Prepared in cooperation with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Groundwater Quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015
Open-File Report 2019–1005
U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Cover. View of the landscape in the Delaware River Basin. Photograph by Elizabeth Nystrom, U.S. Geological Survey. Groundwater Quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015
By Tia-Marie Scott, Elizabeth A. Nystrom, and James E. Reddy
Prepared in cooperation with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Open-File Report 2019–1005
U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey U.S. Department of the Interior DAVID BERNHARDT, Secretary U.S. Geological Survey James F. Reilly II, Director
U.S. Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia: 2019
For more information on the USGS—the Federal source for science about the Earth, its natural and living resources, natural hazards, and the environment—visit https://www.usgs.gov or call 1–888–ASK–USGS. For an overview of USGS information products, including maps, imagery, and publications, visit https://store.usgs.gov.
Any use of trade, firm, or product names is for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Government.
Although this information product, for the most part, is in the public domain, it also may contain copyrighted materials as noted in the text. Permission to reproduce copyrighted items must be secured from the copyright owner.
Suggested citation: Scott, T.-M., Nystrom, E.A., and Reddy, J.E., 2019, Groundwater quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 2019–1005, 42 p., 2 app., https://doi.org/10.3133/ofr20191005.
ISSN 2331-1258 (online) iii
Acknowledgments
The authors extend thanks and appreciation to all well owners who gave permission to sample their wells. Thanks are also extended to our contacts at the New York State (NYS) Department of Environmental Conservation, NYS Department of Health, county departments of health, and to all of the public water supply personnel who provided information and help with this study. Additionally, the authors would like to extend thanks and appreciation to U.S. Geological Survey personnel James Tucci, Daniel Edwards, and Benjamin Fisher for their work collecting the samples.
v
Contents
Abstract...... 1 Introduction...... 1 Objective and Approach...... 2 Purpose and Scope...... 3 Hydrogeologic Setting...... 3 Delaware River Basin...... 3 Genesee River Basin...... 3 St. Lawrence River Basin...... 8 Methods of Investigation...... 14 Well Selection...... 14 Sampling Methods...... 14 Analytical Methods...... 15 Quality-Control Samples...... 18 Groundwater Quality...... 19 Physiochemical Properties...... 19 Dissolved Gases...... 23 Major Ions and Dissolved Solids...... 24 Nutrients and Total Organic Carbon...... 26 Trace Elements...... 28 Pesticides...... 31 Volatile Organic Compounds...... 31 Radionuclides...... 32 Bacteria...... 32 Comparison of Results From Wells Sampled in 2005–6, 2010, and 2015...... 34 Summary...... 35 References Cited...... 36 Appendix 1. Results of Water-Sample Analyses, 2015...... 42 Appendix 2. Results of Water-Sample Analyses, 2005–6, 2010, and 2015...... 42
Figures
1. Map showing topography and geography of the Delaware River Basin, New York...... 4 2. Map showing generalized bedrock geology of the Delaware River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 5 3. Map showing generalized surficial geology of the Delaware River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 6 4. Map showing topography and geography of the Genesee River Basin, New York...... 7 5. Map showing generalized bedrock geology of the Genesee River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 9 6. Map showing generalized surficial geology of the Genesee River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 10 7. Map showing topography and geography of the St. Lawrence River Basin, New York...... 11 8. Map showing generalized bedrock geology of the St. Lawrence River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 12 9. Map showing generalized surficial geology of the St. Lawrence River Basin, New York, and locations of wells sampled in 2015...... 13 vi
Tables
1. Previous groundwater-quality studies and reports of the rotating-basin groundwater monitoring program in New York...... 2 2. Description of wells from which water samples were collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 16 3. Summary of 46 wells from which water samples were collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 18 4. Constituents that exceeded primary, secondary, and (or) proposed drinking-water standards in groundwater samples collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 20 5. Summary statistics for physiochemical properties of and dissolved gases in groundwater samples collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 22 6. Drinking-water standards for physiochemical properties and dissolved gases and number of groundwater samples exceeding those standards collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 23 7. Summary statistics for concentrations of major ions, hardness, alkalinity, and dissolved solids in groundwater samples collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 25 8. Drinking-water standards for concentrations of major ions and dissolved solids and number of groundwater samples exceeding those standards collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 26 9. Summary statistics for concentrations of nutrients in groundwater samples collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 27 10. Drinking-water standards for concentrations of nutrients and number of groundwater samples exceeding those standards collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 28 11. Summary statistics for concentrations of trace elements in groundwater collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 29 12. Drinking-water standards for concentrations of trace elements and number of groundwater samples exceeding those standards collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 30 13. Summary statistics for activities of radionuclides in groundwater samples collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 33 14. Drinking-water standards for activities of radionuclides and number of groundwater samples exceeding those standards collected in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015...... 34 vii
Conversion Factors
U.S. customary units to International System of Units
Multiply By To obtain inch (in.) 25,400 micrometer (µm) foot (ft) 0.3048 meter (m) mile (mi) 1.609 kilometer (km) square mile (mi2) 259.0 hectare (ha) square mile (mi2) 2.590 square kilometer (km2) gallon (gal) 3.785 liter (L) gallon per minute (gal/min) 0.06309 liter per second (L/s) inch per year (in/yr) 25.4 millimeter per year (mm/yr) picocurie per liter (pCi/L) 0.037 becquerel per liter (Bq/L)
Temperature in degrees Celsius (°C) may be converted to degrees Fahrenheit (°F) as °F = (1.8 × °C) + 32.
Datum
Vertical coordinate information is referenced to the North American Vertical Datum of 1988 (NAVD 88). Horizontal coordinate information is referenced to the North American Datum of 1983 (NAD 83). Elevation, as used in this report, refers to distance above the vertical datum.
Supplemental Information
Specific conductance is given in microsiemens per centimeter at 25 degrees Celsius (µS/cm at 25 °C). Concentrations of chemical constituents in water are given either in milligrams per liter (mg/L), micrograms per liter (µg/L), or nanograms per liter (ng/L). Activities for radioactive constituents in water are given in picocuries per liter (pCi/L). Concentrations of bacteria in water are given in colony-forming units per 100 milliliters (CFU/100 mL); heterotrophic plate counts are in colony-forming units per milliliter (CFU/mL).
Color is reported in platinum-cobalt (Pt-Co) units. viii
Abbreviations and Symbols
> greater than < less than AMCL alternative maximum contaminant level bls below land surface
CaCO3 calcium carbonate CFU colony-forming units CIAT 2-chloro-4-isopropylamino-6-amino-s-triazine E. coli Escherichia coli EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency GC–MS gas chromatography-mass spectrometry gross-α gross-alpha gross-β gross-beta ICP–AES inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry LRL laboratory reporting level MCL maximum contaminant level N nitrogen NWQL USGS National Water Quality Laboratory NYSDEC New York State Department of Environmental Conservation NYSDOH New York State Department of Health P phosphorus SDWS secondary drinking-water standard THM trihalomethane USGS U.S. Geological Survey VOC volatile organic compound Groundwater Quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015
By Tia-Marie Scott, Elizabeth A. Nystrom, and James E. Reddy
Abstract 21 wells sampled in the St. Lawrence River Basin, 7 are com- pleted in sand and gravel, and 14 are completed in bedrock. The U.S. Geological Survey, in cooperation with the Groundwater in the St. Lawrence River Basin was generally of New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, good quality, although properties and concentrations of some collected groundwater samples from 5 production wells and constituents—pH, chloride, sodium, dissolved solids, iron, 5 domestic wells in the Delaware River Basin, 8 production manganese, sulfate, nitrate, radon-222, total coliform bacteria, wells and 7 domestic wells in the Genesee River Basin, and fecal coliform bacteria, and Escherichia coli bacteria—some- 1 municipal well, 7 production wells, and 13 domestic wells in times equaled or exceeded primary, secondary, or proposed the St. Lawrence River Basin in New York. All samples were drinking-water standards. The constituent most frequently collected from May through November 2015 in an effort to detected in concentrations exceeding drinking-water standards characterize groundwater quality in these basins. The samples (14 of 21 samples) was radon-222. were collected and processed by using standard U.S. Geo- logical Survey procedures and were analyzed for 148 phys- iochemical properties and constituents, including dissolved Introduction gases, major ions, nutrients, trace elements, pesticides, volatile organic compounds, radionuclides, and indicator bacteria. Groundwater is used as a source of drinking water by The Delaware River Basin study area covers 2,360 square approximately one-quarter of the population of New York miles (mi2) in southeastern New York. Of the 10 wells sam- State, or 4.5 million people (U.S. Census Bureau, 2016) pled in the Delaware River Basin, 3 are completed in sand and (Kenny and others, 2009). In 2002, the U.S. Geological Sur- gravel, and 7 are completed in bedrock. Groundwater in the vey (USGS), in cooperation with the New York State Depart- Delaware River Basin was generally of good quality, although ment of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), developed properties and concentrations of some constituents—pH, iron, a program to evaluate groundwater quality throughout the manganese, aluminum, radon-222, and total coliform bacte- ria—sometimes equaled or exceeded primary, secondary, or major river basins in Upstate New York on a rotating basis. proposed drinking-water standards. The constituent most fre- The program parallels the NYSDEC Rotating Integrated Basin quently detected in concentrations exceeding drinking-water Study program (https://www.dec.ny.gov/chemical/30951. standards (10 of 10 samples) was radon-222. html), which evaluates surface-water quality on a 5-year The Genesee River Basin study area includes the entire cycle by sampling in 2 or 3 of the 14 major river basins in 2,439 mi2 of the basin in western New York. Of the 15 wells the State each year. This program also supports NYSDEC’s sampled in the Genesee River Basin, 6 are completed in sand responsibilities under Section 305(b) of the Clean Water Act and gravel, and 9 are completed in bedrock. Groundwater Amendments of 1977 (Public Law 95–95, 91 Stat. 685) to in the Genesee River Basin was generally of good quality, report on the chemical quality of groundwater within New although properties and concentrations of some constituents— York (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1997). The chloride, sodium, dissolved solids, iron, manganese, alumi- groundwater-quality program began with a pilot study in the num, arsenic, radon-222, methane, total coliform bacteria, Mohawk River Basin in 2002 and still continues throughout fecal coliform bacteria, and Escherichia coli bacteria—some- Upstate New York, that part of New York State north of New times equaled or exceeded primary, secondary, or proposed York City (table 1). Sampling completed in 2008 represents drinking-water standards. The constituent most frequently the conclusion of the first round of groundwater-quality detected in concentrations exceeding drinking-water standards sampling throughout Upstate New York. Groundwater-quality (12 of 15 samples) was radon-222. sampling was conducted in 2015 in the Delaware, Genesee, The St. Lawrence River Basin study area includes the and St. Lawrence River Basins, representing the third round of entire 5,650 mi2 of the basin in northeastern New York. Of the groundwater-quality sampling for this program. 2 Groundwater Quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015
Table 1. Previous groundwater-quality studies and reports of the rotating-basin groundwater monitoring program in New York.
[Bold listing indicates the previous groundwater-quality studies in the Delaware River Basin, Genesee River Basin, and St. Lawrence River Basin]
Study area Year Report Reference Mohawk River Basin 2002 Water-Data Report NY–02–1 Butch and others, 2003 Chemung River Basin 2003 Open-File Report 2004–1329 Hetcher-Aguila, 2005 Lake Champlain Basin 2004 Open-File Report 2006–1088 Nystrom, 2006 Susquehanna River Basin 2004 Open-File Report 2006–1161 Hetcher-Aguila and Eckhardt, 2006 Delaware River Basin 2005 Open-File Report 2007–1098 Nystrom, 2007a Genesee River Basin 2005 Open-File Report 2007–1093 Eckhardt and others, 2007 St. Lawrence River Basin 2005 Open-File Report 2007–1066 Nystrom, 2007b Mohawk River Basin 2006 Open-File Report 2008–1086 Nystrom, 2008 Western New York 2006 Open-File Report 2008–1140 Eckhardt and others, 2008 Central New York 2007 Open-File Report 2009–1257 Eckhardt and others, 2009 Upper Hudson River Basin 2007 Open-File Report 2009–1240 Nystrom, 2009 Chemung River Basin 2008 Open-File Report 2011–1112 Risen and Reddy, 2011a Eastern Lake Ontario Basin 2008 Open-File Report 2011–1074 Risen and Reddy, 2011b Lower Hudson River Basin 2008 Open-File Report 2010–1197 Nystrom, 2010 Lake Champlain Basin 2009 Open-File Report 2011–1180 Nystrom, 2011 Susquehanna River Basin 2009 Open-File Report 2012–1045 Reddy and Risen, 2012 Delaware River Basin 2010 Open-File Report 2011–1320 Nystrom, 2012 Genesee River Basin 2010 Open-File Report 2012–1135 Reddy, 2012 St. Lawrence River Basin 2010 Open-File Report 2011–1320 Nystrom, 2012 Mohawk River Basin 2011 Open-File Report 2013–1021 Nystrom and Scott, 2013 Western New York 2011 Open-File Report 2013–1095 Reddy, 2013 Central New York 2012 Open-File Report 2014–1226 Reddy, 2014 Upper Hudson River Basin 2012 Open-File Report 2014–1084 Scott and Nystrom, 2014 Chemung River Basin 2013 Open-File Report 2015–1168 Scott and others, 2015 Eastern Lake Ontario Basin 2013 Open-File Report 2015–1168 Scott, and others, 2015 Lower Hudson River Basin 2013 Open-File Report 2015–1168 Scott, and others, 2015 Lake Champlain Basin 2014 Open-File Report 2016–1153 Scott, and others, 2016 Susquehanna River Basin 2014 Open-File Report 2016–1153 Scott, and others, 2016
Objective and Approach study cycles. Samples were analyzed for a broad suite of con- stituents, including physiochemical properties and concentra- The objective of the groundwater-quality monitoring tions of dissolved gases, major ions, nutrients, trace elements, program is to quantify and report on ambient groundwater pesticides, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), radionuclides, quality in bedrock and glacial-drift aquifers in Upstate New and indicator bacteria. The resulting dataset will be used to York. Consistent, standardized methods were used to col- establish a groundwater-quality baseline for New York State lect groundwater-quality samples from existing domestic that characterizes naturally occurring and ambient conditions and production wells equipped with permanently installed and to identify long-term trends. The data are made available pumps. Wells were selected to represent an approximately online through the USGS National Water Information System equal number of domestic and production wells, to represent (https://nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/ny/nwis/qw; U.S. Geological an approximately equal number of bedrock and glacial-drift Survey, 2018) and published reports. wells, and to provide a representative geographic distribution Groundwater-quality samples were collected in the of samples with emphasis on areas of greatest groundwater Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins in 2005–6, use. Approximately 20 percent of samples collected in 2015 2010, and 2015. Samples were collected in May through were collected from wells that had been sampled in previous November for the 2015 cycle of this study. Ten environmental Introduction 3 samples and 2 quality-assurance samples were collected in in New York include the West Branch Delaware River, East the Delaware River Basin. Fifteen environmental samples Branch Delaware River, Monguap River, and Neversink River. and 1 quality-assurance sample were collected in the Genesee Drinking water for New York City is diverted out of the basin River Basin. Twenty-one environmental samples and 1 qual- at three reservoirs: Cannonsville (on the West Branch Dela- ity-assurance sample were collected in the St. Lawrence River ware River), Pepacton (on the East Branch Delaware River), Basin. Two of the Delaware River Basin wells sampled in and Neversink (on the Neversink River). 2015 were also sampled in 2005–6 and 2010 (Nystrom, 2007a; The highest elevations in the Delaware River Basin study Nystrom 2012). Three of the Genesee River Basin wells were area are more than 4,000 feet (ft) above the North American also sampled in 2010 (Reddy, 2012). Five of the St. Lawrence Vertical Datum of 1988 (NAVD 88) along the eastern edge River Basin wells were also sampled in 2005–6 and 2010 of the basin, in the Catskill Mountains (fig. 1). The lowest (Nystrom, 2007b; Nystrom, 2012). elevations in the basin are at the Delaware River’s exit from New York State at Port Jervis (fig. 1) (about 420 ft above NAVD 88). Precipitation in the Delaware River valley lowland Purpose and Scope areas averages about 40 inches per year (in/yr), whereas precipitation in the cooler Catskill Mountains averages about This report presents the findings of the 2015 groundwa- 50 in/yr (Randall, 1996). The Delaware River Basin is mostly ter-quality study in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence rural, with larger population centers in the southern part of River Basins. Ten samples from the Delaware River Basin, the basin at Port Jervis, Liberty, and Monticello (fig. 1). Land 15 samples from the Genesee River Basin, and 21 samples use in the basin is primarily forested, especially in the upland from the St. Lawrence River Basin were collected from areas, with urban and agriculture uses mainly in valleys and May through November 2015. This report (1) describes the other low-lying areas (Homer and others, 2015). hydrogeologic setting, the methods of site selection, wells Bedrock in the Delaware River Basin study area (fig. 2) is that were sampled, sample collection, and chemical analysis; mainly Middle to Upper Devonian sedimentary sandstone and (2) presents the analytical results; (3) presents comparisons of shale with a narrow band of carbonate rocks that runs parallel analytical results to drinking-water standards, and (4) pres- to the southern edge of the basin (Isachsen and others, 2000). ents comparisons of the results of this study with results for Bedrock wells in the study area produce small to moderate selected wells in the study areas that were sampled in 2005–6 yields of 10 to 100 gallons per minutes (gal/min) (Barksdale, and 2010 (Nystrom, 2007a, b; Nystrom, 2012; Reddy, 2012). 1970). The surficial material throughout the study area (fig. 3) was deposited primarily during the Pleistocene epoch Wiscon- Hydrogeologic Setting sinan glaciation, when glacial ice covered most of the north- eastern United States (Isachsen and others, 2000). Till was The study areas described in this report cover more directly deposited by the glaciers over most of the study area; than 10,000 square miles (mi2), or 18 percent of New York alluvial, outwash, and ice-contact sand-and-gravel deposits are State, and represent a wide range of geologic, hydrologic, present mainly in the valleys (fig. 3). In the Delaware River and topographic settings, and land uses. Bedrock lithology is Basin, till generally has low yields of water, whereas the well- primarily shale and sandstone in the Delaware and Genesee sorted valley deposits form important aquifers in the basin River Basins; in the St. Lawrence River Basin, bedrock lithol- that may produce yields of 1,000 gal/min or more (Barksdale, ogy consists of complex mixtures of crystalline, metamorphic, 1970). The depths of sand-and-gravel wells sampled in the carbonate, and sandstone (Fisher and others, 1970). Surficial Delaware River Basin range from 42 to 120 ft below land material in the study areas mainly consists of glacial and allu- surface (bls); the depths of bedrock wells sampled range from vial deposits. 195 to 400 ft bls, and all are completed in shale and sandstone.
Delaware River Basin Genesee River Basin The Delaware River Basin encompasses approximately The Genesee River Basin encompasses 2,534 mi2, of 12,700 mi2 in New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and which 95 mi2 is in Pennsylvania. The Genesee River Basin Delaware. This study addressed the 2,360 mi2 portion of the study area encompasses the 2,439 mi2 that is located in west- Delaware River Basin that lies within New York (fig. 1). The ern New York. The study area contains parts of nine counties, study area includes parts of eight counties, including most of including Genesee, Monroe, Livingston, Wyoming, Ontario, Delaware and Sullivan Counties, part of Broome, Orange, and Steuben, Allegany, Orleans, and Cattaraugus Counties (fig. 4). Ulster Counties, and small parts of Chenango, Greene, and Major tributaries to the Genesee River include Black Creek, Schoharie Counties (fig. 1). The West Branch Delaware River Oatka Creek, Conesus Creek, Honeoye Creek, Canaseraga forms the boundary between New York and Pennsylvania for Creek, Wiscoy Creek, Caneadea Creek, Van Campen Creek, 9 miles (mi) before joining with the East Branch to form the Dyke Creek, Silver Creek, and Silver Lake (fig. 4). Other main stem of the Delaware River, which forms the boundary major contributing tributaries in the Genesee River Basin for another 76 mi. Major tributaries to the Delaware River include Keshequa Creek, which is a tributary to Canaseraga 4 Groundwater Quality in the Delaware, Genesee, and St. Lawrence River Basins, New York, 2015