Geographies of Ageing and Disaster: Older People’S Experiences of Post- Disaster Recovery in Christchurch, New Zealand
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Geographies of ageing and disaster: older people’s experiences of post- disaster recovery in Christchurch, New Zealand Submitted by Sarah Tupper to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Geography In April 2018 This thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgement. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and that no material has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University. Signature: ………………………………………………………….. Abstract It was 12:51pm on Tuesday the 22nd of February when a 6.2 magnitude earthquake struck the Canterbury region in New Zealand’s South Island. This earthquake devastatingly took the lives of 185 people and caused widespread damage across Christchurch and the Canterbury region. Since the February earthquake there has been 15,832 quakes in the Canterbury region. The impact of the earthquakes has resulted in ongoing social, material and political change which has shaped how everyday life is experienced. While the Christchurch earthquakes have been investigated in relation to a number of different angles and agendas, to date there has been a notable absence on how older people in Christchurch are experiencing post-disaster recovery. This PhD research attends to this omission and by drawing upon geographical scholarship on disasters and ageing to better understand the everyday experiences of post-disaster recovery for older people. This thesis identifies a lack of geographical attention to the emotional, affective and embodied experience of disaster. In response to this the thesis draws upon qualitative material collected from a six months fieldwork period to better understand the ways in which everyday life is lived out in an environment which has been social and materially altered. This thesis identifies three main interrelated themes which are productive for advancing understandings of how older people are situated in a post-disaster context. The first is that the concepts of emotion, affect and embodiment matter as they help inform how disasters are experienced and negotiated and the implication this has on various social and spatial relations. The second is that the disruption of the disaster to everyday places has implications on senses of belonging which is illustrated in highly temporal and affective dimensions. The third theme highlights the importance of recognising mundane and everyday practices as a means of coping and persisting with ongoing impacts of the disaster. This thesis argues that older people should not be seen as passive or homogenous agents in a disaster context but, in fact, are experiencing highly emotional impacts of disaster. 2 Contents ABSTRACT ......................................................................................................................................... 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS................................................................................................................... 5 LIST OF FIGURES AND TABLES .................................................................................................... 6 LIST OF APPENDICES ...................................................................................................................... 7 CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................... 8 1.1. ACADEMIC RESEARCH CONTRIBUTIONS ....................................................................................... 11 1.2. SITUATING THE THESIS: AN OVERVIEW OF DISASTERS AND AGEING ........................................... 13 1.3. THE RESEARCH CONTEXT: THE CHRISTCHURCH EARTHQUAKES ............................................... 19 1.4. RESEARCH AIMS AND QUESTIONS ................................................................................................ 23 1.5. THESIS OUTLINE ............................................................................................................................ 24 CHAPTER TWO: EXPLORING THE GEOGRAPHIES OF DISASTER ....................................... 27 2.1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 27 2.2. APPROACHING DISASTERS: PREPAREDNESS, VULNERABILITY AND RESILIENCE ....................... 28 2.3. DISASTER PREPAREDNESS ...................................................................................................... 33 2.4. GEOGRAPHIES OF VULNERABILITY .......................................................................................... 35 2.5. GEOGRAPHIES OF RESILIENCE ................................................................................................ 38 2.6. IMPACTS OF DISASTERS: SITUATING OLDER PEOPLE .............................................................. 42 2.7. OLDER PEOPLE AND THE CHRISTCHURCH EARTHQUAKES ..................................................... 50 2.8. CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 55 CHAPTER THREE: EXPLORING GEOGRAPHIES OF AGE AND AGEING ............................. 56 3.1. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 56 3.2. APPROACHING GEOGRAPHIES OF AGEING: HEALTH, MOBILITY AND PLACE ........................... 59 3.2.1. Geographies of ageing and health .......................................................................... 59 3.2.2. Geographies of ageing and mobility ...................................................................... 63 3.2.3. Geographies of ageing and place ........................................................................... 65 3.3. RE-THINKING GEOGRAPHIES OF AGEING: LESSONS FROM CHILDREN’S GEOGRAPHIES ......... 69 3.4. EMBODIED GEOGRAPHIES OF AGEING .................................................................................... 71 3.5. EMOTIONAL GEOGRAPHIES OF AGEING .................................................................................. 72 3.6. AFFECTIVE ATMOSPHERES OF PLACE ...................................................................................... 74 3.7. CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 77 CHAPTER FOUR: RESEARCHING POST-DISASTER GEOGRAPHIES ................................... 79 4.1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 79 4.2. “DOING” POST-DISASTER RESEARCH ........................................................................................... 80 4.3. “"DOING” RESEARCH WITH OLDER PEOPLE .................................................................................. 83 4.4. RESEARCHING EMOTION AND AFFECT ........................................................................................... 86 4.5. RESEARCH DESIGN: ORGANISATIONAL SPACES AND NARRATIVE INTERVIEWS ............................ 89 4.5.1. Entering the field ................................................................................................................ 90 4.5.2. In the field ............................................................................................................................ 91 4.5.3. Leaving the field ................................................................................................................. 99 4.6. ANALYSING QUALITATIVE DATA ................................................................................................... 101 4.7. RESEARCH ETHICS ....................................................................................................................... 103 4.8. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................ 105 3 CHAPTER FIVE: EMOTIONAL, AFFECTIVE AND EMBODIED ACCOUNTS OF AGEING IN POST-DISASTER CHRISTCHURCH ............................................................................................ 106 5.1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 106 5.2. SITUATING EMOTION AND AFFECT ............................................................................................... 107 5.3. CONCEPTUALISING EMBODIMENT................................................................................................ 108 5.4. AFFECTIVE, EMOTIONAL AND EMBODIED GEOGRAPHIES OF DISASTER ...................................... 109 “It was like a horror movie…but it was real” ....................................................................... 109 “I want my old girl to be shining when she goes down” .................................................. 116 “That fear is something I will have for the rest of my life”............................................... 124 “It’s okay to cry” ......................................................................................................................... 128 “It is only when you feel it that you know it has happened” ........................................... 133 5.5. AGEING AND POST-DISASTER RECOVERY ..................................................................................