DOCSLIB.ORG

Intelligence at Tet John Prados Tacoma Park, Maryland

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Intelligence at Tet John Prados Tacoma Park, Maryland The Warning That Left Something to Chance: Intelligence at Tet John Prados Tacoma Park, Maryland Two meanings of the word "chance" are relevant to the present pur- pose. One is chance as a random factor-for this subject the accidental conjunction of chance occurrences that could have furnished warning of a large-scale nationwide North Vietnamese and Vietcong (VC) of- fensive in Vietnam at Tet in 1968. The second relevant meaning is chance as risk. I believe the reasons for the continuing controversy over whether there was a "surprise" at Tet have much to do with these forms of chance. "Surprise" is a loaded word in the intelligence business, and is but slightly less pejorative when applied as historical interpretation. Thus whether the attack at Tet represented a surprise-and intelligence fail- ure-has ever after remained a fervid question, often lurking in the wings of Vietnam discussions, provoking numerous arguments, even forming part of a court case, when the Tet intelligence question be- came enmeshed in the larger dispute over whether falsification oc- curred in compilation of the North Vietnamese Army (NVA) and VC order of battle. The extremes of the Tet intelligence controversy are represented by senior Army officers themselves; there is no need for looking under rugs for perverse so-called revisionist historians purportedly trying to overturn some conventional wisdom. At one extreme is General David R. Palmer, who in a text used at West Point held that Tet had been an intelligence failure comparable to Pearl Harbor.' At the oppo- site end of the spectrum are the officers who held command and intel- ligence posts in Vietnam in January 1968, arguing that Military Assistance Command Vietnam (MACV) knew all about the Tet offen- sive. For the moment we can take as representative of this view a state- ment before a congressional investigating committee on 3 December 1975 by General Daniel O. Graham, who at Tet had been a colonel assigned to MACV intelligence. "We were not surprised by the fact of the Tet Offensive," Graham told the legislators. "We were not sur- The Journal of American-East Asian Relations, Vol. 2, No. 2 (Summer 1993) © 1993 by Imprint Publications, Inc. All rights reserved. 1. Dave Richard Palmer, Summons of the Trumpet: A History of the Vietnam War from a Military Man's Viewpoint (New York, 1984), 228. prised by the massiveness of the numbers of troops committed. What surprised us was the rashness of the Tet attacks."2 One view or the other, as these labels are applied in history, will ultimately lose the battle of interpretation and be called revisionist. Whoever the revisionists turn out to be, however, they will be senior officers of the United States Army who held responsible positions in the military hierarchy. It is time to move forward on interpretation of this history, and a good place to begin is to look at where the idea for an offensive came from and what the United States found out about it. What Did We Know and When Did We Know It? The record and the pattern of military operations across South Viet- nam indicates that Hanoi and the Vietcong began planning for the Tet Offensive sometime in the summer or early fall of 1967. General Will- iam C. Westmoreland, commander of MACV, dates the moment from the time in July that a B-52 bombing mission near the Cambodian bor- der caught a top NVA headquarters and gravely wounded General Nguyen Chi Thanh, senior NVA field commander in the south. Westmoreland's intelligence, or J-2, chief, Brigadier General Phillip B. Davidson, repeats this assessment and relates the strategy to a power struggle he alleges among the top North Vietnamese leadership.3 In truth a great deal remains to be learned about the Vietnamese side of the war, and there is no way to assert with confidence that this was Hanoi's path to a decision. General Thanh's loss certainly was a grievous one, but coincidental in terms of Hanoi's timing of its offen- sive, which depended much more on immutable factors such as the time necessary to assemble the required troops and supplies and move them down the Ho Chi Minh Trail, or infiltrate them by sea into Cam- bodia. The necessary preparation time was considerable. Just to move replacements or troop units to the northernmost portion of South Viet- nam, the Khe Sanh area, required thirty days or more. Sending troops further south took longer. At some point these movements became detectable "observables" in the intelligence jargon. In turn it was pos- sible for the observables to lead to an estimate of Hanoi's intentions. Another avenue making possible some prediction of an offensive was combat intelligence, the day-to-day process of taking and interro- 2. U.S. Congress, House Select Committee on Intelligence, 94th Cong., 1st sess. Hear- ings: U.S. Intelligence Agencies and Activities: The Performance of the Intelligence Community (Washington, D.C., 1975), pt. 5:1653. 3. Phillip B. Davidson, Vietnam At War: The History 1946-1975. (Novato, Calif., 1988), 418-22, 434, 439-50. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Civilian Conservation Corps and the National Park Service, 1933-1942: an Administrative History. INSTITUTION National Park Service (Dept
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 266 012 SE 046 389 AUTHOR Paige, John C. TITLE The Civilian Conservation Corps and the National Park Service, 1933-1942: An Administrative History. INSTITUTION National Park Service (Dept. of Interior), Washington, D.C. REPORT NO NPS-D-189 PUB DATE 85 NOTE 293p.; Photographs may not reproduce well. PUB TYPE Reports - Descriptive (141) -- Historical Materials (060) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC12 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS *Conservation (Environment); Employment Programs; *Environmental Education; *Federal Programs; Forestry; Natural Resources; Parks; *Physical Environment; *Resident Camp Programs; Soil Conservation IDENTIFIERS *Civilian Conservation Corps; Environmental Management; *National Park Service ABSTRACT The Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) has been credited as one of Franklin D. Roosevelt's most successful effortsto conserve both the natural and human resources of the nation. This publication provides a review of the program and its impacton resource conservation, environmental management, and education. Chapters give accounts of: (1) the history of the CCC (tracing its origins, establishment, and termination); (2) the National Park Service role (explaining national and state parkprograms and co-operative planning elements); (3) National Park Servicecamps (describing programs and personnel training and education); (4) contributions of the CCC (identifying the major benefits ofthe program in the areas of resource conservation, park and recreational development, and natural and archaeological history finds); and (5) overall
    [Show full text]
  • NPRC) VIP List, 2009
    Description of document: National Archives National Personnel Records Center (NPRC) VIP list, 2009 Requested date: December 2007 Released date: March 2008 Posted date: 04-January-2010 Source of document: National Personnel Records Center Military Personnel Records 9700 Page Avenue St. Louis, MO 63132-5100 Note: NPRC staff has compiled a list of prominent persons whose military records files they hold. They call this their VIP Listing. You can ask for a copy of any of these files simply by submitting a Freedom of Information Act request to the address above. The governmentattic.org web site (“the site”) is noncommercial and free to the public. The site and materials made available on the site, such as this file, are for reference only. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals have made every effort to make this information as complete and as accurate as possible, however, there may be mistakes and omissions, both typographical and in content. The governmentattic.org web site and its principals shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damage caused, or alleged to have been caused, directly or indirectly, by the information provided on the governmentattic.org web site or in this file. The public records published on the site were obtained from government agencies using proper legal channels. Each document is identified as to the source. Any concerns about the contents of the site should be directed to the agency originating the document in question. GovernmentAttic.org is not responsible for the contents of documents published on the website.
    [Show full text]
  • Smallpox-At-The-Siege-Of-Boston.Pdf
    42 Historical Journal of Massachusetts • Winter 2017 of the newly formed Continental Army. He found many problems awaiting him, including smallpox. Print by Currier and Ives, 1876. and Ives, Currier by Print awaiting him, including smallpox. found many problems He of the newly formed Continental Army. to take command to Cambridge, Massachusetts, traveled Washington After his appointment as Commander-in-Chief in Philadelphia, Washington Greets the Troops the Greets Washington 43 Smallpox at the Siege of Boston: “Vigilance against this most dangerous Enemy” ANN M. BECKER Abstract: In 1775 smallpox created severe problems for the newly created Continental Army assembled outside Boston and significantly affected General George Washington’s military strategy during the Siege of Boston. The existence of this deadly disease in epidemic proportions precluded an American attack. This factor, along with suspected biological warfare by the British, forced Washington to maintain a nine-month siege. Washington took extreme care to protect his army from smallpox as evidenced by his cautious moves, designed to limit the exposure of his troops to the disease. These efforts highlight his concern over its destructive effect on his troops. Washington’s policies of containment and inoculation developed as a response to the impact that smallpox epidemics had on his ability to wage war. Much of his early military strategizing and administrative effort was put toward solving the problems smallpox caused for his troops and ensuring a healthy, reliable military force capable of fighting effectively. The author concludes that Washington’s vigilance in segregating those infected Historical Journal of Massachusetts, Vol. 45 (1), Winter 2017 © Institute for Massachusetts Studies, Westfield State University 44 Historical Journal of Massachusetts • Winter 2017 with the disease and his use of selective inoculation were critical factors in preventing a disastrous epidemic among the troops and militia outside Boston during the siege.
    [Show full text]
  • Informed Dissent
    Informed Dissent Three Generals and the Viet Nam War Essays by Robert Buzzanco and Asad Ismi I V ie t n a m G e n e r a t io n Burning Cities Press Informed DLjetib Three Generals & the Viet Nam War V ietnam Generation, I n c & Burning Cities Press Vietnam Generation Vietnam Generation, Inc. was founded in 1988 to promote and encourage interdisciplinary study of the Vietnam War era and the Vietnam War generation. The journal is published by Vietnam Generation, Inc., a nonprofit corporation devoted to promoting scholarship on recent history and contemporary issues. Vietnam Generation, Inc. Vice-President President Secretary, Treasurer HERMAN BEAVERS KALI TAL CYNTHIA FUCHS General Editor Newsletter Editor Technical Assistance K A LI TAL DAN DUFFY LAWRENCE E HUNTER Advisory Board WILLIAM KING NANCY ANISFIELD University of Colorado WILLIAM J. SEARLE St. Michael’s College MICHAEL KLEIN Eastern Illinois University JOHNBAKY University of Ulster JAMES C. SCOTT LaSalle University GABRIEL KOLKO Yale University KiSVJLN BOWEN York University ROBERT SLABEY William Joiner Center JACQUELINE LAWSON University of Notre Dame University of Massachusetts University of Michigan/Dcarbom BARBARA TISCHLER JEAN BETHKE ELSHTATN DAVID MARR Columbia University Vanderbilt University Australian National University NANCY WEIGERSMA RICHARD FALK JOHN CLARK PRATT Fitchburg State College Cornell University Colorado State University CHRISTINE PELZER WHITE DAVID HUNT JOCK REYNOLDS University of Hawaii William Joiner Center Washington Project for the Arts DAVID WILLSON University of Massachusetts TOM RIDDELL Green River CC PHILIP JASON Smith College MARILYN B. YOUNG US Naval Academy RUTH ROSEN New York University UC Davis All correspondence, including manuscript submissions, should be sent to Kali Tal, Editor, Vietnam Generation, 2921 Terrace Dr., Chevy Chase, MD 20815; (301) 608- 0622; FAX: (301) 608-0761.
    [Show full text]
  • CIA and the Vietnam Policymakers : Three Episodes 1962-1968
    and the — Vietnam Policymakers; Tliree Episodes 1962-1968 by Harold P, Ford History Staff Center for the Study ©f Intelligence Central intelligence Agency 1998 To Jo and John Foreword This volume is part of the Center for the Study of IntelUgence's continuing effort to provide as clear a record of CIA activities as possi- ble within the constraints of overall national security concerns. We believe it is important for the American public to be aware of and to imderstand the Agency's crucial mission. The CIA is committed to a degree of openness that not only documents its activities but also informs the US public of the historical successes and shortcomings of the Intelligence Community. This recently declassified study by former CIA officer Dr. Harold R Ford reviews the Intelligence Community's analytic performance dur- ing the chaotic \^etnam era, with particular focus on the efforts of CIA analysts. It offers a candid view of the CIA's intelligence assessments concerning Vietnam during three episodes between 1962 and 1968 and the reactions of senior US policymakers to those assessments. Without ignoring or downplaying the analysts' problems and errors. Dr. Ford argues persuasively that, for the most part, the Agency's analysis proved remarkably accurate. His study shows that CIA analysts had a firm grasp of the situation in Vietnam and continually expressed doubts that height- ened US military pressure alone could win the war. Contrary to the opin- ions voiced by then Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara and others. Dr. Ford strikingly illustrates the substantial expertise CIA officers brought to the Vietnam question.
    [Show full text]
  • Different Lives” Conference Apply Now for the Caro Provides International Fellowship
    Subscribe to our email list Share this: November 2018 | Volume 13 | Number 9 “Different Lives” Conference Apply Now for the Caro Provides International Fellowship Perspectives on Biography BIO is accepting applications for the Robert and Ina Caro By John A. Farrell Research/Travel Fellowship. BIO members with a work in progress Did liberal scholarship, can apply to receive funding for degrading the principle of research trips to archives or to truth with postmodern theory, important settings in their pave the way for Donald subject’s lives. The fellowship is Trump’s duplicity? restricted to supporting works of Biographer Nigel biography and not works of Hamilton, a former BIO history, autobiography, or president, proposed as much memoir. in a biting address that The application deadline is launched “Different Lives,” a three-day conference on biography at the University February 1, 2019. In the spring of Groningen in The Netherlands, in late September. of 2019, BIO will award either “The White House was won . by a real estate developer committed to a one $5,000 or two $2,500 platform of misogyny, hatred of immigrants, opposition to federal government, fellowships, based on the and greed-obsessed fantasy as preferable to reality,” said Hamilton. “Americans . judgment of the panel of three . are now living with the worrying outcome of that election—especially its judges: Deirdre David, Caroline implications for the concept of truth.” Fraser, and Marc Leepson. To Trump’s “Orwellian suppression of truthfulness” has roots in postwar apply, click here. postmodern and deconstructionist theories, Hamilton contended. Laudably, he said, The Caro Fellowship, first biographers have resisted the call.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reshaping of the US Armed Forces: Present and Future Implications for Northeast Asia
    262 THE KOREAN JOURNAL OF DEFENSE ANALYSIS The Reshaping of the US Armed Forces: Present and Future Implications for Northeast Asia Brian R. Sullivan Over the past decade, the size of the US armed forces and of the US defense budget has declined significantly. While these reductions seem to indicate a loss of US military power, the opposite is true. Great improvement in the US strategic position after the Cold War and the new technology now available to the American military actually has resulted in increased US strength. This favorable situation is likely to endure for a generation. One reason for the difference between military appearance and reality is that new American weapons platforms will have smaller crews but far greater capabilities. This trend will continue as developing systems are incorporated into the operating forces. Furthermore, the US military may be poised on the brink of a “revolution in military affairs” (RMA). Centered on information and information-based warfare, this development could allow American forces to anticipate enemy operations, while blinding hostile forces to US maneuvers. The US possesses the necessary educated manpower in sufficient quantities to operate such weap- ons and equipment. Despite likely new cuts in the size and funding of the US military, the $4 trillion the US will spend on defense over the next two decades will provide it with extremely strong forces. US forces will be concentrated heavily in Northeast Asia, a region of increasing importance to the US. Even with the rise of several Asian states as major economic powers, the US is certain to maintain armed forces materially far superior to theirs for twenty years, perhaps longer.
    [Show full text]
  • Eating Soup with a Spoon: the US Army As A
    Chapman University Chapman University Digital Commons History Faculty Articles and Research History 1-2013 Eating Soup with a Spoon: The .SU . Army as a "Learning Organization" in the Vietnam War Gregory A. Daddis Chapman University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/history_articles Part of the Asian History Commons, Cultural History Commons, Military History Commons, Other History Commons, Political History Commons, Public History Commons, Social History Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Daddis, Gregory A. “Eating Soup with a Spoon: The .SU . Army as a ‘Learning Organization’ in the Vietnam War,” Journal of Military History 77, no. 1 (January 2013): 229-254. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the History at Chapman University Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in History Faculty Articles and Research by an authorized administrator of Chapman University Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Eating Soup with a Spoon: The .SU . Army as a "Learning Organization" in the Vietnam War Comments This article was originally published in Journal of Military History, volume 77, issue 1, in 2013. Copyright Society for Military History This article is available at Chapman University Digital Commons: https://digitalcommons.chapman.edu/history_articles/59 Abstract Standard Vietnam War narratives often argue that the U.S. lost the war because it failed to learn and adapt to the conditions of an un­ conventional conflict. Based on a reappraisal of learning processes rather than on the outcome of the war, this essay argues that as an organization, the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • USMA Leadership Superintendents
    USMA Leadership Superintendents 1 MAJ Jonathan Williams 13 MAJ Richard Delafield Corps of Engineers Class of 1818; Corps of Engineers 15 Apr 1802–20 Jun 1803 28 Jan 1861–1 Mar 1861 2 LTC Jonathan Williams 14 MAJ Alexander H. Bowman Corps of Engineers 1 Class of 1825; Corps of Engineers 19 Apr 1805–31 Jul 1812 1 Mar 1861–8 Jul 1864 3 COL Joseph G. Swift 15 MAJ Zealous B. Tower Class of 1802; Corps of Engineers Class of 1841; Corps of Engineers 31 Jul 1812–24 Mar 1814 8 Jul 1864–8 Sep 1864 4 CPT Alden Partridge 16 LTC George W. Cullum Class of 1806; Corps of Engineers 2 Class of 1833; Corps of Engineers 3 Jan 1815–28 Jul 1817 8 Sep 1864–28 Aug 1866 5 CPT Sylvanus Thayer 17 COL Thomas G. Pitcher Class of 1808; Corps of Engineers Class of 1845; 44th Infantry 28 Jul 1817–1 Jul 1833 28 Aug 1866–1 Sep 1871 6 MAJ Rene E. DeRussy 18 COL Thomas H. Ruger Class of 1812 Corps of Engineers Class of 1854; 18th Infantry 1 Jul 1833–1 Sep 1838 1 Sep 1871–1 Sep 1876 7 MAJ Richard Delafield 19 MG John M. Schofield Class of 1818 Corps of Engineers Class of 1853 1 Sep 1838–15 Aug 1845 1 Sep 1876–21 Jan 1881 8 CPT Henry Brewerton 20 BG Oliver O. Howard Class of 1819; Corps of Engineers Class of 1854 15 Aug 1845–1 Sep 1852 21 Jan 1881–1 Sep 1882 9 CPT Robert E.
    [Show full text]
  • Spartans in Darkness -- Additional Pages Released on Appeal
    Case No. 52331/Appeal No. 3300 You may consider this final Agency decision to be a denial of your appeal. You are hereby advised that under the MDR process, you may appeal a final agency decision in writing, within 60 days from the date ofthis letter, to the Interagency Security Classification Appeals Panel (ISCAP) at the following address: Executive Secretary Interagency Security Classification Appeals Panel ATTN: Classification Challenge Appeals c/o Information Security Oversight Office National Archives and Records Administration 7th and Pennsylvania Avenue, NW, Room 500 Washington, DC 20408 Additional information regarding the ISCAP's appeal process can be found at: http://W\vw.archives.gov by typing "ISCAP" in the search field. Please be advised that we are still waiting on a releasability determination from one OGA regarding their information. We will respond separately when the consultation with that other agency has been completed. Spartans in Darkness: American SIGINT and the Indochina War, 1945-1975 is a product of the National Security Agency history program. As set forth in the attached disclaimer, the contents and conclusions of this publication are those of the author, based on original research, and do not necessarily represent the official views ofthe National Security Agency. "..--'~'---"' .. " . tJ5ft ' JOHN C. INGLIS Mandatory Declassification Review sW Appeals Authority 2 Encls: als This publication is a product of the National Security Agency history program. Its contents and conclusions are those ofthe author, based on original research, and do not necessarily represent the official views of the National Security Agency. Please address divergent opinion or additional detail to the Center for Cryptologic History (EC).
    [Show full text]
  • Information to Users
    INFORMATION TO USERS This manuscript has been reproduced from the microfilm master. UMI films the text directly from the original or copy submitted. Thus, some thesis and dissertation copies are in typewriter face, while others may be from any type of computer printer. The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. Broken or indistinct print, colored or poor quality illustrations and photographs, print bleedthrough, substandard margins, and improper alignment can adversely affect reproduction. In the unlikely event that the author did not send UMI a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if unauthorized copyright material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Oversize materials (e.g., maps, drawings, charts) are reproduced by sectioning the original, beginning at the upper left-hand comer and continuing from left to right in equal sections with small overlaps. Each original is also photographed in one exposure and is included in reduced form at the back of the book. Photographs included in the original manuscript have been reproduced xerographically in this copy. Higher quality 6” x 9” black and white photographic prints are available for any photographs or illustrations appearing in this copy for an additional charge. Contact UMI directly to order. UMI A Bell & Howell Information Company 300 North Zed) Road, Ann Arbor MI 48106-1346 USA 313A761-4700 800/521-0600 UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA GRADUATE COLLEGE STRONGER THAN CUSTOM; WEST POINT AND THE ADMISSION OF WOMEN. 1972-1980 A Dissertation SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE FACULTY in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By ROBERT LANCE JANDA Norman, Oklahoma 1998 tJMI N um ber: 9839796 Copyright 1998 by Janda, Robert Lance All rights reserved.
    [Show full text]
  • The US Air Force and Humanitarian Airlift Operations
    cover1&4.qxd 5/12/2008 10:04 AM Page 1 Wings of Hope The U.S. Air Force and Humanitarian Airlift Operations Daniel L Haulman Wings of Hope The U.S. Air Force and Humanitarian Airlift Operations Daniel L. Haulman Air Force History and Museums Program Originally published, 1997 Updated and Revised Edition 2007 i Cover Photograph: German citizens observe airlift operations in Berlin. ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page The Beginnings of Humanitarian Airlift .......................1 Post-World War II through the Korean War, 1945-1953 . .3 From the Korean War to the Vietnam War, 1953-1965 . .7 The Vietnam War Era, 1965-1973 . .10 From the Vietnam War through the Gulf War, 1973-1991 . .12 The Early Nineties, 1991-1994 ...............................14 The End of the Twentieth Century, 1994-2000 . .17 Into the Twenty-First Century, 2001-2007 . .22 Wings of Hope ............................................25 Appendix ................................................28 Notes ..................................................76 iii C–47s unloading on the ramp at Templehof Airport. iv WINGS OF HOPE The U.S. Air Force and Humanitarian Airlift Operations The victims of recent wars and atrocities in Somalia, Bosnia-Herze- govina, and northern Iraq have captured the world’s attention. The United States has responded to their cries for help by carrying out humanitarian relief operations to these and other areas devastated by natural or man- made disasters. The compassionate codenames chosen by U.S. policy- makers for these operations—Provide Comfort, Provide Hope, Provide Promise, Provide Relief, and Restore Hope—signify the nation’s determi- nation to alleviate the suffering of those less fortunate than itself. On the heels of its spectacular and decisive role in the Gulf War, the United States Air Force has demonstrated its immense capability to airlift tons of sup- plies and personnel in a wide variety of highly significant relief efforts.
    [Show full text]