Gardner-Webb University Digital Commons @ Gardner-Webb University

The tudeE Magazine: 1883-1957 John R. Dover Memorial Library

7-1-1947 Volume 65, Number 07 (July 1947) James Francis Cooke

Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.gardner-webb.edu/etude Part of the Composition Commons, Music Pedagogy Commons, and the Music Performance Commons

Recommended Citation Cooke, James Francis. "Volume 65, Number 07 (July 1947)." , (1947). https://digitalcommons.gardner-webb.edu/etude/182

This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the John R. Dover Memorial Library at Digital Commons @ Gardner-Webb University. It has been accepted for inclusion in The tudeE Magazine: 1883-1957 by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ Gardner-Webb University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. tmm

*rv>- THE- FIFTEENTH ANNUAL Bach Festival CHARLES IVES, American composer, of the Baldwin-Wallace College Con- has been awarded the Pulitzer Prize for servatory of Music was held in Berea, 1946, for a “distinguished musical com- Ohio, June 6 and 7. Under the direction position in the larger forms of chamber, of Dr. Albert Riemenschneider, the festi- orchestral, or choral music.” Mr. Ives’ val included a number of the shorter prize winning work was his Symphony No. cantatas, with the Mass in B Minor being first performed in New York in April 3, perforated on the second day. The various of last year. programs enlisted the services of the Baldwin-Wallace A Cappella Choir, the i'sucilvlvrdecital THE OUTDOOR CONCERT season has ^Oonc^S Cdoncenonceri ananad Opera Workshop, and the Festival or- s. J^or gotten under way in all parts of the chestra. country. On June 16 the Lewisohn Stadi- SINGERS um concerts in opened a ON THE PROGRAMS OF LEADING THE AMERICAN SCHOOL at Fontaine- NEW AND FAVORITE SELECTIONS FOUND season of forty concerts; on June 19 the bleau, France, of which Robert Casadesus Watergate Concerts in Washington, D. C. is the director, has an enrollment of fifty- began its season of eighteen concerts six young musicians, of whom forty are played by the National Symphony Or- pianists. The school opens on . AFTERWARD chestra. Robin Hood Dell in Philadelphia By Olive F. Conway 50 had an auspicious opening on June 23, when Dimitri Mitropoulos conducted the Low JUST 3tiele Choirs^fioir 3rinvisible FOR first of twenty-eight concerts. The six MME. LOUISE HOMER, world-famous AT DAWNING V HEMS JaaN weeks opera season at the Cincinnati Zoo n national Orchestra conducted by Fistou- THE EIGHTEENTH ANNUAL CHICAGO- contralto who for nineteen years was a Charles Wakefield Cadman 50 began on June 29, while the By lari. This same work was given its first LAND Music Festival, sponsored by the leading member of the Metropolitan Low Bowl season will open on . High Medium Medium Low performance in the United States when Chicago Tribune Charities, Inc., will be Opera Association, died May 6 at Winter it was played by Carmelo Carrozza in held at Soldiers Field, Chicago, on August seventy-six. LEONARD BERNSTEIN, young American Park, Florida, at the age of BLUE ARE HER EYES Philadelphia on May 17, with piaho ac- 16. The festival will feature contests in For the past eight years Mme. Homer had 50 conductor and pianist, scored a sensa- By Winfter Watts companiment by F. Cusumano. On this various classifications—vocal solo, dance, lived with her distinguished husband, the tional triumph late in April when he High Medium occasion it Was the feature of a program choral, band, instrumental solo, accordion, composer, Sidney Homer, at Winter Park, made his debut with the Palestine Or- presented by the Pietro Accordion Band and baton twirling. A series of prelimin- w'here she was honorary adviser in voice chestra in . On May 1 he con- A DREAM of Philadelphia, directed by Arnold E. ary festivals will be held in various cities College. She made her debut ducted the same orchestra in the first at Rollins By J. C. Barflett 50 Crowe. during the weeks preceding August 16. Metropolitan Opera as Amneris performance in the Holy Land of his own with the reigning High Medium Medium Low Low symphony, “Jeremiah.” in 1900 and thereafter was a THE EMINENT AMERICAN educator, or- LOUIS KAUFMAN, noted Hollywood vio- favorite of that galaxy of stars which in- FORGOTTEN ganist, conductor, and Bach specialist. Dr. linist, whose unseen solos have featured cluded Caruso, the De Reszkes, Fremstad, THE SEVENTEENTH ANNUAL festival of By Eugene Cowles 50 Albert Riemenschneider, has retired ds over four hundred film scores, has been Destinn, Amato, Melba, Nordica, De Se- American Music of the Eastman School active director of the Conservatory at awarded the Musical Courier Magazine gurola, ScottI, and Journet. High Medium Low directing, of Music, Dr. Howard Hanson, Baldwin-Wallace College, Ohio. Dr. Rie- Citation for the “best instrumental solo” had an impressive opening on April 29, in GARDEN menschneider has held his present posi- in film music for 1946. His solo in Warner MRS. ALLENE K. BIX BY, composer, or- GOIN' HOME in MY Rochester, birds the Eastman Theatre, New tion for nearly half a century. He wall Bros. “Of Human Bondage,” for which Arr. Fisher 50 ganist, teacher, whose piano educational By Dvorak— Yorjc. A radio version of Dr. Hanson’s remain at the "College in the capacity of Erich Korngold wrote the score, brought works for beginners are widely used, died High Medium Low opera, “Merry Mount,” on May 3, was an an advisor, devoting more time to his re- Kaufman the award. April 21 at Binghamton, New York. Mrs. outstanding event. The closing concert markably fine Bach Library, .as well as Bixby, who was bom in- Tunkhannock, HOLD THOU MY HANDS on May 5 had Dr. Serge Koussevitzky as doing special work upon the completion THE VIRGINIA MUSIC FESTIVAL, the Pennsylvania, studied with Paul Bliss. By Graham Godfrey 50 guest of honor at the Founders’ Day pro- of his notable editions of the Bach first of what is expected to be an annual Many of her choral and instrumental Low gram. Chorales. His plan is to present his im- event of major importance, was held at works are included in the catalogs of the mense Bach Library to Baldwin-Wallace Charlottesville, on June 13, 14, 15. The Theodore Presser Co. IS THE KING OF LOVE MY SHEPHERD THE 1947 PHILADELPHIA MUSIC FES- as a memorial to his parents. A remark- National Symphony Orchestra, under By William R. Spence 50 TIVAL, sponsored by The Philadelphia In- able fact is that between Dr. Albert Rie- Hans Kindler, gave three concerts, in two ALFREDO CASELLA, internationally High Low quirer Charities, Inc., was held in that menschneider and his father, Karl Rie- of which a world-famous soloist was known Italian composer, died March 15 city on June 13. Featured on the long the presented. At the first concert Mona menschneider, long-time president of in Rome, at the age of sixty-four. He PACK CLOUDS AWAY program were the New York Philhar- Berea institution, a total of one hundred Paulee, mezzo-soprano of the Metropoli- wrote many important works, his last By Frances McCollin 65 monic-Symphony Orchestra, the U. S. with the University of Vir- years of service has been given to Bald- tan appeared being a “Mass for Peace,” written w-hile Low H Marine Band, the Washington Redskins win-Wallace College. This is perhaps a ginia Glee Club in Brahms’ Alto Rhap- Germans, Rome was occupied by the and Q Band, Fred Waring and His Pennsyl- concert featured John record for service to an educational in- sody. The second produced there in . PR Philadelphia Scala STRESA , 4YRr vanians, and the La stitution. Powell, Virginia composer-pianist. Corps de Ballet. Robert Merrill, of the By Wintter Watts 50 ERIC DUDLEY, director of the Cornell Metropolitan Opera Association, was an High University Glee Club for twenty-five outstanding soloist, and Paul Whiteman years, and since 1903, of the First Presby- was master of ceremonies. THE SWEETEST STORY EVER TOLD terian Church Choir of Ithaca, New York, By R. M- Stults 50 died in that city on May 21, at the age of High Medium Low PRIZE WINNERS in the fifth annual seventy-four. For some years before the young composers' contest of the National World War he was director of the Ithaca TAKE, O TAKE THOSE LIPS AWAY Federation of Music Clubs have recently Conservatory of Music. announced. The major prize of one By Garth Edmundson 35 been Medium hundred dollars for a work for orchestra FREDERICK KITZINGER, conductor, went to Willard S. Elliot of Houston, who at the age of nineteen was an as- second prize of fifty dollars THE TIME FOR MAKING SONGS HAS COME Texas, while sistant to Otto Klemperer at the State in this classification was given to Samuel By James H. Rogers 50 Opera in Berlin, died May 23 in New York Thomas Beversdorf, also of Houston. First mtmorp City. He had accompanied the late High Medium In of Mobort A. fFilliamt, Quarlrrmanttr C. S M, tort in tkojirot battlo Ikt SouiJk prize fifty dollars in Class for a of Faoifio of 1, Emanuel Feuermann, ’cellist, on a world TO A SAILOR SON choral work, was won by Rosalind Burg- recently conducted H ARVKT GAUL tour, and more had TO SOMEONE inski of Lynbrook, Y. Second prize of N. operas and operettas in the United States. By Geoffrey O'Hara 50 twenty-five dollars in this classification Medium went to Penelope Svendson of Forest Hills, N. Y. First prize of fifty dollars in Competitions WHITE NOCTURNE music work, -was Class 2, for a chamber A PRIZE of one hundred dollars is offered By Paul Nordoff of Ithaca, Y., with 50 won by Sidney Cox N. by J. Fischer & Bro., under the auspices Medium a second prize of twenty-five dollars go- of the American Guild of- Organists, to ing to Irwin A. Bazelon of Oakland, Cali- the composer of the best composition for fornia. the organ submitted by any musician re- siding in the United States or Canada. The Oliver IHtson Co . deadline for submitting entries is Jan- on - \y a emp - ty PIETRO DEIRO’S Concerto in E for Theodore Presser Co., Distributors uary 1, 1948, and full details may be Accordion its world premiere on had secured by writing to the American Guild 1712 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia, l.Pu, Fdii /J, March 14 in , when it was played of Organists, 630 Fifth Avenue, New by the noted Norwegian accordionist, Mme. Louise Homer, with her famous composer husband, Sidney Homer, and York 20, N. Y. 420) Toralf Tollefsen, with the London Inter- Dr. Hamilton Holt of Rollins College, Winter Park, Florida. ( Continued on Page

JULY, 1947 "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE” 361 " .

Editorial AS WE BEGAN this editorial performance of Ralph KuWif Vloiii/i a part of their time to motion pic- Pubiicolumi A. Vaughan-Williams’ impos- UME ettto: ture music. It is interesting to in- engrossing London Sym- ing and quire whether they are making by HARVEY S. WHISTLER coincidentally came through I phony uSic an a permanent contribution to “on the air” in our study. Let us m MODERN this HOH M A N N-WOHLFAHRT Beginning § PUBLISHED MONTHLY their careers by their work in Method for , Vol. I. First Position imagine man who never had $0.60 By Theodore Presser Co., Philadelphia i, Pa. a exciting field. Composers have to London and was un- MODERN H O H M A N N-WOHLFAHRT Beginning 1 been written symphonies, oratorios, EDITORIAL and ADVISORY STAFF Method for Violin, Vol. II. with the tremendous First Position ... .75 familiar part of the present day repertory DR. JAMES FRANCIS COOKE, Editor in Chief this lovely and operas which are far more a of the English metropolis. Is there anything m INTRODUCING THE POSITIONS Violin, Ethel M. McKray, Assistant Editors history is to for Vol. I. Guy McCoy and than when they were first heard over a century ago. What Editor pictures in his mind which Third and Fifth Positions 75 Dr. Rob Roy Peery, Music musical work which would make of the vast genius and labor that has been put into a Harold Berkley Dr. Nicholas Douty Karl W. Gehrkens Dr. Guy Maier wonderful world center? The melodic bits become INTRODUCING THE POSITIONS Ruth Evans Buhman Maurice Dumesnil Elizabeth Gest Dr. Alexander would resemble that for Violin, Vol. II. McCurdy good picture is shown, let us say, for Pietro Deiro Edna Fort George C. Krick N. Clifford Page and woof great motion picture? The Second, Fourth, the jolly folk dance, the warp Sixth, Seventh and higher positions .75 William D. Revelli Peter Hugh Reed employed here and there, at least three years and then the films are canned and stored in DEVELOPING English only in the imagination of one who DOUBLE-STOPS for Violin. A complete of the material are course of study in double note Hollywood. Will they be opened for future genera- - FOUNDED 1883 BY THEODORE PRESSER the vaults in and chord development has become familiar with these elements. I 2 j turned into concert , to been. It is only by tions? Will the scores be still as abstract as it always has Music is musicians ? Publications for other bowed be performed by living instruments: association that we attribute to will they be forgotten, and FROM VIOLIN TO . dontenti Or A transitional method for those who for ffnfij, 1947 of creating pictures already possess a it the power fallen rose petals? knowledge of violin disappear like , playing does . . . 1.00 minds. However, one in our pictorial music depends VOLUME LXV, No. 7 • PRICE 23 CENTS Much INTRODUCING THE POSITIONS for , Vol. I. The Fourth not need to have had an exhaus- Position. . . 1.00 That is, the THE WORLD OF upon line and volume. MUSIC 361 realize INTRODUCING THE POSITIONS for Cello, tive experience in music to Vol. II. Second, Second-and-a-Half, melodic line goes up or down, as Third, EDITORIAL and Third-and-a-Half Positions that the art has a great effect up- j ^ the fortunes of the players ascend Music and Moods SOLOS FOR STRINGS. moods. Listen ! There came An indispensable collection 363 on our of easy, melodic material for or descend. The heroine trips up- solo playing or unisonal string class MUSIC AND CULTURE on the radio just now the majes- performance. stairs and the small boy slides A Musical Tour of Europe can Violin Solo (First Today Marinrin 1 tic clash of a cymbal, which Position), Viola Solo (First 365 Position), Cello Solo (First Posi- They Hail from the Red River Valley down the banister. What could be tion). Radio Groce V Win I 366 and circum- and , String Bass Solo (First and Second Conducting As a Career \ only mean the pomp Positions). Each 50 367 more suggestive than the ascend- The Teacher's Round Table .."i:;" Moor c "n" T 368 stance of an unforgettable Brit- Piano Accompaniment Hearing and Musicianship the descend- ^ ZZlZljH, Curtil II 7U , 369 ing major scale and ish historical event thus portrayed MUSIC IN THE HOME ing chi'omatic scale? What are in Williams’ score. Our hypo- Recordings With Varied Appeal ... . scales anyhow? Nothing but musi- So. ' Etude Music Booksheu 370 thetical ignoramus may never 738 Campbell Ave. “ 374 writes: cal stairs. Dr. Rubsamen * MUSIC AND have heard of Napoleon, but when CHICAGO 12, ILL. STUDY “The visual movement most The Pianist's Page he hears the bells in Tchaikov- is Dr - Cu Maier frequently reflected in music How Businesslike Are You’ V 372 “1812” You Don’t Tce ,e BP'd 373 sky’s Overture he knows "Decide" to Be a Sin'oer P that of an ascending or descend- Basic Policies '.' Thomas L Tlinm.i 375 and Traditions of t 0US that they must be connected with MUS,C School ’ The Organ-Piano .’ -"‘urtce 376 CombtaaUon f ing line. One of the cliches of Secrets of Intonation Alexander McCurdy 377 some powerful moment in his- Music for Wind Ensembles William H Stubbms 378 cinema music, -for example, is the Musical Richard Franko tory. Thus, in a general way, by Improve Duels. Goldman 379 ascending or de- Some Emmett E. Blind use of a fast technique Fundamental Principles of Bowine 380 association, music molds our Questions and Answers *" Clarence Cook 381 scending scale, staccato, to ac- Dr - READING The Theory Behind Music Karl w Gehrkens 382 moods. Developing the Boys' Choir Edward Dickinson 383 company someone running up or Coleman Cooper 384 Even without direct associa- Your MUSIC down stairs. The rise or drop in EXPRESSION tion, music may have a powerful Classic and pitch is obviously a transfer from Contemporary Selections effect upon all of us. For years, Breath of Heather (Ditson) Reminiscence the visual field, while the staccato (From "Moods and 385 your Editor has always endeavored Characters"')' '(Presser Observe Warner Bros. Photo imitates the short noises made by Improvement Valse Piquante editorials when it (Ditson) Mortimer- Browning. 386 to write these Piano _ . w Fantasia ' rl in Only 1 Week in D Minor (Presser 7353) L,"; •™ Wilhelm Kern, Op. 725 388 hurrying feet on the steps. This ’ the Tote Birds in W A ’ Mozart was possible to hear, at same Bohemian-American composer, whose opera, "Die Broad-well Teaches The Broadwell the Meadow - Revised by S. Noted Technique is a com- (Ditson) Lebert 389 particular transfer, which mu- plete pe Shepherd Boy Stadt," and other major works won him international fame. His Relaxed Freedom system of intelligent practice (Presser 4946) Morgan West 392 time, a fine musical program “on America, th« .... notable. fhe Beautiful - —G.• D. *. film production have been sent ,.. **,->• — Wilson, 4 contributions to American to you each (Presser)esser) t p Op. 394 other Now you can play music, as beautiful week. It develops and (From Eighteen sically illustrates many strengthens Hymn Transcriptions") the air.” He has invariably found as your mind imagines it; your mental-muscular co- Wnrd with bril- Arr ' ’ by ctar ce hl ways of going up or down, can liance, ordination induces ™ *° ™ nn 395 with perfect control. Develop ; clear, clean accurate that writing became more facile instant playing. A brilliant rising fall- sightreading, ready memorizing, technic is acquired thoughts seemed to flow easier, be traced back to medieval composers who wrote and during a soft musical background ; flawless technique, in weeks instead of months Sonatina, from through the mental- or years. the Cantata, 397 lines for the words asccndit and descendit of the ^ on WI'I1 conditions apparently in- ing melodic muscular coordination and keyboard notice the improvement in and the editorials written under such one patterns of Robert week. 398 visual impression of a storm at sea, for instance, can Broadwell. spire a larger response from the reading public. Why? That is a Mass. The 399 rises Eliminate Learning Blocks Endorsed and Recommended psychologists. be effectively reinfox-ced by a melodic line that gradually U 19302 problem for the The > Lily Broadwell Technique applies mod- by Musicians g Strickland 400 falls to the surge of tempestuous waves. In the Drfam Bubb?^B bb S the Music Teachers National Associa- and accompany *1 r Presser 27523 Frances M. 402 At the 1946 convention of syc °*°® > • Light i’™ > eliminates the unseen Concert pianists, organists, Hand in H I ,i lf 1 professional (Presser blocks that bar 27826) Anita C. Tibbitts 402 film ‘Rebecca,’ Franz Waxraan depicts the collapse of a buniing every person's way to musicians, famous teachers, MvDxv^bJolly Days (Presser tion, Dr. Walter H. Rubsamen, of the University of *, rapid students 27804) " J. Thomas 403 learning. It cuts tiresome practice all are enthusiastic glissandi in the entii'e over the sound Burton Arant 404 impressive paper, “Descriptive Music for Stage and house by means of ci'ashes and downward to one-third. It induces JUNIOR ETUDE read an relaxed play- method and psychological applications ing, makes will accept this transfer of a downward practice simple and logical. of the Broadwell indicating an extensive and brilliant survey of the basic oi'chestra. An audience Piano Technique. MISCELLANEOUS Elizabeth A. Gest 416 Screen,” aux-al line, even though the SEND COUPON FOR principles by which music becomes illustrative. The examples we visual movement to a descending FREE BOOKLET " TECHNIQUE from Dr. Rubsamen’s observa- noises made by a collapsing structure certainly do not descend in • have been purloined Wrwbmb'" . . .Dorothy Greener 364 shall employ Dr. Nicholas 407 pitch. other hand, a rising and falling movement is some- BROADWELL STUDIOS, Dept. 6TG Douty tions. Readers of The Etude often must have wondered, while On the Frederick Phillips 409 COVINA, CALIFORNIA Fortunes in Movie Music interpreted musically by a gradual inci'ease and decrease (Letter) Harold Berkley 411 attending the moving pictures, what processes the composers times 420 Name_ employ in providing the great variety of scores. Many of the in dynamics. Thus, in Waxman’s music for the film ‘Suspicion,’

re Presser Co., that they are so temporary. They deserve a much juster fate that rise and break against the base of a cliff.” Broadwell ~ *~ City $2.50 a T able to see anything particularly holy in M year in U S A j n than that. We never have been n n PIANO COS Cuba. it TECHNIQUE Nici“;u Dominican finest talents in the world have devoted the irreplaceable music of Brahms because was “pure,” “ab- State_ pTikZZXtln “Xft ,?P^ a p ‘L^. Some of the musical Singie^opy* solute,” or “absti’act.” Brahms just chose to write in that non- Music * A letter to The Etude from Dr. Rubsamen giving valuable information about the pictoi’ial way, whereas the mind of Wagner was essentially of The Etude. "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE” of the Movies appears on Page 420 of this issue THE ETUDE JULY, 1947 363 - — —

have every year more and more interesting and that makes we Music and Culture and there you have it. It’s the sentiment ago, in London, in up VIVID impression I have brought Music and Culture distinctive scores. Years the days ^HE MOST | enthusiasm the song.” solemn Sunday I out of Europe, is the tremendous the , one night we at- of the present day of Many of the foremost composers in a representative theater. X for good music. Over here, we are accustomed but tended the movies The graphic He wrote little or nothing without a dramatic have written for the films, with splendid results, Europe’s shortages in terms of material orchestra filed in and placed gray covered al- to hear of picture in mind. Certainly, Brahms, in many of his for the adaptations in the great films little shortages are most part, the the music racks. The film things—food, clothing, heat. Well, those Alfred bums of music upon began most beautiful songs, was thoroughly atmospheric. are left to specialists in the field, such as people stand in dire need of practically and the music commenced. The musicians played vast. The Mote the Wiegenlied and the Sapphische Ode. Dr. Newman, Weil, Forbstein, Rozsa, Korngold, Warner But when you are there among them, you through the album. The pieces hadn’t everything. Musical Tour of Europe Today Rubsamep calls attention to the fact that Mendels- days of the radio, straight the A Janssen, and others. Even in these need for the with what appeared on realize that there is an even greater sohn, in the would slightest connection the screen. •Scherzo from “A Midsummer Night’s the public attending the cinema by the millions builds the life of the soul. Every- series of hackneyed, old sustenance that Dream,” writes it does They were merely a tunes. light staccato passages in the upper hear more of the music of these men than amazed to find people the plain, music was actually where I went, I was — woodwinds and strings to picture that the In one death scene the that of A Conference with the ethereal caper that of the great masters, save for the fact everyday people—hurrying through the scantiest kind ings of Puck his the Light Cavalry Overture by von Suppe. The audi- and merry elves. Mendelssohn was Elysian Fields, or at least that part of them inhabited crowd into absolutely unheated upon the of meals in order to so enamored with passages of this type that many of been the ence, with its mind focused story shown on by the famous composers, for years have and poorly lighted halls so that they might enrich his later works < Rondo Capriccioso, the screen, apparently gave no thought to the in- Scherzo in E happy hunting ground for some of the arrangers of themselves with music. When faced with such a minor, and so forth) contain suggestions of these cinema congruity of the music. It seems only yesterday, when Hollywood. This is as it should be and the spectacle, not once, but over and over again, you feel arjorie oCawrence delightful fairy whims. every music shop had moving picture albums for the audiences gain by these raids upon the great classics very humble, and very grateful to be a musician! Harms Eisler was commissioned by the Rockefeller of the public comes to old-time moving picture pianist, with prescriptions world. The unsophisticated “It is interesting to find this identical music-hunger Internationally Renowned Soprano Foundation in 1940 “to experiment with cinema for love scenes, fire scenes, chase scenes, comic scenes. music know its Beethoven, Brahms, Wagner, Tchaikovsky, showing itself among peoples of different racial traits in an advanced idiom which would interpret been done since then, in the music natural Rimsky-Korsakoff, and Prokofieff, vicariously. What has of the and different immediate backgrounds. In England, phenomena of various kinds.” films, marks a startling advance in A pupil of Bruckner, The improvement in the music of the cinema has talking a new for instance, one finds a definite increase in music SECURED EXPRESSLY FOR THE ETUDE BY ROSE HEYLBUT Fuchs, and SchSnberg, and an operatic form musical art. conductor of been epochal. Starting with literally nothing notable, of interest and musical awareness which can be in- international experience (Metropolitan Opera Com- terpreted only as a result of the war. During the pany, New York) as well as virtuoso , a pianist of high concerts were given everywhere war, public morale Marjorie Lawrence, beautiful Australian-born soprano, had ability and an accompanist for Caruso, Farrar, Ysaye, in town in the National Gallery, in halls, in factories, asserted herself as one of the most eminent artists of the and others, he was well fitted for this commission. rooms. The people flocked to them, but at that time day when she was suddenly stricken with infantile paralysis. One of his creations was for a film as would have meant known “White there was no means of knowing whether this music At a crisis which, for a less gallant spirit, Flood,” depicting her superb forces, made a the ceaseless snows of the Arctic, Ever Play in a String Quartet? interest was not perhaps as much of an emergency invalidism, Miss Lawrence rallied for which Eisler "comeback," and has developed her already wrote “a light, fragmentary etude matter as the concerts themselves. sensational career to new heights of musical and spiritual for solo and orchestras, in which high and ex- distinguished Miss Lawrence had scarcely ceedingly integrity. During the war years, rapid notes for the violins reflect the aerial bij Conditions of Music Abroad H)orolhif Cjreencr a week to herself. In addition to a crowded professional quality of snow drifting over the mountaintops.” in Well, we do know now! To-day, the emergency and schedule, she has sung in encampments, in hospitals, and One of the from a tour of war- most ingenious of the musical painters the blitzes are over—but the music habit remains. The front-line areas, and has just returned of moods is , who, in depicting Ray in their factories, racked Europe during which she sang for British royalty, LOT of rumors have been circulated about quartet graphed one measure beforehand by an "oink” from same people who were given concerts the of the Legion of Honor of the French Milland awakening from a drunken spree in “The players, all concert halls and paying earned the Cross but they’re exaggerated and many of instrumentalist beginning to get into are now crowding to the Lost the mood. Republic, and was chosen as the first artist to perform for Weekend,” used an entirely new combination - them grossly untrue. It is not true, for instance, to hear good music; and their standards A The counters in an admissions In the following con- amateur quartet occupied Germany. of instruments, including the theremin, nova- session count the Allied staffs of the that you can tell a quartet player from an ordinary only are of the highest. Here, we enjoy a certain versatility and of the in the rests. They're too busy any other time. But ference, Miss Lawrence tells of her experiences chord, and high strings, sul ponticello, which pro- person he’s artists of reputation are fre- Note. when walking down the street—that is, when they have a in our entertainment; conclusions she draws from them. — Editor s duced a vague, unearthly measure rest, you can be sure to effect. unless he meets another quartet player. hear quently guests on radio comedy programs, during a decisive “1-2-3-4!" That's to show that they The composers for the cinema, with almost un- The conversation performances they vary their habitual reper- in these cases might start in a luke- know where they are which limited facilities at their command, and are being magnanimous and with no warm manner, but don’t let this fool you. tory with lighter things. The British music lover does A gleam sud- about it. They are generally the ones, iron-clad fetters of tradition to hold them in check, too, who suddenly denly comes into the eye, each spars for an opening, shout “Second not enjoy that sort of thing! For comedy he goes to already have originated ending!” when everybody else has taken are the people to have it. Any week, astonishing instrumental ef- artist reputation is billed, he London, so eager and then comes the inevitable. Simultaneously they the first. comedians; when an of fects which will This causes immediate panic, the whole concerts by five major orchestras, unquestionably find their way into shout: bot- his best style, form, and for instance, brings “Been playing any quartets lately!?’’ From there tom falls is expected to deliver —in the orchestral literature of out of the quartet and everybody opera, and several ballets. the future. What a pity on, it’s every stops and standards are of the best possible recitals, Covent Garden man for himself. Toe to toe they slug it screams selections. Thus, the that Berlioz is not alive Shut up!" at the counter is in use every day and twice on to hear some of the effects, out. who promptly crawls feel free to express himself The vast Albert Hall “We’re playing the Beethoven, Op. 59, No. 1 under his kind and an artist may whether magnificent or bizarre. chair. Saturdays and Sundays. I have used the term ‘too you know the Scherzo: didi da-da; did! da-da; dldi didi to the highest limit of his powers. The cinema composers also have because war time earnings are over now, naturally inclined didi-da!” “At present, there is almost too much music in much music’ but the racers and money toward the leit-motif treatment of Wagner, and tuners always seem te be ’celhste. and the people have not enough If there’s a third party present during the outburst whether the less A cellist takes the bit in musical performances sensitive members of the audience shifts his mouth with anything that to go to all the he sadly from foot to foot, tries to look interested, oo are aware of the return of the s like black notes desire! leit-motifs or not, we but when he finds —even if it's an Andante move- they the two quartetists are attracting ment. (And are willing to go so far as to say that they are sub- just try to tune your own “It is at that point, perhaps, that MARJORIE LAWRENCE questioning glances from passers by, he moves instrument when consciously affected by off a S tU ing! over. The new these tone symbols of persons few feet and be always is.) However. 'the the British radio takes and becomes intensely interested in a window Voiift « or moods. cellist can afford to be of the BBC is really thing if American artists toured there, as ambassadors display of vegetable cutters autocratic, and he always is. Third Program and kitchen knives. Sort of He s the One of the obligations of the composer for the backbone, the structural an important experiment in bringing of good will and good Tinderstanding. The light-and- a “never saw them before in my life” vertebrae of a quartet attitude. People ' cinema is that of not making the music obtrusive. tha hen s teeth ’ to the people the highest type of music heat situation in (and in other French cities) brush past them, but the quartetists are oblivious. - It; s always best to In Walton’s They salsa 0 ^ is still rather think back to performances of magnificent musical setting for the Olivier

Music and Culture Music and Culture T IS ONLY in recent years that musicians have begun to prepare themselves exclusively for a I career in conducting. In former years, the con- ductor usually rose to that position after he had played 1 in an orchestra, or had been a vocal coach. I believe that the young musician should know what he wants to do, and build for it from the beginning. My own career was built in that way. I began with the idea of Radio Conducting As a Career conducting, and did not vacillate. I became familiar with all of the instruments in the orchestra, and clarinet, and the French horn, studied the ’cello, the Conference with in addition to the piano. In general, the conductor From a must have (1) A good working knowledge of the piano. (2) He should play one string instrument. (3) He should have a working knowledge of one wood- lAJeber wind instrument, one brass instrument, and understand all of the percussion instruments. It is not possible to become a sound orchestral con- Well-Known American Conductor ductor, or to convey the correct interpretation of a demand certain phrasings from musicians score, or to EXPRESSLY FOR THE ETUDE BY ANNABEL COMFORT unless one has a knowledge of the instruments in the SECURED orchestra. The piano is the fundamental instrument for the conductor. It is the most comprehensive, and has the fewest limitations. Without a knowledge of Henry Weber has had an extensive career as an orchestral this instrument, the conductor has set a tremendous of radio. Born in Chicago, he was handicap for himself. Being able to play orchestral conductor In the field of Music, the University of scores at the piano is part of the conductor’s back- educated at the Vienna Academy an ground. He will not become proficient in score playing Vienna, and at the University of Chicago. His debut as unless he has acquired a firm piano technique, and a opera conductor was made in Bremen in 1919; and from 1924 _Ia ‘ J superior knowledge of this instrument. to 1929 he was conductor of the Chicago Civic Opera Com- back- The conductor also must have a cultural been musical director of Station A FAMOUS CHORUS OF MEN FROM THE RED RIVER VALLEY pany. Since 1934 he has ground. Good taste is his stock in trade. He should WGN. In 1940 he was appointed artistic director of the have a well rounded education with special emphasis Chicago City Opera Company — Editor s Note. on the humanistic side. He should know Latin, and Greek, and should have a knowledge of the modern They Hail languages, German, Italian, and French. It would be From the classic Red River difficult for a conductor to study the song Valley receives more rehearsal time than he would ever re- literature, or opera scores unless he knew foreign ceive in conducting an opera. As a rule the opera con- languages. He could not expect to have an interna- ductor receives only four hours rehearsal for a fuU The Amphitm Chorus of Northern tional career, and go to other countries to conduct and Dakota three act opera performance, and it is here that without a good knowledge of the language of the coun- eveals Success clarity, and accuracy in the conductor's technique will Formula for Male Choruses in the try where he plans to carry on his work. In conduct- Average American City count. This is why I feel that the best training for the ing, there are opportunities all over the world. young conductor is opera conducting. Among many Breaking Into Radio Conducting other things he will learn how to conserve that im- portant element time. It is difficult to say just how the young conductor ly Cjrace Conducting in radio has taught me two things, and U. lAJatlins can break into radio, and begin to conduct, because they have meant a great deal. The first is accuracy and so much depends on his background, and his versatility. attention to detail. This is so extremely important be- There is no schooling for the conductor that will com- ITIES small and large all of a the- cause the microphone, and the audience are so close over America are dis- keenest critic could pare with the theater. To conduct any kind desire.” Then it was that covering the social and publicity this group rehearsal time, is to the conductor. One finds that he must approach the value of a h“ndred singers atrical venture, where he can have cracka-jack from pargo, North Dakota, conducting of a concert hall orchestra, and the radio C male chorus, made up of foremost „ and the most valuable training that any conductor can Moorhead Minnesota, men citizens. knew that artistically speakin- orchestra, in an entirely different manner. The second There probably is no quick ^ B’ finest spring board for a means of pre- Amphion “had arrived.” ™ have. Opera conducting is the senting the thing learned in radio was how to secure tonal balance civic standing, ideals, and quality that conductor. I know because my own career was built in excel the This is absolutely essential concerts of such a group, when it of the opera in the orchestra. when one takes time A Variety of Vocations this way. The greatest conductors come out to make tours to other parts. is working with an orchestral body in a radio studio. HENRY WEBER Although houses. Here one is faced with more unpredictable How can it is strictly a professional through work in radio does the ear become at- a “top notch” choral group be developed group Amphion situations than in any other field of the art. A con- Only professional si nger in in the average American city? How can such its ranks. From faster pace in tuned to the balance of the various groups of instru- radio when popular music is played, more microphones a group theth^ffactoryT Tthey come, ducting technique can be acquired at a be drilled, from trades and concert work so of it is visual, and the music, fewer micro- without waste of precious time to the offices from field of conducting. ments. In much are used, and in playing symphonic mem- the school-room, and from opera than in any other bers, so that it will the farm. There conductor can watch his players; but in radio, all of phones are used. command the enthusiastic praise men, are’sales- In symphonic conducting, the young leader is apt of teachers, a funeral director, qualified critics? What are the secrets of success an abstractor a this is discounted. The orchestras are smaller, and the A good conductor generally knows how to get along for judge, a janitor, an to deal with better musicians, but he is not likely to the everyday citizens optometrist, lawyers, keep his eye the radio control room. with high choral ambitions? doctors in experience, in a brief period of time. To conductor must on with people; but even then he must have the oppor- surance men, creamery workers, get as much The Amphion Chorus, of Fargo hotel men, mecham^s' For a symphonic program we seldom use over fifty-five tunity to work with a group of men for some time, in the Red River a printer, a grain become a radio conductor one must have an extensive Valley, North commissioner. Twenty-five forty to forty-five men for a light Dakota, and Moorhead, Minnesota, ’way businesses’ knowledge of opera, symphonic music, concert music, or sixty men, and and then they will really begin to understand him, his a ‘ up on the borderline of Canada, a “ ma ,re musical program. ideas, ideals. The conductor must work out prac- knows the answers to srs." operetta, and swing music. and these and similar questions. fall These vigorous "Men of I would advise the young aspirant to finish his tical things first, so that his organization will not the Requisites for admission are a West on Wings of Song” have unparalleled love of music a rea Studying the Score apart. Then he can refine the group to his own per- claims sonably good voice formal schooling, and his musical education, and then to distinction. In and some experience fact, they believe Amphion unique in choir or with opera company. A conductor who is musical director of a radio sta- sonal taste. As a rule, when an orchestra begins to chorus, a willingness to work, try to become connected an A in the field of American music to cooperate his ideas across to-day through its Thus in the third rate company is of no value, because this kind tion, must spend a considerable amount of time in know a conductor, he can put more triple role Red River Valley of the of (1) being a top flight professional North famed myself advantageously. If the conductor is a specialist in the chorus, world over for the the does not give rehearsal time. As there are so few opera study. I have trained to hear orchestral scores <2) sponsoring production of No 1 an annual artists’ course in the Harri wLA aid of playing of Mozart, and plays a considerable amount of com- these one ’ companies in this country where the young conductor without the the piano, taking the scores to my munity hundred men have during a , and (3) financing its period orchestra will own organization of one years developed 6" DANIEL L. PRESTON can obtain experience and training, I believe that it is desk, and reading them as one would read a book. If it his music, the begin to play everything hundred into a powerful force il members without one dollar of aid in ia Director the Mozart style. In radio, the orchestra player from M. o, the MM, w,„. ol the Amphion Chorus still best for him to go abroad. Europe has many opera is a new work, I take the separate choirs, the string in patrons or other benefactors. Not u„d,r only has the group L. Preston, companies, and there still is more opportunity for the parts, the woodwind parts, and the brass, analyze the must be versatile. He must be able to play symphonic spent director, they have inspired $70,000 on community betterment in the past the oigamza-orgamza form, the thematic construction so music, as well as dance music. When my orchestra has tion of many other male 6 R^ssian bassi ” youthful aspirant over there than there is here. He and that I under- e even years, but the Amphion budget choruses the tLA. —the lyric contours of is balanced at The hieh ° rS must make a name for himself, and have a good record, stand it, and it all makes sense. In the thematic mate- been playing only dance music for a period of time, it is the name Amphion was imPeccable of all present writing, and there is chosen from the the ensemble work a surplus %in the ological mvth choirs and then his opportunity will come if he is persistent, rial I mark what is to be emphasized here and thero. necessary to build up an approach from the dance to treasury. Probably story of the lyre player Amphion. no other chorus has attained whosFmu' style, again com- sic caused the stones and does not get discouraged too easily. This angle is important in radio, because the orches- the classic before attempting symphonic parable distinction to move into place of without the backing of some 0 very quickly fall style. in- aC d n f rtmC ™ Some Notable tras are smaller, and one must use every means to build music. An orchestra can into one stitution. ati°nS W6re being built Activities - at T The repertoirer t r heb Technique of the Radio Conductor up what goes through the microphone, and make it r of Amphion ' Amphion When the Amphion is drawn from 1,,7 Artists’ Course is top news for Chorus appeared in concert at reputable 1 VEry music loverf sound important. Opera in English source. In it will be The technique of the conductor in radio should Town Hall, Sigmund Spaeth declared: found wm-Vo” the Red R^er Valley. In co- “It is quite from the 1 ”8 on with favorite microphone possible stately dignity of Palestrina St Moorhead evolve itself. He should be sure of his technique when My in the radio studio is the It is my feeling that opera in this country should that they are the finest group of to the dash State Teachers College and male singers madness of Concordia rnu “overall mike.” It is an ideal in modern arrangements °’ he takes up radio work. He should be so sure of his pickup but it can be not be performed a foreign language. In the United m America to-day.” And Mark Andrews of old Russian S tbe chorus has in the past eleven wrote: “I have songs. It has Mk years brmurhf f used with only small orchestra. never required years of careful orty' intentions, and be able to make them so clear .to his a Several microphones States, opera should be given in English, and in France heard a chorus more perfectly blended. studv and I v five concerts and theater produc- The gent work to perfect the ^ tions to n men, that he can take an orchestra through a work are used to emphasize the various good parts of the it should be sung in French, and in Italy in Italian. quality of tone, diction, organ tones mmun ity. and precision were all that the of tht h Among artists presented Which Robert A. Simon “ have been t° f° without a rehearsal. Time in radio is one of the most orchestral choirs; thus we get a blend or balance from The only hope for opera in this country is to sing it in Heifetz > Harold Bauer, Marian An- dersonderson, Pir-hAi” important elements. It is also a very important ele- the orchestra. When the “overall mike” is used the English, the language of our people. The Chicago The- 366 Richard Bonelli, ( Continued Page 413) "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS on ment in conducting opera. Today, the radio conductor audience will hear more clarity, and less blend. In atre Of The Air has been (Continued on Page 410) ' LIFE’’ <• ' - ' > - THE ETUDE JULY, 1941 "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE’’ 367 Music and Culture Music and Culture The wide prevalence of some degree of deafness has been made known to the public through the great number of people who have adopted hearing devices of many kinds. Dr. Curtis H. Muncie’s charts, showing tests indicating im- l he Old Do s and "Do Nol’s’’ provement upon hearing, through the employment -of his of the Well, my fellow Round Tablers, here I operation for the improvement of the condition cutting, are startling. Un- am back from a wonderful trip to the Eustachian tube, without resort to paper shortage these charts could not Conference of Southern Music Educators fortunately owing to be included in this issue. in Birmingham, Alabama. X traveled by Hearing and Musicianship specializing Dr. Muncie is a distinguished New York otologist, air, in one of those splendid, big Round Table D-C 4's, Teacher’s The tubes in deaf- on the function and treatment of Eustachian and as always it was speedy, quiet, and Dr. ness in which field he has become a foremost authority. utterly comfortable. Between reading a Muncie demonstrated that the Eustachian tubes—seemingly From a Conference with magazine and enjoying a steak dinner, Conducted by unimportant canals which connect the throat with the middle one hearing since their least impair- hears a few names: . . — highly important in Cleveland . ear are immediately on the hearing. He has achieved Pittsburgh . . . Knoxville. Then Birming- ment reflects through re- ham, the balmy atmosphere, Another angle of the problem amazing results in restoring defective hearing with stars a^umeinii : students 1/Ylaurice construction of the Eustachian tubes without the use of ),-. Curtii Wluncie twinkling in the sky. The do count, but . . . unevenly; M. Conference who who, in 2 cutting surgery, using only his sensitive fingers. Dr. Muncie lasted four days and it was indeed a fact, adjust their counting to their Foremost Authority on Otology French-American wrong has made a special study of hearing in relation to musician- A great one. A record breaking attendance Eminent playing instead of adjusting their playing ship during his thirty-four years of research in deafness, and was on hand, with activities going and on all Pianist, Conductor, Lecturer, to their right counting. Yes, of course, has treated a number of famous singers, conductors over town: orchestras, bands, interview he tells about the choruses, you have one or more of this particular musicians. In the accompanying auditions, forums, chamber and how the hearing can music, and and Teacher type. Here our old friend, the metronome, structure and function of the ear SECURED EXPRESSLY FOR THE ETUDE BY DORON K. ANTRIM naturally, a Piano Round Table led be safeguarded. — Editor s Note by is valuable for checking purposes. this editor. I found the participating As for your last statement, you might teachers very progressive, well informed keep a copy of this issue near at hand. on up-to-date developments, and alto- After your little lecture on counting, pick dispute that the most prized possession of the musician gether efficient and competent. The “De- “»to ONE can well it up, The least open it, and read aloud the' first Without it, he’s almost hopelessly handicapped. bussy Clinic” proved to be a highlight, |\l is his hearing. starting from a very soft pianissimo few lines of this, my answer. Then sim- -L hearing impairs his efficiency. This is particularly true of the and it was thrilling to find such interest defect in which allowed a gradual crescendo with- ply say: tones, distinguished from the "You see . . . It is Important, player, and others who make their as among the audience. Three cheers for the singer, string out getting to any crashing fortissimo because it's in The Etude." slight hearing loss will often affect one s sensitive- old South; courteous, friendly, wide pianist who does not. Only a and entirely might other- foreign to his reserved and dis- to pitch. considerable loss can blight or ruin a career which awake whenever musical advancement is ness A tinguished conception of pianism. misfortune any less serious to the concerned. Cadenzas and Concertos wise have been noteworthy. Nor is such a require an unusually high degree of hearing both in quality Returning to the North, I found among Are there cadenzas for the Mozart D teacher. Musicians Correspondents with this Depart- minor the number of musicians whose loss the letters which had accumulated Is Counting Necessary? Concerto (K. 466) other than the and sensitiveness although estimate places on ment are requested to limit letters Hummel Would and Beethoven? Is It ever per- their efficiency as one in ten. my desk, a few which call for a clarifica- to One Hundred and Fijty Words. you please comment upon the of hearing is such as to impair necessity for counting? missible to play a concerto without the for granted. He tion of the relationship I think I at least “And yet, the average musician takes his ears pretty much between this de- try to use good cadenza, or to cut the cadenza? A student psychology with students does his automobile. He has the latter partment and the writers. First, but who is now working rarely gives them the attention and care he among the older ones think counting is be- on this concerto finds the cadenzas trouble and insure maximum service. It does the “Do not’s,” may I request that no low their dignity and they are stubborn pretty dimcult Thank you checked up frequently to forestall for about it. I your help in this. intervals with an audiometer test, long questionnaires be sent, especially When make them do it they not occur to him to have his ears checked at often cry and it ends up being the kind — (Miss) E. H.. North Carolina just good the when they are to be used for which takes only about twenty minutes and tells by chart how school pa- From an Old Legend of a nightmare every teacher tries to lot of grief later on by en- pers, or theses. This obviously avoid. Little Yes, hearing is. Such periodic check-ups could prevent a should be I know you are an authority on Debussy children can be taught to there are other cadenzas for the clap stages, tremendous advan- taken care of by and his music hands and count without difficulty, Mozart abling one to get at incipient trouble in the early a the correspondents and would you tell me the D minor Concerto, and I recom- legend but the older ones who do not feel treatment and cure if taken in time. themselves, and they are at college pre- he had in mind when he composed rhythm mend to you those tage. Deafness is much more susceptible to are a problem. If I could by Fcrrucio Busoni, La Cathedrale engloutie ( show them that cisely The Sunken test, the average person is unable to tell whether there is any to learn how to handle and an- you say it and Carl “Without such a Cathedral )? I wish absolutely must be done it Reinecke. Both are pianistic RECONSTRUCTED OR NORMAL to tell a music club well advanced. Metropolitan THE swer such questions. Then, please would help.—C. C. G., Nebraska. and impairment in his hearing until the trouble is fairly A RECONSTRUCTION do not audience the background of this compo- brilliant. But if your student has dif- EUSTACHIAN TUBE friend. He didn’t know that he had send in anything like this: “At Page 179 sition. I have hunted in vain for informa- ficulty with the singer once came to me on the advice of a D—The reconstructed Eustachian tube (normal). Hummel cadenzas I fear Small bones of the ear, the malleus, incus, and OF THE PROLAPSED of tion on this piece.—Mrs. M. J. W„ Kansas Of course counting pitch and insisted his hearing was perfect. Yet a test re- E— Beethoven’s Sonatas, third line, fifth is absolutely neces- that the above been having lapses of stapes. may well be a little too cochlea, which receives sound measure, So-and-So’s sary, and it plays no favorites: considerable hearing loss in one ear. Restoring the hearing in that ear C—Part of inner ear. the EUSTACHIAN TUBE edition, do you it imposes much for vealed waves means of nerve end organs. In old Brittany, that French her. However, here is a valuable by province itself upon us with thirty per cent Nerve of hearing through which impulses received play the trill with, or without ending. beginners and professionals suggestion: restored his sensitiveness to pitch. Nature has endowed B— so picturesque with its rugged country- no less a Mozartian authority at C are conveyed to brain to be interpreted as Demonstrate alike! Concert pianists required for conversation. Thus most of this reserve hearing A prolapsed Eustachian tube is here shown diagram- on paper.” Who can be ex- often have to de- than Isidor more hearing than is sound. side, rocky coastline, granite dwellings, Philipp says that the Hum- A—The semi-circular canals which control the sense of matically in the process of reconstruction. Note ad- pected pend upon it too, is conscious of conversation deafness. But the nature of to have all music, in all editions, when dealing with ex- mel cadenzas may be lost before one balance. hesions and pre-isthmus lesion ahead of the Anger. and yellow shrubbery, there is a wealth tremely are very satisfactory, but handy at any moment? The measure in- complex and intricate his profession imposes more severe demands on the musician. He needs most of of legends and superstitions. composi- too long and too heavy. They be volved Modernism tions. The classical must twenty-five per cent may be a serious ought to be written down, in every repertoire itself his reserve hearing, and a loss of twenty to has made very little headway and most is arranged and shortened. By examining case. Next in line: fingerings. This prob- replete with pages where the handicap. folks adhere to their ancestors’ meter calls the musical text closely lem varies according customs; for careful examination, you should have to the individual to say the least. no The Deceptiveness oi Hearing they also use the Celtic dialect in their trouble in detecting the superfluous hands. It is a See, as one example teacher’s job to size up a among many the passages homes. One of the most popular legends and finding the proper way to “Hearing is extremely tricky for it is the one sense which is not wholly de- student’s hand and to choose, among slow movement of Beethoven’s is that one according Third work out several to which some of Concerto in the cutting and “welding.” pendent on the individual. We know that we see; we know that we smell and possible fingerings, the one which c minor: anyone beginning the land was once engulfed by the en- Strangely enough, taste. Our hearing is dependent upon the functioning capacity of our ears as well will best fit that particular case. its study must pause Beethoven's cadenzas How and make sure of for croaching sea. And now when the fisher- this concerto (and for as of the speaker, or if it is music to which we are listening, upon the pitch and could anyone judge this blindly? Also, exactly where the subdivided others as well, men go out on certain beats fall- including please clear days, when then the his own!) can be tenned awk- volume. For this reason we do not know sometimes whether we should hear a do not set any time limit because practicing of the “ornamenta- the water is smooth and transparent, ward, unpianistic, certain sound not, for person with one hundred per cent hearing does you “are in a hurry and need tion passages will and completely “un- or even a an answer they claim be adjusted accurately that they can see the silhou- grateful." not hear everything. Furthermore, it is possible for a person to have one hundred for such or such date.” Due to the great and subsequent Sometimes I come to think ette of the ancient performances will pro- city rising towards ceed with that in such instances gave per cent hearing in one ear and be totally deaf in the other without knowing number of letters received, they have to the required smoothness. Beethoven them from the depths of the* ocean and You way to a be filed, classified, and answered, are not alone in genuine sense of humor which of the deficiency in the poor ear unless accidentally discovered or a test is made. which of the ages. your contention, The cathedral stands in the and prompted him Many musicians have a loss of fifteen to thirty per cent hearing in one ear with- is only fair, in order of reception. Finally: other teachers report similar to make trouble for the middle, and from its towers comes problems It pianists. up the . out realizing it. lost hearing high do not write month after month, some- js a fact that students Didn't he write, at the head There are others who have the capacity for sound of the bells. of adolescence One hears the power- let of his cadenza tones but hear low pitches perfectly. Still others are just the reverse. There are times even more often; give the other us say twelve to sixteen, for the first movement of ful chords of the organ, the chanting are ant to his Round Tablers a chance. of suffer from fourth concerto: “Cadenza, senza those who hear better than normal in a noisy environment. Others hear better And now, to the the exaggerated self-conscious- ma priests as they go through the aisles cadere”? “Do’s:” Please stick to one question, and ness. Good psychology Well, since cadenza in Italian in a quiet environment and when there is much music about them their own in a procession. It lasts will help to show to the but a short while, them suggests also hearing becomes relatively defective. Some people hear the telephone ring limit of one hundred and fifty that counting is the act of “falling, or a fall,” but for soon the vision recedes, by no means “un- words. Expose and nothing dignified.” we might put not the voice. On the other hand, individuals with a high bone conduction hear it clearly. However well remains Tell them, for instance it this way in English: but the little ripples on the sur- that Cadenza, meant it may be, too many details, too he gr®at Conservatories but without ‘fizzling,’ or falling better than normal over the telephone but may not hear ordinary conversation. face under , of the blue sky above. It is in- Europe much dilution of the solfeggio,”,f jvhich off. And look Hearing idiosyncrasies are numerous but they are usually pathologic. main point creates teresting is based on at those terrible trills, to know that Edouard Lalo’s counting with confusion and 11 off notes, The ear is one of the most marvelous and delicate precision instruments in the hampers an accurate un- *** f° toward the end. . Sure well known opera Le Roi d’Ys r Which contests’ derstanding deals with are held enough, world. Its are and appreciation of the hddTnVand awards granted. Beethoven had his little fun! As main parts the outer ear terminating with the ear drum, the middle the city of that name which was forever Tell thpm subject. Keep the perspective unobstruct- that after all, what to discarding ear connected with the throat by the Eustachian tubes, and the inner ear con- submerged when the conductors of cadenzas entirely, it was ed by dramatic develop- phony tried in unimportant side issues. Try to oichestras do is in Paris years ago, but the experi- taining the cochlea, the true organ of hearing, and the semicircular canals which ment of the story caused the flood reality count- make your problem gates mg to their ment was control the equilibrium. delicate endings one of general in- musicians with short lived, for let’s not forget The nerve within the cochlea receive to be thrown open. Debussy’s imagination their baton terest. Bear in mind Mention the that if the sound waves through the perilymph fluid but these sound be that the aim of this couldn’t help fact that in dancing composers wanted no cadenza waves must being attracted by such a schools' they department is to help the greatest most instructors count provided no space for delivered for the person to hear. Any interference along the line of conveyance num- subject, and he wrote a Prelude too, and with the for one (see, ber of which pupil, so instance, Etude readers, whenever possible, affords that the feet follow Mendelssohn and Chopin). And may result in deafness. The tone range of the normal ear for practical hearing marvelous opportunities for a the cadence at the of the music. ally, is sixty-four vibrations vibrations. same time. display And do not soldiers regarding difficulty: since caden- to 8,192 The low limit and high limit are greater of varied and shimmering tone drill 1to With the the husky counting zas were than this, but practical hearing is within this range limit, which compares favor- cooperation of everyone, we of “Hup twn tv, originally mere improvisations, colors. He played it himself in public will proceed further a four?” cider students there is no ably with any musical instruments made. on the road to who ' objection to arranging any more number of times, and pianists do might well rhythm ’ would S one of them hear through three different pathways; enlightenment and knowledge. derive profit in a way better “We through the outer ear, through My an- heed the fact that in from a course that will be this performance his in Dalcroze suited to the Eustachian tubes through ticipated thanks to all of you! Eurythmics, now a particular shape of hand, or HEARING and bone conduction. Thus nature has planned a crescendo was built up most available to AUDIOMETRIC TEST OF carefully, many wi 1 give of hearing even music schools. more facility for pyrotechnics Audiometer and Muncie automatic tuning forks in foreground. way though any one of these pathways ( Continued on Page 405) 368 of a given kind. "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE" JULY, 1947 "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE" 369 THE ETUDE ^

daughter of quarreling Swiss Farmers. The Para- Music in the Heme Music in the Home anu “The Walk” dise Garden is an inn depicts the Mingling Voices lovers trip from the Fair to the Inn, where they earth. Sir Edward C. Bair- HERE ARE good and bad pressings spend their last hours on This is music of “Counterpoint and Harmony.” By . of F.R.C.O. Pages, 408. Prict, $5.00. records being made these days. If one set poetic pathos which Goossens plays with sym- stow, Litt.D., Mus.D., The Concerto Macmillan and Co., Limited, and Stainer T seems to have noisy surfaces we suggest pathetic understanding. is music of Publishers, that you ask permission to hear another. We have serenity and poetic beauty far removed from the and Bell, Limited. Music Lover’s Bookshelf Music at the University The Etude found by shopping around that one can acquire a Recordings With nineteenth century concertos. It is meandering Dr. Bairstow, Professor of has given us a work that is not at all like better set more often than not. However, it has and rhapsodic, the sort of thing one enjoys at of Durham, excrescenses which sometimes come been brought to our attention that many record leisure. The violin sings like a bird at times; it the complicated is progressive buyers take a set home and later in virtuoso concertos, from college halls, but rather a practical, claim it has bad never obtrusive as rather it melodies and not contrived para- surfaces. Often the reason for this is not attribut- weaves in and out of the poetic orchestral back- book in which real presented. Musicians for years have won- able to the manufacturer but to the over-use of ground. Albert Sammons, for whom the digms are Any book here concerto har- permanent needles. pickup Varied Appeal dered why counterpoint could not be taught with reviewed may A with a built-in was written, plays it wfith “rapt, lark-like ecstasy.” in be secured from stylus is not good for as both sciences are integrated countless plays—it is limited, Prokofieff: Piano Concerto No. 3 In C major, mony, inasmuch THE ETUDE MUSIC composition. Dr. and when it is used too long it musical structure and in the art of MAGAZINE at the can produce a bad Op. 26; played and conducted by Dimitri Mitro- which, together price given on playing surface on the best record set. The aver- Bairstow has a fine pedagogical mind poulos with the Robin Hood Dell Orchestra. receipt of to pro- age sapphire needle, according to scientific his sound musicianship, has enabled him or check. tests, Columbia set 667. with cash to the begins to wear around five hundred plays. As the duce a book which is a valuable contribution The recording here is not by any means as good wear increases, the damage to a record becomes study of music. The tenor and the alto clefs are used as Columbia has accomplished in other concerto more and more noticeable. Those who own pickups in four-part writing throughout the work. recordings; it is often coarse-grained, frequently with a built-in stylus are warned to have their diffused and badly balanced. The work is a strange points examined under a magnifying glass—or mixture of mechanistic effects and brood senti- Jazzvirtuoso better still a microscope—to determine when to By I d2. WereJltli (2acLman ment; the piano part is technically very difficult. “Horn of Plenty.” The Story of Louis Armstrong. get a new needle. Since a great many recordings ij Mitropoulos handles his dual roles Goffin. Translated from the French by James being released these capably but not Robert days are purely for com- Allen, always as successfully as two artists might have F. Bezou. Pages, 304. Price, $3.00. Publisher, mercial consumption and do not always represent Russian music workers who are done. Towne & Heath, Inc. the vast number of infinite details the devotion of some the artist or artists at their best, comprehended we believe it of of as hopeless radicals. Brahms: Sonata in F Minor, Op. Louis Armstrong, born in “the lowest Negro slum bring interest to each page of his book. In com- often thought best to concentrate on those that offer the best 120, No. 1; which William Orleans” on the Fourth of July, 1900, has become, world-famous Dr. Albert Einstein, in musical and interpretative value. Primrose (viola) and William Kapell New menting upon the of the most (piano). Victor set 1106. as all Jazz and Swing fanciers know, one for instance, he says of a visit to his home: Sound Science Handel-Beecham: The Great Elopement; Sir Mozart: trumpet players in his field. From poverty literature, I was amazed, when Charles A. Culver, Ph.D. Thomas Beecham and the London Philharmonic Quartet in E-flat major, K. 493; George prominent “Speaking of violin “Musical Acoustics.” By he rose to become an international figure Princeton and went The Blakiston Orchestra. Victor set 1093. Szell (piano) and members of the Budapest String and ignominy I visited Professor Einstein in Pages, 215. Price, $3.00. Publisher, his Quartet. in the realm of popular music. Loud and strident, stacks of music on his shelves and piano, Mendelssohn; Reformation Symphony, Op. 107; Columbia set 669. through the Company. could pierce any musical bulwark and his high unerring good taste of this of one of the best planned Sir Thomas Beecham and the London Philhar- The question always arises as to which instru- trumpet at the catholicity and A new and revised edition always amazing. The French author of this with a smile that a subject in monic Orchestra. Victor set 1104. ment—the viola or the clarinet—best suits notes were ‘amateur.’ The Professor pointed out and the most understandable books upon biography has caught the brilliant colors and flashing two presented to informed. It is a The first is a ballet that Sir Thomas arranged Brahms’ last two Sonatas. In our estimation, there his Bechstein grand was one of the which many teachers are not fully highlights of this remarkable virtuoso and it becomes gift of honor: the other school senior level, from the works of Handel; the story concerns the is greater expressive variety and beauty of tone in distinguished Germans as a book for students of at least high that a French touch, with a Zola-like atmos- Hindenburg. the subject. Dr. elopement of the playwright Sheridan with Primrose’s viola than in the clarinet of obvious recipient being—incongruously enough— because of the technical nature of the Weber dramatic back- phere, was needed to bring out the “After I sent the Professor my edition of Tartini’s of the Physics Department of daughter of Linley, the composer. The scoring is (Musicraft set 27). This Sonata Is a work of a Culver was former head ground of his unusual careei You will find the book stacks, he wrote: deftly accomplished and the work hangs together musical poet ruminating on the past; tinged with Concerto to add to the Carleton College, Minnesota. exceedingly readable, whether or not you are a “hep- thanks for sending me the concerto very well indeed. Purists may consider Sir Thomas melancholy and the soft hues of autumnal ‘“My hearty guilty of shadows. cat.” which you played so incomparably. I hope it will modernizing Handel, but few musical The performance here is one of admir- Tonsorial Musical Art listeners will deny that his able musicallty give me fresh courage to manhandle my fiddle performance of this especially on the part of the violist “I Heard Them Sing.” By Ferdinand Reyher. Pages, fingers: the fiddle, incidentally, music is a delight from beginning to end. The Mozart Quartet is Master Violinist with my old The the second that the com- ” 226. Price, $2.00. Publisher, Little, Brown and Com- noted British conductor gives a wholly persuasive Strings Attached. Reminiscences and Reflec- doesn’t deserve anything much better!’ ‘ — uv* UIIU uuc 1UO “With pany. reading of Mendelssohn’s Fifth Symphony, finest chamber Joseph Szigeti. Pages, 358. Price, $4.00. All in all, the book is a highly intelligent, spon- to yet we works in which we find a perfect tions.” By If music is a thing which should bring happiness of the exciting feel not even he can make Mendelssohn’s “Refor- blend of emotion Alfred A. Knopf. taneous, and entertaining preview of the art and intellect. Mr. Szell plays Publisher, its devotees, there apparently is no phase mation”—with its religious implications the piano Etude already have had the pleasure period in which Szigeti has lived and fiddled his way as appeal- part with technical skill and a nice Readers of The which produces such joyous gravity or serious hilarity ing in its entirety as his Scotch and feeling for 11 of this work, printed in advance into people’s hearts. Italian rhythmic freedom. The members of of reading Chapter as the musical masterpieces of the barber shop. Symphonies. Both works are excellently recorded. the in our issue. Szigeti, born Budapest Quartet are admirable in their tonal of publication Ferdinand Reyher, Philadelphia-born world traveling Prokofieff: American Musical Review Symphony No. 5, Op. 100; Serge warmth but the September 5, 1892, in Budapest, is a pupil of the great to many balance of the ensemble is not so newspaper correspondent and contributor Koussevitzky and the Boston Symphony Orchestra. well master, Jeno Hubay, and after succeeding “Music Comes to America.” By David Ewen. Pages, integrated as it might have been. Hungarian leading magazines, has produced a book of homely Victor set 1095. s professor in the class of violin vir- 295. Price, $3.50. Publisher, Allen, Towne and Heath, Beethoven: Sonata in C minor, Henri Marteau as appealing Americana. He takes his readers to Pro- Sibelius; Op. 13 (Pathe- and Symphony No. 4 in A minor, Op. 63; tique); Artur tuosity at the Genoa Conservatory in 1924, was induced Inc. now and Rubinstein (pia'no). Victor set 1102. fessor Ben Halper's Tonsorial Parlor, which Artur Rodzinski and the Philharmonic-Symphony Beethoven: Stokowski in 1925 to come to America. Since A republication of a work issued in 1942 by Thomas Sonata in C-sharp minor. by Leopold then breaks out with well lathered barber-shop har- Orchestra of Op. 27, of series of silhouettes New York. Columbia set 665. M ° 0nli9ht): then he has made America his home. Y. Crowell Co., consisting a cracker barrel, ^ xv.il uuiiai uuiuru Vladimir Horowitz (piano). monies. The book is as American as a Prokofieff has T , , the musical progress in America, some of which have displaced the noted Finnish composer Its appeal may not Victor °set in 5 His career has been that of a dignified artist of upon skillfully written. It be long lived but few will thii and is amusing, picturesque, and in popularity of late, yet a new h n: been published in The American Mercury, The Balti- recording of the about that. It is given Waltzin ‘ book, but rather a novel a good performance C sharp rn ' essentially a musical by Ik . n or, Op. 64. No. 2; and is not Sibelius . Etude, Ground, Coronet, De- Fourth reveals a clarity of line and intention Kurtz M^n ri°Jil S< n more Sun, The Common and well recorded. : le background. Borodin’s tone poem with 9y and s P rin g Song from Songs with a “barber shop chord” in his symphony that is Without \i ^ - cision, Tomorrow, and the Theatre Arts Monthly, to- not always apparent in the orientalism is heard w ° rdS less often today than in form ’ Vladimir Horowitz (piano). Victor Prokofieff score. The first movement of the disc ll- gether with much new and original research material. latter is times. It is well devised descriptive music, 95 i 9 diffuse and Koussevitzky, and this nf Fundamental Steps stressing inner voices, makes recording should revive interest in it. Rimsky-Kors Hinde- it even less comprehensible. A Soviet Aspect of Tchaikovsky “Elementary Training For Musicians.” By Paul Despite his more imagi- kow’s brilliant opus depicting the “legendary ivuuuistem i piano) Associated native handling ai . Victor disc 10-127 Pages, 237. Price, $4.00. Publisher, of the Scherzo and the notable Finale heathen side of “Russian Symphony: Thoughts About Tchaikovsky.” mith. the Easter holiday” is a virtuoso excePtlonal Pianistic (the sco , artistry in both of tl Inc. best movement of the work) I still think sonatas r By Dmitri Shostakovich and others. Pages, 271. Price, Music Publishers, , Rod- designed to show off an orchestra. m n Needless to say tl bringS a roman tic tl Aryan, refugee zinski’s performance was warmer and more “Path?tinu^> warmth to $3.75. Publisher, Philosophical Library, Inc. , German-American appealing. Philadelphians do a superb job, av°ld and Ormandi ng the Pedanticism of recer and recognized as one Beecham's version of the Sibelius , a What do the modern Russians, often assailed for from the tyranny of Hitlerism Symphony is more straightforward rendition of the perform an ro Serkin| music is far mo ' The work est: composers, has been for thoughtfully and tellingly played than Rodzinski’s, persuasive than mation hv -/, Profits, in our their harsh cacophony, think of the most widely played of the foremost present day Stokowski’s performance Ubl Steln s but the latter nonetheless turns of it M warmer treatment of tt Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky? The ques- time on the faculty of Yale University. This has in an unusually im- Fiedler turning to sunny Italy music HornwH f Russian master, some brings us a delightfi tZ Pays the ubi His pressive reading. Both sets are well Quitous “Moonlight” in fascinating. Here is a list of the hard to his mind -to the problems of Education. recorded, with the light work based more rlA,v i tion alone is turned on folk material of the Piedmonte. manner than string tone in the latter being most pianists; his tons under the direction is unusual, in that it does not immediately more mellow. section. It is music to which qualitv k evf™°‘' pronounce names of writers who, new book one may find it dmarnv hard - beautiful and the an of an advanced work Khatchaturian: Gayne— Ballet Suite; Efrem Kurtz resist whistling. The smoothness clarity of Shostakovich, have written this book: Boris Assafyev concern itself with the intricacies reproduction of all these recon bls perf°rmance and the Philharmonic-Symphony reveal an exactin Keldysh, B. Yarustovsky, Daniel is really a kind of drill manual for musical train- Orchestra of New ings is good. artist The f (Igor Glebov) , Yuri but 6legy ° f the York. Columbia set 664. chopin 'waltz is sub Vasili Yakovlev, Professor Arnold Al- ing. He says in his Preface: “The music student enter- Delius: The Walk to the Paradise stantiated huTnA Zhitomirsky, Borodin: Garden from Xaggerated bv Horowitz, h: general insufficiently On the Steppes of Central Asia; Village treatment - and shvang, Ksenia Davidova. ing a class in harmony is in Constant Romeo and Juliet; Eugene Goossens of h °V and tl Mendelssohn pieces is admirable fc basic principles—governing Lambert and the London Philharmonic Orchestra. Cincinnati poetic fppiino- Shostakovich comes right out with the statement, prepared with respect to Symphony Orchestra. Victor r " disc 11-949 6 * 1 1 is more their Columbia disc 71956-D. Delius: Ah appreciable in h: “There is not a single Russian composer of the latter Rhythm, Meter, Intervals, Scales, Notation—and Violin Concerto; Albert performance^ tbeh'r'f*’LisZt Sammons and tl waltz than in the Schuman been evident to most Rimsky-Korsakow: Russian Easter Overture; Liverpool Philharmonic piece Nineteenth or early Twentieth Century who is not correct application.” It has Orchestra, conducted bv and the Ma indebted in some measure to Peter Tchaikovsky.” Later American teachers that the superficial studies sufficient . colm Sargent. Columbia set 672. “With Strings Attached,” by permission of the publishers. aspire to reach an Columbia set X-267. The first From he notes: “Whenever I take up my pen to write some to meet the needs of those who is an intermezzo from the * composer’s . Sinigaglia: Danza opei c — sex, ObU. involuntarily turn to the methods amateur status are entirely inadequate to the Piemontese, Op. 31, No. 1; Arthur -a modern tragedy of boy Szigeti with his wife, Wanda, in their Garden at Palos score, my thoughts agreeable and girl lovers son an Fiedler and the Boston “Pops” Orchestra. Victor bussy IT' Ave Maria; and t Verdes, California used by this unsurpassed master of the art of com- student who looks forward to higher levels in musician- disc Aarr * oc,ues ) - La plus 11-9446. 11-9571 que lent. Victor d position.” Thereafter Shostakovich in his tribute to ship and composition. This demands time, and accord- The music of Russia may have gives a fine but short orientation of the ing to the old Continental ideal, was best acquired altered to a more b highest character, without the stigma of clap-trap Tchaikovsky proletariat ° ' ' character in modern times but the coloring R ondA° P 33; and SchUbe acquaintance has master’s work in relation to musical art. under the baton of a martinet. For the purpose in- victor fifsc publicity and Hollywod ballyhoo. His in scoring still prevails. IS’ book is admirable. Khachaturian’s “Gayne” has RECORDS been world-wide and his observations of the great per- If you are a Tchaikovsky enthusiast, and millions tended, Hindemith’s all the qualities to 1 N °cturne in E minor, Op. 7 plan, along the lines of action make it popular—rhythmic variety, and Sarasate^ he has met are charming as well as graphic. are, you will find many lights upon the works of the The book is original in Rom " A " sonages daluza ‘ 11-95 Jascha vlctor disc musical training, has Russian master and perhaps you will be surprised by in time, action in space, and coordinated action. 370 Heifetz Sm(violin) and His memory, doubtless due to his "MUSIC STUDY Emanuel Bay (piano). EXALTS LIFE’ "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE" 371 THE ETUDE JULY, 1947 : ,

Music and Study long The one-half, one-quarter, or sustained damper Music bring and Culture pedals which he requires serve to into clearer focus 2he dazzling superstructural design which he builds over the living, throbbing foundation. Witness for example his magical use everywhere of consecutive seventh and ninth chord “bottoms” for the sharp pro- jection of the higher overtone textures. The Pianist’s Page Poof! goes also that “whole tone scale” label. Com- Haw Businesslike Are You? paratively seldom in his riper periods does Debussy employ long wholetone or pentatonic successions, since he knew, perhaps better than we, the poverty of such tonalities. His so-called exotic effects are more often 2b, Wccuer produced by composing whole pieces in the old Greek modes. He uses these modes lavishly, especially in his later periods. A good example is the Toccata (“Pour Noted Pianist and le Piano Suite”) composed in the Aeolian or sixth Music Educator scale-step mode. •

contend that the business a detriment to their peace of mind, and to their teach- Debussy's Directions ANY TEACHERS side of their profession should never be men- ing. If you would become a good Debussy interpreter During investigation I had occasion to make a tioned, as it interferes with art. It does—but my follow the precise directions which he gives in all his M discovered this notice at- dental appointment, and definitely—not, however, for most of the reasons given pieces. When you can give a convincing reason for tached to appointment card. Debussy s Last Period by the majority of teachers. my momentarily disregarding the composer's direction in demand for professional And what of those last painful years of Debussy’s Music teaching has been a haphazard business ever “Due to the unusual some disputed spot—as I shall try to do later in the services existing at the present time, and in fair- life, the period during which the critics pontificated since the first music teacher hung out a shingle. Clair de lune—only then may you momentarily stray. to patrons on our waiting list, it is necessary that his creative capacity had deteriorated? We know Pupils and their parents, usually the mothers, request ness Otherwise, I advise the most accurate and literal read- to require at least twenty-four hours notice, re- . now that these were years of exploration in fruitful lessons, and you set aside certain periods of the week fields ing of his explicit markings. gardless of the cause for cancellation. and of experimentation along new paths, with for them. The pupil intends to take the lessons as “Otherwise a charge for the appointment must results that are by no means meagre. scheduled, but sometimes it is not convenient, so you made.” To be sure, the “Twelve Etudes for Piano,” and the The Clair de lune make up the lesson later, or cancel it altogether, which be “Blanc dentist said it had solved many situations, but et Noir Suite” for two pianos of this last period If you will think of the Clair de lune as a rising gives your budget the jitters, and you are irritated. My it still not an ideal . The mem- are not understood by the public, or in fact by most arch of tone which reaches the apex of its curve in Sometimes you schedule two or three different ap- that was dental association feel that they should not pianists. But give them time! . . for so bers of the . The next years will Measure 41, from there descending gradually to the soft pointments for one lesson. This has gone on see penalized for patron’s negligence. these highly original masterpieces fully explored dark shimmer of the final Measures, 66-72, you will long that most teachers think they will always have be and appreciated, I attached the same notice, worded differently, to especially now in the face of the pre- understand why the piece is an almost perfect example to continue with the same unbusiness-like procedure. vailing Parents or pupils did notify me of a sterility of the pianistic produce offered us in of formal design. If, in addition, you can picture your- Some teachers, who charge large fees, have secre- my statements. this generation. These cancellation twenty-four hours in advance, but the “Twelve Etudes” and the three self resting at the edge of a lake or the sea (with taries who make it quite clear to parents of prospective pieces of the were missed, and situation, financially, had “White and Black Suite” are astonishing someone you like very much, of course!) waiting in pupils that lessons are to be paid for several weeks in lessons my examples of musical improved very much. Then I decided to make a and technical fecundity. Their the soft, velvet starlight for the moon to rise—then advance, and are to be taken as scheduled, with no not strength lies in their drastic change. During the following week I sent a Debussy sparse, economical, quasi- you will understand how to play Measures 1-7. Think refunds, no makeup lessons, no credits for missed les- “March Mozartean style and content. letter to the parents of all pupils, and then sat down 26, 1918: The great offensive is on at last, There is hardly a note of three-quarter meter instead of nine-eighth, and play sons. This discussion is not for them, but for the and we are breathless padding in the pieces which surprise their in fear and trembling to wait for the telephone calls with excitement. The hundred and delight at in strict time with soft pedal and with clear, translu- thousands of teachers in towns and cities who do men who arrived last every turn. They are quite T I sure would come in, transferring pupils to other night on leave were called back unlike the piano composi- cent singing .- fine work, w ho produce out- was tone . . (metronome own bookkeeping, who do about J. = 52—56.) to the line again today, poor fellows! It looks tions of Debussy’s earlier periods; and for office management is teachers. This was the letter: serious. as “modern Like the slow rhythm of the waves let your music standing pupils, and whose . . idiom” . For two days now Paris has been bombarded by one of them out-Schoenberg's Schoenberg as “roll” lessons, practicing, dusting, run- San Diego, California. a in two-measure swings—Measure 1 is active, squeezed in between RUTH TEEPLE REID a gun, 75 miles away. During fifteen pioneer essay in the so-called twelve Dear Mary and John: minute intervals tone scale. (See (louder) Measure 2 is passive, ning the vacuum, and so forth. from The (softer) thus dawn to dusk the Germans have been terrorizing Etude Pour Les Notes Repetees.) For my entire music teaching career I had been That I may fully use my time and talents in teach- the .” While inhabitants of the city. . you are taking a ing pupils I have always preferred to manage the . summer off to get acquainted annoyed by the necessity for doing something about my ready on time. those with last period little business When lines were written in my World War I Debussy works, study also the charm- missed lessons; making them up; rescheduling them business end of my teaching with as Tuition is due and payable monthly in advance, and diary there ing set of short was no time to record that Claude Debussy “Epigraphs Antiques,” composed in in an already full schedule at the request of mothers as possible, changing the regulations. and requirements pupils will be enrolled on that basis. If I should be had died 1915. These that day in nearby Paris. Three days later, were written for piano duet, but sound who did not mean to be unreasonable, but who had as circumstances required. For several months I have unable to give a lesson it will be refunded. Lesson time when his body was borne through better on two pianos. Their titles that the present system of giving music the city to be buried match the supersen- — UVUW.U uau iiutca iUl LWU lull given no thought to what these extra hours of labor been aware used by me, with telephone calls, car trouble and so in Pere la Chaise, the sitive music: To entry reads: Evoke Pan, God of the Summer Wind; beats. Count aloud, and continue the two-measure ac- might mean to me. There are always so many good lesson time needs reorganizing. Former methods of forth, will be made up. Extra time given at lessons “The frightful battle is still raging. For a Nameless Tomb; That the tivity been setting aside time for pupils who took their lessons The Germans Night May Be Propi- and passivity character throughout the piece. reasons why pupils miss their lessons: They have shall be considered “overtime” and will be used if and have gained some ground, but the Allies are holding tious; To Thank the Rain in the Morning, At Measure school; when they could; made them up later or cancelled and so forth. 9 the moon rises slowly from the horizon. ill a day or two and have work to make up at where necessary, as make-up time. Tuition for missed like bulldogs. . . . Debussy was buried today. Notice them, is not conducive to steady progress in music, nor What a how calmly it emerges to the same theme as they haven’t practiced; the child had to go to the lessons will not be refunded, nor credited, excepting for tragic moment for the world to lose such a man!” Measure see her was in the to my peace of mind. Neglected and Brilliant 1, excepting that the span of the “rise” is doctor, and the only time he could the reasons stated above, in this paragraph. With the Germans Pieces hammering at the gates of Paris, now three octaves, her music lesson time; a daughter During September there were 22 missed lessons. You It is desire intention to charge for Pianists neglect some of Debussy’s most rewarding and the syncopation of the first afternoon, during not my nor you this was scarcely the moment to ponder on the pass- measure will agree, I am sure, that something should be done music. At least half a dozen of the second has disappeared. Brush the tones lightly and had to have a permanent. something you will not receive. It is with the idea ing of one shy, book of sensitive spirit who had long been ill transparently book several months ago I about this. No business could remain solvent very “Preludes” . . account of little are unaccountably passed by; the long . again, hold the dotted half (Meas- Going over my putting a modem system into my business and exhausted, and whose creative de- output, according lightful ballet written ure 10) for its full the startling discovery that in one month les- long if 25% of its budget was suddenly cut off. You methods that these changes have been made. I believe (about 1910) for piano, La °Boite value. At Measure 15 Debussy made to the critics of his day, had slimmed in quantity directs steps and a Joujoux the Romance of the Toy Tempo Rubato. Pick sons to the amount of fifty-five dollars had been can- would probably take to remedy the situation if it to be to your advantage that we have a definite slumped in quality. Chest—is almost up the tempo here a unknown. And and four pupils had changed their lessons to your monthly income was cut $55.00. Studio expenses what has happened to the exquisite sure to sound the exquisitely repeated celled, and understanding of these provisions and the reasons for v, “Petite Suite” of cnords (pianissimo!) different days temporarily. The shock to my finances do not diminish when pupils miss lessons. them. I shall glad to talk Debussy’s first period? Its four short like silvery ripples. Play the low be these provisions over with Debussy's Rating Today movements written originally for piano a tS f toned and was like a pitcher of ice water poured over me, and Public schools are run on tax money—your money, you, before you sign and return this contract, if and duet ^' richJ • • (like the y- • Hold the damper ^lT , n But now, almost thirty years later, let “Epigraphes Antiques”) dal aI1 thr°ugh the worst of it was; this situation had been going on and mine, and yet we do not receive a rebate on our when you wish. us look at sound enchantingly on two ? Measures 15, 16, 17, to the last chord the score. Who are the most beloved pianos. Pianists are warned asure I®- for years and years, and was likely to go right on un- taxes when our children miss one day, or several French composers? against a published “ar- tkm't forget the two-measure rise and Cordially yours, Bizet, fail ^ Gounod, Ravel, Debussy, with the timid Claude rangement” of this suite for two pianos. m Measures less I did something pretty drastic about it, at once. weeks of school. Private schools, music schools, uni- CONTRACT . . . The W. 21, and 23 how the melody Achille original ’ gaining each year. He has not inched ahead in version is far superior on all ac 1V® J as though versities, and some of my music teacher friends have San Diego, California. counts. , a masculine voice said, “I popularity, he has Few students you New Method is Devised leaped ahead. For ever learn ’ °a ing”— A known for years that it is both necessary and desirable a long time his the glowing Isle Joyeuse '| and subsides in 22, anri Measures 20, 194 Clair de lune has been selling to the tune of Debussy’s most brilliant piano h the to take long view of the business of educating thousands piece, which makes a ,™ feminine answer, “Oh. I'm glad that Music Teachers! Has that happened to you too? Of a Young oi copies per week in corking final voi, l I have read the aDove letter, covering the require- this country alone. number for any ’ ’ • Many of his program. Among other Which may sound dangerously like a course it has. In taking stock of my pupils and their America, and they require their students to register other ments for enrollment in the TEEPLE compositions are not far behind in popularity. dashing items the Toccata and the ad b UTdum people. for least semester, their RUTH REID Fireworks are of .° - but conveys the idea! parents, I found them to be fine, reasonable at a paying tuition a semester f l Almost everybody knows the Arabesques, the course, the most popular; for a n™ lat MUSIC STUDIOS and I agree to abide by each and all Minstrels, brilliant piece for not d°ubtful direction, un poco mosso, at The fathers were educator-administrators, professional in advance. Tuition is not refunded, regardless of the the Submerged Cathedral, the Maid With the too advanced students, teachers the out,.!! , of them. It is my understanding that these lessons are Flaxen often use the Prelude secori<* theme in 27: up top-flight executives, with substantial in- reason. Hair, until v»pr h! Measure men, and the Reflections on the Water, the Afternoon a in A Minor from the “Pour le Piano to be taught by RUTH TEEPLE REID, personally. of Suite.” metric unit has been eighth notes, comes men who run their businesses and professions And so, beginning the first of October, 1945, pupils Faun. Debussy’s high popularity At Mpncnr, — rating runs counter 27 nd for several Parents’ Signatures to Pages thereafter this with secretaries and book-keepers. I took my problem will register, and lesson periods will be set aside for all accepted measurements for such appeal. His uit bennm!S S1Xteenths? • Bubbles ’ automatically setting the pace pupils. suggested one of for five months or more. melodies possess neither the faster to the fathers of three They them Use of this reserved sentimentality of Tchai- May I prick m he a couple of popular Debussy preceding Tempo Rubato sec- price cover the their responsibility. One or two mothers called to ask questions about kovsky nor the sugar of Chopin. bubbles’ ! two alternatives; either raise my to time will be Missed lessons will not They do not strain Pool! goes that “impressionistic” al ady or seduce. label. This item an directed a gradual accel- losses sustained by cancelled lessons, or stop giving be made up, although pupils may request permission what arrangement I would make if their children con- They are neither obvious nor lush. Could ferando Ti if- ? plied to Debussy is vapid and misleading. ) theii secret Debussy was “ iate * refunds, credits, make-up lessons. to change the time or day of their lesson, tracted a contagious disease and were not able to take be that, like the lilies of the field «5?o :° under cer- they a master of tight u e 27. . form and spare content. Like tLjsr. t. Even if the preceding tempo toil not, neither do they Mozart’s is hpiri iho I also consulted several of the best teachers in San tain circumstances. their lessons for two or three weeks. I was tactful (I spin? his « ^ Pace wiu compositions emerge as pure, concentrated actually sound faster, Whatever it is, essences’ Trf firm mark up another miracle; the public 3 Diego, and found nearly all used the same system I Pupils who arrive late will receive the balance of hope) but in explaining that in the future, music There is nothing vague or approximate about nd simUar melodic shapes, increase has taken Debussy to its heart like nobody’s them the tonp used. They wished they could change the system, but their time, as any other arrangement works a great lessons and house rent or car payments would be put business! Debussy’s line and color are cleanly n° te of is cut; his music the third beat (C-flat) He not only one of the most favored then^ecreasp frankly admitted they didn’t know how. They agreed hardship on all pupils who follow. Pupils should upon the same basis. Rent is not refunded when par- Frenchmen requires a Mozartean clarity and a ??d hesitate ar- but one of the most delineation which sbghtly on the final D-flat. beloved composers of all can be produced As vou J f that the constant irritation of a shifting income was range to arrive at the studio five minutes early, to be ents go on a vacation, remaining several weeks; it is only by a perfectly controlled the moon rising, technic. (Measures * measures 27-36),27 YTAT*finally * ( Continued 374) 372 on Page "MUSIC LIFE "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE” JULY, 1947 STUDY EXALTS 373 THE ETUDE

t ”

followed, General the huge reception that Clay re- Study you for a given period of time. people could have Music and Music and Study marked that if the more ‘good will* venture into the unknown had Publicizing this new own job would be easier! as such music, his not refunded when people are in a hospital, and so not occurred to me, but the news got around, “And coming out of such experiences, I believe that have called, requesting forth, and cars are repossessed when payments are not things do. Other music teachers be more than ever have we, in America, should appreciative forthcoming time. copies of the letters. Pupils in my normal classes on musical riches which we are inclined, off on the of the perhaps, The legality of the “contract” before the asked for it, as they say they wish to “get was checked for granted. Looking at miracles for to take somewhat the world letters were printed. It is legal, and binding. right foot first.” The change has worked care- picture as a whole, let us remember that music is the One parent requested a paragraph, written in, which one studio. The mothers of pupils are much more language, the one substance, that reaches all have definite practice one hearts “Decide” to Be a Singer! would cancel the entire contract if the family should ful to see that their children You Don’t periods. and that can do the greatest good in bringing the move to a town or city more than fifty miles from periods, and the parents respect the practice peoples of the world together in closer understanding. San Diego. This I was glad to do. Another parent put Interrupted practice is a thing of the past. The fathers I were the State Department, I should subsidize forth the argument that doctors and dentists are pro- have said, “Why didn’t you do this years ago?” Pupils If finest artists so that they could go to Europe A Conference with fessional people too, but do not charge for cancelled come on time, making a habit of it, for they know they our and America there musically!” appointments, if made far enough in advance. I ex- will get only what is left of their lesson period. Tardi- bring plained that when going to the doctor’s office, a flat fee ness is a habit, and seldom necessary. When you know is charged for an office call. A patient has the doctor’s it to be, you can do something about it, if you wish. attention for from three to thirty minutes, likewise the Bills are paid on or before the tenth of the month, and Ok omaA X OkomaA dentist who has a fixed scale for different types of they really are, when parents sign a contract so stating. The Pianist's Page work. The appointments are made according to the If you try this method, you will be relieved when you Distinguished Baritone work to be done. count up your pupils; multiply them by your lesson fee, (Continued from Page 372) Music teachers charge a certain price for a definite and then realize you will have that income every month flooding the water, the trees and you with its chaste period of time. That time is set aside for the pupil, from the day you put your parents on a contract. You SECURED EXPRESSLY FOR THE ETUDE BY STEPHEN WEST white waves of light, (Measures 37-41). From Measure once or twice a week usually for the entire school sea- can look ahead to the future, realizing that the steady, 42 to 65 the rays become more and more oblique, son, or more. Why, therefore, should music teachers reliable income enables you to plan ahead, which is the light fades, the shadows deepen, until in Measures have to schedule that thirty minute lesson two or three something many music teachers are not able to do 66-72 the moon disappears behind the pines, of millions Americans through his magnificent times to earn the fee? Parents agree that they can under their present arrangement. This program has leaving Thomas L. Thomas has won the enthusiastic admiration of you (and your friend!) in the starry- velvet darkness. voice and his completely natural, unaffected interpretations. Best known for his many broadcasts over never pay the music teacher what the lesson is really been in operation for several months; long enough to all the maior radio networks, he has also earned distinction for his recordings, and on his recital touri worth. They understand that they are merely paying test its practical working ability. Only the cooling murmur of the water and a fragment throughout the United States. Born in Maesteg, South Wales, Mr. Thomas grew up in the typically Welsh of the ardent second themq, float through the air. atmosphere of music appreciation. His town (of five thousand) had its own local orchestra, two oratorio Teachers should not assign the Clair de lune until societies, and numerous church choirs each of which gave special oratorio performances; and from the they have carefully Angered it, especially Measures was faithful visitor at both rehearsals and performances. Even in such a THOMAS L. THOMAS age of four on, young Thomas a 37-42. These measures are better A Musical Tour of Europe Today controlled if Measure general musical atmosphere, young Thomas' household was specifically gifted. His mother sang and his 37 is begun softly, if crescendo rather than accellerando father (after beginning his career in the coal mines) won three notional awards for flute playing, pursued is thought, and if the left hand dotted quarters his studies as Fellow of the Royal Academy, in London, and became flautist of the London Philharmonic. (.Continued from Page 365) (on “ r I \ HE PROFESSIONAL singer is often asked a the beats) In the United States he has played flute obbligati at concerts for celebrated soloists including Lily Pons. are well accented and consciously held back. question which it is not easy to answer. Aspiring Thomas can remember no period of his life when he was not vigorously active in music, tracing his public But, of course, it is in Measures 41 and 42 that students A. students want to know exactly how a successful recitals—all crowded. including stage hands, presented me with a diamond performances back to his fifth year when he appeared in children's cantatas. When he was eleven, the go haywire. It is a pity that these two climactic meas- career may be built. There is but one answer: learn “It is most stimulating for a musician to visit these replica of the Legion of Honor cross. Many of those Thomas family settled in Pennsylvania, where the boy continued singing in amateur performances through- ures should so often ruin the performance. Therefore, the vocal craft and then put it into active use! It is lands, and to realize the truly important need for dear out elementary and high school. He entered Johnson Technical School, prepared himself os a mechani- colleagues had been there when I made my debut; for students who are technically wobbly, I alter the seldom a satisfying reply, however; many young people cal engineer and draftsman, entered business, and became an assistant executive in an engineering firm music . . . not as an entertainment or a bit of or fun remembered me as a young girl—all of them had un- left hand slightly, thus: seem to feel that there are special and mysterious when he was but twenty-two years old, finding his best recreation, all the while, in singing with the local a means of passing an evening, but as a vital factor dergone the cruelest hardships and could have found ‘secrets’ which, once mastered, can unlock the door of glee club. And then the lure of music grew too much for him. He came to New York, sang in various in human life and human rebuilding, without which, use for their francs without buying a diamond cross successful singing. ‘How do you breathe?’ they ask; churches, and began a difficult attack on the air waves, from which he emerged as victor after ninety- apparently, there is no true completeness. It is for a won- me! I have no words to describe the magnitude six auditions. voice and musicianship earned praise; each time the praise ‘what do you do with your chest, your diaphragm, Each time the young candidate's derful thing to see, your and a fine thing to ponder on! of that emotional experience. And, question, is has ever heard of him!" And so Thomas deter- at the end of the throat, your back?’ foundered on the "Yes, but who he? Nobody are not And at that point, I am properly Here a few, but thousands and thousands of opera, although Amneris does not appear all mined to make himself heard. In the following . conference. Mr. Thomas tells readers of The Etude what at in the stumped possibly people, — because I have my own theories — Editor's Note. poor, uncomfortable, burdened down with hard- final scene, there was such tumult in the house that I a professional career in music actually means. about singing. I believe that singing must be entirely ships and bitter memories, all turning to music as the had to be wheeled out twelve times! natural, entirely simple—entirely unhampered by me- first and most important soul-tonic to make them “After that, I was invited by Generals McNarney chanical restrictions whole. I of ‘method’ or ‘school’! wish I had a lot of pictures of some of the and Clay to sing some Christmas concerts for the seven ‘learn’ to throw a ball—to understand the differ- stand beside him all his life, making signs as to what halls I saw—bare, decayed halls, badly lighted, yet troops in Germany. I had planned to appear etc. in the The Importance of Musicianship ence between a catcher and an outfielder? Well, he is and what is not being properly done. He must learn crowded with people in overcoats, hunched up to keep Scandinavian countries and to be home for Christ- himself, his sensations. “How do I breathe? Truly, I haven’t the least idea. I doesn’t learn it—he absorbs it, as part of the very air to guide through own And warm, yet looking ecstatically towards the platform mas—but I couldn’t resist that invitation! After my breathe he breathes. That’s the way music ranks in Wales, and that requires intelligence. The born singer doesn't where there was simply—music. I should like in giving naturally. The purpose of breathing is, not to send concert Berlin, General clay asked preparatory - me to give the exercises first, thus: is easily can't simply to sing, but to keep alive; if a natural breath the it a splendid start! The Welsh people have a natural get discouraged —he —he has got such a picture to every comfortable, warmly clad, well first concert for the combined Allied — staffs. The audi- feeling for vocal music. The smallest town has at least to sing! fed person who complains of being bored! kind that you drew as a baby—is good enough to keep ence of four thousand, in the Titania Palast, was en- Ex. 3 you alive, it's one oratorio society, and everyone is part of it. I well tirely by good enough to let you sing. It seems to invitation and included some 1,200 ‘screened’ Value oi Practical Experience A Thrilling Experience me that the chief function of the good vocal teacher remember seeing the men of our town come home from Germans—those who had passed tests for loyalty and is simply to keep you doing natural things in a natural a day’s hard work in the mines, eat their supper, “Intelligence and persistence, then, count for far “My own wonderful experiences abroad impressed me democracy and are held fit to lead in the rehabilitation way. Of course, if there are functional difficulties, these freshen themselves up, and then set out to walk five more in the long run than rules out of the book. Re- even more deeply with the gallant spirit alive there. I of their land. It was a most ‘glittering’ audience, since or six miles to rehearsal. All evening, they would polish pursued studies in all the military must be overcome—but such difficulties are not natural. cently, I listened to a young chap with a phenomenal my own France and began my career appeared in full-dress uniform! I was Where the vocal tract is normal up the ‘Elijah’ or the ‘Messiah,’ working at phrasing, voice. He sang a song of Brahms; I recognized its at the Paris Opera, where I was accepted as pension- assisted by the Berlin Philharmonic, and sound, the only and sang Tchai- at expression, sending out naturally pure tones enjoy- naire directly kovsky problems that can possibly arise, in this entirely nat- — melody—but the words? I asked him in which language after I came from Australia. Since the (who had been banned by the Nazis) and ural act of singing, are due to acquired bad habits. And, ing themselves! Then they’d walk back home, around he had been singing, and he answered, in German! first requisite at the Paris Opera is the ability to sing Wagner (who had been banned since the war). The one in the morning, and be up and ready for the next French program leaflets alas, we have many of them! What the good teacher Now, I started out by saying that this fellow had a fine in without foreign accent, there are very few were printed in four languages At must then, is day’s work in the pits at six. The whole family learned English-speaking pensionnaires. I remained there for LJT. do, to guide his students so that bad voice. Actually, though, I am not too confident about the oratorios the most minute details of every phrase three years, and became the youngest Brunnhilde, and habits do not arise. After that, the wisest thing is to — his success—because he lacked the intelligence to per- leave —and when the great day of the performance arrived, Salomd, ever to appear at the Paris Opera. these ~v nature alone. Either you do breathe naturally, fect his language work before setting out on auditions. For « ouxpiifcuig now tms simplifies the passage, and or you don’t. If and one heard these glorious works sung by a massed reasons, I have always kept a deep love for the French ow impossible you do, keep on doing so and forget Evidently, he hasn’t realized that no conductor, or it is even for a listener familiar with about it don’t question and doubt chorus of 1,200 of one’s own townspeople, one felt that manager, is going to take the time to teach him what people, and during the early years of the war, I went ANNOUNCEMENT 40 detect — and examine your- it; ' • • • The right hand of Measures i £ self! If you not breathe he had a proper share in it all. if realize there to sing for the troops. During the occupation, of 414 and1^4042 remains do naturally, your teacher will he ought to know. And he doesn’t that at the THE ETUDE takes pleasure in unchanged. help course, I could not go and deeply regretted my enforced announc- Be sure you to overcome whatever faulty habit is holding start, how far can he expect to go in one of the most to play the first theme’s return (Measure Singers are Born ing that it has you back. And once this habit has been overcome, for- highly competitive professions in the world? I have absence. What was my joy, then, when, in October of acquired a short series 1 ) very clearly; of otherwise it will is fade out, since it get about it! “Now, the mere study of rules out of a text-book an idea that this young man is one of those who decided 1946, I was chosen as the only soloist at a great gala articles of unusual interest written m the high from reaches of the treble. To project put on by the Red Cross to raise melodies “The technical aspects of voice production have, doesn’t give that approach. It surprises me, sometimes, to become a singer! funds for penicillin. in this thin register effectively requires swift, fine At the invitation of the French Government, I comparatively speaking, but little to do with the all- to hear a lad say that he learned OV Man River, “Thorough musicianship, sensitive taste, sound feel- was 1011 t° UCh ' * ’ and do,1,t forget around and such applause when he sang it at party, flown to Paris, and I can assure you that I did my Andres De Segurola thatSrp'etol” picture of a vocal career! Naturally, a singer got a ing, a knowledge of languages and of all the other very best! We raised an must have a fine singing voice and he must use his that he has now decided to become a singer. You don’t craftsmanlike essentials, alert intelligence, persever- encouraging amount for the 61 ed^^ " eminent leading ® on of tbe Clair de lune will soon penicillin (Sir Alexander Fleming spoke at the con- baritone of the Metro- hpTnhiitv, ^ T voice properly. The point is, however, that neither decide to become a singer—either you are born a singer, ance—all these are quite as important as a natural N0t a wishy" washy, emasculated version, voice nor ‘method’ or are not. one is singer will cert), and the musical and patriotic enthusiasm evi- politan Opera Company for but a cii mi can be mastered by studying a book you The who born a have voice and sound production habits. And when our young many years 1 y asier yet richly denced at affair sonorous arrangement of rules. And even when they have a voice and a sense of judging when he is using it the was a thing to remember. whirh i j been mastered, the candidate for honors has mastered them—what then? Later, and now a distinguished teacher grade of voice. students can ay problem of channeling correctly. will by of I was decorated with the Cross of the Legion of Honor. mabTv ToTOT P> P^- them into a career still remains He know the feeling ease and Ah, then begins a second cycle of ‘musts!’ He must Mr. De Segurola teachers can teach without conscience We drove to the Quai d’Orsay, and Madame Bideau, literally "knew every- qualms to be settled! freedom that permeates his entire being when he sings. develop himself through experience. How does a great the wife of the Premier, presented me with the award. body" in opera and his “My own experience inclines me to tackle the ques- His teacher will show him what to do, of course, but doctor perfect himself? He studies, of course—but he recollections of 1"1161 that Debussy like is a That, of course, was a magnificent experience—but the great sinsm^nm^ - Mozart, tion from a very different angle. Having had the ad- no teacher can do it for him—neither can a teacher climaxes natural aptitude and thorough study with stars are g cornposer - most interesting and Every curve, every color, even more touching was a sort of second award that nmfn phrase, vantage of a childhood in Wales, I believe that the practical experience, in every least aspect of his pro- significant historically. SUng to the hilt can followed. I was invited to sing Amneris The series will No human voice first requisite for the serious musician is, quite simply, fession. And the gaining of experience, which alone in ‘Aida,’ at be- produce Tif SdtaEf mering ' s arkling my ‘old home,’ the Paris Opera, gin in the September P melodic line which musicianship. Where I grew up, music was in the air, brings surety, is easy matter, in any and between the third issue. DebiTsv7 ev t independent no the ianist feet, and fourth acts, the entire company of my colleagues, P ’.S hands and as a popular diversion, quite as baseball is in the air VOICE profession. My own experience of ninety-six auditions Where wtn^* JOOfind more enchanting and subtle in- here. How the strumpntni , does average American boy of six or gives me a very sympathetic (Continued on Page 406) umental melody than 374 in (Continued on Page 406 ) "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE" THE ETUDE JULY, 1947 "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE 375 Music und Study HERE are more and more requests for infor- use of the organ with Music and Study mation regarding the T other instruments. There are questions as to repertoire, and there are questions as to the effective- ness of other instruments with the organ. Also ques- tions are asked regarding the proper technique in registration so that the particular instruments will go well together. In future articles we shall discuss the various combinations. In this article we shall deal The Organ-Piano Combination with the organ and piano, which is perhaps the most widely used combination and one for which the most information is requested. Later, I shall write on the organ and violin, organ and harp, organ and ’cello, organ and trumpet, and organ and ensembles of ln Sbr. JlLaruL WcCuU strings and woodwinds. f CASADESUS GABRIEL PIERNE* To say that there is a wealth of material written for CAMILLE SAINT-SAENS JULES MASSENET ROBERT Editor, Orjjan Department CESAR FRANCK ISIDOR PHILIPP the piano and organ is to make a decided misstate- ment. There is little written that is good, little that can be even made effective. Some of it is so bad that is delight, I have found that the use with the piano of too it is ludicrous. Some of the things, however, that have some by Haydn. The Schumann A minor a super couplers, celestes, and tremolos which are been written, for example, by Clifford Demorest are also the Grieg, and others. Perhaps the most effective many I do not Basic Policies and Traditions arrangements by Mendelssohn. This is played speedy, does not make for good blending. effective; and here and there we find is the one in G minor this a rule because there are many which are effective. However, our wealth of material, so seldom these days, but it is one of the most beauti- want to make organs on which, if one does not use super couplers so to speak, is found in the things that we can make ful concerti of this period of composition. It is not a there is brilliance at all. Again there are many available and adaptable ourselves. In making these long concerto and its movements are connected. The no organs which have their celestes so well voiced that arrangements, we can consider two things at the out- concerto is one that practically every good pianist Df a Famous Music School fine pianist they will fit into an ensemble of soft stops and should set, first the use of the organ as the solo instrument, plays. (It always thrills me the way every with careful thought the using the piano as the accompaniment; second, the knows the entire repertoire of his instrument, and we be so used. I am sure that organist can very soon tell whether or not the tone use of the piano as the solo instrument with the organ organists know so little of our instrument’s repertoire.) will with the piano. The tremolo, for example, as an accompaniment. The Mendelssohn Concerto affords the virtuoso pianist used go the Paris soft Some of the Principles Indicating Why excellent opportunity for technical display and for if it is not too violent, perhaps should be used in fast throbbing type; The Organ as the Solo Instrument real elegant tone and poetical feeling. The second combinations; but beware of the Conservatoire Has Been Historically Successful We can begin, of course, with the Concerti by piano part which may be easily arranged for the it just cannot be used. When the super couplers are such as four foot octave or a two George Frideric Handel of which a number of editions organ lends itself better than most of them. The used with stops a of are available. They are arranged, for example, in the orchestral effects are endless, the ensemble of the foot stop, they will squeal and sound terribly out pitch tierces, Breitkopf and Haertel Edition so that the organ part organ seems to fold itself well into the ensemble with tune with the piano. Off stops such as and the piano or cembelo part are printed on the the piano. The solo orchestral sound which one can nazards, and mixtures have to be used with care. Then same page. They are most effective with a small obtain from the organ may be used time and again, if they are used with super couplers as well we get a 1/Yjaurice 2)umednil chamber orchestra, but they can be done very well throughout the Concerto. One must not forget the terrible sound from the two instruments. When play- with the use of the piano only. The organ parts are Tchaikovsky B-flat and many others too numerous to ing with a piano, it is always better to be a bit on the Member Df the Juries and Examination Committees for Many Years not easily done but are worth working on and prepar- mention. conservative side than to take too many chances with ing well. The possibilities for ensemble even with the There are shorter numbers which may be considered. bizarre registration. Take your chances when you are piano give opportunity for some thoughtful prepara- The slow movements of any of the concerti mentioned playing alone. the begin with are Numbers not wish to use a OWARD end of the eighteenth century a posed respect. At his death in 1842 Auber succeeded tion. The most useful ones to above may be used when one does period of great musical Five, Number Five in major gives the organists want to use the piano Advance Preparation Necessary ALEXANDRE GUILMANT activity manifested itself him. The author of “Fra Diavolo,” “La Muette de Two, and Ten. F whole concerto. Many GUSTAVE CHARPENTIER possibilities for in importance of practice cannot be stressed too T in Paris. The turmoil of the French Revolution Portici,” “Le Domino noir” and organ an excellent opportunity. The with the organ in Preludes or special numbers The other operatic favorites had had a widespread effect on the Arts; the inventive registration are endless. The tutti passages regular services or in special services. We must not strongly. The organist should have his part well poets of the past was kind and fatherly, a man of fixed wrote inflamed verses and Odes to Liberty while the habits for are so well written that one can use a part of the full forget that we can arrange such things, for example, polished before he even meets his pianist. He should whom precision and order always came first. musicians, their inspiration kindled by patriotic en- His period organ and still have it sound as though much more as Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring, very effectively for have his registration worked out well in advance. Then was one of tranquillity and prosperity for thusiasm, exalted the new order in compositions often the school, organ were being used. The lilting passages can be piano and organ. One way may be for the organ to do when the rehearsals begin he can experiment. A lot of and he occupied his post for almost thirty combining sincerity with grandiloquence bombast. done on the brightest quality of tone with all sorts of the chorale and let the piano do the running parts what he has prepared may be wrong, but the whole and years until death took him in 1871 during the Franco- movement, background will great help. is always so much Previously in 1784, King Louis XVI had signed a decree Prussian off pitch stops and light mixtures. The slow and again one may wish to arrange it so that the be of It war, at the ripe old age of ninety. Then Am- establishing a music school in which Gossec one of the most lovely passages ever written, can be piano does the chorale and the organ does the running easier to make a change here and there for the better acted as brose Thomas was called, and the famous author of real things as the one knows well what he wants to do and has director, and Piccini taught voice. Out of this played on the warmest kind of combinations with part. This is also possible with such when embryonic “Mignon” continued the splendid work of his pre- effect. There also opportunities for exquisite use his practiced it. In playing ensemble music of any kind organization the Conservatoire was born in are some chorale, Stieep May Safely Graze. One must 1800, when decessors. He, too, served for a long period of twenty- solo stops in this slow movement. It is possible to use imagination and do the thing which is most effective it is important for the artists to see each other and Bernard Sarrette took over the directorship and five years, until he passed away in launched a new and ambitious 1896. Theodore all of these concerti with telling effect; I simply take with the 'organ available, and the pianist who col- be able to hear the other well. This is very difficult if more program. Dubois occupied the chair until his resignation in 1905 this one for example. The parts where the piano plays laborates. not impossible, sometimes. Every effort should be made Sarrette was well fitted for this position, as he com- and next in the line came the bined exquisite and distin- are not virtuoso type things, and any good pianist can Questions arise regarding the use of the piano and to have the piano near enough to the console so that GABRIEL FAURE' the musicianship of an excellent band leader gutshed composer, Gabriel Faure, whose enjoy playing real pleasure. There are There are cases the proper balance can be secured. are inclined to with the efficiency of a forceful activities ex- AUBER them with the organ in accompaniments. many We promoter. Under his tended until 1920 when a DANIEL-FRAN(JOIS growing deafness obliged him opportunities for producing beautiful tone and for the in which this is unwise. With a large chorus there may think that it is entirely the responsibility of the or- guidance the scope of the school was broadened until o cede the directorship to Henri Rabaud. the organ. With limitations placement the balance, the curriculum included Thus one sees weaving of the tone from the piano to be physical due to poor of ganist to effect good but much depends upon more or less what it does that during the long term of one hundred and forty careful thought out attention to detail, the organist organ which make it practically impossible for the the pianist. If the latter takes pains with his instru- nowadays: piano, voice, all branches of string and years only seven men assumed that can make his tonal build-up simply melt into the chorus to get the rhythm or at times the pitch. It is a ment and the organist is careful with his part no woodwind instruments, organ, theory, harmony, directorship' This coun- is an amazing fact, eloquent in itself, and at once piano tone. great help to have the piano play a part which will doubt some fine work will result. terpoint, composition, chamber music, orchestra, and comes to mind it when the question is The concerti Pietro for the organ are cer- give the desired sound. With a large chorus in an The tuning of the piano to the organ is sometimes dramatics. Those asked- what is it by Yon early years were very fertile, and on tha makes the Conservatoire de tainly worth serious consideration. Here again are oratorio like the Brahms’ “Requiem,” the organ is a major difficulty. There are many organs that are the staff one saw the names of Gretry, Mehul, and Paris such a high “ls 1 ltutl0n ’ and Probably the pieces which were originally written for use with or- most effective (when no orchestra is available) when tuned to 435 and most pianos are tuned to 440. In this Gossec again. When Cherubini i . finest all-around took the helm in 1822 music school in 1 the world? chestra, but now arranged so that the piano can take used in the massed effects, allowing the piano to take case it is much better, if not the only thing possible a still greater period began. Soon the institution grew The answer can be summed up in three the orchestral parts. The pianist must consider his job the rhythmic background. to have the piano tuned to the organ. If one begins considerably, both artistically and materially. Apart tradition, formality, and discipline. seriously, seizing every opportunity possible to make Recently I heard a performance of the "Messiah” to have the organ that is at 435 put up to 440, he really from his musicial eminence, Cherubini’s firmness of First let us consider “tradition.” the part that he is playing as striking as he can. The sung by a chorus of about five hundred without or- runs into trouble and expense, and then many times While it would character and somewhat disciplinarian make-up im- been easy h,™ for each new (Continued organist again has a big part and it goes without say- chestra. The organ was placed in the rear gallery. The does not get results. An organist must remember that o£ 51) EUGENE YSAYE ing that the organ part is effective and brilliant. Pietro conductor arranged the accompaniment for two pianos, if it is cold in the building, the organ is going to be AMBROISE THOMAS Yon knew how to make an organ sound well. The giving a lot of thought to making each part inde- flat; sometimes a tuning fork will show it to be concerti by Sowerby, Delamarter, and others, require pendent, allowing the organ to be used with the chorus several vibrations off. However, when the building is such a large orchestra and the organ is used in such a only in the climaxes. I must say that the performance heated, it will come up to its normal pitch, whether big way that they are not good with just a piano part. had its thrills. The pianos were used only in the it be 435, 440, or what. Everything depends upon the I am sure that if an organist makes an effort, he can choruses; the organ was used for the accompaniments pitch when the organ was voiced in the factory at 70 get plenty of material from the suggestions above for of all the solos and for the recitatives. It must be degrees Fahrenheit. If an organist finds that he can- the organ as the solo instrument. noted that in the arrangement for the pianos, the not get this information himself, any organ builder Here we find an endless supply of material. Almost organ did not double any running parts that were can tell him in a minute or two. Almost any organist, any piano concerto is a possibility. If the organist has given to the pianos. It is not wise to double much of however can, with the aid of- two timing forks, obtain a lot of imagination he can adapt an accompaniment anything at any time when one is playing with the the information for himself. The time to make the which has been originally arranged for a second piano, piano. The secret of making the piano and organ melt survey, of course, is when the church is heated or at and have a piece that is wholly satisfactory. One may is in the ensemble. For the most part it is up to the 70 degrees or thereabouts. If an organ is old and has start with the Bach concerti. There are a number of organist, who must be careful of his rhythm, and must not been cleaned for a number of years, the pitch will MARCEL DUPRE' VICTOR MAUREL the Mozart concerti which may be arranged, and also take much time to experiment with registration. sag; in this case, if the (Continued on Page 408) THEODORE DUBOIS HENRI WIENIAWSK GEORGES MATHIAS 376 CARLOS SALZEDO JULY, 1947 LIFE’’ 1 "MUSIC STUDY "MUSIC STUDY EXALTS LIFE’ EXALTS 377 THE ETUDE £

the result of the employing Music tonation is of this thba and Study the breath-embouchure control factor in of intonati Richard Franlto Goldman has been Associate Conductor of Music and Study n ' of ear then, to hear and atten- The use the the develoPme the Goldman, Band since 1937, and has devoted much concordance must be phases of band music, pioneering on behalf of a “feel” for the first consider™ tion to various and new works and exerting considerable influ- tion. No one can tell, except by experience, whether of both old h'6 ence on the enlargement of the band repertory. He is con- can achieve this desired state of proficiency, and f sidered an authority on early wind instrument music and on that reason most professional players smile tolerant/ early American composed music, and has conducted many one of their students asks a when question such / premieres of original band works. In official posts, Mr. Gold- Music far Wind Ensembles able to play in Secrets of Intonation “when will I be tune?” A feeling man has served as Music Consultant to the Pan American fo! intonation is much akin to the possession Joint Army-Navy Committee on Welfare and of musical Union, to the During World II, Mr. talent—one either has it, latently and potentially Recreation, and to the USO. War 0r the Army and served three years with one does not. Such a question cannot be answered Goldman enlisted in The Extent and Value of the Literature Office of Strategic Services (OSS). Since the end of the The use of the breath-embouchure method the of in war, Mr. Goldman has resumed his composing and writing. tonation control is the first method which Wiffiam is used by His newest book, "The Concert Band," was published by Lf J4. StullMS players and although it is instinctively all used from Rinehart & Company in December, 1946, and has already beginning, its development the very goes hand in hand been acclaimed the outstanding work on the subject, indis- Goldman in- with the other developments in performance technique pensable to all musicians. Other books by Mr. N OUR previous discussion of "The Band’s Music" (Pitman, 1938) and "Landmarks the Problem of In- until the first development of playing technique has Fortunately there is another method of intonation clude tonation we found that of Early American Music" (Schirmer, 1943). Mr. Goldman intonation in general is a been made, these words will mean little. The two control in addition to the breath-embouchure control Paganini, to I relative matter, and in is at present working on a biography of Niccolo considering the clarinet in variables involved, breath and embouchure are com- which may be used to advantage by most players be- articles stories in various even horn and bassoon, can orchestras do not do their job well or completely unless relation to intonation in general, be published in 1948. His many and Oboe and clarinet, and that certain physical pensatory and must be understood fully. increase of yond the beginning stages, and this An method con- publications have attracted wide attention. A country-wide amount of original musical material, they succeed in arousing musical curiosity at the same and wholly mechanical problems were met which boast of a certain must breath pressure will cause a -slight flattening of the stitutes the crux of our information. This Mr. Goldman's father, Edwin Franko necessarily method is tribute will be paid to but this appears to be less widely performed. The time that they develop performing ability. If the desire be compensated for if we are to be able to pitch. A decrease of breath pressure will cause a sharp- the use of the various intonation and resonance Goldman, on January I, 1948, the occasion of his seventieth “play in tune.” finger- brasses, of course, have unfortunately little solo litera- to explore music has been effectively stimulated, stu- ening. An increase of embouchure intensity will cause ings of which there are literally birthday, when the Goldman Band will appear at Carnegie dozens, varying of knowledge, for example, dents will find an outlet in the performance of en- In the present discussion we shall conductors ture of musical value. To my endeavor to pro- a sharpening of pitch and a decrease of intensity will course with every instrument, and with Hall. It is expected that one or more symphonic vide ourselves every player the only interesting solo written for trombone by an semble works on their own initiative, without the with a technique of compensation for will conduct the organization. All proceeds will go to the cause a flattening. It may readily be seen from this, but constant enough in practice to be allowed their as gen- is the Recitative and Prayer from incentive of contests or other external factors. When physical and mechanical problems which will League of Composers' Twenty-fifth Anniversary Fund, in the acknowledged master be that a combination of these factors will cause a com- eralizations. helpful. name of Dr. Goldman, for commissioning original band works Hector Berlioz’ “Grand” Symphony for Band. And this that happens, something of a new constructive value pensating action which must always be guided by the Every player must know his own instrument Editor's The first step in attacking the thor- from serious composers. — Note. seems to prove my point, since this splendid solo has, has been achieved. It is a value which the students can problem must of desire to maintain a constant tone quality. oughly and completely. We have shown post-school or days, for course be the indirect means of providing oneself how the until the present, remained almost unknown! take with them in college the with The increase in speed of the breath through the in- mechanical a basic and physical problems of the clarinet certainly be used performance of house music or ensemble music is a knowledge of the instrumental technique in- strument ac- Solo material of this sort should without subsequent flattening of the pitch count for its great variability, volved in playing the clarinet. and it is only by the T IS IN THE FIELD of ensemble music that the more widely, as should the ensemble material which pleasure which they may always continue to enjoy. A basic study must be which is the result of mere increase in breath pressure, most careful attention to all of the made of the problems of the tone, possibilities of the wind instrument player can find his best oppor- forms its complement. The original literature for wind In a brief article, one can do little more than give a technique, and and the opposite effect of the tongue, opposite use of this resonance and intonation fingerings that the for which suggestions the writer again refers best can I tunity for developing musicianship and acquiring a ensembles, both wood- very quick glance at to the previous articles in this column. A teacher who knowledge of style. It is a lamentable fact, however, wind and brass, is con- the type of music which F:n<] crn^ would present his students with the ttotot.cn