Marianne Oswald Et La Critique Musicale : La Construction Du Personnage Artistique Depuis Ses Multiples Perspectives
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
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`(&(8'-8(!^7_'&(6O!>#'!=37!%/7#2%!.7&*!5(66(!78(&6#+(!#&'8(+*'67'+(!.(/#'*! 27! 60#6(! /+(='-+(! 7&&%(X! :(+5'! 1! 27! /+0?(**(#+(! I#2'(! B(.&(7#26U@(*27#+'(+*! /0#+! *(*! Y#.'5'(#\!50==(&67'+(*!20+*!.(!23%872#76'0&!.(!5(!6+787'2X!I37'=(+7'*!%$72(=(&6!*0#2'$&(+! =7! /+0?0&.(! $+76'6#.(! (&8(+*! 27! /+0?(**(#+(! I7.7! a76*0&O! (&! >#'! Y37'! (#! 27! 5,7&5(! .(! 6+0#8(+!#&(!=(&60+!(6!#&(!50&?'.(&6(X! ! @(*! +(=(+5'(=(&6*! /7+6'5#2'(+*! 80&6! 1! :7.7=(! I7&'&(! :7+5UB(_(6! >#'! 7! 60#Y0#+*! Y08'72(=(&6!+%/0&.#!1!=(*!&0=9+(#*(*!>#(*6'0&*!(6!>#'!=37!/7+67$%!#&!&0=9+(!'=/0+67&6! .(!.05#=(&6*!'**#*!.(!*(*!7+5,'8(*!(6!.(*!7+5,'8(*!/(+*0&&(22(*!.(!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.O!5(#\U 5'!7H7&6!50&*'.%+792(=(&6!50&6+'9#%!1!5(66(!+(5,(+5,(X! ! :(+5'!7#\!=(=9+(*!.(!=7!?7='22(b!=7!=-+(O!C27#.(!c75,7;&(O!=0&!/-+(O!:'5,(2!)(**'(+! (6!=7!*0(#+O!:'+('22(!)(**'(+O!>#'!*0&6!#&(!'==(&*(!*0#+5(!.3'&*/'+76'0&!/0#+!=0'X!I(!*#'*! /+0?0&.%=(&6!+(50&&7'**7&6(!/0#+!2(#+!7//#'!(6!/0#+!23'&6%+d6!*'&5-+(!>#3'2*!/0+6(&6!(&8(+*! =(*! %6#.(*! #&'8(+*'67'+(*X! :(+5'! 1! =(*! $+7&.*U/7+(&6*O! e75,-2(! f6U@(&'*! c75,7;&(! (6! ".=0&.!c75,7;&(!/0#+!27!5#+'0*'6%!>#3'2*!0&6!/0+6%(!(&8(+*!5(66(!+(5,(+5,(!(6!/0#+!2(*! &0=9+(#\!2'8+(*!6'+%*!.(!27!9'92'06,->#(!/(+*0&&(22(!.(!=0&!$+7&.U/-+(O!>#3'2!7!8020&6'(+*! ='*!1!=7!.'*/0*'6'0&X! ! g2!=(!?7#6!*0#2'$&(+!23'&(*6'=792(!872(#+!.#!*0#6'(&!(6!.#!+]2(!>#37!Y0#%!fH287'&!^%+#9%O! =0&! /2#*! $+7&.! 50=/2'5(O! .#+7&6! 5(*! .(#\! .(+&'-+(*! 7&&%(*X! [! .%?7#6! .(! &(! /0#80'+! (\/+'=(+! 27! /+0?0&.(#+! .(! =7! $+76'6#.(! (&8(+*! 2#'O! Y(! 2(! +(=(+5'(! /0#+! *0&! '&?'&'(! $%&%+0*'6%O!*7!/76'(&5(!(6!*7!/+%*(&5(X! ! I37'=(+7'*!?'&72(=(&6!+(=(+5'(+!234502(!.(!=#*'>#(!(6!23D&'8(+*'6%!.3E667F7O!2(!e%$'=(! .(! 90#+*(! .3%6#.(*! *#/%+'(#+(*! .(! 23E&67+'0! (6! 234>#'/(! =#*'>#(! (&! P+7&5(! .(! 23E9*(+8760'+(!'&6(+.'*5'/2'&7'+(!.(!5+%76'0&!(6!.(!+(5,(+5,(!(&!=#*'>#(!/0#+!2(#+!7//#'! ?'&7&5'(+!60#6!7#!20&$!.(!5(!/+05(**#*X!! ! ! '8! @>?!B#EB<#)>@CF:B<! :;<=);!!!!!!!!!! ++, >?<@:>A@!!!!!!!!!! +++, :B)B:ACB)BD@<!!!!!!!! +-, @>?!B#EB<#)>@CF:B<!!!!!!!! -! !C<@B#EB<#GCH=:B<# !!!!!!! -++, ! CD@:-E=A@C-D!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! L! h#(2>#(*!%2%=(&6*!9'0$+7/,'>#(*!! ! ! ! ! ! ! L! B+092%=76'>#(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! i! e%*#=%!.(*!5,7/'6+(*!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! j! ! AI>JC@:B#K#5#A&0*"#1LM6*+23"#"1#4M1L606/68+"!! ! ! ! M! C7.+(!6,%0+'>#(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! M! B(+*0&&7$(!7+6'*6'>#(!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! LK! :%=0'+(!5022(56'8(!(6!,'*60'+(!5#26#+(22(!!! ! ! ! ! Li! C+'6'>#(!=#*'572(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! JJ! :%6,0.020$'(!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Ji! ! <&72H*(!.(!50&6(&#!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Ji! ! B%+'0.(!1!23%6#.(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Jj! ! c37#609'0$+7/,'(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! JV! ! AI>JC@:B#N#5#J&*%63*'#"1#%6,1"O1"#'6%+6L+'16*+23"!! ! ! ! ZZ! B%+'0.(!<22(=7&.(!QLMKLULMZJS!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ZR! ! :7+'7&&(!E*F72.!(6!27!5#26#+(!.(!a('=7+!! ! ! ! ! ZR! ! c(!6,%k6+(!(6!2(!5797+(6!9(+2'&0'*!! ! ! ! ! ! ZW! ! .)*"#*/*/,012+3!(6!27!?'&!.3#&(!%/0>#(!! ! ! ! ! RK! B%+'0.(!P+7&T7'*(!QLMZJULMVWS!! ! ! ! ! ! ! RZ! ! c(!412+'&("$$!(6!23'=7$(!.(!27!?(==(!! ! ! ! ! RZ! ! c(!^l#?!*#+!2(!60'6!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! RW! c7!5,7&*0&!+%72'*6(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! WK! c7!5,7&*0&!*05'72(!(6!2(!+%72'*=(!*05'72'*6(!! ! ! ! ! ! WZ# # 8! AI>JC@:B#P#5#!"#73Q/+%#"1#/"'1+6,#0"#/R&31L",1+%+1M!! ! ! WV! c(!/7+7.0\(!.(!237#6,(&6'5'6%!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! iK! e(/+%*(&676'0&!/(+*0&&'?'%(!.#!m!8+7'!n!! ! ! ! ! iJ! `'22(*!(6!I#2'(&!?75(!1!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.!! ! ! ! ! ij! <#U.(21!.#!+%72'*=(!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! jK! ! c7!?(==(!09Y(6!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! jL! ! B2#*!+%(22(!>#(!2(!=0&.(!+%(2!o!! ! ! ! ! ! jZ! e%5'/+0>#(+!237#6,(&6'5'6%! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! jM! C0&52#*'0&*!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! VR! ! AI>JC@:B!S#5#!"#7"*'6,,&8"#+,%&*,M#"1#/R"O"47/"#0R$#>,,&#/&#Q6,,"#(#! Vj! m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n!8#(!/7+!I(7&!C056(7#!(6!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.!! ! ! VV! g&6(+/+%6(+!m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n!! ! ! ! ! ! ! MJ! ! m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n!50&6+(!27!90#+$(0'*'(!! ! ! ! ! MZ! e%?2(\'0&*!*#+!27!?%='&'6%!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! MW! ! m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n!7#Q\S!?%='&'&Q*S!! ! ! ! ! ! MV! 4802#6'0&!.#!/(+*0&&7$(!7+6'*6'>#(!A!c(!+]2(!.(!27!/+(**(!! ! ! ! LKL! C0&52#*'0&*!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! LLK! ! A-DA!=<C-D!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! LLJ! D&(!5,7&*0&!?%='&'&(!o!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! LLZ! :7+'7&&(!E*F72.!7#U.(21!.(*!7&&%(*!LMZK!! ! ! ! ! ! LLi! ! ?C?!C-H:>JICB! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! LLM! >DDBTB#>#U#)60V/"#0R&,&/W'"#0"#JL+/+7#>3'/&,0"*#X1&Q/"&3#6*+8+,&/Y## LJM# ! >DDBTB#?#U#J&*6/"'#0"#/&#%L&,'6,#$#>,,&#/&#Q6,,"#(# # # # LZK# ! ! 8'! !C<@B#EB<#GCH=:B<# # # AL&7+1*"#K#5# ! P'$X!LXL!A!C0&*'.%+76'0&*!=%6,0.020$'>#(*!Q)(**'(+S!! ! ! ! LK! ! P'$X!LXJ!A!)+7.#56'0&!.#!=0.-2(!.37&72H*(!.(!27!/(+?0+=7&5(!! =#*'572(!Q<#*27&.(+S! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! LJ! ! # AL&7+1*"#P#5## ! P'$X!ZXL!A!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.!/,060$+7/,'%(!7#!^l#?!*#+!2(!60'6! ! ! RV! ! ! AL&7+1*"#S#5## ! P'$X!RXL!A!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.!/,060$+7/,'%(!.7&*!*0&!50*6#=(!! /0#+!m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ML! ! P'$X!RXJ!A!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.!(6!I(7&!C056(7#!/,060$+7/,'%*!! /0#+!m!<&&7!27!90&&(!n! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ML! # 8''! CD@:-E=A@C-D! ! c7! *5-&(! 5#26#+(22(! (6! =#*'572(! /0/#27'+(! ?+7&T7'*(! .(*! 7&&%(*! LMZK! (*6! '&.#9'6792(=(&6!=7+>#%(!/7+!23'=/0+67&6(!/+%*(&5(!.(*!?(==(*X!^'(&!>#3#&(!=#26'/2'5'6%! (6!#&(!.'8(+*'6%!.(!5,7&6(#*(*!7'(&6!/7+6'5'/%!1!23(**0+!5#26#+(2!=%50&&#L!.(!5(66(!.%5(&&'(O! 2(!m!57*!n!.(!27!5,7&6(#*(!:7+'7&&(!E*F72.O!50==(!0&!8'(&.+7!1!2(!*#+&0==(+!.7&*!27! 5+'6'>#(!=#*'572(!.(!23%/0>#(O!(&!(*6!#&!*7'*'**7&6!(6!+(=7+>#792(!1!/2#*'(#+*!%$7+.*X!f0&! /(+*0&&7$(! 7+6'*6'>#(O! 50==(! Y3H! ?(+7'! +%?%+(&5(! 60#6! 7#! 20&$! .(! 5(66(! +(5,(+5,(O! &0#*! /(+=(6!.(!&0#*!/(&5,(+!(6!.37+6'5#2(+!5(+67'&*!.(*!(&Y(#\!'=/0+67&6*!.%50#27&6!.(!5(66(! /%+'0.(O!5(!>#(!&0#*!09*(+8(+0&*!/+'&5'/72(=(&6!1!6+78(+*!27!/+(**(!=#*'572(!>#'!*3H!(*6! ?0+6(=(&6!'&6%+(**%(X!C(!/(+*0&&7$(!*3'&*-+(!.3790+.!7#!5l#+!.(!5(+67'&(*!.(*!&0#8(22(*! /+092%=76'>#(*!*(!=7&'?(*67&6!*#+!27!*5-&(!=#*'572(!/0/#27'+(!.(!23(&6+(!$#(++(O!&060&*!2(*! 787&5%(*! 6(5,&020$'>#(*! 50==(! 2(! .'*>#(O! 2(! 5'&%=7! (6! 27! +7.'0O! =7'*! %$72(=(&6! 1! #&! =0=(&6!0p!2(*!6(&*'0&*!*05'72(*!(6!/02'6'>#(*!*3'=='*5(&6!.(!=7&'-+(!50&*'.%+792(!7#!5l#+! .(*!.%976*!7+6'*6'>#(*X!! ! Z3"/23"'#M/M4",1'#Q+68*&7L+23"'# :7+'7&&(!E*F72.!QLMKLULMVWSO!0#!f7+7,!<2'5(!^205,Uq7,&O!(*6!&%(!.7&*!27!8'22(! .(!f7++($#(='&(*!(&!c0++7'&(O!720+*!>#(!5(!6(++'60'+(!%67'6!60#Y0#+*!7&&(\%!/7+!23<22(=7$&(X! E+/,(2'&(!6]6!1!237.02(*5(&5(O!(22(!/+(&.!8'6(!50&6756!78(5!2(!6,%k6+(!/7+!23(&6+(='*(!.(!*7!