DOCSLIB.ORG

SWP and Its Off-On, Off-On Relationship with Programme Weekly 2 May 14 2020 1299 Worker LETTERS

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
SWP and Its Off-On, Off-On Relationship with Programme Weekly 2 May 14 2020 1299 Worker LETTERS A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity World War II: breeding n CPGB aggregate n Biden and lesser-evilism ground for comforting myths, n Covid-19 Italian style both for bourgeoisie and left n CPGB 100 years No 1299 May 14 2020 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 SWP and its off-on, off-on relationship with programme weekly 2 May 14 2020 1299 worker LETTERS Letters may have been of wages and of hours, etc lose all political the case with the organisational model interests: 1905 or 1917? the Workers International League (better shortened because of purchase.) of top-table-dominated bureaucratic Alan Johnstone known as Socialist Appeal), the British space. Some names I will admit that it is a very long time centralism, which is promoted by the Socialist Party of Great Britain section of the International Marxist may have been changed since I read the first three volumes of Labour and trade union bureaucracy and Tendency. Socialist Appeal currently sees Cliff’s Lenin (in the late 70s and early most of the left. To insist on “learning” Join CPGB? the 90,000 people who voted for Richard 80s), that I haven’t kept a hard copy of and “generalising experience” as the Ian Birchall marshals a well-argued Burgon in the Labour Party deputy Error of method it, and that I didn’t feel the need to revisit exclusive tasks of this minority is, in fact, defence of Tony Cliff and his emphasis on leadership contest as its target audience Ian Birchall’s reply to my article on the it online to write a journalistic squib to prevent ever overcoming that poison. recruiting new members to the Socialist for recruitment. treatment in the left press of the 150th about the left press’s treatments of the Mike Macnair Workers Party. At the same time, Ian’s If the CPGB through the same deep anniversary of the birth of Lenin (‘Lenin anniversary. Oxford criticism of the CPGB’s failure to recruit entryist tactic also sees these 90,000 avatars’, April 30) begins by condemning My point about the “concrete more than 30 members over the last 30 Labour Party members as its target my article as “supercilious” and as analysis” and the Independent Social Which soviets? years is well-founded. Whereas the SWP audience for recruitment, it should come arguing that “everyone’s out of step but Democratic Party of Germany (USPD) is Ian Birchall asks, “Who invented continuously call for people to ‘join the out and openly say so. Alternatively, if us [CPGB]” (Letters, May 7). Towards not particularly to praise the speeches. It is soviets?” and then answers: “Russian socialists’, it is many years now since the CPGB sees its task to organise the the end, he says that “The Weekly Worker to explain Lenin’s criticism of Béla Kun, workers, who had probably never heard the CPGB called for people to ‘join the left through its Labour Party Marxists spends its time lecturing the rest of the left György Lukács and their objections to of Lenin.” What I would like to know is communists’. and Labour Against the Witchhunt fronts, on its failings - it never imagines it has any sort of engagement with the USPD, what soviets is he talking about: 1905 or As a former member of Militant - it should also come out and openly say anything to learn.” on the ground that its character was to be 1917? and its successor, the Socialist Party in so. The problem, as far as I can see it, is This is a very basic error of method. inferred from the (Kautskyite) character In 1905 workers’ councils arose England and Wales - I can remember that these 90,000 Labour Party people The “everyone’s out of step but us” snark of its majority leadership. This inference spontaneously out of the January- being given a leaflet in 1978 asking are virtual members who can easily is a reference to the old joke about a from the character of the leadership February 1905 strike and were me to “become a Militant supporter”. disappear from Labour at a drop of a hat. mother watching a military drill, saying to the character of the base has been independent of any external initiatives. Since then, SPEW, just like the SWP, This can clearly be seen from widespread of her son: “Look at my Johnny - he’s characteristic of a large part of the far Their popularity derived largely from continuously asks people to ‘join the discussions on social media that, the only one in step.” But, while the point left’s response to the Corbyn movement the absence of political party agitators in Socialists’. Why does the CPGB not following the defeat of Jeremy Corbyn, of parades is to display unanimity, the - the other side of this response being their midst. They expressed the workers’ ask readers of its widely read Weekly the Labour Party never will be, nor ever point of discussion is to learn through merely to tail Corbyn as a good leftist, political and economic demands in a Worker to ‘join the communists’? All I has been, a vehicle for the building of disagreement. And it is perfectly possible without criticising his and his co-thinkers’ situation where trade unions were non- can conclude is that either the CPGB has socialism in Britain. for one person, or a minority, to be the substantive politics. existent and where the political parties something to hide (which I doubt) or it Lenin often remarked that “an ounce only ones who have got the right answer SWP canvassers for Respect claiming held little influence. It was all very wants to hide its modesty under a bushel. of experience is worth a tonne of theory”. - as Galileo was on the shape of the solar to be “left Labourites” - ie, former Labour different in 1917. In the same issue of the Weekly Lenin was also fond of the Russian system, Semmelweis on doctors washing voters disillusioned by Blair - was my The February strikes had been Worker, CPGB guru Jack Conrad proverb, “Life teaches”. Why should any their hands, or Wegener on continental personal experience of canvassing for spontaneous like those in 1905, but the explains that the mass Communist Party sane, right-thinking communist want to drift. Perhaps (as several left economists Respect, alongside SWP comrades, soviets had not arisen directly out of he envisages will be built from the top be in a party - ie, Labour - which treats argue) the Marxist minority should defer in East Oxford, and of arguments put them, as they had 12 years earlier. They down. The problem is that on the left its dissident members so badly? I know to the marginalist majority? forward at Respect meetings. I would be resulted from the combined efforts of there are few cadres still alive today. The this from bitter experience last year, In effect, Birchall is suggesting that perfectly willing to accept that this was politicians and workers’ leaders: the sad death of Neil Davidson, following when my local Corbynistas opposed my minorities ought to defer to majorities, not the invariable practice; but I rather politicians of the Duma Committee and the death of Colin Barker, has weakened application to rejoin. To put it bluntly, because this is to “learn from the doubt that it had no basis in SWP policy, the members of the Workers’ Group the left considerably. However, both why should we have to go through the movement”. Sharp polemics against given the point about the SWP putting on sitting on the Central Committee for Neil Davidson and Colin Barker were anguish and distress of being expelled majority views are thus to be taken as protective coloration more generally, as the War Industries, which installed members of Revolutionary Socialism in from the Labour Party as part of Sir Keir “supercilious” (and so on). in Globalise Resistance. itself in the Tauride Palace on February the 21st Century (RS21), a split from the Starmer’s purge of socialists? But, while it is certainly true that Who invented soviets? Trotsky, who 27 and set up a provisional executive SWP in 2013, which has had the good John Smithee the CPGB is a very small minority in was fairly centrally involved, claimed in committee of the council of workers’ sense to double its membership since the Cambridgeshire the left, the Socialist Workers Party 1905 (London 1971, pp104-05) that the delegates, to which committee several split by asking people to ‘join RS21’. tradition is also a very small minority in Petersburg Soviet was created because socialist leaders and members of Jack Conrad - and his close associate, Bizarre writer the larger workers’ movement, relative the factional struggles between the left parliament attached themselves. This Mike Macnair - are not getting any Daniel Lazare has been a recent (since to the Labour right - and even to the parties and their clandestinity meant explains why, when the first Provisional younger. If the CPGB fails to open itself November 2019) addition to the writing part of the labour and trade union left that non-party organisations had to be Soviet met, it contained no factory up to new members it will remain an team for the Weekly Worker, focusing on which, though no longer organised created (by the left) to engage the masses, delegates. irrelevant sect, albeit with a widely read politics in the United States. by the ‘official’ communists, remains and that the organisational form was What had changed from 1905 paper. Without new members, especially I found myself disagreeing with some politically influenced by their ideas.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • David Cameron and Greensill
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity David Cameron and Greensill: all n Letters and debate n Iran negotiations perfectly proper and above board n Royal family Nazis - according to the authorities n Nationalist nightmares No 1342 April 8 2021 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 LOYAL SERVANTS OF LIBERAL BOURGEOISIE weekly 2 April 8 2021 1342 worker LETTERS Letters may have been This is a strange argument for agricultural commodities (wages) and extending them becomes manifest with the repeal of shortened because of space. Some names for a Marxist to make. Capitalist and so commodity production in back into history, rather than the Corn Laws. may have been changed production begins in the towns in agriculture. analysing each historical period Arthur Bough the 15th century, as the towns grow, Even, then, of course, as in its specificity. It is even more email creating the minimum size of market Marx describes - and Lenin also incongruous to do that at the same Blind alley required for capitalist production to establishes in ‘On the so-called time as trying to claim that the law Gramsci Writing in Weekly Worker, Ammar be able to undercut the independent market question’ - this commodity of value, as a natural law, only exists Debates over how Gramsci’s writings Kazmi asks me to “promptly handicraft producers. It’s why, as production in the countryside is not under capitalism, or indeed that the have been interpreted and deployed explain” and “correct” what I Marx describes, capitalism has capitalist production, unlike that concepts, value and surplus value, can be helpful in clarifying important wrote in my article, ‘Defend David to begin in the towns and such already established in the towns.
    [Show full text]
  • Lars T Lih: 150 Years After His Birth, How to Evaluate Lenin and His Ideas Weekly 2 May 7 2020 1298 Worker LETTERS
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Without a comprehensive n Letters and debate n Abbott & Ribeiro-Addy programme there is no road n STWC ceasefire map to socialism and beyond n Michael Roberts No 1298 May 7 2020 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 Lars T Lih: 150 years after his birth, how to evaluate Lenin and his ideas weekly 2 May 7 2020 1298 worker LETTERS Letters may have been image - though it was sometimes used incidents should themselves be war around the globe. “So,” Lazare struggles. The strike waves of the shortened because of by his critics. What Cliff did argue suspended from membership.” The concludes of Biden, “while he’d be 1930s, for example, forced the space. Some names was that a central task of the party was lack of “anti-Semitic incidents” is not better in Wisconsin, he’d be worse judiciary to establish the precedent may have been changed to learn from the class. As he wrote in their concern, but anyone talking to when it comes to the rest of the world, that “freedom of contract” is not Portugal at the crossroads, “In short these criminals should be shot - sorry, where US power predominates.” inviolable and that the government they [the party] have to learn from I mean expelled. We do not doubt Biden’s record and courts can intervene to protect Compliment their fellow workers as much as - or We know that accepting the of racism and capitalist austerity workers’ union rights and enforce No sport, nothing on television; what more than - they have to teach ..
    [Show full text]
  • Mike Macnair
    Paper of the Communist Party of Great Britain weekly No need for a party? Mike n Labour makes gains workern Non-Labour left Macnair reports from the n Lib Dem slump US Platypus convention n CPGB aggregate No 865 Thursday May 12 2011 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union www.cpgb.org.uk £1/€1.10 CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS BECKONS 8 May 12 2011 865 US LEFT No need for party? The US Platypus grouping does not have a political line because there is ‘no possibility of revolutionary action’. Mike Macnair reports on its convention attended the third annual Platypus about madness and the penitentiary, as International Convention in Chi- well as about the history of sexuality, Icago over the weekend April 29- have been falsified by historians. May 1. The Platypus Affiliated So- And, though he identified Foucault’s ciety is a, mainly student, left group tendency to marginalise class politics, of an odd sort (as will appear further he saw this as merely a product of the below). Its basic slogan is: ‘The left defeat of the left, rather than as an is dead; long live the left’. Starting active intervention in favour of popular very small, it has recently expanded frontism. Hence he missed the extent rapidly on US campuses and added to which the Anglo-American left chapters in Toronto and Frankfurt. academic and gay/lesbian movement Something over 50 people attended reception of Foucault was closely tied the convention. to the defence of extreme forms of The fact of Platypus’s rapid growth popular frontism by authors directly on the US campuses, though still as or indirectly linked to Marxism yet to a fairly small size, tells us that Today, for whom it was an instrument in some way it occupies a gap on the against the ‘class-reductionist’ ideas US left, and also tells us something of Trotskyists.
    [Show full text]
  • Neil Faulkner and His Dreadful Mangling of Basic
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Mike Macnair: Neil Faulkner n Letters and debate n Covid-19: one million deaths and his dreadful mangling n Covid-19 conspiracies of basic Marxism n UN biodiversity posturing No 1317 October 1 2020 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 FREE JULIAN ASSANGE weekly 2 October 1 2020 1317 worker LETTERS Letters may have been an hour of moderate exercise a day - of any suggestions of what leftwing are with sadistic formality deemed ‘fit as an exciting race! Now surely this is shortened because of something that can be easily undone Americans should do. ‘A plague on to work’. what people who know perfectly well space. Some names (and more) in five minutes by both your houses’ is a popular way of I would suggest that nobody now they’re the working class are waiting may have been changed drinking a 330ml can of the world’s absenting oneself from any action or has the faintest idea of how many to engage with - these messages most advertised and biggest selling responsibility, and in my mind it is a workers are unemployed. The press, being sent out that their ears will hear soft drink. dereliction of duty. again, quotes figures every now and as music. This communist truth is Obesity James Linney If DL is correct, and change has to then, generally without question, but about a future of clean-air woodlands Thank you to Gary Simons for email come to the US - and possibly soon I think we can confidently assert that with dappled glades, rather than a his considered letter, raising some - then surely any leftwing person they are woefully underestimated.
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Worker
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity weekly Yassamine Mather n Letters and debate workern July 10 strikes delves into Israel’s n Crisis theory secret nuclear arsenal n Marc Mulholland No 1019 Thursday July 17 2014 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union www.cpgb.org.uk £1/€1.10 Marxism 2014 presents... Codename: carry on as before AN YGAEL GLUCKSTEIN PRODUCTION 2 weekly July 17 2014 1019 worker LETTERS Letters may have been abolished; and that the British state whistling”, pretending not to understand the Lib Dems in Westminster. the respectable face of youth culture - top shortened because of needs to be overthrown - not broken up the term as embodying coded hostility to It does mean there is a real national DJ, presenter of youth radio and family space. Some names - are under attack. These old ideas have ‘foreigners’, whether of English or other question to be addressed - and the TV, friend to prince Charles and prime may have been changed yet to be winkled out their Labourist origin, who may not fall into line behind demand for a federal republic does minister Margaret Thatcher, marathon shells. Loyalty to them forms part a nationalist project. indeed address this - with the strategic runner for charity, the face and voice of Spoilt vote? of what Sandy McBurney calls the In commenting about the “dark side” aim of strengthening working class unity public service ads for car safety and the The debate between Sandy McBurney “rearming of the labour movement”. of the English ruling class (as opposed to on the basis of struggle.
    [Show full text]
  • The Two Phases of Communism Weekly 2 August 15 2019 1264 Worker LETTERS
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Fabian or anarchist? n Letters and debate n Hong Kong protest limits Mike Macnair on the US n Communist University left’s ‘Kautsky debate’ n US: decline and constitution No 1264 August 15 2019 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union £1/€1.10 The two phases of communism weekly 2 August 15 2019 1264 worker LETTERS has tried to maintain his position, taking Letters may have been true, but hardly constitutes a programmatic who wrote of the need for a revolutionary cases, throwing out bad cases and dodgy shortened because of entry. dictatorship. It was Lenin who defined evidence - not any more. Cases since forward the policy of last year’s conference space. Some names I have a copy of a more detailed version and defended the term in his battles with Savile show that the CPS works hand in and the Labour Party version (perhaps?) of may have been changed of ‘What we fight for’ (I don’t know how Kautsky. For Lenin, dictatorship means glove with police officers in preparing the class struggle - For the many, not the old it is, whether the detail is still valid or rule untrammelled by law. charges and evidence. Vital pieces of few. The class struggle is still the most why only a drastically shortened version is Lenin’s definition of dictatorship is evidence are lost in huge court bundles important political struggle in the UK and Revolution now published), which adds: “They will correct; but, unlike the Roman republicans marked ‘not of assistance’.
    [Show full text]
  • Batley and Spen: DON’T VOTE AGAINST STARMER VOTE for MARXIST STRATEGY Weekly 2 June 24 2021 1353 Worker LETTERS
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Mike Macnair: legislation to n Letters and debate n GB News buffoonery ‘protect free speech’ is part n US Marxist Unity Slate of Tory ongoing culture wars n Deniz Poyraz killing No 1353 June 24 2021 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 Batley and Spen: DON’T VOTE AGAINST STARMER VOTE FOR MARXIST STRATEGY weekly 2 June 24 2021 1353 worker LETTERS are building a partition wall between delegate conference being held as a result, taken out of national happy-clappy atmosphere, where Letters may have been South Asian heritage British subjects online (Covid prevented it being strike action over pay. The HMRC everyone just does whatever shortened because of space. Some names and their families and friends in the held at all in 2020) and most of has been vicious against PCS the NEC proclaims is good for may have been changed subcontinent. Can they succeed? my misgivings were correct. reps, trying to get them sacked. the PCS - rather like the Labour Even the partition wall of Starmer’s Although branches this time could It is hypocritical for Serwotka to Party and the TUC then. The friends in the Israeli state, in spite register as many delegates as they condemn ‘fire and rehire’, whilst NEC elections, the motions from Anti-Semitism? of splitting families and forbidding wanted, only one for each branch accepting the deal for worse terms the NEC and restrictions on Those who receive circular the cohabitation of Palestinians with could actually vote and every and conditions.
    [Show full text]
  • Supplement: Before, During and After the 1921 March Action in Germany
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Supplement: Before, n Letters and debate n Pandemic hits third world during and after the 1921 n Spring Communist University March Action in Germany n Inequality keeps growing No 1346 May 6 2021 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 Rent-seeking as mass murder weekly 2 May 6 2021 1346 worker LETTERS PCS they will always call in recently told that 125 branches about that. annual leave, sick pay, etc) for Letters may have been opposition speakers to ensure a had responded, but not which Another practice I did not like above-inflation pay rises is that shortened because of space. Some names balanced debate. However, the option most branches favoured at annual conferences was the fact they have taken major groups of may have been changed online conference arrangements nor what the comments were. the standing orders committee members out of the supposed PCS require branches to state, in One huge problem of (SOC) seemed to place the NEC’s national fight to secure annual advance, who is to speak on PCS merging with another motions on major issues at the pay bargaining with the treasury. PCS merger? a motion and whether they union will be that it might be top of all the relevant sections, My last activity before I retired The Public and Commercial are supporting or opposing it. affiliated to the Labour Party. so the NEC dominated all the in 2018 was to get the ministry of Services union is claiming that It can be seen that delegates Whilst the Provisional Central major debates.
    [Show full text]
  • SWP Embroiled in Scandal Over Sexual Misconduct
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Another fine mess: SWP n Letters and debate n China and Covid-19 embroiled in scandal n Lenin 150 years over sexual misconduct n CPGB 100 years No 1297 April 30 2020 Towards a mass Communist Party £1/€1.10 Why do people believe in conspiracy theories? Edmund Griffiths investigates weekly 2 April 30 2020 1297 worker LETTERS Letters may have been common programme, but, rather, are the Reagan-Bush Sr drug war from impact of the pandemic on capitalism, (PCC) is looking to unite Marxists, shortened because of nothing more than a state-regulated the right by arguing for stiffer and on the working class, nationally however currently misguided, into space. Some names mutual-assistance organisation for penalties against drug users as well as and internationally (‘Crisis and such a party. United, not around a may have been changed aspiring office-holders. By all means, drug dealers - but he’s also an arch- consequences’). The same concerns - charismatic leader or an esoteric let’s detach Democratic voters, and imperialist who’s been neck-deep for capitalism at least - are shared by reading of Marx or Lenin, but around Republican ones as well, from such a in every major US crime of the last politicians, academics and the media, a programme. There can be factions US democracy corrupt structure. But it’s impossible 30 years, from the invasion of Iraq as we can see each day, though with a and disagreements, but unity in action. In his March 12 article, ‘Lessons being to split the organisation, since the and Afghanistan to the destruction good deal less foresight and candour.
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Worker 940 November 29 2012 3 EGYPT
    Paper of the Communist Party of Great Britain weekly Lawrence Parker’s book: n Letters and debate workern Pharaoh Mursi llluminating the factional n Workers Power struggles of the CPGB 1945-91 n Rotherham fostering No 940 Thursday November 29 2012 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union www.cpgb.org.uk £1/€1.10 The madness of a dying system weekly 2 November 29 2012 940 worker LETTERS Letters may have been version of socialist revolution? Not beforehand, avoided buildings of of revolutionaries on campus would Respect, but this has been sidelined shortened because of only will we all be dead by then: the political significance and proceeded be an important step in this direction. by our magnificent, positive space. Some names human race itself is likely to have down almost empty streets, as it Callum Williamson campaign with the Respect battle may have been changed become extinct as well. meandered away from central London London bus, advertising truck and campaign Andrew Northall south of the river Thames. The rally groups in every ward. SPGB enigma email in Kennington Park did not go as the Loopy Polling conducted in the Croydon I was pleased to see Jon D White’s NUS would have hoped. President The Socialist Workers Party’s habit North by-election suggests that Lee quite reflective letter about the Sort it out Liam Burns was heckled and forced of bending in the wind to every Jasper, the Respect candidate, is Socialist Party of Great Britain, and I must thank Heather Downs to leave the stage.
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Court Will Be Used Against a Radical Labour Government Weekly 2 September 26 2019 1268 Worker LETTERS
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Labour 2019 conference: n Letters and debate n Union block votes victories for Corbyn, n Clause four mixed results for left n John Humphrys No 1268 September 26 2019 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union £1/€1.10 Be careful what you celebrate: Supreme Court will be used against a radical Labour government weekly 2 September 26 2019 1268 worker LETTERS Letters may have been we are likely to drive them further of any Brexit related policy should be The Guardian still carries some good and Irish remain are united by shortened because of into the arms of the far-right. to build a European wide movement stuff such as the Windrush articles recognition of the rights of nations to space. Some names Better to offer the democratic for pro-working-class reform. and the war of attrition against the self-determination. may have been changed option of another referendum but Sandy McBurney welfare state. However, my wife Republicans should support this time with concrete proposals for Glasgow and I and friends have been saying a ratification referendum which leave and remain. In this Corbyn is for some time that it has been going is quite different to a second Extremism correct. However, I would suggest Banner down the pan, which I naively referendum or the inclusion of a As you are no doubt aware, the ‘anti- three options on the ballot in a single It was I who put up the banner thought might just be the new remain question to reverse the 2016 Semitism’ campaign in the Labour transferable vote system.
    [Show full text]
  • Nick Rogers’ Article, Horror Rare in Bureaucratic Reports, Ahtissari the Chair
    A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity weekly Hard right readies for n Letters and debate workern Marxist crisis theory phase two of Operation n Turkey overextends Discredit Corbyn n ‘Lobster’ review No 1084 Thursday November 26 2015 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union £1/€1.10 LU leadership: Despite the Corbyn floodtide it’s business as usual 2 weekly November 26 2015 1084 worker LETTERS Letters may have been is tug of war rather than a civil war. under Left Unity’s feet. Hence LU is now more social democratic approach will not time and recall the words of the then under- shortened because of Pulling to the right are those seeking to facing an existential crisis of purpose as its be keen about this being on the conference secretary general of the United Nations, space. Some names merge with the Corbo-movement. The right right wing follow the logic of 1945 politics. agenda, especially as the motion calls for Martti Ahtisaari, who prepared a report may have been changed trend has been proposing various tactics, The Left Unity’s left wing has to re- the policy, if adopted, to be included in any on March 20 1991 on the effect upon Iraq from resigning and joining the Labour Party evaluate, redesign and realign as a smaller manifestos, ‘What we stand for’ statements of the most massive air bombardment Block vote to turning LU from a party into a network, to organisation with stronger politics, from or similar policy documents published by in history. In a period of four weeks, the There was a minor, slightly amusing, affiliating to Labour and no longer standing which renewed growth will inevitably the PA.
    [Show full text]