View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE

provided by ScholarSpace at University of Hawai'i at Manoa

Rapid Invasion Despite Lack of Genetic Variation in the Gall Wasp ( erythrinae Kim)1

Daniel Rubinoff,2,5 Brenden S. Holland,3 Alexandra Shibata,2 Russell H. Messing,4 and Mark G. Wright2

Abstract: The erythrina gall wasp, Kim, has recently and rapidly invaded a broad swath of the tropical and subtropical Pacific Basin, causing severe damage to most of (Erythrina spp.). This small (length @1.5 mm) wasp attacks the photosynthetic tissue (leaves, buds, stems, flowers) of ornamental and native Erythrina, often killing the trees. This inva- sion poses an immediate extinction threat to native Erythrina spp. throughout Asia, , and a number of Pacific archipelagos, including Hawai‘i, where populations of the endemic E. sandwicensis have been devastated. Although this pest is known to occur naturally in , the precise geographic origin of the invasions remains unknown. In this study, 1,623 base pairs of mitochondrial (cytochrome c oxidase subunit I) and nuclear DNA (elongation factor alpha) were used to confirm systematic identity and to examine genetic divergence among invasive populations from Hawai‘i, Guam, American Samoa, Japan, Sin- gapore, Taiwan, and China. Samples from all invasive populations included in our study showed a complete lack of genetic diversity. Molecular findings con- firm that a single species, Q. erythrinae, is involved in this dramatic, recent range expansion and that introductions may have been associated with population bot- tlenecks that have reduced genetic diversity in populations sampled. Although reductions in genetic diversity are generally considered detrimental to fitness, this study provides an example of invasion success despite a lack of detectable genetic variation. The monomorphic genetic pattern observed also suggests that Q. erythrinae initially may have been introduced to one location, and this invasive population may have subsequently served as a source for additional sec- ondary invasions by unknown introduction vectors.

Coral trees (Erythrina spp., Leguminosae/ 1 This research was supported in part by a grant from ) are a widespread and diverse genus the State of Hawai‘i Invasive Species Council, the USDA-CSREES-TSTAR program, and the Tri-Isle Re- of trees with approximately 110 species search and Development. B.S.H. was supported by a (Mabberly 1987), with a global tropical dis- grant from the U.S. Army Natural Resources Division tribution. Their range includes not only during preparation of the manuscript. Manuscript ac- continental endemic species across Africa, cepted 27 April 2009. 2 Department of and Environmental Protection Australia, and but also en- Sciences, 310 Gilmore Hall, 3050 Maile Way, University demic species in the islands of Hawai‘i, the of Hawai‘i at Ma¯noa, Honolulu, Hawai‘i 96822. South Pacific, Micronesia, and the , 3 Center for Conservation Research and Training, where they are important components of na- 3050 Maile Way, University of Hawai‘i at Ma¯noa, Hono- tive ecosystems. Some Erythrina species have lulu, Hawai‘i 96822. 4 Kaua‘i Agricultural Research Center, 7370 Kuamo‘o been widely planted as ornamental trees, Road, Kapa‘a, Hawai‘i 96746. prized for their dramatic, seasonal flowers 5 Corresponding author: (e-mail: rubinoff@ and variegated leaves, and other species are .edu). important agricultural resources serving as windbreaks, shade trees for crops (macada- Pacific Science (2010), vol. 64, no. 1:23–31 doi: 10.2984/64.1.023 mia, , cocoa), living fences, and fodder. : 2010 by University of Hawai‘i Press In the Hawaiian Islands, the endemic coral All rights reserved , or , Erythina sandwicensis, histori-

23 24 PACIFIC SCIENCE . January 2010 cally has been an important component of By killing off spectacular ornamental cultural activities and mythology; were specimens, agriculturally valuable plantings, made from its flowers and , wood and and the endemic E. sandwicensis, the erythrina bark were used for various purposes including gall wasp has already caused substantial im- canoe building. The wiliwili tree is one of pacts to Hawaiian tourism, agriculture, and Hawai‘i’s few deciduous endemic trees and native ecosystems. This pattern is typical ev- grows to heights of over 13 m, preferring erywhere the wasp has spread. dry forests of the leeward slopes on all of Before the 2003 invasions, the erythrina the main islands, from sea level to an eleva- gall wasp was unknown, and there were no tion of 600 m (Wagner et al. 1990). other gall-forming wasps recorded from any Damage to Erythrina trees due to an inva- Erythrina across the Indian and Pacific sive wasp was first documented in 2003, when oceans, although it is well known that sub- ornamental trees in the Mascarene Islands Saharan Africa hosts a diversity of gall wasps and southern Taiwan (Yang et al. 2004) were on Erythrina. Examination of host-plant rela- infested and defoliated by a then-unknown tionships of Q. erythrinae (using 71 different species of eulophid wasp. Within a year, the Erythrina species) confirms an African origin wasp had spread throughout Taiwan and for the wasp (Messing et al. in press). reached Singapore and by 2005 was docu- Despite the widespread ecological and mented in Hong Kong and mainland China economic damage caused by invasive species, (Li et al. 2006) and was reported on O‘ahu biological and genetic factors contributing in the Hawaiian Islands in April of that year to success of invaders often remain unclear. (Gramling 2005). Within 6 weeks of its ar- Although a number of studies investigating rival in Hawai‘i, the wasp had spread over levels of genetic polymorphism in invasive 500 km, throughout the high islands. In populations have demonstrated decreases in 2004 the wasp was described as Quadrastichus genetic diversity relative to native populations erythrinae Kim, the erythrina gall wasp (Kim (Colautti et al. 2005, Lindholm et al. 2005, et al. 2004), from specimens collected in Sin- Chandler et al. 2008), there are also many ex- gapore, Mauritius, and Re´union (regions with amples where population genetic diversity no native Erythrina). In a span of about 2 yr, was not substantially decreased (Holland the erythrina gall wasp had spread across a 2001, Hassan et al. 2003) or, despite de- tropical swath from Hawai‘i to India, a dis- creases, invasions proceeded apparently unde- tance of more than 12,546 km, much of it terred by any perceivable decrease in fitness across open ocean (Heu et al. 2005, Schmae- (Tsutsui and Suarez 2003, Le Roux et al. dick et al. 2006). The erythrina gall wasp has 2007, Chandler et al. 2008). infested and often essentially eliminated most A single species of erythrina gall wasp has trees of all species of Erythrina in those re- recently been documented as responsible for gions, causing a horticultural disaster. In this devastating invasion, but systematic iden- 2006, the erythrina gall wasp moved into the tity of the wasp has been based solely on tropical Atlantic, reaching Florida, and ap- morphology and behavior, and questions re- pears poised to spread into the Caribbean garding the relationships among the popula- and South America, where there are large tions, the number of species involved, the numbers of endemic Erythrina species naive potential for the presence of cryptic species, to leaf-galling wasps. the number of introductions, the geographic The erythrina gall wasp lays eggs in leaves, source region, and the genetic diversity of petioles, young shoots, and stems, forming these rapidly invading populations remain galls in green plant tissue, completely de- unanswered. Tung et al. (2009) found no ge- forming the trees and threatening the ’ netic variation in a mitochondrial and nuclear survival. Larvae of this small (1.5 mm), phy- gene in 47 individuals of the erythrina gall tophagous wasp hatch within the galls and wasp from Mauritius, where it was first re- feed. During severe infestations, even large corded, and populations in Singapore and mature trees are killed. Taiwan, but this result needs to be confirmed Low Genetic Variation in Pacific Invasive Wasp . Rubinoff et al. 25 across the broader geographic range of the DNeasy nucleic acid extraction kits (QIA- invasion and with more extensive sampling GEN, Valencia, ). DNAs were to understand the role of genetic diversity in eluted in deionized autoclaved water and promoting the erythrina gall wasp’s explosive stored at 80C. Polymerase chain reaction invasion. (PCR) was performed using a PTC-200 ther- Using both nuclear and mitochondrial mocycler (MJ Research, Reno, Nevada). Cy- DNA markers, we sequenced samples of the tochrome c oxidase I (COI) primer sequences erythrina gall wasp from across much of its used were as follows: gene regions were PCR recently invaded range in the Pacific Basin, amplified and sequenced using the following including American Samoa, China, Guam, primers: COI, Jerry (50 CAA CAT TTA Hawai‘i, Japan, Singapore, and Taiwan to ad- TTT TGA TTT TTT GG) and Pat (50 dress the following questions: Is the invasive ATC CAT TAC ATA TAA TCT GCC erythrina gall wasp a single species, or have ATA); nuclear elongation factor (EF1-a), Os- multiple gall wasps with similar ecology car (50 GGC CCA AGG AAA TGG GCA caused this invasion? If the invasion is a single AGG G) and Bosie (50 CCG GCG ACG species, how many times was it introduced TAA CCA CGA CGC). Both COI and and from how many source populations? Is EF1-a primers amplified the target fragment there evidence for population bottlenecks consistently under the following PCR condi- (i.e., indicated by lack of genetic diversity tions: 2 min at 92C, 30 cycles of 94C for across populations)? The answers to these 30 sec, 50C for 30 sec, and 72C for 45 questions apply directly to future efforts to sec, with a final 72C extension for 7 min. control the erythrina gall wasp and to prevent PCR-amplified DNA fragments were purified future introductions of additional gall wasp with QIAquick spin columns (QIAGEN), ac- species that may cause additional damage. cording to the manufacturer’s protocol, then checked via agarose gel electrophoresis. materials and methods Forward and reverse strands were cycle- sequenced using the PCR primers. ABI Prism Sampling DYE Terminator Cycle Sequencing Reaction Kits in a thermal cycler (Perkin-Elmer 9700) We acquired samples of the erythrina gall were used to generate single-stranded prod- wasp from much of its invasive range across ucts, and sequences were determined using 7,840 km of the tropical Pacific Basin (Figure an automated sequencer (ABI 377, PE Bio- 1, Table 1). Outgroups included unidentified systems, Foster City, California). erythrina gall wasp species collected in . Specimens were placed into 95% alco- hol in the field and transported to our labora- Phylogeny Reconstruction tory at the University of Hawai‘i. Superficial In cases where different methods give simi- morphological examination of wasps was lar or identical topologies, confidence is in- conducted for all specimens. Target gene creased that the results are representative of fragments were selected for their rapid substi- the evolutionary history of the sequences tution rates and to take advantage of the composing the data set (Cunningham 1997). strengths of both nuclear and mitochondrial Therefore a variety of approaches was used markers and avoid potential bias due to use for phylogeny reconstruction, including max- of only a single character partition (Rubinoff imum parsimony (MP), maximum likelihood and Holland 2005). (ML), and minimum evolution (ME) with various models of molecular evolution (e.g., Jukes-Cantor, uncorrected ‘‘P,’’ Tajima-Nei, DNA Extraction, PCR Amplification, and Kimura 2-parameter, Tamura-Nei, Kimura Sequencing 3-parameter). Statistical support was assessed Genomic DNAs were extracted according to with 1,000 bootstrap replicates for ML, MP, the manufacturer’s protocol using QIAGEN and ME methods (Felsenstein 1985). Trees 26 PACIFIC SCIENCE . January 2010

Figure 1. Map of the western Pacific Ocean showing sampling localities.

were rooted with multiple outgroups, and (Figures 2 and 3). After editing and align- resultant topologies were compared for the ment, sequenced gene fragments obtained three approaches (Figures 2 and 3). were 821 base pairs for COI and 802 base pairs for the EF1-a gene. Bootstrap sup- results port based on 1,000 replicates for minimum evolution/maximum likelihood/maximum Erythrina gall wasp samples from Japan, Tai- parsimony (ME/ML/MP) was 100% for wan, China, and islands spanning approxi- each optimality criterion. Although we had mately 7,840 km of the Pacific Basin (Figure planned to use statistical parsimony to recon- 1) were monomorphic for both loci se- struct haplotype networks and analysis of quenced, with a single COI haplotype and a molecular variance to elucidate population single genotype for the nuclear gene EF1-a genetic partitioning, none of these ap- Low Genetic Variation in Pacific Invasive Wasp . Rubinoff et al. 27

TABLE 1 Sampling Localities, GeneBank Accession Numbers

Sample Codes GeneBank (Species, if not Collection Accession No. Q. erythrinae) Date Source Host Species Collector (COI/EF1-a)

39–47 January 2006 University of Erythrina spp. D. Rubinoff FJ872114/FJ949570 Hawai‘i at Ma¯noa campus, O‘ahu, Hawai‘i 48–52 February 2006 Tutuila, American N. Gurr FJ872114/FJ949570 Samoa orientalis 54 June 2006 Somerset West, Erythrina sp. M. Wright, R. FJ872116/FJ949568 Quadrastichus South Africa Messing, D. sp. 1 Rubinoff 58 June 2006 Somerset West, Erythrina sp. M. Wright, R. NA/FJ949569 Quadrastichus South Africa Messing, D. sp. 2 Rubinoff 82 — Dade County, Pims Palms R. Duncan FJ872115/NA Quadrastichus Homestead, haitensis Florida 102–106 June 2006 Mangilao, Guam Erythrina sp. R. H. Miller FJ872114/FJ949570 107–112 December 2006 Yozo Itoman City, Erythrina variegata N. Uechi (Uechi FJ872114/FJ949570 Okinawa, Japan et al. 2007) 114 April 2006 Road 40, South M. Wright, R. FJ872113/FJ949567 Quadrastichus Africa Messing, D. sp. 2 Rubinoff 141–146 December 2006 Singapore Erythrina sp. R. Messing FJ872114/FJ949570 TW — Taiwan — — EF377343/NA SY — China — — EF377345/NA SZ — Shenzen, — — EF377346/NA Guangdong, China TW — Shenzen, — — EF377347/NA Guangdong, China ZH — Shenzen, — — EF377348/NA Guangdong, China

proaches was appropriate due to a complete and produce neither leaves nor seeds, effec- lack of polymorphism in all invasive popula- tively reducing (or minimizing) their ecologi- tions sampled. cal interactions in the forest. Destructive invasions are well docu- discussion mented and can progress rapidly (MacLeod et al. 2002, Johnson et al. 2006, Muirhead Invasive populations of the erythrina gall et al. 2006), but the pace and scale of the er- wasp have completely defoliated and killed ythrina gall wasp invasion is unprecedented several species of Erythrina trees across a and represents one of the fastest and most wide range of environments. In the Hawaiian devastating insect invasions ever recorded. Islands, there are some instances where en- Although unintentional anthropogenic intro- demic Erythrina trees appear to have persisted duction is the most likely mechanism driving since the invasion, in spite of infestation, but the explosive spread of the erythrina gall the trees apparently enter a dormant state wasp, human-mediated transport has rarely Figure 2. Maximum likelihood phylogram with a total of 38 individual wasps, based on 821 base pairs of cytochrome c oxidase I (COI). Bootstrap support is shown as follows: minimum evolution/maximum likelihood/maximum parsimony (ME/ML/MP), based on 1,000 replicates for each optimality criterion. Sequence fragments representing 35 invasive wasp specimens (Quadrastichus erythrinae) from seven sampling localities shared a single haplotype. Outgroups were collected in South Africa and Florida. Figure 3. Maximum likelihood phylogram based on 802 base pairs of nuclear elongation factor (EF1-a) for 25 inva- sive Pacific Quadrastichus erythrinae plus three outgroups. Note that Q. erythrinae nuclear EF1-a from across the Pacific Basin was found to be identical for all ingroup specimens sampled. Bootstrap support shown is based on 1,000 boot- strap replicates as follows: (ME/ML/MP). Outgroups were collected in South Africa. 30 PACIFIC SCIENCE . January 2010 been so effectively and rapidly exploited by an Canberra, Australia; Jorge Pen˜ a, University invasive species. of Florida; and Nami Uechi, Okinawa Agri- The erythrina gall wasp invasion rep- cultural Research Center, sent specimens or resents not only a single widely dispersed otherwise provided invaluable assistance to species but also a widely dispersed single this work. mtDNA haplotype coupled with no nuclear DNA diversity in a relatively quickly evolving Literature Cited nuclear gene across the Pacific Basin. A com- plete lack of detectable genetic variation sug- Chandler, E. A., J. R. McDowell, and J. E. gests genetic bottlenecks (e.g., Hedrick 2005) Graves. 2008. Genetically monomorphic and a recent, rapid expansion from a founding invasive populations of the rapa whelk, Ra- population of limited size or at least low ge- pana venosa. Mol. Ecol. 17:4079–4091. netic diversity. Genetic monomorphy for nu- Colautti, R. I., M. Manca, M. Viljanen, clear and mtDNA gene sequences from all H. A. M. Ketelaars, H. Burgi, H. J. Mac- widespread geographic sampling sites sug- Isaac, and D. D. Heath. 2005. Invasion gests that introductions have occurred from a genetics of the Eurasian spiny waterflea: single panmictic population. Although non- Evidence for bottlenecks and gene flow native Q. erythrinae populations currently using microsatellites. Mol. Ecol. 14:1869– appear to be thriving in their new environ- 1879. ments, the absence of genetic variation raises Cunningham, C. W. 1997. Is congruence be- questions regarding the long-term persistence tween data partitions a reliable predictor of invasive populations (Sakai et al. 2001). of phylogenetic accuracy? Empirically Knowledge of the provenance of the eryth- testing an iterative procedure for choosing rina gall wasp’s explosive invasion may among phylogenetic methods. Syst. Biol. ultimately be informative in terms of deter- 46:464–478 mining the mechanism of transport and re- Felsenstein, J. 1985. Confidence limits on lease; therefore future research to reveal the phylogenies: An approach using the boot- geographic source of the invasion will be our strap. Evolution 39:783–791. focus. As globalization and the speed of Gramling, C. 2005. Hawaii’s coral trees feel commerce and transportation increase, ad- the sting of foreign wasps. Science (Wash- ditional potentially invasive species that, like ington, D.C.) 310:1759–1760. the erythrina gall wasp, until now have gone Hassan, M., M. Harmelin-Vivien, and F. undetected may exacerbate the pace and Bonhomme. 2003. Lessepsian invasion level of environmental and economic damage without bottleneck: Example of two rab- sustained by global ecosystems. However bitfish species (Siganus rivulatus and Siga- through the application of molecular meth- nus luridus). J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. ods to elucidate taxonomic identity and the 291:219–232. geographic source of such invasions (Holland Hedrick, P. W. 2005. Genetics of popula- 2000), we gain a powerful tool that sheds tions. Jones and Bartlett, Sudbury, Massa- light on details of introduction mechanisms chusetts. that will lead to more effective prediction of Heu, R. A., D. M. Tsuda, W. T. Nagamine, impacts and methods of prevention for future and T. H. Suh. 2005. New pest advisory invaders. no. 05-03. Department of Agriculture, acknowledgments State of Hawai‘i, Honolulu. Holland, B. S. 2000. Genetics of marine bio- Mark Schmaedick, Land Grant Program invasions. Hydrobiologia 420:63–71. American Samoa Community College; Ger- ———. 2001. Invasion without a bottleneck: hard Prinsloo and Ottilie Neser, ARC–Plant Microsatellite variation in natural and in- Protection Research Institute, Pretoria, South vasive populations of the brown mussel, Africa; Walter Nagamine, Hawai‘i Depart- Perna perna (L.). Mar. Biotech. 3:407–415. ment of Agriculture; John La Salle, CSIRO, Johnson, D. M., A. M. Liebhold, P. C. Low Genetic Variation in Pacific Invasive Wasp . Rubinoff et al. 31

Tobin, and O. Bjoernstad. 2006. Allee ef- leoptera), in North America. Divers. Dis- fects and pulsed invasion by the gypsy trib. 12:71–79. moth. Nature (Lond.) 444:361–363. Rubinoff, D., and B. S. Holland. 2005. Be- Kim, I. K., G. Delvare, and J. La Salle. 2004. tween two extremes: Mitochondrial DNA A new species of Quadrastichus (Hymenop- is neither the panacea nor the nemesis of tera: ): A gall-inducing pest on phylogenetics and systematic inference. Erythrina (Fabaceae). J. Hymenop. Res. Syst. Biol. 54:952–960. 13:243–249. Sakai, A. K., F. W. Allendorf, J. S. Holt, Le Roux, J., A. M. Wieczorek, M. G. Wright, D. M. Lodge, J. Molofsky, K. A. With, S. and C. Tran. 2007. Super-genotype: Baughman, R. J. Cabin, J. E. Cohen, N. C. Global monoclonality defies the odds of Ellstrand, D. E. McCauley, P. O’Neil, nature. Public Library of Science ONE I. M. Parker, J. N. Thompson, and S. G. 2(7): e590. (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone Weller. 2001. The population biology of .0000590.) invasive species. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst. Li, H. M., H. Xiao, H. Peng, H. Han, and D. 32:305–332. Xue. 2006. Potential global range expan- Schmaedick, M., M. Tuionoula, and S. Lal. sion of a new invasive species, the Eryth- 2006. Erythrina gall wasp (Quadrastichus rina gall wasp, Quadrastichus erythrinae erythrinae). Secretariat of the Pacific Com- Kim (Insecta: : Eulophidae). munity, Land Resource Division. Pest Fo- Raffles Bull. Zool. 54:229–234. cus, January 2006. Lindholm, A. K., F. Breden, H. J. Alexander, Tung, G.-S., L.-W. Wu, Y.-S. Yang, C.-C. W.-K. Chan, S. G. Thakurta, and R. Hsu, and M.-M. Yang. 2009. Genetic Brooks. 2005. Invasion success and genetic differentiation of the eulophid wasp Quad- diversity of introduced populations of rastichus erythrinae Kim (Hymenoptera: guppies, Poecilia reticulata, in Australia. Eulophidae) from various Erythrina hosts Mol. Ecol. 14:3671–3682. based on mitochondrial and nuclear genes. Mabberly, D. J. 1987. The plant-book: A por- Formosan Entomol. 28:305–313. table dictionary of the higher plants. Cam- Tsutsui, N. D., and A. V. Suarez. 2003. The bridge University Press, Cambridge. colony structure and population biology of MacLeod, A., H. F. Evans, and R. H. A. invasive ants. Conserv. Biol. 17:48–58. Baker. 2002. An analysis of pest risk from Uechi, N., T. Uesato, and J. Yukawa. 2007. an Asian longhorn beetle (Anoplophora Detection of an invasive gall-inducing glabripennis) to hardwood trees in the Eu- pest, Quadrastichus erythrinae (Hymenop- ropean community. Crop Prot. 21:635– tera: Eulophidae), causing damage to 645. Erythrina variegata L. (Fabaceae) in Oki- Messing, R. H., S. Noser, and J. Hunkeler. nawa Prefecture, Japan. Entomol. Sci. Using host plant relationships to deter- 10:209–212. mine the origin of the invasive Erythrina Wagner, W. L., D. R. Herbst, and S. H. Gall Wasp. Biol. Invasions (in press). Sohmer. 1990. Manual of the flowering Online First: DOI 10.1007/s10530-008- plants of Hawai‘i. University of Hawai‘i 9379-y Press, Bishop Museum Press, Honolulu. Muirhead, J. R., B. Leung, C. Overdijk, D. W. Yang, M. M., G. S. Tung, J. LaSalle, and Kelly, K. Nandakumar, K. R. Marchant, M. L. Wu. 2004. Outbreak of erythrina and H. J. MacIsaac. 2006. Modelling local gall wasp (Hymenoptera: Eulophidae) on and long-distance dispersal of invasive Erythrina spp. (Fabaceae) in Taiwan. Plant emerald ash borer, Agrilus planipennis (Co- Prot. Bull. 46:391–396.