DOCSLIB.ORG

Gay Panic Defense By: Kevin Drahos

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Gay Panic Defense By: Kevin Drahos Human Rights Committee - Introduced Anu Lamsal Jillian Baker Kevin Drahos Sydney Uhlman Tyler Juffernbruch Will Keck Gay Panic Defense By: Kevin Drahos Contact: Kevin Drahos | Cedar Rapids, IA | [email protected] ​ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Position Statement: The State of Iowa Youth Advisory Council supports legislation requiring the elimination of the gay and trans panic defense. ​ Position It is the position of the State of Iowa Youth Advisory Council, the voice of Iowa’s youth, that legislation pertaining to elimination of the gay and trans panic defense be enacted. Rationale The gay panic defense is an attempted legal defense, usually against charges of assault or murder. A defendant using the defense claims they acted in a state of violent temporary insanity because of unwanted same-sex sexual advances [4]. The defendant alleges to find the same-sex sexual advances so offensive and frightening that it brings on a psychotic state characterized by unusual violence. The Trans panic is a similar defense applied in cases of assault, manslaughter, or murder of a transgender individual, with whom the assailant(s) engaged in sexual relations unaware that the victim is transgender until seeing them naked, or further into or post sexual activity [6]. This defense tactic is utilized when unwanted advancements are made towards heterosexuals by members of the LGBTQ+ community; however, any justification for murdering or brutalizing a member of the LGBTQ+ community solely because of their sexuality or gender caused panic perpetuates homophobia and transphobia [5]. The most infamous example of the gay trans panic defense is the story of Matthew Shepard: beaten, tortured, and brutally murdered by two men. Being charged with murder, both of the assailant's attorneys argued that “temporary insanity by alleged sexual advances” by Sheperd prompted the murder [6]. Cases like these inspire and allow more hate crimes to happen. In Iowa, the panic defense has been used fairly recently. In 2015, Bruce Pollard walked into an Iowan Cinema X carrying a crowbar to strike a theatre manager in the head and strangle him. Pollard alleged he acted in self-defense after the manager sat “real close” to him in the movie theatre. He said he felt something on his leg and panicked, leading to his violent actions. Pollard was charged with 1st-degree murder warranting his attorneys to argue the gay panic defense [2]. While the gay and trans panic defense does not usually convince a judge or jury of a certain conviction, it still enables violence against the LGBTQ+ community as it suggests that being LGBTQ+ justifies being murdered or brutalized. In 2013, The American Bar Association introduced and unanimously approved a measure to end the gay and trans panic defense [1]. Since then, the gay panic defense has been banned within California, Rhode Island and Illinois and states such as New Jersey, Washington, and District of Columbia have made efforts to end the defense that are still pending [7]. Recommended Action The recommended action supported by SIYAC is to ban the gay and trans panic defense in the State of Iowa. This can be accomplished by the passage of a bill that includes restrictions on the defense of provocation, defense of diminished capacity, and the defense of self-defense that don’t allow for the use of gender or sexuality as a basis for determining sudden quarrel or heat of passion, reduced mental capacity, or using force against another person [3]. Regards, Human Rights Committee State of Iowa Youth Advisory Council Sources: [1] American Bar Association [2] Iowa Court of Appeals [3] UCLA Williams Institute - https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016-Model-GayTransPanic-Ban-Laws-final.pdf ​ [4] Canadian Journal of Psychology [5] The ABA Journal [6] LGBT Bar Organization [7] The United States Congress .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • FORALL12-13 Proof Read
    See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331998586 FOR ALL: The Sustainable Development Goals and LGBTI People Research · February 2019 DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.23989.73447 CITATIONS READS 0 139 2 authors: Andrew Park Lucas Ramón Mendos University of California, Los Angeles University of California, Los Angeles 17 PUBLICATIONS 6 CITATIONS 4 PUBLICATIONS 69 CITATIONS SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects: Gender Identity and Expression View project LGBTI and international development View project All content following this page was uploaded by Andrew Park on 26 March 2019. The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file. FOR ALL The Sustainable Development Goals and LGBTI People “We pledge that no one will be left behind…. [T]he Goals and targets must be met for all nations and peoples and for all segments of society.” United Nations General Assembly. The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. PREFACE This report was produced pursuant to a consultation contract (2018-05 RAP/SDGs) issued by RFSL Forbundeẗ (Org nr: 802011-9353). This report was authored by Andrew Park and Lucas Ramon Mendos. The views and interpretations expressed in this report are the authors’ and may not necessarily reflect those of RFSL. Micah Grzywnowicz, RFSL International Advocacy Advisor, contributed to the shaping, editing, and final review of this report. Winston Luhur, Research Assistant, Williams Institute at UCLA’s School of Law, contributed to research which has been integrated into this publication. Ilan Meyer, Ph.D., Williams Distinguished Senior Scholar for Public Policy, Williams Institute at UCLA’s School of Law, Elizabeth Saewyc, Director and Professor at the University of British Columbia School of Nursing, and Carmen Logie, Assistant Professor at Factor-Inwentash Faculty of Social Work, University of Toronto, provided expert guidance to the authors.
    [Show full text]
  • October 23, 2019 Good Morning Chairman Allen and Members Of
    October 23, 2019 Good morning Chairman Allen and members of the Committee on the Judiciary and Public Safety. Thank you for the opportunity to testify. My name is Sasha Buchert and I’m a Senior Attorney at Lambda Legal. I’m testifying in support of the Tony Hunter and Bella Evangelista Panic Defense Prohibition Act of 2019 and in support of the Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Panic Defense Prohibition Act of 2019. LGBTQ people, and transgender women of color in particular, move through the world under the constant threat of impending violence. In the words of one transgender woman of color in a recent New York Times article, “it’s always in the forefront of our minds, when we’re leaving home, going to work, going to school.”1 This fear is well-substantiated. At least 21 transgender people, almost all of them transgender women of color have been murdered this year already.2 Almost all of the murders involve the victims being shot multiple times, and commonly involve beatings and burnings. Two of those murders this year took place in the DC area; Zoe Spears a Black transgender woman, was found lying in the street with signs of trauma near Eastern Avenue in Fairmount Heights last June and Ashanti Carmon, also a black transgender woman was fatally shot this year in Prince George's County, Maryland.3 There has also been a troubling increase in violence targeting people based on their sexual orientation. Hate crimes have increased nationally over the last three years,4 and there were a record number of suspected hate crimes in D.C.
    [Show full text]
  • SB-2 Submitted On: 2/7/2019 9:40:07 AM Testimony for JDC on 2/12/2019 9:00:00 AM
    SB-2 Submitted on: 2/7/2019 9:40:07 AM Testimony for JDC on 2/12/2019 9:00:00 AM Testifier Present at Submitted By Organization Position Hearing Testifying for Public John Tonaki Oppose Yes Defender Comments: Office of the Public Defender State of Hawai‘i Testimony of the Office of the Public Defender, State of Hawai‘i to the Senate Committee on Judiciary February 12, 2019 S.B. No. 2: RELATING TO CRIMINAL DEFENSE Chair Rhoads, Vice Chair Wakai and Members of the Committee: The Office of the Public Defender opposes S.B. No. 2. This measure would prohibit the accused from claiming discovery, knowledge, or disclosure of a victim’s gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation resulted in extreme mental or emotional disturbance sufficient to reduce a charge of murder to a charge of manslaughter unless the other circumstances of a defendant’s explanation are already sufficient to reasonably find extreme mental or emotional disturbance. Our current manslaughter statute provides, in pertinent part, “The reasonableness of the explanation shall be determined from the viewpoint of a reasonable person in the circumstances as the defendant believed them to be. The added language is simply not necessary for fair application of the defense. A defendant asserting the affirmative defense of EMED must present a reasonable explanation for the defendant to be under the influence of extreme mental or emotional disturbance. The trier-of-fact has always should determine the reasonableness of the accused’s explanation from the viewpoint of a reasonable person in the circumstances as the accused believed them to be Moreover, this measure would create a “preferred class” of individuals to the exclusion others who might equally be aggrieved as potential victims of manslaughter.
    [Show full text]
  • The Trans Panic Defense: Masculinity, Heteronormativity, and the Murder of Transgender Women, 66 Hastings L.J
    Hastings Law Journal Volume 66 | Issue 1 Article 2 12-2014 The rT ans Panic Defense: Masculinity, Heteronormativity, and the Murder of Transgender Women Cynthia Lee Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/hastings_law_journal Recommended Citation Cynthia Lee, The Trans Panic Defense: Masculinity, Heteronormativity, and the Murder of Transgender Women, 66 Hastings L.J. 77 (2014). Available at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/hastings_law_journal/vol66/iss1/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Hastings Law Journal by an authorized editor of UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. Lee&Kwan_21 (TEIXEIRA).DOCX (Do Not Delete) 11/26/2014 2:20 PM The Trans Panic Defense: Masculinity, Heteronormativity, and the Murder of Transgender Women Cynthia Lee* and Peter Kwan** When a heterosexual man is charged with murdering a transgender woman with whom he has been sexually intimate, one defense strategy is to assert what has been called the trans panic defense. The defendant claiming this defense will say that the discovery that the victim was biologically male provoked him into a heat of passion causing him to lose self-control. If the jury finds that the defendant was actually and reasonably provoked, it can acquit him of murder and find him guilty of the lesser offense of voluntary manslaughter. The trans panic defense strategy is troubling because it appeals to stereotypes about transgender individuals as sexually deviant and abnormal. In this article, we examine the cultural structures of masculinity that may lead a man to kill a transgender woman with whom he has been sexually intimate.
    [Show full text]
  • GOP Over Anti-LGBT Platform CLEVELAND – the First Openly Gay Member of the Republican Party’S Platform Committee Said July 19 She Does Not “Plan to Leave” the GOP
    Election 2016: Democrats Ratify Most Pro-LGBT Platform Ever 3 pg. 7 Aug. 2 Primary Could Put Three More Out Candiates on Nov. Ballot Dem VEEP Pick has Strong LGBT Advocacy Record BTL Talks with 'Looking' Creator Michael Lannan KHAOS REIGNS AT HOTTER THAN JULY INTERNET SENSATION TO HOST LIVE SHOW AT PALMER PARK PICNIC pg. 20 WWW.PRIDESOURCE.COM JULY 28, 2016 | VOL. 2430 | FREE ELECTION 2016 Follow our DNC coverage online CREEP OF THE WEEK COVER 20 Khaos Reigns at HTJ, Internet Sensation to Host Live Show at Palmer Park Picnic. Photo: Jason Michale NEWS In spite of promises from 4 Study Finds LGBT Adults Experience Food Trump to “protect” LGBTQ Insecurity people, his party’s platform 6 Aug. 2 Michigan Primary Could Put Three is most anti-gay in history! Additional Out Gay Candidates On Nov. 8 Ballot Platform comparison is stark! RNC looks to reverse marriage 7 Democrats Ratify Most Pro-LGBT Platform Ever equality, DNC looks to achieve full equality 8 GOP Convention Wrap-Up See page 17 See page 12 9 Dem VEEP Tim Kaine Has Strong LGBT Record 14 Jeffrey Montgomery, LGBTQ Leader Dies at 63 20 Khaos Reigns at HTJ, Internet Sensation to Host FERNDALE COVER STORY: HTJ Live Show at Palmer Park Picnic July 30 21 HTJ Spotlight: Kai Edwards 23 Great Lakes Folk Festival Celebrates Culture, Tradition and Communit, A Conversation with Rhonda Ross Legendary Singer’s Daughter is a Star in Her Own Right OPINION 12 Parting Glances 11 Viewpoint: Dana Rudolph 11 Creep of the Week: Donald Trump LIFE Transgender Pride in the Park 25 Through the ‘Looking’ Glass Coming Up, Commemorates 28 Transgender Pride in the Park Commemorates See page 22 Compton’s Cafeteria Riots 1966 Compton Riots 30 Happenings 32 Classifieds See page 28 See Coverage page 20 – 22 33 Frivolist: 6 Tricks to Throwing the Gayest Pool Party Ever VOL.
    [Show full text]
  • February 11, 2020 the Honorable Luke Clippinger House Judiciary
    2526 SAINT PAUL STREET BALTIMORE, MD 21218 TEL (410) 625-LGBT (5428) FAX (410) 625-7423 www.freestate-justice.org C.P. Hoffman Interim Legal Director [email protected] February 11, 2020 The Honorable Luke Clippinger House Judiciary Committee House Office Building, Room 241 6 Bladen Street Annapolis, MD 21401 Testimony of FreeState Justice IN SUPPORT OF HB0488: Crimes - Mitigation - Sex, Gender Identity, or Sexual Orientation To the Honorable Chair Luke Clippinger, Vice Chair Vanessa E. Atterbeary, and esteemed members of the House Judiciary Committee: FreeState Justice is Maryland’s lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) civil rights advocacy organization. Each year, we provide free legal services to dozens, if not hundreds, of LGBTQ Marylanders who could not otherwise be able to afford an attorney. Despite significant advances in recent years, the LGBTQ community continues to be subjected to discrimination and violence at rates significantly above the state and national averages. From hazing and gaybashing to gruesome homicides, LGBTQ individuals often find themselves the targets of violence simply because of their sexual orientation or gender identity. But while the state of Maryland rightly treats these acts as hate crimes,1 criminal defendants are nonetheless able to rely on a “queer panic” defense to mitigate their offenses. The queer panic defense can take many forms, but prototypically claims that a criminal defendant’s crimes are excused or justified because “his violent actions were in response to a (homo)sexual advance.”2 In effect, the defense argues that the 1 See Crim. Law § 10-301 et seq. 2 Cynthia Lee, The Gay Panic Defense, 42 U.C.
    [Show full text]
  • Love in Action: Noting Similarities Between Lynching Then and Anti-LGBT Violence Now
    Love in Action: Noting Similarities between Lynching Then and Anti-LGBT Violence Now Koritha Mitchell Callaloo, Volume 36, Number 3, Summer 2013, pp. 688-717 (Article) Published by The Johns Hopkins University Press For additional information about this article http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/cal/summary/v036/36.3.mitchell.html Access provided by The Ohio State University (21 Sep 2013 15:03 GMT) Princeton © 2012 Koritha Mitchell (center) LOVE IN ACTION Noting Similarities between Lynching Then and Anti-LGBT Violence Now by Koritha Mitchell I use the word “love” here not merely in the personal sense but as a state of being, or a state of grace—not in the infantile American sense of being made happy but in the tough and universal sense of quest and daring and growth. —James Baldwin At my job I am the only out, visibly black woman in the college— when I remind colleagues that I am integrating the university but have no National Guard to help me do so, they are both surprised by the fact of my uniqueness and puzzled by my recourse to that history to drive home my point. Queers have long since been cautioned to stay away from the use of the moniker “civil rights” . To whose body does this history truly belong? —Sharon Holland If you are silent about your pain, they’ll kill you and say you enjoyed it. —Unknown At the 2012 CALLALOO CONFERENCE, participants examined a topic too seldom explored in intellectual spaces: love. One panel in particular demanded that I continue to wrestle with its implications.
    [Show full text]
  • Gay Panic Defense, 42 U.C
    113A AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION ADOPTED BY THE HOUSE OF DELEGATES AUGUST 12-13, 2013 RESOLUTION RESOLVED, That the American Bar Association urges federal, tribal, state, local and territorial governments to take legislative action to curtail the availability and effectiveness of the “gay panic” and “trans panic” defenses, which seek to partially or completely excuse crimes such as murder and assault on the grounds that the victim’s sexual orientation or gender identity is to blame for the defendant’s violent reaction. Such legislative action should include: (a) Requiring courts in any criminal trial or proceeding, upon the request of a party, to instruct the jury not to let bias, sympathy, prejudice, or public opinion influence its decision about the victims, witnesses, or defendants based upon sexual orientation or gender identity; and (b) Specifying that neither a non-violent sexual advance, nor the discovery of a person’s sex or gender identity, constitutes legally adequate provocation to mitigate the crime of murder to manslaughter, or to mitigate the severity of any non-capital crime. 1 113A REPORT Executive Summary Jorge Steven Lopez-Mercado, age 19, was decapitated, dismembered and burned for being openly gay, but according to the police investigator on the case, “people who live this lifestyle need to be aware that this will happen.” When Matthew Shepard, age 21, made a pass at two men in a gay bar, he should have expected to be beaten, pistol-whipped, tied to a fence, and left to die. When Emile Bernard was stabbed, beaten and blinded after coming on to a hitchhiker, his assailant claimed he could not be guilty since the victim “was asking for trouble” by making sexual advances.
    [Show full text]
  • Assembly Assembly Committee on Judiciary-4/24
    MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Eightieth Session April 24, 2019 The Committee on Judiciary was called to order by Chairman Steve Yeager at 9:06 a.m. on Wednesday, April 24, 2019, in Room 3138 of the Legislative Building, 401 South Carson Street, Carson City, Nevada. The meeting was videoconferenced to Room 4406 of the Grant Sawyer State Office Building, 555 East Washington Avenue, Las Vegas, Nevada. Copies of the minutes, including the Agenda (Exhibit A), the Attendance Roster (Exhibit B), and other substantive exhibits, are available and on file in the Research Library of the Legislative Counsel Bureau and on the Nevada Legislature's website at www.leg.state.nv.us/App/NELIS/REL/80th2019. COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: Assemblyman Steve Yeager, Chairman Assemblywoman Lesley E. Cohen, Vice Chairwoman Assemblywoman Shea Backus Assemblyman Skip Daly Assemblyman Chris Edwards Assemblyman Ozzie Fumo Assemblywoman Alexis Hansen Assemblywoman Lisa Krasner Assemblywoman Brittney Miller Assemblywoman Rochelle T. Nguyen Assemblywoman Sarah Peters Assemblyman Tom Roberts Assemblywoman Jill Tolles Assemblywoman Selena Torres Assemblyman Howard Watts COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT: None GUEST LEGISLATORS PRESENT: Senator David R. Parks, Senate District No. 7 Senator Dallas Harris, Senate District No. 11 Senator Melanie Scheible, Senate District No. 9 Minutes ID: 1011 *CM1011* Assembly Committee on Judiciary April 24, 2019 Page 2 STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Diane C. Thornton, Committee Policy Analyst Bradley A. Wilkinson, Committee Counsel Lucas Glanzmann, Committee Secretary Melissa Loomis, Committee Assistant OTHERS PRESENT: John J. Piro, Deputy Public Defender, Legislative Liaison, Clark County Public Defender's Office Kendra G. Bertschy, Deputy Public Defender, Washoe County Public Defender's Office Lisa T.
    [Show full text]
  • (Trans)Forming the Provocation Defense Morgan Tilleman
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 100 Article 8 Issue 4 Fall Fall 2010 (Trans)forming the Provocation Defense Morgan Tilleman Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Criminology Commons, and the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation Morgan Tilleman, (Trans)forming the Provocation Defense, 100 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 1659 (2010) This Comment is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. 0091-4169/10/10004-1659 THE JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL LAW & CRIMINOLOGY Vol. 100, No. 4 Copyright © 2010 by Northwestern University School of Law Printed in U.S.A. (TRANS)FORMING THE PROVOCATION DEFENSE Morgan Tilleman∗ “My family, some who are with me here tonight, always loved and supported Angie. We understood that she was born in a boy’s body but she was a woman. So many transgender people do not receive that love, acceptance and support.” —Monica Zapata1 I. GREELEY, COLORADO: JULY 17, 2009 Sometime in 2008, Angie Zapata, then eighteen, met a thirty-two-year- old man on a social networking site called Moco Space,2 and they began to chat.3 Later that year, in mid-July, she met that man, Allen Ray Andrade, in person for a date.4 A few days later, Angie’s sister, Monica Zapata, found Angie’s body in Angie’s apartment, stiff and “covered with a bloodstained blanket.”5 She had been beaten to death with fists and a fire extinguisher.6 ∗ JD Candidate, Northwestern University School of Law, 2011.
    [Show full text]
  • Gay Panic” Defense
    Touro Law Review Volume 35 Number 2 Article 9 2019 How to Get Away with Murder: the “Gay Panic” Defense Omar T. Russo Touro Law Center Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.tourolaw.edu/lawreview Part of the Civil Rights and Discrimination Commons, Constitutional Law Commons, Criminal Law Commons, Fourteenth Amendment Commons, and the Human Rights Law Commons Recommended Citation Russo, Omar T. (2019) "How to Get Away with Murder: the “Gay Panic” Defense," Touro Law Review: Vol. 35 : No. 2 , Article 9. Available at: https://digitalcommons.tourolaw.edu/lawreview/vol35/iss2/9 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Touro Law Center. It has been accepted for inclusion in Touro Law Review by an authorized editor of Digital Commons @ Touro Law Center. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Russo: Gay Panic Defense HOW TO GET AWAY WITH MURDER: THE “GAY PANIC” DEFENSE Omar T. Russo* I. INTRODUCTION In April of 2018, a jury found 69-year-old James Miller of Austin, Texas not guilty of murder for the 2015 slaying of his neighbor, Daniel Spencer.1 The jury convicted Miller of criminally negligent homicide, a crime that earned him a mere six months in jail followed by ten years of probation.2 During the night, Miller had invited Spencer, his 32-year-old neighbor, to his house where they drank and listened to music; the two were musicians.3 Miller claims that he rejected a kiss from Spencer and that Miller stabbed Spencer in a panic.4 Miller’s defense counsel argued that he acted in self-defense, in a manner known unofficially as the “gay panic defense.”5 The “gay * Juris Doctor Candidate, Touro Law Center; Bachelor of Arts, Political Science, Hartwick College, Oneonta, New York.
    [Show full text]
  • FLESH MADE REAL: the PRODUCTION, RECEPTION, and INTERPRETATION of TRANSGENDER NARRATIVES a Thesis Submitted to the Committee On
    FLESH MADE REAL: THE PRODUCTION, RECEPTION, AND INTERPRETATION OF TRANSGENDER NARRATIVES A Thesis Submitted to the Committee on Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in the Faculty of Arts and Science TRENT UNIVERSITY Peterborough, Ontario, Canada (c) Copyright by Evelyn Deshane 2013 English (Public Texts) M.A. Graduate Program September 2013 ii ABSTRACT Flesh Made Real: The Production, Reception, and Interpretation of Transgender Narratives Evelyn Deshane This thesis examines what the term "transgender narrative" represents at this particular time and location. I do this by examining various methods of transgender storytelling through different forms of media production, including autobiography, film, novels, and online platforms such as Tumblr and YouTube. In chapter one, I look at the production of novels and the value system by which they are judged ("gender capital") in transgender publics and counterpublics. In chapter two, I examine the history of the autobiography, along with the medical history closely associated with transgender identity and bodily transformation. The third chapter examines notions of violence and memorial behind the deaths of transgender people and the ways in which certain political revolutions are formed within a counterpublic. I deconstruct varying notions of identity, authorship, and cultural production and critically examine what it means to be transgender and what it means to tell stories about transgender people. I will conclude with how these stories
    [Show full text]