Electrically Heated Composite Leading Edges for Aircraft Anti-Icing Applications”

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Electrically Heated Composite Leading Edges for Aircraft Anti-Icing Applications” UNIVERSITY OF NAPLES “FEDERICO II” PhD course in Aerospace, Naval and Quality Engineering PhD Thesis in Aerospace Engineering “ELECTRICALLY HEATED COMPOSITE LEADING EDGES FOR AIRCRAFT ANTI-ICING APPLICATIONS” by Francesco De Rosa 2010 To my girlfriend Tiziana for her patience and understanding precious and rare human virtues University of Naples Federico II Department of Aerospace Engineering DIAS PhD Thesis in Aerospace Engineering Author: F. De Rosa Tutor: Prof. G.P. Russo PhD course in Aerospace, Naval and Quality Engineering XXIII PhD course in Aerospace Engineering, 2008-2010 PhD course coordinator: Prof. A. Moccia ___________________________________________________________________________ Francesco De Rosa - Electrically Heated Composite Leading Edges for Aircraft Anti-Icing Applications 2 Abstract An investigation was conducted in the Aerospace Engineering Department (DIAS) at Federico II University of Naples aiming to evaluate the feasibility and the performance of an electrically heated composite leading edge for anti-icing and de-icing applications. A 283 [mm] chord NACA0012 airfoil prototype was designed, manufactured and equipped with an High Temperature composite leading edge with embedded Ni-Cr heating element. The heating element was fed by a DC power supply unit and the average power densities supplied to the leading edge were ranging 1.0 to 30.0 [kW m-2]. The present investigation focused on thermal tests experimentally performed under fixed icing conditions with zero AOA, Mach=0.2, total temperature of -20 [°C], liquid water content LWC=0.6 [g m-3] and average mean volume droplet diameter MVD=35 [µm]. These fixed conditions represented the top icing performance of the Icing Flow Facility (IFF) available at DIAS and therefore it has represented the “sizing design case” for the tested prototype. An analytical model has been also developed both for the preliminary sizing and test guidance. Running wet and fully evaporative functional modes have been verified both analytically and experimentally with reasonable agreement. A room temperature thermal endurance test has been run for 104 cycles with max thermal load representative of 1.5 times the max temperature experienced within the leading edge in fully evaporative conditions aiming to verify the integrity of the composite laminate after the imposed thermal stress through micrographic inspection. The achieved results, despite obtained under limited icing conditions imposed by the IFF wind tunnel, showed great potentialities for the proposed Icing Protection System named EHCLE (Electrical Heated Composite Leading Edge) which has been constantly working below 60% of its maximum operative temperatures under the given icing conditions and the explored power densities. This potentiality justify the need for future development in a larger scale under more severe icing condition for a final assessment about the applicability of such Icing Protection System to real aircrafts. Key words: anti-icing, de-icing, High Temperature Composite, EHCLE, IPS ___________________________________________________________________________ Francesco De Rosa - Electrically Heated Composite Leading Edges for Aircraft Anti-Icing Applications 3 Acknowledgements I would first like to thank my Tutor and advisor Prof. G.P. Russo for his guidance. His expertise during the numerous problems encountered in this study were invaluable. I wish to thank Dr. A. Esposito for his support and availability night and day, his extensive expertise in experimental methods and techniques has been essential to the project. I also wish to thank all the other members of the team which has been working for more than two years to make this research feasible and among them a special gratitude goes to V. Caso and F. Parente for helping to solve experimental and numerical problems. This work was supported by the Department of Aerospace Engineering DIAS and therefore a special thanks goes to the DIAS Director Prof. F. Marulo which believed in the project and made the laboratory available. During the years working at the University of Naples Aerodynamics Laboratory, I had the pleasure of working with many PhD, graduate and undergraduate students. I would like to thank all of them. ___________________________________________________________________________ Francesco De Rosa - Electrically Heated Composite Leading Edges for Aircraft Anti-Icing Applications 4 Table of Contents Abstract .......................................................................................................................................3 Acknowledgements.....................................................................................................................4 Table of Contents........................................................................................................................5 List of Figures .............................................................................................................................7 List of Tables ............................................................................................................................10 Nomenclature............................................................................................................................11 1 Introduction...........................................................................................................................13 1.1 Research objectives............................................................................................................15 1.2 Review of Icing Literature .................................................................................................15 1.2.1 Droplet Classification .....................................................................................................16 1.2.2 Aircraft Icing Risks.........................................................................................................17 1.2.3 Ice Shapes .......................................................................................................................18 1.2.4 Impingement area considerations ...................................................................................19 1.2.5 Flowfield around an iced Airfoil.....................................................................................21 1.2.6 Effects of Ice-Shape Height ............................................................................................22 1.2.7 Effects of Ice-Shape Geometry.......................................................................................22 1.2.8 Reynolds Number Effects ...............................................................................................23 1.2.9 Effect of Ice Shape Location...........................................................................................23 1.2.10 Effects on High Lift and Control Surfaces ...................................................................24 1.3 Definitions..........................................................................................................................24 1.3.1 Glaze ice (Clear Ice) .......................................................................................................24 1.3.2 Rime Ice ..........................................................................................................................25 1.3.3 Mixed Ice ........................................................................................................................25 1.3.4 Hoar Frost .......................................................................................................................26 1.3.5 Ice Accretion Mechanism ...............................................................................................26 1.3.6 Double Horn Shape.........................................................................................................26 1.3.7 Ram Effect ......................................................................................................................27 1.3.8 Run Back Ice and Shear Forces ......................................................................................27 1.3.9 Sublimation.....................................................................................................................27 1.3.10 Importance of Airspeed.................................................................................................28 1.3.11 Cloud types ...................................................................................................................28 1.3.12 Liquid Water Content in Clouds (LWC) ......................................................................29 1.3.13 Ice collection efficiency EM and water interception rate MT ........................................31 1.3.14 Icing Characteristics......................................................................................................32 1.3.15 Super Cooled Drizzle Drops .........................................................................................32 1.3.16 Icing Certification .........................................................................................................33 1.3.17 Icing Severity Classification .........................................................................................35 1.3.18 Supercooled Large Droplet (SLD)................................................................................37 1.4 Review of Anti-icing and De-icing Systems .....................................................................38
Recommended publications
  • The Effects of Design, Manufacturing Processes, and Operations Management on the Assembly of Aircraft Composite Structure by Robert Mark Coleman
    The Effects of Design, Manufacturing Processes, and Operations Management on the Assembly of Aircraft Composite Structure by Robert Mark Coleman B.S. Civil Engineering Duke University, 1984 Submitted to the Sloan School of Management and the Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degrees of Master of Science in Management and Master of Science in Aeronautics and Astronautics in conjuction with the LEADERS FOR MANUFACTURING PROGRAM at the MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY June 1991 © 1991, MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Signature of Author_ .• May, 1991 Certified by Stephen C. Graves Professor of Management Science Certified by A/roJ , Paul A. Lagace Profes s Aeron icand Astronautics Accepted by Jeffrey A. Barks Associate Dean aster's and Bachelor's Programs I.. Jloan School of Management Accepted by - No U Professor Harold Y. Wachman Chairman, Department Graduate Committee Aero Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics MASSACHiUSEITS INSTITUTE OFN Fr1 1'9n.nry JUJN 12: 1991 1 UiBRARIES The Effects of Design, Manufacturing Processes, and Operations Management on the Assembly of Aircraft Composite Structure by Robert Mark Coleman Submitted to the Sloan School of Management and the Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degrees of Master of Science in Management and Master of Science in Aeronautics and Astronautics June 1991 ABSTRACT Composite materials have many characteristics well-suited for aerospace applications. Advanced graphite/epoxy composites are especially favored due to their high stiffness, strength-to-weight ratios, and resistance to fatigue and corrosion. Research emphasis to date has been on the design and fabrication of composite detail parts, with considerably less attention given to the cost and quality issues in their subsequent assembly.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Oklahoma Graduate College Design and Performance Evaluation of a Retractable Wingtip Vortex Reduction Device a Th
    UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA GRADUATE COLLEGE DESIGN AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF A RETRACTABLE WINGTIP VORTEX REDUCTION DEVICE A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE FACULTY In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Science Mechanical Engineering By Tausif Jamal Norman, OK 2019 DESIGN AND PERFORMANCE EVALUATION OF A RETRACTABLE WINGTIP VORTEX REDUCTION DEVICE A THESIS APPROVED FOR THE SCHOOL OF AEROSPACE AND MECHANICAL ENGINEERING BY THE COMMITTEE CONSISTING OF Dr. D. Keith Walters, Chair Dr. Hamidreza Shabgard Dr. Prakash Vedula ©Copyright by Tausif Jamal 2019 All Rights Reserved. ABSTRACT As an airfoil achieves lift, the pressure differential at the wingtips trigger the roll up of fluid which results in swirling wakes. This wake is characterized by the presence of strong rotating cylindrical vortices that can persist for miles. Since large aircrafts can generate strong vortices, airports require a minimum separation between two aircrafts to ensure safe take-off and landing. Recently, there have been considerable efforts to address the effects of wingtip vortices such as the categorization of expected wake turbulence for commercial aircrafts to optimize the wait times during take-off and landing. However, apart from the implementation of winglets, there has been little effort to address the issue of wingtip vortices via minimal changes to airfoil design. The primary objective of this study is to evaluate the performance of a newly proposed retractable wingtip vortex reduction device for commercial aircrafts. The proposed design consists of longitudinal slits placed in the streamwise direction near the wingtip to reduce the pressure differential between the pressure and the suction sides.
    [Show full text]
  • FAA Advisory Circular AC 91-74B
    U.S. Department Advisory of Transportation Federal Aviation Administration Circular Subject: Pilot Guide: Flight in Icing Conditions Date:10/8/15 AC No: 91-74B Initiated by: AFS-800 Change: This advisory circular (AC) contains updated and additional information for the pilots of airplanes under Title 14 of the Code of Federal Regulations (14 CFR) parts 91, 121, 125, and 135. The purpose of this AC is to provide pilots with a convenient reference guide on the principal factors related to flight in icing conditions and the location of additional information in related publications. As a result of these updates and consolidating of information, AC 91-74A, Pilot Guide: Flight in Icing Conditions, dated December 31, 2007, and AC 91-51A, Effect of Icing on Aircraft Control and Airplane Deice and Anti-Ice Systems, dated July 19, 1996, are cancelled. This AC does not authorize deviations from established company procedures or regulatory requirements. John Barbagallo Deputy Director, Flight Standards Service 10/8/15 AC 91-74B CONTENTS Paragraph Page CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION 1-1. Purpose ..............................................................................................................................1 1-2. Cancellation ......................................................................................................................1 1-3. Definitions.........................................................................................................................1 1-4. Discussion .........................................................................................................................6
    [Show full text]
  • Fly-By-Wire - Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia 11-8-20 下午5:33 Fly-By-Wire from Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    Fly-by-wire - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 11-8-20 下午5:33 Fly-by-wire From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Fly-by-wire (FBW) is a system that replaces the Fly-by-wire conventional manual flight controls of an aircraft with an electronic interface. The movements of flight controls are converted to electronic signals transmitted by wires (hence the fly-by-wire term), and flight control computers determine how to move the actuators at each control surface to provide the ordered response. The fly-by-wire system also allows automatic signals sent by the aircraft's computers to perform functions without the pilot's input, as in systems that automatically help stabilize the aircraft.[1] Contents Green colored flight control wiring of a test aircraft 1 Development 1.1 Basic operation 1.1.1 Command 1.1.2 Automatic Stability Systems 1.2 Safety and redundancy 1.3 Weight saving 1.4 History 2 Analog systems 3 Digital systems 3.1 Applications 3.2 Legislation 3.3 Redundancy 3.4 Airbus/Boeing 4 Engine digital control 5 Further developments 5.1 Fly-by-optics 5.2 Power-by-wire 5.3 Fly-by-wireless 5.4 Intelligent Flight Control System 6 See also 7 References 8 External links Development http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fly-by-wire Page 1 of 9 Fly-by-wire - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia 11-8-20 下午5:33 Mechanical and hydro-mechanical flight control systems are relatively heavy and require careful routing of flight control cables through the aircraft by systems of pulleys, cranks, tension cables and hydraulic pipes.
    [Show full text]
  • Pilots Can Minimize the Likelihood of Aircraft Roll Upset in Severe Icing
    FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION JANUARY 1996 FLIGHT SAFETY DIGEST Pilots Can Minimize the Likelihood of Roll Upset in Severe Icing FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION For Everyone Concerned Flight Safety Digest With the Safety of Flight Vol. 15 No. 1 January 1996 Officers/Staff In This Issue Stuart Matthews Chairman, President and CEO Pilots Can Minimize the Likelihood of Board of Governors Roll Upset in Severe Icing 1 Robert Reed Gray, Esq. Under unusual conditions associated with General Counsel and Secretary Board of Governors supercooled large droplets, roll upset can result from ice accretion on a sensitive area of the wing, ADMINISTRATIVE aft of the deicing boots. Pilots must be sensitive Nancy Richards to cues — visual, audible and tactile — that Executive Secretary identify severe icing conditions, and then promptly exit the icing conditions before control FINANCIAL of the airplane is degraded to a hazardous level. Brigette Adkins Accountant Approach-and-landing Accidents TECHNICAL Accounted for Majority of Commercial 10 Robert H. Vandel Director of Technical Projects Jet Hull Losses, 1959–1994 MEMBERSHIP The flight crew was the primary causal factor in the largest number of commercial jet hull-loss J. Edward Peery Director of Membership and Development accidents, according to Boeing statistics. Ahlam Wahdan Assistant to the Director of Membership and Development Report Disputes Commission’s Findings on Mt. Erebus Accident 14 PUBLICATIONS Book offers guidance on successful corporate Roger Rozelle aviation management. Director of Publications Girard Steichen Assistant Director of Publications Airbus A300 Crew Anticipates Clearance, Rick Darby Makes Unauthorized Takeoff 18 Senior Editor Helicopter strikes electrical wires, with two Karen K.
    [Show full text]
  • Aircraft Winglet Design
    DEGREE PROJECT IN VEHICLE ENGINEERING, SECOND CYCLE, 15 CREDITS STOCKHOLM, SWEDEN 2020 Aircraft Winglet Design Increasing the aerodynamic efficiency of a wing HANLIN GONGZHANG ERIC AXTELIUS KTH ROYAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING SCIENCES 1 Abstract Aerodynamic drag can be decreased with respect to a wing’s geometry, and wingtip devices, so called winglets, play a vital role in wing design. The focus has been laid on studying the lift and drag forces generated by merging various winglet designs with a constrained aircraft wing. By using computational fluid dynamic (CFD) simulations alongside wind tunnel testing of scaled down 3D-printed models, one can evaluate such forces and determine each respective winglet’s contribution to the total lift and drag forces of the wing. At last, the efficiency of the wing was furtherly determined by evaluating its lift-to-drag ratios with the obtained lift and drag forces. The result from this study showed that the overall efficiency of the wing varied depending on the winglet design, with some designs noticeable more efficient than others according to the CFD-simulations. The shark fin-alike winglet was overall the most efficient design, followed shortly by the famous blended design found in many mid-sized airliners. The worst performing designs were surprisingly the fenced and spiroid designs, which had efficiencies on par with the wing without winglet. 2 Content Abstract 2 Introduction 4 Background 4 1.2 Purpose and structure of the thesis 4 1.3 Literature review 4 Method 9 2.1 Modelling
    [Show full text]
  • Glider Handbook, Chapter 2: Components and Systems
    Chapter 2 Components and Systems Introduction Although gliders come in an array of shapes and sizes, the basic design features of most gliders are fundamentally the same. All gliders conform to the aerodynamic principles that make flight possible. When air flows over the wings of a glider, the wings produce a force called lift that allows the aircraft to stay aloft. Glider wings are designed to produce maximum lift with minimum drag. 2-1 Glider Design With each generation of new materials and development and improvements in aerodynamics, the performance of gliders The earlier gliders were made mainly of wood with metal has increased. One measure of performance is glide ratio. A fastenings, stays, and control cables. Subsequent designs glide ratio of 30:1 means that in smooth air a glider can travel led to a fuselage made of fabric-covered steel tubing forward 30 feet while only losing 1 foot of altitude. Glide glued to wood and fabric wings for lightness and strength. ratio is discussed further in Chapter 5, Glider Performance. New materials, such as carbon fiber, fiberglass, glass reinforced plastic (GRP), and Kevlar® are now being used Due to the critical role that aerodynamic efficiency plays in to developed stronger and lighter gliders. Modern gliders the performance of a glider, gliders often have aerodynamic are usually designed by computer-aided software to increase features seldom found in other aircraft. The wings of a modern performance. The first glider to use fiberglass extensively racing glider have a specially designed low-drag laminar flow was the Akaflieg Stuttgart FS-24 Phönix, which first flew airfoil.
    [Show full text]
  • February 2002 Alerts
    February 2002 FAA AC 43-16A CONTENTS AIRPLANES AERONCA ................................................................................................................................. 1 BEECH ........................................................................................................................................ 2 CESSNA ..................................................................................................................................... 6 EXTRA........................................................................................................................................ 9 MAULE..................................................................................................................................... 10 PIPER........................................................................................................................................ 10 SOCATA .................................................................................................................................. 13 HELICOPTERS BELL ......................................................................................................................................... 14 EUROCOPTER ......................................................................................................................... 14 MCDONNELL DOUGLAS ...................................................................................................... 15 AMATEUR, EXPERIMENTAL, AND SPORT AIRCRAFT AVID FLYER ...........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • For Improved Airplane Performance
    BLENDED WINGLETS FORFOR IMPROVEDIMPROVED AIRPLANEAIRPLANE PERFORMANCEPERFORMANCE New blended winglets on the Boeing Business Jet and the 737-800 commercial airplane offer operational benefits to customers. Besides giving the airplanes a distinctive appear- ance, the winglets create more efficient flight characteristics in cruise and during takeoff and climbout, which translate into additional range with the same fuel and payload. ROBERT FAYE ROBERT LAPRETE MICHAEL WINTER TECHNICAL DIRECTOR ASSOCIATE TECHNICAL FELLOW PRINCIPAL ENGINEER BOEING BUSINESS JETS AERODYNAMICS TECHNOLOGY STATIC AEROELASTIC LOADS BOEING COMMERCIAL AIRPLANES BOEING COMMERCIAL AIRPLANES BOEING COMMERCIAL AIRPLANES TECHNOLOGY/PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT AERO 16 vertical height of the lifting system (i.e., increasing the length of the TE that sheds the vortices). The winglets increase the spread of the vortices along the TE, creating more lift at the wingtips (figs. 2 and 3). The result is a reduction in induced drag (fig. 4). The maximum benefit of the induced drag reduction depends on the spanwise lift distribution on the wing. Theoretically, for a planar wing, induced drag is opti- mized with an elliptical lift distribution that minimizes the change in vorticity along the span. For the same amount of structural material, nonplanar wingtip 737-800 TECHNICAL CHARACTERISTICS devices can achieve a similar induced drag benefit as a planar span increase; however, new Boeing airplane designs Passengers focus on minimizing induced drag with 3-class configuration Not applicable The 737-800 commercial airplane wingspan influenced by additional 2-class configuration 162 is one of four 737s introduced BBJ TECHNICAL CHARACTERISTICS The Boeing Business Jet design benefits. 1-class configuration 189 in the late 1990s for short- to (BBJ) was launched in 1996 On derivative airplanes, performance Cargo 1,555 ft3 (44 m3) medium-range commercial air- Passengers Not applicable as a joint venture between can be improved by using wingtip Boeing and General Electric.
    [Show full text]
  • A “Short Course” on Ice and the TBM
    A “Short Course” on Ice and the TBM. Icing is topical at the present time as a result of a recent accident in a TBM. I have had a number of conversations with pilots who I would consider knowledgeable and it is apparent that there is a lot of confusion surrounding this subject. Also noting on line posts this confusion is not limited to owner pilots. I have had occasion to be a victim of my own stupidity in a serious icing condition years ago and I can vouch that icing is a deadly serious situation in more ways than one. Before going on with the subject we want to stipulate that the data we are about to provide is a summary of information that is to be found on line, along with narrative and data provided from knowledgeable instructors, if any of the data provided conflicts with anything you have been taught we urge you to satisfy yourself as to which data is correct. TBM operators fly in the same airspace where we find Part 25 aircraft (Commercial Category) aircraft. There is a big difference in how these two categories of aircraft are affected by icing conditions. A 767 will often be climbing at over 300 kts and 4000+ ft/min at typical icing altitudes. This creates two very distinct advantages for the 767: first, their icing exposure time may be less than 1/3 of ours. Second, icing conditions are a function of TAT (Total Air Temperature), not SAT (static air temp). TAT is warmer than SAT because of the effects of compressibility as the airplane operates at faster and faster speeds.
    [Show full text]
  • Weight Optimization of Empennage of Light Weight Aircraft
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 3, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2014 ISSN 2277-8616 Weight Optimization Of Empennage Of Light Weight Aircraft Sheikh Naunehal Ahamed, Jadav Vijaya Kumar, Parimi Sravani Abstract: The objective of the research is to optimize the empennage of a light weight aircraft such as Zenith aircraft. The case is specified by a unique set of geometry, materials, and strength-to-weight factors. The anticipated loads associated with the empennage structure are based on previous light aircraft design loads. These loads are applied on the model to analyze the structural behavior considering the materials having high strength-to-weight ratio. The 3D modeling of the empennage is designed using PRO-E tools and FEA analysis especially the structural analysis was done using ANSYS software to validate the empennage model. The analysis shall reveal the behavior of the structure under applied load conditions for both the optimized structure and existing model. The results obtained using the software are attempted to validate by hand calculations using various weight estimation methods. Index Terms: Empennage, Zenith STOL CH 750 light sport utility airplane, Aircraft structures and materials, PRO-E, ANSYS, Composite materials, Weight estimation methods. ———————————————————— 1 INTRODUCTION compromise in strength and stiffness is called optimal The use of composite materials in the primary structure of structure. Hence, growth factor, which is relationship between aircraft is becoming more common, the industry demand for total weight and the payload, should be as low as possible. predicting and minimizing the product and maintenance cost is Materials with a high strength to weight ratio can be used to rising.
    [Show full text]
  • Airplane Icing
    Federal Aviation Administration Airplane Icing Accidents That Shaped Our Safety Regulations Presented to: AE598 UW Aerospace Engineering Colloquium By: Don Stimson, Federal Aviation Administration Topics Icing Basics Certification Requirements Ice Protection Systems Some Icing Generalizations Notable Accidents/Resulting Safety Actions Readings – For More Information AE598 UW Aerospace Engineering Colloquium Federal Aviation 2 March 10, 2014 Administration Icing Basics How does icing occur? Cold object (airplane surface) Supercooled water drops Water drops in a liquid state below the freezing point Most often in stratiform and cumuliform clouds The airplane surface provides a place for the supercooled water drops to crystalize and form ice AE598 UW Aerospace Engineering Colloquium Federal Aviation 3 March 10, 2014 Administration Icing Basics Important Parameters Atmosphere Liquid Water Content and Size of Cloud Drop Size and Distribution Temperature Airplane Collection Efficiency Speed/Configuration/Temperature AE598 UW Aerospace Engineering Colloquium Federal Aviation 4 March 10, 2014 Administration Icing Basics Cloud Characteristics Liquid water content is generally a function of temperature and drop size The colder the cloud, the more ice crystals predominate rather than supercooled water Highest water content near 0º C; below -40º C there is negligible water content Larger drops tend to precipitate out, so liquid water content tends to be greater at smaller drop sizes The average liquid water content decreases with horizontal
    [Show full text]