APPENDIX 1 SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS (Q4 12/13) UPDATED TO 10 JUNE 2013

Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks)

ON-GOING APPEALS

E/27169/B Mr Canovan E Formation of a means of access to a highway 05 April 12 WR UPHELD 40+ by the demolition of a brick wall together with 16 Jan 13 the laying of hardcore on the land – 31 New Road,

P/00591/12 Mr N Mtchenall R Proposed detached dwelling with vehicular 16 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 23+ access, parking and bin store (revised 28 Jan 13 scheme) - Former Water Works site, Cliff Road, Totland Bay

P/00234/12 Mr T Denny RC CAC for demolition of hotel in connection with 30 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 27+ construction of 2 detached dwellings and pair 13 March 13 of semi-detached dwellings; parking & vehicular access off Popham Road – Priory Manor Hotel, Priory Road,

P/00690/12 Mildren Homes RA Retention of stack sign and flagpoles on 10 Aug 12 WR PART ALLOW 24+ Ltd corner of Sandy Lane and Whitcombe Road; 21 Jan 12 stack sign and flagpole to the south of the entrance to the site; 2 x flagpoles inside the entrance gates of the site; welcome sign within the entrance to the site – former Whitecroft Hospital, Sandy Lane, Newport

1 C - 3 P/00233/12 Mr T Denny R Demolition of hotel; construction of 2 30 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 27+ detached dwellings and pair of semi- 13 March 13 detached dwellings; parking & vehicular access off Popham Road - Priory Manor Hotel, Priory Road, Shanklin

P/00124/12 Mr A Court R Removal of condition 2 on P/025889/04 20 Sept 12 H DISMISSED 34 which restricts the use of the studio to holiday Re-started 12 March 13 23/04/2013 accommodation - Bottom Barn, 16 Jan 13 Lane, Newport

E/24813/B Mr S Cousins E Material change of use of the land from 12 Sept 12 WR agriculture to a mixed use of agriculture and storage through the storage of domestic paraphernalia and abandoned vehicles - Land rear of Youngwood’s Farm, Whitehouse Road, Newport

P/01031/12 Mr G Forbes R Removal of conditions nos 2 and 3 on 27 Sept 12 WR DISMISSED 31 TCP/13426/C to allow approved studio to be 16/05/2013 used as permanent residential unit – Witchingberry Farm, The Green,

P/00760/12 C. B. Trapp R Outline for eight dwellings; formation of 8 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Developments vehicular access (revised scheme) – land r/o 28 Jan 13 Paddock View and 132 Howgate Road, on Western side of Forelands Field Road,

P/00091/12 The Portsmouth R Demolition of church; construction of 8 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Roman Catholic detached dwelling with detached garage / 28 Jan 13 Diocesan boatstore with pergola, vehicular access and Trustees parking – Catholic Church, Seafield Road, Seaview, PO34 5HD

P/00835/12 Mr S R Vincent R Proposed two storey house – 18 Sun Hill, 22 Nov 12 WR DISMISSED 16 PO31 7HY 14 March 13

2 C - 4 P/00875/12 McCarthy & R Demolition of existing building; proposed 16 Oct 12 H ALLOWED 21 Stone two/three storey building to provide sheltered 12/13 Feb 13 12 March 13 Retirement accommodation comprising of 40 apartments Lifestyles Ltd with associated facilities and parking, alterations to vehicular access; landscaping – Staddlestones, Church Road, Bembridge

P/00876/12 McCarthy & R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 16 Oct 12 H ALLOWED 21 Stone existing building; proposed two/three storey 12/13 Feb 13 12 March 13 Retirement building to provide sheltered accommodation Lifestyles Ltd comprising of 40 apartments with associated facilities and parking, alterations to vehicular access; landscaping – Staddlestones, Church Road, Bembridge

P/00342/12 Mr P Tomlinson R Proposed conversion of dwelling to form 4 17 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 11+ sheltered housing units; outline for sheltered 07 Jan 13 housing scheme comprising 2 blocks of 4 flats and 2 bungalows; alterations to vehicular access; outline for pair of semi-detached houses with parking and formation of vehicular access – Rye House, Playstreet Lane, PO33 3LJ E/14561/A Mr S Williams E Alleged breach of planning control: 25 Oct 12 WR Unauthorised works to a Listed Building – windows – 5 St Thomas Street, Ryde PO33 2LZ

E/28279/B Mr L Thorne E Without planning permission, (i) the I PART and Mrs L unauthorised construction of an extension on 6/7 March 13 ALLOWED Thorne the western elevation, (ii) the unauthorised 15/4/13 alteration of a single storey roof on the eastern elevation to form a raised platform/balcony, and (iii) the unauthorised construction of an extension on the rear elevation – Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, Undercliff,

3 C - 5 P/00411/10 Mr L Thorne RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for proposed I single storey rear extension – Beach Cottage, 6/7 March 13 Castlehaven Lane, Niton Undercliff, Ventnor

P/01865/10 Mr P Major R Outline for a detached dwelling (revised 31 Oct 12 WR Dismissed 24 plans) (readvertised application) – Land 04/04 adjacent Graytiles, St Catherine’s Road, Niton Undercliff

P/01120/12 Mrs Wendy Hill R Outline for dwelling (revised scheme) – 6 Nov 12 WR ALLOWED 20 Reservoir Villa, Old Reservoir Lane, 20/05/2013

E/20029/N Mr R Fell E Unauthorised Caravans – Solent View, Lower 28 Nov 12 WR Woodside Road, Wootton Bridge

P/00949/12 Mr A Button R Two detached houses with parking and 26 Nov 12 WR formation of vehicular access off Road (revised scheme) – land adjoining Brookside Cottages, Church Street, fronting Blackgand Road, Niton

P/01368/12 Ms J Drake R Outline for dwelling with vehicular access and 22 Nov 12 WR parking (revised scheme) – 111 Old Road,

P/00836/12 Mr Scott RL LBC for proposed two storey house – 18 Sun 22 Nov 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Vincent Hill, Cowes 14 March 13

P/00179/10 Highfield R Replacement of planning permission 28 Nov 12 WR Residential P/02231/06 – TCP/015900/C in order to Care Home extend time limit for implementation (additional information received in respect of site levels) (re-advertised application) – Highfield House Residential Home, 4 Highfield Road, Shanklin

4 C - 6 P/00858/12 MR & Mrs R Demolition of dwelling and outbuildings; 05 Dec 12 WR WITHDRAWN 10+ Robert & A proposed detached dwelling with double 14 Feb 13 Wood garage - The Roost, Road, Ventnor

P/01361/12 Mr Dave R Retention of balcony on south elevation at 1st 18 Dec 12 WR Chapman floor level – Flat, Osborne Garage, York Avenue, East Cowes

P/00442/11 Mr Jennings IC Retention of garden chalet providing ancillary 28 Jan 13 WR accommodation (revised scheme) - 25 Ward Avenue, Cowes

E/20396/G Mr Sanders E The material change of use of the land from 14 Jan 13 I agricultural to the siting of a horsebox/lorry in 26 June 13 conjunction with the use of the workshop for use as a separate residential unit – ‘Rodgebrook Piggeries’ north east of Rodgebrook Farm, Whitehouse Road,

P/00708/12 Mr B Johnson R Proposed dwelling – rear of 12 Portland 24 Jan 13 WR DISMISSED 20 Street, Newport 20/05/2013

APPEALS RECEIVED BETWEEN 01 Jan 13 – 31 March 13

P/00731/12 Mr P Willis R Proposed detached house to provide 24 Jan 13 WR managers accommodation – Blacksmiths Arms, Calbourne Road, Newport

P/01575/12 Ms M Jones R Demolition of garage; outline for a garage - 29 Jan 13 WR Land rear of 18 Percy Road, Sandown

5 C - 7 P/00706/11 Infinergy Ltd R Land South of Wellow, East of Holmfield 01 Feb 13 INQUIRY WITHDRAWN Avenue, West of Stoneovers and off Broad CANCELLED Lane, , Yarmouth – Five wind turbines (100m to the tip of a rotor blade in a vertical position) provision of crane hardstandings, control buildings, substation, underground cabling, temporary construction compound, new access tracks off Broad Lane and (B3401) to accommodate construction traffic and a permanent 65m high anemometer mast (readvertised application - additional information received)

P/01173/11 Mrs & Mrs R Demolition of tea-rooms and part of cottage; 30 Jan 13 WR Debrett outline for replacement tea-rooms with flat over, detached house and two flats; alterations to cottage; parking; alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) (revised plans) (readvertised application) – Willow Tree Tea Gardens, High Street,

P/01174/11 Mrs & Mrs R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 30 Jan 13 WR Debrett tea-rooms and part of cottage; outline for replacement tea-rooms with flat over, detached house and two flats; alterations to cottage; parking; alterations to vehicular access(revised scheme) (revised plans) (readvertised application) – Willow Tree Tea Gardens, High Street, Godshill

P/01612/12 Mr Sandell R Alterations, extension to and conversion of 08 Feb 13 WR stables to form residential unit; proposed (HAS) building to provide boarding cattery and associated facilities – Barnsley Farm, Bullen Road, Ryde

6 C - 8 P/01465/12 L Pocock ND LDC for continued use of front area of 19 March 13 WR property as driveway/parking area – 33 School Green Road, Freshwater

P/01552/12 Mrs Fitzgerald R Detached double garage – Little 07 Feb 13 WR Farm, Gatcombe

P/01733/12 Mr & Mrs RLDC LDC for proposed detached building to 21 Feb 13 WR Margey provide games room and overspill accommodation – 17 Spencer Glade, Ryde

P/00934/12 Mr K Elderfield IC Alterations and conversion of former dairy to 05 March 13 WR form unit of holiday accommodation, Fairway Farm, Lower Road,

P/01186/12 Mrs J Willson R Removal of condition no.2 on 05 March 13 H TCP/18742/M/19478 limiting occupation of property to agricultural worker - Acorn Farm, 4 Horsebridge Hill, Newport

P/01418/12 Mr Downer R Alterations; two storey rear extension to 01 March 13 WR OUT OF TIME - provide living room with bedroom over to (HAS) 14 March 13 include balcony at first floor level; conversion of roofspace to provide additional living accommodation to include dormer windows on rear elevation - Free Waters, Gatcombe

P/01476/12 Mr A Parker R Balcony at first floor level on rear elevation of 14 March 13 WR two storey rear extension – Sans Souci, East (HAS) Hill Road, Ryde

P/01349/12 Mr D Ruddell R Variation of condition no.6 on P/01309/08- 13 March 13 WR TCP/13355/D to allow reduction in visibility splays – 62 Steyne Road, Bembridge

P/01360/12 Mr S Benton R Alterations to form roof terrace with new 08 March 12 WR sliding/folding doors and removal of internal Awaiting (HAS) walls - Flat C, 22 Spencer Road, Ryde Validation

7 C - 9 P/01325/12 Mr E Wright R Demolition of building; outline for detached 19 March 13 WR dwelling and pair of semi-detached dwellings with vehicular access and parking - Costume Workshop, Station Avenue, Sandown

P/01135/12 Messrs Stewart R Demoliiton of existing bungalow; replacement 27 March 13 WR & Simon King bungalow; chalet bungalow to provide holiday accommodation; formation of vehicular access & associated landscaping (revised description) – 1 Culver Way, Sandown

P/01905/12 Mr D Murrell R Proposed detached garage – Shoreside, 26 March 13 WR Madeira Lane, Freshwater (HAS)

P/01962/12 Mr S Westmore R Replacement of planning permission 27 March 13 WR (P/01858/09-TCP/15656/J: pair of semi- detached bungalows (revised plans)) in order to extend time limit for implementation - 119- 121 High Street, Ryde

P/00834/12 Sainsbury R Variation of condition 23 on P/01533/10 to 27 March 13 WR Supermarkets allow deliveries between 05:30 and 23:30 Ltd (Monday-Sunday) (revised information relating to design of the service yard and noise reduction dated 27 September 2012) (readvertised application) - Sainsbury, Foxes Road, Newport

KEY

Type Appeal Procedure

R = Refusal of planning permission WR = written representations RAC = Refusal to approve matters required for a condition WR (HAS) = written representations householder appeal service H = hearing RL = Refusal of listed building consent I = public inquiry RC = Refusal of conservation area consent 8 C - 10 RA = Refusal of advertisement consent IC = Imposition of condition on planning permission ND = Failure to determine application with prescribed period E= Enforcement notice RLDC= Refusal for lawful development certificate

SUMMARY OF SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS FOR QUARTER ENDING 31 MARCH 2013

Number of new appeals 19

Number of appeals in progress 34

Number of appeals withdrawn / invalid 2

Number of appeals determined 12

Dismissed 9 (75%) Allowed (inc 1 part allowed) 3 (25%)

PERFORMANCE

The Council’s appeal performance is measured by the percentage of appeals against the refusal of planning permission (excluding enforcement, lawful development certificate, advert and non-determination appeals and appeals against conditions) which are allowed.

Target maximum is 30% allowed (National average is around 34.6% allowed – 2011/12 figures).

Number of appeals determined 10 (against refusal of planning permission, listed building and conservation area consent only)

Dismissed 8 (82%) Allowed (including 1 part-allowed) 2 (20%)

9 C - 11