A Comparison of Adult Butterfly Communities on Remnant and Planted Prairies in Northeast Iowa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
268 268 JOURNAL OF THE LEPIDOPTERISTS ’ S OCIETY Journal of the Lepidopterists’ Society 73(4), 2019, 268 –274 A COMPARISON OF ADULT BUTTERFLY COMMUNITIES ON REMNANT AND PLANTED PRAIRIES IN NORTHEAST IOWA EMMA K. S TIVERS , J ACOB T. W ITTMAN AND KIRK J. L ARSEN Department of Biology, Luther College, 700 College Drive, Decorah, IA 52101 Corresponding author E-mail: [email protected] ABSTRACT. Adult butterfly abundance and diversity was compared in four remnant and four planted tallgrass prairies in North - east Iowa. Butterfly surveys were conducted at approximately three week intervals over the summer of 2015. Researchers used a modified “Pollard Walk” technique following a meandering transect, and butterfly sightings recorded using the Unified Butterfly Recorder (UBR) Android app. If a butterfly was observed nectaring on a flower, the species of flower was recorded. Floral resource availability, plant species richness and percent cover were measured in each prairie. Although planted prairies contained signifi - cantly greater floral resources than remnant prairies, there was no significant difference in floral plant species richness between remnants and plantings. Remnant and planted prairies did not differ in butterfly abundance, but remnant prairies had significantly greater butterfly species richness than planted prairies. These results provide valuable information on the current status of butterflies in each prairie type in northeast Iowa, and can be used in directing future land management and conservation work. Additional key words: tallgrass prairie, unified butterfly recorder The tallgrass prairie is one of North America’s most To slow species loss and conserve native habitats endangered landscapes. Over 80% of Iowa was covered such as tallgrass prairies, conservation biologists have by tallgrass prairie pre-European settlement, but now restored natural areas through habitat reconstruction less than 0.01% of its original tallgrass prairie remains (Shepherd & Debinski 2005). Habitat reconstruction (Smith 1998). The few small fragments of remnant repairs damaged plant communities as opposed to prairie are often miles from each other (Ries & restoring faltering animal communities, but the effects Debinsky 2001) isolated among predominantly of this plant-based approach are beneficial in that they agricultural landscapes. Fragmentation of these prairies often support the rehabilitation of animal communities has reduced species abundance and diversity, (Debinski & Babbit 1997). Prairie plantings containing particularly for populations of specialist plants and appropriate host plants are particularly important as animals native to prairies (Collinge et al. 2003; Panzer potential habitat for imperiled butterfly populations, 2002). Some prairie specialist organisms, such as such as Species of Greatest Conservation Need smaller species of insects, are often unable to move (SGCN), as prairie remnants are usually too small or freely among these isolated prairie fragments and are too far apart to support some butterfly species (Iowa often extirpated while these remaining fragments DNR 2012, Smith & Cherry 2014). become dominated by generalist and invasive species It is often difficult to tell if planted prairies are (Ries & Debinski 2001). functionally similar to remnant prairies in terms of their Prairie specialist insects provide many important ability to provide suitable habitat for butterflies. One ecosystem services vital to the overall health and way to determine the quality of a planted prairie is to productivity of prairie ecosystems, such as pollination, analyze the plant and butterfly community of the and serving as food for birds and small mammals that prairie relative to the community composition in share their habitat (Powers & Larsen 2014). Without remnant prairies. Butterfly surveys are of critical the services these insects provide, the prairie could lose importance when documenting butterfly community flowering plant species from lack of pollination and lose profiles, and can suggest the quality of a prairie based more of its native fauna from lack of food, disrupting on the proportion of specialist to generalist species the ecosystem. Specialist butterfly populations have present. The goal of this study was to compare butterfly been negatively affected by habitat loss (Swengel et al. abundance and species richness of eight tallgrass 2011), and many species have been extirpated from prairies in Northeast Iowa to determine if planted their historic range (Larsen and Bovee 2001). Some prairies are similar to remnant prairies in their butterfly species, such as the regal fritillary, Speyeria idalia community composition and abundance. (Drury), have not been observed in Winneshiek County in Northeast Iowa since 1994 (Larsen, personal MATERIALS AND METHODS observation), although they have been observed in Tallgrass Prairie Sites. Eight tallgrass prairies in Howard County as recently as 2007 and Floyd County Winneshiek County or Howard County, Iowa were as recently as 2017 (www.insectsofiowa.org). surveyed in this study, including four remnant prairies VOLUME 73, N UMBER 4 269 and four planted prairies (Table 1). Planted prairies to butterflies per kilometer due to the different lengths ranged in age from 8 to 25 years old and varied in size, of the survey transect in each prairie. the plant species seeded, quality, management history, Plant Surveys. During butterfly surveys all and level of human disruption. Remnant prairies also flowering plant species in bloom observed along each varied in size, management history, and level of human butterfly survey transect were recorded at each site, disruption. and over the five survey dates the cumulative species Butterfly Surveys. Butterfly surveys were list was used to conservatively estimate plant species conducted at each prairie site approximately every richness for each prairie. We used floral percent cover three weeks throughout the summer of 2015 when to estimate floral resource (i.e. nectar) availability in conditions were appropriate for maximum butterfly each prairie. During each sampling period, the surface activity: between 1000 and 1600h CDT, winds less than area of all floral blooms in ten random 1 × 0.5 meter 20 km/h, temperatures of 20 –30°C, and cloud cover quadrats along each survey transect was determined. less than 90%. A modified Pollard walk technique was Each 0.5 m 2 quadrat was delineated by a 1 × 0.5 m PVC used walking at a slow steady pace following a frame with reference marks at 10 cm intervals, and a meandering transect established within each site digital photograph taken of the quadrat from (Pollard 1977). Butterfly survey transects ranged from approximately 1 m above the canopy of each quadrat 435 to 2500 m in length (Table 1) and crossed and flowers blooming in the quadrat recorded. Each representative burned or unburned remnant or planted photograph was then analyzed using ImageJ software areas within each site. All butterflies observed within (Rasband 2015) to estimate the surface area (cm 2) of 10 m of the observers were recorded (Pollard 1977) flower heads for each species of flower in bloom in using the Unified Butterfly Recorder (UBR) Android each quadrat. Floral surface area (cm 2/m 2) was app (http://www.reimangardens.com/collections%20/ converted to floral percent cover as a proxy of nectar insects/unified-butterfly-recorder-app/). Each butterfly resource availability of each species of flower, and floral observed was counted only once with reasonable percent cover averaged over the course of the summer confidence. Photographs of butterflies were taken for each prairie. Every species of blooming forb at the regularly to aid in identification. Butterflies not site was documented, regardless of whether or not it identified in flight were netted for closer examination was represented in a quadrat image. and released in the field if possible. Butterflies unable Using Iowa Coefficient of Conservatism (CoC) to be identified in the field were collected and values (Drobney et al. 2001) for each species of flower identified in the lab. Identifications were made observed blooming at each site, a Floristic Quality primarily using Schlicht et al. (2007). Voucher Assessment (FQA) was performed, generating a specimens from this survey are housed in the Research Floristic Quality Index (FQI) for that site (Swink & Insect Collection in the Hoslett Museum of Natural Wilhelm 1994). The FQI is a measure of the quality of History, Department of Biology, Luther College, habitat present at a site, with higher values Decorah, Iowa. Butterfly abundance was standardized corresponding to higher habitat quality. TABLE 1. Prairie status, location, size, management agency, and butterfly survey transect length of each of the four remnant and four planted tallgrass prairies surveyed during the summer of 2015. Area Transect Latitude Longitude (acres) Land Manager/Owner Length (m) Remnant Prairies Chipera 43° 7.89 'N 92° 0.49 'W 81 Winneshiek County Conservation Board 2500 Crossman 43° 24.48 'N 92° 28.49 'W 11 Iowa Nature Conservancy 925 Hayden 43° 26.51 'N 92° 23.02 'W 240 Iowa Department of Natural Resources 1440 Ludwig 43° 11.64 'N 92° 58.74 'W 2.6 Winneshiek County Conservation Board 435 Planted Prairies Anderson 43° 18.90 'N 92° 47.95 'W 27 Luther College 980 Decorah Community 43° 18.09 'N 92° 48.15 'W 39 Decorah Parks and Recreation 1445 Gateway 43° 19.07 'N 92° 48.74 'W 38.6 Luther College 1625 Plymouth Rock 43° 26.26 'N 92° 0.35 'W 33.8 private landowner