 1 3 4 66 35 261 Dwarka Puri, East Vinod Nagar, Brahm Puri, Ram Nagar, Subhadra Colony, Usman Pur, Jagjit Nagar, Hardev Puri, Bhajan Pura, Babarpur, Mandowali, Maujpur, Sahibabad, Kartar Nagar, Jyoti Nagar, East Loni Road, Kabul Nagar 38. NARIANA INDUSTRIAL AREA: Inder Puri 3 1 23 28 39. SHADI PUR : W. Patel Nagar, S.P. 1 2 3 2 3 1 — 20 31 Nagar 40. KAROL BAGH : Dev Nagar, Anand Parbat, — 1 6 10 2 — 50 69 Sat Nagar 41. RAJINDER NAGAR : . — — 1 — — 12 13 42. PAHAR GANJ . 1 1 64 65 43. DARYA GANJ . 51 51 44. NEW ROHTAK ROAD : 1 I 45. DEEN DAYAL 1 UPADHAY MARG : 46. BHAGAT SINGH MARG : Connaught Place, Con- 1 1 naught Circus 4/. DELHI, isABAR KOAD, 6 3 11 7I ASHOKA ROAD, WINDSER PALACE, DELHI/LUDHIANA 48. CANNING LANE 1 1 49. MALVIYA NAGAR 1 1 2 2 9 50. NIZAMUDDIN : Kilokari . — — 1 1 — 51. JANGPURA : Jangpura, Bhogal . — 4 2 2 1 9 18 52. VINAY NAGAR : Safdarjang Enclave, Saro- — 1 — 4 3 8 16 jini Nagar 3 CLASSIFICATION OF AFFIDAVITS A.T.:1E.AIPOLICE STATION:WISE (DELHI) Total No. of affidavits relating to Sl. police Station/Arca No. of persons killed Affidavits Total No. against No. of Killing Arson Looting. Arson Misc. Named Un- riot affidavits & named victims Looting 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10_ 11 19. JANAKPUR1 : Nangal Rai, Jail Road, 4 3 1 2 1 8 3 Pankha Road, LajlA anti Garden, Khabari 20. SARSWATI VIHAR : Pritam Pura . 1 1 2 2 1 _ 21. UTTAM NAGAR : Anand Vihar, Kiran Gar- 11 — 4 2 13 1 34 51 den, Uttam Nagar 22. NAJAFGARH : Zaroda Kalan, Dichaur, 6 1 Nawada Gaon 23. MAHIPALPUR : . 1 — — 2 24. NANGLOI : . 13 1 — 1 2 25 38 47 64 25. SAHIB PURA — 1 I 26. MADI PUR — — 32 32 27. NAND NAGAI : Nand Nagri 19 1 174 267 5 25 28. GANDHI NAGAR : Gandhi Nagar . 3 1 5 2 8 1 189 200 29. KALYANPURI : Kalyanpuri, Trilokpuri, 40 4 6 7 11 103 93 144 212 Khichripur, Mandoli 30. YAMUNA VIHAR : Yamuna Vihar, Bhajanpura 6 1 3 23 44 54 31. KRISHNA NAGAR : Geeta Colony, Jhecl- 9 2 — 4 5 15 7 242 262 Kurenja, Radhey Puri Extn., Shastri Nagar 32. SHAKARPUR : ShakarPur . 21 — 1 3 4 42 15 299 328 33. SEELAMPUR : Seelampur . I — — 1 1 1 1 85 88 34.