DOCSLIB.ORG

Torah-True and Feminist Too: a Psychotherapist's View of the Conflict Between Orthodox Judaism and the Women's Movement*

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Torah-True and Feminist Too: a Psychotherapist's View of the Conflict Between Orthodox Judaism and the Women's Movement* Torah-True and Feminist Too: A Psychotherapist's View of the Conflict Between Orthodox Judaism and the Women's Movement* Aphrodite Ciamar, Ph.D. Psychotherapist, New York . Historically, religions have been interpreted by men in ways that are detrimental to women, that justify their lower socio-economic status and protect men from accountability. Misused and misapplied religion has traditionally kept women in the yoke of second-class citizenship in the name of God and faith. "May she sew, spin, weave, and be brought social consciousness, initiate social change and up to a life of good deeds." Such is the prayer question the ways in which men and women which a pious father inscribed, on the birth of relate to one another in all spheres of their a baby girl, in an old Hebrew book which was lives—be it school, work, or within the family. used as the family register. This prayer sums In the Orthodox Jewish community, which up the ideal of womanhood as cherished by the has always considered the woman and the Orthodox Jewish parents of a new-born family as the essential link in the continuity daughter. The end-all of her education was to and transmission of Jewish identity, what make the girl into a competent housewife and, happens to the family—and especially what at the same time, to build within her a happens to women—has tremendous impli­ character that would fit her for a life of "good cations. The social changes brought about by deeds." the Women's Movement are here to stay; and Today, while secular society has opened up families (in spite of all their faults) are likely to a new range of roles and psychological continue as our most basic socializing institu­ expectations to women, the status and life of tion. However, changes in how women view Orthodox Jewish women remain circumscribed themselves and their roles will have a crucial by Jewish religious law. Orthodox women face impact on the family. inequality in four areas: (1) the synagogue and In recent decades, therapists and family in participation in prayer; (2) religious counselors have been in the forefront of those education; (3) legal areas such as status in the professionals who are available to help women religious courts and divorce proceedings; and cope with, fit into, and articulate their roles (4) communal leadership. When confronted within a changing society. Slowly, Orthodox with criticism, Orthodox religious spokes­ Jewish women are turning to psychotherapy persons often resort to apologetics and for help in resolving the conflict between the defensiveness. The result is resistance by some traditional world of the home and synagogue, Orthodox Jewish women, anger, and con­ with its prescribed limits and proscribed fusion in the minds of many. behaviors, and the secular world, where the The Women's Movement, the most pro­ new status and the new opportunities created found, bloodless revolution in modern history, by the feminist revolution may be found, tried has challenged traditions, mores and vested and even enjoyed. Perhaps most importantly interests with a depth and intensity never for them, they are asking for reassessment and before felt. Its major impact has been to raise change in their ritual participation within Judaism—asking for more opportunities to * Presented at the Eighty-Seventh Annual Meeting fulfill themselves as Jews and women—not of the American Psychological Association, New less. Thus, the Orthodox women who are York, September 1-5, 1979. engaged in this movement—a small but 297 JOURNAL OF JEWISH COMMUNAL SERVICE growing number—are working for change not Within the frame-work of Orthodox by rejecting their tradition but by seeking to Judaism women lack certain legal rights. They modify it; not by attacking Jewish law but by cannot serve as witnesses in a Jewish court trying to amend it; not by repudiating custom (they are considered unreliable); they do not but by altering it; not by turning their backs on inherit equally with men; they are passive Jewish life but by attempting to enter it. figures in the wedding ceremony where they The target of these Orthodox women is are "consecrated unto their husbands;" and Judaism's traditional sex role differentiation, they cannot initiate divorce proceedings. which cites Halachic (religious) factors for Although communal pressures may be applied excluding women from entire spheres of the to force a husband to give his wife a divorce, Jewish experience. The problems Orthodox these safeguards have been known to fail, and women face in relation to their traditions are many a woman has had to wait, powerless, deep and complex. Thus Halacha, the Jewish while he controlled her fate and future. Over family structure, and her own socialization all the centuries, too, the ancient awe, fear, become obstacles in the Orthodox woman's repugnance and mythology that characterized quest for self-actualization and full member­ male attitudes toward female sexuality, ship within her religion. Many Orthodox menstruation and birthing were intricately women are trying to sort out the differences woven into the Jewish experience and Halacha. between Halachic considerations and those Thus woman became the temptress, the that have been superimposed by the secular potential entrapper of even the most pious culture. man. In a reversal of roles, male lust was Orthodox men define themselves through a assigned to women, who then had to be wide and highly respected set of activities controlled—lest they lead man away from within the synagogue and community; women, God—by imposing rigid standards of behavior on the contrary, are defined in socio-biological between men and women, by strict standards terms as wife and mother and relegated almost of modesty and dress and by seating them in exclusively to home and family life. Women specially designated areas in the synagogue are encouraged and socialized to concern behind a mechitza where their presence would themselves with serving, nurturing and home- not distract the men from prayer. making. They are exempt from particular, In Feminists for Judaism, Sheila F. Segal revered mitzvot, because of their family refers to the impact of the emotion-laden issue responsibilities, even though it is possible to of the mechitza for both sexes: share these responsibilities with their hus­ To many men it is a demarcation of the bands, and they may have more free time than domain in which they reign; to many women their working husbands to fulfill the mitzvot. it is a symbol of their own inferior status, for Nevertheless, because they are not required by it usually relegates them to the back or kicks Halacha to participate in communal prayer them upstairs to the grandstands . The three times a day, Orthodox Jewish women real problem is not the mechitza itself but the do not count towards a minyan nor can they attitudes it symbolizes and nurtures: that the lead a service. Within the family, women may spiritual activity of women is not as important as that of men, that they are have a necessary, even noble, role, but the soul irrelevant to the service, and that they must of traditional Judaism is communal—prayer, be kept apart because of woman's monthly sacred study and ritual obligation, pursuits uncleanness . The assumption that a open almost exclusively to men. As Paula woman could "contaminate" the Torah has Hyman has observed, "the synagogue is a prevailed for centuries, despite the fact that 'men's club', perhaps the most ancient in the Torah cannot be defiled by any human history."! contact. Such distortions have had insidious effects 1 Paula Hyman, "Is It Kosher to be Feminist?" —first teaching women to feel disgust over Ms, July 1974, p. 76. their own bodily functions and ultimately 298 CLAMAR leading them to reject the tradition that Even in families where Orthodox women do nurtures such attitudes.2 not work, they often have more free time than Ms. Segal goes on to note that "most men ever before; and, in varying degrees, they are have virtually no accurate perception of the exposed to the influences of the secular world issues involved today, or even of the reasons and the effects of the Women's Movement. why women have been excluded over the They no longer accept inequalities, com­ centuries." fortable though the status quo might be after Resolving the conflict between the new centuries of conditioning. social order, with its emphasis on self-fulfill­ Thus, the Orthodox Jewish woman who ment, and the Orthodox Jewish conceptions of seeks psychotherapy today does so because legal relationships and responsibilities will not what she sees and hears in the world outside be easy. Today, increasing numbers of challenges what she has been taught to believe. Orthodox wives are working outside the home Feminist psychotherapy is particularly well- and there is a concomitant trend toward equipped to deal with these issues. The greater husband participation in home and Orthodox Jewish woman who seeks to initiate child-care. Aileen Cohen Nusbacher at change in her life through the process of Brooklyn College, who examined the attitudes psychotherapy presents many of the same and life-styles of a group of 30 middle-class basic problems as any other woman seeking Orthodox women committed to both mother­ help—a desire to strengthen her conception of hood and career goals, found that the women herself; a wish to improve the myriad layers of she studied succeeded not by minimizing the her "personna" within her unique social- conflict or by compartmentalizing roles but communal world, and the recognition of her rather because "they were determined in their worthiness as a woman and person. aspirations, encouraged by their husbands, But in addition to these fundamental needs, had mothers as models for working, and were which the great majority of women in psycho­ urged to achieve academically." therapy seek to fulfill, the Orthodox woman "The satisfactions derived from work and needs special help.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • (The) Sisterhood Is Powerful: Remarks by Rabbi Rachel M. Isaacs Upon the Inauguration of the Dorothy “Bibby” Levine Alfond Professorship in Jewish Studies
    (The) Sisterhood is Powerful: Remarks by Rabbi Rachel M. Isaacs upon the Inauguration of the Dorothy “Bibby” Levine Alfond Professorship in Jewish Studies. November 19, 2015 Colby College, Waterville, Maine In October of 1957, the Beth Israel Congregation sisterhood met to discuss issues that ranged from the pedestrian to the controversial. After a vigorous conversation on the value of having a gossip column in the synagogue newsletter, the women of the sisterhood turned to their attention to an issue that was as salacious as it was fantastical: the possibility of women rabbis. Even though the Reform movement had ordained one woman, Regina Jonas, in Germany before the Holocaust, she had perished with her congregation in the concentration camps, and was largely forgotten by the mainstream Jewish world for many decades to come. But on this day in October of 1957, the sisterhood leaders of Beth Israel Congregation discussed the issue in Waterville, Maine. According to synagogue records, “Mrs. George Chesner introduced Rabbi Steinberg who was the speaker of the evening. His topic - ‘Women Rabbis’.” Sisterhood secretary Esther Paikowsky recorded his remarks: “Rabbi Steinberg is definitely opposed to women following this 1 profession. One reason being that there would not be a ‘Rebbetzin (a rabbi’s wife), and since a ‘Rebbetzin’ has functional duties in a congregation, it would not do to have the husband perform these duties. Another objection is who would raise the family and care for the home, certainly a man cannot do that. Therefore a man
    [Show full text]
  • Wertheimer, Editor Imagining the Seth Farber an American Orthodox American Jewish Community Dreamer: Rabbi Joseph B
    Imagining the American Jewish Community Brandeis Series in American Jewish History, Culture, and Life Jonathan D. Sarna, Editor Sylvia Barack Fishman, Associate Editor For a complete list of books in the series, visit www.upne.com and www.upne.com/series/BSAJ.html Jack Wertheimer, editor Imagining the Seth Farber An American Orthodox American Jewish Community Dreamer: Rabbi Joseph B. Murray Zimiles Gilded Lions and Soloveitchik and Boston’s Jeweled Horses: The Synagogue to Maimonides School the Carousel Ava F. Kahn and Marc Dollinger, Marianne R. Sanua Be of Good editors California Jews Courage: The American Jewish Amy L. Sales and Leonard Saxe “How Committee, 1945–2006 Goodly Are Thy Tents”: Summer Hollace Ava Weiner and Kenneth D. Camps as Jewish Socializing Roseman, editors Lone Stars of Experiences David: The Jews of Texas Ori Z. Soltes Fixing the World: Jewish Jack Wertheimer, editor Family American Painters in the Twentieth Matters: Jewish Education in an Century Age of Choice Gary P. Zola, editor The Dynamics of American Jewish History: Jacob Edward S. Shapiro Crown Heights: Rader Marcus’s Essays on American Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Jewry Riot David Zurawik The Jews of Prime Time Kirsten Fermaglich American Dreams and Nazi Nightmares: Ranen Omer-Sherman, 2002 Diaspora Early Holocaust Consciousness and and Zionism in Jewish American Liberal America, 1957–1965 Literature: Lazarus, Syrkin, Reznikoff, and Roth Andrea Greenbaum, editor Jews of Ilana Abramovitch and Seán Galvin, South Florida editors, 2001 Jews of Brooklyn Sylvia Barack Fishman Double or Pamela S. Nadell and Jonathan D. Sarna, Nothing? Jewish Families and Mixed editors Women and American Marriage Judaism: Historical Perspectives George M.
    [Show full text]
  • Gender in Jewish Studies
    Gender in Jewish Studies Proceedings of the Sherman Conversations 2017 Volume 13 (2019) GUEST EDITOR Katja Stuerzenhofecker & Renate Smithuis ASSISTANT EDITOR Lawrence Rabone A publication of the Centre for Jewish Studies, University of Manchester, United Kingdom. Co-published by © University of Manchester, UK. All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. No part of this volume may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher, the University of Manchester, and the co-publisher, Gorgias Press LLC. All inquiries should be addressed to the Centre for Jewish Studies, University of Manchester (email: [email protected]). Co-Published by Gorgias Press LLC 954 River Road Piscataway, NJ 08854 USA Internet: www.gorgiaspress.com Email: [email protected] ISBN 978-1-4632-4056-1 ISSN 1759-1953 This volume is printed on acid-free paper that meets the American National Standard for Permanence of paper for Printed Library Materials. Printed in the United States of America Melilah: Manchester Journal of Jewish Studies is distributed electronically free of charge at www.melilahjournal.org Melilah is an interdisciplinary Open Access journal available in both electronic and book form concerned with Jewish law, history, literature, religion, culture and thought in the ancient, medieval and modern eras. Melilah: A Volume of Studies was founded by Edward Robertson and Meir Wallenstein, and published (in Hebrew) by Manchester University Press from 1944 to 1955. Five substantial volumes were produced before the series was discontinued; these are now available online.
    [Show full text]
  • Paula Hyman That Won a National Jewish Book Award
    PAUL A HYMAN (1946–2011) At the Center of Change by rachel kranson !TTHETIMEOFHERDEATHIN$ECEMBER 0AULA(YMANWASTHE,UCY-OSES0ROFESSOROF-ODERN*EWISH(ISTORY AT9ALE5NIVERSITY3HEHADBEENTHEFIRSTFEMALEDEANOFTHE!LBERT!,IST#OLLEGEOFTHE*EWISH4HEOLOGICAL 3EMINARY THEFIRSTWOMANPRESIDENTOFTHE!MERICAN!CADEMYFOR*EWISH2ESEARCH ANDCO FOUNDEROFTHEGER- MINAL*EWISHFEMINISTGROUPOFTHES %ZRAT.ASHIM7HILESTILLAGRADUATESTUDENT SHEAUTHOREDWHATMAY have been the first social history of Jewish women, The Jewish Woman in America [1976], and then proceeded to transform the way that Jewish scholars think of such basic historical paradigms as assimilation and acculturation BYVIEWINGTHESEPHENOMENATHROUGHTHELENSOFGENDER3EEHERBIBLIOGRAPHYATLilith.org.) -OSTOFTHE*EWISHGIRLSBORNIN!MERICATODAYWILLTAKEITFORGRANTEDTHATWOMENCANBERABBIS COUNT in a minyan, and read from the Torah. And Jewish historians being trained today are called to task when THEYDONOTTAKEGENDERINTOACCOUNT0AULA(YMANWASAT the forefront of the religious and intellectual struggles that GENERATEDTHESECHANGES(ERINFLUENCEEXTENDEDBOTHINTO the academy and far beyond it, affecting the lives of Jewish females in schools and congregations in ways of which many are still unaware. The reflections that follow give some glimpses into her LEGACY ANDTHEEXTRAORDINARYWAYSINWHICHSHESHAPEDTHE Jewish feminist world we live in today. Rachel Kranson teaches in the religious studies faculty at the University of amy stone amy Pittsburgh. She is co-editor of !*EWISH&EMININE-YSTIQUE*EWISH7OMENIN Hyman and her daughter Judith Rosenbaum, 2010.
    [Show full text]
  • Judaism As a Culture Table of Content
    Judaism as Culture The Beauty of Secularism Presented by the Posen Foundation Judaism as a Culture Table of Content Forward David Shaham Judaism, a Jewish State & Social Justice Dr. Ovadia Ezra What is Jewish Secularism? Dr. Yedidya Itzhaki Know How to Respond to the Orthodox (Book Review) Tova Birenbaum Judaism as a Plurality of Jewish Cultures Yaakov Malkin "The Return to History" – Jewish Secularism and its Fracturing Prof. Shalom Ratsabi On Gender and the Beginning of Secularization in Europe Prof. Shmuel Feiner The Secular Battle in the Knesset Lior Tal interviews MKs Nitzan Horowitz and Shlomo Mula A Revolt Grounded in Tradition – A Book Review Noam Regev A Lax Secularism with No Battles Dr. Guy Ben-Porat On Music, Psalms and God Doron Nesher Judaism, Culture and that which is between Them – An Interview with Daniel Posen Yossi Beilin converses with Daniel Posen The Objective is Still Ahead of Us Felix Posen Idealistic Teachers Open Student Minds Doron Nesher interviews Prof. Ron Margolin Judaism as a Culture Dr. Ariel Picard Secularism and Me Miriam Kayni Secular Israeli Identity: No Apologies Needed Dr. Ela Bauer What Appears on the Price List is Holy: On Secularization & Hebrew Dr. Zvia Valdan Women's Singing – Her Lips are Moving and Her Voice won't be Heard? Eli Bareket On Modesty, Permissiveness and Secular Silence Galia Oz The Secular Yeshiva's Fringe Theatre Ariel Levinson How Secularism Affected My Life Shlomit Naim Naor BINA – The Posen Foundation's Link to Young People in Israel Gal Brozin interviews Eran Baruch, BINA general director Loyalty, Flexibility & Mission: The Challenges of Secular Judaism Dov Elboim Dubnov & Kalish: Personal Stories of Secularization Dr.
    [Show full text]
  • MS-603: Rabbi Marc H
    MS-603: Rabbi Marc H. Tanenbaum Collection, 1945-1992. Series E: General Alphabetical Files. 1960-1992 Box 94 , Folder 6, Women, 1977. 3101 Clifton Ave , Cincinnati. Ohio 45220 (513) 221·1675 phone. (513) 221·7612 fax americanjewisharchives.org 3 CD 3 ...o THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE III ::la. date November 23, 1977 c: to Marc H. Tanenbaum 3 from r,nge 'Lederer Gibel subject This is my fil'st chance to report to you on a number of items of interest, based on our last conversation before I left. Of course, we didn't know then that the Sadat thing would come off and we still don't know how much everything has changed because of it. You should know that I was part of a New Outlook delegation of ten (which included Nahum Goldman, Pierre Mendes-France and Prof. Saul Friedlander) ~ho met briefly with Sadat pefore his departure. Institutional identification was not used in the introductions to Sadat. The office here is going to help me get hold of ·one': of the photographs that was taken at the nieeting, which at the end included Begin. Bernie is now involved in setting up some meetings for me, including either Shro,uel Katz or r.toshe Yegar and tomorrow afternoon Bernie and I are having lunch with Jim Wall who was also at the New Outlook Conference. H 've als·o suggested that we try to . get .Yegar to see Wa:p as I think it's important for Wall to hear someone fro~ the other side. Also at the conference I had a chance to talk at some length ~ith .
    [Show full text]
  • RE Final Draft
    Connected to Community: Jewish Ritual, Meaning, and Gender at Brandeis University Master’s Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Brandeis University Hornstein Program for Jewish Professional Leadership Department of Near Eastern and Judaic Studies Sylvia Barack Fishman, Advisor Amy L. Sales, Reader In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Arts in Jewish Professional Leadership and Near Eastern and Judaic Studies by Rachel Elizabeth Eisen May 2016 Acknowledgements One of the first classes I took as a graduate student was called “Half-Jews, Queer- Jews, and Bu-Jews: Mapping Jewish Identities in America,” taught by then-PhD-candidate Emily Sigalow. I went into the class intrigued by intersectional identities and I came out intrigued by qualitative research. Although I had no idea what I wanted to study for my (then still so far off) master’s thesis, I knew how I wanted to study it. This thesis has truly been a labor of love, emphasis on labor. Beyond Emily’s class, I had very little idea of what goes into sociological research, and, in my typical fashion, I dove straight in, and asked questions later. I am grateful to Emily not only for introducing me to this field of research but also for introducing me to her dissertation advisor, Sylvia Barack Fishman. Professors Fishman and Amy L. Sales, my advisors in this thesis, have offered me guidance and support throughout, encouraging me all along. I am also indebted to Harry Abrahams, Jewish Student Life Associate at Brandeis Hillel, Rabbi Peretz Chein of Chabad House Brandeis, Rabbi David Pardo of the Jewish Learning Initiative at Brandeis, and Rabbi Elyse Winick, the Jewish Chaplain at Brandeis, along with multiple student leaders at Brandeis Hillel, for their assistance in recruiting research participants.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ingeborg, Tamara & Yonina Rennert Women in Judaism
    THE INGEBORG, TAMARA & YONINA RENNERT WOMEN IN JUDAISM FORUM JEWISH WOMEN CHANGING AMERICA: CROSS GENERATIONAL-CONVERSATIONS SUNDAY, 30 OCTOBER 2005 PANEL DISCUSSION 2: “CHANGING JEWISH COMMUNITIES” Janet Jakobsen: Good morning. I’m Janet Jakobsen and I’m director of the Barnard Center for Research on Women and this year’s Ingeborg, Tamara and Yonina Rennert Forum on Women and Judaism. The Rennert Forum brings to Barnard scholars, artists, and activists—and you will hear from all three over the course of the day—whose work promotes understanding of the complex roles of sex, gender, and sexuality in Judaism today and throughout history. One of the things that we’re hoping that this conference will do is bring forward some of the great diversity of the work that Jewish women are doing in changing America. We structured the conference in the hopes of exploring that diversity—by looking at different Jewish communities, looking at different religious communities, looking at the making of culture and how that works. And, thanks to last night’s discussion, we have a vivid sense of the wide range of communities that people are working in, both generational communities and also different racial and ethnic communities within Judaism. We’re very excited to be able to bring this diverse set of perspectives to the questions of the conference. As I also mentioned last night, the great difficulty that the planning committee had in formulating this event was how to bring forward any kind of comprehensive representation of the work that Jewish women are doing. We decided we couldn’t do that, so what we are trying to do was start a conversation.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Articles the Impact of Feminism on American Jewish Life
    Special Articles The Impact of Feminism on American Jewish Life by SYLVIA BARACK FISHMAN Introduction 1 HE LIVES OF JEWS in the United States—like the lives of most Americans—have been radically transformed by 20 years of feminism. Some of these changes have been effected by the larger feminist movement and some by a specifically Jewish feminist effort. Thus, while many feminist celebrities, such as Betty Friedan and Bella Abzug, are Jews, the focus of their feminism has not been specifically Jewish in nature; they have pro- foundly changed the behavior and attitudes of American Jews as Americans and not as Jews. Pioneers of the contemporary Jewish feminist movement, on the other hand—women such as Rachel Adler, Paula Hyman, and Aviva Cantor—are primarily recognizable within the Jewish sphere. They and many other Jewish feminists have significantly altered the character of Jewish religious, intellectual, cultural, and communal life in the United States. In the stormy late 1960s and early 1970s, when the rising stars of contem- porary American feminism were publicly denounced from synagogue pul- pits as aberrant and destructive, feminist attitudes and goals seemed revolutionary. Today, however, many general feminist and Jewish feminist attitudes and goals have been absorbed and domesticated within the public lives of mainstream American Jewry. Female rabbis and cantors have been trained, ordained, and graduated from Reform, Reconstructionist, and now Conservative seminaries, and are becoming accepted as part of the Ameri- can Jewish religious scene. Life-cycle events for females, such as the "Sha- lom Bat" and Bat Mitzvah ceremonies, are commonplace. Women's organizations which a short time ago expressed ambivalence about the impact of feminism on their ranks now officially espouse feminist goals.1 'The Women's Division of the Council of Jewish Federations, for example, a group which seems to epitomize commitment to establishment values and communal survival, featured a number of feminist figures at its 1987 General Assembly in Miami.
    [Show full text]
  • Professor Karla Goldman 4704 School of Social Work Building [email protected], 734-763-6583 Office Hours by Appointment
    Professor Karla Goldman 4704 School of Social Work Building [email protected], 734-763-6583 Office Hours by Appointment A History of American Jewish Women Judaic Studies 417 - 001 / Social Work 513 – 001/ History 468 – 001/ AmCult 405 - 009 Tuesday, 2-5 p.m. / 1804 SSWB / Winter 2019 Course Description: This class on American Jewish history foregrounds the experience and perspectives of Jewish women. It explores the creation of American Judaism and Jewish community; the experience of immigration; the pursuit of political activism and social justice; and changing notions of identity, sexuality, family, and leadership through the lens of women’s lives and voices. Drawing upon primary and literary texts, this course challenges us to consider how the telling of American Jewish history changes when women are placed at the center. Course Objectives: Completion of this course will result in the ability of students to: 1. Think critically and expansively about the sources of history. Whose stories get told? Whose are ignored? What kind of historical sources shape the stories we receive? 2. Grasp the central themes shaping the historical experience of American Jewish women. 3. Recognize the difference between accounts of American Jewish history that incorporate women and those that do not. 4. Make connections across historical periods – be able to see the relevance of past historical periods to today. 5. Recognize how evolving gender roles and expectations have inflected American Jewish identity at the intersection of socio-economic, racial, religious, and ethnic American identities. 6. Understand general frameworks shaping American Jewish experience through different historical periods. 7. Become familiar with major events and central figures in the history of American Jewish women while also holding onto the stories and significance of “ordinary” women.
    [Show full text]
  • Curious Daughters: Language, Literacy, and Jewish Female Desire in German and Yiddish Literature from 1793 to 1916
    CURIOUS DAUGHTERS: LANGUAGE, LITERACY, AND JEWISH FEMALE DESIRE IN GERMAN AND YIDDISH LITERATURE FROM 1793 TO 1916 Lea H. Greenberg A dissertation submitted to the faculty at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Carolina- Duke Graduate Program in German Studies. Chapel Hill 2021 Approved by: Ruth von Bernuth Eric Downing Stefani Engelstein Kata Gellen Jeffrey Grossman ©2021 Lea H. Greenberg ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii ABSTRACT Lea H. Greenberg: Curious Daughters: Language, Literacy, and Jewish Female Desire in German and Yiddish Literature from 1793 to 1916 (Under the direction of Ruth von Bernuth) This dissertation examines the interplay of language politics and romantic politics in German and Yiddish literature confronting the challenges faced by Judaism in the long nineteenth century. The project brings into dialogue both German and Yiddish texts, from West Yiddish farces to the literature of a new German Jewish elite to the popular stories of Tevye the Dairyman. This diverse body of literature uses a concern with the sexual purity and loyalty of the Jewish daughter to encode anxieties toward Jewish assimilation into the non-Jewish world. Yet these works also share another layer of the daughter’s subversion: an act of rebellion in the form of a linguistic or cultural departure from tradition. Each of these texts depicts how the Jewish daughter’s adoption of European language and literacy operates in conjunction with her romantic transgressions. I read these works in conversation with the gendered discourse on Jewish language and the history of Jewish women in Europe; these dynamics create a framework for understanding an ambivalence toward new modes of Jewish life.
    [Show full text]
  • Tracing the Contours of a Half Century of Jewish Feminist Theology
    TRACING THE CONTOURS OF A HALF CENTURY OF JEWISH FEMINIST THEOLOGY Mara H. Benjamin This essay examines the trajectory of Jewish feminist theology from the 1970s to today. It uses a synthetic, thematic approach, distilling concerns that appear across generically diverse theological writings over the last half century. These themes include the authority of Jewish classical texts and ritual practice, the meaning of embodi- ment, and the potential of theologies of immanence. The essay is framed by a consideration of the activist roots that fed Jewish fem- inist theology in its initial stages, on the one hand, and the changed conditions of production that characterize the present, on the other. Keywords: activism, authority, embodiment, halakha, immanence, Jewish feminism Feminist activism profoundly reshaped Jewish ritual life in North America. Communal leadership and worship practices are but the most visible, tangible markers of change in religious performance over recent decades. This same activ- ism also decisively changed the landscape of Jewish God-talk in the late twenti- eth and early twenty-first century. Challenging entrenched patterns of women’s subordination necessarily begged fundamental questions about the cosmic order, authority, and the human condition. The critiques of Jewish theological claims that resulted from this encounter led to an outpouring of innovative work in mid- rash, ritual, liturgy, and other expressive forms typical of Jewish theological reflec- tion. These critiques also led to scholarly reconnaissance missions to theological terrain long overlooked or marginalized within academic scholarship. This article examines the impact of feminism on Jewish theology from the vantage point of the current moment, using “theology” expansively to include systematic theological texts and a wide variety of non-systematic modalities that Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 36.1 (2020), 11–31 Copyright © 2020 The Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion, Inc.
    [Show full text]