Emerging Targets of Inflammation and Tear Secretion in Dry Eye Disease
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Drug Discovery Today Volume 24, Number 8 August 2019 PERSPECTIVE feature Emerging targets of inflammation and tear secretion in dry eye disease Maria Markoulli, [email protected] and Alex Hui The underlying mechanisms of dry eye are thought to be part of a vicious circle involving a hyperosmolarity-triggered inflammatory cascade, resulting in loss of goblet cells and glycocalyx mucin and observed corneal and conjunctival epithelial cell damage. This damage leads to increased tear film instability, further hyperosmolarity and hence perpetuating of a vicious circle. The aim of dry eye management is to restore the homeostasis of the tear film and break the perpetuation of this vicious circle. Despite the plethora of treatment options available, many of these are largely palliative, short-lived and require repeated instillations. Two emerging areas in dry eye therapy aim PERSPECTIVE to promote tear secretion and to safely manage dry eye-associated inflammation and are the focus of this review. Features Dry eye disease and its treatment into aqueous deficiency and evaporative dry Promoting tear secretion Dry eye disease is defined by the Tear Film and eye, but it is now understood that both con- Topical pharmaceutical secretagogues Ocular Surface Dry Eye Workshop (TFOS DEWS) ditions lie on a continuum that can be present Secretagogues stimulate the secretion of the II as ``a multifactorial disease of the ocular simultaneously to a varying degree [1]. aqueous, mucin or lipid constituents of the tear surface characterized by a loss of homeostasis The aim of dry eye management is to restore film, hence minimising the impact of tear film of the tear film, and accompanied by ocular the homeostasis of the tear film and break the instability and goblet cell and glycocalyx mucin symptoms, in which tear film instability and perpetuation of the dry eye circle [3]. Current loss that form part of the vicious circle of dry eye hyperosmolarity, ocular surface inflammation treatments can be largely categorized into one disease [2]. The following discussion separates and damage, and neurosensory abnormalities of six categories: treatment for aqueous defi- secretagogues into those that stimulate each of play etiological roles” [1]. The underlying ciency, treatment for meibomian gland dys- these constituents, however it should be rec- mechanisms of dry eye are thought to be part function and eyelid abnormalities, anti- ognized the potential for overlapping effects of a vicious circle involving a hyperosmolarity- inflammatory therapy, surgical approaches, di- affecting multiple components of the tear film. triggered inflammatory cascade, resulting in etary modifications and environmental modifi- loss of goblet cells and glycocalyx mucin and cations [3]. Despite the plethora of treatment Aqueous secretagogues observed corneal and conjunctival epithelial options available, many of these are largely Diquafosol tetrasodium (3% ophthalmic solu- 1 cell damage [2]. This damage to the ocular palliative, short-lived and require repeated tion, Diquas ; Santen, Osaka, Japan) is ap- surface leads to increased tear film instability, instillations [4]. Two emerging areas in dry eye proved for use in Japan and South Korea. This is further feeding tear hyperosmolarity and hence therapy aim to promote tear secretion and to a mucolytic compound and a purinergic P2Y2 perpetuating the vicious circle [2] (Fig. 1). Tra- safely manage dry eye-associated inflammation receptor agonist that stimulates tear fluid and ditionally, the disease has been characterized (Fig. 1) and are the focus of this review. mucin secretion [5,6]. P2Y receptors are meta- 1359-6446/ã 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drudis.2019.02.006 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com 1427 PERSPECTIVE Drug Discovery Today Volume 24, Number 8 August 2019 Tear hyperosmolarity A cascade of signaling events within surface epithelial cells Tear film LFA-1 Vicious circle instability antagonists of dry eye IL-1, 17 IFNγ TNFα+ MMPs Lipid, aqueous, Goblet cell and mucus glycocalyx mucin loss secretagogues epithelial damage -apoptosis Drug Discovery Today FIGURE 1 The vicious circle of dry eye disease (adapted from Bron, A.J. et al. (2017) TFOS DEWS II pathophysiology report. Ocul Surf 15 (3), 438–510) [1]. The core mechanisms of dry eye disease are thought to be tear hyperosmolarity which leads to a cascade of signalling events within epithelial cells. This leads to inflammation which further leads to ocular surface damage and tear film instability. Without intervention, this circle is thought to be self-perpetuating. The proposed actions of the two emerging treatments for dry eye disease presented in this review, secretagogues and lymphocyte function-associated antigen-1 antagonists (LFA-1 antagonists) on this cycle are shown in the blue. IL: interleukin, IFNF: interferon gamma, TNFa: tumor necrosis factor alpha, MMPs: matrix metalloproteinases. botropic guanosine triphosphate binding pro- resulted in an improved fluorescein staining contact lens-related dry eye disease [33]. In the tein (G-protein) coupled receptors and P2Y2 score similar to the control group that was presence of ocular surface inflammation, lacritin receptors specifically activate phospholipase C- taking 0.1% sodium hyaluronate ophthalmic is down-regulated by tear tissue transgluta- b [7]. These receptors are found at the corneal solution, and even further improvements in rose minase which is elevated in dry eye disease Features epithelium, the conjunctival epithelium, the bengal staining, more so than the control [12]. In [34,35]. Lacritin’s application in dry eye disease is goblet cells and meibomian glands [8]. In age- a prospective study evaluating 3% diquafosol aimed at taking advantage of tear proteins as related dry eye mice models, use of diquafosol sodium on 13 patients over a 3-month period, an potential biotherapeutics. In mice models of PERSPECTIVE results in increased goblet cell density and a improvement in meibomian gland appearance Sjögren’s Syndrome treated with lacritin, treat- decrease in ocular surface inflammation [9]. and function and symptoms was found [17]. In a ment with lacritin demonstrated a 46% increase Byun et al. demonstrated that diquafosol study of 15 patients with aqueous deficient dry in tear secretion and a reduction in lissamine accelerates corneal epithelial wound healing eye disease treated for 6 months, an improve- green staining, compared to the control eyes possibly as a result of epidermal growth factor ment in symptoms, corneal staining, tear break- [32]. On the cornea it also resulted in a shift from receptor/extracellular signal-regulated kinase up time and tear meniscus height was noted skin-specific cytokeratin to K12, a corneal-spe- stimulated cell proliferation and migration [10]. after 1 month and maintained for the 6-month cific cytokeratin that is abundant in the healthy Other studies have shown effects of the drug to observation period [18]. Other studies have ocular mucosal epithelium [32]. The drug is suppress the loss of corneal epithelial integrity supported similar findings for diquafosol’s im- currently not available commercially although it [6,11]. pact on the ocular surface, showing an im- is being evaluated for its safety and efficacy in an Several randomized controlled clinical trials provement in symptoms and corneal staining ongoing human clinical trial (NCT03226444), have demonstrated the efficacy and safety of [19], tear volume [20,21], lid margin abnormal- with an estimated 201 participants randomised TM diquafosol administered topically for dry eye ities including vascularity [22], corneal staining to receive either 0.005% or 0.01% Lacripep , or disease [12–14]. In a 4-week randomised, dou- [23,22], meibomian gland function [22] and lipid placebo [36]. ble-masked study of 286 patients with dry eye layer thickness [24]. Diquafosol’s ability to disease comparing diquafosol 3% to sodium improve higher order aberrations has been Mucin secretagogues 1 hyaluronate ophthalmic solution, each taken 6 reported, but other studies have contradicted Rebamipide ophthalmic suspension (Mucosta ; times daily for 4 weeks, diquafosol significantly this, suggesting its impact on this parameter to Otsuka Pharmaceutical, Chiyoda, Japan) is a improved conjunctival staining scores while be equivocal [25–29]. There have also been little mucin secretagogue that promotes the pro- having a similar adverse event profile as the to no studies on the long-term usage of this duction of mucin-like glycoproteins in human sodium hyaluronate [15]. Combining these two agent and it currently remains unavailable to corneal epithelial cells [37] as well as the ex- products has been shown to be effective in most areas within the world. pression of membrane-associated mucins stabilizing vision and dry eye symptoms fol- Lacritin is a tear glycoprotein prosecretory MUC1, MUC4 and MUC16 [37]. Currently in lowing LASIK [16]. In a randomized, parallel- mitogen that promotes basal tear secretion [30] Japan, along with hyaluronic acid and diqua- group comparison study of 497 patients with and epithelial homeostasis [31]. It is downre- fosol, it forms the mainstay of dry eye treatment dry eye disease over a 4-week period, diquafosol gulated in both Sjögren’s Syndrome [32] and [38]. Rebamipide was originally launched as an 1428 www.drugdiscoverytoday.com Drug Discovery Today Volume 24, Number 8 August 2019 PERSPECTIVE oral medication for the repair of gastric mucosa effects has since been shown