DOCSLIB.ORG

2300-Forbes Flyer DEC03-5

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
2300-Forbes Flyer DEC03-5 ForbesForbes FlyerFlyer THE NEWSLETTER OF THE FRANCIS FORBES SOCIETY FOR AUSTRALIAN LEGAL HISTORY ISSUE 3 DECEMBER 2003 History reports itself Making History It is a curious aspect of contemporary culture that the Australian Investigating the South public venerate their sporting heroes and pop idols with such Australian Independent Bar* enthusiasm but spare little thought the men and women who make a significant contribution to government or public service. Of the 150 or so barristers in That is not to say that other nations do not celebrate sporting South Australia, John Emerson or cultural achievements, but in Europe, Canada and America hopes to interview around 100 there is also a certain ethos reserved for great political and legal of them to gain the broadest figures that arguably adds much to the national life. possible perspective for the book The oddity of it is that lack of interest is no explanation. he is writing on the history of the Biographies of the significant politicians or judges of the United South Australian Independent Bar. States of America and Great Britain frequently grace Australian A chance meeting with Justice bookshelves, and names like Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr and Lord John Emerson Tom Gray in 2001 led to discussion Denning have resonance all over the globe. Such is the interest about the history of the Chief in these figures that they have developed their own legend Justices of South Australia, which John was subsequently beyond the community of lawyers. As I write I can be confident commissioned to write (through the John Bray Law that historians somewhere are industriously re-visiting earlier Chapter of the Alumni Association of the University of works and revising, re-interpreting and re-writing the lives and Adelaide). He was asked to write a second book, on the legacies of those well known names. history of the bar, given that the project would involve For the longest time one could not say the same for the similar research, and interviews with many of the same Australian judge. Our legal giants have been fortunate to people as for the book on the Chief Justices. In addition become more than a footnote in the public consciousness. to Justice Gray, the Hon. Christopher Legoe QC was keen Even our most recent and most famous, like Sir Owen Dixon, to initiate a written history of the SA bar, as he was South have been the subject of only limited works. Australia, in many Australia’s first independent barrister. ways, can be said to have short-changed its history, by-passing a One of the challenges for John in writing the 45-year legacy of intellectual rigor and tradition of great public service. history of the bar is to present it in a way that But there is hope that the tide is slowly reversing. encapsulates the very different perspectives of those Historians are placing renewed interest in bringing the lives involved. “At this stage it’s really important to do a and achievements of Australian jurists to public attention. history of the bar while the original people who founded Publishing houses are also offering vital support, with their it are still around (with notable exceptions such as the funding and marketing efforts ensuring that the work finds Hon Howard Zelling and Jack Elliot QC).” He has its ever-present but largely untapped readership. completed 40 interviews and hopes to complete another This edition of the Forbes Flyer showcases extracts of the latest 60 by the end of this year. He began by interviewing books in the series of the Lives of Australian Chief Justices by founders of the various chambers and other senior Dr J.M Bennett (published by Federation Press). Both Sir James members of the profession such as Cedric Isaacson DSO Cockle, the first Chief Justice of Queensland, and Sir John (who practised for around 30 years from 1934 before Pedder, inaugural Chief Justice of Tasmania are featured. there were any real chambers in South Australia) and Dr Bennett is one of the most significant contributors to the The Hon Christopher Legoe QC. The latter, who was the art of legal biography and his most recent works bare the only barrister in SA for at least five or six years, recalled hallmarks of his typically meticulous attention to detailing sitting in his office the first day (in the Epworth building the sources of his original research. in Pirie St) with an all-day sucker, waiting for briefs. The Flyer is also pleased to introduce a new column in this issue, which will highlight the work and research being conducted by Christopher Legoe was also one of the founders of the legal historians around the country. This time round we draw first chambers in 1964: Bar Chambers, with Howard and attention to the work of Dr John Emerson, a South Australian Sesca Zelling. He was later joined by Robin Millhouse and based historian who is currently researching the history of South during the late 1960s Bar Chambers slowly grew, with the Australia’s independent bar, and producing a book on South addition of Michael Detmold, Keith Sangster and Bob Australia’s Chief Justices. Mohr. But it was 13 years before another chambers was established – Hanson – in Carrington Street. Catherine Douglas continue to page 2 Editor THE NEWSLETTER OF THE FRANCIS FORBES SOCIETY FOR AUSTRALIAN LEGAL HISTORY ISSUE 3 DECEMBER 2003 continued from page 1 salary and they’re going to be this Australia. Does he have any idea what individualist type person. Therefore each the future holds after completing the John plans to include a chapter on women one of them is quite different [they are books? He plans to continue writing in the bar and has interviewed (among all] courageous characters and very strong biographies of South Australia’s legal others) Marie Shaw QC, the Hon. Justice personalities . it has been fascinating.” identities and believes there is a large Margaret Nyland and Lindy Powell QC. gap to fill, as he says very few have He notes that although 50% of law The book will include a section about been done to date. graduates are women (this has been the the history of the chambers, which are case for quite some time), a much smaller scattered throughout the city. “Adelaide John Emerson completed his Phd in percentage of barristers in SA are female. has got a spate of little cottages, with French and Australian colonial history John would also like to explore the perhaps a dozen barristers in a cottage last year. He currently works on the experience of young barristers coming in or an old hotel, and a couple of times old two books at least six days per week, over the last few years; why they decided brothels, as opposed to Victoria and NSW surrounded by old law reports in the to join the bar and how they have found where barristers are in massive buildings Staff Library at the University of Adelaide the profession since. all grouped together. That’s interesting, as Law School. to why that might have happened in SA.” He has found the majority of barristers He also wants to investigate how the South interviewed to be supportive, interested Australian Bar has grown and why. *This article was first published in the LSSA and willing to divulge their opinions. Bulletin, Vol 25, No 3 April 2003 “They are the sort of people who can John hopes to complete the history of make this decision to operate essentially the bar by mid 2004, in conjunction with as a sole trader . so they’re not on a his book on the Chief Justices of South The Lives of Australian Chief Justices Dr John Bennett continues his remarkable project, Lives of Australian Chief Justices, with the publication of two new volumes chronicling the lives of the first Chief Justices of Queensland and Tasmania. In the following extract, Dr Bennett reflects on the series so far, outlining how the project started and what he hopes to achieve from writing about the lives of our earliest chief justices. From Sir James Cockle: First Chief As time went on, and the amount of such as indexes, and hardly any of it can Justice of Queensland, 1863-1879 by research material accumulated, the be accessed electronically at the time of JM Bennett. Acknowledgments, challenge presented itself of producing writing this. a series of volumes, cognate as to pages xi-xii In the United Kingdom and the United presentation and length, that would States judicial biographies are generally allow each of my subjects to This being the last study, in the present undertaken and received with great be allocated a separate book. Thanks to series, of the foundation Chief Justices enthusiasm. Generally speaking, that has the sustained interest and commitment in all of the Australian States, the scope not been the case in Australia. This series of The Federation Press, that concept has of the entire project now takes shape. is designed to redress the balance and to become a reality. It is timely to comment on it. encourage an understanding of the way I began this research as a Senior Research While it has been gratifying to find that in which personalities influenced the Fellow at the Australian National some reviewers have declared the works shaping of courts, legal institutions, and University in 1969 and 1970. My initial to be acceptable week-end or vacation the law itself, throughout Australia. plan was to write a collection of reading, that is not their principal object. biographical essays that might be The sources from which to write presented in a single volume.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sir Alfred Stephen and the Jury Question in Van Diemen's Land
    Sir Alfred Stephen and the Jury Question in Van Diemen's Land The Quest for Trial by Jury Just as a child grows and develops into an adult, it cannot but be in- fluenced by background, environment and social conditioning. So it was with the young Van Diemen's Land. Initially, there was the Eng- lish political, social and economic inheritance, which had a great ef- fect on the form of government adopted. Like an authoritarian parent stood the Imperial Parliament, but at the same time, offering some latitude for Van Diemen's Land to engage in some liberal develop- ment. Like a child, Van Diemen's Land offered little resistance. There was a Governor, a judiciary of sorts, and an administrative bu- reaucracy with control over Van Diemen's Land by way of legislation of the Imperial Parliament, such as that of 182 3, 182 8 and 1842. This control led to Van Diemen's Land becoming firmly under the grip of Mother England. The colony now consisted of free settlers, convicts and emancipists, and a few Aboriginals. The colonists must have coined the Nike catch phrase 'Just Do It (for yourself)!' for they sought to enhance their own success and to empower themselves. This was consistent with the attitude of imperialist conquerors throughout the old British Em- pire: to get what they could for themselves in the way of wealth, con- trol and power. There is no better example of this than Governor George Arthur, a career civil servant who amassed a fortune as a landowner and trader, not only in Van Diemen's Land but in other colonies where he saw service.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Queensland Memoir Writer^
    Some Queensland Memoir Writer^. Presidential Address, by F. W. S. CUMBRAE-STEWART, B.A., B.O.L. At Annual Meeting of the Historical Society of Queensland, Friday, 30th August, 1918. Five years have passed since the inaugural meeting of this Society was held under the chairmanship of His Excellency, Sir William Macgregor, then Governor of Queensland and patron of the Society. During the time which has elapsed much history has been made, and the events which have shaken the world have not been favourable to quiet historical research, and I think that the Society must be congratulated on having maintained its existence in spite of so much that has hindered its work. Other difficulties overshadowed us. Before the first year had passed several of our members had died, and Sir William Macgregor had completed his useful and unstinted official service to the Empire. His retirement from the Governorship of Queensland removed him from us to his native;land. None of us who were privileged to be present will forget that morning when, on 15th July, 1914, he said farewell to us. Then came the war, which the wise had foretold, but the foolish ones had thought- was impossible. At one time the question of suspending the Society's operations was considered, but it was decided to carry on. When Sir Wm. Macgregor's successor arrived, he gave very ready and material help by taking the Society under his patronage. There are Others who have passed from our midst whose places we can never fill. Each year has added its toll.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter of the Blue Mountains Association of Cultural Heritage Organisations Inc May-June 2021 ISSUE 74 ISSN 2203-4366
    Heritage Newsletter of the Blue Mountains Association of Cultural Heritage Organisations Inc May-June 2021 ISSUE 74 ISSN 2203-4366 Acknowledgement of Country BMACHO acknowledges and pays respect to the past, present and future Traditional Custodians and Elders of this nation and the continuation of cultural, spiritual and educational practices of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. Sir Francis Forbes, first Chief Justice of NSW (1784-1841) Sir Francis Forbes was the first Chief Justice of New South Wales, appointed to oversee the reform of the administration of law and order in the colony of New South Wales, following the inquiry into the colony's affairs by Commissioner Bigge and Bigge’s subsequent reports of 1822 and 1823. Bigge's investigations began in 1819 following the far reaching changes made in the Colony by Governor Lachlan Macquarie. Before Forbes set up the court system in Australia, people were tried by legal tribunals. Bigge was keen to grant greater jurisdiction to the Local Courts which had previously been administered from England. In the early 1830s Sir Francis Forbes owned the only estate west of the Nepean River, at Emu Plains. Forbes was granted 120 acres at Emu Plains and also 2,560 acres in the Upper Hunter Valley. This land at Muswellbrook, was increased by purchase and used as a cattle run known as Skellatar (Skellater). Edinglassie, Emu Plains, by Conrad Martens 1835 The Edinglassie (or Edenglassie) land grant was at the southern end of Emu Plains, south of Jamison Creek, and upstream from the Emu Plains prison farm, being named after one of 1 HERITAGE May-June 2021 the Forbes family estates in Scotland.
    [Show full text]
  • The Hon Tf Bathurst Chief Justice
    THE HON T F BATHURST CHIEF JUSTICE OF NEW SOUTH WALES FRANCIS FORBES SOCIETY AUSTRALIAN LEGAL HISTORY ‘A TOUGH NUT TO CRACK’1: THE HISTORY OF THE LEGAL PROFESSION IN NEW SOUTH WALES THURSDAY 19 SEPTEMBER 2019* INTRODUCTION 1. I would like to begin by respectfully acknowledging the traditional custodians of the land on which we meet, the Gadigal people of the Eora nation, and pay my respects to their Elders, past, present and emerging. As I will discuss later in this tutorial, the first legal system in Australia belonged to that of Australia’s Indigenous people. We acknowledge and respect the ongoing laws and customs of the traditional custodians of this land. 2. If any of you are here to hear about the development of the law of New South Wales or the history of its courts, you are sure to be disappointed. To console you there will be plenty of these lectures during the Court’s bicentenary in a few years’ time. This speech is about the profession itself, not the law, Courts or judiciary. 3. A traditional view of the advent of the legal profession in New South Wales would focus exclusively on the advent of solicitors, both free and former- convict, and barristers in the emerging penal Colony. However, far too often we conflate the start of the legal profession in New South Wales with the start of the legal profession for men. The advent of the legal profession for women did not occur until over a century later, and regrettably, even later for Australia’s Indigenous peoples.
    [Show full text]
  • Forbes Flyerflyer
    ForbesForbes FlyerFlyer THE NEWSLETTER OF THE FRANCIS FORBES SOCIETY FOR AUSTRALIAN LEGAL HISTORY ISSUE 7 • DECEMBER 2004 History reports itself The Lives of While the year may be rapidly drawing to a close, there Australian is still much activity happening on the publishing front. Chief Justices Following on from the successful third annual Forbes Society lecture, the Forbes Society in conjunction with the Council of Law Reporting for New South Wales will Dr John Bennett continues his remarkable project, publish Dowling's Select Cases, as edited by Tim Castle Lives of Australian Chief Justices with the publication and Bruce Kercher. Chief Justice Spigelman AC will of Sir Henry Wrenfordsley: Second Chief Justice of supply the foreword. Details as to the release of this Western Australia 1880-1883. publication will be available in the New Year. This issue of the Forbes Flyer contains an extract A further development in legal history is the Macquarie discussing Sir Henry Wrenfordsley's appointment Law Monographs: Studies in Law and History, to be as second Chief Justice of Western Australia. edited by Dr Andrew Buck of Macquarie University, and published by Australian Scholarly Publishing. The first In Professor Roy M. Mersky's words (in the Foreword title in the series will be The Poor Man by A.R. Buck and to the book): Nancy E. Wright, and will be available in March 2005. If the life of the law has not been logic, but Dr Buck has advised that the monographs will focus on rather experience, then judicial biography has topics such as legal biographies and the historical a great deal to tell us about the law, and in development of substantive law.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Plunkett's Disappointment
    [2006] ANZLH E-Journal PLUNKETT’S DISAPPOINTMENT: THE REVELANCE OF CATHOLICISM TO A JUDICIAL APPOINTMENT TO THE NEW SOUTH WALES BENCH IN THE 1840s Tony Earls* Prior to the introduction of responsible government in 1856, New South Wales had three Chief Justices, successively; Forbes, Dowling and Stephen. The Crown appointed Forbes on the advice of the Colonial Office in London. With the appointments of Dowling and Stephen, the Colonial Office looked to the advice of the Governor of New South Wales to make an appointment from within the local legal profession. Although William Burton challenged Dowling’s claim to succeed Forbes on a question of seniority, it was the events that led up to the appointment of Stephen, involving two highly credentialed and ambitious candidates, that first tested substantial questions as to rights of precedence and other factors relevant to the appointment. It need hardly be said that the appointment was, and is, a prestigious and important one. However, in order to consider the implications of an appointment, it is useful to attempt to explain why. For the individual, it is the pinnacle of any legal career, affording status and power in their own time and posterity thereafter. In the first half of the nineteenth century this was particularly true when it came to questions of social and governmental rank.1 Amongst other things, a Chief Justice might expect a knighthood following appointment as Chief Justice. As a force in society, the primary influence of a Chief Justice relates not only to the judgement of major cases, but to the administration of the courts, the keystone of the legal system.
    [Show full text]
  • LORD CARRINGTON Papers, 1860-1928 Reels M917-32
    AUSTRALIAN JOINT COPYING PROJECT LORD CARRINGTON Papers, 1860-1928 Reels M917-32 Brigadier A.A. Llewellyn Palmer The Manor House Great Somerford Chippenham, Wiltshire National Library of Australia State Library of New South Wales Filmed: 1972 CONTENTS Page 3 Biographical note 4 Selected speeches, letters and recollections 6 Australian correspondence, 1885-1918 8 Australian papers, 1877-91 9 Newspaper cuttings and printed works, 1882-1915 11 General correspondence, 1885-1928 14 Portraits 14 Miscellaneous papers, 1860-1914 17 Diaries of Lady Carrington, 1881-1913 19 Diaries of Lord Carrington, 1888-93 2 BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE Charles Robert Carrington (1843-1928), 3rd Baron Carrington (succeeded 1868), 1st Earl Carrington (created 1895), 1st Marquess of Lincolnshire (created 1912), was born in London. He was educated at Eton and Trinity College, Cambridge. As a schoolboy, he was introduced to the Prince of Wales and they were to be close friends for over fifty years. Carrington was the Liberal member for High Wycombe in Buckinghamshire in 1865-68. He became a captain in the Royal House Guards in 1869 and in 1875-76 was aide-de-camp to the Prince of Wales on his tour of India. In 1881 he was appointed lieutenant-colonel of the Royal Buckinghamshire Infantry. In 1878 he married Cecilia (Lily) Harbord, the daughter of Baron Suffield. In 1885, at the urging of the Prince of Wales, Carrington was appointed governor of New South Wales. With his wife and three daughters, he arrived in Sydney in December 1885 and they remained in the colony for almost five years. The Carringtons were a popular couple and generous hosts, especially during the celebrations of Queen Victoria’s jubilee in 1887 and the New South Wales centenary celebrations in 1888.
    [Show full text]
  • SIR WILLIAM DENISON Papers, 1846-64 Reels M606-607, M671
    AUSTRALIAN JOINT COPYING PROJECT SIR WILLIAM DENISON Papers, 1846-64 Reels M606-607, M671 Col. W.M.W. Denison Newark Nottinghamshire National Library of Australia State Library of New South Wales Filmed: 1960 BIOGRAPHICAL NOTE William Thomas Denison (1804-1871) was born in London and attended Eton and the Royal Military College. He graduated in 1826 as a lieutenant in the Royal Engineers. He served in Canada and later worked on harbour defences in southern England. In 1838 he married Caroline Hornby and they had six sons and four daughters. He was promoted to the rank of captain in 1841. In 1846, following the dismissal of Sir John Eardley-Wilmot, he was appointed Lieutenant-Governor of Van Diemen’s Land. He was knighted in the same year and awarded a KCB in 1856. He arrived in the colony in January 1847 and held the office for eight years. A strong supporter of the continuance of convict transportation, he clashed with the nominated Legislative Council and two of the judges. The publication of some of his despatches, criticising the colonists generally, added to his unpopularity. His powers were reduced following the creation of an elected Legislative Council in 1850 and, with the cessation of transportation, his later years in Tasmania were more harmonious. In January 1855 Denison was appointed Governor of New South Wales and was given the additional title of ‘Governor-General of Australia’. Prompted by the Crimean War, he immediately reorganised the defences of Sydney Harbour. He presided over the introduction of responsible government in the colony in 1856 and had to deal with considerable political instability, with three ministries formed in the first year.
    [Show full text]
  • Celebrating Clayton Utz We Have Undergone Many Changes Since Then
    CELEBRATING Clayton Utz We have undergone many changes since then. However the essence of Clayton Utz, expressed in the personal qualities of our founding father George Robert Nichols, remains very much the same. Among his many virtues, Nichols was known for his legal astuteness, his passion for justice, and his desire to improve his community. These are qualities for which Clayton Utz is still known, and it is with great pride that we reflect on the contribution that George Robert Nichols and the individuals who followed in his footsteps have made in making Clayton Utz the firm we are today. In an increasingly competitive legal market, Clayton Utz consistently stands out for the quality of our legal work and our people. Our commitment to the community is also an important part of who we are, and we are proud of our Community Connect program which reaches out to hundreds of individuals and organisations across the country through pro bono legal work, financial assistance through grants, and volunteering. We thank our people for their ongoing support of the program, and for the investment they have made and continue to make in our firm. In celebrating 175 years of legal service to the Australian community, One hundred and seventy five years ago, the we also acknowledge the enormous contribution of the many people who over the years have helped to build the Clayton Utz community. foundations were laid for what today is one From a one-man firm in colonial Sydney, we are now a truly national of Australia’s greatest law firms - our firm, firm with 216 partners and over 950 lawyers in six offices around Australia, servicing the needs of our many valued and loyal clients whenever - and wherever - they are doing business.
    [Show full text]
  • Stephen, Robert Campbell
    Stephen, Robert Campbell ASC 1886 HONOURED BY THE KING; COLONEL ROBERT CAMPBELL STEPHEN. Who has been created a Companion of the Bath. Colonel Stephen is the eldest son of the late Hon. S. A. Stephen, of Sydney. He was educated at All Saints' College, Bathurst, and then entered Trinity College, Cambridge. After leaving the University he joined the militia, and obtained a commission In the King's Liverpool Regiment. Subsequently, he received a commission in, and was adjutant of, the 14th Hussars, and also of the Imperial Warwickshire Yeomanry. He commanded the 14th Hussars in India up to the commencement of the war, when he was made colonel, and retained the command for about a year. While stationed at Meerut he was brigadier-general, and from there went to Mesopotamia' in command of the 6th Cavalry Brigade. He returned from there on March 16 last year, suffering from a bad attack of dysentery, and is now in London waiting to be passed by the Medical Board as fit for further active service. Colonel Stephen is a brother of Mr. Colin Stephen, of Messrs. Stephen, Jaques, and Stephen, solicitors. BRIGADIER-GENERAL STEPHEN RETURNS TO SYDNEY. After a distinguished career with the British Army, Brigadier-General Robert Campbell Stephen, who is related to the Messrs. Stephen, of the Sydney Arm of solicitors, Stephen, Jaques, and Stephen, returned by the Cathay yesterday to Australia? He want to England when a boy, and entered Trinity College, Cambridge. There he entered the 14th Hussars, in which he rose rapidly. In 1896 he was promoted to the rank of captain, and in the same year became adjutant.
    [Show full text]
  • Index to Compilation of Speeches Delivered by the Hon. J J Spigelman, AC, Chief Justice of NSW in 2002
    Index to compilation of speeches delivered by the Hon. J J Spigelman, AC, Chief Justice of NSW in 2002 Page number Date speech Description reference within delivered pdf compilation Foundations of the freedom of the press in 20 November 2002 Australia - The Inaugural Australian Press Page 2 of 194 Council address Re-dedication of the honour roll in the original 11 November 2002 Page 18 of 194 Supreme Court building Address upon the occasion of the retirement of 8 November 2002 Page 20 of 194 the Honourable Mr Justice Philip Powell AM Are Lawyers Lemons? Competition Principles 29 October 2002 Page 24 of 194 and Professional Regulation 12 October 2002 The Idea of a University Page 41 of 194 8 October 2002 Becket and Henry II: Exile Page 44 of 194 Convergence and the Judicial Role: Recent Developments in China - Address to the XVIth 16 July 2002 Page 68 of 194 Congress of the International Academy of Comparative Law Convergence and the Judicial Role: Recent 11 July 2002 Developments in China - Address to the China Page 91 of 194 Education Centre, University of Sydney June 2002 Guide to Judicial Conduct Page 113 of 194 17 May 2002 The Maintenance of Institutional Values Page 155 of 194 Negligence: The Last Outpost of the Welfare 27 April 2002 Page 162 of 194 State Negligence: The Last Outpost of the Welfare 27 April 2002 Page 164 of 194 State (Summary) Formal Opening Ceremony Court of Criminal 8 February 2002 Page 180 of 194 Appeal at Dubbo 29 January 2002 Opening to Law Term Dinner 2002 Page 186 of 194 Foreward to G Lindsay, No Mere Mouthpiece: 2002 Servants of All Yet of None, Chatswood, Page 191 of 194 LexisNexis Butterworths, 2002 Foreward to J Anderson, J Hunter and N Williams, The New Evidence Law: Annotations 2002 Page 193 of 194 and Commentary on the Uniform Evidence Acts, Sydney, LexisNexis 2002 Foundations of the Freedom of the Press in Australia - The Inaugural Australian Press ..
    [Show full text]
  • In 1963, When He Was Already a Senior Lecturer in Law at The
    Australian Journal of Legal History (2003) Vol 7 37 ALEX CASTLES ON THE RECEPTION OF ENGLISH LAW BRUCE KERCHER* In 1963, when he was already a Senior Lecturer in Law at the University of Adelaide, Alex Castles wrote his first important legal history article, called ‘The Reception and Status of English Law in Australia’.1 It was very much a creature of its intellectual times, but, particularly in its discussion of American law, it also showed something of the Alex Castles to come. In this paper, I intend to trace his views on the area which I think is his central interest, the reception and rejection of Englishness in Australian law. The argument of Alex’s article, so far as it related to Australia, was in the positivist tradition which was so dominant at the time it was written. With positivism came an attachment to England as the source of both the authority of Australian law and its fundamental contents. In the first paragraph, the article stated that ‘Up to the time of their settlement each of the Australian States has the same legal history as Britain. The basic sources of law in both countries are the same.’ There was no hint that the Aboriginal peoples of Australian might have had laws which were displaced by the actions and decisions of the British. Nor does the article question the notion that Australia was peacefully settled among a scattering of native peoples, but of course no lawyers, academic or otherwise, questioned these assumptions in 1963. This article tells the official story of the reception of English law, one in which law- making powers, and the bulk of the law, were essentially English and trickled downwards to the colonies.
    [Show full text]