Nucleolar Organiser Regions: New Prognostic Variable in Breast Carcinomas
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
390 J Clin Pathol 1990;43:390-392 Nucleolar organiser regions: new prognostic variable in breast carcinomas E Sivridis, B Sims Abstract specimens were selected at random from the Nucleolar organiser regions (NORs), files of the Department of Histopathology, which are important for regulating General Hospital, Alexandroupolis. All protein synthesis, were identified in 20 specimens had been fixed in 10% formol-saline breast carcinomas by means of a silver and processed routinely through absolute alco- (Ag) staining technique. Infiltrating neo- hol and xylene before embedding to paraffin plasms with metastases in four or more wax (Paraplast). There were 14 infiltrating axillary lymph nodes possessed, on ductal carcinomas (of scirrhous, medullary, average, a greater number of AgNORs and mucinous variants), two infiltrating per cell nucleus compared with neo- lobular carcinomas, and four pure intraductol plasms without nodal disease, or with one cartinomas. to three positive lymph nodes. The size, The breast tumours were divided into two morphology, and distribution ofAgNORs groups depending on the number of positive within the nucleus were also different in lymph nodes at the time of surgery. The first the two study groups. Overall, these find- group comprised carcinomas in situ and infil- ings suggest that breast carcinomas with trating carcinomas without nodal disease or multiple, irregular, and widely dispersed with metastases in up to three axillary lymph AgNORs tend to be of high grade malig- nodes (eight cases). The second group consis- nancy. ted of infiltrating breast neoplasms with meta- stases in four or more lymph nodes (12 cases). In every case at least 10 axillary nodes were Nucleolar organiser regions (NORs) are loops examined histologically. of DNA that are responsible for ribosomal The modified AgNOR technique, as des- RNA (rRNA) transcription.' They are located cribed by Ploton et al,6 was applied to paraffin in the nucleoli of cells and in the chromosomes wax sections of 3 ,im. AgNOR counts were 13-15 and 21, 22 in association with proteins.2' performed blind and independently by two As rRNA molecules are the main sites of observers, using a standard procedure'8: in this, protein synthesis it follows that the number of clusters of black dots within nucleoli are NORs in each cell nucleus reflects cellular counted as one AgNOR; black dots dispersed activity." throughout the nucleus are counted as discrete Nucleolar organiser regions can be readily AgNORs. The mean numbers of AgNORs per identified in paraffin wax sections by means of cell nucleus (AgNOR clusters, dispersed a silver (Ag) staining technique (AgNOR)6: AgNORs, and totals) was determined for each they are visualised in the nuclei of cells as case after counting 100 nuclei directly on to brown/black dots by virtue of the argyrophilia tissue sections at x 400 magnification. Cells of NOR-associated proteins.7 These were were examined at random. thought to include proteins B238 and C23,9 AgNOR counting was repeated subse- subunits of RNA polymerase 1 ,10 and probably quently, along the same lines, using projected other phosphoproteins. The function of these transparencies; microphotographs had been molecules is still far from clear; they may partly taken randomly at magnifications of x 200 and reflect ploidy," though an increase in ploidy x 500. Interobserver and intraobserver error does not necessarily lead to an increase in were calculated. AgNORs in human tumours.'2'14 The significance of results (mean numbers of For years the AgNOR technique has been AgNOR clusters plus dispersed AgNORs) was used by cytogeneticists for the investigation of assessed by the Wilcoxon rank sum test. Department of certain genetic disorders, notably that of Histopathology, General Hospital, chromosome 21 .' The recent modification of 68100 the original method,6 however, became Results Alexandroupolis, increasingly applied in histopathology research AgNORs were clearly visible on light micro- Greece as black silver E Sivridis following suggestions that there may be a scopical examination binding association between dots within nuclei stained orange. There were, Department of possible high AgNOR Histopathology, counts and malignant transformation.461617 In however, well defined differences between the General Hospital, this study we investigated the usefulness of the two study groups of breast carcinomas. Thus Birmingham technique in assessing the aggressive- malignant neoplasms without nodal disease or B Sims AgNOR ness in breast carcinomas. with metastases in less than four lymph nodes Correspondence to: on two to three Dr E Sivridis contained, average, AgNORs SD Accepted for publication Methods per cell nucleus (mean 2-81; median 2-65; 12 January 1990 Tumour tissue blocks from 20 mastectomy 0-61; 95%O CI 1-59-403): these were uniform, AgNORs in breast carcinomas 391 Patterns of AgNOR staining in breast carcinomas 112 Mean AgNOR count ulo Lymph node state No of cases AgNOR clusters Dispersed AgNORs Totals - nL 10-~~~~ Negative nodes or one to three positive nodes 8 1 97 0-84 2 81 8- z 0 Four or more positive nodes 12 2 24 6-33 8-57 '6- 0 round, and dense. By contrast, AgNORs in tial use in predicting behaviour in breast car- breast carcinomas with four or more positive cinomas. This would be very convenient for 2 £ nodes were usually, though not invariably, of in small Group A Group B assessing aggressiveness incisional (n481 (na12) bizarre morphology and more numerous: up to biopsy specimens, needle aspiration cytology, Scattergram showing mean three large, often irregular, dense structures or imprint cytology. The validity of such an total AgNOR numbersl and multiple smaller argyrophilic dots, less assumption, however, could only be verified by cell nucleusfor each distinct and widely dispersed within the a large series of patients participating in long specimen of breast carcinoma examined. nucleus (mean 8 57 AgNORs/nucleus; median term follow up studies.30 8 00; SD 2-63; 95O" CI 3-3-13-72). The In other tissues and disease states claims that results are expressed as a scattergram in the the AgNOR activity is ofprognostic value have figure; the difference between the two study not been warranted by the rather scanty and groups was significant (p < 0-001), although contradictory reports.'83' Equally, suggestions the numbers are too small to be able to detect that the method may be helpful in discrim- clinically important differences. The intra- and inating benign from malignant disease or in inter-observer error was between 4 1 and distinguishing between low and high grade 6 30o. The correlation between AgNOR malignancy have been found to be the case in counts by the two methods of enumeration was some studies, 4 5 16 32 33 but not in others.3 37 good: r = 0-8. The table shows the patterns of Further studies are clearly needed before the AgNOR staining and their mean values per clinical importance of the AgNOR staining tumour cell nucleus. AgNOR counts, though method can be fully appreciated. highly reproducible by both methods, were more easily accomplished in projected photo- We thank Mr P Smith, Chief MLSO, Depart- graphic transparencies. ment of Histopathology, East Birmingham Hospital, for his invaluable technical assistance in respect to the AgNOR silver staining tech- Discussion nique, and Mrs C Price for her secretarial The prognosis of primary breast carcinoma assistance. depends on several morphological and endo- crinological variables. These include: tumour 1 Fakan S, Hernandez-Verdun D. The nucleolus and the size; type of tumour; the degree of differentia- nucleolar organizer regions. Biol Cell 1986;56:189-206. 2 Ferguson-Smith MA, Handmaker SD. Observations on the tion into glandular or tubular structures; the satellited human chromosomes. Lancet 1961;i:638-40. presence, degree, and prevalence of nuclei 3 Lewin B. Gene expression. 2. In: Eucaryotic chromosomes. 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley, 1980:875-8. showing hyperchromatism, pleomorphism, 4 Crocker J, Nar P. Nucleolar organizer regions in lym- and mitotic activity; the degree of lymphocytic phomas. J Pathol 1987;151:111-8. 5 Smith R, Crocker J. Evaluation of nucleolar organizer response; the presence of local invasion and region-associated proteins in breast malignancy. Histo- lymph node metastases; and the tumour recep- pathology 1988;12:113-25. 6 Ploton D, Menager M, Jeanesson P, Himber G, Pigeon F, tor state.' 122 Although these various factors Adnet J-J. Improvement in the staining and in the are evaluated in combination, in practice the visualization of the argyrophilic proteins of the nucleolar organizer region at the optical level. Histochem J 1986; most important single factor in determining 18:5-14. prognosis seems to be the extent of disease 7 Hubbell HR, Rothblum LI, Hsu TC. Identification of a silver binding protein associated with the cytologicaf silver at the time of operation.2>25 Microscopic staining of actively transcribing nucleolar regions. Cell evidence of metastases in four or more axillary Biol Int Rep 1979;3:615-22. nodes is associated with a per- 8 Lischwe MA, Smetana K, Olson MOJ, Busch H. Proteins lymph higher C23 and B23 are the major nucleolar silver staining centage of treatment failure and a lower in- proteins. Life Sci 1979;25:701-8. 9 Ochs R, Lischwe M, O'Leary P, Busch H. Localization of cidence of five year survival, compared with nucleolar phosphoproteins B23 and C23 during mitosis. cases where nought to three lymph nodes are Exp Cell Res 1983;146:139-49. 10 Williams MA, Kleinschmidt JA, Krohne G, Franke WW. affected.923 2628 Argyrophilic nuclear and nucleolar proteins of Xenopus The morphological expression of this prog- laevis oocytes identified by gel electrophoresis. Exp Cell Res 1982;137:341-51. nostic determinant may well be the silver-bind- 11 Trent JM, Carlin DA, Davies JR. Expression of silver ing NOR-associated proteins of the cell stained nucleolar organizing regions (AgNORs) in human as cancer.