Oxford University Press Kant and the Transcendental Object A Hermeneutic Study J. N. Findlay Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 This book attempts to analyse and interpret Kant's metaphysics of transcendental idealism, with its distinction between those aspects of objects which have a meaning for knowledge, and involve empirical criteria, and those other aspects of knowledge which can only be referred to in an 'empty' formal manner, without empirical content. £17.50 Divine and Contingent Order Thomas F. Torrance This book examines the implications for our understanding of the universe of the Judaeo-Christian claim that it Is contingent: freely created by God out of nothing, having an existence, freedom, and rational order of its own while still dependent on him. £9.50 The Expanding Circle Ethics and Sociobiology Peter Singer 'An excellent exposition of a most complex problem. Peter Singer has without question clarified the many subtleties and singularities involved in the relation between ethics and sociobiology.' Nature. £6.95 Hume and the Problem of Causation Tom L. Beauchamp and Alexander Rosenberg This book is an interpretation and defence of Hume's theory of causation. An outstanding feature is that it succeeds in making the theory relevant to current debates on causality. It is more philosophical than historical or exegetical, and deploys a careful technical exposition of Hume's ideas from a modern logical point of view. £15 For more information about Oxford books on philosophy, write to John Midgley, Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford. BASIL BLACKWELL

The Collected Philosophical Papers of G. E. M. Anscombe If there is anything that characterizes Elizabeth Anscombe's philosophical writings it is the capacity to be struck by questions. She has made new questions for philosophy, has taken familiar and unquestioned assumptions and

shown how far from being obvious they are Philosophy as she does it is fresh; Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 her arguments take unexpected turns and make unexpected connections, and show always how much there is that had not been seen before . . . ' Cora Diamond From Parmenides to Wittgenstein 752 pages, £10 00 10 631 12922 7) Metaphysics and the Philosophy of Mind 256pages, £15.00(0 631 12932 4) Ethics, Religion and Politics 176 pages, £12 00 (0 631 12942 1) Rational Theology and the Creativity of God KEITH WARD This precise, elegant argument on the existence and nature of God makes an important contribution to philosophical theology It is a defense of a revised form of the traditional philosophical idea of God, taking full account of a renewed stress on temporality and creativity, as well as putting well-known arguments in a new light 256 pages, £14 00 (0 631 12597 31 Theology and Ethics JAMES M. GUSTAFSON Theology and Ethics is Professor Gustafson's magnum opus It is nothing less than the construction, by the foremost living exponent of Christian ethics, of a systematic account of ethics in relation to theology in the modern world The result is comprehensive, timely and provocative 384 pages, about £15.00 (0 631 12945 6) Illegitimacy: A Philosophical Examination JENNY TEICHMAN Books about illegitimacy generally focus on its moral or legal aspects, rarely is any thought given to the concept itself and the role it plays and has played in human life Jenny Teichman's book is a new departure' a philosophical and factual analysis of the very notion of illegitimacy, tracing its meaning and importance in the practices of different societies It is a substantially revised and expanded version of the author's earlier book The Meaning of Illegitimacy, which M A Stewart in Philosophical Books described as 'utterly absorbing . offers a notable practical application of the analytical skills of a professional . . . beautifully written, objective, humane, often witty 208 pages, about £9 50 (0 631 12807 7)

Basil Blackwell Publisher, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF BASIL BLACKWELL

Perspectives on the Philosophy of Wittgenstein Edited by IRVING BLOCK A collection of fifteen essays by eminent scholars covering almost every aspect of Wittgenstein's philosophy The contributors are G. E. M. Anscombe, Kenneth Blackwell, Irving Block, Frank Cioffi, Michael Dummett, P. M S. Hacker, Hide Ishiguro, Anthony Kenny, Saul A. Knpke, Brian McGuinness, David Pears,

D. Z. Phillips, Erik Stenius, Peter Winch and Paul Ziff Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 328pages, £15.00 (0 631 19550 51 Wittgenstein's Tractatus: An Introduction H. 0. MOUNCE The aim of this book is to help the student with only an elementary knowledge of and philosophy to understand the main doctrines of Wittgenstein's Tractatus It follows the order in which Wittgenstein wrote, and keeps technicalities to a minimum H 0 Mounce covers everything of essential importance in the Tractatus, and also much of the more incidental detail 144 pages, hardback £12 00 (0 631 12556 61 paperback £4 50 (0 631 12707 0) Wittgenstein and his Times Edited by BRIAN McGUINNESS The theme of this book is the agreement and difference between Wittgenstein's thought and that of those who were, in a broad sense his contemporaries. It contains five original contributions' Anthony Kenny on Wittgenstein and the Nature of Philosophy; Brian McGuinness on Freud and Wittgenstein, J C. Nyin on Wittgenstein's Later Work in relation to Conservatism, Rush Rhees on Wittgenstein on Language and Ritual, and G H. von Wright on Wittgenstein in Relation to His Times 128pages, £7.95(0 631 11161 1) Logical Positivism OSWALD HANFLING This book includes discussion of most of the main ideas of Logical Positivism, a prominent twentieth-century form of Empiricism advocated by the and scientists of the 'Vienna Circle' in the 1920s and '30s Connections are made throughout with the classical empiricism of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and with the ideas of Ludwig Wittgenstein 190pages, hardback £14.00 (0 631 10861 0) paperback £5.50 (0 631 12853 0) Essential Readings in Logical Positivism Edited by OSWALD HANFLING A collection of readings to accompany Logical Positivism, this book includes some of the key writings of the Logical Positivists. The main writers represented are Montz Schlick, and Friedrich Waismann, and there are also items from G. E Moore, A. J Ayer, David Rynin, Hans Reichenbach and Carl Hempel. 256pages, paperback £5.95 (0 631 12566 31

Basil Blackwell Publisher, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF ANALYSS Edited by CHRISTOPHER KIRWAN V*tumi4iM.4 CONTENTS October 1981

The Wlener-Kuratowskl procedure and the analysis of order HERBERT HOCHBERG Plantlnga on the essence of essence CAROLINE J. SIMON Wittgenstein' s operator N P. T GEACH Was there ever a radical mistranslation17 IAN HACKING Reply to Yu JAMES HUDSON and MICHAEL TYE On Yu on Hudson 4 Tye WAYNE WASSERMAN Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 Expressions and tokens PHILIP HUGLYand CHARLES SAYWARD 'Entallment' survives Lewy's paradoxes JOHNK SLANEY Direct tableaux proofs B H SLATER Brand on event Identity PETER M SIMONS Russell on the reduction of particulars ALBERT CASULLO Hess on reasons and causes PETER SMITH Conditional murderers CHRISTOPHER BRYANT Butter's problem again ERIC STIFFLER Stelner on Nozick on the right to enforce PATRICK WILSON Sterner on rights and powers DAVID MILLER A negation-free version of the Berry paradox ROBERT E KIRK

ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS institutions- £9 75 (inland) £12 00 (overseas) $29 25 (USA) $34 00 (Canada) Individuals £6 25 (Inland) £7 50 (overseas) $18 75 (USA) $21 90 (Canada) Orders to. Journals Department, Basil Blackwell Publisher Ltd. 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF, England Published by BASIL BLACKWELL, Oxford

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science Contents, Volume 32 Number 3 September 1981 An ida H.-C. HUNG NomK Necessity is Cross-Theoretic GRAHAM ODDIE Verisimilitude Reviewed Discussions ELIE ZAHAR Second Thoughts About Machian Positivism: A Reply (o Feyerabend Review Articles JOHN HENDRY Pauh as Philosopher (review of A. Hermann, K. V. Meyenn and V. F. Wcisskopf teds ): Wolfgang Pauli. Wissenschafthcher Bnefwechset mil Einstein. Bohr, Heisenberg u a Band I) ROLAND PUCCETTI Current Mind—Brain Conrusions (review of M Bunge: The Mind—Body Problem A Psychobioiogical Approach) NEIL TENNANT From Logic to Philosophies (review of S Haack. Philosophy of ) Re^'iews CLIVE KILMISTER on D Bohm Wholeness and the Implicate Order, A. G. MOLLAND on A. Szabo The Beginnings of Greek Mathtmattcr, MICHAEL REDHEAD on R. Peierls Surprises in Theoretical PhvsJcs and J M. Ziman: Reliable Knowledge- An Exploration of the Grounds for Belief in Science; RICHARD SWINBURNE on C Glymour. Theory and Evidence; CHARLES LARMORE on S Gaukroger. Explanatory Sjructures Obituaries HERBERT DINGLE (G J Whilrow) JOSEPH HENRY WOODCER (Karl Popper) Published for tha Britith Soclsty for the Philosophy of Sciance by Aberdeen University Press. Farmers Hall, Aberdeen AB9 2XT, Scotland Editor: John Worrell Price £5.00 (Britain) Subscription Price£14.00 (Britain) £6.00 (Outside Britain) £17.00 (Outside Britain) BASIL BLACKWELL New in Paperback Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature 'This is an ambitious and important book Ambitious because it attempts to place the main concerns and discussions of within a Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 historical perspective, important because this is all too rarely attempted within our present philosophical culture, and almost never done this well . immensely rich and interesting book ' Charles Taylor, Times Literary Supplement 418 pages, paperback £4.95 (0 631 12838 7) Naming and Necessity SAUL A. KRIPKE ' . . brilliant and very influential . . stands up as an impressive and enduring work of philosophy, outstanding in its sweep, clarity and penetration ' Colin McGinn, Times Higher Education Supplement (July) 180pages, paperback €3.50 10 631 12301 8} Sameness and Substance DAVID WIGGINS 'There is no denying the importance of having a proper theory of identity . The attempt which David Wiggins has made to supply this need and the thorough honesty of this treatment deserve to be treated with very great respect.' A J. Ayer, London Review of Books 250 pages, paperback £4 95 10 631 12846 8) Virtues and Vices PHILIPPA FOOT ' . an important work It is definitely one of the best available collections of modern ethical essays ' New Blackfnars 240 pages, paperback £4 5010 631 12749 6) Posthumous Writings This book contains all of Frege's extant unpublished writings on philosophy and logic, other than the correspondence. It comprises twenty-seven pieces, dating from 1879 to 1924-25 (July) 302 pages, paperback £5 95(0 631 12835 2) Philosophical Letters RENE DESCARTES Edited and translated by Anthony Kenny '(Descartes's) mam published works are at best incomplete and at worst incomprehensible without his letters . . This excellent translation of the helpful notes gives a true picture of Descartes's development as revealed in his letters.' Times Literary Supplement Second edition, 288 pages, paperback £4 95 (0 631 12818 2!

Basil Blackwell Publisher 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF IMETAPHILOSOPHYJ Edited by Terrell ward Bynum Associate Editor: John L. Fodor Managing Editor: James A. Thomas volume 12 NO. 2 CONTBITS April 1981

Certainty, doubt and anxiety: toward a theory of the psychology of metaphysics AVNER COHEN Superfluous Information, epistemlc conditions of Inference,

and begging the question DAVID H. SANFORD Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 The entity-restriction of rights: notes on a fashion in ethics BENJAMIN FREEDMAN

Review Article: Margolls on persons and nonreductlve materialism BARBARA VON ECKARD7 The Philosopher as Teacher: The ethics of helping: a comparison of the role of self-reliance In International affairs and pedagogy PATRICK J. HILL

Annual Subscription: institutions: £19.75 (UK) £24.25 (overseas) $45 00 (USA) $50.50 (Canada) individuals: E13.00IUK) £16.00(overseas) SJOOO(USA) $54 50 (Canada) Journals Department BASIL BLACKWELL PUBLISHER LTD., 108 cowley Road, Oxford 0X41JF, England.

The Philosophical Quarterly Special Numbers: The Editors intend to devote one issue in 1982 to articles on Scientific Realism and one issue in 1983 to articles on Medical Ethics. Contributions should be submitted by 31 December of the preceding year, to the Executive Editor, The Philosophical Quarterly, The University, St Andrews, Scotland. Vol. 32 No. 126 January 1982 Intention, Responsibility and Double Effect Antony Duff Knowledge and Understanding John Campbell The Value of Autonomy Robert Young Towards an Eliminative Reduction of Possible Worlds Andrew Roper DISCUSSIONS Bad Samaritans Cause Harm John Harris Lowe on Intentionality Eric Stiffier Gewirth on Absolute Rights JerroldLevinson CRITICAL STUDY Jonathan Lear, and Logical TheoryJohn Corcoran and Michael Scanlan BOOK REVIEWS BOOKS RECEIVED

Annual Subscriptions: Individuals £8.00 (S20.00) Institutions £16.00 ($40.00) for orders placed directly with the Journals Manager, Scottish Academic Press Ltd., 33 Montgomery Street, EDINBURGH EH7 5JX, Scotland. Volume XXIII December 1981 No. 2 CONTENTS GOTTFRIED SEEBASS Mediation Theory and the Problem of Psychological Discourse on 'Inner' Events: Part I FRANCIS W. DAUER Incorrigibihty

CLARK ZUMBACH A Note on the Thesis Argument of the Third Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 Antimony KEITH GRAHAM How do Illocutionary Descnptions Explain? ROY A. SORENSEN Disagreement amongst Ideal Thinkers ALAN N SUSSMAN Counter-Factuals and Non-Trivial De Re Modalities RICHARD SHUSTERMAN Evaluative Reasoning in Criticism JONATHAN HARRISON Gulliver's Adventures in Fairyland Books Received Subscnptions Institutions: £18.50 (UK) £22.75 (overseas) $49.50 (USA) $57 00 (Canada) Individuals £12 50 (UK) £15 25 (overseas) $32 50 (USA) $37.25 (Canada) Orders to: Journals Department, Basil Blackwell Publisher Ltd., 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF, England The German edition of Ratio is published by FELIX MEINER VERLAG, Richardstrasse 47, 2000 Hamburg 76, West Germany Published by BASIL BLACKWELL, Oxford

.•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••», The Journal of Philosophy

Subscriptions at $15.00/year; $12.00 to students $20.00/year to libraries Students' price extended to retired and unemployed philosophers. Published bimonthly 1904 to 1976, montnly thereafter. Complete volumes and all separate issues available back to January 7, 1904 (volume i, number 1); prices as follows:

BACK VOLUMES I-LXXVI (1904-1979, penultimate year) 32-page issues, $1.50; 64-page, $3.00'. Volumes, $30.00 each.

CURRENT VOLUMES (this year and last) 64-page issues, $2.00; special issues, 96-page or over, $3.00. Volumes (unbound, volume indexes included), $25.00 each.

ALSO AVAILABLE Cumulative Fifty-year Index, 1904-1953; articles classified by subject and author; 452 p.; cloth, $12.00. Ten-year Supplement, 1954-1963: 98 p.; cloth $3.00, paper $2.00. 720 PHILOSOPHY HALL, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY. NYC 10027 REVUE INTERNATIONALE DE PHILOSOPHIE

Editor •. Michel MEYER 143, av. A. Buyl, 1050 Brussels, Belgium Each number is devoted to a particular movement, a particular philosopher, or a particular problem. We publish 3 issues annually. Articles are written in English, French, German, or Italian. Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 Coming numbers : Scandinavian Philosophy Kant's Critique of Pure Reason Hegel Our last issue was devoted to Aristotle (E. Berti, M. Mignucci, W. Leszl, J. Hintikka, L. Couloubaritsis, W. Kluback, E. M. Barker, J. Barnes, J. Brunschwig, Ch. Lefevre, F. Van Steenbergen, R. H. Wettstein, R. Sternfeld and H. Zyskind)

AUSTRALASIAN JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY Contents of Vol. 59, No. 3; Sept. 1981 EDITOR: BRIAN ELLIS

ARTICLES John Biro Meaning, Translation and Interpretation David Lewis What Puzzling Pierre Does Not Believe John Kikulten Mill on Duty and Liberty Stephen Read Validity and the Intensional Sense of 'and' J.B. Maund Colour—A Case for Conceptual Fission Michael Philips A Pleasure Paradox

DISCUSSION Peter Galle Gruzalski and Ellis on Utilitarianism

CRITICAL NOTICE Chris Murphy Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature by R Rorty

REVIEWS, BOOKS RECEIVED, NOTES AND NEWS ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTIONS: Individuals A$I3 (US$16 or Stg £7 50); Institutions AS23 (US$27 or Stg €13). All correspondence should be addressed to the Editor or Business Manager, Department of Philosophy, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Victoria. 3083. Australia. PUBLISHED QUARTERLY BY THE AUSTRALASIAN ASSOCIATION OF PHILOSOPHY HWML rUn llifc mfcUlii Ur SU = ?=====§ General Editor: P. F. SECORD Co-Editor: P. COLLETT Associate Editors: A. GIDDENS, P.MANICAS. C. SMITH Managing Editor: J. S. WEST Volume 11, No. 2 July 1981

A. W. McHOUL: Ethnomethodology and the Position of Relativist Discourse WILLIAM H. FODDY: Obscenity Reactions: Toward a Symbolic Interactionist

Explanation Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 JOSEPH LYONS: Memory traces and infantile amnesia: A reconsideration of the work of Erwin Straus JOSEPH LYONS: Why Human Development Requires More than One Mode of Experience PHILIP L. KNOWLES: Ecological Perspective Applied to Social Perception MAURY SILVER and JOHN SABINI: Procrastinating

Annual subscriptions: Institutions C20.50 (inland) £25.25 (overseas) $52.50 (USA) $60.00 (Canada); Individuals £10.50 (inland) £13.00 (overseas) $30.00 (USA) $34.50 (Canada)

Orders to: JOURNALS DEPARTMENT, BASIL BLACKWELL PUBLISHER., 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0X4 1JF, England.

PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH AN INTERNATIONAL QUARTERLY RODERICK M. CHISHOLM, Editor ERNEST SOSA, Associate Editor in cooperation with a distinguished group of American and Foreign Scholars Descriptive, analytic, critical, and historical articles represent- ing the major contemporary trends in philosophy. In addition to phenomenological research, PPR publishes studies in a wide range of areas including ethics and value theory, meta- physics, aesthetics, logic, language, political, social, and re- ligious philosophy, theory of knowledge, and the sciences. Address All Communications to: PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH BOX 1947 BROWN UNIVERSITY PROVIDENCE, RHODE ISLAND 02912 Annual subscription ratr. $15.00 (foreign, $18.00) for libraries and institutions. $12.00 (foreign. $13.00) for in- dividuals: single copies $3.75 (double issue. $7.50) and $3.00 (double issue. $6.00) respectively, plus postage and handling on back issues only. Papers submitted for publication will not be returned unless accompanied by a self- addressed, stamped envelope, or equivalent postage. A circular listing the main contents of the journal since 1940 will be sent upon request. Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 THE MIND ASSOCIATION Officers of the Association President: Professor A. R. Manser. Vice-Presidents: Professors G. H. Bird, H. H. Price, B. A. O. Williams and Mr. J. D. Mabbott. Secretary: Mr. D. Holdcroft (University of Warwick). Treasurer: Mr. G. G. L. Stock (University of Aberdeen). Elected Members of the Executive Com- mittee: Professor M. A. Boden (University of Sussex), Professor A. R. Manser (University of Southampton), Dr. H. Mellor (University of Cambridge), Professor T. L. S. Sprigge (University of Edinburgh).

American Treasurer: Professor N. D. Belnap (University of Pittsburgh). Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 The Mind Association undertakes the management and financial support of MIND. Membership of the Association is open to any individual on condition that he intends to subscribe to MIND indefinitely. There is no membership fee apart from the subscription charge. In addition to receiving MIND members are entitled to attend the philosophical conference (the Joint Session) organized in cooperation with the Aristotelian Society and held each year in July at a U.K. university. The AGM of the Association takes place at this conference. Members are entitled to vote at the AGM in the election of officers and on matters pertaining to the management of MIND and to the organiz- ation of the Joint Session. Members resident in Europe receive details of the Joint Session, the Agenda for the AGM, and a copy of the Treasurer's Report each year. Members from other countries may receive these on request from the Treasurer. A membership list is published each year with the January issue of MIND. The Treasurer is responsible for maintaining this list. Members must inform him before November ist of any amendments required in the current list and of intended resignations. Requests for membership (accompanied by payment) should be made either to (i) Guy Stock, Treasurer, Mind Association, Dept. of Logic, King's College, Aberdeen, ABO. 2UB or to (ii) Basil Blackwell, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford 0x4 IJF. Membership is not available to subscribers who purchase MIND through a bookseller. Payment to the Treasurer is by sterling Bankers' Order only. The Treasurer can only accept Bankers' Orders made payable on January ist and therefore intending members must return their completed Orders at least six weeks before the beginning of the year in which their membership will commence. Bankers' Order forms are available from the Treasurer and prospective members are urged to subscribe in this way if possible. Payment to Basil Blackwell is by annual cheque or money order made payable to Basil Blackwell, Publisher, Ltd. Blackwell's will not accept payment by Bankers' Order. Members may pay a Life Membership fee of £160 instead of an annual subscription. This may be paid either to the Treasurer or to Blackwell's. Basil Blackwell must be informed of any change in a subscriber's address at least 3 weeks in advance of the date on which the change is intended to take effect- (N.B. If this information is sent on a printed change-of-address card, it is essential to indicate that the addressee is a subscriber to MIND.) Oxford Books for Students Moral Philosophy D. D. Raphael Professor Raphael's purpose is to introduce moral philosophy to those with little or no acquaintance with the subject. He explains and discusses utilitarianism, naturalism, and rationalism, and stresses that far from being an esoteric subject, moral philosophy has a bearing on practical problems experienced by those concerned with law, government, and social service. Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/mind/issue/XCI/361 by guest on 29 September 2021 £5.95 paperback £2.50 OPUS Aristotle the Philosopher J. L Ackrill The aim of this book is to convey to the non-specialist the force and excitement of Aristotle's philosophical investigations, and to show why contemporary philosophers still draw from him, and return to him. A picture emerges of a lucid, lively, subtle, tough- minded thinker of astonishing range and penetration, whose ideas can still be the subject of argument, and from whom we still have much to learn. £6.95 paperback £2.95 OPUS An Introduction to Plato's Republic Julia Annas This book provides a clear and systematic introduction to the Republic. It brings out the coherence and interest of the main moral argument, while Jher themes in this complex book are also fully discussed: Plato's views on education, his theory of human motivation, and his account of knowledge and understanding. £15.00 paperback £5.95 Scientific Revolutions Edited by Ian Hacking This new collection is concerned with the way revolutions in science occur. It centres on the contemporary debate between those who offer a traditional, positivist and realist account of science and those who believe that the history of science supports a fundamentally different view of the way in which scientific concepts work. Paperback £3.50 Oxford Readings in Philosophy

For more information about Oxford books on philosophy please write to John Mldgley, Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford. Oxford University Press

Primed in Great Britain at Aberdeen University Press