SHORT NOTES 65

SHORT NOTES have more extensive distributions. The genus hw11111ohi11e.1 appears to conform to this general pattern in that the species HERPETOLOGICAL JOURNAL, Vol. 3, pp. 65-67 ( 1993 ) with the smallest range. P. geo111e1ric11s. is a southwestern Cape endemic. Poynton ( 1989: p.2) describes two contrasting faunas in the southern subcontinent. "the one being more A HYPOTHESIS EXPLAINING THE cool-adapted and presently showing re lict patterning in areas ENIGMATIC DISTRIBUTION OF THE of high altitude and latitude, the other being warm-adapted GEOMETRIC TORTOISE, with continuous ranges brought about by recent range expan­ sion". He goes on to point out that this led to a "'dynamic PS AMMOBATES GEOMETRICUS, IN model involving reciprocal spreading and withdrawing of the SOUTH AFRICA interlocking cool- and warm-adapted groups following the cyclic changes in Quaternary climate". Mouton & Oelofsen ' ' E. H. W. BAARD AND P. LE F. N. MOUTON ( 1988) discuss the importance of the Cape Fold Mountains. the coastal lowlands and the cold Benguela sea current in 'Cof'e Na111re Co11ser\'{/fio11. Pril'llle Bag X50/4, 7599 speciation events among cordylid lizards in the southwestern Srelle11bosch, So111h Africa Cape. During changing climates these mountains become ef­

'John Eller11101111 Museum. Deparrmenr 1fZoology. Uni1·ersitr of fective barriers trapping warm-adapted populations along the Stellenbosch. 7600 Srellenbosch, South Africa western coastal lowlands. Due to a supposedly increased in­ fluence of the Cold Benguela current on coastal climates (Accepted 8.5. 92) during glacial periods, populations along the coastal lowlands become subjected to more adverse climatic conditions than The genus Psammobmes Fitzinger, 1835 comprises three inland sister populations. These coastal populations may be­ species, namely Psammobates geometricus, P. oculife r and come adapted to local conditions, and may eventually P. tentorius (Loveridge & Williams, 1957; Boycott & speciate. Bourquin, 1988; Branch, 1988). P. geometricus and P. oculife r are monotypic species, while P. tentorius is di­ It is not difficult to picture P. geometricus to have origi­ vided into three subspecies, namely P. t. tentorius, nated through a very similar series of events as that proposed P. t. trimeni and P. t. verroxii (Loveridge & Williams, 1957; for the Cordy/us cordylus complex by Mouton & Oelofsen Greig & Burdett, 1976; Pritchard, 1979; Boycott & Bourquin, ( 1988). During a warmer interglacial period a warm-adapted 1988). Previously the P. tentorius complex was subdivided ancestral species could have had an extensive range which into as many as 28 different species and subspecies (Hewitt, also included the southwestern coastal lowlands. With the 1933). advance of a subsequent glacial period, range contraction and fragmentation could have taken place leaving behind an iso­ It was suggested by Siebenrock ( 1904), Duerden ( 1907), lated population along the southwestern coastal lowlands. Miiller (1939) and Greig & Burdett (1976) that the Due to differential environmental pressures west and east of Psammobates taxa fall into two groups, geometricus and the Cape Fold Mountains, the western population could even­ ocu/ife r constituting the one and the tentorius complex the tually have diverged from the original eastern stock in other. The proposed sister group relationship between becoming more cool-adapted. geometricus and oculife r is, however, based mainly on phenetic principles and does not necessarily reflect the true Psammobates geometricus today occurs in three areas phylogeny. For phylogeny reconstruction, a cladistic analy­ which are more or Jess geographically isolated from one an­ sis, based on the search for synapomorphies, is called for other (Fig. I). These are the southwestern coastal lowlands (Wiley, 198 1 ) . A preliminary analysis of phylogenetic affini­ (the area from Gordon's Bay in the south to Piketberg in the ties within Psammobates, forming part of a study on the north), the Worcester-Tulbagh valley and the Ceres valley. biology and conservation status of P. geometricus (Baard, These three areas are separated from one another by mountain 1990), corroborated the above grouping. ranges. Presently P. geometricus occurs nowhere on moun­ tainous terrain and it is therefore believed that such areas The present distribution of the three species of serve as physical barriers restricting movement of these tor­ Pswnmobates (Boycott & Bourquin, 1988; Branch, 1988), toises and consequently gene flow among the populations. however, seems to contradict this grouping since the two sis­ The question to be addressed therefore, is how these isolated ter species (P. geometricus and P. ocu/ifer) are populations originated or, in other words, how the populations ' geographically separated by P. tentorius. Bearing in mind, were formerly geographically linked. however, that allopatric speciation is in all probability the most common mode of speciation (Wiley, 1981 ), it is to be The answer to this depends on knowing the genealogical expected that sister species initially will have allopatric distri­ relationships among the extant populations. Because such in­ butions. Furthermore, it is not diffi cult to perceive that formation is not available at present, it would be impossible to P. tentorius, through range expansion, could have penetrated arrive at any firm conclusions in this regard. It is. however, into areas left void by a contracting f?erJ111e1ricus-ocul(fer an­ still possible to discuss the various ways in which the present cestral species. populations could have been linked in the past.

As far as the herpetofauna of southern Africa is concerned, During periods of lowered sea-levels (Deacon, Hendey & the southwestern Cape is considered the richest centre of en­ Lambrechts. 1983). the western coastal lowlands and the demism (Hewitt, 1910; Poynton, 1964; Poynton & Broadley, Worcester-Tulbagh valley could have been linked via the 1978). Restricted distribution ranges are characteristic of southern coastal forelands of the present day Hangklip area forms from the southwest. while forms in the northeast tend to (Fig. I). For example. Tankard's ( 1976) time-depth plot of 66 SHORT NOTES

O km 100 _____,

0

fmPs ammobates geometricus populations

E=:=:=J Cape Fold Mountains (altitude > 500m a.s.I.)

Fig. I Map of the south western Cape Province, indicating the present location of Psammobates geometricus populations, as well as possible communication routes and routes of genetic exchange between populations. sea-levels for South Africa over the past 47 OOO years sug­ route between the Ceres and Worcester-Tulbagh populations gests a rapid fall in sea-level with the advance of the final would have been via a northeastern, inland route (Fig. 1 ). The Wurm glaciation, with a minimum sea-level of -130 m historical inland extension of, firstly, climates favourable to reached at 17 OOO to 18 OOO years B.P. This implies that a P. geometricus and, secondly, its favoured habitat, considerable portion of the continental shelf would have been renosterveld, might possibly have facilitated this inland link exposed during such times allowing communication between via the present-day Karoo. the western coastal lowland and Worcester-Tulbagh valley populations of P. geometricus. The natural occurrence of P. geometricus in the Ceres val­ ley was questioned by Juvik ( 1971), who suggested that the Another possible communication route between the population there might have originated from pet tortoises coastal and Worcester-Tulbagh valley populations might brought in from elsewhere. However, since there are at least have been the gap in the Fold Mountains through the present­ six natural populations in the valley, as well as a strong pres­ day Nuwekloof Pass (Fig. 1 ). At present P. geometricus is ence of renosterveld habitat, and considering that absent from this ravine and, the terrain being very rugged, it is P. geometricus appears to be closely associated with this unlikely that it ever fu nctioned as a link between the two habitat (Greig, 1984; Boycott & Bourquin, 1988; Branch, populations. 1988; Baard, 1990), we regard it highly unlikely that a fairly large population in the wild could have originated from a few As regards the Ceres valley population, there are also two escaped or released individuals. possibilities of how this population and the Worcester popula­ tion could have been linked in the past. A link was possible In conclusion, it is clear that there are various ways in through the Dwars River ravine (the present-day Michell's which the three populations could have been linked geo­ Pass) (Fig. 1 ). At present, this route appears to be impassable graphically in the past. More definite conclusions in this for terrestrial tortoises, particularly with the Dwars River and regard, however, would only be possible once the relation­ its steep embankments limiting access. However, geological ships among the populations are known. A study to determine information from this region (Visser, De Villiers, Theron & these relationships by means of electrophoresis or DNA­ Hill, 1980; Sohnge & Hlilbich, 1983; A. P. G. Sohnge, pers. analysis is therefore highly recommended. comm.) suggests that the present drainage patterns in the Ceres and Worcester-Tulbagh valleys differ considerably Unravelling the genealogical relationships between mem­ from those approximately 10 million years B.P. (i.e. during bers of Psammobates presents an exciting challenge to future the formation of the gorge, temporary flat areas could possi­ workers in this field. A cladistic study of the fam ily bly have facilitated a link). A more likely communication Testudinidae, additional to that of Crumly ( 1984) and SHORT NOTES 67

Gaffney & Meylan ( 1988) is. however. fundamental to this. Gre ig. J. C. & Burde tt. P. D. ( 1976). Paucrns in the distribution of An analysis of the hiogeography of this genus and possibly southern African terrestri al tortoise' !CryptoLiira: other genera as well. may contribute significantly to our un­ Te stuLiiniJae ). Zoo/. A.Ji'. 11(2). 249-273.

derstanding of the biogeographical patterns already observed Hewitt. J. ( 1910). The wological region of southern Africa as in other animal groups in southern Africa. deduced from the composit ion of its Laccrtilia. Ann. Tro n.IT. Mus. 2. 56-71.

Ack11mrledge111e111s. The authors want to thank Prof. A. P. G. Hewitt. J. ( 19.1 3). On the Cape species and subspecies of the genus Siihnge (Department of Geology, University of Stellenbosch) Chersinella Gray. Part I. Ann. Noto/ Mus. 7. 255-29.1. for supplying information on the historic geological fe atures Juvik. J. 0. (I97 I). The status of P.H111111whates geometrirns in the of the Ceres and Worcester-Tulbagh valleys. Thanks are also Western Cape. Jnr. Turrie anti Tortoise Soc. J. 5( I). I 0- 13. due to the Chief Director Cape Nature Conservation for per­ mission to publish this paper. It is part of a series of papers Loveridge. A. & Williams. E. E. (I957). Revision of the African tortoises and turtles of the suborder Cryptodira. Bull. Mus. originating from a Ph.D. dissertation completed in I 990 under Comp. Zoo/. Han·. 1 1 5(6) . 163-557. supervision of the Department of Zoology. University of Stellenbosch. Mouton. P. LeF. N. & Oelofsen. B. W. ( 1988). A model explaining patterns of geographic variation in Cordr/11s conlrlus REFERENCES (Reptilia: Cordylidae) in the south-western Cape. South Africa. S. Afr. J. Zoo/. 23( I). 20-3 1. O Baard. E. H. W. ( 1990). Biological aspects and co11se1w1tion .5/atus MUiier. L. ( 1939). ber Variation und Systematik einiger f�l the geometric rortni.H'. Psammo/Jates geometricus sUdafrikanischer Landschildkroten der Geometrica-Gruppe. (Linnaeus, 1758) (Cryp todira: Testudinidae ). Ph.D. Abhandlu11gen und Berichte fiir Na1urku11de und dissertation, University of Stellenbosch. Stellenbosch. Vorgeschichte, Naturwiss. Ver. Mof;deburg 7. 129-164.

Boycott. R. C. & Bourquin. 0. ( 1988). The South African Tortoise Poynton. J. C. ( 1964). The Amphibia of southern Africa: a faunal Book. Johannesburg: Southern Book Publishers (Pty.) Ltd. study. A1111. Natal Mus. 17, 1-344.

Branch. W. R. ( 1988). Fidd guide to the snakes a11d other reptifrs Poynton. J. C. ( 1989). Evolutionary activity in the southern part of of Southern A.fiirn. Cape Town: Struik Publishers. Africa: Evidence from the Amphibia. Proc. of the 1987 H. A.A. S1e/le11bosch Conference, J. Herpetol. Assoc. A.fr. 36. 2-6. Crumly, C. R. ( 1984). A hypothesis for the relationships of land tortoise genera (Family Testudinidae). Studio Geologica Poynton. J. C. & Broadley, D. G. (I 978). The herpetofauna. In Sa/manticensia especial I (Studio Palaeoche/011iologica /). In Biogeography and ecology of southern Africa. 927-948. Comunicacio11n de/ I Simposiw11 Internacional Sohre Werger, M. J. A. (ed.). The Hague: Junk. Que/011ios Fosi/es. Paris, Octuhre 1983. 1 15-124. De Broin. F. Pritchard. P. C. H. (I979). Encvclopedio of Turtles. The British & E. Jimenez-Fuentes (eds). Crown Colony of Hong Kong: T.F.H. Publications. Deacon. H. G., Hendey. Q. B. & Lambrechts. J. J. N. ( 1983). Siebenrock. F. ( 1904). Die sUdafrikanischen Testudo-Arten der Fynbos palaeoecology: A preliminary synthesis. South Geomerrirn-Gruppe. Si1�11ngsh. Akod. Wiss. Wien 113. 307- African National Scientijlc Programmes Report No. CSIR. 75. 323. Pretoria. Sohnge. A. P. G. & Htilbich, I. W. (I983 ). Geodynamics of the Duerden. J. E. (I907 ). Variations in the Geometrica-group of South Cape Fold Belt. Ceo/. Soc. S. A.fr. , Spee. Pub/. No. 12. African tortoises. Report of the S.A. Assoc. f(> r the Adl'Gncemenr of Science. pp. I 78-208. Tankard. A. J. ( 1976). Cenozoic sea-level changes: A discussion. Ann. S. Afr. Mus. 71. I- I 7. Gaffney. E. S. & Mey Ian, P. A. (I988 ). A phylogeny of turtles. In Th e ph rlogeny and classiflc<11io11 of the tetrapods. Volume I: Visser, H. N., De Villiers. J. E., Theron. J. N. & Hill. R. S. ( 1980). Amphibians, reptiles. birds. 157-219. Benton. M. J. (ed.). Die geologie van die gebied tussen Ceres en Moorreesburg. Oxford: The Systematics Association. Department <>f Mineral Affa irs. Geological Sun·er. Open fi le Report No. 198 1 -0024. Greig. J. C. ( 1984). Conservation status of South African land tortoises. with special reference to the geometric tortoise Wiley. E. 0. (I98 1 ). Pln-/oge11etics: The theorr mu/ practice of (P.1·<1111moho1e.1· geomerricus). Amphihia-Reptilia 5. 27-30. pln·/ogenetic systematics. New York: John Wiley & Sons.