Reading the Surface: the Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Reading the Surface: The Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C. Andersen, Karen Blixen and Beyond Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2013 Reading Committee: Marianne Stecher. Chair Jan Sjaavik Marshall Brown Program Authorized to Offer Degree: Scandinavian Studies ©Copyright 2013 Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg Parts of chapter 7 are reprinted by permission of the publishers from “The Aesthetics of Surface: the Danish Gothic 1820-2000,” in Gothic Topographies ed. P.M. Mehtonen and Matti Savolainen (Farnham: Ashgate, 2013), pp. 153–167. Copyright © 2013 University of Washington Abstract Reading the Surface: The Danish Gothic of B.S. Ingemann, H.C. Andersen, Karen Blixen and Beyond Kirstine Marie Kastbjerg Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Professor in Danish Studies Marianne Stecher Department of Scandinavian Studies Despite growing ubiquitous in both the popular and academic mind in recent years, the Gothic has, perhaps not surprisingly, yet to be examined within the notoriously realism-prone literary canon of Denmark. This dissertation fills that void by demonstrating an ongoing negotiation of Gothic conventions in select works by canonical Danish writers such as B.S. Ingemann, Hans Christian Andersen, and Karen Blixen (Isak Dinesen), as well as contemporary writers such as Peter Høeg and Leonora Christina Skov. This examination does not only broaden our understanding of these culturally significant writers and the discourses they write within and against, it also adds to our understanding of the Gothic – an infamously malleable and indefinable literary mode – by redirecting attention to a central feature of the Gothic that has not received much critical attention: the emphasis on excess, spectacle, clichéd conventions, histrionic performances, its hyperbolic rhetorical style, and hyper-visual theatricality. As genre markers of trivial entertainment, these characteristics are often dismissed, but to understand how the Gothic works one must take into account its foregrounding of surface mechanisms and its peculiar surface-depth perspective, which informs all levels of narration, setting and characterization. When meaning is not buried in the depths but is played out on the surface, an extremely unstable sense of personal identity is the result. This is the most important contribution of the Gothic counter-narrative to the representation of the human predicament and it clashes dramatically with the Danish discourse of self-formation, Dannelse (Bildung) , which governs the national consciousness to the present day. By dressing up reality – and realism – in excess in disorienting narratives of fragmented subjects, Danish Gothic provides an important correlate to the construction of a harmonious Golden Age Romanticism and of Danish literature as wholesome, moderate and realistic in nature. Danish Gothic challenges the ways in which Danish literary histories have been written since the early 1800s, and the reception history of these writers reads like a Gothic tale of repression and persecution in itself. The aesthetics of the depthless image, which governs the Danish Gothic, seems, however, supremely relevant to the simulated, post-heteronormative hyper-reality of today. Chapter 1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1 Chapter 2. Theoretical Framework: Gothic Criticism ...................................................................................... 9 2.1 What is Gothic? ............................................................................................................................................ 9 2.2 The Gothic as Hybrid Form ......................................................................................................................... 12 2.3 Gothic Conventions .................................................................................................................................... 15 2.4 Gothic: Escapism or Social Commentary? .................................................................................................. 19 2.5 Gothic Criticism .......................................................................................................................................... 22 2.6 The Ghost of Freud ..................................................................................................................................... 26 2.7 The Gothic Surface: ‘A Writing of Excess’ ................................................................................................... 30 2.8 The Monster and the Abject ....................................................................................................................... 35 2.9 Queer Gothic and Performative Selves ....................................................................................................... 39 2.10 Subversion or Conservatism? ..................................................................................................................... 41 2.11 A Multiplicity of Discourses ........................................................................................................................ 45 Chapter 3. Danish Romanticism and the Gothic ........................................................................................... 50 3.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 50 3.2 European Gothic and Romanticism ............................................................................................................ 51 3.3 Universalromantik: Oehlenschläger and Steffens ...................................................................................... 56 3.4 Oehlenschläger & Staffeldt’s Gothic Ballads .............................................................................................. 59 3.5 Oehlenschläger & Staffeldt: Aladdin & Noureddin ..................................................................................... 63 3.6 National Romanticism ................................................................................................................................ 67 3.7 Bourgeois Mono-Culture: Poetic Realism, Biedermeier, and Fantasten..................................................... 70 3.8 Biedermeier Culture and ‘Everyday Stories’ ............................................................................................... 77 3.9 Dannelsesromanen: The Construction of Bourgeois Identity ..................................................................... 81 3.10 Romantisme: The Dualistic Self .................................................................................................................. 89 3.11 Brandes and the Modern Breakthrough: The End of Romanticism ............................................................ 93 Chapter 4. B.S. Ingemann’s Romantic Gothic Tales: Demons, Darkness and Dobbelgängers ........................... 99 4.1 Bernhard Severin Ingemann: Introduction ................................................................................................. 99 4.2 Ingemann’s Early Works 1811-1822 ........................................................................................................ 101 4.3 Eventyr og Fortællinger (1820): The Prose Breakthrough ........................................................................ 112 4.4 “Altertavlen i Sorø”: The Return of the Past ............................................................................................. 114 4.5 “Moster Maria”: A Romantic Bluebeard .................................................................................................. 118 4.6 ”Sphinxen”: Overview of the Plot ............................................................................................................. 124 4.7 “Sphinxen” and its Genres ........................................................................................................................ 128 4.8 Echoes and Madness ................................................................................................................................ 131 4.9 The Fall into the Abyss: Adolescence and Sexuality ................................................................................. 134 4.10 The Fragmented Self in Ingemann’s Works .............................................................................................. 138 4.11 The Female Doubles ................................................................................................................................. 145 4.12 Doubles and Doppelgängers .................................................................................................................... 147 4.13 Mirrors and Reflections ............................................................................................................................ 150 4.14 ”De Fortryllede Fingre”: The Manipulable Skin ........................................................................................ 156 4.15 The Body as Barrier .................................................................................................................................. 159 4.16 The Persecuted Maiden of the Female Gothic.......................................................................................... 166 4.17 Textual Labyrinths ...................................................................................................................................