METHODIST HISTORY

VOLUME XXIII

October 1984 - July 1985

Charles Yrigoyen, Jr _, Editor

Published by General Commission on Archives and History The United Methodist Church Madison, New Jersey

------Contributors and Articles

Baker, Frank Riding the Rounds with John Wesley 163 Barton, J. Hamby The Two Versions of the First Edition of John Wesley's The Sunday Service of the Methodists in ...... 153 Dickerson, Dennis C. William Fisher Dickerson: Northern PreacherjSouthern Prelate ... 135 Forbes, Bruce David "And Obey God, Etc.": and American Indians 3 Handy~ Robert T. American Methodism and Its Historical Frontier: Interpreting Methodism on the Western Frontier: Between Romanticism and Realism ...... 44 Patterson, L. Dale Improvement in Methodist Ministerial Education at the End of the Nineteenth Century...... 68 Perry, Stephen The Revival of Stewardship and the Creation of the World Service Commission in the Methodist Episcopal Church, 1912-1924 ...... 223 Prim, G. Clinton Southern Methodism in the Confederacy ...... 240 Richey, Russell E. From Quarterly to Camp Meeting: A Reconsideration of Early American Methcdism 199 Ryder, Mary R. Avoiding the "Many-Headed Monster": Wesley and Johnson on Enthusiasm 214 Stein, K. James I 784-Historical-Theological-Ecclesiastical 25 Strong, Douglas M. Partners in Political Abolitionism: The Liberty Party and the Wesleyan Methodist Connection 99 Williamson, Douglas J. Willbur Fisk and African Colonization: A "Painful Portion" of American Methodist History 79 General Index Volume XXIII, October 1984 - July 1985

Abolition, 87, 99-115 Board of Home Missions, 226 Adams, Daniel, 10 Board of Negro Education, 230 African colonization, 79-98 Boles, John B., 20 I A.M.E. Church, 135-152 Book of Common Prayer, 153 A.M.E. Zion Church, 144 Book Reviews, 61, 121, 191,252 Agnew, Theodore L., 44, 46, 64 Boot, John, 8 Allegheny Mountains, 46 Boston Tea Party, 118 Allen, Richard, 135, 138 Bowers, Susan, 54, 56 Allen University, 147, 151 Bowne, Borden Parker, 236 American Anti- Society, 102 Boyd, R. R., 176 American Board of Commissioners for British M. E. Church, 145 Foreign Missions, 8 Brown, Hallie Quinn, 138 American Colonization Society, 79 Brown, John M., 142, 146 American and Foreign Anti-Slavery Brown, Morris, 138, 144 Society, 103, I 10 Browning, William H., 242, 248 American Wesleyan Anti-Slavery Bruce, Jr., Dickson D., 201 Society, 104 Brunson, Alfred, II American Indians, 3-24 Buckles, L. c., 175 Anderson, J. Monroe, 244 Burts Meeting House, 56 Andrews, John, 39 Bushnell, Horace, 69 Anglicanism, 214-222 Byrne, Donald, 53 Archives and History, General Commission on, Annual Meeting, 131 Cain, Richard H., 141, 142, 143, 149, Arminian Magazine. The. 166 150, 152 Articles of Religion, 33, 113 Calkins, Harvey Reeves, 234, 236 Asbury, Francis, 4, 25-43, 51, 52, 135, Calkins, L. W., 176 155, 156,202,208,211,212 , 113 Asbury Manual Labor School, 8 Campbell, Jabez P., 136, 137, 138, 142, Ashmun Institute, 136 143, 146 Astwood, H.C.C., 144 Camp meetings, 52, 199-213 Atlanta University, 140 Canadian Indian missions, 10 Auman, Orrin W., 232, 233 Capers, William, 7 Ayling, Stanley, 222 Case, William, 10 Centenary campaign, 226, 232, 233 Bacon, Leonard W., 47 Centenary Conservation Committee, 227 Baird, W. F., 174 Chautauqua Sunday School movement, 68 Baker, Fraflk, 134, 163 Checote, 8 Baltimore, M D, 25-43 Cherokees, 4, 8, 20 Bangs, Nathan, 10, 35 Chicago Temple, 223 , f Barnes, Daniel, 10 Chickasaws, 4, 8 Barratt's Chapel, 28, 161 Choctaws, 4, 8 Barton, C. M., 226 Christian perfection, 113 Barton, J. Hamby, 134, 153 Christian Recorder, The, 138, 139, 152 Bennett, William W., 241 Christmas Conference, 25-43, 51, 151, 155 Benson, Lee, 112 Churchey, Walter, 159 Bethel A.M.E. Church, Philadelphia, 135 Cincinnati University, 72 Between-the-Logs, 6 Circuit riders, 45, 53 l,, !I Birney, James, 102, 104, 107 Circuits, 206 Blackmore, Sophia, 250 Cist, Charles, 155 Board of Foreign Missions, 226, 228 Civil Rights Act of 1875, 152 r f - 256

Clark, John, 10, 11 Dorchester, Daniel, 24 Clark, M. A., 15 Douglass, S. T., 139 Clark University, 148 Downey, David G., 229, 231 Clay, Henry, 107 Drew Theological Seminary, 69, 70 Clegg, Leland, 9 Drew University, 153, 158 Closed communion, 36 Clough, A. B., 174 Ebenezer Manual Labor School, 11 Coe, George, 69 Ecclesiological issues, 37 Coke, Thomas, 4, 25-43, 51, 154-163, Ecumenical Methodist Conference, 144 199,210,211 Education, 36 Coker, Daniel, 138 Elbright, Ozias, 171 Collective bargaining, 233 Emancipation Proclamation, 107 College, Methodist, 36 Emory, Robert, 153 Colonization, 79-98 Enthusiasm, 214-222 Colorado Conference, 232 Episcopacy, 105 Colorado Seminary, 72 Epworth League, 230 C.M.E. Church, 144, 145 Ewing, T. R., 172 Combe, George, 50 Commission on Courses of Study, 74 Commission on Finance, 225 Falley, Mabel C., 235 Committee of Twenty-One, 229, 232, 233 Farmer, William B., 229, 230, 231 Confederacy, 240-249 Federal Indian policy, 19 Conference as revival, 204 Fillmore, Daniel, 89, 95 Conference Course of Study, 81 Financial administration, 223-239 Cooper, D. C., 173, 175 Finley, James 8., 6, 10, 20 Cooper, Ezekiel,161, 199,205,207,210, Fisk, Clinton 8., 24 212 Fisk, Willbur, 79-98; elected bishop, 80 Copway, George, 11 Flathead, 12, 81 Correspondence School, 76, 77 Fletcher, John William, 117, 118 Council of Boards of Benevolence, 229, Flournoy, Josiah, 86, 88, 89 232 Forbes, Bruce David, 2, 3 Course of study, 68-78 Forsyth, David D., 226, 227, 228, 233 Cranston, Earl, 72 Fort, John Lowe, 226 Crawford, James, 184 Foster, J. N., 184, 187 Creeks, 7, 8 Fowles, George, 230, 231 Creighton, John, 27 Franklin, Benjamin, 117 Cross, Whitney, 110 Frazier, E. Franklin, 86 Cuninggim, Jesse, 68, 77 Free African Society, 135 Cushman, Ralph, 238 Free Soil Party, 107 Frontier of Methodism, 44-53 Dartmouth, Lord, 116-120 Fullerton, Thomas, 3 Davenport, T. D., 247 Dawes Act, 23 Gaines, Wesley J., 143, 147, 148, 151 Deed of Declaration, 165 Garnet, Henry Highland, 139 Delawares, 9, 12 Garrett Biblical Institute, 227, 228, 233 Delay, Jacob, 184, 185 Garrettson, Freeborn, 29, 158, "59, 204, Demarest, Isabella, 137 208 Dickerson, Dennis C., 134, 135 Garrison, William Lloyd, 100, 101, 102, Dickerson, Henry and Sophia, 136 103, 108 Dickerson, William Fisher, 135-152 Garvey, Marcus, 97 Dickinson, A. E., 245 General Council on Finance and DJSCOYERY, 54,116, 168, 250 Administration, 223, 230 Dodge, William E., 136 Genesee Conference, 10 Doraisamy, Theodore R., 250 Georgia, 3. 136. J46. 164, 166 257

Gibson, J. L., 179 Jones, J. William, 243 Goen, C. c., 47 Joy, James R., 154 Goodell, William, 102 Granberry, John c., 243 Kansas, 6, 9, 12 Graves, J. R., 48 Kavanaugh, Hubbard H., 240 Grimke, Francis J., 138 Keith, Fordyce M., 184 Kickapoo, 9 Hamilton, Kate W., 234 King, David, II Handy, Robert T., 2, 44 Kingsbury, Benjamin; 84, 90 Hankins, J. c., 185 Kittrell College, 15 I Harmon, Nolan, 153, 154 Knox, C. E., 185, 186 Harper, Frances Ellen, 139 Kraut, Alan, 112 Harvey, Van A., 52 Haskins, Thomas, 39 La Grange College, 116 Haygood, Atticus G., 242 Lake Mohonk Conferences, 24 Hayne, J. E., 150 Latson, Joel, 179 Heard, C. M., 73 Lawson, John, 214 Hicks, John, 18 Laymen's Missionary Movement, 225, 233 Holdich, Joseph, 8I Leak, R. H. W., 151 Holloway, Emma Lou, 96 Lee, Benjamin F., 143 Holsey, Lucius H., 145 Lee, Daniel, 13 Horne, Frank A., 230, 231 Lee, Jason,S, 13, 81 Horsley, Samuel, 48 Lee, Jesse, 30, 160,203, 210 Horton, Jotham, 105 Lee, Luther, 101-115 Hoskins, John, 27 LeFlore, Greenwood, 8 Huddleston, Allen, I I, 12 Legal Hundred, 165 Hudson', Winthrop S., 47 Legge, William, 117 Liberator, 100, 10 I, 108, III L Hughes, Edwin Holt, 223 I Liberia, 14, 85 I Huntingdon, Countess of, 117 Liberty Party, 99-115 Iliff School of Theology, 72, 233 Liberty Standard, III Illinois Conference, 11 Lincoln, Abraham, 168 Indian Mission Conference, 9, 12 Lincoln University, 136, 137, 140, 147 t Indian Rights Association, 24 Longley, M. M., 178, 183, 188 III.1 Indian schools, 9 Lord's Supper, 206 - ~i I Indonesia, 250 Love Feast. 206 11 Interchurch World Movement, 228, 238 Lovely Lane Chapel, 25 Itinerants' Club, 68-78 Lowth, Richard, 27 II Loyd, J. F., 170, 189 " Ludlum, David M., 108 Jackson, Thomas, 164 Lynch, James, 142 ; " Jaco, Peter, 165 Jarratt, Devereux, I 18 Jenifer, John T., 143, 148, 151 McClain, J. F., 178 John's Island, SC, 146 McClary, T. M., 176 Johnson, Charles A., 200 McConnel, S. D., 184, 186 Johnson, David, 171 McConnell, Francis J., 232, 236, 237 Johnson, John, II, 12 McCoy, Isaac, 20 Johnson, Samuel, 214-222 McDonald, B. W., 247 Johnson, Thomas, 9 McFerrin, John B., 241, 243, 246 Johnson, William E., 149, 150, 152 McGready, James, 202 Johnston, James H. A., 140 McHenry, James, 8 Joint Centenary Commission, 238 McKendree, William, 7 Jones, Absalom, 135 McKendree Chapel, 173, 175

------...... _-----_.- 258

McLaughlin, William, 8 Oden, William, 9 McLeod, Dickson, 20 Oechsli, Leonard, 250 McMurry College, 168 Oglethorpe, 4 Malaysia, 250 Ohio Conference, 6, 7, 169 Mangum, Adolph W., 245 Ojibwa, 3, 10, II Marksman, Peter, II Oklahoma, 5, 7, 8, 9, 12 Martin, J. Sella, 142 Oldham, Marie Augusta, 250-251 Maser, Frederick E., 54, 116, 168, 250 Oldham, William F., 250 Abolition Society, 103, 105 Oneida missions, 10, II Mathews, Donald G., 79, 96, 201 Oregon Mission, 13 Matlack, Lucius, 104, 108, 110 Oviatt, G. D., 175 Matthews, Timothy S., 184 Owen, William, 245 Meacham, James, 268 Merrill, Abram D., 84 Page, John, 8 Merritt, Timothy, 93 Patterson, L. Dale, 66, 68 Methodist Federation for Social Action, Paul Quinn College, 151 232 Payne, Daniel A., 136, 138, 139, 141, Methodist Magazine, The, 164, 166,210 142, 144 Methodist missions, 14 Payne High School, 147, 148 Methvin, John Jasper, 19 Payne Institute, 147 Miller, John Franklin, 176 Peoria, 9 Mills, Sr., Frederick V., 116 Perkins, Jared, 84 Mills, William G., 242 Perry, Stephen, 198, 223 Ministerial education, 68-78 Peterson, P. A., 153 Minnesota Conference, 12 Philippines, 250 Missionaries, training of, 81 Pilcher, Benjamin L., 168, 169 Missionary Society, 7, 13, 227 Pilcher, John Nelson, 169-190 Mississippi, 9 Pitezel, John H., II, 12 Mississippi Conference, 8 Pointer, Jonathan, 6, 10 Missouri, 9 Polk, James K., 107 Missouri Conference, 10 Potawatomies, 9, 10 Miyakawa, T. Scott, 46 Prim, G. Clinton, 198, 240 Mohawk, 10; language Bible, 81 Priolean, L. S., 146 Mononcue, 6, 10 Moore, Henry, 164, 165 Quakers, 79, 220 Morgan, John, 184 Quarterly conference, 199-213 Morris, James W., 137, 139 Queen, Louise L., 67 Morris Brown College, 147, 148, 151 Quinney, Electa, II Mossell, Charles W., 137, 144 Mossell, Mary Ella, 144, 151 Rail, Harris Franklin, 233, 236 Rankin, Thomas, 116-120 Native Americans, 3-24 Reason, 216 Neely, Richard, 8 Reformed Methodist Union Episcopal Christian Advocate, 105 Church, 150 New England Conference, 80, 81,91,101 Renfroe, J. J. D., 246 Nez Perce, 12, 81 Revival, 204, 210 Nineteenth Amendment, 235 Rhodes, H. .I., 137 Noll, William T., 54 Richey, Russell E., J98, 199 Nolley, Richmond, 48 Roman Catholics, 242 North, Frank Mason, 227 Rutherford, Thomas, 164, 165 North Carolina Christian Advocate, 240 Ryder, Mary R., 198,214 Northwestern University, 227, 228 Northwest Kansas Conference, 74, 75 Norwood,Frederick A., 46 259

St. George's Church, 118, 135 Taylor, S. Earl, 226, 227, 228 Salem Mission, 10 Telford, John, 164 Sawyer, Joseph, 10 Tennessee, 9, 170-190 Schaff, Philip, 49 Tennessee Conferenee~ 21 Scott, Hugh R" 243 Texas, 14 Scott, Orange, 91, 92, 95, 96, 100-115 Thanett, John, 179 Seminoles, 8 Theological issues, 32 Shadford, George, 118 Thomas Chapel, Delaware, 204 Shawnee, 9 Thompson, Robert Ellis, 47 Shawnee Mission Manual Labor School, Thompson, Tyler, 250 9 Thompson, William, 165 Shepherd, Thomas, 214 Tillson, Davis, 187 Sherman, David, 153 Tomes, J. N., 176 Sherwood, Lawrence, 46 Torry, Alvin, 10, II Shorter, James A., 136, 137, 142, 144, 151 "Trail of Tears," 8 Sibley, B. E., 173 Trott, James, 20, 21 Sims, eN., 72 True Wesleyan, 99, 105, 108, 109, 110, Singapore, 250-251 II I, 113, 114 Slavery, 37, 51, 79-98, 100, 105 Tucker, J. W., 144, 145 J Smith, Gerrit, 107, 115 Turner, Henry M., 141, 142, 143, 150, Snowden, E. R., 184, 187 152 Social Service Commission, 232 t South America, 14 United States Christian Commission, 169 South Carolina, 135, 136, 141, 146 University of Denver, 72 tl Southern Methodism, 240-249 Southern Methodist University, 77 Vanderbilt University, 76 Spalding, Henry, 13 Vasey, Thomas, 27 II Spates, Samuel, I I, 12 Vesey, Denmark, 135 'I Spokane Falls College, 72 Vincent, B. T., 72 Squire Grey Eyes, 6, 10 Vincent, John Heyl, 68 Stanton, Henry B., 103 Stein, K. James, 2, 25 Stewardship, 223-239 Wade, Raymond, J., 231 Stewart, John,S, 6, 12, 18 Walker, Catherine Rankin, 12 Stivers, T. S., 176, 189 Walker, Jesse, 10 Stoneman, George, 182 Walker, Jr., William, 12 Stradly, J. A., 245 Walker, Sr., William, 12 Strahan, Publisher, 154, 157 Ward, Thomas M. D., 142 Strong, Douglas M., 66, 99 Ward, W. C, 72 Strong, James, 70, 72 Ware, Edmund A., 140 Stuart, Charles M., 227 Ware, Thomas, 30, 212 Student Volunteer Movement, 225, 228 Washington, James Melvin, 62 Sunday, John, 10, II Washington, Samuel, 150 Sunday Service, 153-162 Waters, James C, 137, 147, 148, 151 Sunderland, La Roy, 84, 92, 95, 96, Waters, W. S., 176 101-115 Wayman, Alexander W., 137, 142, 143 Sweet, William Warren, 52 Webb, A. S., 245 Swift, Wesley, 154 Webb, R. S., 246 Syracuse University, 72 Webb, Thomas, 117 Weld, Theodore, 108 Talley, Alexander, 8, 20 Wesley, John, 3, 25-43, 116, 153-162, Tanner, Benjamin T., 139, 140, 143 163-167,214-222 Tappan, Lewis, 107 Wesleyan Academy, 80, 81 260

\Vesleyan Methodist Connection, 95, Women's National Indian Association, 24 99-115 Woodruff, Ada Luella, 235 , 80 Woods, Peter, 54 West, William, 39 Woods, Susan Bowers, 54 Westcott, Lorenzo, 136 Worcester, Samuel, 8 Whatcoat, Richard, 27, 29 World Service Commission, 223-239 Wheeler, James, 6 Wright, Louis B., 50 Wheeler, L. N., 173 Wyandots, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 18, 20 Wheeler-Howard Act, 24 Wylie, Steward, 148 Whipple, Henry B., 12 \Vhitaker, Gary, 243 Young, Isabella, 165 Whitman, Marcus, 13 Young Men's Christian Association, 169 Whittier, John Greenleaf, 101 Wilberforce University, 140, 147, 151 Williamson, Douglas J., 66, 79 Zeal, 216-222 Willson, Shipley W., 84 Zion's Hera/d. 84, 94, 101 Wise, E. B., 171 Zion's Walclllnan, 92, 101, 105