A paper of Marxist polemic and Marxist unity Dispelling myths: Ben Lewis n Letters and debate n Trump’s Afghan deal introduces his new book on n Israel’s general election Karl Kautsky’s republicanism n Sanders and US left No 1289 March 5 2020 Towards a Communist Party of the European Union £1/€1.10 #SWPTOO weekly 2 March 5 2020 1289 worker LETTERS Letters may have been Ruth Coppinger in Dublin - the one who were in the pub the other Jewish, be declared ineligible. He and will fight it to the bitter end. shortened because of Solidarity-People Before Profit week after a CPGB meeting, who ascribes his racism to us, but we Gerry may have stolen our website, space. Some names TD not re-elected - where the Sinn heard Gerry Downing shouting at do not discriminate. His special which our subs paid for over the may have been changed Féin transfers were not sufficient our comrades, all of whom are all pleading on behalf of his friend past several years just as much as to make up the discrepancy in members of SF, while they were of 30 years who supports the state his did. But we don’t accept his her own first-preference votes, trying to have a quiet and fraternal of Israel because of she lost some common theft - of our website, Class-conscious? and transfers from the knocked- drink with others, will recognise of her family in the holocaust and our publication or our name. The James McBarron’s letter (February out Labour Party candidate gave the syndrome. needs a ‘refuge’ is a blatantly racist Trotskyist Faction has its own 20) correctly points out that Anne the 4th constituency seat to the I have to say that I want nothing to argument. For that ‘refuge’ to exist, website up and running, on www. McShane, in her article on the Irish Green Party candidate (see the do with Gareth Martin either, since the majority of the Arab population socialistfight.org, or alternatively election, had mistakenly reported article, ‘Revolutionary Marxism he racially abused one of our non- had to be expelled. trotskyistfaction.org, and in due that the Greens had benefited most and Ireland’s 2020 election’, on white comrades of Turkish-Muslim It means very little to say that course we will have our own from Sinn Féin transfers (‘Sinn the Bolshevik Tendency website origin, who lives in London, by you are ‘strongly opposed’ to what publication to replace that which Féin’s success, left’s collapse’, (bolsheviktendency.org) for a accusing him, quite bizarrely, of happens to the Palestinians if you has been stolen. We will continue February 13). In fact it was the pre-election critique of this non- “justifying someone walking into a support the state that is doing it to the politics of the old Socialist reformist-socialist electoral bloc class-based approach to a “left synagogue in London or anywhere them, which took their land by force. Fight. Renegades and capitulators to of Solidarity-People Before Profit government”). else and committing murder”. If the Labour Party had rules that made Zionism will not be allowed to steal who benefited much more from It is both surprising and disappointing There have been no such events support for racist states like Israel our banner. Sinn Féin transfers, where they to see a long-time Platformist anarchist in London, and it is a psychotic incompatible with membership, such Ian Donovan were competing with the Greens. like James buying into this decidedly Islamophobic smear to imply that people would have to choose between Trotskyist Faction, Socialist Fight However, James goes on to non-class-conscious bourgeois a Turkish communist would even their support, however qualified, for describe this as “a class-conscious parliamentarianism. consider justifying or doing such a racist state and their loyalty to Royal socialism vote” - which is a very peculiar Alan Gibson a thing. He also stated to him that the anti-racist ethos of the workers’ As reported by Stan Keable in ‘A way to assess this voting pattern. Cork, Ireland “weaponisation of the holocaust” movement. And, furthermore, those vision of royal socialism’ (February Given that the first preference of is an “anti-Semitic trope”. This is victims of Zionism who see the 27), the Labour Left Alliance these votes was not for a working Pathetic itself an anti-Arab, anti-Muslim workers’ movement in the west as conference was a significant event class party, it is hard to see how it Gerry Downing’s pathetic letter trope, since a supposed threat hostile to them would begin to see in the evolution of the Labour could be called a “class-conscious” claiming that the ‘Trotskyist of another ‘Hitler’ and another our movement as the tribune of the left, which was revitalised by vote by working people. Sinn Féin Faction’ including myself were ‘holocaust’ has been the rallying cry oppressed that it should be, and be the election of Jeremy Corbyn are an openly pro-capitalist party, ‘expelled’ from Socialist Fight is of Israeli wars against the Arab and drawn towards it, making it far more as Labour leader in 2015. Stan who are committed to retaining pure fraud (February 27). He does other Muslim states surrounding it difficult for rightwingers to get a reports that 130 delegates at the the sweetheart tax deals for the not have a majority of full members since the Suez attack on Egypt in hearing among them. conference represented about 36 multinationals that dominate of SF willing to vote for such a 1956, if not earlier. He is a pro- Gerry reveals what his fascist- local and national Labour Left the Irish economy (p19 of their measure. No meeting of members Zionist, Islamophobic bigot, who I baiting rantings were really about groups. election manifesto). has or will be called to do so. Nor hold in contempt, and his behaviour when he finally repudiates my The Labour left in England has In response to the large vote has he been able to exclude our amply justifies the things that have 2014 Draft theses on the Jews and long been ‘social-monarchist’ - for Sinn Féin and the potential for supporters from the international been said about him. modern imperialism, the basic or ‘old Labour’, as it was known them to be part of a government forums of the Liaison Committee In both his case and that of ideas of which he was won to under the reign of Tony Blair. Social coalition, Irish business leaders for the Fourth International. When Downing, this is all to do with their in 2015, and which he defended monarchism is the programme based were quick to point out they had he tried to do so, in defiance of Zionist fantasies about the ‘evil’ in front of Andrew Neil and the on the 1945 Labour government, nothing to fear from Sinn Féin in the most basic tenets of workers’ of people from the Middle East (or Jewish Labour Movement’s Phil which established a version of power. Those who seek to portray and party democracy, his actions indeed elsewhere) who have some Collins on the Daily politics show state capitalism with a ‘welfare them as part of the ‘left’ might were repudiated by other comrades sensitivity to those outraged by in March 2016. He is trying to live state’ under the governance of also do well to remember that internationally and our supporters the three quarters of a century of that down with the ferocity of his the constitution of the crown-in- in September 2008 they voted were reinstated. This ‘expulsion’ is genocidal oppression committed by denunciation, and to imply that I parliament, which Stan calls the in favour of the bank guarantee. dead in the water. Zionist Jews, allied with ‘democratic’ somehow fooled him or twisted “constitutional monarchist system”. This bailout of the banking sector It is just about Gerry Downing US and British imperialism, who his arm into defending these ideas Corbyn’s social-monarchist resulted in the massive debt which farting out his denunciations on a evidence some softness on the for close on five years. Not so. programme was seen as a move the Irish state is still saddled with. stolen website, using a stolen banner. Allies’ defeated imperialist rivals. He embraced those ideas when he towards ‘socialism’ by restoring This was a significant contributor The joke is that a “unanimous vote” This has been the case since Gamal moved leftward under the influence some public ownership, the to the years of austerity, which in his fantasy version of ‘Socialist Abdul Nasser spoke to attack “the of the general move to the left in national health service, the have followed for working people Fight’ is when Gerry Downing, lie of the six million” in 1964. Other the British labour movement that welfare state, council housing and and it was justified by Sinn Ella Downing and his race-baiting, Arab and Muslim leaders, such as accompanied the rise of Corbyn. progressive taxation, etc. Social Féin at the time as being “in the Islamophobic, white South African Abbas, the Assads and Ahmadinejad Now that Corbynism has been monarchism is the trade unionist national interest” - which any anti- crony, Gareth Martin, each put have publicly doubted or denied the defeated by the ruling class, and politics of the British working capitalist worth their salt knows is up both of their hands. Their six holocaust, or published material politics has moved to the right, class. Its aim is to bargain with just a code for ‘in the interests of hands outvoted all the members of that does that, or, as in the case of Gerry is moving to the right also the ruling class and the employers maintenance of profits and general Socialist Fight who failed to vote Hamas, endorsed the Protocols of and making his peace with the for better terms and conditions for stability of the capitalist system’.