Vol. 2, No. 2 (2010) Articles
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Goettingen Journal of GoJIL International Law Vol. 2, No. 2 (2010) Articles New Protectionism – How Binding are International Economic Legal Obligations During a Global Economic Crisis? Stephan Hobe & Jörn Griebel Reservations and the Effective Protection of Human Rights Johanna Fournier The Future of Peacekeeping in Africa and the Normative Role of the African Union Charles Majinge Humaneness, Humankind and Crimes Against Humanity Bernhard Kuschnik Secession in Theory and Practice: the Case of Kosovo and Beyond Ioana Cismas Current Developments in International Law The Russian Federation, Protocol No. 14 (and 14bis), and the Battle for the Soul of the ECHR Bill Bowring “Nothing but a Road Towards Secession”- The International Court of Justice’s Advisory Opinion on Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in Respect of Kosovo Mindia Vashakmadze & Matthias Lippold GoJIL Focus: ICC Review Conference Kampala June 2010 – A First Review of the ICC Review Conference Hans-Peter Kaul Uganda and the International Criminal Court Review Conference: Some Observations of the Conference’s Impact in the ‘Situation Country’ Uganda Sabine Klein Amendments to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Considered at the First Review Conference on the Court, Kampala, 31 May-11 June 2010 Roger S. Clark The Crime of Aggression After Kampala: Success or Burden for the Future? Robert Heinsch The International Criminal Court’s Exercise of Jurisdiction Over the Crime of Aggression – at Last … in Reach … Over Some Astrid Reisinger Coracini Complementarity After Kampala: Capacity Building and the ICC’s Legal Tools Morten Bergsmo, Olympia Bekou & Annika Jones Goettingen Journal of International Law (GoJIL) c/o Göttingen Institute for International and European Law Platz der Göttingen Sieben 5 37073 Göttingen Germany [email protected] www.gojil.eu ISSN 1868-1581 The Goettingen Journal of International Law is published Open Access and semi-annually by Göttingen Law School students. Submissions: The GoJIL encourages submissions addressing general international law and employing methodologies from neighbouring disciplines such as international relations, history, or economics. The Journal also welcomes contributions emanating from specialized branches of international law such as international criminal law, international humanitarian law, and international economic law, in particular if they address issues which are of general relevance. The length of contributions is not restricted. However, we recommend a maximum of 15,000 words. Contributors are requested to insert a short abstract to their submission. Contributions should be saved in MS Word (any version through 7.0) format. Authors should be prepared to supply any cited sources upon request. The full Author Style Sheet is available online at http://gojil.uni-goettingen.de/authorguidelines.pdf. The views expressed in all contributions to the GoJIL are those of the individual authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Board of Editors or the Göttingen Institute of International and European Law. Except where otherwise noted, all contributions are licensed under the Creative Commons Licence Attribution - No Derivative Works 3.0 Germany and protected by German Intellectual Property Law (UrhG). Advisory Board Prof. Dr. KAI AMBOS (Göttingen University), RAUSCHNING (Göttingen University), Prof. Prof. Dr. THOMAS BUERGENTHAL Dr. WALTER REESE-SCHÄFER (Göttingen (International Court of Justice), Prof. Dr. University), Prof. Dr. FRANK SCHORKOPF CHRISTIAN CALLIESS (FU Berlin), Prof. Dr. (Göttingen University) Prof. Dr. BRUNO GEORG NOLTE (HU Berlin/International Law SIMMA (International Court of Justice), Prof. Commission), Prof. Dr. ANDREAS L. PAULUS Dr. PETER-TOBIAS STOLL (Göttingen (Göttingen University), Prof. Dr. DIETRICH University). Scientific Advisory Board KATRIN AREND (University of Göttingen), Institute, Heidelberg), SVEN MIßLING HELMUT AUST (HU Berlin), CHEN GE (University of Göttingen), JÖRN MÜLLER (University of Göttingen), MATTHIAS (University of Göttingen), KILLIAN O’BRIEN GOLDMANN (Max Planck Institute, (Walther Schücking Institute, University of Heidelberg), CARSTEN HOPPE (European Kiel), NIELS PETERSEN (Max Planck Institute, University Institute, Florence), STEFAN Bonn), LYDIA LÖHNER (University of KORTE (FU Berlin), THOMAS KLEINLEIN Göttingen), TOBIAS THIENEL (University of (University of Frankfurt/Main), BERNHARD Kiel), IGNAZ STEGMILLER (University of KUSCHNIK (University of Tübingen), Göttingen), MARKUS WAGNER (University of CLEMENS MATTHEIS (University of Miami) Göttingen), NELE MATZ-LÜCK (Max Planck Editorial Board Editors-in-Chief: MOHAMMAD AL-HASANI, JOHANNES JÜRGING, GEORG KALINNA, MATTHIAS LIPPOLD NICOLAS KLEIN, CAROLIN KLÜPFEL, RHIAN MORITZ, JULIA MÖBUS, ANNIKA MALEEN ANTONIA BAUTSCH, FABIAN BISMAYER. ANJA POSCHADEL, JOHANNA ROCH, GEORG DAHLMANN, ANNE DIENELT, JOHANNA SCHÄFER, KAREN SCHWABE, PHILIPP SOCHA, DORMANN, NIELS EBLING, SEBASTIAN HOLGER STOLTENBERG-LERCHE, TOBIAS EHRICHT, ANJA EIKERMANN, KATHARINA TSCHAPPE, LUISA WENDEL, ELENA JOSEPHINE EMILJANOW, OSMAN GUELYESIL, BENEDIKT WOLTAIRE HEINRICHS, PETJA IVANOVA, MORTEN JONAS, Native Speaker Board NEELA BADAMI, PRIYA BHATIA, ELIZABETH ANDREW EWING, KAREN KIMKANA, ISABEL CAMPBELL, DEEPALOKE CHATTERJEE, MCCANN, ALEX MURRAY, DANIEL PEAT Vol. 2, No. 2 (2010) Contents Editorial Editorial ...................................................................................................... 417 Acknowledgments ...................................................................................... 421 Articles New Protectionism – How Binding are International Legal Obligations During a Global Economic Crisis Stephan Hobe & Jörn Griebel.................................................................... 423 Reservations and the Effective Protection of Human Rights Johanna Fournier ...................................................................................... 437 The Future of Peacekeeping in Africa and the Normative Role of the African Union Charles Majinge ......................................................................................... 463 Humaneness, Humankind and Crimes Against Humanity Bernhard Kuschnik .................................................................................... 501 Secession in Theory and Practice: the Case of Kosovo and Beyond Ioana Cismas .............................................................................................. 531 414 GoJIL 2 (2010) 2, 413-415 Current Developments in International Law The Russian Federation, Protocol No. 14 (and 14bis), and the Battle for the Soul of the ECHR Bill Bowring ............................................................................................... 589 “Nothing but a Road Towards Secession”- The International Court of Justice’s Advisory Opinion on Accordance with International Law of the Unilateral Declaration of Independence in Respect of Kosovo? Mindia Vashakmadze & Matthias Lippold ................................................ 619 Gojil Focus: ICC Review Conference Kampala June 2010 – A First Review of the ICC Review Conference Hans-Peter Kaul ........................................................................................ 649 Uganda and the International Criminal Court Review Conference: Some Observations of the Conference’s Impact in the ‘Situation Country’ Uganda Sabine Klein ............................................................................................... 669 Amendments to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Considered at the First Review Conference on the Court, Kampala, 31 May-11 June 2010 Roger S. Clark ............................................................................................ 689 Contents 415 The Crime of Aggression After Kampala: Success or Burden for the Future? Robert Heinsch ........................................................................................... 713 The International Criminal Court’s Exercise of Jurisdiction Over the Crime of Aggression – at Last … in Reach … Over Some Astrid Reisinger Coracini .......................................................................... 745 Complementarity After Kampala: Capacity Building and the ICC’s Legal Tools Morten Bergsmo, Olympia Bekou & Annika Jones ................................... 791 Vol. 2, No. 2 (2010) Editorial After our last issue “Strategies for Solving Global Crises - The Financial Crisis and Beyond” in March we are delighted to present this issue to our esteemed readers. Like every student activity, GoJIL also goes through a process of constant rejuvenation. With this characteristic feature it is necessary to maintain the essence of experience and to rethink and further the underlying idea. Having this in mind, we would like to introduce our new section, “GoJIL-Focus”. In GoJIL-Focus we shall put complex questions or events that are of vital importance to international law into perspective by facilitating a comprehensive assessment through the eyes of a variety of authors. We are very pleased to begin this new feature with an exceptional highlight – nothing less than the first Review on the ICC-Review Conference in Kampala, Uganda. The Conference in Kampala focused mainly on the crime of aggression. We do not assume that the never-ending discussion on this topic can be brought to an end by the outcome documents of Kampala and therefore, GoJIL is pleased to continue this debate in the new light of the results reached in Kampala.