Clios Psyche 6-3 Dec 1999

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Clios Psyche 6-3 Dec 1999 Clio’s Psyche Understanding the "Why" of Culture, Current Events, History, and Society Volume 6, Number 3 December, 1999 Holocaust Consciousness, Novick’s Thesis, Comparative Genocide, and Victimization How Hollywood Hid the Holocaust Reflections on Through Obfuscation and Denial Competitive Victimhood Melvin Kalfus David R. Beisel Psychohistory Forum Research Associate SUNY-Rockland Community College In the decade following the Second World Review of Peter Novick, The Holocaust in American War and our initial confrontation with the Holo- Life. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1999. caust in all of its enormity, the motion picture in- ISBN 0395840090, 373 pp., $27. dustry continued to be dominated by “the Jews Peter Novick is a fine historian who has who invented Hollywood.” It was these Jews who written a fine, if flawed, study. In The Holocaust had created the myths that helped Americans cope in American Life he asks many of the right ques- with the enormous trauma of the Great Depression tions and offers some insightful answers. As I read (Continued on page 106) along, I found myself nodding in agreement at IN THIS ISSUE Life Is Beautiful Is Not a "Romantic Comedy"......... 114 Flora Hogman How Hollywood Hid the Holocaust: .............................89 “Vicitm Olympics”: The Collective Melvin Kalfus Psychology of Comparative Genocides................. 114 Ralph Seliger Reflections on Competitive Victimhood .................89 Review Essay by David R. Beisel Forgiveness and Transcendence............................ 116 Anie Kalayjian Response to David Beisel.....................................93 Peter Novick The Holocaust as Trope for "Managed" Social Change..................................... 119 The Memory of the Holocaust: Howard F. Stein A Psychological or Political Issue? .........................94 An Israeli Psychohistorian: Avner Falk ................ 122 Flora Hogman Paul H. Elovitz Holocaust Saturation in America.............................97 Deconstructing Hillary Clinton’s Stab at Psychohistory 126 Eva Fogelman H. John Rogers Response to Eva Fogelman.................................100 Male Violence towards Women ............................ 127 Book Review by Andrew Brink Peter Novick Knafo’s Schiele ..................................................... 128 From Denial to Remembrance...............................101 Book Review by Dan Dervin Ellen Mendel In Memoriam: Robert G. L. Waite ........................ 129 Personal Reflections on Coping & Trauma in Poland ... 103 Thomas Kohut and John M. Hyde In Memoriam: H. Stuart Hughes ........................... 131 Eating and Being in the Holocaust ........................105 Paul H. Elovitz Bulletin Board ....................................................... 132 Page 90 Clio’s Psyche December, 1999 many points while imagining the howls of outrage answer outside the boundaries of traditional social provoked by his several challenges to current or- and political categories. thodoxies. For example, Tony Judt -- an unusually Novick's chronological reconstruction balanced scholar and one of my favorite historians seems correct. No one talked or thought much -- found Novick's book to be "dense, carefully re- about the Holocaust in the 1940s and 1950s be- searched, and rather irritating" ("The Morbid cause, he says, Jews fought hard not to be identi- Truth," The New Republic, July 19 and 26, 1999). fied as victims; the immediate post-war years were The book stirred up my own thoughts on competi- an upbeat time; tales of horrific suffering were too tive victimhood. depressing to listen to, anyway; and West Germany Psychohistorians will find here some useful had become an ally in the Cold War (no repression observations. In an interesting chapter on Holo- here). Even the 1950s success of the book, stage caust consciousness in relation to the newly emerg- play, and film versions of The Diary of Anne Frank ing phenomenon of competitive victimhood (the made Anne into a universal, not Jewish, symbol. tendency among various non-Jewish groups to pro- Things changed, says Novick, with press coverage mote their own victimizations), he speaks of of the capture and trial of Adolf Eichman. In the "Holocaust envy." In a couple of places, he notes 1970s came viewings of the television mini-series, that the Holocaust has become a kind of "moral The Holocaust. These two events in particular and ideological Rorschach," "a screen on which were what brought the Holocaust forward into people [have] projected a variety of values and American consciousness. Moreover: "When a high anxieties." And he acknowledges that "in the spe- level of concern with the Holocaust became wide- cial case of Holocaust survivors, the succession of spread in American Jewry, it was, given the impor- trauma, repression, and return of the repressed of- tant role that Jews play in American media and ten seems plausible." That, however, is about it, opinion-making elites, not only natural, but virtu- psychologically. Novick soon becomes defended: ally inevitable that it would spread through the cul- "the available evidence," he says, "doesn't suggest ture at large." (We know what he means, but one that, overall, American Jews (let alone American may hear in these words disquieting echoes of anti- gentiles) were traumatized…."; he concludes that Semitic statements like "The Jews run Holly- historical explanations do not involve "conjuring wood.") up dubious" notions like a "social uncon- Novick finds this renewed emphasis on scious" (which he puts in quotes). Indeed, he casts Jewish consciousness the result of "survival anxi- doubt on the realities of repression itself while ety," fears that secularism, materialism, and out- seeming to allow for it. "(Even here … survivors group marriage in the late 20th century were erod- in the late 1940s frequently wanted to talk about ing Jewish identity. When Novick turns to other their Holocaust experience and were discouraged contributing factors, he broadens his analysis to from doing so.)" Passages like these suggest that include other recent social and intellectual trends, Novick has an inadequate understanding of trauma; mentioning the related growth of "the new ethnic- one guesses that he does not know, or accept, that ity" and "identity politics." Although he writes embedded in the repressed trauma is also the wish that the "roots of these many-sided phenomena to express it. And, like many writers on the Holo- were various and tangled -- too complex to be de- caust, he flees from any psychological explana- tailed here," he does offer some brief observations. tions. (See my "Resistance to Psychology in Holo- caust Scholarship," the Journal of Psychohistory, The threatened "loss of identity" in the U.S. -- Vol. 27, No. 2, Fall 1999, p. 124.) and not only among Jews -- produced a quest for "a new identity of experience[d] collective disadvan- Even though he is not a psychohistorian, tage." The new identity became a victim identity. Novick does ask important psychohistorical ques- Causes included new media images of blacks in the tions: Why here? Why now? Why has the Holo- post-civil rights era as "trapped in despair and caust, which "took place thousands of miles from hopelessness in the urban ghettos. A new focus on America's shores" and affected only "a small frac- spousal abuse and child abuse," the homeless who tion of one percent of the American population," flooded city streets, and "a strong emphasis in his- become a central part of late-20th-century Ameri- torical and literary works on the experience of los- can consciousness? This is a truly important issue, ers." yet one of the things which makes Novick's work so frustrating is that he is unable to provide any All of this helped the Holocaust move "to the center of American culture." In the 1970s it December, 1999 Clio’s Psyche Page 91 "came to seem an appropriate symbol of contem- On the whole, Novick's is a good effort at porary consciousness" because the assassinations traditional historical explanation. But when he of the 1960s, the hopes for a Great Society which gets, finally, to an emotion — to the passages "had all been dashed," and Vietnam and Watergate quoted above about abuses and "diminished expec- had raised doubts about America's idealism and tations" — that Americans became "depressed" what constituted the real bases of U.S. culture. In about, he has to leave it there, and moves quickly this environment, the Holocaust "became an aptly on to other issues. bleak emblem for an age of diminished expecta- Psychohistorians will want to know more. tions." But what Novick leaves out here is the cru- The emergence of a new widespread phenomenon cial role of Christian fundamentalists and the grow- which prizes the victim identity is a startling devel- ing apocalyptic expectations, studied by Strozier opment and is not "self-evident." To identify is to and others, that this is the End Time and that the describe and it is a description of a process, not a imminent Second Coming of Jesus is connected in cause of things; it cries out for deeper explanation. some way with the birth of the State of Israel. He misses the possibility that the consciousness of How to approach the emerging culture of many Christians turned to Jews and to recent Jew- competitive victimization psychohistorically? One ish history not merely because Christianity empha- way to mark the onset of a depression (I remember sizes "suffering and redemption." reading somewhere in the psychoanalytic litera- ture) is when an analysand
Recommended publications
  • Where Does It Come from & Why Does It Persist?
    ANTI- SEMITISM WHAT ARE ITS NEW FORMS? WHERE DOES IT COME FROM & WHY DOES IT PERSIST? WILL IT EVER GO AWAY? A SYMPOSIUM WITH AYAAN HIRSI ALI, DAVID BERGER, PHYLLIS CHESLER, JEREMY COHEN, IRWIN COTLER, MOHAMMED S. DAJANI DAOUDI, HASIA DINER, STUART EIZENSTAT, AVNER FALK, IRA FORMAN, MICHEL GURFINKIEL, DAVID KERTZER, BRIAN KLUG, DAVID MAMET, DAVID NIRENBERG, EMANUELE OTTOLENGHI, CYNTHIA OZICK, DINA PORAT, ALVIN ROSENFELD, ARI ROTH, SHLOMO SAND, MAXIM SHRAYER, CHARLES ASHER SMALL, ELI VALLEY, HANS-JOACHIM VOTH, XU XIN AND OTHERS ONLINE: MICHAEL BARKUN, BENT BLÜDNIKOW, ROBERT CHAZAN, LEONARD DINNERSTEIN, EVA FOGELMAN ZVI GITELMAN, MICHAEL GOLDFARB, JONATHAN JUDAKEN, SHMUEL TRIGANO, SERGIO WIDDER ART CREDIT 34 JULY/AUGUST 2013 INTERVIEWS BY: SARAH BREGER, DINA GOLD,GEORGE JOHNSON, CAITLIN YOSHIKO KANDIL, SALA LEVIN & JOSH TAPPER THE OLDEST HATRED IS BY SOME ACCOUNTS ALIVE AND WELL, BY OTHERS AN OVERUSED EPITHET. WE TALK WITH THINKERS FROM AROUND THE GLOBE FOR A CRITICAL AND SURPRISINGLY NUANCED EXAMINATION OF ANTI-SEMITISM'S ORIGINS AND STAYING POWER. DAVID BERGER Europe meant that Jews became the Christianity could not eliminate the evil OUTSIDERS & ENEMIES quintessential Other, and they conse- character of Jewish blood. quently became the primary focus of David Berger is editor of History and In the ancient Greco-Roman world, peo- hostility even in ways that transcended Hate: The Dimensions of Anti-Semi- ple evinced a wide variety of attitudes to- the theological. tism and Ruth and I. Lewis Gordon Pro- ward Jews. Some admired Jewish distinc- Once this focus on Jews as the Other fessor of Jewish History and dean of the tiveness, some were neutral, but others became entrenched, it continued into Bernard Revel Graduate School of Jewish were put off by the fact that unlike any modern Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Contents Humanities Notes
    Humanities Notes Humanities Seminar Notes - this draft dated 24 May 2021 - more recent drafts will be found online Contents 1 2007 11 1.1 October . 11 1.1.1 Thucydides (2007-10-01 12:29) ........................ 11 1.1.2 Aristotle’s Politics (2007-10-16 14:36) ..................... 11 1.2 November . 12 1.2.1 Polybius (2007-11-03 09:23) .......................... 12 1.2.2 Cicero and Natural Rights (2007-11-05 14:30) . 12 1.2.3 Pliny and Trajan (2007-11-20 16:30) ...................... 12 1.2.4 Variety is the Spice of Life! (2007-11-21 14:27) . 12 1.2.5 Marcus - or Not (2007-11-25 06:18) ...................... 13 1.2.6 Semitic? (2007-11-26 20:29) .......................... 13 1.2.7 The Empire’s Last Chance (2007-11-26 20:45) . 14 1.3 December . 15 1.3.1 The Effect of the Crusades on European Civilization (2007-12-04 12:21) 15 1.3.2 The Plague (2007-12-04 14:25) ......................... 15 2 2008 17 2.1 January . 17 2.1.1 The Greatest Goth (2008-01-06 19:39) .................... 17 2.1.2 Just Justinian (2008-01-06 19:59) ........................ 17 2.2 February . 18 2.2.1 How Faith Contributes to Society (2008-02-05 09:46) . 18 2.3 March . 18 2.3.1 Adam Smith - Then and Now (2008-03-03 20:04) . 18 2.3.2 William Blake and the Doors (2008-03-27 08:50) . 19 2.3.3 It Must Be True - I Saw It On The History Channel! (2008-03-27 09:33) .
    [Show full text]
  • The Pennsylvania State University
    The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School Department of Comparative Literature ARCHETYPES AND AVATARS: A CASE STUDY OF THE CULTURAL VARIABLES OF MODERN JUDAIC DISCOURSE THROUGH THE SELECTED LITERARY WORKS OF A. B. YEHOSHUA, CHAIM POTOK, AND CHOCHANA BOUKHOBZA A Dissertation in Comparative Literature by Nathan P. Devir © 2010 Nathan P. Devir Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy August 2010 The dissertation of Nathan P. Devir was reviewed and approved* by the following: Thomas O. Beebee Distinguished Professor of Comparative Literature and German Dissertation Advisor Co-Chair of Committee Daniel Walden Professor Emeritus of American Studies, English, and Comparative Literature Co-Chair of Committee Baruch Halpern Chaiken Family Chair in Jewish Studies; Professor of Ancient History, Classics and Ancient Mediterranean Studies, and Religious Studies Kathryn Hume Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of English Gila Safran Naveh Professor of Judaic Studies and Comparative Literature, University of Cincinnati Special Member Caroline D. Eckhardt Head, Department of Comparative Literature; Director, School of Languages and Literatures *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School. iii ABSTRACT A defining characteristic of secular Jewish literatures since the Haskalah, or the movement toward “Jewish Enlightenment” that began around the end of the eighteenth century, is the reliance upon the archetypal aspects of the Judaic tradition, together with a propensity for intertextual pastiche and dialogue with the sacred texts. Indeed, from the revival of the Hebrew language at the end of the nineteenth century and all throughout the defining events of the last one hundred years, the trend of the textually sacrosanct appearing as a persistent motif in Judaic cultural production has only increased.
    [Show full text]
  • Falk on Arab-Israeli Conflict
    11 Unconscious Aspects of the Arab-Israeli Conflict AVNER FALK Most experts agree that the Arab-Israeli conflict is the most intractable in the modern world (cf. Friedman 1989, Reich, 1991). Its violence and persistence have defied rational analysis. The Middle-East Peace Con- ference brokered by U.S. Secretary of State James Baker, which opened on October 30, 1991, in Madrid, Spain, and the Washington talks that followed, are not considered likely to produce a peace treaty any time soon. The irrational obstacles, resistances and fears on both sides are so great that the negotiations are expected to break down at any time. The Iranian Shiite leaders and Palestinian Arab extremists have held a War Conference calling for jihad against Israel. While rationalistic views of the conflict by political scientists focus on the conscious aspects of territorial claims and nationalisms, psycho- analytic views of the strife have raised the unconscious issues of group self, defensive group narcissism, historical hurts, narcissistic injury, denial, projection, splitting, externalization, and lack of empathy. Although all of these unconscious processes do play a vital role in the conflict, I believe that a still more powerful role is played by the inability to mourn historical losses on both sides. I review the psychohistorical and psychopolitical literature on the conflict and attempt to support my thesis with evidence from Jewish and Arab historiography. Despite its obvious conscious causes, the bloody Palestinian Arab intifada (uprising) raging in the Israeli-occupied territories and in Israel This chapter is based on lectures given by the author at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem's Truman Institute (1988) and Washington's Brookings Institution (1989).
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Final Edited Version
    STUMBLING BLOCKS TO STEPPING STONES THE TORAH AS A KEY TO JEWISH-CHRISTIAN RECONCILIATION: A NEW MODEL A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE UNIVERSITY OF DUBLIN FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR IN PHILOSOPHY 2019 BY JULIA ZAHRA WISDOM MCKINLEY IRISH SCHOOL OF ECUMENICS 01001221 DECLARATION I declare that this dissertation has not been submitted as an exercise for a degree at this or any other university, and that it is entirely my work. I agree that the Library may lend or copy this dissertation on request. Signed:_________________________ Date________________ (Julia Zahra Wisdom McKinley) DEDICATION For my Teachers. My grandmothers. Earl Williams. Nancy Rambin. D’vorah. David and Andrew Silcox. Rabbi Alan Ullman. And Grandpa John. All the flowers of all the tomorrows, are in the seeds of today. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I wish to acknowledge and express my thanks for the constant support and encouragement of the staff at the Irish School of Ecumenics. There is always a kind smile and a welcome cup of coffee. In particular, I wish to thank my supervisor Dr. Andrew Pierce for always having ‘just the right book’ to hand, and for taking on a difficult task. Also, my thanks to Prof. Geraldine Smyth for her warm encouragement in the early days, and for giving me the steps to begin. And Prof. Mike Cowan for wisdom and inspiration, and for ‘seeing’ potential in this project and thereby enabling it. I also wish to thank my family. For extreme patience and boundless support. Philip, for being my ezer k’negdo when I needed it most, and being so accommodating with the endless accumulation of books.
    [Show full text]
  • 614 Possible & 259 Probable
    873 Possible & Probable Official Acts (614 Possible & 259 Probable) [Possible Acts were found during our research for Official Acts, but have not been confirmed. Further research may confirm that these are Official Anti-Jewish Acts or that they aren’t. If they can’t be confirmed as Official Acts, in the future they will be removed from this work entirely. Probable Acts are seemingly complete except they are missing the full date (day or month/day). If and when their months and days are found, they will become Official Anti- Jewish Acts, and moved into the Official Acts category.] 1 400 BC [Probable] "Order" of Bagoas* [Present-day Iran, Iraq, Egypt; Achaemenid Empire]: "[…] as punishment for the fratricide** in this temple, Bagoas imposes a fine of twenty [Greek] Drachma for each lamb they (Jews) sacrifice in the[ir] temple." [Researcher’s note: *Bagoas was a Visier (Chief Minister) in the Achaemenid Empire. **According to the source, this order came after the death of the high-priest and his son Jonathan's succession. His other son, Joshua, however, wanted to hold the same position and tried to gather favor with the governors of Syria and Phoenicia. An altercation between the two brothers ensued in the temple and Joshua was killed.] Theologisch-Chronische Behandlung über das wahre Geburts- und Sterb-Jahr Jesu Christi von Johann Baptist Weigl. Zweiter, praktischer Theil. (Theological-chronological treatment of the real birth-year and year-of-death of Jesus Christ by Johann Baptist Weigl. Second part.); (Sulzbach; 1849); Researched and
    [Show full text]
  • Pdf [Accessed: 31/05/2016]
    VICTIMHOOD AS A DRIVING FORCE IN THE INTRACTABILITY OF THE ISRAELI-PALESTINIAN CONFLICT: Reflections on Collective Memory, Conflict Ethos, and Collective Emotional Orientations A Thesis by Emad S. Moussa January 2020 A Thesis Submitted in Fulfilment of the Requirements For the Award of the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Supervisors Prof. Barry Richards & Dr. Chindu Sreedharan Faculty of Media and Communications This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with its author and due acknowledgement must always be made of the use of any material contained in, or derived from, this thesis. 1 IN MEMORY OF MY GRANDPARENTS Moussa and Aisha AND, TO MY GRANDMOTHER Ghefra Ghannam From whom I learned about a vanished homeland 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT This work would not have been possible without the help and guidance of my supervisors, Prof. Barry Richards and Dr. Chindu Sreedharan. I have benefited immeasurably from their insight and rich academic experience. Nobody has been more important to me in the pursuit of this project than the members of my family. I would like to offer my profound appreciation to my loving wife, Amanda, for her support and extraordinary patience. Somewhat, I also feel obliged to thank my little one, Sanna, who despite her unquenchable curiosity and endless stream of questions, was grownup enough to understand that sometimes daddy needed some quiet time to work on his project. Of course, I would like to thank my parents, whose love and guidance are with me in whatever I pursue.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliography
    BIBLIOGRAPHY Aaron, Joseph. The CIA No Longer Trusts Jews -- and for Good Reason. Jewish Bulletin of Northern California. 2-25-2000, p. 21 Abadi, Jacob. Israel and Sudan: The Saga of an Enigmatic Relationship. Middle Eastern Studies, v35, n3, July 1999 Abel, Ernest. The Roots of Anti-Semitism. Abley, Mark. He Said He Loved Lucy ..., The Gazette [Montreal], April 12, 1999, p. A1 about.com. [online; The Whitwell Paperclip Project] [http://history1900s.about.com/homework/history1900s/library/holocaust/blclip.htm Abraham, Gary A. Max Weber and the Jewish Question: A Study of the Social Outlook of His Sociology. University of Illinois Press. Urbana and Chicago, 1992. Abraham, Henry. The Heirs of King Solomon. Jewish Exponent. 12-9-94, p. 144 Abrahams, Israel. Jewish Life in the Middle Ages. Meridian Books. The World Publishing Company, Cleveland and New York; The Jewish Publication Society of America, Philadelphia, 1961 Abrahamsen, David. The Mind of the Accused. A Psychiatrist in the Courtroom. Simon and Schuster, New York, 1983 Abrahamowitz, Yosef I. Symposium: Galut or America. Response, p. 18-19 Abramowitz, Rachel. Is That a Gun In Your Pocket? Women's Experience of Power in Hollywood. Random House, New York, 2000 Abrams, Gary. Warm Biography of Arafat Given Cold, Hot Reception. Los Angeles Times, June 19, 1989, p. 5, 1 Absolute Arts [absolutearts.com] Indepth Arts News: Gemma Levine: Portrait Photographer 25 Years, [Exhibition at London's National Portrait Gallery, 2001-1-22 until 2001-04-08] [http://www.absolutearts.com/artsnews/2001/01/22/27972.html] Abu-Jamal, Mumia. Edited by Noelle Hanrahan. Forward by Alice Walker.
    [Show full text]
  • Featured Scholars, Editors, and Authors Name Institution Interviewer Date
    Featured Scholars, Editors, and Authors Name Institution Interviewer Date C. Fred Alford U. Maryland PHE Mar. 2007 David Bakan York U. Todd Dufresne Sept. 1998 Herbert Barry U. Pittsburgh BL/PHE Sept. 2000 David Beisel SUNY-RCC BL June 1994 Rudolph Binion Brandeis U. BL Dec. 1994 Sue Erikson Bloland Manhattan Institute PHE June 2005 Andrew Brink U. Toronto PHE Sept. 1999 Jennifer Burns Stanford PHE Dec. 2012 Donald Carveth York U. PHE June 2006 Molly Castelloe Clio’s P. Online Forum BL Mar. 2012 Marilyn Charles Austen Riggs/Harvard PHE Nancy Chodorow UC-Berkeley PHE/BL Mar. 2005 Geoffrey Cocks Albion College PHE Sept. 2004 Mary Coleman Georgetown U. PHE Mar. 2001 Ralph Colp Columbia PHE Sept. 2002 Lloyd deMause~ Journal of Psychohistory BL June 1996 Abram de Swaan U. Amsterdam Vivian Rosenberg June 2001 John Demos Yale U. BL June 1995 Daniel Dervin Mary Washington U. PHE Sept. 2000 Alan Elms UC-Davis Kate Isaacson Dec. 2001 Paul H. Elovitz~ Ramapo College Pauline Staines June 1996 Paul H. Elovitz~ Clio’s Psyche Juhani Ihanus Dec. 2015 Avner Falk Hebrew U. PHE Dec. 1999 James David Fisher Psychoanalytic Practice PHE/Jacques Szaluta Dec. 2015 John Forrester~ Cambridge University PHE Sept. 2006 Lawrence Friedman Indiana U. PHE/BL Dec. 2003 Peter Gay Yale U. David Felix/PHE/BL Sept. 1997 Carol Gilligan NYU PHE Mar. 2004 Betty Glad U. South Carolina PHE/BL June 1999 James Glass U. Maryland Fred Alford June/Sept. 2007 Jay Y. Gonen Veterans Admin. PHE Mar. 2001 Fred Greenstein Princeton PHE June 2008 Carol Grosskurth U.
    [Show full text]
  • The Specialist and the Banality of Evil
    Greg Diglin 1 “An Essay on Responsibility and Obedience” The Specialist and The Banality of Evil The Specialist, a 1999 documentary film, written and directed by Israelis Rony Brauman1 and Eyal Sivan respectively, offers a unique perspective on a spectacle which exponentially increased the world’s comprehension of the Holocaust.2 In 1961, Adolf Eichmann, the Nazi bureaucrat who once headed the German government department which coordinated the transport of several million European Jews to their deaths during World War 2, faced trial by the State of Israel at Jerusalem.3 Eichmann was charged with 15 counts of crimes against the Jewish people, and his guilt was a foregone conclusion even before the hearings commenced.4 Nevertheless, Eichmann’s trial challenged the status quo in respect to numerous political and ontological issues, some of which I will elaborate upon in the course of this essay.5 The Specialist, released thirty- seven years after Eichmann’s execution in 1962, raised quandaries in respect 1Although Brauman’s role is undoubtedly important, it is apparent that he was subordinate to the director, his cousin, Eyal Sivan. For that reason, I will only offer a limited discussion of the part which Brauman played in the making of The Specialist. 2Hanna Yablonka. The State of Israel Vs. Adolf Eichmann. Trans. Ora Cummings and David Herman. New York: Schocken Books, 2004: 221. Benjamin Robinson. "'The Specialist' on the Eichmann Precedent: Morality, Law, and Military Sovereignty." Critical Inquiry 30 (2003): 65. 3Peter Papadatos. The Eichmann Trial. London: Stevens and Sons, 1964: 27. Simone Gigliotti. "Unspeakable Pasts as Limit Events: the Holocaust, Genocide, and The Stolen Generations." Australian Journal of Politics and History 49.2 (2003): 167.
    [Show full text]
  • Iran and the Bomb: a Psychoanalytic Study Avner Falk
    Iran and the Bomb: A Psychoanalytic Study Avner Falk Issue 11, Summer 2012 During the past decade, the entire world has been preoccupied with the Iranian government’s attempts to obtain nuclear bombs. Such weapons of mass destruction in the hands of a fanatical and tyrannical religious regime which considers the “Western” world, and above all Israel and the United States, the embodiment of evil, and that has repeatedly declared its intention of wiping Israel off the map, seem to pose the most serious threat to world peace, if not to the very existence of our species, that exists t oday (alongside those of North Korea, Al-Qaeda and other fanatical rogue states and terrorist organizations). Nor are these terrible fears unrealistic. The Iranian regime is clearly bent on obtaining nuclear weapons and becoming a world power. It makes no secret of its wish to destroy Israel and punish America. The Italian journalist Arturo Diaconale has published a book about a nuclear holocaust involving a war between Iran and Israel (Diaconale 2006). The Middle East, of which Iran is part (and which it wants to dominate), is considered the most unstable, dangerous and volatile part of the world today. Gilles Keppel, a French scholar of the Arab and Islamic world, saw the Middle East as a nexus of international disorder and attempted to interpret “the com plex language of war, propaganda, and terrorism that holds the region in its thrall” (Keppel 2004, 2005) . How do we understand the fact that one Muslim regime threatens the security of our world and the
    [Show full text]
  • Mourning in Jewish History
    14 The Problem of Mourning in Jewish History AVNER FALK The ethnic groups known as Hebrews, Israelites and Jews suffered heavy losses and group-narcissistic injuries throughout their history. They lost their Kingdom of Israel to the Assyrians in 722-721 B.C.E. They lost their Kingdom of Judah along with their sovereignty, their language, their Holy City of Jerusalem, and their Temple of Yahweh to the Babylonians in 587-586 B.C.E. They lost their Second Temple along with their Holy City to the Romans in 70 c.E. Half a million Jews were slaughtered by the Romans during the tragic Bar-Kochba revolt of 132-135 C.E. For eighteen centuries thereafter, with few notable exceptions, the Jews lived as a hated, despised, persecuted minority everywhere. For many centuries the Jews lived in a kind of ahistoric time bubble. They lived more in fantasy than in reality, more in the past than in the present. They developed the myth of Jewish Election, the myth of Jerusalem as the center of the world, and the myth of the ten lost tribes of Israel living in a faraway land beyond the raging river Sambation (symbolizing the rage of the Jews at their own fate). The psychological function of these myths was to deny the unbearable Jewish reality. For 1,500 years, from Flavius Josephus in the first century to Bonaiuto (Azariah) de' Rossi in the 16th, there was no scientific chronological Jewish historiography (Yerushalmi, 1982). On the other hand there was a vast body of fantastic, mystical, mythical, and Messianic Jewish literature.
    [Show full text]