The Style of Sinan's Domed Structures

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Style of Sinan's Domed Structures DOGAN KUBAN THE STYLE OF SINAN'S DOMED STRUCTURES Nations dissent in their taste no less in architecture than in jood and clothing. Fischer von Erlach Among the great domed buildings of the world must be the art historian. But what the documents do not pro­ included a group of Ottoman mosques dating from vide, the imagination and intelligence must fill in, and between the sixteenth and the eighteenth century, this leads unavoidably to considerable subjectivity. Ob­ whose classical physiognomies have all ultimately to be viously the paucity of documentation limits the possibi­ credited to a single man, Koca Sinan, the chief archi­ lities for accurate interpretation. tect of the Ottoman Empire for half a century (1538- The little information we do have at least tells us 88). Although Sinan's life and a number of his something about the nature of the culture in which this buildings have been written about many times, 1 regret­ architecture was produced. It was a culture in wh ich tably no adequate comprehensive presentation of his the physical world served only as a stepping stone to the architecture is available in any language. 2 Such being other, true, world. Man served God and the Sultan. It the case, one can hardly be surprised that his work was his duty to abide by the commandments of his remains largely unappreciated and that his style, faith, and he was interested in this world only insofar although synonymous with the classical age of Ottoman as it pertained to the next. He does not describe it and architecture, is almost totally ignored in general his­ never attempts to theorize about it, because everything tories of art. works according to a divine order he cannot know. This The main facts of Sinan's life are known, and most absence of an independent objectivity regarding the of his buildings have survived. Important information world led to a basic pragmatism toward every aspect of about building practices in his time can be found in the life, including art and architecture. This gives us a clue account books of the imperial buildings he created. 3 for understanding Sinan's style. But all these make Sinan a documented legend, not an To study Sinan, our methodology must be essentially individual. We have poetry that glorifies his art, but no archaeological and our analysis descriptive; comparing real description of the man hirnself. Nothing substan­ Sinan's work to other domed styles can also lead to tial remains to tell us about his ideas or the opinions his some constructive insights. Formal analysis will con­ contemporaries held of his work. Descriptions com­ stitute the core of my discussion. That does not mean parable to the anonymous passage on the Cathedral at that historicalor cultural content has been relegated to Edessa,4 or that of Procopius on Hagia Sophia,5 or of the second rank, but only that it is less in need of fur­ Serlio on church plans6 are totally lacking for Sinan's ther elucidation. What we are seeking to make is a masterpieces. Without any contemporary reference to statement about the place Sinan and the Ottomans can the ideas of his time, we are forced to fall back on the claim in the general history of architecture. 7 buildings themselves and on what we know generally about the society in which their creator lived. When Isidore of Miletus and Anthemius of Tralles No less severe a drawback is the total lack for his decided to cover the central nave of J ustinian' s basilica buildings of original drawings and models. A history of at Constantinople with a dome that could form a the Selimiye comparable to Geymüller's of St. Peter's suitable cover for stately processions, the Near Eastern cannot be written. Even drawings comparable to symbolism that derived from the dome's early mythol­ Villard de Honnecourt's would be a great blessing for ogy was still current. 8 But by the sixteenth century, THE STYLE OF SINAN'S DOMED STRUCTURES 73 when Ottoman architecture used it, that symbolism ingly minor additions and variations, together with the had been lost, replaced by a millennium of uninter­ changes in the form and structure they incur, are of rupted experience with domed structures that had led great stylistic importance. They also have theoretical to the use of the dome as a roof form for even the implications. They came about as a result of complex smallest spaces. The Ottoman is the only architectural and culturally significant developments in the Islamic style in wh ich the semi-spherical dome constituted the world, where the dome and the minaret became sym­ only form of roofing. This simplicity of basic form was bols of Islam. As a result, Islamic architecture devel­ compensated by the development of very elaborate oped a wide range of variations both in shape and in dome-covered spatial structures. Art historians are so structural and functional use. Examples of variations used to seeing domes, in both the East and West, are the single-shell dome-on-squinch of Central Asian associated with ancient symbolism and dressed in tombs, the multiple rows of small domes over the magnificent exterior forms that they pay little attention parallel bays of Indian mosques, domes only enhancing to the peculiar architectural vocabulary elaborated in the mihrab bay, and double-shell domes, with or with­ Turkey. It is easy for a superficial observer to look at out drums, in the great mausolea of the Seljugs, Hagia Sophia and decide that Turkish domes are sim­ Timurids, and Mamluks. ple imitations ofit. To counteract that hasty generaliza­ In Christian architecture the symbolic associations of tion we have first to remember the style-generating role the dome played an important role in its adoption as a of the semi-spherical dome. roof form for religious buildings. But its cultural sym­ Domical forms or domes built in all-natural mate­ bolism eventually turned into a formal symbolism that rials have been in use for millennia in all climates, with resulted in domes becoming buildings in themselves. or without symbolic association. The nomad te nt and Thus, although apparently minimal when reduced to the round hut may claim to have originated the domical schematic drawings, the conceptual differences shape, but here I am not concerned with the origin of between the great Ottoman mosques, on the one hand, the form; rather I am talking about the use of a and Hagia Sophia or Santa Maria in Carignano in developed brick dome within a structural and spatial Genoa, on the other, are immense. They not only concept. Until the advent of the industrial age, brick express different views of the world, but stylistically domes were the most convenient and dependable large­ they represent opposite ends of the spectrum. space covers for monumental structures. The difference The insistence on keeping the structural form of the between the way the Ottomans used the dome and dome intact from both inside and outside led to the other styles lies first in the Ottomans' use of domes as development of so me distinctive characteristics. If the sole element for roofing, and second in their western Gothic in its classical period of the twelfth and emphasis on structural design. In the Islamic, the thirteenth centuries can be characterized as a style Byzantine, and the Western architectural traditions, exploring the structural and spatial potentialities of the domes were used in combination with other roofing cross-vaulted bay, then Ottoman Turkish architecture systems, such as vaults in various forms or flat ceilings. can be characterized as a style exhausting the In a church interior, a barrel-vaulted nave is visually as possibilities of the simple spherical dome. To reduce a important as the dome-covered crossing. In a hypostyle style to a single motif is amistake, but to explain the Arabic mosque, the wooden ceilings of the aisles are as impact of a consistently used form in the conceptual important to the sratial perception of the interior as is development of a style is necessary. What the classical the dome over the mihrab bay. Structures with hetero­ orders are to Greek, Roman, and European architec­ geneous roof forms have spatial qualities that are very tu re generally, the domed baldachin is to the Turkish. different from those where the roof system consists The place of the Ottoman style so weIl represented entirely of domes. by Sinan's buildings in the universal history of art is Modifications in the shape of the dome itself were still unclear, essentially because historians insist on also characteristic of the style. The use of the drum using the criteria of Western art history even when the modifies the direct perception of the dome from the so-called non -Western arts are being dealt with. 9 interior, and raising it over the supporting mass, gives Although significant progress has been made in break­ it a particular emphasis on the exterior. The use of the ing down this conceptual deadlock by Western art double-shell dome further dissociates the dome from its historians themselves,lO the non-Western artistic tradi­ simple structural and geometrical purity. These seem- tion still remains little known, and consequently the .
Recommended publications
  • Door/Window Sensor DMWD1
    Always Connected. Always Covered. Door/Window Sensor DMWD1 User Manual Preface As this is the full User Manual, a working knowledge of Z-Wave automation terminology and concepts will be assumed. If you are a basic user, please visit www.domeha.com for instructions. This manual will provide in-depth technical information about the Door/Window Sensor, especially in regards to its compli- ance to the Z-Wave standard (such as compatible Command Classes, Associa- tion Group capabilities, special features, and other information) that will help you maximize the utility of this product in your system. Door/Window Sensor Advanced User Manual Page 2 Preface Table of Contents Preface ................................................................................................................................. 2 Description & Features ..................................................................................................... 4 Specifications ..................................................................................................................... 5 Physical Characteristics ................................................................................................... 6 Inclusion & Exclusion ........................................................................................................ 7 Factory Reset & Misc. Functions ..................................................................................... 8 Physical Installation .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Sasanian Tradition in ʽabbāsid Art: Squinch Fragmentation As The
    The Sasanian Tradition in ʽAbbāsid Art: squinch fragmentation as The structural origin of the muqarnas La tradición sasánida en el arte ʿabbāssí: la fragmentación de la trompa de esquina como origen estructural de la decoración de muqarnas A tradição sassânida na arte abássida: a fragmentação do arco de canto como origem estrutural da decoração das Muqarnas Alicia CARRILLO1 Abstract: Islamic architecture presents a three-dimensional decoration system known as muqarnas. An original system created in the Near East between the second/eighth and the fourth/tenth centuries due to the fragmentation of the squinche, but it was in the fourth/eleventh century when it turned into a basic element, not only all along the Islamic territory but also in the Islamic vocabulary. However, the origin and shape of muqarnas has not been thoroughly considered by Historiography. This research tries to prove the importance of Sasanian Art in the aesthetics creation of muqarnas. Keywords: Islamic architecture – Tripartite squinches – Muqarnas –Sasanian – Middle Ages – ʽAbbāsid Caliphate. Resumen: La arquitectura islámica presenta un mecanismo de decoración tridimensional conocido como decoración de muqarnas. Un sistema novedoso creado en el Próximo Oriente entre los siglos II/VIII y IV/X a partir de la fragmentación de la trompa de esquina, y que en el siglo XI se extendió por toda la geografía del Islam para formar parte del vocabulario del arte islámico. A pesar de su importancia y amplio desarrollo, la historiografía no se ha detenido especialmente en el origen formal de la decoración de muqarnas y por ello, este estudio pone de manifiesto la influencia del arte sasánida en su concepción estética durante el Califato ʿabbāssí.
    [Show full text]
  • The Making of Seljuk Patterns on Curved Surfaces
    Bridges Finland Conference Proceedings Geometric Patterns as Material Things: The Making of Seljuk Patterns on Curved Surfaces Begüm Hamzaoğlu* Architectural Design Computing Program, Istanbul Technical University Taşkışla, Taksim, Istanbul, 34437, Turkey E-mail: [email protected] Mine Özkar Department of Architecture, Istanbul Technical University Taşkışla, Taksim, Istanbul, 34437, Turkey Email: [email protected] Abstract There is very little information today on the historical techniques that medieval craftsmen used to apply the intricate geometric patterns on architectural surfaces. This paper focuses on the particular problem of applying geometric patterns on curved stone surfaces and explores possible technical application scenarios for a select group of 13th century Anatolian patterns. We illustrate hypothetical processes of how to apply three patterns on three different types of curved surfaces and discuss the relation between the surface geometry and the tools. Our main motivation is to shed light on how the geometric construction of the designs and the making of these patterns correlate. Introduction Geometric patterns consisting of polygons, stars and lines were used as ornaments on monumental building façades in medieval Anatolia, also known as the Seljuk period. The style was widely common throughout the larger region at the time. The question of how these intricate designs were constructed geometrically has drawn the attention of many interdisciplinary studies [1][2][3][4]. However, only a few of these studies focus on how abstract patterns were transformed into the material things that they are whether carved into stone, tiled in brick or ceramic, or arranged in wood using special crafting techniques [5]. Materials, tools and all other components of the making process such as the craftsman’s hand movements are all factors in the formation of the shapes.
    [Show full text]
  • Islamic Domes of Crossed-Arches: Origin, Geometry and Structural Behavior
    Islamic domes of crossed-arches: Origin, geometry and structural behavior P. Fuentes and S. Huerta Polytechnic University of Madrid, Spain ABSTRACT: Crossed-arch domes are one of the earliest types of ribbed vaults. In them the ribs are intertwined forming polygons. The earliest known vaults of this type are found in the Great Mosque of Córdoba in Spain built in the mid 10th century, though the type appeared later in places as far as Armenia or Persia. This has generated a debate on their possible origin; a historical outline is given and the different hypotheses are discussed. Geometry is a fundamental part and the different patterns are examined. Though geometry has been thoroughly studied in Hispanic-Muslim decoration, the geometry of domes has very rarely been considered. The geometrical patterns in plan will be examined and afterwards, the geometric problems of passing from the plan to the three-dimensional space will be considered. Finally, a discussion about the possible structural behaviour of these domes is sketched. Crossed-arch domes are a singular type of ribbed vaults. Their characteristic feature is that the ribs that form the vault are intertwined, forming polygons or stars, leaving an empty space in the centre. The fact that the earliest known vaults of this type are found in the Great Mosque of Córdoba, built in the mid 10th century, has generated a debate on their possible origin. The thesis that appears to have most support is that of the eastern origin. This article describes the different hypothesis, to then proceed with a discussion of the geometry.
    [Show full text]
  • Dome Construction
    DOME CONSTRUCTION For further information on dome construction Application of Domes: Blue mosque, XVIth century – Istanbul, Turkey Please contact: ( Æ 23.50 m, 43 m high) n Plain masonry built with blocks or bricks n Floors for multi-storey buildings, they can be leveled flat n Roofs, they can be left like that and they will be waterproofed UNITED NATIONS CENTRE n Earthquakes zones, they can be used with a reinforced ringbeam FOR HUMAN SETTLEMENTS They are Built Free Spanning: (UNCHS - HABITAT) n It means that they are built without form n This way is also called the Nubian technique PO Box 30030, Nairobi, KENYA Timber Saving: Phone: (254-2) 621234 n Domes are built with bricks and blocks (rarely with stones) Fax: (254-2) 624265 Variety of Plans and Shapes: E-mail: [email protected] Treasure of Atreus – Tomb of Agamemnon (Æ +/- 18m) n Domes can be built on round, square, rectangular rooms, etc. Mycene, Greece (+/- 1500 BC) n They allow a wider variety of shapes than vaults AUROVILLE BUILDING CENTRE Stability Study: (AVBC / EARTH UNIT) n The shape of a dome is crucial for stability, and a stability study is Office, often needed. Be careful, a wrong shape will collapse Auroshilpam, Auroville - 605 101 Dhyanalingam Temple – Coimbatore, India Auroville, India elliptical section ( Æ 22.16 m, 9.85 m high) (3.63 m side, Need of Skilled Masons: Tamil Nadu, INDIA 0.60 m rise) n Building a dome requires trained masons. Never improvise when Phone: +91 (0)413-622277 / 622168 building domes, ask advice from skilled people Fax: +91 (0)413-622057
    [Show full text]
  • Unique Properties of the Geodesic Dome High
    Printing: This poster is 48” wide by 36” Unique Properties of the Geodesic Dome high. It’s designed to be printed on a large-format printer. Verlaunte Hawkins, Timothy Szeltner || Michael Gallagher Washkewicz College of Engineering, Cleveland State University Customizing the Content: 1 Abstract 3 Benefits 4 Drawbacks The placeholders in this poster are • Among structures, domes carry the distinction of • Consider the dome in comparison to a rectangular • Domes are unable to be partitioned effectively containing a maximum amount of volume with the structure of equal height: into rooms, and the surface of the dome may be formatted for you. Type in the minimum amount of material required. Geodesic covered in windows, limiting privacy placeholders to add text, or click domes are a twentieth century development, in • Geodesic domes are exceedingly strong when which the members of the thin shell forming the considering both vertical and wind load • Numerous seams across the surface of the dome an icon to add a table, chart, dome are equilateral triangles. • 25% greater vertical load capacity present the problem of water and wind leakage; SmartArt graphic, picture or • 34% greater shear load capacity dampness within the dome cannot be removed • This union of the sphere and the triangle produces without some difficulty multimedia file. numerous benefits with regards to strength, • Domes are characterized by their “frequency”, the durability, efficiency, and sustainability of the number of struts between pentagonal sections • Acoustic properties of the dome reflect and To add or remove bullet points structure. However, the original desire for • Increasing the frequency of the dome closer amplify sound inside, further undermining privacy from text, click the Bullets button widespread residential, commercial, and industrial approximates a sphere use was hindered by other practical and aesthetic • Zoning laws may prevent construction in certain on the Home tab.
    [Show full text]
  • The Emotive Power of an Evolving Symbol: the Idea of the Dome from Kurgan Graves to the Florentine Tempio Israelitico
    Ori Z. Soltes, Georgetown University The Emotive Power of an Evolving Symbol: The Idea of the Dome from Kurgan Graves to the Florentine Tempio Israelitico Preliminaries: Complementarity and Contradiction It is a truism within the history of art and architecture that a given visual form may symbolize more than one idea simultaneously - even ideas that contradict each other, although there is usually a logic to the apparent contradiction. Thus in abstract Islamic art, for example, the relationship between God and humanity might be symbolized by a monumental structure - such as a domed building or the mihrab form on a prayer rug - overrun with minutely detailed decoration. In that case, the decoration, in being minute, symbolizes humanity, while its monumental framework symbolizes God. But simultaneously, the framework, in being, as a frame, finitizing, symbolizes humanity, while the infinitizing pattern truncated by the frame symbolizes the God who is infinite. Thus ‘monumental’ versus ‘minute’ and ‘infinite’ versus ‘finite’ are visually presented in an interwoven array of apparent contradictions that nonetheless offer a logic to their interweave. For God is by definition utterly other than humanity, yet, according to the Muslim - and Jewish and Christian - tradition, God breathes the soul into us that makes us more than a clod of earth (Bible) or a bloodclot (Qur’an), which means that, in some sense, we are like God. And therefore in some sense God must be like us. So the simultaneous similitude and absolute alterity of that relationship is effectively conveyed by the relationship among these abstract visual elements. We may see this art historical principle well articulated by the dome form.
    [Show full text]
  • Arh 362: Islamic Art
    ARH 362: ISLAMIC ART CLUSTER REQUIREMENT: 4C, THE NATURE OF GLOBAL SOCIETY COURSE DESCRIPTION This course surveys the art and architecture of the Islamic world from the 7th through the 20th centuries. By looking at major themes and regional variations of Islamic art and architecture, the course examines how meanings in various socio-political and historical contexts have been encoded through forms, functions, as well as the aesthetic features of arts, crafts, and the built environment. The last portion of the course, spanning the 19th to the late 20th centuries, examines the West’s discovery of the Islamic arts as well as the integration of Western ideas into indigenous ones. This course can only briefly address some of the major themes. The topics (especially those pertinent to the modern period) are introduced through a number of key readings, but they should be merely seen as introductions, providing possible directions for future and more advanced studies. Discussions and questions are always encouraged. The readings, which have been selected to supplement the required textbooks, are particularly chosen to serve this purpose. COURSE-SPECIFIC OUTCOMES Gain valuable information about Islamic art and design as well as the cultures that gave shape to them Read critically and interpret and evaluate art historical issues in relation to socio-political conditions in non-Western contexts Develop a foundation for writing good critical essays about non-Western art and material culture Research non-Western art in a museum context Comparative studies of Western and Non-Western styles in a variety of media, including 2D and 3D art and design as well as architecture.
    [Show full text]
  • Brooklyn Park Sports Dome COVID-19 Policies
    Updated 3/10/2021 Brooklyn Park Sports Dome COVID-19 Policies Capacity & Time Usage • As of now, with current Minnesota Department of Health (MDH) guidelines we can accommodate 125 participants at one time in the dome. The following will be how each area of the dome is assigned for maximum participation: ▪ Playing Field = Less than or equal to 100 participants ▪ Batting Cages = Less than or equal to 5 participants per cage ▪ Walking Track = Less than or equal to 10 participants per hour o If your Playing Field group is in need to exceed 100 participants (not to exceed 125), please contact Mike Ramirez ([email protected]) to discuss accommodations. • Players and parents are not allowed to congregate in the dome lobby, as it is a small, confined space. Parents should wait in their vehicle or outside the facility. Tables and chairs will be removed. • Parents are responsible to drop off and pick up their players at the required time. Players dropped off early or staying late will have to wait outside. • The official clock for dome use time is located on the east wall of the dome on the support building above the office window. • It is required that entering groups remain outside the facilities until the exiting group is outside and more than six feet away. This will limit the number of people crossing paths during the entering and exiting process. • Please be cognizant of your time while participating. Your participants should be completely cleared of the field and out of the dome prior to your scheduled end time.
    [Show full text]
  • The Influence of the Arch
    The Influence of the Arch The Influence of the Arch by ReadWorks The lasting influence of ancient Rome is apparent in many areas of our contemporary society. Sophisticated elements of law, engineering, literature, philosophy, architecture, and art can all be traced back to the Roman Empire. But perhaps one of the most lasting contributions from Roman civilization is something we see nearly every day: the Roman arch. An arch is a curved structure designed to support or strengthen a building. Arches are traditionally made of stone, brick, or concrete; some modern arches are made of steel or laminated wood. The wedge-shaped blocks that form the sides of an arch are called voussoirs, and the top center stone, called the keystone, is the last block to be inserted. During construction, the arch is supported from below before the keystone is put in. The curve of an arch may take different shapes, but it is often a rounded or pointed semicircle. Although the Romans revolutionized the arch, the structure has been around since before them. The Assyrians used arches to construct vaulted chambers or underground drains. However, these early arches were only suitable for small structures. The designs weren't sophisticated enough to support larger edifices, like palaces or government buildings. The Romans, however, improved the arch and made it strong enough for large-scale, widespread use. By developing an arch capable of supporting huge amounts of weight, they laid the groundwork for some of the most important advancements in architectural history. The arch became a vital feature of bridges, gates, sewers, and aqueducts, which in turn were integral to the modernization of cities.
    [Show full text]
  • Turkish Bath, Heating System, Spatial Characteristic, Sustainability
    Architecture Research 2017, 7(2): 41-48 DOI: 10.5923/j.arch.20170702.02 Sustainability by Protecting of Traditional Heating Systems in Turkish Baths Müjgan Bahtiyar Karatosun, Tuba Nur Baz* Department of Architecture, Dokuz Eylul University, Izmir, Turkey Abstract The Turkish baths represent an important group of buildings that dating back to the Ottoman period and bearing the traces of daily life. The Turkish baths, which are an important cultural heritage item that reached today, give information about the structural features as well as reflecting the social structure and the way of life of the period they used. In this sense, it is seen that Turkish baths have unique heating, ventilation and acoustical characteristics when they are viewed from the point of view of their construction systems. The heating system in Turkish baths is also an important feature that also affects the spatial character of the building. In this context, it is important in terms of preservation of the building that the heating methods in accordance with the originality of the bath structures which maintain the original characteristic of the present day can be maintained. The aim of this study is to examine the effects of Turkish baths in terms of sustainability by examining them in the context of one of the characteristic features of heating systems and preserving the original character of the baths. Keywords Turkish bath, Heating system, Spatial characteristic, Sustainability In this study, it is aimed to examine traditional heating 1. Introduction systems which are the characteristic feature of Turkish baths in terms of sustainability by protecting these The history of aqua culture, which has a long history, structures.
    [Show full text]
  • SACRED SPACES: ISLAMIC ART and ARCHITECTURE (Mecca and the Dome of the Rock) ART of EARLY ISLAM
    SACRED SPACES: ISLAMIC ART and ARCHITECTURE (Mecca and the Dome of the Rock) ART of EARLY ISLAM Online Links: Mosque - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Dome of the Rock - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Mecca - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Kaaba - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Minaret - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Mihrab - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Minbar - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Adhan - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Muezzin - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Isra and Mi'raj - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia ART of EARLY ISLAM Online Links: Origin of the Crescent Moon Symbol - The Guardian The Kaaba – Smarthistory Dome of the Rock - Smarthistory Known to the Muslim faithful as Umm al-Qura- the Mother of Cities- Mecca is the holiest place in the Islamic world. Here, the prophet Muhammad (c. 570-632 CE), the messenger of God and founder of the Muslim faith, was born. Here, too, within the city’s Great Mosque, is the most sacred Muslim shrine, the Ka’aba. According to tradition, this cube-shaped building, draped in black cloth embroidered with a band of sacred verses in gold and silver thread, was originally built as a replica of a heavenly prototype. It was sacred to the Meccans before the time of the Prophet. And since the birth of Islam in the seventh century, it has been the focal point of the hajj, now the world’s largest annual pilgrimage. One of the “five pillars” of Islam, the hajj lasts several days, during which pilgrims must carry out certain rituals in Mecca and at sacred sites nearby. Muslims consider the city and an area several miles around it to be haram (“restricted,” “sacred”) and off-limits to non-Muslims.
    [Show full text]