Phenylacetic Acid in Human Body Fluids: High Correlation Between Plasma and Cerebrospinal Fluid Concentration Values

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.45.4.366 on 1 April 1982. Downloaded from

Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 1982;45:366-368

Short report Phenylacetic acid in human body fluids: high correlation between plasma and cerebrospinal fluid concentration values

M SANDLER,* CRJ RUTHVEN,* BL GOODWIN,* A LEES,t GM STERNt From the Bernhard Baron Memorial Research Laboratories and Institute of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Queen Charlotte's Hospital,* and the Department of Neurology, University College Hospital, Londont

SUMMARY In a group of six Parkinsonian patients and 13 "controls" with non-Parkinsonian neurological disease, there was a high correlation between both free and conjugated phenylacetic acid concentrations in plasma and cerebrospinal fluid taken at about the same time. This compound is the major metabolite of phenylethylamine, the production of which may be disturbed in a number of neuropsychiatric illnesses. Thus plasma measurements might be employed clinically to provide an estimate ofcentral changes in phenylethylamine economy. A small but significantly higher proportion Protected by copyright. of conjugated phenylacetic acid was present in the plasma (but not cerebrospinal fluid) of Parkin- sonians compared with controls.

Phenylacetic acid is the major metabolite of phenyl- been expected between plasma and cerebrospinal ethylamine, a "trace amine"'l which has become the (CSF) compartments. focus of considerable clinical attention in recent With clinical interest being predominantly centred years. This amine has been invoked as a possible on neuropsychiatric illness, it has been tacitly aetiological agent in the pathogenesis of certain assumed that information about central phenyl- disease states, including depressive illness,2 schizo- ethylamine economy might most usefully be obtained phrenia,3 migraine4 and aggressive psychopathy.5 by determining phenylacetic acid levels in the Because phenylethylamine itself is normally present CSF.8 9 Where this has not been logistically feasible, in body fluids in very low concentration requiring however, plasma measurements have been per- extremely sensitive methods for its estimation which, formed.5 Although both approaches have yielded

by their nature, are exacting and prone to inter- positive and distinctive findings, the relationship http://jnnp.bmj.com/ ference, phenylacetic acid assay has become accepted between the two groups of data remained unclear. as a guide to the production of its parent monoamine. We therefore decided to perform parallel studies on Like phenylethylamine, unconjugated phenylacetic plasma and CSF samples drawn at abouLt the same acid is a lipid-soluble relatively non-polar compound time to see whether we could identify any connexion which might be expected to penetrate cell-membrane between the two sets of values. Unexpectedly, we barriers with some facility. However, in the cat at were able to identify a high degree of correlation not least, the 14C-labelled acid is only able to cross the only between free phenylacetic acid values but also In acid blood-brain barrier with difficulty.6 man, this those of its glutamine conjugate. on September 25, 2021 by guest. is excreted mainly as its glutamine conjugate7 which is much more polar and less lipid soluble than the Methods free acid. Thus, little communication might have Lumbar CSF and venous blood samples were drawn Address for reprint requests: Professor Merton Sandier, within 10 to 15 min of each other on in-patients at Queen Charlotte's Maternity Hospital, Goldhawk Road, University College Hospital. The 13 "control" subjects London W6 OXG, UK. (seven male, six female) were patients who had had CSF Received 13 November 1981 examinations performed as part of an investigation of Accepted 9 December 1981 peripheral neuropathy, radiculopathy or spinal cord 366 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.45.4.366 on 1 April 1982. Downloaded from

Phenylacetic acid in human body.fluids 367 disease. Six Parkinsonians (five male, one female) were least five times higher than those of CSF and the recent admissions who had not begun levodopa therapy at plasma levels of conjugated phenylacetic acid the time the samples were collected. Blood was taken into exceeded those of CSF at least twelve-fold, CSF lithium heparin tubes; plasma was separated immediately values in an individual changed sensitively in direct and stored at - 15°C to await analysis. CSF specimens proportion to those of the corresponding plasma. It were also stored at - 15°C. Plasma and CSF concentrations of free and total (free + conjugated) phenylacetic may thus be inferred that, had Sandier et al measured acid were measured by gas chromatography-mass spectro- plasma phenylacetic acid concentrations in their metry using a selected ion monitoring procedurett with depressive8 or schizophrenic9 series, they would slight modifications. [D5] phenylacetic acid was sub- respectively have been decreased or increased, in stituted for the [D7] isomer as internal standard in the proportion to the CSF values obtained. Had it, estimation of free phenylacetic acid, and a mixture of conversely, been practicable to acquire CSF samples [D5] phenylacetic acid plus [D5] phenylacetylglutamine from the aggressive psychopaths5 they described, we 1:2 assay was (ratio in CSF and 1:10 in plasma assay) may suppose that they would have followed the used, instead of [D7] phenylacetic acid, in the estimation of the total acid. raised plasma values observed in these subjects. Despite the general consensus that phenylacetic Results acid production mirrors that of endogenous phenylethylamine, findings have begun to emerge making a Mean (± SD) concentrations of free, conjugated and reassessment of this view timely: germ-free rats total phenylacetic acid in Parkinsonian and control excrete only about one quarter as much total plasma and CSF are shown in table 1. In both groups phenylacetic acid as conventional controls,1' suggest- there were highly significant correlations between ing a sizeable contribution from the gut flora. plasma and CSF concentrations of free, conjugated However, the proportion of phenylacetic acid and total phenylacetic acid respectively. There was a provided by gut flora (if these data can be extra- small but significantly higher proportion of plasma polated to man) may derive from some route of Protected by copyright. (but not CSF) conjugated phenylacetic acid in degradation different from that initiated by phenyl- Parkinsonians compared with controls (table 2). alanine decarboxylation to phenylethylamine. Although the output of the latter is increased sub- Discussion stantially in man following complete and irreversible inhibition of the phenylethylamine-preferring mono- Although plasma concentrations of free acid were at amine oxidase B by deprenyl,'2 the total is still only a

Table 1 Showing plasma and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) concentlations offree and conjugated phenylacetic acid in Parkinsonian and control subjects

Control subiects (n = 13) Parkinsonians (n = 6) Plasma CSF Plasma CSF

Free phenylacetic Mean ± SD 161 8 t 803 31 6 23 6 105 7 ± 845 25 6 t 15 acid (ng/mI) R 0 834 0 924 p <0001 <001 Conj phenylacetic Mean ± SD 412-5 ± 247 9 29-7 ± 143 424 5 ± 339 3 20-2 6-6 http://jnnp.bmj.com/ acid (ng/ml) R 0 900 0 922 p <0001 <0-01 Total phenylacetic Mean ± SD 574-3 316-9 61-3 i 36-3 530 2 419 7 45 8 ± 21 acid (ng/ml) R 0-962 0 970 p <0001 <001

Table 2 Conmparing plaisma and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) concentration offree phenylacetic acid expr-essed as a percentage of concentration of conjugated andfree plus conjugated (total) acid int Parkinsonians and control subjects on September 25, 2021 by guest. Plasma CSF Control subjects Parkinsonians Control subjects Parkinsonians n = 13 n = 6 n = 13 n = 6

Free as percentage Mean SD 440 + 17-2 25-8 ± 954 108-7 56-5 118-3 32-7 conj phenylacetic t 2-40 NS acid p <0-05 Free as percentage Mean SD 29 6 7-61 20 2 ± 590 49 0 ± 130 58-4 ± 665 total phenylacetic t 2 69 acid p <0 02 NS J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry: first published as 10.1136/jnnp.45.4.366 on 1 April 1982. Downloaded from

368 Sandker, Ruthven, Goodwin, Lees, Stern small fraction of the very large daily output of tographic assay of phenylacetic acid in biological phenylacetic acid.7 Even though further information fluids. Clin Chim Acta 1975;62:443-6. is required, however, before the full significance of 8 Sandier M, Ruthven CRJ, Goodwin BL, Coppen A. changes in phenylacetic acid concentration in Decreased cerebrospinal fluid concentration of free phenylacetic acid in depressive illness. Clin Chim different clinical groups is clear, these findings can Acta 1979;93:169-71. still be useful as state markers and employed accord- 9 Sandler M, Ruthven CRJ, Goodwin BL, et al. Raised ingly, particularly for the purpose of defining subsets cerebrospinal fluid phenylacetic acid concentration: of particular diagnostic classifications. We should preliminary support for the phenylethylamine remember, too, that in clinical conditions associated hypothesis of schizophrenia? Commun Psycho- with raised circulating concentrations of phenyl- pharmacol 1978 ;2 :199-202. acetic acid,513 the literature provides us with ample 10 Fellows LE, King GS, Pettit BR, Goodwin BL, reason for suspecting that the compound may, under Ruthven CRJ, Sandler M. Phenylacetic acid in certain circumstances, be toxic in its own right.'4-'9 human cerebrospinal fluid and plasma: selected ion assay. Biomed Mass Spectrom 1978;5: was one of interest which monitoring There further finding 508-11. emerged from this investigation. A small but signi- Sandler M, Bonham Carter S, Goodwin BL, Ruthven ficantly higher proportion of plasma (but not CSF) CRJ. Trace amine metabolism in man. In: Usdin E, phenylacetic acid in Parkinsonians compared with Sandler M, eds. Trace Amines and the Brain. New controls was present in conjugated form, thus pro- York: Dekker, 1976:233-81. viding yet another biochemical change to add to the 12 Elsworth JD, Glover V, Reynolds GP, Sandler M, list of systemic (as opposed to central) deficits of this Lees AJ, Phuapradit P, Shaw KM, Stern GM, disease. Whilst its significance remains unclear, it is Kumar P. Deprenyl administration in man: a selective reminiscent of an earlier finding of ours in Parkin- monoamine oxidase B inhibitor without the "cheese son's disease20 where we an increased basal effect". Psychopharmacology 1978 ;57 :33-8. detected 13 Woolf LI. Excretion of conjugated phenylacetic acid in urinary output of the (sulphate) conjugate of tyra- phenylketonuria. Biochem J 1951 ;49:ix-x. Protected by copyright. mine, another trace amine closely related to phenyl- 14 Sherwin CP, Woolf M, Woolf W. Maximum produc- ethylamine. A more systematic study of conjugation tion of glutamine by the human body as measured by mechanisms in general in this disease state might the output of phenylacetylglutamine. J Biol Chem provide useful information. 1919;37:113-9. 15 Sherwin CP, Kennard KS. Toxicity of phenylacetic References acid. J Biol Chem 1919;40:259-64. 16 Davison AN, Sandler M. Inhibition of 5-hydroxy- Usdin E, Sandler M, eds. Trace Amines and the Brain. tryptophan decarboxylase by phenylalanine metab- New York: Dekker, 1976. olites. Nature 1958;181:186. 2 Fischer E. The phenethylamine hypothesis of thymic 17 Loo YH, Miller KA, Nowlin J, Horning MG. Identi- homeostasis. Biol Psychiatry 1975 ;10:667-73. fication of metabolites of phenylacetic acid in rat 3 Sandler M, Reynolds GP. Does phenylethylamine brain by plasma desorption mass spectrometiy. Life cause schizophrenia? Lancet 1976;i :70-1. Sci 1980;26:657-63. 4 Sandler M, Youdim MBH, Hanington E. A phenyl- 18 Fulton TR, Triano T, Rabe A, Loo YH. Phenylacetate ethylamine oxidising defect in migraine. Nature and the enduring behavioral deficit in experimental 1974;250:335-7. phenylketonuria. Life Sci 1980;27:1271-81. 5 Sandler M, Ruthven CRJ, Goodwin BL, Field H, 19 Loo YH, Fulton T, Miller K, Wisniewski HM. http://jnnp.bmj.com/ Matthews R. Phenylethylamine overproduction in Phenylacetate and brain dysfunction in experimental aggressive psychopaths. Lancet 1978 ;ii :1269-70. phenylketonuria: synaptic development. Life Sci 6 Pedemonte WA, Mosnaim AD, Bulat M. Penetration 1980;27:1283-90. of phenylacetic acid across the blood-cerebrospinal 20 Bonham Carter SM, Youdim MBH, Sandier M, fluid barrier. Res Commun Chem Pathol Pharmacol Hunter KR, Stern GM. Enhanced tyramine conju- 1976;14:111-6. gation in Parkinson's disease. Clin Chim Acta 1974; 7Goodwin BL, Ruthven CRJ, Sandler M. Gas chroma- 51:327-9. on September 25, 2021 by guest.