DOCSLIB.ORG

The Decline of the 5 Star Movement in the Italian Government (#20233)​ Author: Massimo Franco 1 Journalist, Italy

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Decline of the 5 Star Movement in the Italian Government (#20233)​ Author: Massimo Franco 1 Journalist, Italy Campaign A New Dawn in Politics! The Decline of the 5 Star Movement in the Italian Government (#20233)​ Author: Massimo Franco 1 Journalist, Italy Government Party 22/03/2019 - 09:57 | Discussion Description: The 5 Star Movement is officially in Purgatory: the triumph of 4 March 2018 seems unrepeatable and the judicial inquiries in Rome are only the corollary of this progressive disintegration. The Five Star Government Movement officially entered Purgatory: in the ambiguous space of parliamentary majorities, even numerically uncertain; voting on ministers rescued from trials thanks to the help of Giorgia Meloni and Silvio Berlusconi, described as unpresentable but welcome as a crutch; and of surveys that show how the triumph of 4 March a year ago is a mirage today unrepeatable. The judicial inquiries that also affect members of the "grillismo" in Rome are only the corollary of this progressive disintegration, and perhaps deeper than it appears. They reveal the side of a possible corruption, destabilizing for the Manichaean identity of the Movement, based on a self-perception of moral superiority. And they sharpen the contradictions, comparing the "acquittal" in the Senate of Matteo Salvini, a cumbersome Showing Page 1 out of 3 but indispensable League ally, and the expulsion-flash of the President of the Capitoline Assembly, Grillo, Vito Marcello De Vito, after his arrest. In short, two behaviors on the same day. Add to this the official defense of the Minister of Infrastructure, Danilo Toninelli, yesterday in the hall of Palazzo Madama, the purgatory picture is even clearer. To give him visibility is the striking of the League, which left the Five Stars alone at the stalls of the government, except for a fleeting final appearance of a couple of ministers. With the vaguely grotesque touch of Toninelli, who to contest the PD's request for no confidence concluded the intervention claiming the "portable plaque" that it will introduce for the happiness of motorists. Against the background of this chipped fresco, one can see the outlines of the vice premier Luigi Di Maio and the mayor of Rome, Virginia Raggi. One can see, because all the moves of these days and hours have been made to protect its profile; to separate their responsibilities from any act that casts doubt on their integrity and capacity: although the list begins to lengthen, nationally and locally, with yesterday's survey of Ray's councilor, Daniele Frongia, who has suspended himself. Palazzo Chigi and the Campidoglio appear united by a single destiny, which is that of the Movement and its "ruling" leaders. They cannot and must not fall, because otherwise the scaffolding set up by Casaleggio Associati and its representatives strategically scattered in the ganglia of the power of the 5 Star Movement would collapse. And yet, it is difficult to escape the feeling that the greater strength of the yellow-green executive has taken a descending slope difficult to ascend. It blends Di Maio's leadership crisis with the credibility not only of its miraculous proposals, but also of its ability to offer an alternative strategy to Italy. The hope of the voters to "prove the novelty" of the Five Stars, after the disappointing results of the previous governments, begins to weaken. Certainly there is no going back, but the M5S does not seem able to go much further: if not in tow of that Salvini who proposes an agenda "grillina" exclusively in the anti-system and anti-European impulses. The speed with which it tends to burn its leaders, real or in pectore, assimilates the Movement to the parties from which it wants to mark diversity. Alessandro Di Battista, after his Guatemalan sabbatical, passed from the role of electoral reserve to that of desaparecido used and set aside in a few weeks. And not everyone is ready to bet on the future of Di Maio, although it is considered among the best. But the question is whether, apart from the individual leaders, the Five Stars will have a future that is not a retreat in the old minority enclosure: in the Paradise of the opposition without responsibility. The price he is paying is obvious. It oscillates between a realpolitik made of compromises difficult to justify if not in the name of power, and the primordial instincts that combine justicialism, third worldism, palingenetic pretensions, and presumption: a toxic mixture in the face of a situation that is already complex for anyone who governs. As for the price for Italy, there is a fear that the majority is following a path opposite to the one that leads out of the crisis. It is not just the effect of a preconception, but the revenge of reality on a desire for change entrusted to a "new" ephemeral and unrealistic, exposed to the infiltration of business committees. Showing Page 2 out of 3 Time to Implement: 1 month - 6 months Impact: 50% Relevant links/articles: The Decline of the 5 Star Movement - Corriere della Sera OLD NID: 3007 Associated Users Evaluating users: User Date Overall Rating Max Nardotto 22/03/2019 - 10:17 5 Showing Page 3 out of 3.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Does the Five Star Movement Deviate from Its 'Democratic Formula'?
    Innovative Politics: Does The Five Star Movement Deviate from its ‘Democratic Formula’? Anna Grazia Napoletano S4609301 16 November 2017 Comparative Politics Master thesis Supervisor: Dr. Maurits J. Meijers Nijmegen School of Management Radboud University Nijmegen Word count. 33, 759 Table of Contents 1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………. 3 1.1 Innovative politics: from a minimalist concept of democracy to a complex one……….. 8 1.2 Innovative politics: Pirate Party, Geenpeil and the Five Star Movement……………….. 12 2.The Five Star Movement: History and organization……………………………………... 15 2.1 Italian political context:……………………………………………………………… 15 2.2 From a website to a Movement: The Five Star Movement’s embryo stage………….. 18 2.2.1 Anti-media………………………………………………………………………….. 19 2.2.2 Meetup……………………………………………………………………………… 21 2.3 From a Movement to a party…………………………………………………………. 24 2.3.1 Current structure……………………………………………………………………… 27 2.3.2 The Five Star Movement manifesto and its system of checks and balances…………. 28 2.3.3 Staff…………………………………………………………………………………… 30 2.3.4 Financing……………………………………………………………………………… 30 3. Divergence from the Five Star Movement’s Democratic Formula………………………. 31 3.1 The FiveStar Movement democratic formula: direct-participatory, transparent and deliberative………………………………………………………………….. 31 3.2 Direct and Participatory Democracy……………………………………………………. 32 3.3 Transparent Democracy…………………………………………………………………. 35 3.4 Deliberative Democracy………………………………………………………………… 35 3.5 Deviations from the Five Star Movement’s democratic formula……………………….. 36 3.6 Expectations regarding the Five Star Movement’s divergence from its “democratic formula”……………………………………………………………………………………… 38 3.6.1 The massive organization of internal democracy and “the Iron Law of Oligarchy”….… 38 3.6.2.The Lack of ideology: Delegation Vs. Representation and Taggart’s protest politics….. 41 4. Methodology……………………………………………………………………………… 46 4.1 Exploring the world of the Five Star Movement………………………………………….
    [Show full text]
  • Federico Pilati, Flavio Piccoli
    H-ermes. Journal of Communication H-ermes, J. Comm. 19 (2021), 207-232 ISSN 2284-0753, DOI 10.1285/i22840753n19p207 http://siba-ese.unisalento.it La costruzione dell’immaginario M5S attraverso i social media: qual è stato il ruolo del Direttorio? Federico Pilati, Flavio Piccoli The construction of M5S imaginary through social media: what has the role of the Directorate been? Over the last decade, the term populism has become increasingly popular. However, due to the mutability of populist movements and the diversity of the contexts in which they have developed, it has been difficult to place the different manifestations of the populist phenomenon within a single ideology. In fact, a populist narrative seems to resort to the cultural toolkit at its disposal, drawing from time to time on different components of the social and cultural environment in which it is immersed, without being crystallized in a coherent and static ideology. From this perspective, populism can therefore be traced back to the type of discourse used to frame a political event, in which the narrative component of the discourse is used strategically – or adaptively – to constitute a multifaceted and contradictory political identity to which everyone can refer even if not all the instances are shared. To investigate the hypotheses regarding the role of online communication in the construction of such populist narratives, we will analyse all the tweets produced by the three best known representatives of the Five Star Movement (Alessandro Di Battista, Luigi Di Maio and Raffaele Fico) from 2013 to 2019 by means of computational techniques. Starting from the works that have already defined the communicative style of the founder Beppe Grillo, our goal is to shift the attention to the Directorate, the plural leadership of the Five Star Movement innovative organizational structure and understand its role in the construction of the social imaginary connected to the party.
    [Show full text]
  • Morte Di Una Legislatura Mai Nata Le Elezioni E La Schizofrenia Grillina
    AGENDA DEL GIORNALISTA AGENDA DEL GIORNALISTA Nuova edizione 2018 Nuova edizione 2018 Cartacea Digitale Cartacea Digitale tel. 06-6791496 – www.cdgedizioni.it – [email protected] tel. 06-6791496 – www.cdgedizioni.it – [email protected] DL353/2003 (conv. in L 27/02/04 n. 46) art.1 comma 1 delle Libertà DCB - Roma / Tariffa ROC Poste Italiane Spa Spedizione in Abb. postale QUOTIDIANO LIbERALE PER LE gARANzIE, LE RIFORmE ED I DIRITTI CIvILI Direttore ARTURO DIACONALE Fondato nel 1847 - Anno XXIII N. 88 - Euro 0,50 Mercoledì 9 Maggio 2018 Sempre più vicini al voto Silvio Berlusconi boccia l’ultima richiesta della Lega di appoggiare dall’esterno un Governo a guida Salvini-Di Maio e così la prospettiva delle elezioni a breve diventa sempre più concreta Le elezioni e la schizofrenia grillina Indifferentemente, di qua o di là di ARTURO DIACONALE non perderà l’occasione, come ha di PAOLO PILLITTERI già fatto Alessandro Di Battista destinato a nascere morto il governo definendo “traditori della patria” o, non è una canzone di Totò questo Èche il Presidente della Repubblica si gli eventuali sostenitori del go- N“indifferentemente”. Magari si limi- accinge a varare dopo aver verificato che verno mattarelliano, di conte- tasse alle rimembranze musicalcanore del- non esiste alcuna possibilità di far partire stare la presunta neutralità l’Italia del tempo che fu. L’avverbio in la legislatura con un governo provvisto di dell’Esecutivo destinato a ballare questione è qualcosa di peggio perché ri- un’ampia maggioranza politica. In realtà il al massimo una sola estate. guarda la politica: di oggi.
    [Show full text]
  • Annales De La Faculté De Droit D'istanbul
    Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul, 68: 113–137 DOI: 10.26650/annales.2019.68.0007 http://dergipark.gov.tr/iuafdi Submitted: 07.11.2019 Revision Requested: 25.12.2019 Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul Last Revision Received: 07.01.2020 Accepted: 07.01.2020 RESEARCH ARTICLE / ARAŞTIRMA MAKALESI The ‘Executive of Change’ and the 2019 Crisis as a Touchstone for the Italian Parliamentary Form of Government Valentina Rita Scotti1 Abstract The government crisis which began on 20 August in Italy has put an end to the innovative experience of the ‘Executive of Change,’ which has challenged the traditional constitutional conventions regarding the relationship between state powers, as well as the fundamental values on which the Italian Republican Constitution grounds the legal system. The article analyses the reasons for the crisis and, moreover, the impact it has had on the role and prerogatives of the President of the Republic, the Prime Minster and the Parliament, contextualizing it in the general framework of the evolution of the Italian parliamentary form of government. Keywords Parliamentary form of government, Government crisis, Constitutional interpretation, Constitutional conventions, Fundamental constitutional values 1 Corresponding Author: Valentina Rita Scotti (Post-doctoral Research Fellow), Koç University, School of Law, Comparative Public Law, Istanbul, Turkey. Email: [email protected] ORCID: 0000-0002-2733-476X To cite this article: Scotti VR, “The Executive of Change’ and the 2019 Crisis as a Touchstone for the Italian Parliamentary Form of Government” (2019) 68 Annales de la Faculté de Droit d’Istanbul 113. https://doi.org/10.26650/annales.2019.68.0007 ©The Authors.
    [Show full text]
  • Neo-Populism: Applying Paul Taggart's Heartland to the Italian
    Neo-Populism: Applying Paul Taggart’s Heartland to the Italian Five Star Movement and League parties Amedeo Varriale Abstract: In the early 2000s the British academic and expert in the field of populism, Paul Taggart, conceptualised the heartland – which he defined as ‘a version of the past that celebrates a hypothetical, uncomplicated and non-political territory of imagination.’ The idea is that populists envision this return to an almost utopic, laborious, morally pure, and culturally homogenous ‘place’ where professional political administration is not completely rejected but certainly kept at a minimum. Applying Taggart’s heartland to leaders and parties allows us to build on an efficient comprehension of specific uses of populist dialogue, as well as their general discursive styles and political narratives. Those who have capitalised on the current populist zeitgeist (a term Cas Mudde often uses), such as the American President Donald J. Trump, have mobilised masses by implicitly calling for a return to the heartland with slogans such as ‘Make America Great Again’. However, Trump is not the only politician who has discursively framed the concept of heartland in the twenty-first century. Interestingly, the heartland can also be applied to ‘right-wing’ national- populists and ‘left-wing’ techno-populists in Italy. The League, believes that with their involvement, their country can return to be a safer, more stable, hard-working, producerist society. Similarly, the Five Star Movement pressures the elites for a more virtuous, honest, and transparent way of doing politics through the digital web and direct democracy practices. Those values are the ones that shape their idea of heartland.
    [Show full text]
  • Monthly Report on Italy
    Luiss School of Government School of European Political Economy Monthly Report on Italy in collaboration with Luiss CISE Centro Italiano Studi Elettorali N. 1 February 2019 1 of 18 Monthly Report on Italy Foreword Italian politics has always been an arcane subject. A handful of specialists and enthusiasts love to talk of its Machiavellian intricacies for hours on end, but most people, especially north of the Alps, not only do not understand it, but see no reason why they should care to understand it. Today there are at least three reasons why they should. First, in Italy the crisis of the political establishment that is now evident in many advanced democracies has begun a quarter century ago. This means that the country is further down the road of the democratic malaise – it is a laboratory and a bellwether. Second, Italy is the first country from within the historical core of the European community to be governed by anti-establishment parties. Third, its politics represents the greatest threat to the stability, or possibly even the existence, of the common European currency. Founded in 2010 in a University that has a very strong international vocation, the LUISS School of Government aims at easing the connection between Italy and the world outside it. It aims at preparing the future Italian public elite to the complexities of an ever more integrated planet, and at providing first-class education to non-Italian students in Italy’s capital city. SoG professors have often helped non-Italian journalists and newspaper readers understand Italian politics. Thus, it seems only natural to me that, also in preparation of the coming European elections, the LUISS SoG should offer a monthly report on Italy that provides an interpretation of the country’s recent political events, and makes an educated guess about what happens next.
    [Show full text]
  • PLAYING with FIRE Italy, China, and Europe
    THE NEW GEOPOLITICS MAY 2020 EUROPE PLAYING WITH FIRE Italy, China, and Europe GIOVANNA DE MAIO BROOKINGS – ROBERT BOSCH FOUNDATION TRANSATLANTIC INITIATIVE PLAYING WITH FIRE Italy, China, and Europe GIOVANNA DE MAIO EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The most significant event for Italian foreign policy in 2019 was the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with China endorsing the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which marked a break in the ranks of G-7, raising important concerns from Washington that Italy would become an entry point for Chinese influence in Europe. In reality, Chinese investment in Italy’s key industries, including energy and telecommunications, has been growing since 2013. Chinese foreign direct investment in Italy is also significantly lower than in other major European economies such as Germany and France, which have not endorsed the BRI but have secured important trade and investment deals with Beijing. Due to Italy’s difficulties in attracting investment because of high taxation and bureaucracy (among other factors), Italy’s decision to sign the MoU on the BRI is an attempt to gain advantages over its European competitors to attract Chinese investment and address longstanding economic stagnation. On top of these existing issues, the devastating economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic (a 9.1% drop in GDP for 2020 is forecast by the International Monetary Fund) risks pushing Italy further into China’s arms. There are indeed mechanisms on both national and European levels to protect against foreign investment in strategic sectors, while different views on China in the Italian political landscape have led to more decisive actions to restrict the development of a 5G wireless network through Chinese technology.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Paper
    UNDERSTANDING COORDINATED AND INAUTHENTIC LINK SHARING BEHAVIOR ON FACEBOOK IN THE RUN-UP TO 2018 GENERAL ELECTION AND 2019 EUROPEAN ELECTION IN ITALY LaRiCA - University of Urbino Carlo Bo Sep 20, 2019 Acknowledgments This study was supported in part by a grant from The Social Science Research Council within the Social Data Initiative. CrowdTangle data access has been provided by Facebook in collaboration with Social Science One. Authors Fabio Giglietto, Nicola Righetti, Giada Marino (Università di Urbino Carlo Bo) Università di Urbino Carlo Bo - LaRiCA Via Saffi 15 - 61029 - URBINO (PU) [email protected] Permanent link: https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/3jteh/ V 1.0 updated September 20, 2019 Keywords: political news, authenticity, coordinated inauthentic behavior, Facebook, CrowdTangle, elections, Italy This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, PO Box 1866, Mountain View, CA 94042, USA. Patterns of Facebook Interactions around Insular and Cross-Partisan Media Sources in the Run-up to the 2018 Italian Election | LaRiCA at UNIURB 1 Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Crazy ideas, “fake news”, coordination and authenticity on the Internet 6 2.1 A pretty crazy idea 6 2.2 Inauthentic Behavior 9 2.3 Coordinated Behavior 13 Organized networks of pages, public groups, and verified profiles 16 3.1 2018 Italian general election 16 3.2 2019 Italian election
    [Show full text]
  • The Electoral Consolidation of the Five Star Movement
    The Electoral Consolidation of the Five Star Movement Alberto Stefanelli1∗ 1Department of Political Science, Central European University, Budapest, Hungary Keywords: Populism, Five Star Movement, Italian Politics, Elections, Beppe Grillo Abstract In many European countries, the success of populist formations is transforming the party system and the traditional electoral competi- tion structure. Italy is no exception. Since the 2013 Italian general election, scholars have wondered wether the electoral successes of the Five Star Movement (FSM) marked the end of the so-called Italian Sec- ond Republic. This paper analyses the electoral performance and the transformation of the Five Star Movement on both local and national levels. First, I will briefly overview the characteristics of the FSM in relation to the main conceptual dimensions of populism. Secondly, I will examine the electoral history of the FSM from its foundation till the 2017 administrative elections round. Thirdly, I will focus on the territorial strengthening at the local level and on the geographi- cal consolidation of the FSM electoral support. Lastly, I will briefly overview the socio-demographic profile of its voters and the evolution of its electorate. ∗Alberto Stefanelli is a Master student at the Central European University, Budapest. He is specialising in research methods and voting behaviour. He is currently leading the outreach team of Team Populism. Email: [email protected] 1 1 Introduction “The mainstream media has often spoken of Pannocchia1 in the same way they speak of our movement. Do you remember? They said that we were sexist, homophobic, demagogues, pop- ulists. They do not realise that millions of people no longer read their newspapers or watch their TVs.
    [Show full text]
  • Di Maio Vuole Il Partito Dei Moderati Lontanii - Tempiin Cuiincontraval Gilet Gialli
    Quotidiano Data 14-07-2020 CORRIERE DELLA SERA Pagina 17 Foglio 1 / 2 II. PERSOSAGGIO II, M[SISTRO DEGLI ESTERI Gli anici? Ronzi più che Di Baffista Di Maio vuole il partito dei moderati Lontanii - tempiin cuiincontraval gilet gialli. « Io come De Gasperi? Un complimento» re), in una forza in grado di Lilli Gruber. «Dipende a quale Conte, Di Maio preferisce in- catalizzare l'elettorato oggi tipo di democristiano si riferi- terlocuzioni moderate, come di Tommaso Labate conteso da Berlusconi, Renzi, scono.Se mi danno del Cirino le sue ambizioni politiche del Calenda e anche dal Pd. Pomicino, sarebbe offensi- futuro prossimo.Parla di con- ROMA «Io voglio fare il partito Con Davide Casaleggio l'in- vo», rispose lui. «E se le des- tinuo con Matteo Renzi, con dei moderati», ripete all'infi- terlocuzione è azzerata; idem sero del De Gasperi?». «Non cui si è instaurato un rapporto nito da settimane, proseguen- con Di Battista, che al mini- ne sarei degno. Ma sarebbe di simpatia reciproca cemen- do in quell'opera di riposizio- stro degli Esteri torna utile co- un complimento». tato sull'accordo in vista di namento e di auto-revisioni- me spauracchio («Alessandro Ecco, l'ambizione pseudo- una legge elettorale propor- smo che lo fa assomigliare, è una risorsa, eh?») tutte le degasperiana da terzo millen- zionale. E sente spesso, per giorno dopo giorno, a poco volte che deve marcare stretto nio è quella che l'ha portato, analoghi motivi, anche Gian- meno di un lontano parente Giuseppe Conte. Forte del so- negli ultimi giorni, a mescola- ni Letta, che recentemente ne del vicepremier gialloverde stegno della stragrande mag- re nel frullatore basso profilo, avrebbe tessuto le lodi in pre- che l'anno scorso volava in gioranza dei maggiorenti del senso di mediazione, euro- senza di Silvio Berlusconi.
    [Show full text]
  • Fondation Robert Schuman / Les Forces Populistes Sont Les Grands
    GENERAL ELECTIONS IN ITALY 04th March 2018 European Populist parties ahead in the Italian Elections monitor parliamentary elections Corinne Deloy Two parties won the parliamentary elections on 4th March in Italy: the 5 Stars Movement (M5S) and the Northern League (Lega). The M5S, a populist party led by Luigi di Maio Results confirmed its place as the peninsula’s leading party. It won 32.68% of the vote, a score higher than in the previous parliamentary elections on 24th and 25th February 2013. The right coalition formed by Forza Italia (FI), the party of former President of the Council (1994-1995, 2001-2011), Silvio Berlusconi, the League (Lega), a populist, anti-European, xenophobic party led by Matteo Salvini and the Brothers of Italy (FdI), led by Giorgia Meloni – came out ahead in the parliamentary elections. Together these parties won 37% of the vote but they failed to win the absolute majority. Within this coalition the League easily drew Free and Equal (LeU), the left party against ahead of Forza Italia winning 17.37% of the Matteo Renzi founded by the outgoing leader vote. Relinquishing his regionalist demands of the Senate Pietro Grasso, won 3.39% of the Matteo Salvini undeniably won his wager of vote. making his party a National League (Italians First). Forza Italia and the League agreed that “For the first time in Europe the anti-system the party which came out ahead would lead any forces have won,” it said in the editorial of the possible government. As for Silvio Berlusconi, daily La Stampa on 5th March.
    [Show full text]
  • Monthly Report N. 7
    in collaboration with Luiss Luiss School of Luiss CISE School of Government European Centro Italiano Studi Political Economy Elettorali Mapping Italy: scenario and political risks No. 7 November 2020 Monthly Report on Italy Table of contents 1. Scenario and risks 4 1.1. Politics 4 1.2. Scenario 4 1.3. Forecasts 6 1.4. Mapping risks 6 2. Polls 8 3. Economic Scenario 10 No. 7 November 2020 2 of 13 Monthly Report on Italy Italian politics has always been an arcane subject. A handful of specialists and enthusiasts love to talk of its Machiavellian intricacies for hours on end, but most people, especially north of the Alps, not only do not understand it, but see no reason why they should bother to understand it. Today there are at least three reasons why they should. First, in Italy the crisis of the political establishment that is now evident in many advanced democracies began a quarter century ago. This means that the country is further down the road of the democratic malaise – it is a laboratory and a bellwether. Second, Italy is the first country from within the historical core of the European community to be governed by anti-establishment parties. Third, its politics represent the greatest threat to the stability, or possibly even the existence, of the common European currency. Founded in 2010 in a University that has a very strong international vocation, the Luiss School of Government aims to facilitate the connection between Italy and the world outside of it. It aims to prepare the future Italian public elite for the complexities of an ever more integrated planet, and to provide first-class education to non-Italian students in Italy’s capital city.
    [Show full text]