DOCSLIB.ORG

The French Conquest of the Canaries in 1402-6, and the Authority for the Same Author(S): C

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The French Conquest of the Canaries in 1402-6, and the Authority for the Same Author(S): C The French Conquest of the Canaries in 1402-6, and the Authority for the Same Author(s): C. Raymond Beazley Source: The Geographical Journal, Vol. 25, No. 1 (Jan., 1905), pp. 77-81 Published by: geographicalj Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1775986 Accessed: 27-06-2016 02:30 UTC Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://about.jstor.org/terms JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. The Royal Geographical Society (with the Institute of British Geographers), Wiley are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Geographical Journal This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 02:30:45 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms THE FRENCH CONQUEST OF THE CANARIES IN 1402-6. 77 supply of water foi Egypt is ample, and the Blue Nile could be safely drawn upon for local needs. The construction of a reservoir, though of limited storage capacity, south of Rosaires, would materially assist in augmenting the winter discharge of the Blue Nile; and a beginning might be made in the irrigation of the northern portion of the Ghezira, particularly to the north of Wad Medani. But the projects of constructing a barrage on the Blue Nile, for controlling the river Gash, and for obtaining additional supplies from the rivers Dinder, Rahad, Settit, and Atbara, have yet to be studied, and a series of levels run, before any definite schemes can be formulated. In Appendix I. Sir William Garstin enumerates the following works, which deserve special attention:- (1) The remodelling of the Bahr el-Gebel. (2) The construction of a barrage in the Blue Nile. (3) A canal system in the Ghezira in connection with this barrage. (4) The regulation of the river Gash. (5) The construction of a storage reservoir somewhere in Sudan territory, south of Rosaires. (6) The regulation of the Victoria and Albert lakes. " Of these," he says, " the first and last will be undertaken more in the interests of Egypt than of the Sadan, except as regards the Nile valley north of Khartum. The others are designed for the benefit of the Sudan alone." From Khartum to Berber the conditions are quite different to those on the Blue Nile, and resemble those of Upper Egypt and Dongola. In regard to Egypt, more particularly, none of these schemes are of extreme urgency except the provision of escape power for the Nile during an exceptional flood. Sir William Willcocks' suggestions and proposals in this respect are dealt with in Appendix I. under the following heads: (1) the raising of the Aswan dam; (2) the utilization of the Wadi Rayan depres- sion as a secondary reservoir; and (3) the remodelling of the Rosetta branch of the Nile. The combination of the first two schemes, making the one the complement of the other, is an entirely novel idea, and a striking instance of the high capacity of its author; but space precludes our dealing with these technical matters, as well as with the indeterminable question of cost. A. S. W. THE FRENCH CONQUEST OF THE CANARIES IN 1402-6, AND THE AUTHORITY FOR THE SAME. By C. RAYMOND BEAZLEY, M.A. THE French conquest of the Canaries, at the beginning of the fifteenth century, that first chapter of modern colonial history, has long been considered to rest upon an authority (' Le Canarien') of exceptional value, being not only a contemporary witness, but written by men who were present at, and took part in, the events here recorded with such a wealth of life-like and picturesque detail. And in many respects this view is correct enough. For the Livre de la Conqueste et Conversion des Canariens . en 1402 . par Jean de Bethencourt . compose par Pierre Bontier (sic), moyne de S. Jouin de Marnes, el Jehan le Verrier, prestre seculier, chapelains du dix seigneur, printed by Pierre Bergeron in 1630, collated by d'Avezac with the Mont Ruffet manuscript of c. A.D. 1482 (from which Bergeron seems to have worked, and which Charton used for his' Voyageurs ancieas et modernes' of 1855), is, after all, one form of the original record of this Norman conquest in the Atlantic. It is also, combined with the results of d'Avezac's collation of the This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 02:30:45 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms 78 THE FRENCH CONQUEST OF THE CANARIES IN 1402-6, manuscript aforesaid, the form reproduced and translated by Major in 1872 for the Hakluyt Society; in other words, the standard form for English scholars of the last generation. But it is not the most original, nor the most trustworthy form; for the history of the French expedition to the Fortunate islands is here revised to suit the views of the Bethencourt family. It therefore magnifies the figure of Jean de Bethencourt, depreciates the achievements and importance of his colleague, Gadifer de la Sale (or Salle), and combines the original narrative of Pierre Boutier the Benedictine and Jean le Verrier the secular priest, with additions of various kinds, such as the last twenty-five chapters of Major's edition, following upon the description of the Canary islands (Hak. Soc. edition, pp. 140-220). Its representation of many incidents is totally different from that of the primitive Record lately rediscovered, where the writers' sympathies are clearly with Gadifer, and where Jean de Bethencourt is unsparingly criticized-not in reference to his treatment of his wife, as in the later Redaction, but in regard to his conduct in the joint leadership of the Canary conquest. Gadifer de la Salle, through the words of his chaplain and advocate, Pierre Boutier, has once more, after the silence of centuries, made himself heard. The acquisition of the Egerton manuscript No. 2709 by the British Museum in 1888 has produced this result. The manuscript in question, formerly in the possession of the Baroness de Hensch de Langry, is of much earlier date than that from which Bergeron, Charton, d'Avezac, and Major worked; it belongs to the first quarter of the fifteenth century (c. A.D. 1420); it contains a reference to the Papal schism ended in 1429 (fol. 29b, "nous auons deux papez," etc.); it is usually composed in the first person plural, and not, like the text of 1482, in the third person; and it un- questionably represents an older (probably the very earliest) form of the conquest narrative. It implicitly contradicts the tradition that Jean le Verrier dictated to Pierre Boutier the record to which these two ecclesiastics jointly set their names. It makes clear that the two ecclesiastics aforesaid were not, as suggested by the later text, both chaplains of Bethencourt, but that Boutier was the spiritual attendant of Gadifer. Finally, as already noticed, it furnishes Gadifer's statement of the whole episode of the Canarian invasion, and supplies a number of detailed accusations of inefficiency, slackness, disingenuousness, fussy assumption of superiority, and the like, against Jean de Bethencourt. This Egerton manuscript, henceforth its primary authority for the French conquest of the Canaries and the first extension of European influence to the Atlantic islands, before its acquisition by the British Museum, had remained wholly without notice or collation ; a short but excellent description of it is given in the ' Catalogue of Additions to B. Mus. MSS.,' 1888-93, and a transcript of it was made by Miss Lucy Toulmin Smith for M. Pierre Margry and printed (un- fortunately with many mis-readings) in the latter's 'Conquete . des . .. Canaries,' 1896. But no one has yet made an adequate comparison of this text with that given by Major and d'Avezac, although the main features of difference have been already pointed out both by the Museum 'Catalogue of Additions ' above quoted by Margry. It may, therefore, be of use, by certain select examples, to warn English students who may touch on, or in any way interest themselves in this fascinating chapter in the History of Exploration, that the old standard text, given to them and translated for them in the Hakluyt Society's putlica- tions, can no longer be taken as sufficient. Here and there it adds points not in the Egerton manuscript, but (within the period common to both) it omits far more important matters represented only in the latter. And among these we have first and foremost the matter of the chief credit and honour. In Major's text these are almost wholly due to Bethencourt; in Egerton they are mainly Gadifer's. This content downloaded from 128.197.26.12 on Mon, 27 Jun 2016 02:30:45 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms AND THE AUTHORITY FOR THE SAME. 79 To show how important are the modifications now introduced into the received account, it will be enough to compare the more interesting variants of the preface and the first nine chapters. At the beginning, the 'Livre nomme le Canarien' speaks of the present Norman conquest of the Canary isles (qui se dient les Isles de Canare) as parallel to the Christian conquests of heathen lands in olden time. Here both texts agree; but whereas in that of Major Bethencourt only is named as leading the enterprise, in Egerton Gadifer is not merely mentioned but placed first.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Canarian : Or, Book of the Conquest and Conversion of The
    \A/;-^!:-.J., /M|!;> ^AA- H-^'tHw 1' f.' ' UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH JJarlini^ton Alemorial Ijibrary m * . * A. ••• ,,i.«'.^ ^ • # 4 PORTRAIT OF MESSIRE JEAN DE BETHENCOURT, KING OF THE CANARIES. THE CANARIAN, OR, BOOK OP THE CONQUEST AND CONVERSION OF THE CANARIANS IN THE YF.AR 1102, Messiee jean DE BETHENCOURT, K""., Lord of the Manors of BHhencourt, Riville, Gotirrel, hnd Grahiville hi Tcintti Baron of St. Martin le Gaillard, Councillor and Chamberlain in Ordinary to Charles V aiid Charles VI, COMPOSED BY PIERRE BOXTIER, and JEAN LE VERRIER, TRANSLATED AND EDITED, SlSIitf) Xoics ant) ait £ntvoBuction, BY RICHARD HENRY MAJOR, F.S.A., etc., KEEPER OF THE DEPARTMENT OF MAPS AND CHARTS IN THE BRITISH MUSI AND HON. SEC. OF THE ROYAL GE'JGR XPHICAL S'iCIETY. LONDON: rniXlEl) FOIJ THE HAKLUYT .SOCIETY'. M.I^CCC.T.XX LE CANARIEN Livre de la conqucfte et converfion faidte des Canariens a la foy et Religion cadiolique apoflo- lique et Romaine en I'an 1402 : par Meffire Jehan de Bethencourt, Chevalier, gentilhomme Cauchois, Seigneur du lieu de Bethencourt, Riville, Gourrel, Chaftelain de Grainville la Tain- tnriere, Baron de Saincl Martin le Gaillard, Confeiller et Chambcllau ordinaire des Roys Charles 5 et 6. COMPOSE PAR PIERRE BONTIER, moyne de Sainc Jouyn de Marnes, El' JEAN LE VERRIER, Preare, SERVIJEURS DU DIT DE HETIIENCOURT. corxciL THE HAKLUYT SOCIETY. The Eioht Hon. Sia DAVID DUNDAS, President. Admihal C. E. DRINKWATER BETHUNE, C.B. Major-Gen. Sir HENRY C. RAWLINS Rev. GEORGE P. BADGER, F.K.G.S. J. BARROW, Esq., F.R.S., F.R.G.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Tirant, 22 (2019), Pp. 207-220 « Desvoyé De La Droitte Voye
    Colloque Don Quichotte avant Don Quichotte ? ISSN: 1579-7422 « Desvoyé de la droitte voye ... » : Gadifer de La Salle, Jean de Béthencourt et Le Canarien Leaving the true path: Gadifer de La Salle, Jean de Béthencourt and the Conquest of the Canaries Jane H. M. Taylor (Durham University) Ce fut, nous dit le prologue de l’ouvrage connu sous le nom « Le Canarien »,1 une expé- dition entreprenant « voyages et conquestes sur mescreans » — une croisade donc — et conçue « a l’onneur de Dieu et au soustenement et acroissement de nostre sainte creance » ; les partici- pants espéraient « acquerir vie permanable », ils ont montré « cuer, hardement et voulenté » dans de « beaulz faiz » qui feront inéluctablement penser aux « enciennes ystoires » et aux « bonnes chevalleries et estranges choses que les vaillans conquereurs souloient faire au temps passé ».2 Reconnaissant ainsi tous les poncifs du prologue de récit chevaleresque, le lecteur s’attendra sans doute au discours laudatif, univoque, qui est le propre de ce genre.3 1. Mes citations (désormais sous le sigle LNC) seront tirées de la plus récente, et belle, édition, Le Livre nommé « Le Canarien » : textes français de la conquête des Canaries au XVe siècle, éd. Aznar et al (2008), ici pp. 72-75 ; notons que ce texte avait déjà été publié, dans ce que les éditeurs appellent (LNC, p. 53) une « transcription strictement paléographique », par les soins encore de Pico, Aznar et Cor- bella, Le Canarien. Manuscritos, transcripción y traducción (2003). À consulter aussi celle, plus ancienne mais plus complète, de Serra et Cioranescu, Le Canarien: crónicas francesas de la conquista de Canarias, 1959-1964, que je cite désormais siglé Serra/Cioranescu ; dans cette collection, [G], la version de Gadifer de La Sale se trouve au tome III ; [B], la version de Jean de Béthencourt, dans le tome II ; notons entre parenthèses que ce volume contient des photos de toutes les illustrations de [B].
    [Show full text]
  • Morocco in the Early Atlantic World, 1415-1603 A
    MOROCCO IN THE EARLY ATLANTIC WORLD, 1415-1603 A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences of Georgetown University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History By Earnest W. Porta, Jr., J.D. Washington, DC June 20, 2018 Copyright 2018 by Earnest W. Porta, Jr. All Rights Reserved ii MOROCCO IN THE EARLY ATLANTIC WORLD, 1415-1603 Earnest W. Porta, Jr., J.D. Dissertation Advisor: Osama Abi-Mershed, Ph.D. ABSTRACT Over the last several decades, a growing number of historians have conceptualized the Atlantic world as an explanatory analytical framework, useful for studying processes of interaction and exchange. Stretching temporally from the 15th into the 19th century, the Atlantic world framework encompasses more than simply the history of four continents that happen to be geographically situated around what we now recognize as the Atlantic basin. It offers instead a means for examining and understanding the transformative impacts that arose from the interaction of European, African, and American cultures following the European transatlantic voyages of the 15th and 16th centuries. Though it has not been extensively studied from this perspective, during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries Morocco possessed geopolitical characteristics that uniquely situated it within not only the Islamic world, but the developing Atlantic world as well. This study considers Morocco’s involvement in the early Atlantic world by examining three specific phases of its involvement. The first phase lasts approximately one hundred years and begins with the Portuguese invasion of Ceuta in 1415, considered by some to mark the beginning of European overseas expansion.
    [Show full text]
  • Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America. A
    A GENEALOGICAL HISTORY Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America $C* Elizabeth Hirschman and Donald Yates Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America m 2012 Also by Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman and Donald N. Yates When Scotland Was Jewish: DNA Evidence, Archeology, Analysis ofMigrations, and Public and Family Records Show Twelfth Century Semitic Roots (McFarland, 2007) Jews and Muslims in British Colonial America A Genealogical History Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman and Donald N. Yates McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Jefferson, North Carolina, and London 5.Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data 6. Hirschman, Elizabeth Caldwell, 1949- Jews and Muslims in British colonial America : a genealogical history / Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman and Donald N. Yates, p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7864-6462-3 softcover : acid free paper (So) 1. Jews — United States — History — 17th century. 2. Jews — United States — History— 18th century. 3. Muslims — United States — History — 17th century. 4. Muslims — United States — History — 18th century. United States — History — Colonial period, ca. 1600-1775. United States — Ethnic relations. I. Yates, Donald Neal. II. Title. E184.3512.H57 2012 305.800973 -dc23 2011048960 British Library cataloguing data are available © 2012 Elizabeth Caldwell Hirschman and Donald N. Yates. All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying or recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writingfrom the publisher. Front cover images © 2012 Shutterstock Manufactured in the United States of America McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Box 611, Jefferson, North Carolina 28640 www.mcfarlandpub.com 1 Table of Contents Preface j Introduction 4 One.
    [Show full text]
  • La Conquista De Las Canarias: Un Ensayo Bélico Para América (1402
    La conquista de las Canarias: un ensayo bélico para América (1402-1501) The Conquest of the Canary Islands: a Warfare Essay for America (1402-1501) Javier García de Gabiola Investigador independiente [email protected] Resumen La conquista de las Canarias se puede considerar como un ensayo de la posterior lucha por América, en la que los conquistadores, grupos de mercaderes, aventureros y religiosos, pactaban entre ellos y con la corona sus aportaciones económicas y derechos sobre el botín y tierras como si de una empresa comercial se tratara. Sus rivales, los primitivos guanches, opusieron una resis- tencia heroica e inesperada a la conquista castellana, que sólo pudo triunfar al cabo de 100 años gracias a la habilidad de hombres como Bethencourt, Rejón, Vera o Lugo, modelos para Cortés o Pizarro. Este estudio se centrará en los aspectos puramente bélicos del conflicto, describiendo las campañas con cierto nivel de detalle para entender así mejor las tácticas y estrategias apli- cadas que decidieron el resultado de la guerra, haciendo hincapié, entre otros aspectos, en una aproximación científica a los efectivos numéricos de los ejércitos en liza, sobre todo por parte de los guanches. Así, los nativos contaban con efectivos superiores a los castellanos, pero no del tamaño mencionado por las crónicas. Con base en estimaciones de población y del número de guerreros movilizados en las islas menores (más fáciles de contabilizar con fiabilidad por los cro- nistas), en torno a un cinco-diez por ciento de la población actuaría como guerreros. Este por- centaje se ha aplicado a las islas mayores, reduciéndolas asimismo en función del número total de reinos que se opusieron a los castellanos, ya que no todos lo hicieron.
    [Show full text]
  • Trinkets (F)Or Treasure?
    Trinkets (f)or Treasure? The role of European material culture in intercultural contacts in Hispaniola during early colonial times Floris W.M. Keehnen Trinkets (f)or Treasure? THESIS TO OBTAIN THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF PHILOSOPHY IN ARCHAEOLOGY – RELIGION AND SOCIETY IN NATIVE AMERICA – FACULTY OF ARCHAEOLOGY – LEIDEN UNIVERSITY Trinkets (f)or Treasure? The role of European material culture in intercultural contacts in Hispaniola during early colonial times Floris W.M. Keehnen Student number: 0518387 Course Code: ARCH 1046WTY Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Corinne L. Hofman Den Haag, June 2012 Floris W.M. Keehnen Conradkade 162 2517 CK Den Haag The Netherlands [email protected] (+31)617118999 Faculty of Archaeology, Leiden University © Floris W.M. Keehnen 2012 Cover image: Christopher Columbus at Hispaniola, (after) 1594 engraving by Theodor de Bry, Plate IX of Americae Pars Quarta, Sive, insignis & admiranda historia de reperta primùm Occidentali India à Christophoro Colombo anno MCCCCXCII. Scripta ab Hieronymo Bezono ... Addita ad singula ferè capita ... scholia [...] ('Grand Voyages to America', vol. 4). Reproduced in Winsor (ed) 1886, The Narrative and Critical History of America, vol. 2. Source: http://www.art-prints-on-demand.com. “One man's trash is another man's treasure ” Contents Acknowledgements 1 | Introduction .............................................................................................................................................. 11 1.1 Setting the scene: cultures in contact in the Caribbean ...............................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Peopling of the Canaries: New Data and New Hypotheses
    The peopling of the Canaries: new data and new hypotheses [CIRCULATION DRAFT] Prepared in conjunction with a presentation at the 18th African Archaeology Research Day, Cambridge, 24th November, 2018 Roger Blench McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research University of Cambridge Department of History, University of Jos Kay Williamson Educational Foundation 8, Guest Road Cambridge CB1 2AL United Kingdom Voice/ Ans (00-44)-(0)7847-495590 Mobile worldwide (00-44)-(0)7967-696804 E-mail [email protected] http://www.rogerblench.info/RBOP.htm This printout: Cambridge, November 8, 2018 Roger Blench The peopling of the Canaries: new hypotheses. Circulation draft TABLE OF CONTENTS ACRONYMS AND CONVENTIONS .............................................................................................................ii 1. Introduction................................................................................................................................................... 1 2. Early descriptions and possible visits............................................................................................................ 2 3. Existing archaeological resources ................................................................................................................. 3 4. Palaeo-environmental evidence..................................................................................................................... 4 4.1 Pollen and charcoal..................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Communication and the Social History of Contact in the Spanish Atlantic
    The Pennsylvania State University The Graduate School Department of History COMMUNICATION AND THE SOCIAL HISTORY OF CONTACT IN THE SPANISH ATLANTIC, 1341-1602 A Dissertation in History by Scott Cave Ó 2018 Scott Cave Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2018 The dissertation of Scott Cave was reviewed and approved* by the following: Matthew Restall Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of Colonial Latin American History Dissertation Advisor Chair of Committee Ronnie Hsia Edwin Erle Sparks Professor of History David G. Atwill Associate Professor of History Amara Solari Associate Professor of Art History and Anthropology Gregory Smits Professor of History and Asian Studies Director of Graduate Studies *Signatures are on file in the Graduate School iii ABSTRACT When Columbus landed in the Bahamas in 1492, he brought local people aboard and "spoke" with them—or so he claims. Many of the Europeans who followed in his wake similarly claim to have "spoken" with the indigenous people they met. The questions that immediately occur to modern readers are all variations of "How?" How did the people of Guanahani speak to Columbus? How did the conquistadors of Puerto Rico learn the "secrets of the land" they were about to conquer? How did the Calusa of south Florida know to reject Spanish visitors before those visitors had even arrived? How did information flow in the absence of a shared language? In this dissertation, I answer those basic questions, and describe how the struggle to communicate and gather information shaped the social landscapes of European and indigenous people in the Spanish Atlantic through the long sixteenth century.
    [Show full text]