NEVADA HISTORICAL SOCIETY QUARTERLY Cheryl A. Young, Editor William D. Rowley, Book Review Editor EDITORIAL BOARD Jerome E. Edwards, Chairman University of Nevada, Reno Michael J. Brodhead University of Nevada, Reno Robert Davenport University of Nevada, Las Vegas Doris Dwyer Western Nevada Com/nunity College James Hulse Univel'sity of Nevada, Reno John H. Irsfeld University of Nevada, Las Vegas Candance C. Kant Clark County Community College Eugene Moehring University of Nevada, Las Vegas Guy Louis Rocha Nevada State Archives Wilbur S. Shepperson University of Nevada, Reno The Quarterly solicits contributions of scholarly or popular interest dealing with the following subjects: the general (e.g., the political, social, economic, constitutional) or the natural history of Nevada and the Great Basin; the literature, languages, anthropology, and archeaology of these areas; reprints of historic docu­ ments (concerning people, flora, fauna, historical or archaeological sites); reviews and essays concerning the historical literature of Nevada, the Great Basin, and the West. Prospective authors should send their work to The Editor, Nevada Historical Society Qumterly, 1650 N. Virginia St., Reno, Nevada 89503. Papers should be typed double-spaced and sent in duplicate. All manuscripts, whether alticles, edited documents, or essays, should conform with the most recent edition of the University of Chicago Press Manual of Style. Footnotes should be typed double-spaced on separate pages and numbered consecutively. Correspondence concerning alticles and essays is welcomed, and should be addressed to The Editor. © Copyright Nevada Historical Society, 1987. The Nevada Historical Society Quarterly (ISSN 0047-9462) is published quarterly by the Nevada Histolical Society, 1650 N. Virginia, Reno, NV 89503. The Quarterly is sent to all members of the Society. Membership dues are: Student, $5; Senior Citizen without Qua}terly, $7.50; Regular, $25; Fan1ily, $30; Sustaining, $35; Contlibuting, $50; Associate Fellow, $100; Fellow, $250; Associate Patron, $500; Corpo­ rate Patron, $1,000; Life, $2,500. Membership applications and dues should be sent to the Director, Nevada Historical Society, 1650 N. Vi"ginia, Reno, NV 89503. Second-class postage paid at Reno, Nevada. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Nevada Historical Society Qualterly, 1650 N. Virginia, Reno, Nevada 89503. NEVADA HISTORICAL SOCIETY QUARTERLY VOLUME XXX SUMMER 1987 NUMBER 2 Contents The Nevada Historical Society Quarterly: A Thirty Year Retrospective Jemme E. Edwards 81 The Mission of the State Historical Society Jeanne Elizabeth Weir 86 Early Cattle in Elko County Mrs. Edna B. Patterson 93 Idah Mechman Strobridge, First Woman of Nevada Letters Anthony Amaral 102 Historic and Prehistoric Land-Use Patterns at Reese River David Hurst ThOlnas III A Case of Mistaken Identity: William M. Stewart and the Rejection of Nevada's First Constitution David A. Johnson 118 James Mooney and Wovoka: An Ethnologist's Visit with the Ghost Dance Prophet L. C. Moses 131 The Maverick and the Cowboy Wilbur S. Shepperson 147 CUMULATIVE INDEX, VOLUME XXIX 158 THE COVER: Branding Cattle on the Dressler Ranch in Douglas County (Nevada Historical Society) The Nevada Historical Society Quarterly: A Thirty Year Retrospective JEROME E. EDWARDS THIS ISSUE OF THE Nevada Histodcal Society Quarterly marks its thirtieth anniversmy of publication. To celebrate this achievement, the Editorial Board decided on a special issue reprinting some of the best work published in the Quarterly over its lifetime. It has been this writer's pleasant task to review all the issues of the Quarterly and to select the articles included here. The Nevada Historical Society is known to a world-wide audience through the pages of the Quarterly. Circulation numbers 1,800, which includes members all over the United States, and in Europe, South America and Asia as well. Most of the counhy's leading university and public libraries are subscribers, and the Historical Society exchanges publications with a large number of other historical societies and museums. The Quarterly's articles are cross-listed and indexed in other journals. Through its pages readers can be acquainted with contemporary scholarship about Nevada and the Great Basin, learn about recent acquisitions to the state's historical repositories and examine documents from the past. In short, the Quarterly is the Historical Society's window on Nevada's heritage. The Quarterly was not the first periodical to be issued by the Nevada Historical Society. The Society, however, after its beginning in 1904, was hampered in its ambitions by a hand-to-mouth financial situation. Yet, five volumes of Papers were published from 1913 to 1926, and biennial reports were sporadically issued. These contained much quality material still of value to researchers on Nevada's historical heritage, but their publication was intermittent. In 1957, the Quarterly was established in an attempt to redress this problem and to provide for the state of Nevada a regularly published periodical with "articles of interest to readers in the social, cultural, eco­ nomic, and political history" of Nevada and of the Great Basin area. The first editor was William C. Miller of the Speech Department at the University of Nevada. In 1961, he was succeeded as editor by Mrs. Andy Welliver of the Historical Society staff. Jerry Edwards is professor of History at the University of Nevada, Reno. He is chairman of the Editorial Board of the Nevada Historical Society Qllarterly, and author of Pat McCarren, Political Boss of Nevada. 81 82 Jerome E. Edwards During its first dozen years, the Quarterly was restricted in its offerings because of the lack of widespread support from the scholarly community of Nevada. In one early issue, the editor pleaded, "we are looking for material," and the periodical published all that it could get. Overall editorial standards were lacking, so too much depended upon the calibre and qualifications of the individual contributors. At its best, the Quarterly published excellent mate­ rial, but unfortunately the journal was not always at its best. Under Miller and Welliver, the emphasis was on trail and mining history, on the reproduc­ tion of documents (many of them interesting and significant but all of which were unannotated), and on biography. Examples of the last included the writings of Effie Mona Mack on William Morris Stewart, James Nye, and Orion Clemens and Sister Margaret P. McCarran's warm appreciation of her father, Senator Pat McCarran. Other writers who contributed quality work to the Quarterly during these early years include such diverse scholars as Edna Patterson, Juanita Brooks, Anthony Amaral, Grace Dangberg, and David Myrick. With the first issue of 1970, the Quarterly significantly changed direction, and this direction has for the most part been followed to the present. Under the leadership of Wilbur Shepperson, then chairman of the Editorial Board and a member of the History Department at the University of N evada-Reno, the journal became more consistently professional and scholarly, while at the same time retaining its popular appeal. For the first time the editors of the Quarterly exercised needed supervision over submitted articles and also required that they be put through a review process. The criterion for pub­ lished articles was widened to include not only material on the history of Nevada and the Great Basin, but also its anthropology and archaeology, its literature, language, and natural histOlY. Articles of a national or western scope, but with a Nevada twist, were encouraged. The journal became less parochial with offerings by scholars who did not reside in Nevada. New sections were added, including "Notes and Documents" to reprint interesting historical documents and others informing readers of developments in the areas of manuscript collection, scholarly research, museum exhibits, and oral histOlY throughout Nevada. The Quarterly also began a book review section, and scholarly reviews were solicited nationally. The stated aim of these changes was to make the Quarterly into a vital, intellectually provocative publication, which would keep its readers abreast of the latest developments in scholarship and also keep them involved. As Professor Shepperson put it: There are now more than a half-million people in Nevada and the resources of the state-both in money and historians-are equal to a more ambitious and systematic effort. The Board of Directors and the staff are hopeful that the Quarterly can now become an important forum for sharing historical arguments and news as well as letters, items of interest, articles, and other notes relevant to Nevada history and social life. 1 A Thirty Year Retrospective 83 Subsequent to Shepperson, the Quarterly has been edited successively by Lylln Williamson, John Townley, Gmy Roberts, and since 1985, Chelyl Young. The present director of the Historical Society, Peter Bandurraga, has also been closely involved with its publication. Today, the journal still reflects the changes which were instituted in 1970. Physically, however, it has considerably improved, as a larger page size and far more readable type face were adopted in 1979. Photographs are used more imaginatively than they were in the past; and increasingly an effort has been made to utilize the vast photographic resources of the Historical Society, which are by far the largest and 1I1OSt complete in the state. In 1986, the QUaJTerly began using a slicker type of paper to enhance