Computational Methods to Advance from Genetic Association to Biological Insight
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Computational Methods to Advance From Genetic Association to Biological Insight The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Fine, Rebecca S. 2020. Computational Methods to Advance From Genetic Association to Biological Insight. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37365548 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! "#$%&'(')#*(+!$,'-#./!'#!(.0(*1,!23#$!4,*,')1!(//#1)(')#*!'#!5)#+#4)1(+!)*/)4-'! ! 6!.)//,3'(')#*!%3,/,*',.! 57! 8,5,11(!9:!;)*,! '#! <-,!=)0)/)#*!#2!>,.)1(+!91),*1,/! )*!%(3')(+!2&+2)++$,*'!#2!'-,!3,?&)3,$,*'/! 2#3!'-,!.,43,,!#2!! =#1'#3!#2!@-)+#/#%-7! )*!'-,!/&5A,1'!#2! B,*,')1/!(*.!B,*#$)1/! ! ! ! ! C(30(3.!D*)0,3/)'7! "($53).4,E!>(//(1-&/,''/!! ;,53&(37!FGFG! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! H!FGFG!8,5,11(!9:!;)*,! 6++!3)4-'/!3,/,30,.:! ! ! ! =)//,3'(')#*!6.0)/#3I!J#,+!K:!C)3/1--#3*! ! ! ! ! !!!!!8,5,11(!9:!;)*,! ! "#$%&'(')#*(+!$,'-#./!'#!(.0(*1,!23#$!4,*,')1!(//#1)(')#*!'#!5)#+#4)1(+!)*/)4-'! !"#$%&'$( <-,!)*13,(/)*4!(0()+(5)+)'7!#2!+(34,L/1(+,!4,*,')1!.('(!-(/!,*(5+,.!$(//)0,!,22#3'/!'#! &*.,3/'(*.!'-,!4,*,')1!5(/)/!#2!-&$(*!'3()'/!(*.!.)/,(/,/:!C#M,0,3E!3#&4-+7!NGO!#2!4,*#$,L M).,!(//#1)(')#*!/'&.7!PBQ69R!/)4*(+/!1(*!5,!(''3)5&',.!'#!*#*1#.)*4!0(3)(')#*:!9&1-!0(3)(*'/! (3,!1-(++,*4)*4!'#!)*',3%3,'!(*.!1#**,1'!'#!5)#+#4)1(+!)*/)4-'!5,1(&/,!PSR!'-,3,!(3,!#2',*!$&+')%+,! %#//)5+,!1(&/(+!4,*,/!('!,(1-!+#1&/!(*.!PFR!+)*T)*4!*#*1#.)*4!0(3)(*'/!'#!'-,!4,*,/!'-,7!3,4&+(',! )/!.)22)1&+'E!M-)1-!#5/1&3,/!'-,!3,+,0(*'!5)#+#4)1(+!%3#1,//,/:!U*,!&/,2&+!(%%3#(1-!)*!(..3,//)*4! '-)/!%3#5+,$!)/!'-,!(%%+)1(')#*!#2!(+4#3)'-$/!'-('!/,(31-!2#3!1#$$#*(+)'),/!(13#//!+#1)E!M-)1-!1(*! )$%+)1(',!5)#+#4)1(+!%3#1,//,/!'-3#&4-!4,*,!/,'!,*3)1-$,*'!(*(+7/)/!(*.!%3)#3)')V,!+)T,+7!1(&/(+! 4,*,/:!<#!2(1)+)'(',!%3#43,//!23#$!4,*,')1!(//#1)(')#*!'#!5)#+#4)1(+!-7%#'-,/,/E!W!-(0,!5&)+'!&%#*! '-)/!/'3(',47!'#!.,0,+#%!'M#!.)22,3,*'!$,'-#./:! ;)3/'E!W!.,0,+#%,.!(!4,*,!/,'!,*3)1-$,*'!(*(+7/)/!$,'-#.!2#3!'-,!XY#$,"-)%E!(! 4,*#'7%)*4!(33(7!M-)1-!2#1&/,/!#*!3(3,!(*.!+#ML23,?&,*17!1#.)*4!0(3)(')#*:!<#!.#!'-)/E!W! (.(%',.!=X@W"<E!(!4,*,!/,'!,*3)1-$,*'!(*(+7/)/!$,'-#.!.,0,+#%,.!57!#&3!+(5!2#3!BQ69!.('(:! =X@W"<!)/!%(3')1&+(3+7!%#M,32&+!(/!(!'##+!2#3!5)#+#4)1(+!)*',3%3,'(')#*!.&,!'#!)'/!&/,!#2!4,*,!/,'/! '-('!-(0,!5,,*!,Y',*.,.!0)(!1#,Y%3,//)#*!.('(!'#!$(T,!%3,.)1')#*/!(5#&'!'-,!2&*1')#*!#2! &*1-(3(1',3)V,.!4,*,/:!W!(%%+),.!'-)/!$,'-#.!'#!$(*7!.)22,3,*'!'7%,/!#2!'3()'/E!)*1+&.)*4! (*'-3#%#$,'3)1!P,:4:!-,)4-'RE!-#3$#*(+!P,:4:!(.)%#*,1')*RE!(*.!4+71,$)1!P,:4:!2(/')*4!4+&1#/,R:! 9,1#*.E!$(*7!.)22,3,*'!4,*,!%3)#3)')V(')#*!(+4#3)'-$/!2#3!BQ69!-(0,!5,,*!.,0,+#%,.! &/)*4!(!1#$$#*(+)'7L5(/,.!/'3(',47E!5&'!)'!)/!.)22)1&+'!'#!.,',3$)*,!M-)1-!(3,!'-,!$#/'!(11&3(',:! )))! ! ! ! >#/'!*,M!$,'-#./!5,*1-$(3T!&/)*4!Z4#+.!/'(*.(3./[!P4,*,/!(+3,(.7!T*#M*!'#!%+(7!(!3#+,!)*!'-,! '3()'!#2!)*',3,/'R:!C#M,0,3E!/&1-!4#+.!/'(*.(3./!(3,!5)(/,.!'#M(3.!M,++L/'&.),.!4,*,/!(*.! %('-M(7/:!<-,3,2#3,E!W!.,0,+#%,.!\,*1-$(3T,3E!(!+,(0,L#*,L1-3#$#/#$,L#&'!$,'-#.!2#3! 5,*1-$(3T)*4!%3)#3)')V(')#*!$,'-#./!'-('!3,+),/!#*+7!#*!'-,!#3)4)*(+!BQ69!.('(!(*.!,0(+&(',/! $,'-#.!%,32#3$(*1,!&/)*4!/'3(')2),.!]=!/1#3,!3,43,//)#*:! <-,!$,'-#./!.,/13)5,.!)*!'-)/!.)//,3'(')#*!1#*'3)5&',!'#!(*!)$%#3'(*'!(*.!43#M)*4!5#.7! #2!M#3T!#*!$#3,!,22,1')0,!(*.!3)4#3#&/!(*(+7/)/!#2!BQ69!.('(!'#!#5'()*!5)#+#4)1(+!)*/)4-':! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! )0! ! ! ! )&"*+(,-(.,/$+/$#( ! !"#$%&'$(00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(111! )&"*+(,-(.,/$+/$#(00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(2! !'3/,4*+56+7+/$#(0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(211! 8+51'&$1,/(00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(9! !$$%1":$1,/#(00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(91! !"#$%&'()(************************************************************************************************************************************(+,! !"#$%&'(-(***********************************************************************************************************************************(+,,! !"#$%&'(.(***********************************************************************************************************************************(+,,! .;&<$+%(=>(?/$%,5:'$1,/(0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(=! /#'&(#01(23456'&78&09:(931,0;(<#',#%,30(***********************************************************************************(-! =&0&(>&%(&0',9"?&0%(#0#2:>,>(******************************************************************************************************(@! A#'%,%,30,0;("&',%#B,2,%:(***************************************************************************************************************(C! =&0&($',3',%,D#%,30(********************************************************************************************************************(EE! F&09"?#'G,0;(>%'#%&;,&>(***********************************************************************************************************(E@! H,>>8&(#01(9&22(%:$&(&0',9"?&0%(************************************************************************************************(EI! J8??#':(************************************************************************************************************************************()E! .;&<$+%(@>(A.B8AC?.)>(&(6+/+(#+$(+/%1';7+/$(&/&*D#1#(7+$;,5(-,%(A9,7+.;1<(5&$&(000000(@@! KB>%'#9%(*************************************************************************************************************************************().! L0%'3189%,30(*******************************************************************************************************************************()@! M&%"31>(*************************************************************************************************************************************()C! /&>82%>(***************************************************************************************************************************************(-N! O,>98>>,30(*********************************************************************************************************************************(N@! .;&<$+%(E>(F+/';7&%3+%>(&/(:/"1&#+5G(&##,'1&$1,/B5&$&B5%12+/(#$%&$+6D($,(+2&*:&$+(6+/+( <%1,%1$1H&$1,/(&*6,%1$;7#(0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(IJ! KB>%'#9%(*************************************************************************************************************************************(IP! L0%'3189%,30(*******************************************************************************************************************************(IE! M#%&',#2>(#01(M&%"31>(**************************************************************************************************************(I.! 0!! ! ! /&>82%>(***************************************************************************************************************************************(Q@! O,>98>>,30(*******************************************************************************************************************************(EPP! .;&<$+%(K>(!<<*1'&$1,/(,-(#1/6*+B'+**(LM!(#+N:+/'1/6(5&$&($,(1/$+%<%+$(6+/,7+B415+( &##,'1&$1,/(#$:51+#(,-(",5DB7&##(1/5+9(000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(=OI! KB>%'#9%(***********************************************************************************************************************************(EPI! L0%'3189%,30(*****************************************************************************************************************************(EPQ! M&%"31>(***********************************************************************************************************************************(EE-! /&>82%>(*************************************************************************************************************************************(E)P! O,>98>>,30(*******************************************************************************************************************************(E-.! .;&<$+%(P>(81#':##1,/(000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(=EJ! M#R3'(6,01,0;>(#01(,?$2,9#%,30>(*********************************************************************************************(E.P! S8%8'&(1,'&9%,30>(*********************************************************************************************************************(E.N! !30928>,30>(*****************************************************************************************************************************(E@.! !<<+/519(!>(Q:<<*+7+/$&%D(7&$+%1&*#(-,%(.;&<$+%(@(0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000(=PP! J8$$2&?&0%#':(6,;8'&>(63'(!"#$%&'()(**************************************************************************************(E@N!