A Comparative Analysis of the Suitability of South Africa's Current

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Comparative Analysis of the Suitability of South Africa's Current Fit to Govern? A Comparative Analysis of the Suitability of South Africa’s Current Proportional Representation Electoral System versus the Majority System. Thembelani Mazibuko 2145-8129-5 Dissertation submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Social Sciences in Political Science at the School of Social Sciences. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Pietermaritzburg Campus November 2017 i Declaration I, Thembelani Sabelo Mahluli Mazibuko, declare that this dissertation – Fit to Govern? A Comparative Analysis of the Suitability of South Africa’s Current Proportional Representation Electoral System Verses the Majority System – is my own work and that all sources that I have used or quoted have been indicated and acknowledged by means of complete references. Signature: ……………………………………… Date: ……………………………………… ii Abstract The debate around the type of electoral system that South Africa should use has been ongoing for some time. The debate started during the Congress for a Democratic South Africa negotiations. While the negotiations resulted in South Africa settling on the list proportional representation system, the debate around which electoral system South Africa should use continues. This particular research evaluates two particular types of electoral systems. The first type is the first-pass-the-post majority system, where politicians are elected directly by voters, and the second type is the current list proportional representation system, in which voters vote for a political party which then deploys the politicians into elected office. More particularly, the research asks which of the two electoral systems is better equipped for the purposes of running South Africa’s elections given the normative goals of advancing accountability, ensuring a diverse and representative set of elected representatives and mitigating against the influence of private money on the political system. The research utilized the behavioural approach in order to study the research question. The researcher used comparative method as a methodology in order to compare and contrast the two systems from the perspective of different countries. This research differs from other research in that the researcher locates the research question within the values and ideals contained in South Africa’s own constitution. It is found that it is the proportional representation system that achieves the aforementioned normative goals of advancing accountability, ensuring a diverse and representative set of elected representatives and mitigating against the influence of private money. Furthermore, the research found that the idea that the majority system is more accountable is not borne out in objective fact. It is found that it is the proportional representation system that yields a more representative and diverse set of elected representatives whereas the majority system tends to favour incumbency – of both the political party and the politicians. The research also finds that, under the proportional representation system, politicians are less likely to be dependent on soliciting money for their political survival and therefore that the proportional representation system provides an effective bulwark against the proliferation of money in politics. In light of the above findings, the research found that it is the proportional representation system which creates a political culture that is in line with the values contained in the Constitution. The value of the study is that it debunks myths about the “effectiveness” of the majority system while simultaneously shining a light on the underappreciated virtues of the current proportional representation system. The study also sounds a warning bell about the influence of money in contemporary democracies. iii Acknowledgements I would like to thank my mother, Nomangwe Azalea Mazibuko, for all of the sacrifices that she has made in order for me to be in this position. You worked yourself to the bone in order for me to succeed, I will forever be grateful. Thank you for the emotional and financial support. I would also like to thank my sisters Sihle and Zinhle as well as my big brother Ndumiso for their support. I would like to express my gratitude to my supervisor, Dr Sakhile Hadebe as well as to the University of KwaZulu-Natal, may this university continue growing from strength to strength. I would also like to thank Professor Steven Friedman from the University of Johannesburg for his advice as well as for sharing his own research with me, much of which is used in this work. I would also like to thank Professor Andrew Reynolds from the University of North Carolina for his encouragement and advice, your research has been a guiding light for me. This research is dedicated to the memory of my father, Ndumiso Ndlovu, who passed away a month before the submission of this project. iv Table of Contents Declaration ............................................................................................................................................. ii Abstract ................................................................................................................................................. iii Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................................... iv Table of Contents ................................................................................................................................... v List of Graphics ...................................................................................................................................... vii List of Tables ......................................................................................................................................... viii Acronyms ................................................................................................................................................ ix Definitions and Points of Clarity ............................................................................................................. xii Chapter 1: Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Background and Context ................................................................................................................ 2 1.1.1 Background and Context: Past Debates on the Electoral System ........................................... 3 1.1 Assumptions................................................................................................................................... 6 1.2 Gap in the Literature ...................................................................................................................... 7 1.3 Problem Statement ........................................................................................................................ 7 1.4 Research Questions ........................................................................................................................ 8 1.5 Objectives ...................................................................................................................................... 8 1.6 Chapter Outline .............................................................................................................................. 9 1.7 Theoretical Framework and Methodology ..................................................................................... 9 1.7.1 Principle Theory ...................................................................................................................... 9 1.7.2 Methodology ........................................................................................................................ 10 1.8 Proportional Representation and Majority System Explained ....................................................... 13 1.8.1 Proportional Representation Explained ................................................................................. 13 1.8.2 The First-Pass-The-Post Majority System Explained ............................................................... 15 Chapter 2: Literature Review ................................................................................................................. 17 2.1 The Importance of Electoral Systems ........................................................................................... 17 2.2 Criteria for Electoral Systems ....................................................................................................... 19 2.3 Different Types of Electoral Systems ............................................................................................ 22 2.4 Issues in Electoral System choice ................................................................................................. 26 2.4.1 Representation, Diversity and Proportionality ..................................................................... 26 2.4.2 Accountability, Legitimacy and Public Trust in Parliament ................................................... 27 2.4.3 Political Extremism ............................................................................................................... 30 2.4.4 Peripheral issues between PR and MS .................................................................................. 32 Chapter 3: Electoral Systems and “Accountability” ................................................................................ 36 v 3.1 The Idea of Accountability ...........................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • AC Vol 43 No 13
    www.africa-confidential.com 28 June 2002 Vol 43 No 13 AFRICA CONFIDENTIAL NIGERIA 3 SOUTH AFRICA Banker versus banker The Central Bank is trying to End of an Alliance impose order on Nigeria’s 100 Squabbles and scandals are now destroying the only opposition banks: many make big profits from which really mattered illicit foreign exchange deals. One The most serious opposition group, the Democratic Alliance (DA), has been gravely wounded by solution would be a single exchange rate, although that could corruption allegations and political misjudgement. The governing African National Congress is sticking put several banks out of business. the knife in deeper with a new law allowing elected representatives to defect to other parties without losing their seats. The ANC stresses that such a law operates in most European parliaments but its clear aim is to give it control of all nine provinces and all main provincial and city councils. FRANCOPHONE WEST In the two opposition-controlled provinces, Western Cape and kwaZulu-Natal, enough opposition AFRICA 4 representatives want to cross the floor to give the ANC majority control. The ANC’s advantage is mainly due to opposition incompetence; the biggest personal loser is the DA’s Tony Leon (45), whose energetic The voters’ friend and pragmatic leadership once rattled the government. After a decade of ‘democratising’ The national parliament passed the Floor-Crossing Legislation on 20 June but opposition parties argue some Francophone countries are that it violates voters’ rights and want the courts to stop it. The case, heard by the Cape High Court on starting to see real change brought about through the ballot box.
    [Show full text]
  • EASTERN CAPE NARL 2014 (Approved by the Federal Executive)
    EASTERN CAPE NARL 2014 (Approved by the Federal Executive) Rank Name 1 Andrew (Andrew Whitfield) 2 Nosimo (Nosimo Balindlela) 3 Kevin (Kevin Mileham) 4 Terri Stander 5 Annette Steyn 6 Annette (Annette Lovemore) 7 Confidential Candidate 8 Yusuf (Yusuf Cassim) 9 Malcolm (Malcolm Figg) 10 Elza (Elizabeth van Lingen) 11 Gustav (Gustav Rautenbach) 12 Ntombenhle (Rulumeni Ntombenhle) 13 Petrus (Petrus Johannes de WET) 14 Bobby Cekisani 15 Advocate Tlali ( Phoka Tlali) EASTERN CAPE PLEG 2014 (Approved by the Federal Executive) Rank Name 1 Athol (Roland Trollip) 2 Vesh (Veliswa Mvenya) 3 Bobby (Robert Stevenson) 4 Edmund (Peter Edmund Van Vuuren) 5 Vicky (Vicky Knoetze) 6 Ross (Ross Purdon) 7 Lionel (Lionel Lindoor) 8 Kobus (Jacobus Petrus Johhanes Botha) 9 Celeste (Celeste Barker) 10 Dorah (Dorah Nokonwaba Matikinca) 11 Karen (Karen Smith) 12 Dacre (Dacre Haddon) 13 John (John Cupido) 14 Goniwe (Thabisa Goniwe Mafanya) 15 Rene (Rene Oosthuizen) 16 Marshall (Marshall Von Buchenroder) 17 Renaldo (Renaldo Gouws) 18 Bev (Beverley-Anne Wood) 19 Danny (Daniel Benson) 20 Zuko (Prince-Phillip Zuko Mandile) 21 Penny (Penelope Phillipa Naidoo) FREE STATE NARL 2014 (as approved by the Federal Executive) Rank Name 1 Patricia (Semakaleng Patricia Kopane) 2 Annelie Lotriet 3 Werner (Werner Horn) 4 David (David Christie Ross) 5 Nomsa (Nomsa Innocencia Tarabella Marchesi) 6 George (George Michalakis) 7 Thobeka (Veronica Ndlebe-September) 8 Darryl (Darryl Worth) 9 Hardie (Benhardus Jacobus Viviers) 10 Sandra (Sandra Botha) 11 CJ (Christian Steyl) 12 Johan (Johannes
    [Show full text]
  • African National Congress NATIONAL to NATIONAL LIST 1. ZUMA Jacob
    African National Congress NATIONAL TO NATIONAL LIST 1. ZUMA Jacob Gedleyihlekisa 2. MOTLANTHE Kgalema Petrus 3. MBETE Baleka 4. MANUEL Trevor Andrew 5. MANDELA Nomzamo Winfred 6. DLAMINI-ZUMA Nkosazana 7. RADEBE Jeffery Thamsanqa 8. SISULU Lindiwe Noceba 9. NZIMANDE Bonginkosi Emmanuel 10. PANDOR Grace Naledi Mandisa 11. MBALULA Fikile April 12. NQAKULA Nosiviwe Noluthando 13. SKWEYIYA Zola Sidney Themba 14. ROUTLEDGE Nozizwe Charlotte 15. MTHETHWA Nkosinathi 16. DLAMINI Bathabile Olive 17. JORDAN Zweledinga Pallo 18. MOTSHEKGA Matsie Angelina 19. GIGABA Knowledge Malusi Nkanyezi 20. HOGAN Barbara Anne 21. SHICEKA Sicelo 22. MFEKETO Nomaindiya Cathleen 23. MAKHENKESI Makhenkesi Arnold 24. TSHABALALA- MSIMANG Mantombazana Edmie 25. RAMATHLODI Ngoako Abel 26. MABUDAFHASI Thizwilondi Rejoyce 27. GODOGWANA Enoch 28. HENDRICKS Lindiwe 29. CHARLES Nqakula 30. SHABANGU Susan 31. SEXWALE Tokyo Mosima Gabriel 32. XINGWANA Lulama Marytheresa 33. NYANDA Siphiwe 34. SONJICA Buyelwa Patience 35. NDEBELE Joel Sibusiso 36. YENGENI Lumka Elizabeth 37. CRONIN Jeremy Patrick 38. NKOANA- MASHABANE Maite Emily 39. SISULU Max Vuyisile 40. VAN DER MERWE Susan Comber 41. HOLOMISA Sango Patekile 42. PETERS Elizabeth Dipuo 43. MOTSHEKGA Mathole Serofo 44. ZULU Lindiwe Daphne 45. CHABANE Ohm Collins 46. SIBIYA Noluthando Agatha 47. HANEKOM Derek Andre` 48. BOGOPANE-ZULU Hendrietta Ipeleng 49. MPAHLWA Mandisi Bongani Mabuto 50. TOBIAS Thandi Vivian 51. MOTSOALEDI Pakishe Aaron 52. MOLEWA Bomo Edana Edith 53. PHAAHLA Matume Joseph 54. PULE Dina Deliwe 55. MDLADLANA Membathisi Mphumzi Shepherd 56. DLULANE Beauty Nomvuzo 57. MANAMELA Kgwaridi Buti 58. MOLOI-MOROPA Joyce Clementine 59. EBRAHIM Ebrahim Ismail 60. MAHLANGU-NKABINDE Gwendoline Lindiwe 61. NJIKELANA Sisa James 62. HAJAIJ Fatima 63.
    [Show full text]
  • In Die Bosveld in Die Bosveld
    Gregan vir sewe jaar 2 Marlene tronk toe gestuur Humphries sterf Peterson-verdagte 3 ® wil vra vir borgtog 4 18 Mei 2018 R8.00 Verdagtes in Coertze-aanval verskyn in hof Vier rowers het die egpaar vermoedelik in hul slaapkamer oorval nadat hulle die voordeur met ’n koevoet oopgebreek het. samewerking met lede van Andries van der Heyde HPG, dieselfde dag ’n verdagte in Winterveld met Twee verdagtes is op Dins- die gesteelde bakkie dag 8 Mei in Winterveld, aangekeer. Soshanguve, in hegtenis Nog ’n verdagte, ’n vrou, geneem nadat Hennie en wat glo die egpaar se Marie Coertze by hul huis op gesteelde kragopwekker in die Alma-pad buite Bela-Bela haar besit gehad het, is ook vasgebind en beroof is. in hegtenis geneem, het Die Coertze-egpaar is dr. lt.kol. Abel Phetla, Roelof Coertze, mediese speurtakhoof, aan Die Pos praktisyn van Bela-Bela, se gesê. bejaarde ouers. Die ander verdagtes word Vier rowers het die egpaar volgens hom nog gesoek. vermoedelik kort ná 01:00 in * Die verdagtes, Albert hul slaapkamer oorval nadat Ndlovu en Mildred hulle die voordeur met ’n Makondo, het op Donderdag koevoet oopgebreek het. 10 Mei in die Bela-Bela- Die egpaar, wat in hul landdroshof verskyn. Hulle sewentigs is, is vasgebind word aangekla van huisroof Brrrrr terwyl die rowers die huis met verswarende Brrrrr geplunder het. omstandighede, asook vir Verskeie waardevolle die besit van gesteelde items, asook die egpaar se goedere. inin diedie BosveldBosveld twee voertuie, is gesteel. Ndlovu is volgens die ’n Woordvoerder van die polisie ’n Mosambieker. Heritage Protection Group Die saak is na Donderdag (HPG) het in ’n verklaring 17 Mei uitgestel vir verdere Die winter is hier — ook in die Bosveld.
    [Show full text]
  • CALD Executive Mission to South Africa
    CALD Executive Mission to South Africa Council of Asian Liberals and Democrats – Democratic Alliance Forging South-South Cooperation Among Political Parties 29 September - 5 October 2018 Saturday, 29 September 2018 Travel from Asia to Johannesburg (OR Tambo International Airport) Sunday, 30 September 2018 Variable Arrival and check-in at hotel Protea Hotel Marriott Johannesburg Wanderers Cnr. Corlett Drive & Rudd Road, Illovo 2196 South Africa T: +27 11 770 5500 F: +27 11 770 5555 E: [email protected] W: protea.marriott.com 13h30 Travel to Apartheid Museum 14h00 – 17h00 Apartheid Museum Visit 18h00 – 19h15 Welcome, introductions and programme overview With William Clayton and Kati Georgousaki With DA International Office Coordinator & FNF Programme Officer 19h15 – 21h00 Opening dinner Solly Msimanga, DA Gauteng Premier Candidate and With Executive Mayor of Tshwane 1 Monday, 1 October 2018 08h00 – 09h00 Breakfast and check-out of hotel 09h00 – 09h45 Travel to DA Campaign Headquarters Nkululeko House, Bruma, Johannesburg 09h45 – 10h15 Welcome and Introductions Nkululeko House, Bruma, Johannesburg 10h15 – 10h45 Tour of DA Campaign Headquarters Nkululeko House, Bruma, Johannesburg 10h45 – 11h30 The By-Elections Office With Gary van Wyk, DA Executive Director: By Elections and Political Activity Nkululeko House, Bruma, Johannesburg 11h30 – 12h00 Finger Food Snacks 12h00 – 12h45 Travel to Constitution Hill 12h45 – 15h00 Constitution Hill Visit 15h00 – 16h00 Travel to the Airport 16h00 – 17h00 Check-in 18h00 – 20h00 Flight to Cape
    [Show full text]
  • The Smoke That Calls: Insurgent Citizenship, Collective Violence and the Struggle for a Place in the New South Africa
    CSVR Final Cover 7/6/11 1:36 PM Page 1 C M Y CM MY CY CMY K The smoke that calls Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and th violence citizenship, collective Insurgent Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa. in the new a place for and the struggle violence citizenship, collective Insurgent Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa. The smoke that calls that calls The smoke The smoke Eight case studies of community protest and xenophobic violence www.csvr.org.za www.swopinstitute.org.za Karl von Holdt, Malose Langa, Sepetla Molapo, Nomfundo Mogapi, Kindiza Ngubeni, Jacob Dlamini and Adele Kirsten Composite CSVR Final Cover 7/7/11 9:51 AM Page 2 C M Y CM MY CY CMY K Published: July 2011 Copyright 2011 ® Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation | Society, Work and Development Institute The smoke that calls: Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa. Eight case studies of community protest and xenophobic violence Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation Society, Work and Development Institute 4th Floor, Braamfontein Centre, 23 Jorissen Street, Braamfontein Faculty of Humanities PO Box 30778, Braamfontein, Johannesburg, 2017 University of the Witwatersrand Tel: +27 (0) 11 403 5650 | Fax: +27 (0) 11 339 6785 Private Bag 3, Wits, 2050 Cape Town Office Tel: +27 (0) 11 717 4460 501 Premier Centre, 451 Main Road, Observatory, 7925 Tel: +27 (0) 21 447 3661 | Fax: +27 (0) 21 447 5356 email: [email protected] www.csvr.org.za www.swopinstitute.org.za Composite CSVR - Chapter 1 - 5 7/6/11 1:52 PM Page 1 C M Y CM MY CY CMY K The smoke that calls Insurgent citizenship, collective violence and the struggle for a place in the new South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Tweeting in Solidarity': a Corpus Linguistics-Driven Analysis of Tweets
    Linguistics Department School of Literature, Language and Media University of the Witwatersrand ‘Tweeting in Solidarity’: A corpus linguistics-driven analysis of tweets during the South African student protests By Amé Bolton 674657 A Master’s Research Report submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master’s in Linguistics Supervisor: Tommaso Milani Date of Submission: 31 March 2018 ❖ Contents ⁂ Acknowledgements .................................................................................................................... 3 0. Abstract .................................................................................................................................... 4 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 5 2. Literature ................................................................................................................................. 7 2.1 The Internet as social ....................................................................................................... 7 2.2 The Internet as political ................................................................................................. 13 3. Key concepts and definitions ................................................................................................. 19 3.1 On identity politics ......................................................................................................... 19 3.1.1 Identity and community online ..............................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • K Thomas the Power of Naming Senseless Violence
    Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation CSVR was founded in January 1989 and has offices in Johannesburg and Cape Town, South Africa. CSVR adopts a multidisciplinary approach to understand and prevent violence, heal its effects, and build sustainable peace locally, continentally, and globally. CSVR’s work includes a focus on transitional justice, peacebuilding, criminal justice reform, trauma studies and support, victim empowerment, and violence prevention, with a specific focus on the prevention of gender-based, youth, and collective violence. The organisation is increasingly working on a pan- continental basis to share expertise, facilitate learning exchanges, and strengthen the capacity of Africa’s civil society and regional organisations. Centre for Humanities Research Since its inception in 2006, the CHR has emerged as a meeting point for researchers in the Humanities and Social Sciences throughout southern and, more recently, eastern and western Africa and beyond. The CHR strives to develop unifying and interdisciplinary themes in the humanities that will enable a renewal of its study in Africa. Its flagship fellowship research platform, the Programme on the Study of the Humanities in Africa, brings together master’s, doctoral and postdoctoral fellows and faculty into a discussion on constructing new directions in humanities research. Through a series of focused research projects on law and violence, aesthetics and politics, anti-racism and the critique of race, and the postcolonial university in Africa, the CHR strives
    [Show full text]
  • Social Protests and Water Service Delivery in South Africa
    Social Protests and Water Service Delivery in South Africa _.., ___IYBNIIIMA W'IIAOirlf9oo- []-- WATER llESEAACM CC.Mf$$1011f Social Protests and Water Service Delivery in South Africa Report to the WATER RESEARCH COMMISSION by BARBARA TAPELA Assisted by Bukiwe Ntwana and Darlington Sibanda Institute for Poverty Land and Agrarian Studies (PLAAS) University of the Western Cape WRC Report No. TT 631/15 ISBN 978-1-4312-0672-8 May 2015 Obtainable from: Water Research Commission Private Bag X03 Gezina, 0031 [email protected] or download from www.wrc.org.za The publication of this report emanates from a project entitled Social Protests and Water Service Delivery in South Africa (WRC Report No. K5/2133) DISCLAIMER This report has been reviewed by the Water Research Commission (WRC) and approved for publication. Approval does not signify that the contents necessarily reflect the views and policies of the WRC, nor does mention of trade names or commercial products constitute endorsement or recommendation for use. © Water Research Commission ii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Since 2004, South Africa has been hit by high volumes of social protests. Protestors claim that they protest over lack of ‘service delivery’ and water is one of the elements of service delivery. In 2012 the frequency, geographical spread and violence of service delivery-related social protests in post-apartheid South Africa reached unprecedented levels. Water service delivery issues rose in prominence among various reasons cited for protests. While this ascendance is remarkable, grievances over water services are not new. Water service delivery issues have been (and still are) a part of a range of conflated grievances that masquerade under the general rubric of ‘service delivery’ issues and underpin many rallying calls for social protest action.
    [Show full text]
  • South Africa Country Report BTI 2018
    BTI 2018 Country Report South Africa This report is part of the Bertelsmann Stiftung’s Transformation Index (BTI) 2018. It covers the period from February 1, 2015 to January 31, 2017. The BTI assesses the transformation toward democracy and a market economy as well as the quality of political management in 129 countries. More on the BTI at http://www.bti-project.org. Please cite as follows: Bertelsmann Stiftung, BTI 2018 Country Report — South Africa. Gütersloh: Bertelsmann Stiftung, 2018. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Contact Bertelsmann Stiftung Carl-Bertelsmann-Strasse 256 33111 Gütersloh Germany Sabine Donner Phone +49 5241 81 81501 [email protected] Hauke Hartmann Phone +49 5241 81 81389 [email protected] Robert Schwarz Phone +49 5241 81 81402 [email protected] Sabine Steinkamp Phone +49 5241 81 81507 [email protected] BTI 2018 | South Africa 3 Key Indicators Population M 55.9 HDI 0.666 GDP p.c., PPP $ 13225 Pop. growth1 % p.a. 1.6 HDI rank of 188 119 Gini Index 63.4 Life expectancy years 61.9 UN Education Index 0.720 Poverty3 % 35.9 Urban population % 65.3 Gender inequality2 0.394 Aid per capita $ 25.8 Sources (as of October 2017): The World Bank, World Development Indicators 2017 | UNDP, Human Development Report 2016. Footnotes: (1) Average annual growth rate. (2) Gender Inequality Index (GII). (3) Percentage of population living on less than $3.20 a day at 2011 international prices. Executive Summary In the period under review, South Africa faced some of its most stringent economic-, social- and political challenges since its democratic transition in 1994.
    [Show full text]
  • Submission by CASAC to the Marikana Commission of Inquiry
    Submission by CASAC to the Marikana Commission of Inquiry The role of the South African Police Service in the Marikana massacre on 16 August 2012 January 2013 www.casac.org.za CASAC SUBMISSION to MARIKANA COMMISSION OF INQUIRY 1 Executive Summary Context & Compass of the Submission 1. This submission by the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution (CASAC) to the Marikana Commission of Inquiry led by Judge Ian Farlam is located within the context of civil liberties as articulated in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the South African Constitution. 2. The submission is primarily concerned with the manner in which the South African Police Service (SAPS) acted at Marikana on the 16th of August 2012. The submission addresses a number of the issues which form part of the Terms of Reference (TORs) of the Farlam Commission. 3. The scope of the submission encompasses: The actions of members of the SAPS and officials of the South African government that contributed to the course of events on the 16th of August. It also covers action taken by members of the SAPS and/or government officials that led to the death of ANC councillor Pauline Masuhlo who died as a result of injuries that she sustained on the weekend of 15-16 September. 4. In this submission CASAC respectfully requests the Commission to examine whether: It can be inferred that a policy of "maximum force" has been introduced into the operational practice of the SAPS, contrary to the Constitution; There is a direct or indirect causal link between the articulation of such a policy and the events at Marikana on 16 August 2012; In any event, whether the statements and acts referred to in this submission have contributed in any manner, whether directly or indirectly, to the events at Marikana on 16 August 2012.
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Social Protests and the Right to Peaceful Assembly
    MASS SOCIAL PROTESTS AND THE RIGHT TO PEACEFUL ASSEMBLY A 12-COUNTRY SPECIAL REPORT BY FREEDOM HOUSE JANUARY 2015 Table of Contents Overview: Mass Social Protests and the Right to Peaceful Assembly ......................................................... 1 Chile: Reclaiming the Street – Chile’s Student Movement .......................................................................... 7 China: The Case of Shifang ........................................................................................................................ 13 Denmark: The Case of COP15 ................................................................................................................... 19 Kyrgyzstan: Commotion-Based Democracy .............................................................................................. 24 Libya: Save Benghazi Friday ...................................................................................................................... 30 Malaysia: The Bersih Movement ................................................................................................................ 37 Morocco: February 20 Movement .............................................................................................................. 44 Peru: “El Baguazo” ..................................................................................................................................... 49 South Africa: The COSATU March ........................................................................................................... 54
    [Show full text]