2011 Date Item Description Summary Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Materials Review Committee Reconsideration of Materials Summary – 2011 Date Item Description Summary of Customer Findings and Action Taken Comments Mar How Israel Lost: The Anti-Semitic The author is a Pulitzer-prize-winning journalist who has 2011 Four Questions Remove from written extensively about the Middle East. collection He is critical of Israeli policy but as a serious and well-known Written by Richard Ben journalist, brings an important perspective to the issue. Cramer, Simon & The Library’s extensive collection of material on the conflict in Schuster, 2004 the Middle East includes a variety of points of view. Adult Book Retained in the adult collection Aug Hooray for Dairy Inaccurate content The author implies that calves stay with their mother for six 2011 Farming Remove from weeks but, according to Canadian dairy farming guidelines, this collection is not current practice. Written by Bobbie The information in the book, written in 1997, is outdated and Kalman, Crabtree more recent books are available in the collection. Publishing Company, Withdrawn from the collection 1997 Children’s book Nov What’s Up: Balloon to Movie is offensive and This animated film does contain negative stereotypes. 2011 the Rescue racist It is designed to be misleading by resembling Pixar’s Up and the No cultural or artistic company that produced it, Video Brinquedo, is known for Directed by Everton reasons for retaining producing low quality films based on other well-known films. It Rodrigues, 2009 was acquired in error. Children’s DVD The Library does not own and will not buy other titles produced by Video Brinquedo. Withdrawn from the collection 1 Date Item Description Summary of Customer Findings and Action Taken Comments Nov The Aristocrats Movie is degrading and This documentary style film features well-known comedians 2011 inappropriate for the such as Robin Williams and Whoopi Goldberg. Created by Penn Jillette library It was positively reviewed in the Toronto Star, the Globe & and Paul Provenza, Remove or apply Mail and the New York Times and was shown in North directed by Paul warning label American theatres. Provenza, 2006 Many North American public libraries own the film. Adult DVD Its restricted rating means that no-one under 18 can borrow it (Restricted) and the cover has comments warning customers about its contents. Retained in the adult collection 2.