F ** F the Establishment of Dhammayuttika Nikaya of Vajiranana Bhikkhu

) *+,./ +10 2,+ , /0 19 4 5 6 : *

/ 0**

<%) %7(=%C,::&$-"[)([&', '(, # , 6 '- [)([ 6), $ * !-& 6+ (* #' & % )'#"6 [= : )('% : 6 # ?Q,'%% [+,'%% % Q [ :& $ ?6 6 &): ) [ [ ?[% ,'%% + )% 7(=% C% , <$Q,'%%&;)?+*&;))$)$ 6 3 :;' :& $ 6 % [+% 6 6& 6 ) :&, $Q,'%% ?7(=% C% ,+ ::& $ "* [= "# [$ ' ) : * ' % &6 $

The establishment of Dhammayuttika Nikaya of Vajiranana~ Bhikkhu: The problem of Sanghabheda

Abstract

The research finds that Vajiranana~ Bhikkhu did not declare his separation from religious ceremonies of the assembly of monks in Mahathat Temple in the same way that Devadatta Bhikkhu did from those chaired and ruled by the Lord Buddha during His lifetime. Such declaration was used as a criterion to judge whether there was an intention to cause Sanghabheda (schism). Moreover, during the

* “!" #$% & : #' )%”( ##+ ,+! $-( ! " + +& $.&+!( /0,$ , .( 2334. ** /./5$. +!( 6,. &+! , "( ( ! "## $ %&'-' $((( initial period of the Dhammayuttika Nikaya sect, monks of the Dhammayuttika Nikaya and Maha Nikaya sects were able to take part in common religious ceremonies. More restricted rules that prevented them from doing so appeared after the founder of the Dhammayuttika Nikaya sect had ascended the throne to become King Rama IV. The King explained however that members of the two sects were in a spirit of unity. It can be concluded that the establishment of the Dhammayuttika Nikaya sect by Vajiranana~ Bhikkhu did not cause disagreement among Buddhist monks, or Sanghabheda, which is considered to be an Anantariyakarma in Buddhism. )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

&)); )$ $ @ ,'%% '* )Q$ # ))] , 6 7(% &"%%-*&;))$)$8P =%C,Q,'%%?++*" A:&, <$ # -, (D6 [= "#[$ ' : ?$ )); % %7(=%C, Q,'%%* 6')"&+:&$<#$([ ([?+6(!'&%6([-* =#()*%#76"7 6%7(=%C,6)%((9% % %!*%66'&%#- (&)); )$ $ , .1/1: 1/1) () ,'%!% * #% 67(% % ([* - (& 6 &"6 =%CQ?, + 4&#'% Q$ ,'% #():6',4?*[ %+ 7(=% C% #, '$ <, [ % + &% ,'%% $6 7(=% C% , 6'%'%6)* (% %'% ?$ %'%6''% Q,'%?% ):&+ $)(% '<%&% (-, .13J: 0/1) * %-, '#?(& 6 ;6<$%)( 6)6)'$[ # $ -, * %Q6") %: Q[ + $ ( 6 4&#$ <6 $ 6 ( 6 -%%, .1.1: J.) )?& 5% % 77' -%%, .1.1: F1?) "#$ &?% $ ' 6%)(:&$ 677' 6)[% 6 7(=% C% Q, ,'%?% + + * ::&$C-6#$%,%\[(? #$,-*5"76), "# $ 7(=% C% :, "4Q, [ #?$$ 4&*%Q6# '&)[> [% ! $66):")# "& )+ )(:&% $"* [= ! -C%)<?%7(=%C, - C 6 #6 , %[=' 6 ), $ Q,'%% 6<+ -* C ' , 6Q" [= [ )' #&; &; 6%Q & '$ , /G !: "4Q, ,'%#% '%-' &; 6 [)+ & #' , /G 6+&$ %Q,'%%*A% “… ,- !- C &+ ; : :& '$ 7] ! 6&* "; 7 66<$%C%)( QQ6 " # $% & ' ( ?#$ % -', '+ % Q6 ) ' &! +* "( " '&, ”' (..0J/01//0F)

*!(6!7( .)8(897! ),)&)%:&$6 .)+ $+ /%;"$/( ( (.) # ( "< , 7 6,./6! /5 %7(=%C,Q,'%%?++* 8(/./(787=;,( ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

"[= ! )('% ::& $* # ' -% ??#[$ ' 6 :& 1 # -, )Q " 4Q, [ )$ 6 $ '')[ , # $ '% % + 6 . ;: %'%'N " + :6 % 6+)&* "[ [ -* D -, [= <"$ [= ' ( Q ,! 6)"%'+' . %''-% [& 6 '4],, .13J: /G1.) #%A9 ?+: #-", [ Q [ ), [=? ), :&$ '$ Q ' ?, )" 3 (%'% [C& %\ %%4], .11.: /) &% [=: $ /J #=6'% :&$%?" /. & * [[ “ [Q .. & * &$6&6 %5%-”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

/L. &'% *'%: “(! -.' /'/0-1.*. /J. &'%: *'% /'/*. 0-1.... (%.).T/3G1/0/L-0/J) /'/#300")440" #3)440" /'/#3 #,%[=' ,6Q )440" #300")440" “' [= [= & 6+ [) <* '$ &'$ ,6(:” ), :&$ '$ ! ' " # $% & ' ( ()' -. !!&*+"(" ' /'/0-1. * '&,'” (..0J/0L/ . $ / '/ .* 0 * /0L-/0J) . $ / 0'/ -1 * $ / '/ * 0 * $ : '; Q[$ ' '$ :Q /'/#300"0"00" ",4Q ([ )0" #30")0" $ ' + :)& * [=' * 6 [6 / #3'/ 0 )0" " #30 !Q$[ #%9A 0"0"00")0" $ /'/ ), [=? ), $ Q% #303&56 #33 [:6 $ &56 $ /'/#33 “() ' 78 9/ ' 9/ ( &56 #303&56 $ 789/' : ( ('/ ; &<-") / #30'/ )440" #3 .' ' '#< ! )440 " $ / #3)'/ 44 )' 1)-' 0" #30)440 " $ () ' "" ' * 1 ' 0 * ! " # ()' 789/' : ( $% & ' () ' &! +* "( 789/ =' : ( ( '/ > &<-") "'&,'” (.. .' ' '#< ! 0J/01//01-/0F) )' 1)-' () ' "" '=* 1 ' #[=',)$;'# 0 * C(&6 , %[=' ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

()' 789/' : ( 0! ”" (.)% .T/3G3/0/1-- 789/' ? ( ('/ @ &<-") 0/L) .' ' '#< ! )' 1)-' <$6"[=+)%)(:&$*<$" () ' "" '=* 1 ' '% !'$:%&#' &6# 0 * %A9 ), ?=? ), $ ()' 789/' ? ( ' “&, 6 =C% , "[<$$ 6 $ 789/ =' ? ( ( '/ A &<-") :&$< $ '+ : #'&$ ” .' ' '#< ! (%.).T/3GL/0/T) #[=' ,)$ )' 1)-' ;' <$"'%'$:%&# () ' "" ' = * 1 ' ' 0 * “( ! )33+ "('/! () ' 78 9/ ' ? ( 78 +"(55" ' &+-( 9/ ' ; ( ( '/ B &<-") 9/ )33+"(!-" '. ' '#< ! ' -" -( ) ' 1)- ' () ' . +* "( #" )9 #" 9 ( "" '=* 1 ' 0 * -9/ 5 .3&* ()' 789/' ; ( -( 9/ 5&! 789/' ; ( ('/ C &<-") +"(5"5'-"” (.. .' ' '#< ! 0J/0J//0J) )'1)-' () ' "" ' * "[=6(#'&%<$6 1 ' & "[=+)'$:%&#:!'&% () ' C ( D )(&< $6"[='$ :$ &#% ;6 C ( * 1 &' <$6"[=:$ '$:&#% ;6 (& &6 () ' ,'!0 # %.).T/3//-3/./0./-0.3) [=6+ 0 " 55 &0D/ " +#%9A,'''9A *6 ... ,... ,'... ,)$$%6P:$ : )... )=!00" Q)#$ &?% =#+ [() :& &4C$ 55&0D/ " () ' ?"[=:$ ("& & ' -( ' ' , .3T3: JG) )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

. [=: # 6+6)" 66 +?*C(?64'$$4)'6 QQ6#&;6%7(=%C, [%&%[% Q,'%%*"[=" [,'%%#&;6%7(=%C, #$[':+ %C5)6 Q,'%% 4'$ 4)'$ 6 =% ' '+ 7(=% C% :&, $ Q% &6+6C($',(6%&?+# ,'%?% + ([* 6(=#() () #$ ([6 &?% & $ :&:$ #)? N, :&^ $6 :&$ (* (&&( & <$'"% 7(=% C% , & 6 7(=% C% , % ^& !([+(6+:&$?6* : $ C(C&Q%,%\?(' “)33 '/ * Q'''$ %4)'('?6 $ D 3&* #" D 0 1)-< ,'%<%&% (& ' 39.-"9 () &?6 '" - ( & &^ "5"&0)3 ' 77:&] ?$ 6 % (6 : '; 0" 14 "5" ) '4'$[%[ # '/&13 ,'%#% C(& 6++&?% + &) 0)&,* &" ” * $ . ( 6 (&)); )$ $ , .1/1: /. # E .-. .3LF [ ,'%% 010) :&$* “,'%- (&”, ?4&6 % (, (), #?6 '"%%7(=%C,&?$'$ 6+:&$#%'"%[(&%! ;[ )Q& ; [=& $ : '; 5 % ' %<%&%:&$ '% : 6:&&#$ $ Q; & &; * C( C6 7(=% C% , ,-%C:& $ "88 '%'%#$ Q) ::&$ $;) "' * 5 :'* , 77 '% (% (, [],, .3LF: # ) 6 7(=% C% Q, ,'%% .0, 31) N [^ :&% ?$ 6 $ * * 6 '4'$ “'#, -?? )$ ”$ ?4&6 )(7 % % * :'% 6=?% *, #?6 :&6+ $ 6 7(=% C% , !)& * 5= + 5& Q,'%% + * "[= (6 6+:&$6=% ?Q$ ( '> =%?, .1.3: FL) 6&?% + ) 6 7(=% C% Q, ,'%% ?+*([6(=#()Q * ."$.>? 87=(."$+(7@ &;Q,'%%+*" <7 ." /$./= ( 7,( [ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

2. #.-.E .3JG [ ,'%:&% $ 5&< “” )3 = * “--” ?64& 5" -,&" ' = 0 * ...” -%% ]77,6 () #?66+:&$% (" &, .3T3: L) ,]?%7(=%C,:&$-? [ % + -%+ ' '+ + 6 -, 6 , ): :& $ ?'$ $ + $ +6 . #$ [6 *6 &4&=% &?+ [+ % '%<%&% (-%% 77] ,6 [ ], ,'%%=#[( '&;6 .3JG: .G) #E' E .-. .3J/ [ % 7(=% C% Q, ,'%% : '; :&?$ 6 '4' $ . 4& 5%4=%?, 5?$'$;)%#$; “? “$--” #?66+:&$%- '” =#[(?() : )* ?[ % + -* 6%, %\ (5%4=%?,, #$:;'!:&$%&?+* .3J/: 03-33) “ 6 ''+ 7(=% C% :&, Q$ ,'%?% + ,'%-”% #?66+:&$% %6%7(=%C,Q “--” :&$"#$,-% ,'%% "* [= "#[$ ' Q'[,'%% &%[ : + Q)(:&% )'$ (, # % (5%, .3J/: 0.) : '#; “ 67(=% C% , '% '$ )([ & % &;) 6 ,'%-”% :&$ % ()$ 7(4% Q% 7(=% C% :, :& $"[= (& 6 , : .1) &"?% 7(=% C% #, :6+ $ )+66% 6 “...30")"5&1 %7(=%C,Q,'%%:&$"#$, ,4, . , ( =([6?$#)[=#[(6 0" D ) D ( ' &); 4[C), (8 ,'%4) - &5( -/ = * '/3" 1 (+<$#7N^%+* ,,&G +"(-43 %'%4-= :&$ Q% :6+ $ 0' " 1'-" = “…'/="LMIN 0 " #D . 0D 0 ""(+ &1 ' (#.- &1) 0 * '/ 44H 1 +"() &5&#0 = D/ 9 " ' 09 " = ) *(-"J3D3= &)('/. # 93 P9/5&)0"* : & 5&0' I5G .&3 3 3D39/ *'/& <9#9"J)K '/0"' 1)" '3 9/ ) 0= * ),=0"!* -! " ' 3")0" )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+ ]

= ),&) 0 " J)LQR5&5.- P9/3-D/ 15&0 <+"(LQR5&5.< "3D!)51) -...' = * = * ' + 0'('/ &'/5&+"('5&3")44 3 -...”D/ (),&6 <4, )'/ (,% .13F: /33-/31 &' "33))+"(11'D '$D) +"('JS3 3 5&." &0= *05D/"D”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“...1 &35&!'/&56 :$6::&$Q*&;)[ +3 0"1&9= % 7(=% C% :, :& $"[=<* $88 &, >%% < '/ 0' = 5&1 ,- 3,&1* = ...”( (5&" “5&)5&= " " ( 5%;: B$) '/5&! (14, -+ "() 00 " &56+5&1' '+ *+"(LQR5&5.< #" -"5&)=5&/""( J)LQR5&5.<5&3 ! * ".=5&," ^ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

5&11&5&1 &)=5&1- 3,&-"1 D , !9 ==0"5&11' 3,&!0* 5)5&D/ ! (6 - %%, .1.1: 0D "'/'" + 5 NN P9/ T.) " 3* & )3 '/ 3,& 0! 0 3 ' #' 7(=% C% :&, &$ ); '5D/'/5&3!&#D*'/& 6&', :&$'+))%%%C5 0< 5&3 !9- &<$C-+ 6%-&-#% 4Q, &' , 4H 0' "'+"(" ?#:&$ [$ 6%'%&6Q' '$ % 0" '/ + '/ " - '/ ):& $Q* ?' % %'%#$%& 5&3!")3,&!0 <&6': H1V ! 5&3! ! “...5" " ' <5&+ "('5&3! 5&+-J)'(0 )1"31D/3D/0 0" *00"'/5&!0- 5 / 9/ -/ <&3' &0' #9 &'/ 4 * " #" )51! ) )# 0 0 " 5& " '/D/ 5& 3<5 ' ( D ( -,W ='=5&1 , &<-<-- 0" &)" -D 0" " () P9/ 5&* H1V5&3! ! - 0" -" = #0" * 0D =5&,= N" (5&- "5&" -" ! &" 9 11-+ "() 5&1 5N P9/ <* < ' <" 3...”' 14* !+"(/-4& 5&4* +"(-4 (),&6 <4,(%, .13F: 5&3 ! #5&3" 5)! 3= /31 &''D$ ) 0'K 1=1)'/& -"'1&&P9/&#9 ) 4%:&$%)("))%%%C5 3=0 " '/) &, ?7(=% C% ,&? '$ :$ $ , 3,&00! " " 0 “3&<P9/" 5)5&4 (4) (5&. '-+"() 3* &<8 D " +"('3"(<+"(--+ " =3D&<3,& 0! '/'( &D 0 " -&D/ 0 -10" 0 " H1V! )*<!#95' 0! '3 "( 01#D/ D <5. LH("=0+&- 40( " . N &* -1D/ )5" D/ *'/+13&*'/ 0 <" )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

3/-45&3!5D/+ 6 5%:&$%)(%7(=%C, D-"...” () #, C(& 6 =6 ?% , 4,% .1.J: 0J0T) “...5&P (5&. '-+"() ) 5&14, ')3- 3 D 6=%?,;%)(:$#C(&6 3D )- " 3 -) 44 ) P9/5* D/ 530( "...”9 “...) (.N-+"() ( 6 5,% .1/J: []) 3 ' )05 D/ 5&' . '-"= D/1)! 6=?% ,%)(':Q 6 7(=% C% , "0"3X5& - ?[ (& % -%+ 1) #"90 3<

%)(Q&"%?%7(=%C,# /. &); [ (?), &); [ 6)')([&%& 6 3 , '4 % + 6 7(=% C% , ?$'$ ):&$6C(#%%=C <(* &); [ (?), !))??$ “"& " " &”6 6 6(-&*&;)7( :&$ ), $ 6,77 '%$:# $=%C', % %'% *,]#$%7(=%C, Q6&;) &#6 %A9 %= :% $ [ ()6 &); [ 6 0 ( 3" 3 ,'4%*)Q-6 &;)- 3)&=0" * 5-0X'/ [ (,?) *)?&;) -) ' 3 3)& * 5-'/ &8, )P B4, &); , -% $ &5./ 0*0 = &); )$ $ 53D/ -1D/ 1 '/0 -D/ (&)); -$ &"=,, 5D 3D/ -D/ 1/ 1 '/ -D/ .1/J: 1J-1T) )6&;)[ (,?) ..." ( 5.5= 9 (, %], + 6 &% '4&% ) '9 ' ' * #@, E .-. .0F0 6<$6 6%' '! -5& (%..3//J1/ &); , -% =$ # $'+%6 .T) %-4&-6#$'+4 &;) [ (?), #$&' # #$ #?%';77'%$:$#C(&6 %6& )&+ ); [ (?), “=%C,& '$'% . &, '$ :&$Q77 “[:Q” ) '%)%''6 / &, '$'%,A /” -% : 6 '$ : ^ (%../G/.T.//31) “=C% , " &6 '$ '% . "#$:&$ "6&, '$'%)%''6 / .. &); [ ()6 + 6 7(% "6&, '$'%,A /” =%C,<*( &;)[ (6) :&$ (%../G/.T0//31) "$6)Q-6#$%7(=%C, : '; 7(=% C% ,;::& $ &) '& L & 6 7(=% C% )"C, 6 :* , <* #&$ ' # C( 6 6 &' , ( 6 _ , .1.1: .L) “'?6 ”, ! )(% $ ; * 6&) 0. &;)[ (&) &;)- Q?$#):&$*Q[%&% [ 6 1 , '4 % 7(% !% ;$'$ * ,] )? =%C<, =* C% , &); [ (&) :&$ * 7(=% C% ,+%+ [ % 66?6 $ ,]#$%7(=%C, (&;))$- 7(=% C% ,+6 & $ - &"=,, .1//: 0./) )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

3. &)(); $ ,%'- Q 6+;)Q) & # “'?6 ”, %4 *Q666?$ ?%7(=%C,&$ 7(=% C% , # $%&) * 9', ! %)('&% 6%7(=%C, 7(=% C% , C '%? Q,'%%*"[=: &;)()$,%'- : + Q"'(, # , %4 (&;))$- &"- '(, '(, %?= C% , 4 6 =,, .1/J: F0) 7(=% C% #, $ '(, "[=? ' '* Q& )(); $ ,%'4% (Model) )('% & % '(, * )(:&% )$ 7(=% C% &, )?; + 6=%C, 4 6% % $:&$6&" ,''' % % '', ' '% $ '% 7&% )(); $ ,%'4% !#':&$6=%C,!::&$?$#N^#&# : $ ?&$6+:&$:,)$#$Q ...5&3!' (5&,= " %?=%C,+N^6+ (%..L/.0J- 5&11-+ "() * X .0T/33T-31.) !)5< 5&'1 =%C,' ,)$:&$ X"(-5&5.<!&1<! 4'+% ))),1&5,'K & ,''' '% : '"'; ? ), $ :+ 0"*H.! "LM 5&3!" 6[N^#&##)8] &$[+N^&'%& " -5&)1

&',6'%'%6:Q'''$ % )&"6 '=% C% , 4 6 "#$:Q%'%%:&$Q$ 6):"[[=#& '6)6)'$ ' , ! )(#% '+ $ Q$ :& $ [ % : Q[ + "&?%7(=%C,:&$"#$[' $ )?& 5% % 77' 6 77' $ 6 )6 [ :% :& $C-#6 $ %,%\ %)('Q',("[= )+ %7(=%C,6 ?' ' &"%&',6+*6 “ '+'6+*'$: <)",4Q ) Q'?&% ); [ Q$ )' %<%& "[)<$6=)$ )=%C, 6<?[#&',;)* [” (%.). T/0JL/0G3) #' ):&$ &% ))+ &?% #)<$ &% )& ;) : 6 ' '# $ ), $ $? :+ 6& ())] , & % !' Q 4Q, ':& $,?)+ )% 6-C% F '&):; & -$ “ + ?:N$ P "#$%&*([,'%%?+(&;))$ (4&$ ? 'Q , 1 ...(4& - &",=, .1/J: LF) :,7' '+'%' -% ( 5'% 4() &- Q $ 'Q , 1 6+ 'Q , 1 6+ <#&$ %)(Q',<?6%7(=%C, <$+))” (%.). T/0JT/0G1) '(, 6' :'%%'%#$Q''? ) + “ 6,' (6 1GG %#+ + :6# $ &% #% ?+ #* $ %$ ) '#& '6 < $ ; %'% &$?$#)6+6+% 6+'Q,- "&+ #$Q''$ % Q:$ Q %'%#$Q'$ ' "[ $ =C% (, 1GG 6 :&$;:)< (-% [ 5'% 4(] , :-”6 (%.). T/0TG/0G1) .10F: 3.1) '6,'4:& ?$ N$ P : '; )()% ?'% (, #$,)$6' =%C,46 ,)$,7'#$=%C,+ "[= C% (, 1GG :6 6 N^ " 4Q, [' ( :& $ ' - ), '$ 7'#, $"[=#&6 6 &4[ '% (') 33& 5. !" 6 6 ( ?6 7(=% C% , $ Q$ 3' 4- - -1 D %)()',(6%&?+=# 5.')0 4 6 -C% ,-%C;6Q6 3 ) 5&') 5&33& :&$)"[ ): "[ ()5&5 .5 ! " & [#7=# &' , ' #)35&+ "('5&3" & , )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

"03'&&< (%.). T/ 5&.D/ 0 " ( 0T//0G1-0GF) 51 )#& =05* D 1 ' ) (6?%7(=%C,:5 5&. " -) ''/03 :&$-"['([& )# =' &0 " ','-[) =K 5& ([6,)$* (-*5D ' 1-"5&- !-& #6+ $ (* # )('% & % )5&. <"$ + )'#"6 [= : 0 (&)(); $ %7(=%C,+;::&$'&) 7(4,% .31L: .0-.3) &',&;&?& '"6? +#$ ,-%C: # &:4&$ : '; =#& ;6[& % 6)$C* )$6<#?(+ [ )"C% ! 7(=% C% ,;: % 7(=% C% ,& ,-%C6&', "[ [ + )()% ''( &+ ); (6?=%C,46$;%:&$*%6 6&', * ( 6 - %%, .1.1: J0) 7(=% C% ), ":&$ $): :& $7(=% C% :, :& '$ )([ "[([% '; &% )(Q% " [ "[# “?'”6 &6 [ % %7(=%C,:&$&;))&',6 =#& &$+%:&$:&$ %)(':6#? “?'6 ” ?' [6 )# $"['> ? Q,'%% [+,'%% &' , 6 )" [' )?[% %Q"[:&$ &6&;) #' > + ;'$"# “?'”6 ()$ 7(4% % ?& ) 6& 6+ :$ “4Q, [ ;" < $ ;'* ))(:&% $:# < &'% '% #& )(:&% $ ”% (& 6 ,: .0) % )&6 )(); $ 7(4% ':6 “#)% + ;?$ # )% '% '% <, "[?[ * ?6 '', % Q$ % ,'%% #6%7(=%C,:&$&;)) $$ & 4 ,'% Q$ #, &', 6& &&'% #[ + . N^ ;?$ ” (& 6 ,: .3) *!87=(."$+(7@<77A/.- :;' ?66&): $/= .+,$ )[[%?[ _ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

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“...?$ (+%Q*6[ "76,&# &% 6+ ! * :% # [ ,'%% Q)$ [* ##)?(&% (%-<$%)) ; (# ,'%% ;'$"B % !+"'6 (,'%-<% $%)) ( : * * ?,'%% ( '% ) ',, .1.J: /3-/1) '6(+” ("&, )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

.3T3: T-/G) &;),A$)$ ...'/'35&! ;6&"Q6[,'%% 3,&. +"(<<! &%[%:$ “...'%? <9.. P9/NN" +"('1D/0' " ,'%'%6*!))%& -"D' 0"/0"0"1& 6,- &4&'> &Q 9 + "('H440' 1&" %:#&6+*'$”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

D'0""#0"-'/' ([,'%%6Q) =""-1"-"'-"D 93 “”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“” “” &)! ) )$ , .1/1: 3L3-3L1) :&% $7(=% C% , &"6 %6) )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+ ]

)(Q% " 6 7(=% C% , ? & (Dr.Dan Beach Bradley) -([ ,'%-% % :&$ Q% :6+ $”...)8$ P A, (7(=% C% -<, $%)) $ + &"6 %Q -?, ?$ ?% 6:6 Q :#?+*:',,C6 :#' % )$ 6 ) ”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r.William L.Bradley) <$* #Q -#, 4&#$ % ' > ^ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

#$%&#-C,-' #K 9- '-3)"'/= 6',6< !&$%& ")5 11 ' 3#'/ %-'?''6?$#- '-3)"1D/'( "LM :#?( + ( 6 - %%, .1.1: TT) 7(% I) = " )5 ' $> =%C""#, $ * 7 66'<, [" 5'/ &' '/'/"P (Rational Philosophy) 4&$ 6 ? -, (& , .13L: /0/) )!+6)":,&$4&"#$ ,-* ? - #&6 "6%' %:? Q % 6 7(% :# &' &% &N% =] % 7 (Metaphysics) =%CQ', 6 -#, &6 ?$ '$ $ 6& ''= ?4 $ ! ), $ # -, &4#9 $ ":& $ = 6 % 6+ (', .133: J3) 7(% ,-6 6 )6 6+&))'': 6 =%C, 6 '* <, 6+ A( (Doctrine) '&)::& "&$ ::& $)%6&?'% ' 6 & 6 , - %66$#$,-%%'%' -:&#$ $%6+ )6 % $ 6 A6 & (:?% Q, .131: ; :6:#,-6?&])), 1L) : '; 7(=% C% ,;- ( 6 _ , .1.1: //J) ; -, ,6Q'$''6,)$':$ -'% ' 'Q + :& $ -% % &) “ ,6 )$ '% "?), $ &6 *?6)%” (&;))$)$, '$ % # ! 6 6 .1//: 0L) ' ;'% ?+ $ %66%#+6#" &% (6 * Q* 6 ?,)$'+,$ (,=( ( “6 ?, $&$:8< ,$ .10F: //J-//T) 7(=% C% , 46 - 6,?'%%68P '% ? % : '$ -'% 4 & 6 "?$ '* $ 6+ 6%' '6 ( * 6* 6 &.% 6 :% $ %&6 &% % ” (& 6 ,: 0L) ; L" M I (14, - :6+ ') “& ; :$ $ <#7$ +"() '3-/'/&J(3 :$ :$ $',) '% ” * “? /&5.'<5.- ”$ (& 6 ,: 0L) 7(=% C% ', 6 1'/)/-"3! # “ # ##)” & #6 % (<3! ! [Reverend Jesse ? :% $ Caswell]-+"() L#H &9 34 9/H,,&J) =9/'/)")' #D0"'90"' &0"&56 78&< P9/ '+"(39/ ' ' ' ! 0D/ )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

' )'11&&0"5) =3'/< < 3 ' 5&&56 ' 0 " #0" 0 " ' &5 #9 #&" )1 D/ 0"' ='15"! ='K 3&/ #D0"3!' &0' J" ) < 0=&5-"/1"0 & 0 " * ,,&H ' )0 "1 JJ3<)JJ3< 1&-3!5&55 0"5"J) JJ3< " -" 3= ! -( 0"<'/)33&5D/J ' --( & & & 9 5(5(5 JJ3 0" " 1'0= < 0" <'/)33&55&-D/ D/ = ( ' 5 ! " 55 D/)33+"(-=D/ 0" X" 3 1 JJ 0 '/ ='LH -30K/ 01)- 0(1' 3&'' & 9 " " L' KH K 1JJ&'/ 90" ='LH D/&3= &<"- &&' 9"=#91' 5&='D"D0L D 5&& & & K 0" "/"0L3D11 )K 0 4" -9 " 1'0( -" K ,. 9/ , 0= "#D0"& & "'"("'/5 &)* < * &-" 5+ 0'/ 0 " D LLQb ( ()-0= " &-)" ' " ) '/)33XP 0)9 '/ 1)0= " &-)3 & D &" )& ( 1 &44H "( " )) 4 "( 0" )P 39/ D/ M 0'/*!-1 *3! !K ) '<)33 4 -"'()- &5&3' &3&'' 5&)D/ 0 " -)" )(,! ()-0"1/9 ()- JJ)5D/5&55 '/& =9 3!(- (-- 'JJ3< JJ3<) (& 6 ,: 0L-0J &''D$ ) JJ3<'#" " &'/ " =3" ( 1V< " % ;* 6 7(% 0P"+)9'K "78 =%C,--% %)(:&$) JJ3< 3&-"+<- % ? ! 6Z- !1 19/ " =&0 =JJ3<'0P" -" ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

+5&55 D/ 14 !+"(1' +" (<#$ $,,?)6 &&% :% Q 4,0""('" &'#P9/< ! &," D " , 59 0. ; [ <% )$ 6 P9/#<3D5&55 ( :Q< , 6C(: 6 $ ? $ &;))$)$, .3F0: $'$ 6 <% !$ < &'% ? % ' : (* 0/-00 &''D$ ) [,'%%):#$ 3. ; [ % 6 %C%'% )(% ( #' & % [= )%'% 6'$-66'+6 6), :&$ '$ Q ' ?, &% [=: $ -, 6 , + 6 . , ,6'% /J &# %A9 ), [=? ?[ % )6 , N 9 (%.). T/3G1/0/L-0/J) :& $7(=% C% :, :& $6 @@ [,'%%):) '% 6 “??$ ” "+ /J 6 * [&$Q:#[<$%,%\ (%' '?, &% [= ) :& $6 7(% )',, .1.J: /F-/L) =%CQ, ,'%% :+ :& $ * "[= &, 6+ * % "#$['):*'% ?([66&% !"#$,'%%6 1 &6 $ : '; 6 7(% *6#+" =%C,[,'%%:&$%[ '&): '#'; %:6Q=#*=%C,6$)% [%:*=%C,6$)%> & Q ' $ %'% 3 )6$?$;))%! %)%,%\? /. ; [ % )6 ([ ?% + ?$ )); &% 6+ %'% &:Q<#,6 /. ; [ % )6 ?:Q5( #), &:6 %'% &''[? ,, ,]: ,'Q,, &) [,'%%:&$%Q'$' '* < $,4 ,]'%4 ?5(#$6"66[ !:6)Q% )* %'% [ ,'%% ## &'$ & &6 )(); $ ):#$&' 7(4% Q% :6+ $ “'-, .. ;[%66%'% '%%C5 %6=C?* :6 %,%\ &6 % :; Q?& # &6? )" %6+##&)$ [,'%%#$#6+"$& &'” (&)(); $ -% '[7!#6+"$& 7(4, .31L: .3) (-6 Q 6 +"'* #, [$ &)); ), )$ $ 6 ,'%'% * (<#$ %,)6 )(% Q&'?[ ,'%% )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

'"6 7 6Q% # $ 6 " 6 0"D )0"D)) [6 # # &'$ 4- ))" )) ...#"3"#9'-9 .''&")4 &03"' 4 ' 5 D/ '/5& =) * #" ' 4 ) "' D/ 5 #(""0X'& -D/ # 1D/ ' " 51 &09 #(" / 5' / '/5&- ) ! 5& 0 '/ 3* (D ' ) 5& - 1 -' 3." 0XD & S" ='"( ( (&;)()$ (" 3" '=J= %7(4, .31L: .T-0G 1# 5&)9 5&= " " ( &''D$ ) 0= D X5& ' 4 9 &#( " 0D/ )" 0" &)); ), )$ $ 6 =0-" -1" " ' . -1 " ( %)( “]7)*:6+ ) ' P-9/ " / ' D/ ; ?* $ 6Q&6 :% & $ )% "'/#D0#9'1' =*#D 6:'(#$Q'$*6'+...)'?$ & ' 3 " 1 #,77'%;6'#$8]&)?$#)+<$6 -5&&5&)5&= " #$(<$6(” (&;)- "(J4,D/.'+"= ),))$ $ , .130: 0.-00) &)); $ D/ * #0D 3" - &"=, ; 6%%)D &' (&)); ), $ "6&'?[%6$ )$ , .130: 0.-00) " &'6 ?[ 6,& &# 'Q?' 6Q&;))$- &;)()$ %7(- )$8P%-,''%- “...&$" 4&$%[%6 &'::"%Q )%'%:$ ))&&$ :& $ <&% ' 6 ? '+ $ ...&.')) % ,C":&6 )$ 1 =-0")" * ”$ (&)); -$ )8$ P )) ) -% ,''-% & )); -$ ")) &"=,, .1G1: /JF-/JL) ))4 #"3")) #%A9 ), 6 = C% , ' D/ & )) 4 )'6 ( '$)C ), ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

:#$ ?=C ' ), :$ &; $ 0. ; [ <% )$ 6 '"% “&4[,,C+ "? :Q< ![,'%%<$)6 : :* #? , 6: #” &Q*"7 )+) “=%C,:,)?+4& &;)),)$)$%)(Q =C' 4&? + '$ '%,A 7', 6+ #$ 6 )'=C&, ”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”...Q) $)6+&$ 6 " &;)),)$)$, .130: "#$:$ 6Q%#74'...” (&;) 00) ()$ 7(4,% .31L: 03) )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

&); A, )$ $ " ( #( : (&;) %)( ()$ 7(4,% ..."'==" 3D5&- .1/3: .LL) )=5&""(= 300'/[ 5&3! 3D &;)()$ %- 5. 333)05 ' - 7(4+ ; “?)$ :$ ; "* 7 -'3)= /-0 #& '# $ 6 * (:&% $ 34 ( " 5* $ ; * $ ” (& 6 ,: .T3) &)); $ #" 5c " 0 - &"=, ; 6 - "' ' 0= "- 3'/ %%)D:Q & )); -$ )8$ P *00"#95'' D/'/= %-,''%- 3)# D )# D ' #D ...D/0"5&5.( 31#D/ D &&56" ' D 3.I#! 9 0D 5, ( = 0'= 331'* 5&33+! " “3 ” D 3 -3&( (&;) 5&'/ ! () 0& A, )$ $ , .10T: F1) 33),=5< 05,( 5&5.('/1' - )+6%%)D '='D-D01'/5&- (5&)= S'!=' " 3 5&# ! 5&I " " (-+"() #&" 0 1' D 5& =0'3-' .'+" 9/ ...,&35&0 - 5&" ),3 ' &&*))' '/053" 3" ))" " (=0 5& 5 4& J15& -5! . -"5,(# (&;))$ 0 '/ -= ),( - )$8P%-- K (0=D3 #" ,''-% &)); -$ &-"=(&-D ""+ 3D &",=, .1G1?: "& . 0 -1 " /0.-/01) DK #-1D/ "D =-1+" " D 5& !&)); -$ )8$ P 5&X& 9 0D #( -% ,&'-% 6 )(% ' : , - )3 0&# ( " / * <$)6 “&,# _ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

;; < $ * ' &% 6 "; * 5&+"('5&35. " ' <$ * 6 ;6 :;6 , Q? $ () 0X5.09 " ; & ; '&' : ...” ( +"D")" D)" &6 ,: /JJ-/JT) &5./0*05D/3 )(% < )$ ?[6 # -1D/ 1 '/0 -D/ 5D D/ %9A;:,)$6,77'% 3-D/ 1/ 1 '/ -D/ ..." #$[<$)6#& '66 ( 5.5= 9 ,77 '%#<$ )$ 6 &9 # $ 6 $ ) '9 ' ' ( &# %A9 %= Q% ' , 593<9 * 77 '%%?< )$ 6 & 6+ ,W 5&+"('5&35. " ,W&G D ,W &) ( , 5&1 # 1D/ *,W ),W3) ' 5&3# ' 3 -<30DLQR +" 5&X55 33 '!+" D )" " D D " D D )" I )"1)5" 5 ' 5& 0 " $ 0' $ 0"( $ 5. 0X5&,&15&<)D 9 $ ' $ $ & 0"+" D )" " D ) " D $ 0")” (..% 3/JGG/JJ/- 536# !+"()3 JJ.) 0"1)" 5 5 ' 5&( )'/*+"("... #?% ' :&; $ Q% '%?<$ =5' 5& 0X5&- )6: 6 :$ $ “Q =C% -, : 8+ X5533 '!90"+" D )" " D ,<$ + $ + '$ '%: ' )" ")(D/5&+"(' =%C-, : 8+ <, $ + $ + 5&3" '$'%' A, =C% -, : 8+ ) 5&+"('5&3" ,<$+$ + '$'%' 6+” .#' -5& 3* " ( - (..% /G/0JL//1T) 5& " ) -/ &1" 3. ;[%6%C ! )#5&X5533'! %'%)%'%' + 6 -, 6 , + 6 . :&$ ( 5.+" &$)&;)()$ D )" " D ) " D 7(4&% &"6 : $ “...[' 5&X55 33 '!() 5&5 . " #6 * ' :+ # ) '6 " 7 &* $ + + ') ?[ ? )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

'+Q : & : $ #$ Q$ < $ 6&6+ )%)(:&$:# 6$ ?$ ; )6 $6"# $ <%&'%'#& %)(':6# &"#% ”6 (&)(); $ ?Q,'%% [+ 7(4,% .31L: 01) ,'%% % Q [ )&+ )(); $ :&$ ?6 6 &): ) [ %7(4%6[6 [%?[,'%%:&$ % ' , “?:&$ 6 ) 7(=% C% ,<$Q,'%?% + ' &% * + )Q 6 ; + ' '% ![,'%%:&$ ::& $%)Q [ 7 %+ $ ; , %&)&;))$)$ ?:&$ $”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“ $ + :&% $:& $ “?'6 ” *?6)%” ';%'+?$ ?'[6 )# $"['> ?&' , &% (6 * 7(% 6) "[# ' > ')?[% + =%C', #6 “ # ##) ” ;'$"# “?'”6 ?& ) [ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

"%;*6%7(=%C, :;' 6%7(=%C,[ -- % )(% ( # ,'%%:&$%[%:6 '&% [= 6 ), :&$ '$ Q ' ?, Q=#*=%C,6$)%Q'$ &% [=: $ /J #%A9 ), %'% 3 &, 6+ * [=? :& $7(=% C% :, :& $6'% ?([% 66& % !"# $ 6 “??$ ” "+ /J 6 '* ?, ,'%%6*6# &% [= &+),:&$ 6 7(=% C% , +"'&): ! Q,'%%+::&$*"[= ; [ :% =* C% ,6)$ % > & "#$['):*'% #')6$?$;))%! %) 1 &6 $ %,%\?([%?+ )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+ ]

-. .13J. . :, - _./Department of Religious Affair. 2005. Phrabatsomdet Phrachomklao Chaoyuhua Kap Ngan Phraphutthasatsana. Department of Religious Affair, The Ministry of Culture. ) 4 .% .1.J. - !" #$!%& (' )* +,%". ,6: "%'%./Krachang Nanthaphoti. 1985. Mahanikai-Thamma yuti Khwamkhatyaeng Phainai Khong Khana Song Thai Kap Kan Song Sep Amnat Pokkhrong Rawang Fai Anachak Lae Satsanachak. Nonthaburi: Santi Tham Press. 6 5.% .1/J. *%&(' *. : 4% './Ki Thanitson. 1975. Prawat Khana Song Thai Kap Thamma yu tika prahan. Phra Nakhon: Thamma rat Press. %' ),'. .1.J. ./(!&'(" .. 1233-1242. ,: " % % -' ./Khanuengnit Chanthabutra. 1985. Kan Khlueanwai Khong Yuwa Song Thai Run Raek A.D. 1934-1942. Bangkok: Thammasat University Press. ))'Q% &-% ,, ) .$ .1G1. :*": ' $./ . : -./Chongchitthanom% Ditsakun, Momchao. 1962. Phra Ratcha prawat Lae Phraratchaniphon Bang Rueang Nai Phrabatsomdet Phrachomklaochaoyuhua. Phra Nakhon: The Fine Arts Department. )$)$, &;). .1//. “"#$<$A%'%$#6” $ ;:%<', $ /-/T. :, 4% , % . /Chom Klao Chaoyuhua, Phrabatsomdet Phra. 1968. “ Kham Son Hai Phu Pati Bat Ru Nai Thang Thi Chop “Nai Maha Makut Rajanussorani, P. 1-19. Bangkok: Mahamakutarajavidayalaya University Press. . .1/F. ?:* @E . : 4% C%'%\./ . 1973. Cha Ruek Wat Rajapradit. Phra Nakhon: Akson Niti Press. . .1/1. *:: #@' $< : Pali Nai Rajakan Thi IV. Vol 2. Bangkok: Mahamakut Rajavidayalaya Press. . .1//. “ ” $ ;: % <', $ .T-T0. :, 4% ,A- %./ . 1968. “Phra Rattanatrai” Nai Mahamakut Rajanutsarani, PP. 29-93. Bangkok: Mahamakut Rajavidayalaya Press. ^ ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

. .1//. “&$#,-” # ;:%<, $ .G–.J. ,: 4% , % . / . 1968. “Wa Duai Kan Nai Phraphutthasatsana” Mahamakut Rajanutsarani, PP. 20-28. Bangkok: Mahamakut Rajavidayalaya Press. . .3F0. !GH . : 4% 4=( _./% . 1920. Sang khit to wat katha. Phra Nakhon: Sophon Phiphatthanakon Press. . .13J. “"- ?' & 6,)&” # : $' ./::"*::'$:Thailand. ),&6 <4, (().% .13F. :*"@J . :, " % $ C( ?' % " &" 5' 6./Charudi Phaloprakan, (Bannathikan). 2005. Thetsana Phra Raj Prawat Lae Phongsaa wadan Krungthep. Bangkok: The National Identity office, The Prime Minister’s office. ),))$ $ , &).; .130. “& 6 ”% # *: , $ T-33. ,: &%%./Chunlachomklao Chaoyuhua, Phrabatsomdet Phra. 2000. “Wat Samo Rai An Mi Nam Wa Raachathiwat” Nai Prawat Wat Raajaa thi wat wihan,: 9-44. Bangkok: Wat Raachaathiwatwihara. 7(, (,_4), &;). .10/. '. ,: 4%,%./ Yanasangwon, (Suwatthano), Somdet Phra. 1988. Satsanawong. Bangkok: Mahamakut Rajavidayalaya Press. 5%. .3J/. <–. -6: 4%%'",./ Thanitson. 1938. Man Kap Phra Songkhram Ngiap Rawang Tham Yuti-Mahanikai. Nakhon Sri Thammarat: Mitra Bamrung Press. 5%4=%?,. .3J/. '. : 4% Q=./Thaanitsaro Phikkhu. 1938. Khan Maha Satsana Wong. Phra Nakhon: Samatthaphap Press. &",=, &;))$- . .1/J. ). ,: "% % % (./Damrong Rajaanuphap, Somdet Phrachaoborommawongthoe Kromphraya. 1975. Khwam Song Cham. Bangkok: Soemwit Bannakhan Press. )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

. .3//. : G ': Mo Blat Le. Trans. by Kusuma Na Ayutthaya and Srilak Sa-nga Mueang. 2th ed. Bangkok: Matichon Press. <, C:) '% % . .13F. @E (. J . % + 6 0. :, " % !% ./Pasuk Phongpaichit and Chris Baker. 2003. Setthakit Kanmueang Thai Samai Krungthep. 3th ed. Bangkok: Silkworm Press. A, )$ $ , &); . .10T. *. ,. :, ()&&% ./Mongkut%+ Klao Chaoyuhua, Phrabatsomdet Phra. 1996. Thetsana Suea Pa. Bangkok: Bannakit trading . , % , %%. .10F. (*_Q^ HH . 6 /, 3, L, T, /G, 0J, 3G. :, 4%,%./Mahamakutrajv idayalaya Foundation. 1993. Tipitaka with Commentaries. Vol. 1, 4, 7, 9, 10, 38, 40. Bangkok: Mahamakutrajvidayalaya Press. ! "## $ %&'-' $(((

'' 4 =%?,. .131. .. X 1. :, '% ./Mettanando Phikkhu. 2002. Het Koet Phoso 1. vol. 2. Bangkok: Saeng-athit. , ). .10J. "' * "q ! " . :- 4,% (.% ,: %?./McConnell, John. 1995. Sat Lae Sin Haeng Kan Ra-ngap Khwamkhatyaeng. Phra Phaisan Wisalo, Trans. editor. Bangkok: Sem Sikkhalaya. -% ( 5'74(),% . .10F. *' . % + 6 0. :, =-C , % # Q = ./Ratchatham Nithet (Rabaep Thitayano), Phra. 1993. Prawattisat Phraphutthasatsana. 3th ed. Bangkok: Sapha Kanseuksa Mahamakutrajvidayalaya Nai Phraboromrajupatham. %'% (C&%\ %%4), . .11.. "*xz$%H. :, 4% % ) B(, % . Rat Pariyat (Sarit Sirithar), Phra. 2009. Krabuankan Kae Panha Nai Phraphutthasatsana Tam Lak Athika Ron Samatha. Bangkok: Mahachulalongkonrajvidayalaya Press. ', 4'% . “('%#&)); @$ 4& 6&6 -=% %%Q6. * ./-.., . (.133-.131): F1-TL./Langat, Robert. “Phra Rat Samana Prawat Nai Phrabatsomdet Phra Chom Klao. “Trans. By Pridi Phisaphumwithi. Journal of Silpakon University 21-22, 2 (2001-2002): 65-97. 7(4,% &)(); $ . .1/3. %&.' : 4% A, % ./ Wachirayanavarorot, Somdet Phra Maha Samana Chao Kromphraya. 1971. Kan Khana Song. Phra Nakhon: Mahamakutrajvidayalaya Press. . .1GL. * . % + 6 0. : 4% , % ./ . 1964. Phra Prawat Trat Lao. 3th ed. Phra Nakhon: Mahamakutrajavidayalay Press. . .31L. ./ . : 4% %-(%'%\. J/ . 1964. Rueang Nikai. Phra Nakhon: Phisanbananiti Press. 6 - %%. .1.1. !:}~ !' . % % 77% ( ',% =% '%-' (C-' % - ./Wanthani% Songsiri. 1982. The Reign of King Rama IV. M.A. Thesis, Department of History, Faculty of Arts, Silpakorn University. %:? Q. .131. ::)(~ . :, 4(./Wilailekha Thawonthanasan. 2002. Chon Channam Thai Kap Kan Rap Watthanatham Tawantok. Bangkok: Mueang Boran. )*+,. /& : /10 ,2 31& &4 51+

-%%]77,6 (), . .3JG. '. ,: 4%C)%7- (YYY)./ Siripanyamuni (On), Phrakhu. 1937. Maha Satsana Wong. Bangkok: Akson Charoen That (Heng Hua Hong) Press. " &. .3T3. *EH@ (*%&./ "' ./ &# . : 4% % ( % . Wat Sam Phraya’s Teacher Training Centre. 1951. Pathakathaphiset Rueang Konkai Kan Pokkhrong Khana Song Lae Rueang Sangkhaphet. Phra Nakhon: Kanphim Phanit Press. 6=?% ,. .1.3. $ !! . % + 6 .. ...: .../Sihanada Phikkhu. 1981. Phra Thammayut Nai Thatsana Khong Khaphachao. 2th ed. Non of the Printing place: Non of the printing years. ,=( ( $ . .10F. *