APPENDIX 1 SCHEDULE OF PLANNING APPEALS (Q4 12/13) UPDATED TO 10 JUNE 2013 Overall Appeal Procedure/ Appeal duration Ref Appellant Type Details/site Start Date date of H/I decision and of appeal (if known) date (in weeks) ON-GOING APPEALS E/27169/B Mr Canovan E Formation of a means of access to a highway 05 April 12 WR UPHELD 40+ by the demolition of a brick wall together with 16 Jan 13 the laying of hardcore on the land – 31 New Road, Brading P/00591/12 Mr N Mtchenall R Proposed detached dwelling with vehicular 16 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 23+ access, parking and bin store (revised 28 Jan 13 scheme) - Former Totland Water Works site, Cliff Road, Totland Bay P/00234/12 Mr T Denny RC CAC for demolition of hotel in connection with 30 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 27+ construction of 2 detached dwellings and pair 13 March 13 of semi-detached dwellings; parking & vehicular access off Popham Road – Priory Manor Hotel, Priory Road, Shanklin P/00690/12 Mildren Homes RA Retention of stack sign and flagpoles on 10 Aug 12 WR PART ALLOW 24+ Ltd corner of Sandy Lane and Whitcombe Road; 21 Jan 12 stack sign and flagpole to the south of the entrance to the site; 2 x flagpoles inside the entrance gates of the site; welcome sign within the entrance to the site – former Whitecroft Hospital, Sandy Lane, Newport 1 C - 3 P/00233/12 Mr T Denny R Demolition of hotel; construction of 2 30 Aug 12 WR DISMISSED 27+ detached dwellings and pair of semi- 13 March 13 detached dwellings; parking & vehicular access off Popham Road - Priory Manor Hotel, Priory Road, Shanklin P/00124/12 Mr A Court R Removal of condition 2 on P/025889/04 20 Sept 12 H DISMISSED 34 which restricts the use of the studio to holiday Re-started 12 March 13 23/04/2013 accommodation - Bottom Barn, Rowridge 16 Jan 13 Lane, Newport E/24813/B Mr S Cousins E Material change of use of the land from 12 Sept 12 WR agriculture to a mixed use of agriculture and storage through the storage of domestic paraphernalia and abandoned vehicles - Land rear of Youngwood’s Farm, Whitehouse Road, Newport P/01031/12 Mr G Forbes R Removal of conditions nos 2 and 3 on 27 Sept 12 WR DISMISSED 31 TCP/13426/C to allow approved studio to be 16/05/2013 used as permanent residential unit – Witchingberry Farm, The Green, Calbourne P/00760/12 C. B. Trapp R Outline for eight dwellings; formation of 8 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Developments vehicular access (revised scheme) – land r/o 28 Jan 13 Paddock View and 132 Howgate Road, on Western side of Forelands Field Road, Bembridge P/00091/12 The Portsmouth R Demolition of church; construction of 8 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Roman Catholic detached dwelling with detached garage / 28 Jan 13 Diocesan boatstore with pergola, vehicular access and Trustees parking – Catholic Church, Seafield Road, Seaview, PO34 5HD P/00835/12 Mr S R Vincent R Proposed two storey house – 18 Sun Hill, 22 Nov 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Cowes PO31 7HY 14 March 13 2 C - 4 P/00875/12 McCarthy & R Demolition of existing building; proposed 16 Oct 12 H ALLOWED 21 Stone two/three storey building to provide sheltered 12/13 Feb 13 12 March 13 Retirement accommodation comprising of 40 apartments Lifestyles Ltd with associated facilities and parking, alterations to vehicular access; landscaping – Staddlestones, Church Road, Bembridge P/00876/12 McCarthy & R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 16 Oct 12 H ALLOWED 21 Stone existing building; proposed two/three storey 12/13 Feb 13 12 March 13 Retirement building to provide sheltered accommodation Lifestyles Ltd comprising of 40 apartments with associated facilities and parking, alterations to vehicular access; landscaping – Staddlestones, Church Road, Bembridge P/00342/12 Mr P Tomlinson R Proposed conversion of dwelling to form 4 17 Oct 12 WR DISMISSED 11+ sheltered housing units; outline for sheltered 07 Jan 13 housing scheme comprising 2 blocks of 4 flats and 2 bungalows; alterations to vehicular access; outline for pair of semi-detached houses with parking and formation of vehicular access – Rye House, Playstreet Lane, Ryde PO33 3LJ E/14561/A Mr S Williams E Alleged breach of planning control: 25 Oct 12 WR Unauthorised works to a Listed Building – windows – 5 St Thomas Street, Ryde PO33 2LZ E/28279/B Mr L Thorne E Without planning permission, (i) the I PART and Mrs L unauthorised construction of an extension on 6/7 March 13 ALLOWED Thorne the western elevation, (ii) the unauthorised 15/4/13 alteration of a single storey roof on the eastern elevation to form a raised platform/balcony, and (iii) the unauthorised construction of an extension on the rear elevation – Beach Cottage, Castlehaven Lane, Niton Undercliff, Ventnor 3 C - 5 P/00411/10 Mr L Thorne RLDC Lawful Development Certificate for proposed I single storey rear extension – Beach Cottage, 6/7 March 13 Castlehaven Lane, Niton Undercliff, Ventnor P/01865/10 Mr P Major R Outline for a detached dwelling (revised 31 Oct 12 WR Dismissed 24 plans) (readvertised application) – Land 04/04 adjacent Graytiles, St Catherine’s Road, Niton Undercliff P/01120/12 Mrs Wendy Hill R Outline for dwelling (revised scheme) – 6 Nov 12 WR ALLOWED 20 Reservoir Villa, Old Reservoir Lane, 20/05/2013 Sandown E/20029/N Mr R Fell E Unauthorised Caravans – Solent View, Lower 28 Nov 12 WR Woodside Road, Wootton Bridge P/00949/12 Mr A Button R Two detached houses with parking and 26 Nov 12 WR formation of vehicular access off Blackgang Road (revised scheme) – land adjoining Brookside Cottages, Church Street, fronting Blackgand Road, Niton P/01368/12 Ms J Drake R Outline for dwelling with vehicular access and 22 Nov 12 WR parking (revised scheme) – 111 Old Road, East Cowes P/00836/12 Mr Scott RL LBC for proposed two storey house – 18 Sun 22 Nov 12 WR DISMISSED 16 Vincent Hill, Cowes 14 March 13 P/00179/10 Highfield R Replacement of planning permission 28 Nov 12 WR Residential P/02231/06 – TCP/015900/C in order to Care Home extend time limit for implementation (additional information received in respect of site levels) (re-advertised application) – Highfield House Residential Home, 4 Highfield Road, Shanklin 4 C - 6 P/00858/12 MR & Mrs R Demolition of dwelling and outbuildings; 05 Dec 12 WR WITHDRAWN 10+ Robert & A proposed detached dwelling with double 14 Feb 13 Wood garage - The Roost, Steephill Road, Ventnor st P/01361/12 Mr Dave R Retention of balcony on south elevation at 1 18 Dec 12 WR Chapman floor level – Flat, Osborne Garage, York Avenue, East Cowes P/00442/11 Mr Jennings IC Retention of garden chalet providing ancillary 28 Jan 13 WR accommodation (revised scheme) - 25 Ward Avenue, Cowes E/20396/G Mr Sanders E The material change of use of the land from 14 Jan 13 I agricultural to the siting of a horsebox/lorry in 26 June 13 conjunction with the use of the workshop for use as a separate residential unit – ‘Rodgebrook Piggeries’ north east of Rodgebrook Farm, Whitehouse Road, Porchfield P/00708/12 Mr B Johnson R Proposed dwelling – rear of 12 Portland 24 Jan 13 WR DISMISSED 20 Street, Newport 20/05/2013 APPEALS RECEIVED BETWEEN 01 Jan 13 – 31 March 13 P/00731/12 Mr P Willis R Proposed detached house to provide 24 Jan 13 WR managers accommodation – Blacksmiths Arms, Calbourne Road, Newport P/01575/12 Ms M Jones R Demolition of garage; outline for a garage - 29 Jan 13 WR Land rear of 18 Percy Road, Sandown 5 C - 7 P/00706/11 Infinergy Ltd R Land South of Wellow, East of Holmfield 01 Feb 13 INQUIRY WITHDRAWN Avenue, West of Stoneovers and off Broad CANCELLED Lane, Shalcombe, Yarmouth – Five wind turbines (100m to the tip of a rotor blade in a vertical position) provision of crane hardstandings, control buildings, substation, underground cabling, temporary construction compound, new access tracks off Broad Lane and Thorley Street (B3401) to accommodate construction traffic and a permanent 65m high anemometer mast (readvertised application - additional information received) P/01173/11 Mrs & Mrs R Demolition of tea-rooms and part of cottage; 30 Jan 13 WR Debrett outline for replacement tea-rooms with flat over, detached house and two flats; alterations to cottage; parking; alterations to vehicular access (revised scheme) (revised plans) (readvertised application) – Willow Tree Tea Gardens, High Street, Godshill P/01174/11 Mrs & Mrs R Conservation Area Consent for demolition of 30 Jan 13 WR Debrett tea-rooms and part of cottage; outline for replacement tea-rooms with flat over, detached house and two flats; alterations to cottage; parking; alterations to vehicular access(revised scheme) (revised plans) (readvertised application) – Willow Tree Tea Gardens, High Street, Godshill P/01612/12 Mr Sandell R Alterations, extension to and conversion of 08 Feb 13 WR stables to form residential unit; proposed (HAS) building to provide boarding cattery and associated facilities – Barnsley Farm, Bullen Road, Ryde 6 C - 8 P/01465/12 L Pocock ND LDC for continued use of front area of 19 March 13 WR property as driveway/parking area – 33 School Green Road, Freshwater P/01552/12 Mrs Fitzgerald R Detached double garage – Little Gatcombe 07 Feb 13 WR Farm, Gatcombe P/01733/12 Mr & Mrs RLDC LDC for proposed detached building to 21 Feb 13 WR Margey provide games room and overspill accommodation – 17 Spencer Glade, Ryde P/00934/12 Mr K Elderfield IC Alterations and conversion of former dairy to 05 March 13 WR form unit of holiday accommodation, Fairway Farm, Lower Road, Adgestone P/01186/12 Mrs J Willson R Removal of condition no.2 on 05 March 13 H TCP/18742/M/19478 limiting occupation of property to agricultural worker - Acorn Farm, 4 Horsebridge Hill, Newport P/01418/12