DOCSLIB.ORG

Proquest Dissertations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Proquest Dissertations u Ottawa L'Universite canadienne Canada's university ITTTT FACULTE DES ETUDES SUPERIEURES 1^=1 FACULTY OF GRADUATE AND ET POSTOCTORALES u Ottawa POSDOCTORAL STUDIES L'Universite eanadieime Canada's university Devin Zane Shaw "AUfEMDErATHESETAUTHORWTHESIS"" Ph.D. (Philosophy) GRADE/DEGREE Department of Philosophy FACULTE, ECOLE, DEPARTEMEW7 FACULTY, SCHOOL, DEPARTMENT Freedom and Nature in Schelling's Philosophy of Art TITRE DE LA THESE / TITLE OF THESIS Jeffrey Reid DIRECTEUR (DIRECTRICE) DE LA THESE/ THESIS SUPERVISOR CO-DIRECTEUR (CO-DIRECTRICE) DE LA THESE / THESIS CO-SUPERVISOR Frederick Beiser (Syracuse University) Denis Dumas Douglas Moggach Sonia Sikka Gary W. Slater Le Doyen de la Faculte des etudes superieures et postdoctorales / Dean of the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies Freedom and Nature in Schelling's Philosophy of Art Devin Zane Shaw Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies In partial fulfillment of the requirements For the PhD degree in Philosophy Department of Philosophy Faculty of the Arts University of Ottawa © Devin Zane Shaw, Ottawa, Canada, 2009 Library and Archives Bibliotheque et 1*1 Canada Archives Canada Published Heritage Direction du Branch Patrimoine de I'edition 395 Wellington Street 395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON K1A 0N4 Ottawa ON K1A 0N4 Canada Canada Your file Votre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-61259-0 Our Tile Notre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-61259-0 NOTICE: AVIS: The author has granted a non­ L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive exclusive license allowing Library and permettant a la Bibliotheque et Archives Archives Canada to reproduce, Canada de reproduire, publier, archiver, publish, archive, preserve, conserve, sauvegarder, conserver, transmettre au public communicate to the public by par telecommunication ou par I'lnternet, preter, telecommunication or on the Internet, distribuer et vendre des theses partout dans le loan, distribute and sell theses monde, a des fins commerciales ou autres, sur worldwide, for commercial or non­ support microforme, papier, electronique et/ou commercial purposes, in microform, autres formats. paper, electronic and/or any other formats. The author retains copyright L'auteur conserve la propriete du droit d'auteur ownership and moral rights in this et des droits moraux qui protege cette these. Ni thesis. Neither the thesis nor la these ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci substantial extracts from it may be ne doivent etre imprimes ou autrement printed or otherwise reproduced reproduits sans son autorisation. without the author's permission. In compliance with the Canadian Conformement a la loi canadienne sur la Privacy Act some supporting forms protection de la vie privee, quelques may have been removed from this formulaires secondaires ont ete enleves de thesis. cette these. While these forms may be included Bien que ces formulaires aient inclus dans in the document page count, their la pagination, il n'y aura aucun contenu removal does not represent any loss manquant. of content from the thesis. •+• Canada Table of Contents Abstract iv Acknowledgements vi Abbreviations vii Introduction 1 Chapter 1: Dogmatism, Criticism and Art 10 1.1. The Primacy of Freedom 10 1.2. The Pantheism Controversy 14 1.3. Fichte' s Science of Knowledge 21 1.4. The Practical Rivalry of Dogmatism and Criticism 32 1.5. The Sublime of Greek Tragedy and the Interests of Reason 48 Chapter 2: From Nature-philosophy to the "Mythology of Reason" 53 2.1. Nature-Philosophy and the Beginning of the Philosophy of Art 53 2.2. Fichte, Kant, and the Thing in Itself 58 2.3. Appropriating Spinoza and Leibniz 61 2.4. The History of Self-Consciousness 66 2.5. A Natural Doctrine of the Mind 70 2.6. Toward a Philosophy of Art 77 ii Chapter 3: Artistic Activity and the Subversion of Transcendental Idealism 87 3.1. The System of Subversion 87 3.2. The Limits of Theory and Practice 96 3.2.1. Theory 96 3.2.2. Practice 99 3.3. Teleology and Nature-philosophy 105 3.4. From the "Phenomenology of Genius" to the New Mythology 110 Chapter 4: Substance and History: Art and the System of Identity 124 4.1. The Light of 1801 124 4.2. The Turn to Absolute Reason 130 4.3. The Relationship between Art and the Absolute 139 4.4. The Gods of Art 146 4.5. Substance or History? 158 Chapter Five: From Art and Nature to Revelation and Freedom 160 5.1. The Moment in Munich 160 5.2. From the "Living Center" of Nature and Art... 167 5.3... .to Theological Anthropology 184 5.4. The Politics of Mythology and the Mythology of Politics 192 Conclusion 201 Bibliography 210 iii Abstract The goal of this thesis is to establish the centraiity of the philosophy of art in Schelling's thought from the System of Transcendental Idealism (1800), through the period known as his absolute idealism or identity-philosophy (1801-1806), to the address Uber das VerMltnis der bildenden Ktinste zu der Natur of 1807. One of the central problems of previous interpretations of Schelling's philosophy of art is the lack of clear and comprehensive criteria for establishing the similarities and differences among his various presentations. In order to establish a measure for evaluating the continuity of Schelling's philosophy of art, I focus on demonstrating the structural features that are consistent from 1800 to 1807: 1) What philosophy constructs in the ideal, art produces in the real. Thus artistic activity is the highest human vocation (Bestimmung) because practical philosophy can only approximate its object, which is the moral law. 2) While both the natural organism and the artwork embody the same identity of real and ideal, of necessity and freedom, the work of art overcomes these oppositions through the identity of conscious and unconscious production, whereas the organism's activity is unconscious. 3) Artistic production has a socio-political task: it aims to overcome the fragmentary condition of modernity through a new mythology and artistic renewal. iv All of these features are first outlined in the System of Transcendental Idealism and are maintained through 1807.1 argue that they can be understood in relation to Schelling's ideas of freedom and nature. The philosophy of art emerges as a solution to the problem of how to show that human activity can be objectified within the real world. For the philosophy of art, the objective result is the artwork. Thus for Schelling, artistic production exhibits an ethic of free activity that was 'more free than freedom,' as freedom was conceived, in Kant and Fichte, as conformity to the moral law. Though he also thinks freedom as an infinite approximation to a regulative ideal, Schelling adds that artistic activity actually produces its own law, as beauty, in the harmony of form and content of the work, which exhibits the identity of freedom and necessity, and the self and nature. Art presents the absolute in the finite world, and makes possible a new mythology that can unify humanity. I conclude by arguing that Schelling abandons the philosophy of art when he shifts his concern to the relationship between freedom, revelation, and theology. Schelling's orientation turns from a hopeful future of humanity, realized in a new mythology, to a focus on Christian revelation, the figure of Christ and the idea of human freedom as positive capacity for good or evil. In this account, Schelling reduces the role of art to the production of a work of nostalgia for a lost connection to nature. Art is reduced to this role because Schelling now conceives of freedom, and virtue, as the highest activity of human being; but this idea of freedom is of an ecstatic or existential nature. Schelling elevates human freedom to the pinnacle of the system when he finally surpasses its conception as an activity that approximates the moral law. In the Philosophical Investigations into the Essence of Human Freedom of 1809, and the Stuttgart Seminars given a year later, freedom is rethought as a positive, ecstatic act of inner law-giving, which is realized as virtue. v Acknowledgements The origins of this thesis can be traced at least as far back as my supervisor Jeffrey Reid's graduate seminar "The Self and Its World in Fichte, Schelling and Early German Romanticism," of Winter 2005, in which I first read Schelling's work. It would not have been the same project without his constant encouragement and constructive criticism. The comments and suggestions of my committee, comprised of Denis Dumas, Douglas Moggach, and Sonia Sikka, helped to push my research beyond the project phase, and Frederick C. Beiser's incisive criticism improved the final draft. I would also like to thank my family and friends, in academia and otherwise, who listened, nodded, and gave support through the process of my writing and researching. Mark Young, Mark Raymond Brown and Dean Wm. Lauer all had to listen to endless philosophical speculations as I worked through Schelling's philosophy of art, and near the end, Mark Raymond Brown read part of the first draft. Sascha Maicher helped out when Schelling's German appeared to be opaque. My family supported my university education even when they weren't sure when it would end. Finally, my wife Caroline had patience during the time I was knee-deep in the absolute. -D.Z.S., December 1,2009 vi Abbreviations The following is a list of frequently used abbreviations that appear in the main text and footnotes. All references to Schelling's work cite the page of the English translation, when available, followed by the volume and pagination from K.F.A Schelling's edition of his father's work, as reproduced in Schellings Werke. Nach der Original Ausgabe in neuer Anordnung.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • (Modern Philosophy) Part I: Fichte to Hegel 9. Walter Benjamin, Der
    Notes 1 Idealism and the Justification of the Image 1. J.G. Fichte, The Vocation of Man (New York: Bobbs Merrill, 1956), p.80 (adapted). 2. Idem, The Science of Knowledge (New York: Appleton, Century Crofts, 1970), p.188. 3. Fichte (1956), pp.81f. 4. Ibid., pp.98f. 5. Ibid., pp.124f. 6. Ibid., p.147. 7. For example, the so-called 'Atheismusstreit'. See: F. Copleston, A History of Philosophy, Vol. V, II (Modern Philosophy) Part I: Fichte to Hegel (New York: Doubleday, 1965), pp.lOOff. 8. Friedrich Schlegel, Kritische Schriften (Miinchen: Carl Hanser, 1956), p.46. 9. Walter Benjamin, Der Begriff der Kunstkritik in der Deutschen Romantik in Gesammelten Schriften 1:1 (Frankfurt am Main, 1972), p.26. 10. Quoted in Benjamin (1972), p.37. 11. F. Schlegel, Lucinde (Stuttgart: Reclam, 1963), p.35. 12. F.J.W. Schelling, System of Transcendental Idealism (Charlottesville: Uni­ versity of Viriginia Press, 1978), p.219. 13. Ibid., p.232. 14. Henrik Steffens, Inledning til Philosophiske Forelasninger i K9benhavn (1803) (New edn) K0benhavn: Gyldendal, 1905), p.21. 15. Ibid., pp.21f. 16. Ibid., p.22. 17. One of the best summaries of Grundtvig's thought in English remains E.L. Allen, Bishop Grundtvig: A Prophet of the North (London: James Clarke, 1949). James Clarke have also published (more recently) an anthology of Grundtvig's writings. A sign of increasing Anglo-Saxon awareness of Grundtvig's significance is the recently formed Anglo­ Danish conference Grundtvig and England. 18. Henning Fenger, Kierkegaard: The Myths and Their Origins (Newhaven: Yale University Press, 1980), p.84. 19.
    [Show full text]
  • Speculative Geology
    15 Speculative Geology DALE E. SNOW We are not at peace with nature now. Whether it is the record-setting rain on the east coast or the raging wildfires in the west, distant news of melting permafrost or bleaching coral reefs, or the unexpected eruption of Mount Kilauea a few miles from here, things seem increasingly, and increasingly violently, out of control. I would like to suggest that there are resources in Schelling’s Naturphilosophie we can use in the twenty-first century to help us think differently about both the power of nature and our own relationship to it. Although Schelling saw himself, and was seen by many, as antagonistic toward the mechanical science of his own time, it would be a mistake—and a missed opportunity—to see his view as a mere Romantic reaction. It is a speculative rethinking of the idea of nature itself that finds a place for even those phenomena which seem most distant and alien. Schelling described his philosophy of nature as “speculative physics” both to distinguish it from what he calls the dogmatic or mechanistic model of nature, and to announce a new approach to natural science, concerned with the original causes of motion in nature (SW III: 275). Since every “natural phenomenon … stands in connection with the last conditions of nature” (SW III: 279), speculative physics can bring us to an understanding of nature as a system. Geology presents an illuminating case of this approach, as can be seen from Schelling’s characteristically enthusiastic introduction to a paper published by Henrik Steffens in Schelling’sJournal of Speculative Physics (Zeitschrift für speculative Physik) on the oxidization and deoxidization of the earth.1 After praising Steffens’ work on a new and better founded science of geology, Schelling reflects darkly on the too long dominant mechanical approach to geology.
    [Show full text]
  • A History of German-Scandinavian Relations
    A History of German – Scandinavian Relations A History of German-Scandinavian Relations By Raimund Wolfert A History of German – Scandinavian Relations Raimund Wolfert 2 A History of German – Scandinavian Relations Table of contents 1. The Rise and Fall of the Hanseatic League.............................................................5 2. The Thirty Years’ War............................................................................................11 3. Prussia en route to becoming a Great Power........................................................15 4. After the Napoleonic Wars.....................................................................................18 5. The German Empire..............................................................................................23 6. The Interwar Period...............................................................................................29 7. The Aftermath of War............................................................................................33 First version 12/2006 2 A History of German – Scandinavian Relations This essay contemplates the history of German-Scandinavian relations from the Hanseatic period through to the present day, focussing upon the Berlin- Brandenburg region and the northeastern part of Germany that lies to the south of the Baltic Sea. A geographic area whose topography has been shaped by the great Scandinavian glacier of the Vistula ice age from 20000 BC to 13 000 BC will thus be reflected upon. According to the linguistic usage of the term
    [Show full text]
  • The Idea of the University by Henrik Steffens (1809)
    Henrik Steffens held these talks in 1808/1809 in the time of Napoleon’s occupation. The Emperor had just lifted his ban on university teaching. This was, amazingly enough, the formative time of Berlin University, an enterprise that would involve Steffens, Wilhelm von Humboldt, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schelling, Johann Gottlieb Fichte, Friedrich Schleiermacher, Savigny and others. The lectures here were addressed to the students, not the administration or the prevailing governmental authorities. That in itself was quite a statement in these times. To Steffens, a university wasn’t supposed to be merely a trade school, but a place that opened you up, allowed you to blossom as an individual and helped you to learn to embrace the things of this world. We bring here in English, his first talk on the theme of what a university might be. --TCR The Idea of the University by Henrik Steffens (1809) Introduction These lectures were held at the commencement of the winter semester 1808/1809. Illness and various duties have, until now, prevented me from putting them into their current form. As my lectures are always extemporaneous, the reader will not find an exact reproduction of them but rather the succession of the ideas they contained. An esteemed person from abroad has spoken about the qualities of German Universities, as they must appear to a foreigner. One of the foremost minds of this nation has elaborated on the theme, deepening our understanding of it as it applies to this country1. It seems to me by no means superfluous to give the students themselves information about academic learning.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading the Surface: the Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C
    Reading the Surface: The Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C. Andersen, Karen Blixen and Beyond Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2013 Reading Committee: Marianne Stecher. Chair Jan Sjaavik Marshall Brown Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Scandinavian Studies ©Copyright 2013 Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg Parts of chapter 7 are reprinted by permission of the publishers from “The Aesthetics of Surface: the Danish Gothic 1820-2000,” in Gothic Topographies ed. P.M. Mehtonen and Matti Savolainen (Farnham: Ashgate, 2013), pp. 153–167. Copyright © 2013 University of Washington Abstract Reading the Surface: The Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C. Andersen, Karen Blixen and Beyond Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Professor in Danish Studies Marianne Stecher Department of Scandinavian Studies Despite growing ubiquitous in both the popular and academic mind in recent years, the Gothic has, perhaps not surprisingly, yet to be examined within the notoriously realism-prone literary canon of Denmark. This dissertation fills that void by demonstrating an ongoing negotiation of Gothic conventions in select works by canonical Danish writers such as B.S. Ingemann, Hans Christian Andersen, and Karen Blixen (Isak Dinesen), as well as contemporary writers such as Peter Høeg and Leonora Christina Skov. This examination does not only broaden our understanding of these culturally significant writers and the discourses they write within and against, it also adds to our understanding of the Gothic – an infamously malleable and indefinable literary mode – by redirecting attention to a central feature of the Gothic that has not received much critical attention: the emphasis on excess, spectacle, clichéd conventions, histrionic performances, its hyperbolic rhetorical style, and hyper-visual theatricality.
    [Show full text]
  • Vor Berømte Landsmand – Seminar Om Henrik Steffens«, Universität Stavanger 18./19 September 2019
    Janke Klok (Berlin/Groningen) über: »Vor berømte landsmand – Seminar om Henrik Steffens«, Universität Stavanger 18./19 September 2019 Tagungsbericht Das Seminar war als Auftakt für die Feierlichkeiten zum 250. Geburtstag von Henrik Steffens (1773–1845) in Stavanger im Jahr 2023 konzipiert und fand im Rahmen vom Kapittel statt, Stavangers jährlichem internationalen Festival für Literatur und Meinungsfreiheit (18.–22. September 2019). Ganz bewusst hatten die Veranstalter mit Blick auf das Jubiläum des Philosophen sich an ein breiteres Publikum gewandt, schließlich ist Steffens auch in seiner Geburtsstadt Stavanger eine relativ unbekannte Größe. Neuausgaben und Monografien belegen jedoch in den letzten Jahren (ebenso wie die beiden vorhergehenden Steffens-Seminare 2017 in Oslo und 2018 in Berlin) ein zunehmendes Interesse an Steffens – und dieses Interesse sollte in Stavanger weiter geweckt werden. Vor unerwartet großem und aufmerksamem Publikum versuchten der norwegische Schriftsteller TORE RENBERG sowie dänische, deutsche und norwegische Forscher_innen den Naturphilosophen, Novellenautor und politischen Professor einzusortieren, taucht er doch in der Philosophiegeschichte allenfalls als ein Begleiter Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph Schellings und in der Literaturwissenschaft als derjenige auf, der die Romantik nach Dänemark gebracht haben soll. Tore Renberg eröffnete in seiner ihm eigenen bekannten Art das Symposium: »Koffor i hekkan ska me bry oss om Henrik Steffens i dag, egentlig?« (»Warum zum Teufel soll ich mir eigentlich heute noch etwas aus Henrik Steffens machen?«) Auf seine Frage nach der Bedeutung von Henrik Steffens für die europäische Philoso- phie- und Kulturgeschichte gingen anschließend vier Wissenschaftler_innen ein. BERND HENNINGSEN (Humboldt- Universität zu Berlin) beleuchtete Henrik Steffens’ politische Bedeutung: »Henrik Steffens – en altmuligmann i omveltningstider. En innføring« (»Henrik Steffens – ein ›Mann für alles Mögliche‹ in Umbruchzeiten.
    [Show full text]
  • Lutheran Revival and National Education in Denmark: the Religious Background of N
    Scandinavica Vol 58 No 1 2019 Lutheran Revival and National Education in Denmark: The Religious Background of N. F. S. Grundtvig’s Educational Ideas Grażyna Szelągowska Warsaw University Abstract N. F. S. Grundtvig’s idea of national education has usually been regarded as a part of the history of adult education or as a complex of national ideas. This article takes into consideration that Grundtvig was first and foremost a clergyman, a founder of grundtvigianism and of the Grundtvigian revival movement. It presents a new perspective on the Lutheran background of Grundtvig’s educational programme, and its impact on the shaping of a civic society in Denmark. A religious revival which Grundtvig underwent during the first decades of the nineteenth century shaped the background of his educational programmes. Keywords N. F. S. Grundtvig, Lutheran revival, Grundtvigianism, national education, education in Denmark 6 Scandinavica Vol 58 No 1 2019 Introduction The nineteenth–century modernisation process in the Scandinavian countries has usually been presented as an example of a rather unique interplay of various agents: a peaceful transition from absolutist to democratic systems, the emergence of a free market economy, a crucial role for the state and the development of the underpinnings of the Nordic welfare model, a special position for the Lutheran churches, a wide spectrum of various popular movements, and the growth of civic society. The process of building a modern national identity is common to all those forms of modernisation, however different in particular Nordic countries. Romantic philosophy, with its sympathy for nationality and national identity (and even the idea of a new Nordic union: Scandinavianism), constituted a basis for the emergence of nineteenth–century social movements like national and pan–national organisations, popular education and folk high schools.
    [Show full text]
  • Henrik Steffens
    Henrik Steffens (1779 bis 1845) als Lehrer der Mineralogie und Geologie an der Universität Halle und sein Ausscheiden aus dieser Lehranstall1 Von Walter Steiner Mit 8 Abbildungen (Eingegangen am 17. Juli 1969) An der halleschen Universität haben seit ihrer Gründung im Jahre 1694 natur­ kundliche Fragen, und speziell geologische und mineralogische, stets eine Rolle ge­ spielt. Anfangs waren es vornehmlich Mediziner, wie Friedrich Hoffmann (1616 bis 1742)" und der flei.fjig sammelnde Johann Friedrich Gottlieb Goldhagen (1742 bis 1788)" - die sich mineralogischer Beschäftigung rühmen konnten. Aber schon 1780 trug eine Persönlichkeit an der halleschen Universität den Titel eines .Professors 4 philosophiae ordinario und Specie der Naturgeschichte und Mineralogie" • Es war der Weltumsegler Johann Reinhold Forster (1729 -1798)5, der einen 1 Zum 125. Todestag von H. Steffens im Jahre 1970. 2 Friedrich Hoffmann (1616-1742). Von 1693-1742 Professorprimarius für Medizin an der Universität Halle. Hielt Vorlesungen über Anatomie, Chirurgie, praktische Medizin. Physik und Chemie. Besitzer eines Naturalienkabinetts. Sehr bekannt geworden durch die nach ihm benannten Hoffmanns-Tropfen und die Erschlie(jung der Lauchstädter Heil­ quellen. 3 Johann Friedrich Gottlieb Goldhagen (1742-1788) . 1769 zum Professor Philosophiae et Historia naturalis ordinarius ernannt; damit erstmals eine naturkundliche Professur an der philosoph. Fakultät. Er lit!st u. a. Naturgeschichte, Mineralogie und Lithologie. Be­ sitzer eines bedeutenden Naturalienkabinetts, das zum Grundstein sowohl der mineralo­ gisch-geologischen als auch der zoologischen Universitätssammlung wurde. 1788 stirbt er im 46. Lebensjahr an Typhus (s. Kaiser, W. & Krosch, K. H.: Zur Geschichte der Medi­ zinischen Fakultät der Universität Halle im 18. Jahrhundert: Johann Friedrich Gottlieb Goldhagen (1742-1788) und Friedrich Albert Kar! Gren (1760-1798) .
    [Show full text]
  • Essays on Scandinavian Literature
    Essays On Scandinavian Literature By Hjalmar Hjorth Boyesen Essays On Scandinavian Literature BJÖRNSTJERNE BJÖRNSON I Björnstjerne Björnson is the first Norwegian poet who can in any sense be called national. The national genius, with its limitations as well as its virtues, has found its living embodiment in him. Whenever he opens his mouth it is as if the nation itself were speaking. If he writes a little song, hardly a year elapses before its phrases have passed into the common speech of the people; composers compete for the honor of interpreting it in simple, Norse-sounding melodies, which gradually work their way from the drawing-room to the kitchen, the street, and thence out over the wide fields and highlands of Norway. His tales, romances, and dramas express collectively the supreme result of the nation's experience, so that no one to- day can view Norwegian life or Norwegian history except through their medium. The bitterest opponent of the poet (for like every strong personality he has many enemies) is thus no less his debtor than his warmest admirer. His speech has stamped itself upon the very language and given it a new ring, a deeper resonance. His thought fills the air, and has become the unconscious property of all who have grown to manhood and womanhood since the day when his titanic form first loomed up on the horizon of the North. It is not only as their first and greatest poet that the Norsemen love and hate him, but also as a civilizer in the widest sense. But like Kadmus, in Greek myth, he has not only brought with him letters, but also the dragon-teeth of strife, which it is to be hoped will not sprout forth in armed men.
    [Show full text]
  • Kierkegaard and the Limits of Thought
    1 Kierkegaard and the Limits of Thought Daniel Watts Whereof we cannot speak, thereof we have just contradicted ourselves. (Graham Priest) The ultimate can be reached only as limit. (Søren Kierkegaard) Graham Priest’s Beyond the Limits of Thought (Priest 2001) parades an eclectic line-up of thinkers to show how the history of philosophy has been shaped by the spectre of paradoxes at the limits of thought. One name that is missing from Priest’s line-up is ‘Søren Kierkegaard’. This omission is something of a surprise, especially given Hegel’s centrality in the book and its (second- edition) inclusion of Heidegger and Derrida. For, Kierkegaard’s writings are famous for nothing if not the way they involve such notions as ‘the absurd’, ‘the incomprehensible’ and ‘the Absolute Paradox’ and for their opposition to Hegelian ‘mediation’. But one can appreciate why an author might hesitate to venture something pithy about Kierkegaard on the limits of thought. For one thing, there is a real question whether we are supposed to take at all seriously talk of ‘the Absolute Paradox’ and the like in his enigmatic and often playful texts. And, as we shall see, the critics are so far from consensus in this regard as to associate Kierkegaard with nearly every imaginable view. I hope in this essay to help illuminate Kierkegaard’s place in the history of thinking about the limits of thought. I shall concentrate in the first instance on his treatment of the idea that 2 Christianity cannot be thought or understood. I shall begin by showing how this idea is ostensibly advanced by the pseudonymous work, Philosophical Fragments; and how this text positively courts the threat of self-referential incoherence in this connection.
    [Show full text]
  • Downloaded from Brill.Com09/27/2021 03:29:43AM Via Free Access
    III - ARCHEOLOGY Anne Kveim Lie - 9789042029446 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:29:43AM via free access Anne Kveim Lie - 9789042029446 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 03:29:43AM via free access Treatment Politics: The Rise of Radesyge Hospitals in Norway Anne Kveim Lie Abstract This chapter discusses the rise of the radesyge hospitals in Norway. It will be argued that the end of the 18th century constitutes a historical moment where systematic treatment of patients in hospitals is formulated as a condition of possibility for the first time in Norwegian history. The radesyge hospitals are medicalized in a sense that the treatment intention permeates the whole institution in an unprecedented way in Norway. Nevertheless, focusing on their establishment as part of a teleological process towards the modern health care system obscures historical specificities, for instance the fact that medical experience was performed according to a totally different epistemology. Key Words: History of medicine; radesyge ***** In 1771, Collegium Medicum, the highest administrative organ in health affairs in Denmark-Norway, wrote in a letter to the head of the diocese in southern Norway that a disease called Radesyge was threatening the southern part of Norway. [It] is so dangerous, common, contagious and devastating to the entire population, and in particular to the army, that no measures would be too fast, effective or serious to stop and eradicate this confounded plague, before it gains so much ground, that the extensiveness either makes assistance impossible, or at least difficult or insufficient.1 In the letter, the Collegium Medicum was referring to several concerned reports they had received from local doctors as well as from the head of the diocese in Kristiansand, Hans Hagerup.
    [Show full text]
  • Essay Review Romantic Life and Science
    ANNALS OF SCIENCE Vol. 62, No. 3, July 2005, 377–385 Essay Review Romantic Life and Science ROBERT J. RICHARDS, The Romantic Conception of Life: Science and Philosophy in the Age of Goethe. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 2002. xix + 587 pp., 5 plates $35.00 (cloth) $20.00 (paper). ISBN 0-226-71210-9 (cloth). Reviewed by E. P. HAMM, Science and Technology Studies Program, School of Analytic Studies and Information Technology, York University, Toronto, Ontario M3J 1P3, Canada Romance has for some time been a term of dubious associations. In the seventeenth century, Thomas Burnet decried those critics who would call his Theory of the Earth a ‘Philosophik Romance’; in the eighteenth century, Buffon did just that, and before too long, his theory of the Earth was the subject of the same epithet. By 1780, the early days of the era of Romanticism (so early that it was not yet being called that), Goethe, an admirer of Buffon’s theory, commented with delicate irony: perhaps Buffon really had ‘written a Romance . for it is only by means of the Romance that the worthy public learns of extraordinary things’.1 Burnet’s ‘Romance’, Buffon’s ‘roman’ and Goethe’s ‘Roman’ refer to fanciful tales of military prowess and chivalry. Soon, a group of people close to Goethe would claim this word for themselves, and since that time there has been learned debate about the meaning of Romanticism. In everyday speech, there is more agreement: to say someone has a ‘romantic’ view of the French Revolution, or the lives of indigenous peoples, or international relations, or most anything else serious, amounts to saying the view will not stand up to criticism, is not well-founded, is a fantasy.
    [Show full text]